Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
Kulbir Singh · 14 Dec 2005
There is no such thing as Tapoban AKJ or other AKJ. AKJ is AKJ.
Just like Singhs living around village Maliya are called Maliyaan walay Singh and Singhs living in Gurdaspur are called Gurdaspur walay Singh, Singhs living and coming to Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib are called Tapoban walay Singhs.
As for wearing Baana for both males and females, Singhs around the world, out of Chaao for Guru Sahib wear baana all the time. Similarly Singhs around the world keep Sarbloh and Bibek out of love for Guru Sahib. The rehits like Baana, Sarbloh and Bibek are not unique to Tapoban Singhs.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Dec 2005
and yes i am SELAYANG WALLAH SINGH...and just the other day i had the Great FORTUNE to meet a AKJ Chardeekalla wallh Singh Ji and his fmaily from New Zealand......wow..what a meeting of hearts seeped in Gurbani/Love for the Guru Granth Ji...and of all reasons he came all the way to meet me because of what i write on Tapoban Board..Wahgur...it hsould have been the other way around..i should have gone to meet him as he was definitley more chardeekala than me..
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
Kulbir Singh · 14 Dec 2005
Lionking,
---------------
Shoudl be be attaching jathebandis to ourself, calling ourselves Taksali, AKJ or whatever Singhs?
-------------
It’s your personal choice whether you want to walk on the path to Guru Sahib alone or in a group. Gurbani encourages walking in a group called Sangat. Being part of a group of hum-khiyaali (similar minded) Gursikhs does not equate getting separate from Panth. Panth is much bigger than Jathas and organizations. Panth is made up of Panthak organizations and all Gursikhs. If a Gursikh is a member of Akali Dal or other Sikh organizations he does not cease to be a member of Khalsa Panth.
This is a mania that many so called “Panthak” individuals have. They think that being a member of a Jatha equates to not being a member of Khalsa Panth. This is very absurd thinking. If I live in the vicinity of Tapoban Sahib and I go to Tapoban Sahib and I hang out with Gursikhs there, I am no longer member of Panth Khalsa? What kind of twisted notion is this?
----------------
You might say that everyone else does it - but shoudl we follow others, or follow our Ek Guru
Ek Pita Ekas ke Hum Barik
-----------
Being member of AKJ, does our Guru change? Being a member of AKJ, do we cease to be “Barik” of “Ek Pita”?
No matter what you do, you cannot avoid a label. If you live in Toronto they will call you Torontowalay. Some are called Vaheguru-Vaheguru walay, others are called Taksal walay. Some are called Jathay walay and others are called choliyaan walay. Some are Ludhianawalay others are Amritsar walay. Some are Patialawalay others are Jalandhar walay. Some are Gol-pagaan waalay others are Sidheeiyaan pagaan waalay. Some are called Bhindranwalay others are called Mehtay walay. No matter what you do, you will be labelled for the purpose of distinguishing from others. These labels don’t separate us from Panth Khalsa.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
Harcharan Singh · 14 Dec 2005
Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
There is a difference between someone else giving you a label and you giving yourself a label, which is what most jaatha paatha Singhs do.
The only jaatha our Guru blessed us to join was the Khalsa. All other man made Jaathaa's mean nothing.
Satnaam.
Harcharan Singh
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
Kaljug Jeev · 14 Dec 2005
wjkk wjkf....heheh we here in malaysia some where northen are called taliban wale..kekek...cause we sit down n wear dumalley:>thths wicked:P...wjkk wjkf
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
LionKing (LK) · 16 Dec 2005
Kulbir Singh jeo,
***********
It’s your personal choice whether you want to walk on the path to Guru Sahib alone or in a group. Gurbani encourages walking in a group called Sangat. Being part of a group of hum-khiyaali (similar minded) Gursikhs does not equate getting separate from Panth. Panth is much bigger than Jathas and organizations. Panth is made up of Panthak organizations and all Gursikhs. If a Gursikh is a member of Akali Dal or other Sikh organizations he does not cease to be a member of Khalsa Panth.
************
AKJ SIKH, or KHALSA SIKH?
You are indicating that it's a different entity from the Khalsa Panth, or is Khalsa Panth like all other religions with sects and cults, i.e Shia Muslim, Sunni muslim, Taliban Muslims.. is our Panth Khalsa like this?
By labeling yourself as something other than a Khalsa of the Guru, indicates its a seperate entity than khalsa Panth, and as far as I know AKJ isn't separate.
**********
This is a mania that many so called “Panthak” individuals have. They think that being a member of a Jatha equates to not being a member of Khalsa Panth. This is very absurd thinking. If I live in the vicinity of Tapoban Sahib and I go to Tapoban Sahib and I hang out with Gursikhs there, I am no longer member of Panth Khalsa? What kind of twisted notion is this?
