Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Gandalf · 13 Dec 2005

In the last few months, I have noticed some really blatant racism/casteism/sexism/intolerance/anger in some of the posts on this web site As someone who has never visited Tapoban, I have to wonder...Is Tapoban really like this? Does Tapoban think of people with different views than them like this...it seems that Tapoban has the mentality that Sikhism is exclusive to Jatt Punjabis and no one else... Some of the most recent posts reek of a male chauvinist, intolerant Punjabi attitude ....for example.... --------------- stop your silly gora talk- the goray are self-centred- they never cared about us in India and they definitely don't care about us here... Loof after no.1 - SIKHS --------------- i just want to point out jatts are a brave, tenacious, highly motivated, industrious, race with unique habits known and practiciced only to themselves. This is why others cannot relate to or understand wher ewe are coming from. We are not your enemies but friends brothers, you have to accept us. This mighty jatts keep on roaring for all times. --------------- western society has brainwashed sikh women into "GIRL POWER - do what you want" attitude some sikh women take advantage of the sikh teaching of equality, and exploit it. --------------- ajj kaal koee biban hageeaa jerieaa brabbar haakh mangdieaa ------------- But one major factor i have noticed is that of women. Back in the day women were taught that they needed to change to fit into the family they are moving into, as many times when they get married they ended up living with an extended family. Today it seems most women (not all) expect the entire family to change for them. ---------------- some of these goray need some jutheyan ------------------ first guy doesn't how to spell..typical canadian

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Balpreet Singh · 13 Dec 2005

Gandalf, This is a message board and on a message board, you will find a lot of different people with a lot of different opinions and thoughts. The vast majority of people who post on this message board have never been to the Gurdwara, forget being regular members of the Sangat. In order to have a message board, you need to allow people to voice their opinions. The disclaimer at the top of the message board clearly says that the Gurdwara does not necessarily endorse everything on this board. There's not much of a message board if the only people allowed to post are people who go to the Gurdwara Sahib. I think it's more than just a little naive to wonder "Is Tapoban really like this? " as you put it, after reading some of the more distasteful views on this board. If you have found any jatt-centric or biased posts posted under "Admin" then do share them. Otherwise, I think everyone understands that these views are not the views of the Gurdwara. So, when you see a post you don't agree with, voice your opinion. Debate it. That's what the message board is for. The Admin certainly does bar any over-the-top biased posts, but sometimes the best way to challenge an idea you don't agree with is not to silence it, but to allow it to be heard and then use arguments to show how wrong it is.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

LionKing (LK) · 13 Dec 2005

I have read on some forum that once a Mona touched the patila of daal, and the sevadars threw it all just because he had stirred the daal with the Karchi. I was not way to impressed by this, could some sevadar from Gurdwara Tapoban please confirm if this happened or not. Actuallly, I'll find out if this post is even posted on the phorum to the pbulic. Again I'm not acussing or anything, but this is just something thta heas been going around on the net, and I would like to know how true this is by sevadars.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Balpreet Singh · 13 Dec 2005

Lion King, According to the langar maryada at the Gurdwara Sahib and from what we understand to be Gurmat maryada, a non-amritdhari is not allowed in the langar area but is free to eat in the Pangat with everyone else. The Langar area is only for tyaar-bar-tyaar amritdhari sevadaars. Although your story is compeletely fabricated and this event never happened (simply because the sevadaars would be more careful than to allow this), if a mona did handle the food in the langar, it would not be used. This is not some special "Tapoban Maryada", it is the bibeki maryada used in many langars.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

LionKing (LK) · 13 Dec 2005

Balpreet Singh ji, thank you for your propmt response and thank you for confirming that the story is not correct, as this is a story that is spreading on the internet. ***** if a mona did handle the food in the langar, it would not be used. This is not some special "Tapoban Maryada", it is the bibeki maryada used in many langars. ***** Simply because the person stirred the daal?´ So if a Mona DID stor the patila full of Daal ready to be distributed t Sadh Sangat in Pangat, it would have been thrown out because a Human being simply stirred it? If the Daal has been prepared by doing Paath while preparing it, will the spirituality and Naam Bani just => LO AND BEHOLD go "poof". Will the Naam, Bani Spirituality, the phaal of preparing with with Pyaar Naam just dissappear if the person stirres the daal for a few seconds? Please enlighten me on this issue as I am ignorant on how much bibek sevadars keep. Hopefully this post will be posted as I seriously would like responses to above questions. Vaheguru Vaheguru Vaheguru Vaheguru Vaheguru Bhull chukk maaf

