Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

Singh · 14 Nov 2005

I know Khalsa Aid do alot of good work. They are currently in Pakistan. My question is with so many sikhs injured in kashmir on India side, and no one helping them. Should Khalsa Aid be there rather than Pakistan? There are so many aid agencies in Pakistan already. Muslim groups only help muslims, no one helps sikhs. Arab countries have so much wealth, and can easily help those in pakistan if they wanted. Sikh money should help Sikhs. I am not against the humanity of helping everyone, but we should not forget our own sikhs, in our rush to help everyone. Sikh delegation from US visits Pak quake victims By SSN Nov 12, 2005, 14:01 Email this article Printer friendly page ISLAMABAD: US-born nine-year-old Manjot Singh comforts an earthquake injured Kashmiri woman during the visit of a Sikh delegation from US to Agha Khan medical camp in Islamabad on Friday. — PTI photo Relation between India and Pakistan will become friendly with the passage of time, said a member of 45-member Sikh delegation from North America visiting religious Sikh shrines in Pakistan these days. Talking to reporters during a visit to Melody Relief and Rehabilitation Centre for Earthquake Victims here, he said that "human beings belong to the same lot and there should not be any hatred between the two neighbouring countries." Referring to the loss of life and property in the tremor, he said that we are facing natural disasters like the earthquake in Pakistan collectively and we had not been sitting here together if that had not been the case. He said that after Tsunami and Katrina, a lot of money had been collected around the world and same is happening in connection with South Asian earthquake. He said that numerous organizations in private and public sector around the world are contributing towards relief work. One can find donation boxes for the victims of earthquake in Pakistan in shops in the Americas, he said. He said that Gurdawara Parbandhak Committee of North America had Already given a donation of $25,000 to Pakistan. Giving an example of their visit to Pakistan, he said that the Sikh delegation started collecting money for the quake victims only two days ago and presented to the Melody Rehabilitation and Relief Centre a sum equivalent to Rs 215,000. The delegation headed by Rashial Singh Rana, who had been Pardhan of the Gurdawara Parbandhak Committee of North America for two years, has already visited Gurdawara Panja Sahib and Peshawar and is scheduled to visit Holy shrines of Sikhs in Lahore, Mian Chunnu and Nankana Sahib. From Lahore, the entourage would proceed to India.

Re: Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

typical · 16 Nov 2005

Singhji I understand your concern but don't you know that it is more advantageous for so-called Sikh aid organisations to be seen helping non-Sikhs because they get more publicity for their organisations and get the 'sewadars' photos in more newspapers and on TV. There have been discussions on other forums about why these organisations don't help Sikhs but like Gurdwara committees, Akali Dals and most organisations run by Sikhs, it is the pardhan's egos that count and not the views of Sikhs. I remember a few years ago when over 30 Sikhs were massacred in Kashmir and the 'sewadars' of the only Sikh aid organisation in UK were going around the Nagar Kirtan with loudspeakers asking for donations to help the Sikh families of those massacred. I asked them whether all or even a majority of the money would be sent to these widows and orphans and the reply I got was very evasive saying that the money would go towards 'humanitarian' work of the aid organisation. Knowing that this organisation operates in mostly non-Sikhs areas most of the time then I can only assume that the money which the Sikhs at the Nagar Kirtan donated thinking was going to the Sikhs in Kashmir went to non-Sikhs. Gurbani tells us to use our Akkal when donating to charities so to those Sikhs who are concerned that their fellow Sikhs are overlooked then I suggest rather than donating to these aid organisations they should try and locate the many not so well known organisations that are working to help Sikhs and donate directly to them. It's a sad commentary on us Sikhs that when a few years ago a Sikh organisation in Karnataka set up a project to build houses for poor Sikh Sikligar families that the project took over a year to get the finances together, it wasn't millions of dollars needed, it wasn't even hundreds of thousands of dollars needed but something like 30,000 dollars! An amount that took a few hours for some Sikh gurdwaras in the west to gether for the earthquake victims. I think it's just not high profile enough for the publicity hungry Sikh Gurdwara pardhans and aid organisations to help Sikhs!

