Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What would you do?

What would you do?

Kulbir Singh · 14 Dec 2005

Here's the situation: You have Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee's parkash at your home. Your neighbours's 8 months old son is visiting your house. All of sudden your area gets flooded with water and the waves are up to 20 feet high. You can survive if you leave right away. You have only half a minute to think. The problem is that you can either save the child or the saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Please answer the following questions: 1) What would your instincts tell you to do? 2) What does your Bibek Budh or Gurmat Vichaar tell you to do? 3) Would your answer be any different if the child was your own? I have been asked this question by a friend. Need feedback from you all. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: What would you do?

Answer · 14 Dec 2005

Grab one child with one hand and hold guru ji's saroop on your head with one hand.

Re: What would you do?

G · 14 Dec 2005

Interesting question...my thoughts: 1) Instincts would say to save Guru ji, for the Guru is everything to a Sikh. 2) Although we venerate and give utmost satkaar to Guru ji's saroop, we only do so because of the Shabad within it. Keeping in mind that Guru ji told us not to attach ourselves to their 'deh' but rather the Shabad, I think Guru ji would have us save the child. Considering the importance of this manukhi janam and the fact that Guru sahib demonstrated they would sacrifice their body for the innocent, I think the child would take precedence. Further, being a Sikh your hands/feet/body/soul are not yours, but belong to Guru ji. Do you see Guru Sahib using their hands to save themselves at the expense of a child? I do not thing this is possible. 3) No...instincts might change to protecting your child since we're enveloped in moh, but it doesn't make the analysis any different. I think Guru ji would prefer us to save the child. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karni, WJKK WJKF!

Re: What would you do?

Singh · 14 Dec 2005

save the child, Guru Ji has shakti to protect itself.

Re: What would you do?

H · 14 Dec 2005

save the kid and go back to save guru maharaj ji. die trying

Re: What would you do?

stranger · 14 Dec 2005

Logical - save the child The shabad is way bigger then the physical material it has been written on - simple. If anyone says other wise they need to see a shrink!

Re: What would you do?

Harpreet Singh · 14 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Just my 10 cents "Who can save the one who saves everyone?" Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: What would you do?

MOW · 14 Dec 2005

i would like to hope i would save guru jis saroop and give the kid a quick swimming lesson

Re: What would you do?

Vastoo · 14 Dec 2005

I would do Ardas to Guru Ji to save me and the child.

Re: What would you do?

. · 14 Dec 2005

wasnt this similar to the situation bhai bidhi chand (?) was in?

Re: What would you do?

simmi · 14 Dec 2005

i will try to save the child first as i feel guruji would want me to do that

Re: What would you do?

unknown · 14 Dec 2005

1) I think my instinct would lead me to save the child. I don't think I could handle seeing or knowing that child is going to drown and I could have saved it. 2) I think that we tend to focus a lot on the physical aspect of Guru Sahib now and when they were in human form. If the actual physical form of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was of very high value, then we would not have 1000's of copies of it. We should worship the shabad and not the paper and the shabad lives forever. So saving Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji would be saving the physicalness of it, because gurbani cannot be destroyed. However, our love for Guru Sahib does not allow us to even see a piece of paper that Gurbani is written on to be destroyed. It is very difficult to see bedbi, or destruction of Sri Guru Granth Sahib, even if it is of its physical form. So even if I saved the child, I would feel terrible for not being abe to save Guru Sahib. 3) If the child was my own, I would act the same way. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: What would you do?

singh · 14 Dec 2005

The answer is so obvious that if anyone chose to save the SGGS they would be complete fools, idiots, and idolaters. Save the children

Re: What would you do?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 15 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh To bhai Shaib Jee, it kind of depends on the individual, for instance their capability from their intelligence and speed, since, just say if that particular Sikh has abilities not known to man, such as supernatural powers like e.g. speed of mind and muscular power then that person has the chance to save both Guru Jee and the child. If a regular Sikh was to make a quick decision, then I think that person should save the child because the light that is inside that Guru is inside every other Guru Granth SAhib Jee on earth, so essentially Guru Jee is still alive and well, similarly there is only one of that particular child and none other, so the child should be obviously saved. What Bhai Sahib stranger said was fine. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh

Re: What would you do?

MS · 15 Dec 2005

Save the child, Nothing will happen to Maharajee's Saroop! - Guroo Sahib being like Vaaheguroo cannot be created nor destoryed, praising him does not increase his value as cursing him does not reduce him. Indestukhtable is Guroo Sahib, only moorakhs die the most pointless deaths trying!

