Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

no keskhi bibis kirtan

no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 06 Nov 2005

In this poster there is a picture of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh. There are women kirtanis doing kirtan but it appears they are not wearing keskhis. My question is that in Bhai Sahibs time was it allowed for non-keskhy wearing bibis to do kirtan? (The bibis on the right vaja looks like she is wearing a keskhy but the one on the left doesn't) [%sig%]

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

It was and is a strict rule in the Jatha that at Jatha Smagams, rehtivaan Gursikhs, dressed in bana are given time to lead the keertan. There are pictures of Bhai Sahib sitting in the Gurdwara Sahib (Singh Sabha Model Town) when ragis are doing keertan and in the same way, Bhai Sahib was in the Gurdwara Sahib when these bibis did keertan. Neither is wearing a keski and it is not a Jatha program.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

... · 06 Nov 2005

Yeah, ban everyone doing kirtan unless they wear keski's, wah! Dhan Panthic Sikhs.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

Let anyone who shows up at the Gurdwara with a vaja do kirtan! Let the Muslims who do it as a job also do kirtan! Let any Tom Dick or Harry do kirtan! Vah! Dhan Practical Minded Sikhs!

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

uksingh · 06 Nov 2005

obviously at normal kirtan programmes bhai sahib isnt gonna kick off kirtanis without keskis but at akj programmes kirtanis have to be amritdharee , with keskis on. both an old singh and bibi who i know, have sed at rensvais only amritdharee bibis wearing keski were allowed to do kirtan in front of sadh sangh.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

vichar · 06 Nov 2005

cant you see their jhoore? the two bibis doin vaja are wearing keskis cant you see the bulge on top of the head they have shawl over keski.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 06 Nov 2005

muslims did kirtan at darbar sahibb until we stopped them they were ood enough to do it in guru jes times wat do u think the first dhahdees were? this is first time ive heard this so were becomin like musalmaans thatonly these people can pray wat the hell is tha id like to see u stop a bibi in a gurghar from doing kirtan just because she deosnt wear a keski bibia shud wear keskis but stop forcing just because they dont have keskis, doesnt mean they arnt khalsai bibian withpout keski are khalai too wat r u talkin bout "bana" man bhai randheer sinh je didnt wear proper bana himself can he be stoped from doing kirtan too? bhai sahib wore a kurtha pyajama that is NOT purtaan pyajama maybe purtaan akj bana but not purtaan KHALSA bana nihans preserved the purtaan bana of the khalsa bhai sahib was a extermly ck gursikh wud u stp them too from doin kirtan, cause they arnt wearin a chola? bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

Khalistani, You are a Taksali Singh. Did you know that the official stance of Taksal is to only allow amritdharis to do keertan or lead the sangat? (Check Gursikhijeevan video section for the answer to that question). Anyone can come to Gurdwara and listen. But they can't lead teh sangat. The only people that can lead the Sangat are people who are Sikhs and believe in Guru Sahib as their Guru. Does it make sense that someone does keertan and katha about how great Guru Sahib is and then once he leaves the Gurdwara smokes a cigarette or drinks alcohol? Or he does keertan about naam when he doesn't have naam? It's stupid. The rababis were paid to do their job. They would go out and then wash their mouths with water because they said the kirtan had polluted their mouths. Do these peopel deserve to do keertan? If they really think Guru Sahib is so great, why don't the become Sikhs? Doesn't it look foolish that here are these people singing about teh greatness of Guru Sahib and how he's the only one, but then they themselves don't want to become Sikhs and still follow the Path of Mohammed who says non-Muslims all go to hell? So according to them, Guru Sahib was a false prophet and couldn't go to their heaven, but they still should be allowed to sing about Guru Sahib? We're not Muslims that we won't allow people into our Gurdwara, but we're not IDIOTS that allow non-Sikhs to do parchar about Sikhi to us. As for Bhai Sahib's Bana: check the picture section. Find me a single picture in which Bhai Sahib is doing kirtan in a pyjama kurta. Just find me ONE. Though a kurta pyjama can be bana if the top is chola style ie. not curved edges but straight down.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 06 Nov 2005