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Balpreet Singh · 13 Dec 2005

I am not aware of any such story "spreading on the internet" . Where else have you seen it but here before you posted it? I'm not going to get into the technicalities and guess work of what goes "poof" or not, but it is a practice and principle that if anyone who is not tyaar-bar-tyaar handles the langar, it is not used.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

LionKing (LK) · 13 Dec 2005

Balpreet Singh Ji, I read the story on a sikhsangat.com blog quite a while ago. Although I do not agree with you, I would like to thank you for your response, and for clearifying that the story is not true.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Balpreet Singh · 13 Dec 2005

I've done a search on the Sikhnet blogs and didn't find any such story. Are you sure that's where you saw it?

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

K. Singh, Germany · 13 Dec 2005

<Admin CUT: as we have told you before, "K.Singh" or "Gurcharan Singh", foul language like this will not be tolerated. Your IP of "proxy.aol.com" is the same from last time and we repeat that such messages will NOT be tolerated here.>

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Gurcharan Singh · 13 Dec 2005

Sir, please stop attributing to me anything.I have just read this article.I have NOT used any filthy language.It looks like one BILGA is bent on doing this since he disagrees with issues., and attributing my name to something he may be sending. Oh I dont have time for such childish story tellings Gurcharan Singh

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Admin · 13 Dec 2005

Gurcharan Singh, once again the IP "proxy.aol.com" has appeared with your latest post in which you deny using the alias "K. Singh". Pardeep Singh's IP is different from that. The very next message to be posted on our board after K.Singh's (again with IP of proxy.aol.com) was >>>>>>>>> Re: ABUSE IN HARYANA GURDUARA Author: Gurcharan Singh Date: 12-13-05 15:27 >>>>>>>> Do not try to lie to us or the sangat. We will not approve any further posts in the future that contain vulgar language or personal attacks. If you cannot abide by these rules, you are free to go elsewhere. Admin.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Gurcharan Singh · 14 Dec 2005

Vin bollian subh kichch jandaa kis aagai keechay ardass" SGGS, page 1420 "tu aapay subh kichch jandaa kis aagai karee pukar" SGGS, p.1258 "kya maango kichch thir na rahaee" SGGS, page 481

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Singh · 14 Dec 2005

amazing the kinds of lies people spread about tapoban. shows alot of jealousy......

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Dec 2005

Let them talk >>> inMdku inMdw kir mlu DovY Ehu mlBKu mwieAwDwrI ] ni(n)dhak ni(n)dhaa kar mal dhhovai ouhu malabhakh maaeiaadhhaaree || By slandering, the slanderer washes the filth off others; he is an eater of filth, and a worshipper of Maya.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Gandalf · 14 Dec 2005

Im not talking about gossip about Tapoban or anything. People gossip about everyone. That goes without saying. The reason I raise this issue is because I am amazed that some of this stuff has been allowed on this board (go back and look at some of the posts that I copied in the original post. It is very blatant, and anti-Sikhi). How can the moderators justify putting such anti-gurmat views up? And these are just a few of the posts that come to mind. At the top of the board it reads: Any type of posts that contain vulgar language, personal attacks, flame wars, and content against the teachings of Gurmat are STRICTLY PROHIBITED. Yet posts like these have been put up Does that mean that these posts do not go under any of the categories mentioned that will be prohibited?? I know that this is a message board, and that the views do not reflect Tapoban views, but I have to wonder when some really anti-Gurmat things have been allowed on this board (i.e. sexist, racist, caste-ist), if this view of Sikhi/Gurmat is one held by the moderators.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Balpreet Singh · 14 Dec 2005

Gandalf, Let's not beat a dead horse here. I've already made it clear to you that these views are not shared by the moderator nor the Gurdwara. I don't know what answer you are looking for by once again posting the question. None of the stuff you posted seems so offensive to me that it warrants shock. I find it to be ignorant and needing a response, but not so horrible as to shock my conscience. All the posts you mentioned were given a response countering them. With hundreds of messages posted every week, it's not unlikely that some questionable stuff may sometimes leak through. But as I've said none of this stuff was over the top. Just ignorant.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 15 Dec 2005

