Re: sikhs in vancouver
Jagjit Singh · 09 Nov 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, Sikhs in vancouver seem to have managed to makes themselves the "pakistanis" of canada. By this I mean, as the UK look at the pakistani youth, in the same way Sikhs are percieved in BC.
Since in every other part of the world, Sikhs have earned themselves a good name, why specifically in BC are they getting such a bad name?
Firstly Sikhs have to accept the criticisim has some truth. The level of violence between punjabis in BC is at crisis point. In UK, if 3 punjabi boys were shot dead, you would have a national outcry. But if you believe the Vancouver Sun, then over 100 youths have been shot dead in BC. This is far too many.
Secondly Sikh youth in BC have yet to hit the media and community with positive youth projects to get the youth away from drugs and community seva.
Thirdly, the Gurdwaras have lost control of the community and seem incapable of addressing these problems.
Lastly, you have the Kim Bolan effect. This one journalist has demonised a whole community. Is there not one educated Gursikh in BC who can sit down go through all her reports and create a report highlight her numerous inaccuracies, assumptions and exaggerations? if you do this, then community leaders can present this to the vancouver Sun for a response. You have to create a dossier of her mis-information.
SOLUTIONS
1) Create a sikh youth organisation which highlights positive sikh stories to the media. Stories of high accomplishments, and humanity.
2) Be far more vocal and start condemning the gang violence and tackle the problem by working with the authorities.
3) Start using the internet to start countering Kim Bolan by responding with articulate debate against her "sensationalistic" brand of journalism.
4) Start working with young kids doing Sikhi camps to stop kids getting into gangs.
5) Challenge Gurdwara leaders to take responsibility for the community problems, especially when gangs are linked to Gurdwara committees.
6) BC SIKHyouth and other Sikh organisations should call a joint conference with Police, politicians, community leaders to create Sikh awareness and show that the community is ready to confront its problems.
7 ) Start projects where weekly Gurdwaras are giving langar to homeless.
Essentially, sikh youth have to start to create their own vioce via their own groups, and cannot waste time waiting for Gurdwara committees, but you can start challenging them to do more.. Create groups like we have SCAN -Sikh Community Action Network in Slough to address social probelms.
If Sikhs in vancouver continue to sit in their homes and ignore it. It will bite you anyway, with a stereotype being built that will reduce opportunities for you and your kids in BC.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: sikhs in vancouver
BCSikhYouth.com · 09 Nov 2005
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa,
VAheguru ji ki fatheh!
Interesting suggestions Gurmukh pyare jee.
We will try to act on your suggestions to improve the situation.
Although some of it is an exaggeration. The Sikh youth of BC are not looked upon as "hooligans" and "troublemakers" by most British Columbians. Yes, there are many stereotypes and prejudices because of Kim Bolan, the central hate propaganda machine of the province, but we will continue to work against it and create awareness and positive publicity of Sikhi and the Sikh youth in BC.
If you don't mind please visit our website and share your constructive criticism. Please write articles for us which you think would be beneficial to the media. We have received several media inquiries from our website and we regularly get visitors on our website from The Province, the Sun, Canadian Geographic, and various multifaith groups.
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa,
Vaheguru ji ki fatheh!
-sevadars,
the Sikh youth of BC
www.BCSikhYouth.com
[url=http://www.bcsikhyouth.com]Sikhism[/url] | Sikh youth | Community
[%sig%]
Re: sikhs in vancouver
Gurcharan Singh · 09 Nov 2005
It is indeed a let down for all Suikh ciommunities in the world outside India.
Every whwere starting with Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, To Fiji, to UK and Afghanistan to Australia, Sikh communities have established themselves very well, with great respect and dignity.
One can walk down the streets of Mlayaisa, and observe the respect for dastardharii Sikh.Even the Police handles a Dastardharri Sikh with great respect and care when addressing the Sikh.
What has exactly gone wrong with Sikhs in Vancouver?That they have earned such a notorious reputation?There appear to be many argumentative Sikhs in Vancouver,who appear to know it all,this can be seen even on the nets here, but why are they not using this know how at practical level and putting the image of Sikhs right ?Or is it all just computer base heroism?
There is ONLY ONE KIM BOLAN who seems to have been demonised by the Sikhs in return and being blamed for all their woes?Is this really true?
I find that hard to believe when I see all the argumentative Sikhs on the net here, who say they have all the knowledge on Sikhi, outside Sikhi and about the life of this world.YET they cannot handle ONE Kim BOLAN!!!!!This is really unbelievable !!!!!!!!!!!!
One KIM BOLAN has the community on the run-what does it say about Sikh intelligence, about the Vancouver Sikhs, and their ability to stand up and face issues like SIKHS with dignity!!!!!
I beleive had Kim Bolan been in UK or elsewhere, she would have the audacity to continue her tirade as she has demonised the Sikhs.....she would have faced challenges and intelligently softened down ....
Even Khushwant Singh , who wrote once that the turbanned Sikh identity would disapper by the end of last century, was challenged by a ASP Pritam Singh, in Kuala Lumpur and proven wrong.Kushwant singh apologised and never again he said the same.
I am sure had it been Vancouver , they would have all agreed with kushwant Singh, instead also gone on to hasten that process with kushwant Singh .
OH, come of it, I know this will invite many critics, but reallity does sting !One Kim Bolan- with a skirt has got Sikhs on the run .... .....is it a fiction ..or what ???
Re: sikhs in vancouver
Japnaam Singh · 12 Nov 2005
Vaaheguroo jee kaa Khaalsaa, Vaaheguroo jee kee Fateh!
Gurcharan Singh and Jagjit Singh,
I don't know where the both of you get your information.
Sikhs in BC are doing just fine, and are generally viewed favourably.
In fact, as someone who has travelled to various parts of Canada and the United States, I'd say that Sikhs are treated the best in Vancouver, in comparison to any other place in the world.
You could quit with the crisis-inventing, even though it appears to be well-meaning. It's still built on false knowledge.
There are definitely still steps that need to be taken, but BC has the strongest "Sikhi infrastructure" in the western world.
Khalsa Schools, Khalsa Credit Unions, lots of youth groups, etc.
There's still a way to go - such as creating a more sophisticated media/education presence, but that problem exists everywhere, and is an issue that transcends location and country.
Japnaam Singh
Re: sikhs in vancouver
Jagjit Singh · 14 Nov 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I do not think we are crisis-inventing at all. Just giving practical ideas with which Sikhs in vancouver can improve their image.
Yes, sikhs in vancouver may have created a mini-punjab there. But 100
+ youth killed in gang violence in a problem.
Also at some point you will have to confront the community assasination style of sensationalist jounrnalism of Kim Bolan.
Rather than being defensive, it may be better for all to share ideas with what other young sikhs are doing around the world, and improve what you already have.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh