Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

Sewadar · 10 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! http://www.ilfordrecorder.co.uk/content/re...3A43%3A40%3A240 Media Sensationalisation once again. This was on the front page of the Ilford Recorder and the headline is plastered all over Ilford! To use a blanket statement that "SIKHS" demand an apology is an irresponsible statement as well as incorrect. A majority of practicing/orthodox Sikhs don't even entertain the idea of eating meat. To sensationalise the story on the front page of the Ilford Recorder just uplifts the present tensions between Muslims and Sikhs within the national Asian community. Phrases like "members of the local Sikh community" could have been easily used to make the statement instead of falsely categorising ALL Sikhs as meat eaters. Call 020 8478 4444 and ask to speak to Chris Carter - Chief Editor an express your concerns about using blanket statements about ALL SIKHS. http://www.ilfordrecorder.co.uk/content/re...3A43%3A40%3A240

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

True facts · 10 Nov 2005

It is totally irresponsible of the above so called sewadar hiding behind a pen name to ask Sikhs to do this at this moment and time. For all we know it is another non sikh at his games yet again. This is not the time wash your linen in the public, and go against an issue raised. It is laughable to suggest Sikhs pointing out about meal prepared in a non Sikh manner can endanger Sikh muslims realtions.....where as insisting everything goes halal does not endanger and threaten others? What a laughable one sided suggestion.These same people are quite happy hugging monas and having mona relatives....I wonder if they would call a boycott of their mona relatives? Yet they are disturbed by some others diet habits!The SRM is the recognised CODE, until that states ....digging out unauthenticated lines "from Gurbani" is real mischief on these poeples part.Are they suggesting that the scholars of the PANTH overlooked these lines all these years ?Only these people found out?This people are from derawaad and asserting their views upon Sikhs. For the sake of sikh image , it would not be right for poepl to ring up the recorder and start some conflicting view.This issue should be brought up with SGPC and asked to settle.That is the right way of doing it. Why not write to SGPC and ask them to consider this issue again and incoporate it in the SRM, this not islam or some extremist gang situation where onepersons view can be asserted upon the community. There appears to be a conflict with some "new found" claimed tuks from gurbani ..if indeed this evidence then address it properly through the sgpc-instead of washing this linen in the public between Sikhs. An issue arose about Sikh children being fed halal, quite rightly under the existing REHAT MARYADA this is wrong, steps have been taken to address these...instead we get a group or claimed group trying to under mine the Sikhs issue. I am not at all suggesting either way,BUT I am saying it is wrong to hijack this issue and lead it to another angle. To say Guru Hargobind has given clear instructions is cally for controversy, as the question arises DID THE ACADEMCIANS of the panth NOT SEE THIS eaelier when THE SRM was being constructed?

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

Gurcharan Singh · 11 Nov 2005

I am in support of the above as well.The so called sevaadaar has left out an important paragraph and tried to mislead the sangat by saying veru nagative comments about inter faith relations...when the following is part of what was said ..in the article .. "Mr Singh, of Wellesley Road, Ilford, said while supporting the right of Muslim and Jewish communities to demand halal and kosher food for their children, he also expects children of other faiths to be given a choice based on religious needs." I think this anti meat lobby is trying to "tthos"their views using unsusbstantiated gurbani tuks ... This is bad .How come the learned of the PANTH did not see this tuks?Can that be explined before rattling off in your own direction???

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

Sewadar · 11 Nov 2005

Apologies to Gurcharan Singh & True Facts. Didn't mean to mislead the Sangat. Just felt that it is incorrect to give a headline on the front page saying "SIKHS DEMAND HALAL APOLOGY", particularly as "practicing" Sikhs don't eat meat. So for people like me Sikhs should not even eat meat. Just sticking up for my beliefs. The numbers there if anyone wants to ring the local paper.

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

LionKing (LK) · 11 Nov 2005

I agree with the above posts that the poster shouldn't really be arguing about meat aloud or not - that's something that should be taken up with the Akal Takhat/Panth. Right now the Panth has decided something, altho I personally don't agree with it, you should first make sure that the students in question don't keep on "kurehating" As For the "New Tuks", I do disagree with above posters (Gurcharan Singh and True facts) that they (the scholars) went through EVERY SINGLE piece of evidence, as it would mean that they would include the Hukamnama by Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji which was one (or two) of the hundred or so Hukamnamas collected by Historian Prof Ganda Singh, in his book "Hukamname" Which wasn't publish before about 40-50 year's after the Rehit Maryada was draftet. Again the Maryada isn't written on stone, and the "new" evidence collected, by what you call, "derawadd people"... (altho, personally I would associate myself with Akal Takhat, rather than any Dera, whether Taksal, AKJ, or Nihangs...) should be considered as it's an issue which is still contreversial and not accepted by a lot of Jathebandis. Regards LionKing

