Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Sikh Peace Team in Israel

news · 14 Dec 2005

I dont' much agree with "his holiness" nor do I think he can even in his wildest dreams usurp Guru Arjan Dev jee or Guru Ram Das jee's title as keeper of Amritsar or Darbar Sahib. Indian Sikh delegation for peace arrives in Israel By JPOST.COM STAFF Leaders of the Sikh faith have arrived in Israel with the goal of helping to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. At the head of the delegation of 14 is His Holiness Bahaisahibaji Monindar Sing, who holds the title of "Keeper of the Golden Temple." The delegation will stay in Israel and the territories for ten days and will meet with Jewish, Christian, and Muslim leaders. Among those scheduled to meet the Sikh leaders are Eliyahu Bakshi Doron, formerly Chief Rabbi of Israel, Sheik Abdul Salaam of Nazareth, and leaders of Bethlehem's Muslim and Christian communities. http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1134309573055&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull Adherents of the Sikh faith in India number in the tens of millions.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Be practical · 16 Dec 2005

what has the israeli /palestine issue got to do with the sikhs???! How many countries came running to sort out the Sikh affairs when we were in trouble? This is as mad as the sikh canadian guy who is a hostage in iraq!

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

khalistani · 16 Dec 2005

lol a story i got for u is bhai keneya jes :) bhula chuka maf

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

DS · 17 Dec 2005

How about these Sikhs help get justice for the Sikhs murdered in India, try to get Sikhs released from jail, end discrimination against Punjab by India oh how about Kashmir, Assam, Nagaland?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

gabroo · 17 Dec 2005

Shusshhhh, please. stop 'stopping' a seva by saying 'wat about this seva' so on.... its sooo childish!!!! it IS the duty of Sikhs to help ALL. although the titles they give themselves are HIGHLY questionable.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

LionKing (LK) · 17 Dec 2005

Agree with DS I agree that this is a good step, however, how about get out of the shackles of slavery first, before tryiing to save others..?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

H · 17 Dec 2005

typical punjabi attitude. can never back up a sikh brother/sister when they are doing something good, we jus have to pull em down. wasters!!!

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Dec 2005

barking up the wrong tree is what i think.... Anyway who gave this man the title of "Keepr of the Golden Temple" ( he is using the WRONG WORDS to describe Harmandar Sahib ...what people wont do for some cheap publicity. Diditn this man's chief promote his own MARYADA to challenge the Akal Takhat one ??

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Singh · 17 Dec 2005

Perhaps Mohinder Singh should go to Iran and try to pacify that guy Mahmoud who wants to wipe Israel from the face of Earth and who wants Europeans to move Israel to Europe.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Ehmi.. · 17 Dec 2005

'although the titles they give themselves are HIGHLY questionable.' Stop and think for a moment, has this person given themselves this title or has someone else written it? It’s easy too easy to start blaming people but before doing this make sure you are pointing the blame at the right person. It’s a news article, here’s me thinking the writer is responsible for what’s written and not the person it’s written about! At the end of the day why do some of you people not like positive things to happen? A Sikh group has gone on a peace trip and all you want to do is complain about else is not being done, why? At least Sikhs as a whole will be noticed from this and this will help us all. Gosh some people only seem to be able to cry about anything and everything, look at the bigger picture and try to look at the positives in a situation instead of crying on and on about what YOU don’t agree with, if you don’t like it YOU go out there and do something about it! Ehmi.. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

DS · 17 Dec 2005

It is just ironic that where the Indian forces doing the killing of Sikhs,(Punjab and most of india) Muslims Kashmir, UP,Gujrat), Hindus (Dalits in all India) and Christians (Nagaland , Assam and other areas) all these Sikh organisations, babas and Sants stay strangely silent. Where is helping your own and others gone then?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Ehmi.. · 17 Dec 2005

Author: DS Date: 12-17-05 12:01 It is just ironic that where the Indian forces doing the killing of Sikhs,(Punjab and most of india) Muslims Kashmir, UP,Gujrat), Hindus (Dalits in all India) and Christians (Nagaland , Assam and other areas) all these Sikh organisations, babas and Sants stay strangely silent. Where is helping your own and others gone then? .... What do you expect these 'babas and Sants' to do exactly? I'm not saying that they do not need to do anything, but think of it this way - this team has gone there in peace and thus Sikhs should get some recognition. When these Sikhs then raise issues (like the situation in Punjab) they might get listened to as they have done something that has put them on the map. I have read a lot of things against Bhai Mohinder Singh on this forum, but how many other people have managed to get Sikhs to major events around the world? Isn’t the fact that Sikhs are getting somewhere on a international level good or is it a case of sour grapes because the person doing the representing isn’t someone you would like to see there? Whatever the problem is of the people doing all the hating how about not saying anything if you don’t have anything positive to say, and you go out there and do enough parchar to get yourself and Sikhs recognised by the world. Everyone and everyone can talk the talk (especially on internet forums), but its how and when which is important.. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

DS · 17 Dec 2005

'Isn’t the fact that Sikhs are getting somewhere on a international level good or is it a case of sour grapes because the person doing the representing isn’t someone you would like to see there?' I have no issue with this man, but i do have an issue about keeping silent about human rights attrocities against Sikhs. Will Mohinder Singh get information about holocaust museums, how the jews never forget their victims and speak loud and clearly about Nazi attrocities around the world. Will he apply then speak about getting help from the Israelis to punish Indian Nazis?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Problem solver · 18 Dec 2005

It is a good step. But shouldn't they first attempt to do something for Kashmir before looking at far off lands?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Anjaan · 19 Dec 2005

Dear All Sorry to be rude. But wouldnt it be good if all you slanderers get off you "tight arses" and do something also. This is a start for everyone and all of us sikhs......just wait a little longer and all your complaining will be dealt with..... Remember the following words..... "Nanak Naam Chardi Kalaa, Terey Bhanay Sarbat Da Bhala" "Hum Nuhi Changa, Bura Nuhi Koy"

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Anjaan · 19 Dec 2005

Oh..and one more thing.... Gyani Ji....(Jarnail Singh)....you should be giving us "Gian" and not slandering people who are actually doing something..... I would like to see you "Gyani Ji" do something also.....and on another subject.....how did you get your name of Gyani Ji.....its easy to slander other people isnt it? Admin....may I please request that you close this thread.....as you are not going to get any Sikh Parchaar from this.....Thank You

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Dec 2005

no body has any issue with the man.... it is just that "charity" begins at home... solve or at least try and bring them out..all the SIKH PROBLEMS in PUNJAB..then go solve others problems......anybody ever heard a peep out of mahinder singh and his nishkam sevak jatha about the sikh prisoners in Indian jails ?? the 1984 victims..the children of the riots...martyrs...

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

KS · 19 Dec 2005

It is sad that when Sikhs use their right to question strange activities, or why people stay silent on issues that effect Sikhs that a hush up campaign starts. This is not slander but a question thousands want to know, why is their silence on justice for Sikhs?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

oye hoye · 19 Dec 2005

Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Date: 12-19-05 05:24 no body has any issue with the man.... it is just that "charity" begins at home... solve or at least try and bring them out..all the SIKH PROBLEMS in PUNJAB..then go solve others problems......anybody ever heard a peep out of mahinder singh and his nishkam sevak jatha about the sikh prisoners in Indian jails ?? the 1984 victims..the children of the riots...martyrs... ..... I attended a Gurmat Camp in Birmingham (3 years ago) held for children (aged between 8-16) as a sewadar and one of the talks was on 1984, and the literature given out that day had been put together and printed by GNNSJ. So there you go, there has been more than a ‘peep’ from them, actually there is actual material available from them. Just because you don’t know something or you may have not come across it does not mean it does not exist. Also just so you know, GNNSJ is not Bhai Mohinder Singh Ji’s own Jatha as you have stated in your post. Guru Nanak Nishkam Sewak Jatha was established by Baba Puran Singh Ji (Kericho Vale) and the name GNNSJ came about for the Jatha after Baba Puran Singh Ji had a discussion with Gyani Amolak Singh Ji and they decided on this name. Its good to know what you’re on about before making sweeping statements - isn't it Gyani Ji.. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

jugroop singh · 19 Dec 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, one other excellent Seva that GNNSJ could do is publicise the holocausts against Sikhs in the same way that Jews have. from what i understand, they have the resources and contacts to do so. this would be worthwhile project and Siree Guru Sahib Ji would surely do Kirpa upon those who made this happen. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

charna de thoor · 19 Dec 2005

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" wrote: > no body has any issue with the man.... it is just that > "charity" begins at home... solve or at least try and bring > them out..all the SIKH PROBLEMS in PUNJAB..then go solve others > problems......anybody ever heard a peep out of mahinder singh > and his nishkam sevak jatha about the sikh prisoners in Indian > jails ?? the 1984 victims..the children of the > riots...martyrs... this seems 2 me that it is personal to bhai mohinder singh ji and to the jatha what is it you have againt them? is it jelousy or just basic hatered?how about asking them face to face in stead of this slander?whats wrong with you western people. how about sitting down and japing naam? and its not guroo its vaheguru! nindah chuglie erkha vakhiely? close your eyes and jap vaheguru vaheguru vaheguru vaheguru vaheguru! gur parmaser eko jaan pai prapat manukh dehuria gobind millan ke eho tare varia avar kaaj tarey kitha na kaam mill saath sangat bhaj keval naam? every body knows this shabad so why is it that were not doing it vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ke fathe bhull juk khema?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Dec 2005

veers Anjaan ( obviously), charana de dhoor (whose ?) reacted just like the sant baba chelas i know all too well..tsk tsk tsk. A "real Sant" is not bothered by all such "nindiya"....only the chelas cant stand it. BTW i was just expressing my GURU GIVEN RIGHT to express my opinions...not NINDIYA..no sir not by along shot.....and then the second typical reaction.."Admin..Please close the thread..please..blah blah blah.." if you want the thread closed why open it in the first place ?? think about that ?? To the poster who told me about the Diwan/literature etc on 1984 by this Jatha..GOOD. Thats what I want from all sikhs..lets settle our own problems first and then go outside...to Rome/Palestine wherever. Bhul Chuk Maaf the incorrigible..dass of real SANT..GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

KS · 20 Dec 2005

Here is an oppurtunity for the GNNSJ to show that they support Sikh human rights, will they get involved? WORLDWIDE DAY OF PROTEST 17 JANUARY 2006 SIKHS TO CALL FOR THE ABOLITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY AND THE RELEASE OF ALL POLITICAL PRISONERS IN INDIA A Worldwide Day of Protest is being organised for 17 January 2006. Sikhs in cities around the world from London, to Paris, to Toronto and to New York are aiming on 17 January to show their opposition to the death penalty and call for the release of all Sikh political prisoners held in jails in India. Candles will be lit in prominent places in cities throughout the world, including in India itself. Sikhs in more than 100 cities are expected to take part in the protest and will be joined by prominent non-Sikhs, such as politicians, human rights and trade union activists. In the UK the candle light protests will be taking place simultaneously in around twenty towns and cities The protests are being supported by Amnesty International and other members of the World Coalition Against the Death Penalty. The protest in London will be taking place outside the Houses of Parliament in Westminster between 5-7pm. MPs, Lords and members of the public will join Sikhs to light candles celebrating life, freedom and opposition to the death penalty. The worldwide protests are taking place on 17 January to coincide with the 11th anniversary of one of the most controversial and highest profile death penalty cases in recent Indian history. 11 years earlier on 17 January 1995 Professor Davinderpal Singh Bhullar, a Sikh political activist, was illegally deported from Germany. Davinderpal Singh was handed over to the Indian authorities on the basis that he had nothing to fear on his return to India. For 11 years Davinderpal Singh has been forced to live with the mistake by the German authorities. He was arrested and put in prison as soon as he landed in Delhi, tortured to obtain a false confession, charged and sentenced to death by hanging for a crime he did not commit. When Germany deported Davinderpal Singh to a death-penalty prone country it violated the European Convention on Human Rights. After his deportation, the court of appeal in Frankfurt allowed his appeal and said that he should not have been deported as he would face torture, harassment and death in India and were he to re-enter Germany he would be given asylum. The verdict of the court of appeal in Germany came too late for Davinderpal Singh. However, it has left Germany and the EU with a moral obligation to ensure the threat of the death penalty by India is removed and Davinderpal Singh and other political prisoners that are unnecessarily being held, either without trial or under false charges and without evidence, are released immediately. Protests in different towns and cities are in the process of being organised. Our aim is to organise candle light vigils in at least 20 towns/cities. We are already aware of vigils being organised in prominent locations in Birmingham, Bradford, Bristol, Coventry, Derby, Gravesend, Huddersfield, Leeds, Leicester, Manchester, Nottingham, Slough, Southampton, Walsall and Wolverhampton. We are also hopeful that Sikhs in the UK will also organise candle light vigils in other locations such as Cardiff, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Liverpool and Newcastle. There is no reason why the candle light vigils should not extend further to other towns and cities, especially where there are Gurdwaras or Sikh students at University.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Anjaan · 20 Dec 2005

"if you want the thread closed why open it in the first place ?? think about that ??" Dude, you are the one who opened the thread....not me.... Anjaan I surely am.....it would be nice to get "Gian" from a person who calls himself Gyani......but I am surely not to get this from here, so I will not post any further....

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Singh · 20 Dec 2005

Soho road will never publicise 84, because they work with the GOI. They do not hide this. Soho road Gurdwara has never taken any coach to any 1984 March in June. The oppose the babbars and feds in birmingham. They even provided the langar for the huge event of the Ram katha done by RSS types in birmingham. They always hate the mention of a real sant like Sant Jarnial singh.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

H · 20 Dec 2005

wot are you guys on about. u havent the slightest clue about gnnsj, all working off wot u've heard from other people who are anti-gnnsj. bhai sahib ji never ever consider themselves the keeper of golden temple, neither the keeper of gnnsj, they say its the sangats. they dont even claim themselves as a mahapurakh, jus a humble servant of guru granth sahib ji. i bet none of you have ever had a 1 to 1 with them, nor been in their presence. its all chinese whispers with people like youselves. you say what have gnnsj done for sikhi. why don't you ask what we are doing for humanity at large and then you will see the benefit of bhai sahib ji attending events such as ram katha, globalisation for the common good in barcelona, and the peace team in israel. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Singh · 20 Dec 2005

So Mr H What good for humanity came form giving free langar to the RSS supporters at the Ram katha? You just saved them thousands of pounds worth of overhead costs, and instead they will spend the money in India producing more leaflets against the Sikh Gurus. Did Bhai mohinder Singh even have the guts to say to them once that they should accept sikhs as a separate race and religion? Plus in return what favours did the GNNSJ get? Do not even think about telling us there was no backroom deals with GOI. Do you deny that Soho road provide info to GOI about khalistani singhs in birmingham?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Bhopinder Singh · 20 Dec 2005

Israel is a ally of India and has helped them in kashmere .Officers of the rank of col. work and train Indians in Kashmere . They even wanted to attack Pakistan from Jodhpur a airbase in India in 1983,targetting nuclear installations of Pakistan. For sure this guy is working for goi.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Sewadaar · 20 Dec 2005

Dear Brothers Gyani-Ji, Bhopinder Singh and Mr Singh I know you have a lot of views against gnnsj. I would like to organise a meeting with yourselves and gnnsj. I have been reading a few posts recently and it seems that as 'H' has put it, there seems to be a lot of chinese whispers. Let me know of your availability, so I can arrange for a sit in and you can then direct your views and comments to those at gnnsj. Respected Brothers, this is a global message board and you are not doing the "Sikh Community" any justice by attacking fellow Sikhs who are trying to do good for individuals and humanity. We should all be grateful with what people are doing out there and put out our hands in support of all this. Let me know of your availability, so the issues can be ironed out. I look forward to hearing from you soon. As Anjaan Ji has quoted:- Remember the following words..... "Nanak Naam Chardi Kalaa, Terey Bhanay Sarbat Da Bhala" "Hum Nuhi Changa, Bura Nuhi Koy"

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

H · 20 Dec 2005

fistly whatever gnnsj does, it is nishkam, selfless, we don't expect anything in return. as it goes for deals and talks with the GOI about khalistani singhs in uk, what in god's name are you on about. you ask me to prove that there were no deals, you prove to me that there were. and who said that langar should only be kept to ourselves. if somebody came asking something from you, would you turn away from them or would you put out your hand and serve them no matter what faith they were from. and whenever bhai sahib ji and the sangat go to these events, we dont go shying away from who we are, we go dressed as sikhs so that sikhs as a whole get a recognition. we don't go shying away from what we are. bhul chuk maaf

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Singh · 20 Dec 2005

Yes, I would always turn any the RSS supporters who thinks nothing of killing thousands in Godhra and raping women to breed a new race. Yes, I would say no to those who do ninda of the Guru. Have you forgot Guru Ke Ninda Sunee Na Kahn? That is not seva, that is stupidity! If you think no deals are being done, then you have no clue what is going on in your jatha. SHAME ON SOHO ROAD FOR HELPING RSS!