Read Amritpal Singhs site and you will see that infact the Nihang style Chola is not the Puratan style of dress either :)

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 06 Nov 2005

Yeh sorry I think 'vichar' is right, you can see a little bump on the singhnis head which could be a distaar.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

... · 06 Nov 2005

/\ you sound like a muslim yourself, what a fanatic.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Phatay chak · 06 Nov 2005

Author: "/", C'mon Singh, I think that Khalistani was just passing off his views. Reading Khalistanis posts, I think that he is a good Gursikh. Maybe he didn't know of Taksal's view on this so he thought it was ok for Muslims to lead the sangat, but I think that you could have replied a little more politely.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

**** · 06 Nov 2005

"/ " on what basis have you declared "khalistani" is a Taksali? i think you have got a chip on your shoulder

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

.. · 06 Nov 2005

****, regular readers of this forum know that Khalistani is a Taksali. Just search old posts.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 06 Nov 2005

im a singh i belive tha taksal is pretty much maintanted almost 100 percent the purataan maryada but not everyhting i post is taksal opinion bhai sahib wore bana??? wat picture have u seen that in??? imn ot saying bhai sahib was wrong at all i belive bhai sahib was a reat gursikh regardless of there "bana" muslims have been doing kirtan for a long tme in darbar sahib it was purtaan maryada but i agree on the other hand if a muslim goes and washes there mouth after and gets paid i wudnt think those people shud be alowed in ma opinion but a muslim with sharda doing sipht of vaheguru is not worng in my opinion and neither is a bibi without keski is tha bibi not khalsa? bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 06 Nov 2005

ok veer je for akj in past only wearin bana when doin kirtan does tha look like chola to u? bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

Khalistani, You said Bhai Sahib wore a kurta pyjama while doing keertan. I said he did not. Now you're bringing up a totally different point about a Singh doing keertan in a picture. Anyways, that Singh is wearing an achkin. An achkin is pretty close to a chola actually and jatehdars of the Takhats even wear them. It is acceptable. What is not acceptable would be pants/shirt/suit. What that picture you pointed out shows is not pants/shirt. But like I said, that's besides the point. Bhai Sahib did not do keertan in anything but bana. Think about the Muslims doing keertan point once again. If you are a Muslim, then you believe that those who do not believe in Muhammed as the last prophet of Allah (God) will go to Hell. That means their religion teaches them that Guru Nanak and all Sikhs will go to Hell. How can they honestly then praise Guru Nanak? If someone is singing the praise of Guru Sahib, then the listener and observer will automatically wonder, if the Guru is really that great, and this person is singing about it, why doesn't he himself follow the Guru? A Muslim can be in the sangat and enjoy all he wants. He can receive langar and degh, no problem. But he cannot sit at taabiya or do keertan or do katha. It is against Gurmat maryada.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

........... · 06 Nov 2005

"does tha look like chola to u?" not saying its right not saying its wrong but it looks like modern attire of the time.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

ekta · 06 Nov 2005

not every1 is akj but panthic so plz.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

LK · 07 Nov 2005

/\ - Sue Bhai Satta ji and Bhai Balwant Ji, an all other Sufi Saints bani that is in Guru Sahib. Sue Bhai Mardana ji for doing Kirtan with Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Ji :) You discriminate a whole people based on a few peoples action? Shame.... How narrow minded we have become...

