Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhang ancient marayad

Bhang ancient marayad

SaNmukh · 11 Nov 2005

http://www.amritworld.com/bhang.html The 'Sukhnidhaan' or 'Bhang' (cannabis) (Amrit Pal Singh 'Amrit') According to the 'Sikh Rahat Maryada', "A Sikh must not take hemp (cannabis), opium, liquor, tobacco, in short any intoxicant. His only routine intake should be food". A Nihang is preparing 'Sukhnidhaan' At Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji, the 'Sukhnidhaan' is offered as a holy food. Generally, 'Bhang' (Cannabis) is called 'Sukhnidhaan, but seeing condemnation of 'Bhang' in the Gurbani and 'Sikh Rahat Maryada' named it 'Sukhnidhaan', instead of 'Bhang'. Whatever is the case, we have to accept that 'Sukhnidhaan' is a drink, in which 'Bhang' too is mixed. In his book 'Sri Hazoori Miryada Prabodh', Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji, then the chief priest of 'Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji, has expressed his views about 'Bhang' under the heading of 'Sukhnidhaan De Bhog Baare' (page 257 to 264). He wrote that all the 'Maryada', which is being followed at Takht Sahib, is 'Puratan' (old) tradition. Supporting the offerings of 'Sukhnidhaan' at Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji, Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji has presented these arguments: - 1. According to the 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala', Mogul King Babur offered 'Bhang' to Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Delighted on this, Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji granted him the boon to have the kingdom for seven generations. Guru Ji recited a 'Shabd' also on this occasion, in which he did not condemn 'Bhang'. On the other hand, when Yogi Jhangar Nath offered a cup of wine to Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Guru Ji recited a 'Shabd', in which drinking wine was condemned. 2. The 'Mahant' (abbot) of 'Gurusar Satlaani' got license for 'Sukhnidhaan' from the British government. 3. The 'Sukhnidhaan' is being offered at Sri Amritsar Sahib, Taran-taaran, and Sri Anandpur Sahib Ji. 4. 'Nihangs' of the 'Budhha Dal' offer 'Sukhnidhaan'. 5. There is description of 'Sukhnidhaan' on many pages of book 'Sooraj Prakash'. 6. At 'Shaheedi Baag' in the city of Sri Anandpur Sahib, a small room, which was constructed during Guru's time, has been excavated, in which there were big 'Suneharas' (a kind of big vessel). It proves that 'Sukhnidhaan' was prepared and offered during the time of Guru Sahib. 7. According to the book 'Khalsa Dharam Shaastar', Guru Gobind Singh ordered to take intoxicants to remove sadness. The quantity of 'Chhatar-dhara' (opium) and 'Sukhnidhaan' was fixed. 8. All the 'Rahats' can be known only from Guru history and 'Rahatnamas'. We cannot know 'Rahats' from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Let us now discuss these points one by one: - The main argument by Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji is that Mogul King Babur offered 'Bhang' to Guru Nanak Dev Ji, according to 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala'. Pleased by this, Guru Nanak Dev Ji granted him the boon to have the kingdom for seven generations. Singh Sahib Ji says that Guru Ji recited a 'Shabd' also on this occasion, in which he did not condemn 'Bhang'. On the other hand, when Yogi Jhangar Nath offered a cup of wine to Guru Nanak Dev Ji, Guru Ji recited a 'Shabd', in which drinking wine was condemned. Quoting to the 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala', Singh Sahib Ji made it clear, in a way, that 'Sukhnidhaan' and 'Bhag' are one and the same. The particular 'Sakhi' of 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala' does not use the word 'Sukhnidhaan'. Only word 'Bhang' has been used. It is absolutely opposite to the fact saying that according to 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala', Guru Ji was pleased when Babur offered him 'Bhang'. In fact, 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala' though says that Babur offered 'Bhang' to Guru Ji, but there is no mention that this pleased Guru Ji. Instead, Guru Ji was pleased when Babur released innocent prisoners. 