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!! i've been posting on tapoban.org for about 2 or 3 years now... and i have to actually agree with Gandalf, that the quality of the moderation of the forums has distinctly decreased over time. Many anti-gurmat and anti-panthic posts have been allowed and cross-jatha politics have actually been allowed to escalate in posts, especially in relation to anything about sampardas. with guru ji's kirpa the punj pyare gave me naam drir and i respect a lot of the jatha singhs and the rehit they keep. i understand it and i agree with many of the beliefs, such as the importance of keski, such as pad-chhed is manmat, sarbloh bibek is important, etc. some of these rehits i have not been able to keep but i agree with them. but at the same time i agree with many teachings from different sampardas, and i have noticed that any posts about rara sahib or damdami taksal turn into ninda-festivals. and the moderation really doesn't start until somebody gets frustrated and says, "admin please close the thread," and then Admin comes in and says "thread is now closed." the moderators have been playing the role of "let the fight happen then we'll pretend we stopped it." gandalf is not beating a dead horse. this is actually an issue that is still taking place - some rules are made for the forums, but there is favourtism in who gets to break those rules. that includes posts with caste-prejudice, sexism, anti-panthic politics, and posting events for certain groups is allowed but other groups are not allowed. please forgive my mistakes. vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefathehhh !!!!!

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

hmm... · 15 Dec 2005

kar kirpa, I think your argument is based on you belief that all Jathas are equal and can't ever be wrong or promote manmat. You're wrong. There are Jathas and sampardas out there that promote the wrong belief. Other message boards try to hide or ignore this by disallowing discussions on the issue. I think it's important that these practices be exposed, even if it does make people uncomfortable or result in hard feelings.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

bibek daan... · 15 Dec 2005

"hmm..." jio i think the point, at least what i got from "kar kirpa" ji, is that the moderators of a public forum need to be unbiased. it is not that there cannot be differences in thought...but rather, if you are going to profess that this is a public forum and that people are entitled to thier views, subject to the exception that disrespect will not be allowed, the admin/moderators have an inherant duty to act in an evenhadned manner when judging disrespect. the moderators (from what i have noticed) seem respectful to non-tapobanians, but at the same time, a bias against non-jatha people is possibly present. it is important to note that what is "gurmat" is relative from person to person, org to org (even though it should not be). so, some bias is inevitable, even when avoided. i am not saying that the admin/moderators DO discriminate (from my current observation i am in no position to say they do at least), but that they are EXPECTED not to... fateh ji!

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

... · 15 Dec 2005

The difference on this board is that the ADMIN let through anything which criticises other Panthic Jathebandies and Sampardhas and allow the nindiya to escalate, but they will not allow posts through which criticise AKJ or Tapoban Singhs. ADMIN probably won't allow this post through either - but if they are honest and sincere, then they should allow all posts through, even when they criticise Tapoban or AKJ.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Admin · 15 Dec 2005

As Admin we try to be as unbiased as possible. In the future we will try to do our job as best as we can and try to maintain that. We think it's unfair to say that "they will not allow posts through which criticise AKJ or Tapoban Singhs", because as you can see, this thread is going and that is in addition to the "jatha vs. deras" one and many threads which have challenged sarbloh bibek and other issues. As always we will continue to try to make this board as educational as possible with as little useless controversy as possible and will try to be even more vigilant in the future.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 15 Dec 2005

Thank you veer Gurpreet Singh ji............ Fateh!!!!!!