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

hmm.. · 07 Nov 2005

Author: khalistani "i belive tha taksal is pretty much maintanted almost 100 percent the purataan maryada" Excuse me.. they dont seem to have preserved Raag Kirtan Maryada/ Gurmat Sangeet! anyway lets not discuss the wholes in taksal maryada here.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

uksingh · 07 Nov 2005

kiaa oujoo paak keeaa muhu dhhoeiaa kiaa maseeth sir laaeiaa || And what good are your purifications? Why do you bother to wash your face? And why do you bother to bow your head in the mosque? jo dhil mehi kapatt nivaaj gujaarahu kiaa haj kaabai jaaeiaa ||3|| Your heart is full of hypocrisy; what good are your prayers or your pilgrimage to Mecca? ||3|| thoo(n) naapaak paak nehee soojhiaa this kaa maram n jaaniaa || You are impure; you do not understand the Pure Lord. You do not know His Mystery. kehi kabeer bhisath thae chookaa dhojak sio man maaniaa ||4||4|| Says Kabeer, you have missed out on paradise; your mind is set on hell. ||4||4||

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

. · 07 Nov 2005

the person who laid the first foundation stone of siri harimander sahib was also a muslim.. Singh wrote:

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 07 Nov 2005

Do you really think that Bhai Mardana after spending all those years with Nirankari Jot Satguru Nanak didn't recieve charan pahul and naam from Guru Sahib? He still believed in Mohammed as his prophet ? We all know Bhai Mardana was a Sikh. Bhai Satta and Balwand are the same story. Do you really think they stayed Muslims? Being born in a faith is one thing, but they clearly became Sikhs in their lives. The story of Mian Mir laying the foundation of Darbar Sahib started at the time of Giani Gian Singh. Previous writers say that Guru Sahib himself did this. Besides, Mian Mir is known to have done nitnem of Sukhmani Sahib.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

x · 07 Nov 2005

/\ you need more history lessons, the Sufis dont believe Mohammad to be the last Prophet, nor do the Shi'a, both are MUSLIMS.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 07 Nov 2005

veer je maybe u didnt read ALMOST 100 PERCENT KEPT MARYADA by taksal i dunt belivr taksal is fully one hunred percnet purtaan, they dont keep purtaan bana compeltly, and purtaan keertan style but w/e thas not wat im gonan judge takal on its dastaar style and if they do kirtanin tunes but thas a whooolle diff topic which i think we husd jjust leave and yaa wa bout sufi sants? nxt thing u kno u gona say bhagath namdev je, and bhagaht kabir je, bhagaht fareed je, all thos sants who were not sikh, were tyaar par tyaar gursikhs with kirpana etc. etc. sufi sants are SIK sants they shud be allowed to do kirtan i agree if somene doesnt like kiirtan, and does it for money, etc. fame, w.e other rreason then they shud be stopped and tha is not bana man there no such thing as well its pretty close to bana thas like me saying one of those long english coats is a chola veer je if u wanna take a look at pictures just go to the pictures on this site go to akj,org any site i think sikhi online has pics of them they allhave kurtha pyajama thas wat bhai sahib wore and i dunt think thee anything worng with tha atall but if u think tha wearing only bana is acceptable when doing kirtan, then to u bhai sahib must b wrong as well but u wont say that wil u ull prob rather say well thas CLOSE to chola or somehting liike tha and the pic i gave u was a jatha kirtan pic looks like to me at least bhai sahib was sittig right by him and tha guy wasnt wearing a chola y didnt bhai sahib stop him i think bhai sahib was to deeply immersed in banee to see if he was wearing a chola or not bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 07 Nov 2005