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

oye hoye · 20 Dec 2005

Author: Singh Date: 12-20-05 10:02 Yes, I would always turn any the RSS supporters who thinks nothing of killing thousands in Godhra and raping women to breed a new race. Yes, I would say no to those who do ninda of the Guru. Have you forgot Guru Ke Ninda Sunee Na Kahn? That is not seva, that is stupidity! If you think no deals are being done, then you have no clue what is going on in your jatha. SHAME ON SOHO ROAD FOR HELPING RSS! ..... Can you provide some evidence/proof to back up your claims? Thanx.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Dec 2005

I received this mail today..and it speaks volumes..much more than what anjaan ji and the other chelas of this Baba are saying.. WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Ke Fateh This email has been copied to Sardar Mohinder Singh, so that he can give his views on the matters mentioned in the emails below, published on the internet world-wide. 1. The email below contains an extract from a newspaper, in which Sardar Mohinder Singh has been described as "Keeper of the Golden Temple." This may be a mistake by the newspaper, and Sardar Mohinder Singh can issue a correction. The King of Saudi Arabia is sometimes described as the "Keeper of the Mosques" in Saudi Arabia, i.e. Mecca Mosques, so it may simply be a journalistic mistake. The SGPC is legally, and in practice, responsible for the upkeep of some historical Gurdwaras, including Darbar Sahib - Akal Thakat complex in Amritsar (Golden Temple). Both the SGPC and Sardar Mohinder Singh can clarify the situation reported in The Jerusalem Post, as to who is responsible for the upkeep of Darbar Sahib - Akal Thakat complex. 2. Sardar Mohinder Singh can also explain as to why "Naurang Singh innovated a working constitution or a 'Maryada' to contradict and/or destroy the Sikh Rehat Maryada devised by the most learned scholars of the Sikhs". Is this different Maryada still being practised by Sardar Mohinder Singh, than the Maryada approved by the SGPC? How is the Maryada different from that approved by the SGPC? The SGPC can be approached on the differences. Kashmir Singh LL.B, LL.M, C.Eng, Project Management NVQ4; former Member of statutory OFWAT water industry customer services committee for England and Wales, IEE Council 07721 - 507055 General Secretary, British Sikh Federation, P.O.Box 242, Wolverhampton WV4 5DH, England, UK posted by: Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

oye hoye · 25 Dec 2005

Author: Singh Date: 12-20-05 10:02 Yes, I would always turn any the RSS supporters who thinks nothing of killing thousands in Godhra and raping women to breed a new race. Yes, I would say no to those who do ninda of the Guru. Have you forgot Guru Ke Ninda Sunee Na Kahn? That is not seva, that is stupidity! If you think no deals are being done, then you have no clue what is going on in your jatha. SHAME ON SOHO ROAD FOR HELPING RSS! ***** I'm still waiting for some proof/evidence to back up your claims..

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Dec 2005

WOW..HEAR how "deafening" the SILENCE now is.....all the anjaans and the janijaans have kept quiet....thats it then..folks the show is over....no answers here as ususal.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