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

D Kaur · 15 Dec 2005

I myself have been coming to this site for three years now and have to say that this is one of the best sites. Everyone is making it sound as if the admins allow bashing of other jathas but not their own, when this is not case. The admins do not intend for fights to stir up and then pretend to stop them. From what I know, the Singhs have nothing but respect for Taksali Singhs, so why would they purposely allow posts that bashs Taksal? They allow individuals to have a discussion, remember this is a discussion board. Once the thread is out of control, the admins shut it down; this has nothing to do with stirring up fights. It is not the admins or the Singhs of Tapoban Sahib that post such hateful and negative posts towards other Jathas, so why is the Tapoban Sangat getting blamed for such negative posts? People have bashed the Tapoban Singhs on this site and those posts have been posted up. Why don’t you go and look at other forums and see if those forums let anything negative about their website or their admins up. I know from first hand that the other Sikhi forums will not allow any post with bashing of their website or of their Singhs. So I suggest you all lay off on this whole “Tapoban Singhs are this” or “Tapoban Singhs are that.” No one is holding a gun to your head and forcing you to come visit the site, if you don’t like the way it is being run then I guess you should go to another forum which is being run “properly”, but I’m sure you will not find any. kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa, why would the admins accept a post which is against gurmat? If a post is preaching anti-gurmat related issues, then those posts should not be accepted. There are many groups out there that promote anti gurmat rehits, who want people to follow them. Posts by these people SHOULD NOT be accepted if they are trying to preach their anti-gurmat views. I suggest you all back of the Admins. They have done an amazing job running this site. I have nothing to say to them but thanks for the hard work they have put in making this an educational forum. -- D Kaur [%sig%]

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 15 Dec 2005

vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!! what i think does not matter and is of no significance because i am not any type of authority on anything, but i would just like to clarify that i definately do not believe that all jathas have no weaknesses. i believe all groups have some strengths and some weaknesses. and when all groups work together it is called "gunnaa dee saanjh" and what happens when we are united is "vich sangat har prabh vasai jeeo" but without that atmosphere we suffer. which is happening right now. bipran kee reet is not just janeiu and caste system. bipran kee reet is also duality and "my jatha" vs. "your jatha" politics and as long as we stay in that we will never get support from guru sahib "niyara" does not just mean being distinct in bana it also means being distinct in our aacharan, our karams. but right now we are arguing amongst each other like the rest of the world. please forgive me if i said anything against gurmat. it is nothing personal to the Admins. much respect to them as gursikhs. moderation of this forum is poor. but the Admin as gursikhs are amazing. Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa Vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Jasmin · 15 Dec 2005

I find this forum to be educational, and focoused. The admin. deserves credit for that. While I've visited other forums this is the one I come back to again and again. Easy to navigate, strict, but fair, in its overall viewpoint. It was one of the blessings that I reflected on this past thankgiving. chandri kala

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

International Akaali · 16 Dec 2005

I visited tapoban i think two months ago... There are a lot of nice gursikhs there who will greet you the greatedt respect.. I may not agree with all there views but i cannot forget how well i was treated there. Rub Rakha

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

_ · 17 Dec 2005

I agree with kar kirpa. If you tell a lie and save someone life, then that imho is good action. Then when you have to adjust to the situation then sometime you cannot be as strict as you would want to to improve the overall outcome. Like one time i seen this little rabbit that was hopping to its mother. THen this boy came and kicked the rabbit into the wall and blood started coming out of its ears. Then that kids friend came and pushed that kid to the ground and started stomping of the rabbits heads until the brains started leaking out of the eye sockets. If one was a bystander to such a situation would that be anti gurmat? imho it would be because in times of great evil if good men do nothing they are equally responsible for the evil incurred.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Dec 2005

Bhenjis Jasmin Kaur, D. kaur.... You have said all the correct things and well said too. I LOVE this Board and have found it to be educational, supportive, solidly Pro GURMAT and Akal Takhat Maryada. The Admins have a very very tough job....let them do it as only they can. As it has been said..no body is holding a gun to your temple..go elsewhere if you dont like it....they way i see it..Tapoban's popularity is worrying some other sites...in MALAYSIA..people NOW "dismiss it " as just another CANADIAN SITE ( when they got hammered ) but used to promote it when they mistakenly thought the site Admin would support their derawadee/sampardaee nonsense no matter what...sadly they found out the TRUTH....THIS SITE only Promotes GURMAT and nothing else. Keep it up Veero.

Re: Question about Tapoban Sangat views

Singh · 19 Dec 2005

Gandalf ji, It is not just tapoban, but all sikh messageboards are being infested with this jatt stuff. it is all coming from the jattworld site. I would not be surprised if it just one guy with no life, who spend all his time on the internet. rather than coming here or other sikh sites, and slating the admins. You should go to the source and challenge them. By the way a JATT is nothing but a farmer. A JATT is not a sikh. A farmer can be french, english, hindu, or whatever. Farming is not a religion, neither a race, or an ethnic group. Mr jattworld shoud stop being such an ALLOO, GOBI, KHADOO and every other vegatable under Waheguru`s sun.