Re: What would you do?

Karnail Singh Barshi · 15 Dec 2005

Apart from Vastoo, are you are foooooooooooooooools ?? My God where has Sikhi gone ? If those puratan Sikhs thought like you do, we would all be sat here reciting the kalma !!!! What if the Mata's of Mir Manus jail thought like you. Let us abandon our SikhI and save our children. Where would we be? If Bhai Mati Das Ji abandoned his Sikhi - well its not a phisical thing is it, it is only a set of ideas - where would we be. What if Bhai Taru Ji said "well its only some lifeless article on my head, so what if they cut it?" Where would we be? We should be willing to die for our Guru Granth Sahib Ji, but instead we abandon Guru Ji. Vastoo Ji, for me you gave the TRUE answer. ASK GURU JI TO SAVE YOU AND THE CHILD !!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: What would you do?

Preetam Kaur · 15 Dec 2005

I agree with "H", I love what H wrote and Mow's post made me laugh out loud vaheguru.... i honestly believe that shabad guru and guru granth sahib ji is protected by shaheeds, I would ask them to appear! my instincts would be to save the child - because vaheguru is also in that child and we have to imagine what the scene would be - imagine the cries of the child begging "HELP ME HELP ME PLEASE HELP ME" Like i said, i agree with "H", I would like to think that save the child and return to attempt to take maharaj saroop out...and maybe die trying, coz i definitely cant swim

Re: What would you do?

Preetam Kaur · 15 Dec 2005

I'm still pondering over it though...such a difficult question, it'll be a huge test from maharaj, i think in reality i would do a very emotional ardas to maharaj then take both maharaj saroop and the kid. like bhar kulbir singh ji said we could only take one, that means me and the kid would end up dying..but oh well atleast we were both with guru granth sahib ji til our last breaths, i'm sure the kid would appreciate it once we end up before dharam rai, ...but then what about maharaj saroop, that would be so disrespectful and stupid of me, i honestly do not know, kulbir singh can you share your thoughts please

Re: What would you do?

Kaur · 15 Dec 2005

I would protect Guru Sahib's Saroop I have been protected from harm time and again in my life by Guru Sahib in ways that even I find hard to believe or comprehend, in impossible no way out situations. So I have 100% faith that He would save the child (as mine or another's), at this point in my life I have no doubt whatsoever. [%sig%]

Re: What would you do?

Dogma · 15 Dec 2005

Didn't anyone see the pictures from Hurricane Katrina and the Gurudwara in New Orleans? I think we all saw how Guru Granth Sahib remained untouched by the flood waters...

Re: What would you do?

Sword · 15 Dec 2005

"i honestly believe that shabad guru and guru granth sahib ji is protected by shaheeds, I would ask them to appear!" Shaheed singh would apppear if god wanted them to appear, your job is to pray to god and non other. no wonder chardi kala gursikhs never talked much about their encounters with the shaheed singhs cuz moorakhs would start calling for shaheed singhs rather than akal purakh. cuz im also a moorakh i would take sri guru grant sahib upon my head and grab the child by the other hand and recite naam to help me save us all.

Re: What would you do?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 15 Dec 2005

this is just from my moorakh mind and you know when the 'going gets tough' then kachay-pillay sikhs like me just freeze but this is what i would say: start to do jaap of "rakhiya day shabad" and "chaupai sahib" and get guru maharaaj's suroop. guru maharaaj jee will save the child. but then my logical brain says this: start to do jaap of "rakhiya day shabad" and "chaupai sahib" and get guru maharaaj's suroop. first pick up the child and run with him upstairs where guru maharaaj's suroop is. then take guru sahib ji's suroop on your head and some how get onto the roof with the child and guru sahib ji's suroop. Dogma is wrong. Only one suroop was above the water in New Orleans Gurdwara. Some brand-new larivaar suroops and pad-chhed suroops were completely covered in mud and they had to do agan-bhet seva. You did not see this because they only focused on the "one miracle" and not the 10 mistakes they made. Anyway, Guru Sahib jee can save their own suroop and you and the child, but this is all about hukam. Guru sahib jee doesn't have an obligation to do anything at anytime, whether we want a miracle or not. Guru Sahib jee is not a magic wizard that saves themselves in floods. But if Guru Sahib jee wishes, they can save the whole universe from destruction. They are the fish and the net, the deer and the hunter. Guru Sahib jee is the king of the universe and we can never understand their game. Whatever happens, whether we think it is good or bad, beadbi or adab, it is in their hukam. We just can do what we think Guru Sahib would be happy with us for doing.