oye hoye · 27 Dec 2005

How is the show over? Your post is nothing to get all excited about. It only contains words that have been said here many times before and once again someone wants Bhai Mohinder Singh to answer these questions, nothing to get all excited about. I am waiting for the day when someone actually asks Bhai Mohinder Singh questions and THEN reports back on these forums – anyone can make up any rubbish and post it as fact. As always even people who have never met someone are making accusations (much like you saying you have not heard a ‘peep’ from GNNSJ about 1984 when I have solid proof in the word of a booklet – just because you have not come across something it does not mean it does not exist..). When will the day come where one Sikh will embrace another? Why always look at what you see as a negative and not look at all the positives coming from the same place? Why be selective when talking about someone? No one is perfect and very few people claim to be perfect, but it seems a lot of people feel they are perfect if they feel they are capable of continuously pointing fingers at other people. Gyani Ji, why don’t you visit GNNSJ and have a chat with Bhai Mohinder Singh Ji (or contact Bhai Mohinder Singh and get them to visit Malaysia), it might help clear some of the misconceptions you have and if not at least you will have seen how things are done for yourself, rather than going with what people say on forums – we all know how much we should depend on hearsay.. Also as the person who accused GNNSJ of helping RSS please provide some evidence as there is ‘deafening’ silence on that front too. I am not affiliated with GNNSJ or any other ‘Jatha’; I have one Leader and Guide who is Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaaj so please refrain from insulting me by assuming that I am part of any Jatha/group. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

lost singh · 28 Dec 2005

i know its goign over old stuff, but i go to soho road gurdwara lots n i think its really nice, but i was shocked to hear the allegations of connections with goi..... is this tru or is it jus anti gnnsj talk.... but surely the langar for pro rss ppl cannot be denyed??? can this be explained in another light or is this definately a wrong move by the gurdwara...... plz reply.... wjkk wjkf

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Dec 2005

<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> well neither am I veer. so for me the show is indeed over as there are no answers. IF "everything" was dependant on "meeting" and then only ASKING??ANSWERING???..then whats the use of the Internet?? Media ??Magazines ??Newspapers ?? Radio TV ?/ If as you said its all "made up"..why doesnt the "accused" answer..or is it beneath him a he is "keeper of whatever he thinks he is "..?? Whats the use of the "booklet" if it cant be scanned and put on the net for the entire world ?? sory if offended..i implied nothing about your Guru/Leader..MINE is also the SAME as YOURS.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

oye hoye · 28 Dec 2005

What makes you think Bhai Mohinder Singh even knows what is going on here?! This is a forum where a limited range of 'Sikhs' express their views and just because there may not be answer to you questions there does not mean there is not an answer as the person you refer to may not even know this place exists! That is exactly why I have suggested that you speak to the so called 'accused' directly.. Everything you come across via 'Internet?? Media ??Magazines ??Newspapers ?? Radio TV?/' only gets there either because someone has asked someone questions and has the answers to publish, or because the information is hearsay. Like I said, whats with all the hatred? Can't you accept all as your kin when it comes to Sikhi? Look at the example of Bhai Kanehya Ji. Look at the bigger picture and try and stop focusing on the negatives that come your way - no one is perfect. I won't be commenting further as I feel I have said what I need to say and if you still want to go on believing everything you read online, the best of luck to you. ham nehee cha(n)gae buraa nehee koe || I am not good; no one is bad. If only we thought like that..

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Sewadaar · 03 Jan 2006

I will repeat my message again........come on folks, let get the issues ironed out for once and for all......wherever you are in the world, I will from my own pocket pay for your travel...... Dear Brothers Gyani-Ji, Bhopinder Singh and Mr Singh I know you have a lot of views against gnnsj. I would like to organise a meeting with yourselves and gnnsj. I have been reading a few posts recently and it seems that as 'H' has put it, there seems to be a lot of chinese whispers. Let me know of your availability, so I can arrange for a sit in and you can then direct your views and comments to those at gnnsj. Respected Brothers, this is a global message board and you are not doing the "Sikh Community" any justice by attacking fellow Sikhs who are trying to do good for individuals and humanity. We should all be grateful with what people are doing out there and put out our hands in support of all this. Let me know of your availability, so the issues can be ironed out. I look forward to hearing from you soon. As Anjaan Ji has quoted:- Remember the following words..... "Nanak Naam Chardi Kalaa, Terey Bhanay Sarbat Da Bhala" "Hum Nuhi Changa, Bura Nuhi Koy"

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Karnail Singh Barshi · 03 Jan 2006

