Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Taking hukum and parchia

Taking hukum and parchia

confusingh · 11 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fatheh I'm making a decision regarding marriage to another Amritdhari person. I was advised by gursikhs that rather than taking hukumnama if i wished for a yes/no answer that i should do an ardas to Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji and write down the 2 options (yes and no- to marry that person) on 2 pieces of paper and after taking ardas with faith in Guruji randomly choose one and take that as Guruji's answer. I asked regarding this on the AKJ website and was told to just do an ardas to Guruji for His blessing and make the decision myself. http://www.akj.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=883 Could others please forgive my ignorance and provide more information regarding taking hukum in this way, its significance and history of its use. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fatheh

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

good ? · 11 Dec 2005

VJKK VJKF yes i would also like to know the answer to the above question as many chardi kalla Gursikhs i know use this method (not on a regular basis however only when a genuine yes/no answer is required)

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

agyani · 11 Dec 2005

why are you people using parchia(n)? where is it written in guru granth sahib's bani or in sikh ithihaas? if you are going to get married, and this person has the gunns of a gursikh, why are you in dubida? take hukam and go for it... using parchia(n) is the easy way out...its like gambling...it is brahmanvaad...why dont you just flip a coin?// i understand that you think this is a huge decision, and it is, but parchia(n) are not going to answer it for you...either you want to marry this person for thier gursikhi or you do not. if you think it is a good idea then guru sahib is with you (both of you - remember she is going through the same thing) i hope you are able to find peace...and guru sahib keeps you in chardi kalaa!!

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Frank · 12 Dec 2005

I think it is a perfectly good idea. I have myself done it many times when I could not figure out the what to do, and the decisions made were always fruitfull. When a yes came everything worked out and when a no came we were glad in the long run we did not make that decision as we were leaning towards it. It is not brahmanvaad. Don't worry too much, do ardaas and ask Guru jee to give you his answer through the parchees if you feel you need a direct answer. But mark my words once you have asked and the decision has come DO NOT second guess anything or you will be in for a real tough time. I did this once and we really had a tough time. Many Gurmukhs have used parchees, it is not an anti gurmat thing. For example Baba Nand Singh used to use parchees when 2 villages came and wanted him to go to there villages. He would put both names in a pot and do ardaas in front of Guru Granth Sahib. But I do agree with you, if you make a decision without parchees and do ardaas and ask for blessings Guru jee will help you as well. It is all a matter of your shardaa. Everybody is at a different stage of faith. In the end we have to learn to accept the will of the lord, whether it seems good or bad to us. To try and keep faith that all decisions we are making in fact are him in the background actually putting us on that path. In the end there is no good or bad, it is all the lord. Everthing and everywhere. Nobody is really coming and nobody is really going. It is Him just playing. Hope this helps.

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Jagjit singh · 12 Dec 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, personally I am not in favour of this at all. This is not taking any direction from Guru ji, but you are making decisions based on chance. There is no difference to just tossing coin. Base your decisions on the hukamnama, common sense, not on chance. I personally would never advise this. Further thinking that Guru ji is making that decision for you just because you stand by Guru ji when you are doing is just superstition. Our Guru is not blind, and as Gursikh we should be blind aswell. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Karnail Singh Barshi · 12 Dec 2005

agyani, does have a point. Whay are you not making the decision yourself and doing ardass for Guru sahibs blessing. Is'nt this what you do in allother decision making ? The other thing is, if the parchi answer is No, then will/can you walk away? If the decision goes against what you want, you cannot say "Best of three." You have to stick to the decision no matter what. Why cannot you make the decision yourself ? Akalpurkh has given you a mind exactly fro this reason, use it. If you really cannot make up your mind then maybe you don't want to go ahead with the marriage but are looking for a way out. I would say that if you really want to go ahead with this match, do ardaas saying that you WOULD LIKE THIS TO GO AHEAD AND are asking for Gurus blessing and take hukamnama, and go with what Guru Ji says. [%sig%]