khalistani ji Rehat - Taksal cannot even prove they existed since Parataan times, so I am not sure how they maintained a maryada. The current Gurmat Rehit Maryada of Taksal states a dastaar for bibian, yet even the greatest jathedar of taksal - Sant Jarnial Singhs Singhni does not wear one. He was a great Gursikh, but his own singhni was not following taksal mayada. Please check page 24, under the section of Pnaj kakaars - kesh section. This by no means is a judgement on Sant ji, but more of how even Taksal since its inception by Sant Sundar Singh, and not Guru Gobind Singh and Baba Deep Singh. If in four jathedars the Taksal can make such glaring ommsiosn in rehit, how can it say it is so Purataan? It has already been shown that the above poster is not a AKJ smagam, but a local Gurdwara programme at Singh Sabha Ludhiana. Typical AKJI, always have their foot in their mouths. Muslims - If Bhagat kabir jis bani speaks aginst Islam, does that still make him a Muslim or just a bhagat? He clearly states he does not accept islamic thinking. They wre not muslims or hindus but just bhagats. Bhai mardana was not a muslim, but had Charan Pohal Amrit. So he was Amritdhari. Muslims have never doen kirtan at darbar Sahib, only Amritdharis have. This is Panthik, AKJ, Taksal and maryada or most respected Sikh jathas.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

HJ SINgh · 07 Nov 2005

Hey c'mon people, lets not turn this into a debate over Taksal. I request Admin to please only allow posts that are related to his topic. Khalistani jee, please visit the following link on Gursikhi Jeevan to see what Taksals(Gurmats) stance is on whether or not non-Sikhs should be allowed to lead the sangat on the stage. http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalonNonAmritdharis.wmv

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 07 Nov 2005

yoo im puttig my own stance on this not taksals i respect taksals stance ill def. talk to older siinghs about this but for now i got my viws which dont make me no rep for damdami takasal and y r u turnin this into a taskal debate which i asked not to happen thas y i said mostly i belive it does stil retain almost purtaan maryada if u wanna check about lienage, im sue there some older akalees around where u live if u wanna kno taksal postion and i wil definelty watch that video veer je and i will definetly ttalk to older singhs :) veer"singh" je the pic i was refering to was wat to me alooked like a jatha smagam and it was posted in one of my posts, at the request of another member :) i think wrre gettin away from the topic this was about bibi in keskia being able to do kirtan or not it hink any bibi is allowed to do kirtan and not everyone has to be in bana,even in akj,a s the pictures ive given show if uw anna discuss muslims, i gues sit wud be best to open a new thread then bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

RoopKaur · 07 Nov 2005

If you saw a new raagi jatha, but the main keertani guy wore his long hair down and covered it with a bandana, would you think this was normal behaviour for a Sikh keertani? Obviously not. So why are you differentiating with bibiaa? Some might think not letting non keski wearing bibiaa do keertan is discrimination against them, but it is actually the other way around. You are setting standards higher for Singhs, who would not be acceptable if they let their hair down and do keertan, and yet you lower standards for bibiaa.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

ekta · 07 Nov 2005

khalistani is a singh of guru sahib and owes his allegiance 2 panth siri khalsa ji.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

LionKing (LK) · 08 Nov 2005

RoopKaur would the case be different if the Singh refuses to tie his wet kes due to eksi Ishnana and isntead wants to do kirtan with a bandana and open hair? for example..

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Whats a name · 08 Nov 2005

Author: RoopKaur Date: 11-07-05 21:54 If you saw a new raagi jatha, but the main keertani guy wore his long hair down and covered it with a bandana, would you think this was normal behaviour for a Sikh keertani? Obviously not. So why are you differentiating with bibiaa? Some might think not letting non keski wearing bibiaa do keertan is discrimination against them, but it is actually the other way around. You are setting standards higher for Singhs, who would not be acceptable if they let their hair down and do keertan, and yet you lower standards for bibiaa. AGREE 100% IF A GUY WHERE TO SIT THERE WITH HIS HAIR DOWN AND A BANDANA THERE WOULD EB A BIG HOO HAY

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 08 Nov 2005

Surely it is for him to say that. So far he has just said he is 100% taksali. He has told us that for years now. Ekta give a new record... ekta wrote: > khalistani is a singh of guru sahib and owes his allegiance 2 > panth siri khalsa ji.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

siinghh · 08 Nov 2005

Bhai Randhir Singh Ji never wore tapoban style clothes. He used to wear Kameej With Pyjami/Pyjama and a coat over that. Wanna bet anyone get in touch via email. No use making statements on internet. When you have seen nothing dont comment on that.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 08 Nov 2005

siiinghh, What is "tapoban style clothes"? Have the Singhs that go to that Gurdwara Sahib made up a new type of clothing? Is it a designer lable? Bhai Sahib in his early days wore a chola. Later in life he wore an achkin. Is wearing "tapoban style clothes" against Gurmat?