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala' says that when Babur heard Guru Nanak Dev Ji singing this hymn, "Khurasaan Khasmaana Keeya, Hindostaan Daraaya", he called Guru Ji and asked him to sing it again. Guru Ji sang it again. Babur said, "Friends, he is a nice 'Faqir'." Then, he offered 'Bhang' to Guru Ji and said, "Saint, eat the 'Bhang'." Guru Ji replied, "Meer Ji, I have eaten Bhang, whose stimulation never ends". Babur asked, "Which is the Bhang, whose stimulation never ends?" Guru Ji asked Bhai Mardaana Ji to play on 'Rabaab'. Guru Ji recited this hymn: - "Bhau Tera Bhaang, Khalrhi Mera Cheet" (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 721). Let us read the translation of whole of this hymn: - Tilang, First Mehl, Second House One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru. The Fear of You is my marijuana; my consciousness is the pouch, which holds it. I have become an intoxicated hermit. My hands are my begging bowl; I am so hungry for the Blessed Vision of Your Darshan. I beg at Your Door, day after day. 1. I long for the Blessed Vision of Your Darshan. I am a beggar at Your Door - please bless me with Your charity. 1. Pause. Saffron, flowers, musk oil and gold embellish the bodies of all. The Lord's devotees are like sandalwood, which imparts its fragrance to everyone. 2. No one says that ghee or silk are polluted. Such is the Lord's devotee, no matter what his social status is. Those who bow in reverence to the Naam, the Name of the Lord, remain absorbed in Your Love. Nanak begs for charity at their door. 3. 1. 2. Guru Ji clearly says that 'Bhau Tera Bhaang', means 'The Fear of You is my marijuana'. Thus, the God's Fear is the true 'Bhang', for a Sikh. Reading this holy hymn, how can we say that Guru Ji accepts the Bhang' and he have not condemned it? If Guru Ji was pleased when Babur offered 'Bhang' to him, why did he (Guru Ji) not drink it? 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala' does not say that Guru Ji drank 'Bhang'. Then, according to 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala', King Babur offered land to Guru Ji, but Guru Ji refused again. Babur requested Guru Ji to have mercy on him. Hearing this, Guru Ji asked him to release innocent prisoners. Babur requested for a boon of kingdom for his generations. Guru Ji granted him the boon. Babur released the prisoners and gave them cloths. On this, according to 'Janamsakhi Bhai Bala', "Taan Baba Ji Barhe Prasann Hoye" (At that time, Baba Ji was so pleased). Therefore, we see that neither Guru Ji accepted 'Bhang', which was offered to him, nor he was pleased on this. Guru Ji did not accept it, because he was against its use, it is obvious. In its place, Guru Ji was happy, when Babur released the prisoners. According to the second argument given by Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji, the 'Mahant' (abbot) of Gurusar Satlaani got the license for 'Sukhnidhaan' from the British government. A 'Mahant', even he has many devotees, cannot be an ideal for Sikhs, who prays for victory of invaders against his own brothers/fellow-countrymen. Also, how can it prove that 'Maryada' of offering 'Bhang' at Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib is an old one ('Puratan'), if any 'Mahant' got license for 'Bhang' from the British government? The third argument given by Singh Sahib Ji says that at Sri Amritsar Sahib, Tarantaaran Sahib, Sri Anandpur Sahib, 'Sukhnidhaan' is being offered. It is possible that when Singh Sahib Ji visited Sri Amritsar Sahib Ji, 'Sukhnidhaan' was being prepared there. However, still it does not prove anything. If something is happening in modern age, how does it prove that it was in practice even Guru Gobind Singh's time? Recently, a Gurdwara was in news, where the Police found opium being cultivated. Does it prove that cultivating opium in Gurdwara premises is a 'Puratan Maryada' (old tradition)? The next argument given by Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji says that 'Nihangs' of the 'Budhha Dal' offer 'Sukhnidhaan'. If some Nihangs of Budhha Dal use 'Sukhnidhaan', it does not prove that it is a 'Maryada' started by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. According to the book 'Twareekh Guru Khalsa', written by Giani Gian Singh, Budhha Dal was founded in Samvat 1791 Bikrami (1734 AD). (See, 'Twareekh Guru Khalsa', part second, page 119, year 1987, the Language Department, Punjab). Any 'Maryada', which is being practiced presently in an organization, which was founded many years after Guru Gobind Singh left for his heavenly abode, does not prove that it