Re: Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

khalistan_zindabaad · 16 Nov 2005

gurfatheh, veer ji i will find out for you what khalsa aid is doing in india at the moment, i know that they have a drugs rehabilitation camp there, but me find out 4 u what else is going on in india

Re: Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

simple singhani · 18 Nov 2005

wjkk wjkf khalsa aid has done a lot in india from what i hear....but the the disaster in pakistan is sooo horrific how could u even say we shudnt help..them.. i dont undertstand.. (am not having a go at u lol) but.. go on the khalsa aid website.. that will tell u all they have bin doin in the past years... a sikhs job is to help humanity. see all humanity as ONE! i know what your saying and i canb see where you are coming from but.. i think its wrong to say.. they shudnt be helping other minorties.. and religions....like when guru arjun dev jee helped the hindus.. by going to different countries and making a difference is also..raising awareness and it is building an image on sikhs. it only takes on person to mess up our identity.. so we all need to work together to do things like sikhs in the square and various different events and charitys.. dont u think??? bhull chuk maaf wjkk wjkf

Re: Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

typical · 18 Nov 2005

Whatever Khalsa Aid does for Sikhs is incidental, most of the work they do is purely for non-Sikhs. It's all good, yes we should help everyone but let me give you an analogy. Imagine there's a very sewa orientated guy and he goes out to help his neighbours and fix their houses and do whatever that needs to be done around their houses, he also donates a large part of his pay to the others BUT at home his family starves and can only eat one meal a day and his house is in disrepair and falling apart because the guy spends so much time helping his neighbours and has no time to do things for his family...Now what would you think of that person? The Pakistan earthquake was bad but governments and other aid agencies are sending hundreds of millions to the area now tell me that the tens of thousands that Sikhs send will make a BIG difference to the victims. Shouldn't that tens of thousands be better spent helping Sikh victims of the earthquake who are being bypassed by all the aid agencies. Tangdhar’s Sikhs struggle to survive in quake aftermath By Bilal Butt, Tangdhar (Jammu and Kashmir): The once beautiful hamlet Sikh hamlet of Tangdhar lies in ruins today, completely devastated by the October 8 earthquake. A population of 300 to 400 Sikh inhabitants and 52 homes lies in a devastated state now. The inhabitants, mostly comprising of Sikh community who have been staying in the village for generations together complain of government apathy. “No one comes to visit us. We are suffering. We are not getting any kind of help from the government. If the government is sending some help it is getting lost on its way. Some people whoever comes to see us just goes back and forgets everything,” said Harmeek Singh, a villager. Most of the villagers are putting up in tents and with harsh winter knocking at the door, they eagerly wait for shelter and basic amenities like blankets. The villagers who suffered militancy for more than a decade and now the quake say they will not flee from the village in spite of all the difficulties. “We will not run away from this place come what may. This is our birth place. We suffered twice, once during militancy and the other time during the quake. We just want a little help from the government,” said Parmeet Kaur, another villager. More than 1,300 people have been confirmed dead in Kashmir, and 50,000 in Pakistan in the quake and the aid agencies say the numbers could double. The number of injured in the quake could also rise substantially with large areas still not reached nearly two weeks after the earthquake struck and the first heavy snowfalls of the harsh Himalayan winter a month or less away.

Re: Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

KS · 19 Nov 2005

I would like to know where all the Sant Baba who traveled to Gujarat and South india to set up langars have all gone? Maybe there is no political points to be gained by helping sikhs or Muslims.

Re: Khalsa Aid - India or Pakistan?

typical · 19 Nov 2005

It's just the Sikhs that these Babas and Khalsa Aid doesn't help. Wasn't there some Baba who built a mosque for Muslims in Punjab a few years ago. While we're on the subject of Khalsa Aid and Sant Babas, I heard that Khalsa Aid and these Babas had a bit of a tiff in Gujerat. Apparently Khalsa Aid 'sewadars' tore up many posters of the Sant Babas in Gujerat claiming that they were taking all the credit for the 'sewa' whilst Khalsa Aid thought they should have got the recognition for their activites. Comes back to my previous post, it's all about egos and not true sewa.