Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 14 Nov 2005

Can somebody please explain to me why lassan (garlic) and massara(n) di daal (lentils) are not used in Guru-ka-langar? (in most Gurdwaras around the world) I have heard that massar are included in langar at Anandpur Sahib but I am not sure if this is true- I can't recall eating massar when I have ate langar there. Somebody once said that apparently (according to legend) massar/lentils came from cows so that's why they are not prepared at Guru-ghar. Surely, if this is the only reason, then Sikhs do not believe in such nonsense? I know most Sikhs eat massara(n) di daal at home, so why isn't it used in langar? Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Singh · 14 Nov 2005

first i have heard of this, garlic and lentils are always used in langar..

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

innocent bystander · 14 Nov 2005

daal wihtout lassan ....... you gotta be kidding what is the world coming too.... next they will be saying you can't make chips in langar

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

.,. · 14 Nov 2005

I've seen that daal and garlic used in gurdwaras....

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

.... · 14 Nov 2005

I think hindoo tradition is creeping in here

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005

The question is not what the world is comming ot, it is whatvis what are the SIKHS comming to with their own versions of Sikhi snd sikh practices..some sikh do not even beleive in the panch pardhan and panch parawan ...

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Kulbir Singh · 14 Nov 2005

Brahmins don't eat onions or garlic. Looks like some Sikhs are copying Brahmins and avoiding the use of garlic and onions. In Gurmat, there is no prohibtion over the use of garlic or massara di daal. Kulbir Singh

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 15 Nov 2005

Thanks for the replies- I have read various versions of Sikh rehit maryada (Taksal, SGPC etc) and never seen anything against garlic or lentils either. So, are these ingredients used at Tapoban sahib?

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

BirRaas Singh · 15 Nov 2005

The same hukamnama attritubed to Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji in regards to "maas machi deh nehreh nahi jaana", also prohibits the use of onions in the next line.

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

agyani · 15 Nov 2005

erm in gurbani it clearly states that garlic is bad for u: i heard that in the katha of "jap ji sahib di matham" by gyani thakur singh - go download it on www.gurmatveechar.com

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Dasre · 15 Nov 2005

In india Samaagam sangat donot use garlic in Langar. only ginger, onoin and chillies are used to make masaalaa for Daal or Subzi. [%sig%]

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

!! · 15 Nov 2005

Muslims brought garlic to india, hindus treated muslims as malesh or impure did not use whatever they used in their daily life. Majority of sikhs are hindus by what they believe and follow their culture. Little things are doing great demage to sikhi but still believe these are sikh traditions.

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Kulbir Singh · 15 Nov 2005

--------- Thanks for the replies- I have read various versions of Sikh rehit maryada (Taksal, SGPC etc) and never seen anything against garlic or lentils either. So, are these ingredients used at Tapoban sahib? ------- There is no prohibtion on the use of these ingredients at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. ---------- Muslims brought garlic to india, hindus treated muslims as malesh or impure did not use whatever they used in their daily life. ----------- I don't think Muslims brought garlic to India. There is mention of Garlic in Vedas and other religious books of Hindus. Kulbir Singh

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

A Singh · 15 Nov 2005

gee whizz, another RSS infiltration! Many Gurdwaras (in india particularly) do not prepare the langer with 'tarka/turka' hence Pardeep Singh's initial observation. In my experience, despite this being the case, the Dhal tastes so wonderful - it is Guru Sahib's langar afterall!

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

GushK · 15 Nov 2005

Although there is no restriction in Sikhi on the use of Lassan remember the concept of Langar is to be "open to all". That's why there's no meat in Langar. From this point of view I can also understand that if certain sects don't eat lassan, onions etc, it could be removed from the dhaal to make sure they can also partake in the blessing of Gur Ka Langar. Regards Gursharan Singh

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

khalsa · 15 Nov 2005

The ancient Indians valued the medicinal properties of garlic and thought it to be an aphrodisiac. But it was not considered to be suitable food for the upper classes who despised its strong odour. It was also forbidden by monks who believed it to be a stimulant which aroused passions. Widows, adolescents and those who had taken up a vow or were fasting could not eat garlic because of its stimulant quality. Although highly regarded as a medicine, garlic was avoided in cookery. The Buddhists and Jains avoided eating it as did high-born Hindus and Brahmins.

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

singh · 15 Nov 2005

dear bir raas singh please quote the next line after maas macchi... where onions are mentioned in guru hargobind ji's hukamnama.

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Balpreet Singh · 15 Nov 2005

Bir Ras Singh, You are wrong. I hope it is an innocent mistake and not more Sanatani propoganda. The Hukumnama by Guru Hargobind Sahib contains NO MENTION of garlic or onions. Yes, the hukumnamas by Banda Singh Bahadur do contain these in addition to meat and fish. If you can find it, tell me where it is below:

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

khalistani · 15 Nov 2005

i do remeber one thing baba gurbachan singh je said tha u shdunt eat garlic, onions, etxc. before going into tABIYA now ma guess for this is in those times tha stuff wud make ure breath smell real bad, and in tabiya we shud have nice smellin breath for our guru, nice smells, we dont like when peoploe have bad breathe, y shuid we have it when we go to tabiya so tha can be a reason but for these dayz i think if one jus uses mouthwash lol its sall gud bhula chuka maf

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

sewak · 16 Nov 2005

IN Malaysia, our old Gurdwara Sahib TAtt Khalsa, known for its extreme rehat during 1920 onwards till 1980's, langar was made without and garlic.

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

manjh payara guru ko · 17 Nov 2005

brahmin can eat meat but.....without lassan(garlic) [%sig%]

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

p.d.s. · 17 Nov 2005

daal is good for protein, onions good for skin and garlic good for blood circulation

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

*saintsoldier* · 17 Nov 2005

many brahmgiani mahapurakhs prohibted lasan and laal mirch because it is not good for bhagti as it disturbs immune system and mental state. baba hor khana kusi kuar jit kade tan pirea man mei chale bikar [%sig%]

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

khalistani · 17 Nov 2005

i dun kno bout the bhagthee.. maybe... from wa kno garlic is good for immune system but i do kno sant je only said befor eogin into tabiya prob cause of bad breath but now we got mouth wash and mints hehe lol bhuka chuka maf

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

kabadi · 17 Nov 2005

lussan induces kaam

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

keepin it real · 19 Nov 2005

i've been told, its an aphrodisiac and therefore not used.

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

G Singh · 19 Nov 2005

garlic also is known to induce kaam

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

Kulbir Singh · 21 Nov 2005

As written before, Garlic is not prohibited in Gurmat. Some people do believe that it induces Kaam but Singhs who do abhyaas at amritvela need to eat "garam" things e.g. badaam (almonds), Badaam Rogan (almond oil) etc. Same way, even if Garlic is garam, it gets digested by Singhs who do abhyaas in the morning. Kulbir Singh

Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal

G Singh · 21 Nov 2005

bhai sahib, what do you mean by garam? and how do badams and almond oil fall into this category