is an old tradition. For example, nowadays, Budhha Dal has started to install 'Sri Sarabloh Granth' along with Sri Guru Granth Sahib and Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji. It is a well-known fact that installing Sri Sarabloh Granth Along with Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is not an old tradition. Instead, it is perfectly a new idea. Even Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji himself has not written that Sri Sarabloh Granth should be installed in Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji. Can anyone claim that installing Sri Sarabloh Granth is an old tradition, because at the present time it is being installed by Budhha Dal at some places? Not only Budhha Dal', but 'Tarna Dal' also was founded in the year of 1734 AD. In addition, none of these organizations was founded by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. In another argument, Singh Sahib Ji writes that description of 'Sukhnidhaan' has been given on many places in book 'Sooraj Prakash' (Sri Gur Pratap Sooraj Granth). Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji himself would not have been accepted every point of the 'Sooraj Prakash' a reliable source. For example, it is the same 'Sri Gur Pratap Sooraj Granth' (Sooraj Prakash), which does not believe that 'Ragmala' of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is recited by Guru. It is not rational to accept one thing and reject other in 'Gur Pratap Sooraj Granth'. Only a serious analysis of many books can show us the way to a result. Giving another argument, Singh Sahib Ji wrote that At 'Shaheedi Baag' in the city of Sri Anandpur Sahib, a small room, which was constructed during Guru's time, has been excavated, in which there were big 'Suneharas' (a kind of big vessel). It proves that 'Sukhnidhaan' was prepared and offered during the time of Guru Sahib. Big 'Suneharas' found in an old room do not prove that only 'Sukhnidhaan' was being prepared in them. If someone finds a cauldron in an old room, how can it be said that only 'Karhaah' (pudding) was cooked in it, not any vegetables? Even we believe that 'Sukhnidhaan' was prepared in those 'Suneharas', it is impossible to prove that this 'Sukhnidhaan' was prepared for Guru Ji, or by his permission. Singh Sahib Ji wrote that according to 'Khalsa Dharam Shaastar', Guru Gobind Singh Ji ordered to take intoxicants to remove sadness. The quantity of 'Chhatar-dhara' (opium) and 'Sukhnidhaan' was fixed. First, the 'Khalsa Dharam Shastar' is not an old book. Therefore, the tradition of 'Sukhnidhaan' cannot be proved an old one by this book. If we accept the argument of 'Chhatardhara' and 'Sukhnidhaan' given by the 'Khalsa Dharam Shastar', then why is only 'Sukhnidhaan' being offered at Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji? Why do they not offer 'Chhatardhara' (opium)? There is description of opium and marijuana in a same line. One is being offered at Takht Sahib Ji, and other is not. Why is it so? Singh Sahib Ji wrote that all the 'Rahats' can be known only from Guru history and 'Rahatnamas'. We cannot know 'Rahats' from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Though, it is right that we get information about all the 'Rahats' from Guru history and 'Rahatnamas, but only one book of history or only a single 'Rahatnama' cannot be accepted as an authority. We know that present 'Maryada' of 'Amrit Sanchar' (Sikh baptism) is not written in any of old 'Rahatnamas'; even then, present 'Maryada' of 'Amrit Sanchar' is being followed across the world. Why is it so? Does it not indicate that we get the 'Sikhi Rahat' from an unbroken tradition, which was started by Satguru Kalgidhar, the tenth Guru? It is obvious from arguments given by Singh Sahib Bhai Joginder Singh Ji that he used the terms 'Bhang' and 'Sukhnidhaan' as synonymous with each other. being the head priest of Takht Sahib Ji, he must have read these lines of the Gurbani: - Kabeer Bhaang Maachhulee Sura Paan Jo Jo praanee Khaanhe. Teerath Barat Nem Keeye Te Sabhai Rasaatal Jaanhe. 233. (Kabeer, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish and wine; - Pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they followed will all go to hell. 233.) (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 1377). I do not know why Singh Sahib Ji did not consider it necessary to mention these lines when he was discussing such an important topic.