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Funny · 08 Nov 2005

" Let the Muslims who do it as a job also do kirtan! " I just think it's hilarious that people are acting this way. What about the "muslims" or "hindus" who'se own writings we bow to everyday in the Guru Granth Sahib jee? Have you considered what you're saying? Khalistani singh ji said, lets not turn this into a debate over Damdamee Taksaal. I agree with singh. **The original post was related to the bibis in the picture not wearing keskis. Maybe certain people are just too SCARED to REALIZE that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was of a high enough avastha to love EVERYBODY regardless of their bana and didn't treat anyone as higher or lower **

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 08 Nov 2005

do people just ignore the stuff in my post where i say im not a rep fro taksal, im a singh of guru jes first and foremost? but if i keep on going on about this, then someones gona reply to it, etc. etc. and im gonna reply to tha,m etc etc. so im gonna stop it here:D bhai shaib didn not wear chola man ive looked at almos tall there pictures they dont wear bana but i dunt consider them lower than anyone tha did wear bana Y? cause of ther ebhagthee and avastha so if a bibi withpout a keski got up on stage ud stop her from doing kirtan? thas saaad bhai sahib wud never do tha to peple who didnt have full bana for example check the pictures where singhs are doing kirtan purtaan akj did NOT wear bana bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Jagjit Singh · 08 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, without wishing to offend anyone. I am wondering why so many Gursikhs are so haung up on closthes. Whether tapoban chola, taksali chola, nihnag chola, kurta pyjama, - all are respectable gursikhi attire. All are comfortable for sitting and doing bhagti - so why the need for this. Just me but I thought abyass and seva is the most important thing. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

siinghh · 09 Nov 2005

**** What is "tapoban style clothes"? ****** The sort of clothes affiliated to tapoban wear. ******* Have the Singhs that go to that Gurdwara Sahib made up a new type of clothing? Is it a designer lable? ****** I never said that. **** Bhai Sahib in his early days wore a chola. Later in life he wore an achkin. **** Who told you that? ***** Is wearing "tapoban style clothes" against Gurmat? ****** Did I say it?

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

siinghh · 09 Nov 2005

****** There are pictures of Bhai Sahib sitting in the Gurdwara Sahib (Singh Sabha Model Town) when ragis are doing keertan and in the same way, Bhai Sahib was in the Gurdwara Sahib when these bibis did keertan. Neither is wearing a keski and it is not a Jatha program. ********* This is a jatha program kido. Prove me how it isnt. Kaal De Jamme gal ida kardey Jiven Brahm Giayta Hunde. Admin you need to be more reponsible. Some things may not fit in your story but its Paaap to propagate lies. Is sikhi not about sach da marg. I am still waiting for reply on questions I asked about bhai sahib wearing baana and about the managment of model town gurdwara. I will highly appreciate if someone clariied on it (even in private via email).