*********
No, but is Tapoban a Jathebandi, or does tha make you any different of a Sikh from the rest of the Sikhs around the globe. By particularily calling yourself as AKJ SINGH, this is what we find out about you -
* You believe raagmala is not Gurbani
* You most likely are for the struggle against india
etc... AKJ has a few "official believes", which are different to the rest of Panth.
*********
----------------
You might say that everyone else does it - but shoudl we follow others, or follow our Ek Guru
Ek Pita Ekas ke Hum Barik
-----------
Being member of AKJ, does our Guru change? Being a member of AKJ, do we cease to be “Barik” of “Ek Pita”?
No matter what you do, you cannot avoid a label. If you live in Toronto they will call you Torontowalay. Some are called Vaheguru-Vaheguru walay, others are called Taksal walay. Some are called Jathay walay and others are called choliyaan walay. Some are Ludhianawalay others are Amritsar walay. Some are Patialawalay others are Jalandhar walay. Some are Gol-pagaan waalay others are Sidheeiyaan pagaan waalay. Some are called Bhindranwalay others are called Mehtay walay. No matter what you do, you will be labelled for the purpose of distinguishing from others. These labels don’t separate us from Panth Khalsa.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
************
There's a difference between what others call you, and what YOU CALL YOURSELF.
We have limited ourself to Ajthebandiya and Sampardava, how about all Sikhs hug together and call ourself Sikhs of the GURU, rather than
Taksali Singh, AKJ Singh, Nirmalla Singh, Nanaksaria Singh - how about everyone unites under the banner of the Nishan Sahib and Akal Thakhat and call ourself SIKHS OF GURU PANTH and GURU Granth Sahib jeo.
Again, I don' think WE should label ourself, and think that calling other Sikhs with titles is wrong. This will most likely utimately lead to AKJ marrying AKJ, Taksalis Marrying Taksalis etc.
Semi caste system?
bhull chukk di Khima bakhsni
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
LionKing (LK) · 16 Dec 2005
There's a difference between Vancouver Sikh Youth, and Toronto Sikh Youth, where they are clearly to identify them. Torotono Valey or Vancouver valey says nothing, doesn't say what they believe in, or how they are different, they are simply the same as others.
You cannot compare a certain jathebandi or samparda with an area, as that's a messed up comparison.
*********
for the Akhand Keertani Jatha, it is not a sect, it simply a jatha, a group of Sikhs who follow guru jis rehit and do keertan together.
*********
Okay, that's just fair enough then. This would imply that anyone can join it, and anyone can do Kirtan, whether taken Amrit from Akal Thakhat or somewhere else. Follow the Rehit decided by the Panth and accepted by Akal Thakhat would imply that they can do kirtan with the jatha?
Does this mean that the jatha doesn't have any political opinion(i.e. Khalistan or not)
Does this mean that the Jatha has not "official" decisions?
As soon as you say - Akhand Kirtani Jatha, you see a picture of Singhs who are very different from i.e Singhs who ahve taken Amrit From Akal Thakhat. Or am I mistaken here?
To me what coems up is -
* Do not believe in Raagmala
* Fight for Khalistan (Which I personally think is a good thing)
So saying it's simply a Jatha of Kiranis is wrong, cause it's not, cause if it was just a bunch of people doing Kirtan, then ANY AMritdhari following the Panth Khalsa Rehit would be allowed to join, and they wouldn't have any "official" decisions on some matters, as it's just a group of Kirtanis, and these Kirtanis would then have their own opinions...
******
There is a huge difference between a group and a sect. There have always been different groups of different Sikhs, under the umbrella of the Khalsa panth.
******
Guru Ji made the Khalsa Panth.
Or did he make Udhaisis, Nirmaley, Seva Panthis etc like the UK Nang's say?
*****
Even now, if we talk about youths, we will talk about the Vancouver Sikh youth, or the Toronto Sikh Youth, are they now seperate sects? I dont think so.
*****
There's a difference
Whereas Toronto Sikh Youth and Vancouver sikh youth don't have any "official" decision on anything, AKJ DOES. which makes it into a Jathebandi or Samparda and NOT just a Kirtan jatha, like you try to prove it.
If AKJ is simply a group of Singh doing Kirtan, it cannot have any official stand.
Classifying yourself as a Jatha Singh, or Taksali Singh isn't going to lead a step closer to Panthic ekta.
Please think about it from inside, do not try to protect whichever Jathebandi you call yourself to belong to. What does your heart say?, Does your heart say you're a jathe Singh, or simply a Sikh of the Guru without further classifications...?