My God, the amount of hatred spewed from our so called gursikhs is truly astonishing. All this person has done is gone to the middle east as a delegation of peace and he is being accused of all manner of things. People like Arshi / Singh / Bhupinder have their agendas that they follow, they are so blinkered in their approach that they cannot see the damage they are doing to the ekta of the panth. Someone accused Naurang Singh of starting a new maryadha. Is the AKJ (and I suspect it is the AKJ lot who are stirring up trouble here) maryadha the same as that of AkalTakhat? I do not see the AkalTakhat maryadha supporting Keski as a kakaar. I cannot see AkalTakhat supporting the non-recitation of RaagMala, so who is running their own maryadha anyways ????? I have no idea about the RSS accusation, but all I will say is that even if Aurangzeb came to a Gurdwara for langar no one could refuse him. If these RSS people have come into the Gurdwara, under what pretence could they be removed? In which case, it would be the same people who would be shouting that no one can be barred from a Gurdwara. The silence is deafening Arshi ? - How do you even know that Mohinder Singh even knows that you have asked him any questions? You think he spends his time surfing the net like you do? I am sure he has better things to do. You seem to be a legend in your own head! These criticisers will never ever meet Mohinder Singh because they know that their accusations are nothing but half truths and made up stories. They will use forums like this or huddle in little groups and spread their hatered.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

anti-backstabbers · 03 Jan 2006

you said, "I have no idea about the RSS accusation, but all I will say is that even if Aurangzeb came to a Gurdwara for langar no one could refuse him." But RSS did not come to soho road for langar. A gourmet style langar was taken to their Ram katha at REC. Guru ji never took langar to the moghul darbar. All the sikhs in birmingham took a stand against the Ram katha. Even the hindu parcharak took a stand and did not turn because he said the RSS event has upset Sikhs. But Soho road stabbed fellow sikhs in the back and went to the event and made langar. This saved the RSS thousands of pounds, which they can better use in india in riots to kill minorities. Oh well - Soho road believing in world peace again! Then there was the Behzti incident. All the Sikhs in UK took a stand. So what does Soho road do. It goes to Daily newspapers making accusations against chardi kala sikhs calling them terrorists. Please explain that one please? WE DO NOT HATE SOHO ROAD. BUT SOHO ROAD STABS SIKHS IN THE BACK IN FAVOUR OF RSS AND PUBLICITY FOR ITSELF! If you want a meeting? Get Soho road to book a coach to the June 84 march in Hyde Park, and lets all have a meeting there! Lets see if they can ever book a coach for a sikh event?

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jan 2006

so "Barashi"..answer anti-backstabber above ??? since you seem to be so much in the know....about this "keepr of the Golden Temple"..IS he going to Hyde Park and is he holding a Candlelight vigil on jan 17th... FYI barashi..my one and ony "agenda" is GURU KHALSA PANTH. You have betrayed your ignorance about the Akal Takhat maryada..if you care to READ it you will find that it says..ANY ONE IS FREE to READ or NOT READ Raagmaala ( This is NOT said about any GURBANI...example we are NOT told that we can or not read Japji Sahib according to our WISH..BUT it is said about Raagmala...and it is CLEAR that this is Because Raagmala is NOT GURBANI !!! IF it was Gurbani..no one would DARE to tell us NOT to READ IT. The "Keski" part is a no brainer...no AMRITDHAREE in his right mind will ever "EVER" leave his/her Pavittar Kesh UNCOVERED for any reason whatever. The AKJ have simply seen fit to "emphasise" this..BUT if you can show me anywhere it says that I DONT HAVE TO wear a KESKI,/ or i can Leave my Kesh INCOVERED.....( in the Akal Takhat maryada...i will accept it.) On the other hand the Various SANTS/Sant Samaj Trade Union have PUBLISHED their own verisons of the MARYADA that CONTRADICTS and UNDERMINES the Akal Takhat maryada. They tried to introduce this maryada and win the SGPC Elections ( they LOST..and LOST BADLY). I beleive the Soho peoiple have their own maryada and if they dont..please clarify. GURU KHALSA PANTH GURU GRANTH JI KI JAI Hovey...ALWAYS.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

singh · 03 Jan 2006

jarnail singh arshi, what have you done for the victims of 1984, sikh political prisoners, human rights abuses in india etc why havent you formed an organisation and solved all our panths problems? its all good and well to criticise others but harder to get out of idle criticism and actually do something to make a difference. im no supporter of nishkam sevak jatha as they have a few questionable practices as like at any other dera but for 1984 they were critical of india and did organise collecting money and getting coaches of sangat down for the protests that were held at the indian embassy and hyde park in the years following 1984. that was when the panth was united behind the stuggle. the struggle is over it was lost over 10 years ago what do you want niskham sevak jatha to do about it now? the only way to get justice for sikhs in india is to get mainstream political opinion back to the idea of a seperate homeland. i suggest you go back to india form your own akali dal and agitate. otherwise just idle criticism over the net is useless.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