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

/\ · 09 Nov 2005

siinghh, You are talking in so much haumai. Are you a close companion of Bhai Sahib? You used to attend Bhai Sahib's program? If we aren't "brahm giayate" I sincrely doubt you are either. From all the pictures I've seen, Bhai Sahib is wearing bana. He certainly didn't wear coat-pants. In Gurmat Bibek he wrote that a Singh should stay in the bana he appeared in before the punj pyaare. One of Bhai Sahib's companions, G.Harbhajan Singh jee has told us Bhai Sahib did wear a chola in the past. In "Lagaan Matraan dee Vilakhanta" Bhai Sahib writes that he was mistaken for a Nihang. Would this have happened if he wasn't in bana? In the later pictures Bhai Sahib is pictured in achkins. But I repeat, never have I heard or seen of Bhai Sahib in shirts/pants. It is a fact that Bibis had to wear a keski to do kirtan during Bhai Sahib's time and subsequently. What exactly is your point and what are you trying to prove, besides the fact that we were born yesterday and not "brahm giayate"? Are you trying to tell us that Bhai Sahib wore pants?

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 09 Nov 2005

A bibi has sorted out the the pic thing. Check the link below, it has pics of these bibis then and now doing keertan. http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=14906&st=24 Plus notice how nangs tried to make an issue but slapped down by the sangat.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

* · 09 Nov 2005

... , She knows the bibiaan in question as well.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 09 Nov 2005

how does bhai sahib wear bana? wat r u guys talkin bout? AKJ DID NOT WEAR BANAAA mahybe IM WRONG sure y not im bhulanhaar hanna? buttttt from wat i ve seen in every ssingle picture of bhai shaib je they did NOT wear a chola at leastin there later yrs i kno for sur i havent seen young pics of them.... im not sayin bhai sahib was baad for not wearin it but im sayin bhai sahib didnt wear it while doin kirtan, so y stopp non keski wale bibian form doibng kirtan? this is the FIRST time ive actually heard that non keski bibis cannot do kirtan i peronsally belive all bibis shud wear keski but i wud NEVER stop a bibi from doing kirtan JHSUT cause she doesnt wear keski and then u use bhai sahib was an escuse, who HIMSELF never wore bana jus doesnt make sence to me... bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

akj · 10 Nov 2005

khalistani, wat do you class as bana? wearing a kurta is perfectly acceptable and there are variations of bana , i tihnk that what bhai sahib wore can be classed as bana. and not wearing one of the 5 kakaars or even if u dont class a keski as kakaar still, not wearing a dastaar is not on the same par as not wearing something tht u class as bana. bhai sahib was wearing bana jus cos it dnt fit the standard u set as bana. when doing kirtan seva one should wear a dastaar because that is the true roop of a gursikh, a khalsa should always be tyaar bar tyaar and you jus dnt look rite if u aint wearin a dastaar and u got a lil joora at the bak insted

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

bana-na · 10 Nov 2005

if you want to get technical here... if we not allow muslims to do kirtan, then why their clothing? kurtha pajama is a pakistani traditional dress. chola is original dress. so it seems we have made ourselves believe that kurta pajama is bana when its really not. to get even more technical, we shouldnt let salwar kameez because thats pakistani as well. if youre going to say bana-only, then wear the sikh chola....

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

singh · 10 Nov 2005

what are you talking about? chola is no different to kurta pajama. BOTH have origins in pakistani dress. why dont you read this. http://www.amritworld.com/nihangs/chola.html

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 10 Nov 2005

muslims do not wear a kurta pyjama, but wear a salwar kameez

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

uksingh · 10 Nov 2005

khalistani, theres a big difference between not wearing bana and not wearing a keski you dont have to go pesh for not wearing bana, you do for not wearing a keski. not wearing a keski in darbar sahib is very disrespectful, and is in my view manmat.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 10 Nov 2005

uk singh je how do u go pesh for not wearing a keski? thas IF u belive keski is kaakaar so wat abotu the vaaast majority of the panth which belives kesh is kakaar? they cant do kirtan now? een thougm a opinion is keski shud be tied on everoyne, no matter wa butttt i wud never stop a bibi form doin kirtan ju cause she wasnt wearin a keski as long her head is covered i think it will be ok bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