Re: What would you do?

singhz lets unite · 15 Dec 2005

so ru saying u will commit a sin by letting the child be killed? u dont think that ur gonna have to pay the price in hell if u to that?? i mean wat respect and love really is it if ur commiting sins at the same time to? dont u people read Japji Sahib? on the 20th Pauri it says : "Bharia Hath Par Dhan Dhe, Pani Dhote Utras Su Khe" Dont u guys learn anything from that?

Re: What would you do?

Dogma · 15 Dec 2005

" Dogma is wrong. Only one suroop was above the water in New Orleans Gurdwara. Some brand-new larivaar suroops and pad-chhed suroops were completely covered in mud and they had to do agan-bhet seva. You did not see this because they only focused on the "one miracle" and not the 10 mistakes they made." wow...didn't realize that. Were all these Saroops in the same Gurudwara, or in other Gurudwaray?

Re: What would you do?

Dogma · 15 Dec 2005

after alot of thinking...here's what I think: I grab the child...and we both stand next to Guru Sahib. If myself or the child are meant to be saved then Guru Sahib Himself will save me. If we are meant to die, then at least I died doing Guru Sahib's darshan and in His Sangat. That's my final answer..... wahegurujeekakhalsa wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: What would you do?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 15 Dec 2005

singhz lets unite jee Whatever happens, whether we think it is good or bad, beadbi or adab, it is in their hukam. We just can do what we think Guru Sahib would be happy with us for doing. also from jap ji sahib : nanak hukmai jae bujhai tha haumai kahai no koae

Re: What would you do?

Dust · 15 Dec 2005

Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh No pre-plannned theories work in these type of situations.These are just presumption that i should that and i will do that. i believe He is always with you and shall quide you what to do at the movement. Sarbhang Bhugta Sarbhang Jugta------Jap Sahib Whenever we encounter with any sort of problem that may sometimes longterm and sometimes which needs immediate redressal we move inward to seek his guidence. And Jugta(resolve) there. If happens like this, then Guru ji as His birad (nature) is, will guide you to first save the child(crying) first. Guru ji is not attached with any body (Five elemental or of blissful paper). The martydom of Shri Guru Arjan Dev ji Maharaj and Shri Guru Teg Bahadur ji Maharaj are the exaples. But it is really really difficult to leave behind the parkash of Guru Granth Sahib ji. I pray to Guru ji this never happens, where we may get fail. Bhul Chuk Maf Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: What would you do?

gurvah · 16 Dec 2005

===================== Author: Dogma Date: 12-15-05 20:10 " Dogma is wrong. Only one suroop was above the water in New Orleans Gurdwara. Some brand-new larivaar suroops and pad-chhed suroops were completely covered in mud and they had to do agan-bhet seva. You did not see this because they only focused on the "one miracle" and not the 10 mistakes they made." wow...didn't realize that. Were all these Saroops in the same Gurudwara, or in other Gurudwaray? ===================== Please refer to [URL=http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/1788/2005-09-18.html]this[/URL] article by Panthic Weekly covering this issue, as well as [URL=http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/1825/2005-09-25.html]pictures[/URL] [%sig%]

Re: What would you do?

LionKing · 16 Dec 2005

Author: Dogma Date: 12-15-05 20:10 " Dogma is wrong. Only one suroop was above the water in New Orleans Gurdwara. Some brand-new larivaar suroops and pad-chhed suroops were completely covered in mud and they had to do agan-bhet seva. You did not see this because they only focused on the "one miracle" and not the 10 mistakes they made." wow...didn't realize that. Were all these Saroops in the same Gurudwara, or in other Gurudwaray? ************* Singho, please read this link - http://panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/1825/2005-09-25.html Would you want your Guru Sahib Saroop be in that condition. This is a real dilemma, and I think I agree with some above posters, that will try saving both, or die tryign to...

Re: What would you do?

Dogma · 16 Dec 2005

thank you to gurvah and to Lionking for the links... I never even HEARD that other saroops were left behind let alone damaged by the flood waters..