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Frank · 12 Dec 2005

"""Further thinking that Guru ji is making that decision for you just because you stand by Guru ji when you are doing is just superstition. """" I don't agree with this part. Once you have done ardaas and have that love and faith that he will guide you, then it will be so. It could be through parchees or through any other method. I have done ardaas inside many times that I don't understand a certain shabad or aspect of gurmat. So I just randomly put on any katha or kertaan or went to the gurdwara and it is explaining my exact question. This has happened to me many times and I know to many of you. You could say it is just chance or coincidence, but to the Sevak it is the Grace of the Guru showering his blessings. "Satgur no Jaihaa Ko Ichdaa, Taihaa Phaal Pavai Koee" It is just a stepping stone really doing the parchees. You won't get stuck there, soon you will realize that Guru is Ang Sang and will always and is always helping and guiding you. Lets not get caught up in small details. Either way a Sikh does ardaas and is blessed with the Guru's Grace, we have that garauntee from the Guru. If you feel the need to use parchees then do so, if not then make your decisions on you own, either way we do ardaas and have faith that Guru jee will make us succesfull.

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

LionKing (LK) · 12 Dec 2005

Why do we think tha our Guru doesn't speak He DOES! Go and TALK to him. don't base your decition on a 50-50 chance. ASK YOUR GURU, PLEASE TALK TO HIM. If you still don't know how to talk to your Guru - listne to below - http://gurmatveechar.com/audio/Bhai_Pinderpal_Singh_(Ludhiane_wale)/Bhai.Pinderpal.Singh--Guru.Granth.Sahib.Ji.Boldey.Hun.Mp3

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Vidhiaarthi · 12 Dec 2005

wjkkwjkf! Parchiaa can be used. Theres nothing wrong with them! If you are going to Guru Sahib and asking them and then taking a parchi what wrong is that? If you were going to some next dude then, yes it would be wrong. Someone said it's all about chance. We can then say Hukam is chance. Bhana is chance etc. Should i wear my seatbelt when driving my car? If i have a crash then it may save my life it may not. But it improves the CHANCES. However, if its hukam for me to die on that day at that time then regardless if im wearing a seatbelt or not im going to die. Am i being too vague or going off topic? Parchia are fine... do Ardas with Sharda and Guru Ji will not look down upon you! Dont forget Guru Sahib Ji is our Father, they are not some angry person whom we cant approach and whom we should fear of. THEY ARE THE KING OF KINGS. OUR BELOVED FATHER! Hope you resolve your issue Singh ji! wjkkwjkf!

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

LionKing (LK) · 12 Dec 2005

EXACTLY, Guru jis is our father and will always guide us, so why not listen to what he's got to say himself, rather than taking parchia - if there's no dofference, then GO AND ASK HIM, WHY CAN't we just go and ASk GURU JI, what his Hukam is - after all it's a HUKAMNAMA

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Jasmin · 12 Dec 2005

Doesn't make sense to me. I understand the temptation, wanting an answer. But rationally it's 50/50 what if you asked about doing something anti-gurmat, and by chance you got a yes answer----and then you believed the guru ji was telling you to do it? Just a thought. Use with caution if at all.

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Dec 2005

what if you put BLANK parchaiaan..( Both of them blank)...try it and see. Guru ji could have bound a "blank" birr and let our "shardha" reveal the Hukmnama.... NO WAY..GURU JI asked BHAI GURDASS JI to have pen and papaer and INK ready and WRITE IT all down in Black and White for us so that we can READ IT... Go READ the HUKMNAMA..and LISTEN to what Guur Ji got to say..then use your SHARDHA to OBEY what Guru Ji says no matter whether you like it or not.