singh · 11 Nov 2005

****** One of Bhai Sahib's companions, G.Harbhajan Singh jee has told us Bhai Sahib did wear a chola in the past. ***** and also ************** Balpreeet Singh on this forum The story about Bhai Sahib wearing a dumalla came from my conversation with Giani Harbhajan Singh jee. Giani jee told me this. It's possible I misunderstood, but I don't think that's the case. The painting you saw also is at his house and he told me that Bhai Sahib posed for it. You say it's "nonsense" since you haven't seen a picture of it at Bhai Balbir Singh's house. Use your budhi here. Think hard. What are the earliest pictures of Bhai Sahib? There is one of him being very young (before the Jatha formed). The rest are all after Bhai Sahib's release and most are from the 50s. The story of Bhai Sahib wearing a dumalla is quite early (though obviously after his teens). ********** My Questions... Who is this Giani Harbhajan Singh Ji and how old is he? When did Giani Harbhajan Singh Ji come into first contact with Bhai Randhir Singh Ji? Do you have any photographs of the painting being discussed here? What was the age of Bhai Randhir Singh Ji when he took Amrit?

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

So khalistani, what you are saying is Taksal says keski should be tied in Rehet maryada, but will do nothing to enforce it, neither will take steps to encourage it, and will side with those who oppose it. So is that stand just a case of giving lip service to keski, with no practical back up to the words?

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

khalistani · 11 Nov 2005

im npot taksals voice am i? if i was id tell u who the hell mad me taksals offical rep? so y u askin me about taksals opinion if aint its rep? y dont u go ask some older taksal singhs? and i doubt taksal wud make someone get peshee u dont get pesheee for thing like tha i have many pics of many sant mahapurshes without keski and no dastaar so its only akj and tapoban that will make u do peshee if its not kakaar y wud u do peshee? thas at least for people who dont belive its kaakaar i think people r CONFUSED takal doesnt force things on others own perosnal beliefs how wud u like it if sant jarnail singh je in 84 decided to ban all non raag maala readers? they did exact oppsite of this they didnt belive in forcing on others and neither shud peopleon this forum at least on this issue the wearing of a keski fofr abibi is her owb personal choice for everyone it is bu dont think of her as less for not wearing one so is tha person better than non keski wearing bibi? keski is great but tha itself isnt gona get u nowheree bhula chuka maf

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

d · 12 Nov 2005

i agree with khalistani

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

Amarjit Bhambra · 25 Jul 2006

Ek om Akar Sat Nam, " Guru NanaK dev's teaching was that there is One God, Hence " Ek Om Akar". The every start of our Bani. It does not matter what one wears, Through the Nam, our souls are clean and not via washing of clothing. If we are critizing everyone at what their are wearing - we are not clean ourselves. Our Bani is full of Respect and love. Let us respect love and respect each other - We should respect other peoples religion as we respect our own. It is only if you give respect than your get that respect back. Us Sikhs are well respected people - Respect goes a long way. By the way did you all know that the word Ek om Akar was first orgiented from the word 'OM"? So what do we learn from this? Om, Allah, Whya guru sat name ALL refers to one God. Can we not learn from this?

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

ns · 25 Jul 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Cool words by Amarjit jeeo, I would just like to add one thing. The problem we have in each and every jathebandi is youth going by wordmouth about purratan gursiks belonging to their jathebandi. To comprehend Bhai Randhir Singh Jee's work is not easy and doubt if it can be done by us mere kereh who haven't done anywhere as much kamai. Bhai Sahib had naam simran rehansbhai's lasting 72 hours, Akand paat sittings of all the way through. Admins should ban such posts that go around criticizing every little knit picking on purratan Gursikhs.This is the biggest downfall of youth today to date no wonder we don't make any progress.

Re: no keskhi bibis kirtan

........... · 25 Jul 2006

i think a person who is on the path to become a sikh, in another words progressing in his sikhi yet has not taken amrit, should be allowed to do kirtan.......as otherwise it is not right for a person who does manmat himself to lead holy congegration...