Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Working in Drinks industry

Working in Drinks industry

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. I wish to ask the sangat if it is ethical for an Amritdhari Sikh to work for a company which operates in the drinks (alchohol) industry. The job I have been offered will not be front line but will be part of the finance department of this company. I will value your opinion before I make a decision

Re: Working in Drinks industry

**- · 11 Nov 2005

Would you work for the Indain Govt? No Same answer applies to the drinks industry

Re: Working in Drinks industry

Lakhvir Singh · 11 Nov 2005

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh. I used to work with an ad agency in which I had two major clients entrusted upon me - one of a cigarette company and the other of an alcohol one. While I do not find it fair to say that these two industries should exist on moral grounds, I found it really painful to work in that agency as the work involved would play me down heavily on my conscience. I could not speak to my Directors to give me something else to work on, they wouldn't understand my reasons. So I had only one choice left - to quit. And I did. You decision would be best when you choose whether it is against your conscience or not. If it isn't, then go ahead, earn your honest living. But if you will work under the constant burden of working for the company whose line of business you do not support, then don't do it. Easier said than done, I know, and it is a tough decision to make. But you have to stand up for at least one thing at this time - either for your principles, or for getting a job. Standing up for one's principles isn't the easier thing to do, trust me, I've seen what it takes to do that. I had to give up a lot, my job, my financial security . . . but I'm now doing something that does not clash with my principles. Remember, even GuruJi's horse refused to tread a foot further on approaching a tobacco farm, even when it was still a distance away. I asked my Guru for guidance when I was in turmoil of decision and He helped me through - by encouraging me to follow what I lived on - my faith and my principles. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.

Re: Working in Drinks industry

Gopi · 11 Nov 2005

Surely it's more important that you work hard and earn an honest living (ie. not in Crime/Prostitution/Illegal Activities) than whether you happen to work for a company that produces alcohol. Whatever next - it's not right for an sikh to work in a store because it sells meat? Its not right for a sikh to work as a doctor (see other post on here) because you may have to shave someone to save their life??? It's not right for a Sikh to work as a policeman because you may have to touch someone who has hurt themselves when drunk? You must remember that Guru Ji's Armies fought (and killed) enemies of the Khalsa - but this still was in the sense of 'Working Hard and Earning a Honest Living' because they lived fulfilling and decent lives. If they followed this trend of thought - we'd all be muslims now. I think common sense should prevail here but I echo the previous poster's view - it's an individual decision - and you'll see both sides of the coin on this forum but at the end of the day - this has to be your decision.

Re: Working in Drinks industry

S Singh · 12 Nov 2005

Singh Take the job. No one is exactly going to force you to drink. You are going to be in the finance department. Build some experience if you do not like it move on. If we took such a view then I suppose no Sikh would ever get a job in the city for a mutual fund as that would mean holding equity in companies that could be selling alcohol.

Re: Working in Drinks industry

. · 12 Nov 2005

would a sikh give mouth to mouth resucitation to a dying person who smells of drink or tobacco?

Re: Working in Drinks industry

singh · 13 Nov 2005

>>>would a sikh give mouth to mouth resucitation to a dying person who smells of drink or tobacco?<<< You could use a paper bag :)

Re: Working in Drinks industry

Hargurmit Singh · 13 Nov 2005

The cash flow that will be used to pay your salary will come from the profit of selling alchol. If you had other opportunities, would you really want to feed your family with this money considering that finance professionals have lots of opportunites these days..? Although Not strictly applicable to your situation, you may want to veecharo the hukamnama that we read daily in Asa Di Vaar (Ank 471 ) - koorree raas koorraa vaapaar || koorr bol karehi aahaar || - this tells us about duplicity. Here we say that we should not consume intoxicants but feed our family out of the earnings of this trade. A tough question to answer. Veer Lakhvir Singh has shared with you how the Gurus horse, Neela, had through the sangat of the Guru Sahiban developed the nose to stay away from tobacco fields. What i am sharing is a hukamnama from Guru Nanak Sahib that may partially be relevant to your case. At the end, ask Guru Sahib through an ardas and a hukamnama and he will guide you. [%sig%]

Re: Working in Drinks industry

ekta · 13 Nov 2005

with S Singh, be practical live practical.

Re: Working in Drinks industry

???? · 13 Nov 2005

Im not sure whether this is wrong.... but many people and the panj piyare have told me not 2 be involved in anythin 2 do with alcohol... for example opening a liquor store, selling alcohol and bein in a business that sells alcohol... so i guess that means that u shudn't get this job... u can still earn a honest livin by havin another job... but havin a job in this industry might mean that u are kind of promoting it and sayin that its ok..... jus an opinion. bhull chuk maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kee fateh!!!!

Re: Working in Drinks industry

LK · 13 Nov 2005

Easy for us to talk. Shoudl learn from someone who ahs experienced it - Lakhvir Singh - thanks for sharing your experience. ************** Author: . Date: 11-12-05 14:41 would a sikh give mouth to mouth resucitation to a dying person who smells of drink or tobacco? ************** Such a Sikh, would defenetly earn my respect. Such a Sikh would be AMAZING to have the Darshan of - one who has totally surrendered her/himself - totally killed of every single bit of ego. A SIkh would do mouth to mouth resuciation to a, what we would call a, "neech" person. What society sees as a "neech" person a SIKH comes and helps Vah Vah Vah. Might not have personally done it as I'm over flowing of Ego... but I think a REAL Sikh shoudl do. Perhaps if Guru Ji has reserved this seva (self-less service for humanity) for Daas, Daas would do it? I don't know. Hard thing to say. But a Real Sikh would do it. I would be ashamed standing by of someone else did it and no Sikh did it - Sharm di gal hoy gi. Vaheguru

Re: Working in Drinks industry

jss · 13 Nov 2005

i would give the mouth to mouth resucitation... hopefully i'd have a face shield on me (most likely i would have one, being in the healthcare field)

Re: Working in Drinks industry

B Singh · 13 Nov 2005

Who was the SIKH who gave water to the dying enemies, they who were fighting the Khalsa? Did he see them as enemies or he saw what was in them? Did Guru Ji bless him? WAHEGURU

Re: Working in Drinks industry

. · 14 Nov 2005

I agree with the sentiments above. we should not think twice about saving anothers life. This is why the argument pertaining to the surgeon thread is futile.

Re: Working in Drinks industry

Be practical · 14 Nov 2005

Take the job! Almost every corporate anyone works for has some indirect link to human suffering. Most have their hands bloodier than those of alcohol companies. So unless thousands of sikhs write in to say that they have just resigned from pharmaceutical companies for not allowing developing nations to produce cheaper alternatives for dying people., or stopped working for banks/financial institutes for loaning african nations money they cant repay in anything but blood, carry on and have a successful career. Everyone needs to scratch under the surface and realise most of us work for corrupt agencies who screw the poor man. If you dont like it , best to go to the jungle or become a farmer or something.