Re: Bhang ancient marayad

Bhopinder Singh · 11 Nov 2005

Very interesting post ,goes on to proove that bhang was never used by sikhs,it also prooves who Joginder Singh is.

Re: Bhang ancient marayad

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

Althougth I do not accept everything Amritpal writes, I do think he has done a really good job at countering alot of UK nang parchaar. I do not understand why so many people put so much emphasis on books, and consider them above Gurbani?

Re: Bhang ancient marayad

A Singh · 11 Nov 2005

Dear SanMukh, Thanks for bringing this up, I think it also worth while alongside this topic discussing other aspects of "Maryada" which have clearly come out of the Nihang fold and are now believed by many to be "the" Khalsa Maryada. In this respect, let's look at the following points: 1. The Blue dress (Amrit Pal Singh 'Amrit') taken from: http://www.amritworld.com/nihangs/bluedress.html In Asa ki Var, Guru Nanak Dev Jee made mention of those Hindus of his time who had begun to wear blue clothing during the reign of the ‘Lodhi’ and ‘Mogul’ dynasties. Let us read the original words of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji: - Neel Vastar Pahir Hovainh Parvaan. Malechh Dhaan Le Poojainh Puraan. (Wearing blue robes, they seek the approval {of the Muslim rulers}. Accepting bread from the 'Malechh' people, they worship the 'Puraanas'). (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 472). An individual colour by itself does not have a religion, however one can see that within certain religions, particular colours are given some special status. For instance, the colour saffron has particular significance within certain Hindu religious sects. Likewise, the colour blue was associated with Islam. During Guru Nanak Dev Ji's time, the foreigner Muslim rulers, as well as other common Muslims used to wear blue clothing. History provides many accounts of the treatment meted out to Hindus at the hands of these Muslim rulers, at the same time it also indicates that certain Hindus received significant positions with the Muslim courts. To be accepted in the eyes of the Muslim court, such Hindus began to adopt blue clothing. They wore the long shirts and tunics of the foreign Muslim classes as a means to please their new rulers. Guru Nanak Dev Ji says:- Neel Bastar Le Kaprhe Pahire Turk Pathhaanee Amal Keeyaa. (People began to wear blue robes and garments; the life-style of Turks and Pathhaans was adopted). (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 470). Although the Hindus working under the Muslim officers would receive their wages in kind (usually by way of food grain), service to the Muslim rulers fast became their only source of income. Despite working under the Muslim regime, these Hindus would still refer to the Muslims as ‘Malechh’ amongst themselves. In their own homes, they would follow their own religious beliefs and recite Holy Scriptures such as the ‘Puraanas’ and spend money on their religious ceremonies, in which the ‘Vedas’ and ‘Puraanas’ would be recited. This money would of course be obtained from their Muslim employers, who they considered to be ‘Malechh’. Money or articles obtained from ‘Malechh’ patronage is termed ‘Malechh-Dhaan’. In short, this points to the double standards and parsimoniousness of such Hindus, who on one hand refer to the foreign Muslim rulers as ‘Malechh’ and one the other, except their ‘Malechh Dhaan’ for use in their livelihood and for the performance of their religious ceremonies. It is in this settting that Guru Nanak Dev Ji made these comments: - Neel Vastar Pahir Hovainh Parvaan. Malechh Dhaan Le Poojainh Puraan. (Wearing blue robes, they seek the approval {of the Muslim rulers}. Accepting bread from the 'Malechh' people, they worship the 'Puraanas'). (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 472). Accordingly, we can say that Syad Muhammad Latif was wrong, when he wrote the following about Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Ji in his book 'History of the Punjab': - ... he actually wished his followers to adopt a livery of his own invention, (in supersession of the blue dress which Nanak had ordered them to wear).... (History of the Punjab by Syad Muhammad Latif, page 280). Whilst it is true that Guru Nanak Dev Ji himself wore blue dress, when he went to 'Makka', the sacred city of Muslims. Bhai Gurdas Ji writes: - Baba Phir Makke Gya, Neel Bastra Dhaare Banvaaree. (Baba {Guru Nanak} then went to 'Makka' wearing blue robes). However, this was clearly for purposes of disguise for it was not possible for a non-Muslim to enter the city of 'Makka', so Guru Ji donned the Muslim outfit. Not only he wore blue robes, he also took 'Musalla' (prayer mat) and other Muslim paraphernalia. Bhai Gurdas Ji writes: - Aasa Hathth Kitaab Kachchh, Kooja Baang Musalla Dhaaree. (He was carrying a stick in his hand, a book under his armpit; he was with 'Kooja' {water pot with handle} and 'Musalla' {prayer carpet used by Muslims}.) From these references, we can see that blue robes were