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Jagjit Singh · 13 Dec 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, one of my veers said, "Someone said it's all about chance. We can then say Hukam is chance. Bhana is chance etc." Parchaian or tossing a cion is chance. it is 50/50. You yourself are giving Guru ji just a yes or no answer, creating everything black or white. Hukam is not chance. It is Truth. It is specific to you, at that time, with a detailed message, according to the blessings of Guru ji. If you do not understand it then consult an elder. Bhana is not chance, Bhana is destiny and karam. Basicaly people are using this as an easy way, possibaly when they do not understand the hukamnama, or it situations in which they are in a real dilemma, and what to subconciously believe that Guru ji is with them in their decision. I would say Guru jis is only with you, if you have a specific hukamanama, and understand its specific message to you. If ever in doubt then consult another Gursikh, if still in doubt then go in front of the Panj pyares and take their advice. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

.... · 13 Dec 2005

Jagjit Singh you say that Hukam is not chance, Im in a similar situation to confusingh, the lavan da paath came as a hukamnama, I dont know how to interpret this. Please let me know your views on this

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

SINGH · 13 Dec 2005

Sant Baba Thakur Singh Ji said it was ok to use Parchia. Also, what if you took a hukam from sikhitothemax as getting to the Gurdwara was not accessible. Would that be considered ok? If thats considered ok, then what if Ragmala came as a Hukam? Would we have to follow that? What would the message be? Please answer my questions, I am serious and do not wish to cause offence or go off topic. Thanking the Sangat! SINGH

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

. · 13 Dec 2005

doesnt matter which paat it was, what did it say

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

hmmm · 13 Dec 2005

http://www.akj.org.uk/literature/article.asp?b=t&s=naam&f=karma The use of parchia for me touched on the subject of free will and determinism. Determinism is making your decisions using chance events like a gamble. It says on the above akj site that sikhi believes in One God and as such it follows that it also believes in free will. It says "Determinism is repugnant to the sikh mind" and Guru Nanak allied himself to supporting Free Will as opposed to the complete dependence on Divine Will. Now if a sikh does not have free will then surely that person cannot be held to account in Dharam Raja's court? The use of Parchia for a final definate decision takes away the responsibility of that decision away from that person and supposedly gives it to Guruji. But he can't be held to account only WE will for our decisions. Also if parchia are used for decisions where should a sikh draw the line? Surely the decision of taking amrit is as important as deciding to marry. So if a sikh used parchia to decide whether to take amrit this would open up the possibility of Guruji saying no someone should not take amrit?! Maybe winning the lottery would be as important as marriage so could this be used to pick the lottery numbers? I apologise for using silly examples but i don't understand the history and background of the use parchia nor the limitations or conditions of its use. Forgive me

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

think · 13 Dec 2005

is this about 'shardha' or about being careful when making a huge decision? Those who say a cyber hukumnama or a hukumnama chosen by a person is also chance is not correct as Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji has the most important part to play of providing the actual written hukum itself. SGPC rehit maryada which provides the basic beliefs of Sikhs states in Chapter VI Article VII on taking Hukam that "Raising the drapery covering the Guru Granth Sahib and merely taking a look or making others take a look at the exposed page, without taking the command (reading the prescribed hymn) is contrary to gurmat (Guru's way). " The command is READING THE PRESCRIBED HYMN not merely taking a look or anything else. Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji is SHABAD Guru- it is the actual written hymns that contain the message/command. Please do not provide opinion alone- back up what you say.

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

lost · 13 Dec 2005

I think parchiaa is limited to use in extreme situations? Whereas a hukumnama depends on your interpretation and you will take from it what you will into the context of your own life. It can be used WITHOUT any condition in ALL situations so if you were considering taking amrit then you could use it then too. So with a hukumnama the onus still remains on YOU as an individual to make the decison and be accountable/responsible for it