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

Gurcharan Singh · 11 Nov 2005

Lion King, I agree with what you have said.BUT the fact remains NO new bani has come to light after the SRM was drafted. I understand your reasoning.BUT Ganda Singh can only draft what he has from the Gurbani that existed.The Hukamnama of Guru Hargobind Sahib was already known to the sangats at that time.There is no such thiong as new Gurbani comming to light every so many years. ganda has researched only from the existing historical facts and old rehatname and writings associated by written history, and Gurbani. I am sorry I dont buy that suggestion. Now why I said dera waad?because if you look at history of Sikhs over the last fifty years many new devianist sects have come about.It is know many of these are using tuks of Gurbani and adding their own lines.Why did Bhai fauja Singh lead the Sikhs against Nirankari Gurbacchan?because Gurbachan was distorting gurbani further and writing more books by distorting Sikh gurbani.There are many more example.A few saadhs have been charged in the Punjab from time to time, because they have been distorting Gurbani and publishing it.It is also a fact that it is mostly the derawaad saadh who propogate Sikhi of their own brand are also impressing Sikhs to be vegetarians.there may be an exception where individuals taken upon themsleves to be come vegetarians.that is their wish, I can respect that. Now I am very perturbed to see on the net someone caliming that they have Gnada Singhs translation over tyhe Hukamnamas.Now the questiion is why is this not being discussed in the Gurduaras?why has it not hit the newspapers in the past when it came to light.Gandas Singh book was published in the 60 s if I am not wrong.Another by Bhai Ashok was also published around this time.Bhai Ashok mentions the same hukamnames but does NOT say about the specific one that is supposed to say ..MAA MASSHI TON DOOR rahena...neither does one in Punjabi by Roop singh, and yet another by kuldeep singh kaura. I also know for a fact that no such hukamnama was issued, though I see someone is claiming one was and has put such on the nets.The authencity of which is dubious and not ascertained. It is possible a letter may have been sent out to the sangat of Dhaka,where if at all, it could have been mentioned for one reason or another...BUT I still beleive even this tuk may have been taken out of context, or added on later by someone with a vege brigade mind. I am sorry, I do not agree until this is verified by more learned sikh scholars>i have also asked the writer to provide the whole tuk.Instead that writer misscontrued my challenge.I know, had this tuk been genuine and really from Guru Hargobind sahib, the 20 year process from 1925 to 1945 to establish the SGPC would have been taken that tuk into account.There is no way the Guru sahibs over ruled each other. I think instead of arguing over this on the net, this should be forwarded to the SGPC and allow Akal Takhat process to decide after wider consultations. As individuals we can agree to disagree. To sewadaar, Thanks for acepting our reasoning.An issue arose let Sr harmander Singh take the culprits to task.OPlease for the sake of Sikh PR image ..not wash the linen in Public. Feel free to take the issue to the Akal TaKhat and SGPC-that is where it can be decided, and let the ruling come.It is easy to shout on the nets.But a different issue to argue out with authorities.Please do not be an obstacle in the path of Sikhs trying to get things right for Sikhs.I am in with harmander Singh and I can tell you it is not easy. Bhai sahib, since you live in Illford let me share with you some thing else.Today was my daughters birthday.Some close members in the family decided to give a surprise dinner, and booked a table at the collisium in Ilford.I did not know where they had booked.It was kept a secret form us.We were told to drive to ilford, and then met by the relatives who then asked me to wait in the car with my daughter while the rest of the family went in.30 minutes later we had a call to cross over the road walk 40 yeards and come into the collisium.Wqhen I arrived there, I was shocked to to see it was a dance hall with live music.I was very angry, and almost turned away, when I saw an amritdahri young man walk into that club.Another amrtdhari followed him in.I thought I shall not upset my daughter, who herself was not comfortable seeing the venue.Well, I have a bottle of water, what the hel, since the rest were there, we went in.To my amazement I saw another amritdhari who has been participating in nager kirtans as one of the panj piara, at the Sikh youth camps in Chigwell, inside the venue.That interested me.So, I met my realtives and the look on my face was enough to to tell my wife I was not pleased at all.She held my hand and said thank you for comming inm I did not think you would and I did not want to upset my brother and his family for booking this ...I said that is ok, I have just seen something interesting ...and thought I will come in and see what exactly an ammritdhari was diong in this place...she smiled ...and said look over there ..is he not from the Sikh camp??I said he is not the only one there are a few more.My daughter to her credit I must say was not too pleased and looked me then at her mum..and kept quiet.My son too kept quiet. Bhai sahib I was shocked when the music started ..the same amritdharis got on the floor.One or two had their joora down with a scarve over the head.I would not be suprised if one or two of them were part of the campaign for respect too.Then my gaze got to a table where another singh with khoola dharra was sitting with a few other singhs.They had a bottle of wine, and the chap with the khoola dharra was consuming from a glass!! a glass of wine!Now can anyone tell they have found another tuk where this has has been allowed? Is this what it means to be amritdhari ?Is it wrong to eat meat but these guys are happily consuming wine?Is that Okay ? I could not believe my eyes, then some of these guys were on the floor dancing away ...bhangra... these same f ellows then tell us we cannot consume meat prepared in the jhataka manner, which is clearly stated as accpetble in the SRM. Is drinking wine on the quiet acceptable?While these same fellows never tire telling us that consumming meat is against gurmat ...when SRM clearly states only jhatka is allowed. The question is ..is it ok for a sikh in sikhi roop to be frequenting halls where alcohol is served? Yes, I was cross with my family.After a little while I asked to leave with my family.We gave the excuse that I was not feeling well.My daughter said ..she did not enjoy all that loud music, I agreed with her and aplogised to her for going to such a place.Mum too felt she was put in difficult position as..the family thought they were being very nice to give a surprise treat. But that does NOT leave the fact that today I saw amritdharis youth in the halls of alcohol, and cheap dances. What a load of rubbish when they tell one it is against gurmat to eat jhatka meat!! I have no reason to lie and get at anyone, but when I see people playing double standards....by the way I took pictures of these sikh saroopi and ammritdhari sikh youth vey discreetly. I wonder how many of them (there at least six sikh roopi and amritdharri youth) nevertire telling others how sinful it is to eat meat!There were many more sikhs in the hall. Please practice what you preach, and do not preach what you have no intention of maintaining yourself!