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
Bhopinder Singh · 16 Dec 2005
LionKing (LK)
you are also using LionKing why?
you could have joined fox or rat or any other sepecies of animal kingdom why lions
They rule. no no no
that is cultish.
By the way you should have joined kaa crow black
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
manjh payara guru ko · 17 Dec 2005
well said bhai bhopinder singh ji
[%sig%]
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
LionKing (LK) · 18 Dec 2005
"Label", I've already responed your first three paragraphs, that it doens't matter what other label you - you as a SIKH should call yourself a SIKH of the GURU. Not an AKJ or Taksali Singh. If we want ekta it's not goign to help by US LABELING OURSELF.
As for candian Singh - that too I've answered- as that has no meaning whatsoever. IF I say he's a Canadian Sikh, it doens't make you ANY DIFFERENT from a BRitish Sikh, but if you cally yourselg an AKJ Sikh/Singh, you are different from someone calling himself a TAKSALI SINGH/Sikh - are we meant to look at each tohers differences and accordingly label ourself?
Akhand Kirtani Jatha enjoysto not call itself separate from Akal Thakhat, yet it does not follow the Maryada prescribed by the Colelcted Panthic decisions made by all Panthic scholars from all Jathebandis and Sampardava.
Although Babbar Khalsa did get it's name rom Babbar Akalis, Babbar Khalsa did not fashion itself after Babbar Akalis, as can bee seen in their different methods of doing panthic seva.
If Akj doesn't believe in deviating away from Gurmat, why is not not follow Guru Sahib's Hukami Raag when singing Shabads?
In Guru Sahib Ji's 1430 angs, more than 1300 of these are written in Raag, with a raag prescribed to each shabad withing those angs, so why isn't AKJ following Guru Sahib's Hukami Raag when doign Shabads, it is' so puritanical..? [also puritanical isn't a very good thing, as Guru Ji was innovative, unfortuantly we arn't =( ]
Again I've got nothing Against AKJ, or Taksal, or any Jathebandi, however I think in order to get a Khalistan we will need ekta. In order to get ekta we have to throw out these labels an simply call OURSELVES Sikhs of the Guru. Do you think Bhai Fauja Singh Ji and Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji, called themselves AKJ or Taksali Singhs?
"Mai JEEE Akhand Kirtani haiga!!!"
"Acha? Mai ta Taksali Haiga!!"
Have you EVER head ANY Singhs, especially from 84 labeling themselves?
I'm sure Bhai Fauja Singh ji and Bhai Jarnail Singh ji disagreed in several things (like keski, Raagmala whatever), however they chose to keep these disagree-ing things inside themselves, and just hug each toher and accept each other as brothers, goind beyond labels and sampardas and jathebandiya.
My point is simply - lets unite under the Kesri Nishan Sahib - and not let our disagrreances be a hinderance, and allow them to stay inside, but still at the same time look beyond this disagree-ances and jathebandis and look at we ARE the children of the one Guru, why can't we sit and talk to each other under one roof without unsheathing our Kirpans and wounding each other? Simply beacuse we cannot accept that others don't agree with us -
Sadi Haumai nu Thes paunchdi hai.
Our EGO doesn't allow us to go beyodn labels and hug others who disagree with us, and go beyodn ajthebandis and call ourselfs SIKHS OF THE GURU
Bhull chukk maaf
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
LionKing (LK) · 18 Dec 2005
I don’t understand is how can you question AKJ's loyalty to the AKal Takht? Jatha Singhs have given so many Shaheedis for the Panth and Guru Granth Sahib Jee, what better way to show loyalty then that? if you can tell me of a better way to show loyalty then Shaheedi then by all means please tell me. Even today if you go to India you will notice Jatha Singhs at the forefront when countering Bipran Ki Reet preached by RSS and Sant Samaj. Furthermore, Jatha Singhs are amongst the very few Sikhs in India carrying out Amrit Sanchaars to the poor Vanjara and sikligar community.
As for your claim that Jatha is deviating from the Akal Takht, what about modern SGPC, Sant Samaj and others who have disowned their OWN Guru and replaced it by the man made Padched Saroops? Are the majority not going against the AKal Takht in that respect? Yet you only see one thing, “oh akj does not do Raag Kirtan”, other than that you have no other Bahaana to use against the AKJ. The Rehet AKJ Singhs follow in no way contradicts what is taught by Guru Granth Sahib or Sikh history.
**************
Kind of remidns me of jatts saying - We're the backboen of the Panth. It is Guru Sahib's Rehmat and Kirpa that made those Singhs give Shaheedi, it is NOT the fact that they were AKJ that made them Shaheed.