Re: What would you do?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 16 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh To Kulbir Singh Jee, The question that's been asked by Kulbir Singh Jee is completely ridiculous, as I've been asked so many questions similar to this one when was young by kids, yes kids, it's a frame of a child's innocence but really a way of finding the weakness of a person. Also, if you really have been asked this question by a person, Kulbir Singh Jee, then I propose to you to tell that person to grow up and get over your own guilt of weakness. I personally think that both the child and Guru Jee can be saved by anyone, it can be done simply and quick. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: What would you do?

Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2005

The following thoughts came to my mind when looking for answer to these questions. These thoughts were just random thoughts and not in any order: 1) It is not about saving Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee but about avoiding be-adbee of Guru Sahib. The dirty flood water would do be-adbee of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. 2) The child has come to my house and is therefore in my care. What will I tell his parents if I don’t save the child. 3) If the child is mine and I save it instead of avoiding be-adbee of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, I will feel guilty all life. It is easier to save someone else’s child instead of saving your child as there will be much less guilty feeling. 4) This point may be controversial but a thought came to my mind that Guru Sahib’s saroops are many but this child is just one of kind and if this child gets perished here, it cannot be found again but saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee can be found again. 5) Then I really stretched the limits by thinking that if instead of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, there had been a dehdhaari Guru (Guru with human form), I would have tried to go for Guru Sahib instead of the child. There were many other thoughts but in the end I just pleaded to Vaheguru to spare me from such situation. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: What would you do?

Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2005

Shaktishali Sha Soora jeeo, --------- The question that's been asked by Kulbir Singh Jee is completely ridiculous, as I've been asked so many questions similar to this one when was young by kids, yes kids, it's a frame of a child's innocence but really a way of finding the weakness of a person. ------------ Whether the question is ridiculous or not is not the issue. The issue is that a friend of mine asked me this question and I thought of putting these question on the forum. This Gursikh friend is a very intelligent and serene person. I don’t think it was fair to tell him that his questions were ridiculous. I tried to answer them to the best of my ability and then posted the questions for sangat and his benefit. He himself saw the responses and was satisfied with the posts. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: What would you do?

Bhopinder Singh · 17 Dec 2005

Kulbir Singh I think you are right reasonably. My first thought was child to.

Re: What would you do?

Bhopinder Singh · 17 Dec 2005

Shaktishali Sha Soora ji Brother I think we should believe each other.It could be he was asked this question for he is saying it.

Re: What would you do?

singhz lets unite · 17 Dec 2005

"Whatever happens, whether we think it is good or bad, beadbi or adab, it is in their hukam. We just can do what we think Guru Sahib would be happy with us for doing. also from jap ji sahib : nanak hukmai jae bujhai tha haumai kahai no koae" uh...sorry to say this but define that line that comes in Japji Sahib.....very shameful that i dont understand it :( THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR HELP:P

Re: What would you do?

uk singh · 18 Dec 2005

1) What would your instincts tell you to do? Save the child and wrap Guru Ji in a plastic bag weighted down. 2) What does your Bibek Budh or Gurmat Vichaar tell you to do? Save Guru Sahib. 3) Would your answer be any different if the child was your own? Nope. These questions got me thinking. If someonce bursts into a Guru Ghar and start shooting randomly, how many of us will stand in front of Guru Sahib to protect him? Everything depends on sharda. Someone who believes Guru Sahib to be hazar nazar will not think about multiple copies of Guru Ji in the world. They will certainly jump to Guru Ji's rescue without any hesitation. Evidently most of us are weak and do not consider saving the true King but a child due to wordly attachments.

Re: What would you do?

LionKing (LK) · 18 Dec 2005

I agre with Kulbir SIngh, it's not about "saving" but actually of avoiding the beadbi of Guru Sahib's SAroop to occur tha makes you not leave saroop.

Re: What would you do?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 18 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsavahegurooJeKeFateh If it was to save Guru Jee from a bullet, I would save Guru Jee no matter what, I'm already angry about what had happened in 1984 when Guru Granth Sahib Jee was shot. Furthermore, there is no excuse for Guru Granth Sahib JEe not to be saved from a flood because a materialistic form covers both Guru Jee's light and the child's soul, so there's no doubt about it Guru Granth Sahib JEe should be saved. But if I had supernatural powers both Guru Jee and the child would be saved. Courage, faith and wisdom comes all from doing Naam Bhagti. VahegurooJeKaKhalsavahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: What would you do?

uk singh · 18 Dec 2005

Dear LK, Not taking Guru Ji would be beadbi.