considered to be a Muslim dress. Hindus of the time (and many even to this day) would wear a white ‘dhoti’ and would cover their heads with turbans. It was only Hindus in the employ of the Muslim rulers who would wear blue clothing. In 'Pracheen Panth Prakash', we find a reference to a Sikh, who was in the service of the Muslim rulers and would wear blue clothing. Ratan Singh Bhangu writes: - Kahan Singh Kyee BanDeyon Judaayee. Lyee Turkan Syon Baat Banaayee. Rupyo Panj Sai NiT Lain Thhahraayo. Asvaar Panj Sai Saath Rakhaayo.2. Neel BasTree, Sir Chakra Sajaavai. Rahit Bhujangee Reet Rakhaavai. Parhai Baanee, ArDaaso Karai. Dangyon Phangyon Nah So Tarai.3. Thus, Kahan Singh left Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Ji and joined Muslim rulers. He got Rupees five hundred per day (as wages for him and his men). He had five hundred horsemen with him. He used to wear blue robes and put 'Chakra' (a discus) around his head. The timeframe in consideration here is circa 1714-1715 AD. If it is true that Kahan Singh used to wear blue robes, then this is not something necessarily out of the ordinary. It was said that in 'Kalyug', the Atharva Veda would become prominent and people would began to wear blue robes. Guru Nanak Dev Ji says: - Kal Maih Bed Atharban Hooyaa Naayaun Khudaayee Alhu Bhyaa. Neel Bastar Le Kaprhe Pahire Turak Pathaanee Amal Keeyaa. (In the Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the Atharva Veda has become prominent; Allah became the Name of God. Blue robes and garments are worn; the life-style of Turks and Pathhaans is adopted). (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 470). Elsewhere in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib , Guru Nanak Dev Ji goes on to say: - Kooja Baang Nivaaj Musalla Neel Roop Banvaaree. (The Muslim devotional pots, calls to prayer, prayers and prayer mats are everywhere; the Lord appears in blue robes). (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, page 1191). Blue clothing was not worn by the majority of Indians in the past, however under the influence of the Islamic regime under the Muslim government, it become popular even amongst non-Muslims. Many Indians embraced Islam whilst others, who did not convert, adopted parts of Islamic culture and lifestyle, one element of this being the blue attire. In case of Kahan Singh, it was only natural that he would wear blue robes. He was in service of the Muslims, who had also given him a flag and kettledrum. Ratan Singh Bhangu writes in his 'Pracheen Panth Prakash': - Dyo Nigaaro Nishaan Ghalaaye. ([The King] sent a kettledrum and a flag [to those Sikhs]). Obviously a flag sent by the Muslim ruler to Kahan Singh would not be a Sikh flag (Nishaan Sahib). Those Sikhs who had turned against Baba Banda Singh Bahadur and his army, fought under this flag. Naturally, if the Muslim government provided them with money, a flag and kettledrum, it is also possible that Kahan Singh and the Sikhs who sided with him would have been provided with a particular colour of uniform, as it would have been necessary to differentiate them from the Sikhs fighting under the command of Baba Banda Singh Bahadur. On other occasions, we see that the blue dress was also used by the Sikhs to disguise themselves. Not only did they wear the blue dress, they once even carried a green 'Haidari' flag and recited 'Allah Hoo Akbar'. Giani Gian Singh writes in his book 'Panth Prakash': - Neelee Bardee Singhan Dhaaree. Sajyo Ves Turkan Anuhaaree. Du-Ik Hazaar Singh Tat Raavee. Jaaye Tinai Eh Byot Banaavee. Sabz Rang Kar Jhanda Aage. Akbar Haq Bolne Laage. (The 'Singhs' wore blue dress. They disguised themselves as Muslims. On the bank of river Raavee, there were one or two thousands Singhs. They made this plan. They carried a green (Muslim) flag in front of them and started to say 'Akbar Haq'). Thus, these Sikhs attacked the city of Lahore wearing Muslim dresses, which were blue. It appear that in later times, it became very common to see blue attire amongst select Sikh militant groups. Otherwise, the majority of the Sikhs fighting under the command of the Budhha Dal and the Taruna Dal would only wear a Kachhehra and turban and cover their bodies with blankets. Giani Gian Singh writes in his 'Panth Prakash': - Khat Ras Ka Wah Swaad Na Jaanai. Kaprha Aur Na Tan Par Thhaanai. Kamar Jaangheeya, Ik Sir Patka. Bhoore Giltee Baana Jatka. (They {Singhs} do not know taste of six flavors. They do not wear any other clothes. There is underwear around their waists and a turban on their heads. They wear blankets, a Jatt dress). Conclusion: - The blue dress has no exceptional significance in Sikh culture and tradition. There are select instances when Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Sikhs disguised themselves in Muslim attire which was blue, however it only became common to see a few Sikh groups dressed in blue much later. 2. http://www.amritworld.com/nihangs/pharla.html 3. http://www.amritworld.com/nihangs/dumala.html and 4. http://www.amritworld.com/nihangs/chola.html Gur Fateh!