The thing that allowed them to give Shaheedi wasn't that they were AKJ, and I dout they would NOT give Shaheedi if they weren't AKJ-ers. It's all Guru Sahib's Kirpa. Guru Sahib ji ne aap kirpa karke ohna nu Shaheedi Bakshi.
*******
Yet you only see one thing, “oh akj does not do Raag Kirtan”, other than that you have no other Bahaana to use against the AKJ.
*******
ONLY one thing? tusi te ehda gal karey o Jida Raag Kirtan Choti Gal hai. Raag Kirtan is FUNDAMENTAL. It's a MAJOR THING. Going Guru Sahib's Hukam with EVERY SHABAD being recited.
What is good about AKJ is Good. I agree with some things AKJ does, and disagree with others.
There are other thing that go against Akal Thakhat Maryada, and I will not have time to listen them all but here's a few -
Again I will be generalising the term AKJ, considering the things on akj.org, akj.org.uk, akji.org, akjinternational.com, keertan.net, ikirrtan etc.
*********
Article VI
(a) Only a Sikh may perform kitran in a congregation.
(b) Kirtan means singing and scriptural compositions in traditional musical measures.
**********
Has been mentioned earlier.
************
(c) In the congregation, kirtan only of Gurbani (Guru Granth's or Guru Gobind Singh's hymns) and, for its elaboration, of the compositions of Bhai Gurdas and Bhai Nand Lal, may be performed.
************
As for as I've heard, AKj-ers do Sing - Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji, on special occasions, and does Sing the names of Panj, names of Char Sahibzadey (last time I heard that was in my local Gurdwara today) etc
Although, I do agree that MOSTLY AKj-ers DO Sing only Gurbani. MOSTLY.
****
(d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be a refrain.
****
This AKJ does follow
On the other hand I do ackowledge and have mad respect that AKJ stresses Laridhar, and that AKJ stresses BaNa, and rehit. Again This was not to be a discussion of what AKJ is, or how panthic it is.
I do disagree with you on the Babbar issue, however I would like to go back to the topic of labeling ourselfs as ONLY SIKHS or as AKJ, Taksali etc Sikhs.
Let's get back to the original isuse. I do agree with some things AKJ does and disagree with others. Let's leave it there for this thread. If you want to discuss how panthic AKJ is, we can do that in another thread.
Bhull chukk maaf karni
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: AKJ Tapoban & Other
ManjitSingh · 18 Dec 2005
LionKing (LK) Jeo,
From your posts I would like to discuss 3 things.
1. You have pointed out that we should follow Akal Takhat Maryada, only then we can call ourselves as a member of Panth Khalsa.
Are you pointing to the Rahit Maryada adopted and printed by SGPC?
If you yes, do you know how many times it was changed and why it was changed? Let us just discuss three things (which are major problems) that were changed for the reasons well known to everyone.
Keski - This has been stated in other posts before that Keski used to be a Kakkar in the Amrit Sanchaars that used to be held at Akal Takhat and was stopped by the Jathedaar Gurmukh Singh. I hope no Sarbat Khalsa was called to take this big decision about changing this Rahit.
RaagMala - It was decided (in the form of Matta) by SGPC that everything after Mundavni is not Bani but later on under some pressure this was chaged to keep raagmala in SGGS but everyone was free to read it or not.
Kuthha - It was cosidered as Bujjar Kurehit in the firs Rahit Maryada adopted by SGPC but later under some pressure it was changed to Kuthha by Halaal (Musalmani treeka).
A recent change that we all have seen - Raagmala was not read at all at Akal Takhat but when it came under Taksal control this was changed.
So when you refer to Akal Takhat maryada I am not sure which maryada you refer to. Do you think the so called Akal Takhat maryada, which is actually adopted and printed by SGPC, is Panthik maryada?
2. Definition of Khalsa Panth.
I hope everyone will agree with the following definition. Khalsa Panth is a collection of Amritdhari gurshikhs who follow the Gurmat Rehit Maryada.
The two major parts are Amritdhari which we all accept and Gurmat Rehit Maryada where the differences exist.
Every Amritdhari Sikh follows a certain Rahit Maryada. Which maryada should be followed to be a member of Khalsa Panth, Akal Takhat maryada, which has been chaged many times under pressure from certain people or jathebandis?
3. Keertan in Hukami Rag - I could not find any source where this maryada is stated that Keertan can be only in the Raag that comes along with that particular shabad. Usually Rahit Maryada can be found in SGGS and Rahitnamas written by Gurshikhs from time to time but none states that Keertan other than the said raag is forbidden. Even if someone knows raags and how can we make sure that this raag has the same form as it was at the time when that shabad was written?