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

singh · 11 Nov 2005

gurcharan singh ji what is your email address how may i contact you

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

LionKing (LK) · 12 Nov 2005

i have also asked the writer to provide the whole tuk. *********** At this time I do not have enough time to run through your entire post, as a matter of fact I hardly had time to read through your entire post - I will do that more thoroghly later on, but I shall leave you with the exact copies of the Hukamnamas By Guru Sahib - Hukam 1 The exact same quote is written in both Hukamnamas written by Guru Sahib "Maas machi de neRe nahi avNa" Hukam 2 - Page 1 - Page 2 - More Hukamnaamas for further reference can be found on Dhurkibani.com under the resource section. Hukamnamas scanned from Prof Ganda Singh Ji's "Hukamname - Guru Sahibaan, Mata Sahibaan, Banda Singh Ate Khalsa Ji De" Publish by Punjabi University, Patiala, 1999

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

Singhnature · 26 Nov 2005

Vahegurooo jee kaaa khalsaaaah, Vahegurooo Jee kee fateeeh! LionKing, inaddition to the link you have provided, there are written hukamnama's issued by Shaheed banda singh bahadur, where he states clearly in the one dated 17, December, 1710, if you will be kind enough to read it, clarifies the following: Ekumkar Fateh Darshan Aavna Khalsae De Rehit Rahna "Bhung", "Tamak-oo" Hafeem Po Satt "Dharoo" Amal Kee Nahee Khana "Maas" "Maachlee" Pi Satt "Dharoo" Amal Nahee Khana Chor-ee Jar-ee Na-hee Kar-nee The Hukam is quite clear Shaheed Banda Singhji is stating that the Khalsa must remain disciplined, drugs, tobacco, alcohol, meat, fish should not be consumed (in any manner) in public nor in hidden quarters. If one looks closely at the hukamnama there is no indication or mention of Jhatka, or any mention of halal is to be consumed, Bhai Sahib states meat is meat, fish is fish, alcohol is alcohol, tobacco is tobacco, dope is dope FULL STOP and none of it is to be consumed! CONCLUSION ___________ The hukamnama has a clear connection with the written hukamnama(s) by Satguru Hargobind Sahib that one should NOT go near meat and fish. For me that is written evidence and no Jathedar of Akal Takht, MP, President, Monarchy, baba, Sant or Mahant is higher than my Guru. Now, some baffoon is gonna say "well if he hasn't stated Jhatka or egg then it must be OK to eat" - DOH!

Re: SIKHS DEMAND APOLOGY FOR HALAL MEAT

LionKing (LK) · 27 Nov 2005

Singhnature, did the Hukamnama by Banda SIngh use the word Kutha or Maas (too lazy to have a look =P) On the other Hand, Hukam By Banda SIngh also says that onion should not be consumed.... So I'm not 100% sure about the writing of Banda Singh BHull chukk Maaf