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Jagjit Singh · 14 Dec 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I fail to see how putting two pieces of paper with YES/NO, in front of Guru Maharaj, then doing ardas, and then picking one up is right? What is the difference between doing that and doing ardas then tossing a coin and saying heads for yes, and tails for no? Nobody would do the latter, so why do the former? A hukamnama is always specific. However the same hukamnama from for example, Darbar Sahib, can mean specifically different things to thousands of different Gursikhs around the world. This is a the amazing power of the Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib. No living person who claims to be a Guru in false Gurudooms can ever do this. The only reason, things like parchaain start is because of our lack of knowledge of Gurbani, lack of faith in Guru, or laziness in trying to find the interpretation of the hukamnama. If this is the case, then solve this problem, do not add another problem to it. Guru Sahib will be happy to take ownership of a decision which is made in line with Gurmat, but people are passing ownership of decisions based on chance. To the veers who are in dilemmas because they may have lavan da paath or other hukamnamas. It is impossible for me, to interpret the shabad for you, as I do not know who you are , or what your circumstance is. I will not even try on this messageboard. If you are in UK, approach me in the sangat, and we can discuss it further. The lavan shabad for someone can tell them to marry, others remove doubts about marriage. For others, it may mean concentrate more on naam and spirituality at these stages of your life are passing, or as you become one with soul - bride and Akaal. For others it is the accomplishment of achieving this. It all depends on you, your state of sikhi, and what is happening in your jeevan. Guru ji has spoken to you accordingly. Hukamnamas are there as a means for Guru ji to give you advice and direction. They remove your dilemmas. But as is the case for some, who have been unable to interpret it, and it has put them more in dilemma or dubda. Then there is nothing wrong in doing ardas. In this ardas asking Guru ji to remove dubdas and dilemmas from your mind, and taking another hukamnama. My benti is leave all other avenues in life, of chance, trickery, blind worship, and fall in front of sahib siri Guru Granth sahib accepting Guru ji ass the sole guide in your life, by accepting his words of Gurbani. - the SHABAD GURU. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Dec 2005

i used to do that "parchian" stuff when i was in std three. Whenever the exams approached i would write "you will pass" on one parchee..and put "you will fail" on naother. Then I would do ardass and pick one up...IF the result was "You will Fail"..I would put them back..do another ardass and pick again...UNTIL i got the parchee that declared "You will PASS"... THATS how SILLY all this stuff is. I have outgrown it a long time ago...Trust in Guur Ji's HUKM..ALWAYS no matter what...no picking numbers/lottery tickets/yes/no answetrs etc..

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

LionKing · 14 Dec 2005

Agree with Jagjit Singh ji - ******* My benti is leave all other avenues in life, of chance, trickery, blind worship, and fall in front of sahib siri Guru Granth sahib accepting Guru ji ass the sole guide in your life, by accepting his words of Gurbani. - the SHABAD GURU. ******* Yes, just take the Hukamnama and Ask Guru ji what his hukam is. Accept it.

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

SHABAD Guru · 14 Dec 2005

i disagree wit those who say this is about 'sharsha' as nobody doubts whether Guruji COULD do this but WOULD Guruji intervene in a chance game and give us a resolute black and white decision? The names of Bhai Nand Singh ji and Sant Takhur Singh ji were mentioned but in connection with use for very minor decisions- did even they use this for the decision of marriage? i agree with lon king, jagjit singh, jarnail singh and others- life is not black and white which is why we have hukumnama so we can apply it to our own life situation. With hukumnama we see Guruji intervene by giving us a SHABAD but with the chance game how do we know whether He intervened or just allowed someone to take a gamble? If Guruji would be willing to take sole responsibility of major decisions in life then surely we could stand Him in Dharam Raja's court on our behalf

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

_ · 14 Dec 2005

What if you took a hukamnamma and got an answer to your question; would there then be some sort of timeframe to complete that hukamnamma within? If you got your answer would it be wrong to complete that task ten years later?

Re: Taking hukum and parchia

LionKing (LK) · 16 Dec 2005

Do ardaas and take Hukamnama before doing everything. The HUkamnama might be talking about ur situation at the time, and ten yers later your probably not goign to be in the exact same situation.