Re: What would you do?

d · 18 Dec 2005

bani hai guru, guru hai bani gods words do not die they are everlasting, however i think out of respect for the sri guru granth sahib saroop i would save the the guru granth sahib. all emotional feelings in this world are false, same with relationships- the one that matters in the end is with god. but to save guru granth sahib and understand that you will have to live without your child takes a highly spiritual mind; i dont think most people could do it.

Re: What would you do?

d · 18 Dec 2005

what you would do in the situation is already preordained by god is it not?

Re: What would you do?

singhni wannabe · 19 Dec 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheyguru ji ke fateh!! I agree with "kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa" what ever happens will happen but if i could i would save both!! vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheyguru ji ke fateh!!

Re: What would you do?

2 sense · 21 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh Don't be put in such a situation. Make the choice ahead of time. If you couldn't be responsible for the child (or for Guru Sahib) under any and all cirumstances then decline the responsibility. If you can't put the child first then DON"T BE A BABY SITTER! If you feel you would let a child die rather than see Guru ji be spoiled then inform the parents you cannot take responsibility for their child as it would come second if you have to make a choice. If they choose to leave their child with you, It then become their responsibility not yours...

Re: What would you do?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 21 Dec 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh Bhai Sahib '2 sense' Jee, excellect point, by saving one your being selfish to the other, because the child is under your care and responsibillity, don't baby sit if you can't be responsible for the child. Lets end this boring topic, lol and instead read the posts sent by me, lol. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKEFateh

Re: What would you do?

khalistani · 21 Dec 2005

i think this is a really hard question to answer but we gotta remeber one thing guru je is no little kid they dont need us to save them its not the acxtual physical saroop we worship its the joth inside, the spirtual powetr asnd light inside the gurbanee itself that can never be destroyed as bhai kulbir singh said, its a case of beadbi we respect the physical saroop also because of the gurbanee itself we dont wanna let it get any mud on it, etc. but a kids likfe is no little thing god also abides in everyone and everything i think the kid should be saved the kid will truly die, guru je does not die, and is not born there are 2 thingw here if we save guru je, a life is lost, the kid is gone, tha joon will never come again for it but guru je nevr dies they are eternal the only bad thing tha can happen is beadbi will happen due to water etc. first of all try to save em BOTH but if u cant, then i think save the kid its jus by looking at 2 choices, gurbanee can neevr die but tha kid will bhula chuka maf

Re: What would you do?

Jasmin · 21 Dec 2005

If I had to choose, I would also choose the child.

Re: What would you do?

amarjeet singh · 21 Dec 2005

nah 4get the kid, im sure he'll be able to get out himself. kids nowadays are propa clever. id save guru granth sahib ji.

Re: What would you do?

uk singh · 22 Dec 2005

khalistani ji - would your answer be different if Guru Sahib was in human form?

Re: What would you do?

singh · 22 Dec 2005

1) What would your instincts tell you to do? 2) What does your Bibek Budh or Gurmat Vichaar tell you to do? 3) Would your answer be any different if the child was your own? 1- instinct would say save child, obviously because im a paapi, and a manmukh, my mind will say save child, leave guru ji 2- gurmat would say save guru ji, life and death mean nothing, death is inevitable, however to allow beadbi of guru ji is MAHAPAAP 3-answer should be the same if the child was youre own, but how many ppl would actually leave their child? only the gurmukhs

Re: What would you do?

sikh · 11 Jan 2006

i would try to pick up both guru ji and the child, but if i cant handle it i would hurry and get the child out and go bak in to get guru ji.HE is MUCH MUCH MUCH more imporant than my life............

Re: What would you do?

singh · 11 Jan 2006

khalistani - i have a question for you -if instead of guru sahibs saroop it was an old "sant" belonging to the dera that you follow - who was too frail to walk on his own - you believed him to be a "brahmgyani" - would you rescue this sant or the child?

Re: What would you do?

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 12 Jan 2006

All Pre thought calculations fail, depends how Guru Sahib will direct from somewhere, to act with the situation.

Re: What would you do?

ok · 12 Jan 2006

I found this one the best. >>>>>>>>>>>> Author: H Date: 12-14-05 08:34 save the kid and go back to save guru maharaj ji. die trying >>>>>>>>>>>>

Re: What would you do?

*** · 13 Jan 2006

lol this topic is funny if the water is 20 ft high wat are the chances of either geting saved how will u swim with guru ji on our heads?? personally i dnt wna think of such a situation and wud do ardas to be saved but i'm a mooruk so doubt i wud be saved