To Mr Karnail singh Barshi · 04 Jan 2006

you said, I cannot see AkalTakhat supporting the non-recitation of RaagMala, so who is running their own maryadha anyways ????? Please read a history book, and you will find before Rode came along, no raagmala was read at the Akal Thakht sahib. This is a separate matter. From what has been written above, you have alot more to answer for. I think it would be good for all of us terrorists in AKJ, DT, BKI and ISYF to have a meeting with Soho road at the June 1984 march.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

H · 04 Jan 2006

wot you on about, GNNSJ was there at the Behzti demo in bham and from what i can remember, had the only bibi jatha there. we were there throughout the night and served the sangat there tea and snacks too. get your facts right

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Karnail Singh Karshi · 04 Jan 2006

<<< so "Barashi"..answer anti-backstabber above ??? since you seem to be so much in the know....about this "keepr of the Golden Temple"..IS he going to Hyde Park and is he holding a Candlelight vigil on jan 17th... >>> Let me first say I have no affiliation with any jatha. “Arashi” as pointed out by other people GNNSJ were at the Bezti protest as they were at previous rallies. So you have no idea what you are talking about. Just jump on the latest bandwoagon. It is oh so easy to sit behind a pc and type out post after post after post, WHAT HAVE YOU DONE ABOUT THE VICTIMS OF 1984? <<< FYI barashi..my one and ony "agenda" is GURU KHALSA PANTH. >>> I beg to disagree, you may be deluding yourself that this is your agenda but we know all too well that this is not. <<<<..ANY ONE IS FREE to READ or NOT READ Raagmaala ……………………….>>>> The only reason this is as it is because it has been made an issue off, and therefore it has been specifically clarified, that is all. Your Keski babbling is way off target Arashi, no one is saying Keski is not essential, BUT it is not a Kakaar, this is what AKJ believe and Akal Takhat do not. So who has a change in maryadha??? <<<< On the other hand the Various SANTS/Sant Samaj Trade Union have PUBLISHED their own verisons of the MARYADA that CONTRADICTS and UNDERMINES the Akal Takhat maryada. They tried to introduce this maryada and win the SGPC Elections ( they LOST..and LOST BADLY). >>>>> Babbling again Arashi Ji. <<<< I beleive the Soho peoiple have their own maryada and if they dont..please clarify. >>>> YOU BELIEVE??? So much for facts and figures eh Arashi? Just pick up any rumour that supports your agenda and start shouting it out. <<<< I think it would be good for all of us terrorists in AKJ, DT, BKI and ISYF to have a meeting with Soho road at the June 1984 march. >>>>> You lot will never sit down and discuss, rather you will churn out half truths and lies. Again, I am no member of GNNSJ but this hue-and –cry against anyone other then AKJ is getting to be a bit much. Whenever someone does anything half decent rather then acknowledge it you lot with your hidden agendas will criticise. Now, don’t get me wrong there are things that maybe questionable at Soho Road, so go there are iron them out and if you still do not get a satisfactory answer then by all means air your views, but to get on the bandwagon like Arashi on any issue remotely to do with Sant Mahapursh is opportunism of the worst kind.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Admin · 04 Jan 2006

Thread closed. Admin.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Harcharan Singh · 07 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh I have met some sikhs who had Baba Puran Singh Ji's sangat, they came from India post 1984 and were lost in the all the craziness going after Baba Jarnails Singh Ji's shaheedi with many different parties staring up and trying to fiercly recruit youth to their ranks. Many Singhs were confused when encountering some of the non-genuine freedom fighters who had their own agendas. Baba Puran Singh Ji took some of these Singhs under guidance and helped them to fing Guru ji and become strict NITNEMi. They recall there being much pyaar between Baba Puran Singh ji and Baba Jarnail Singh ji, Baba Puran Singh Ji spoke highly of Baba Jarnail Singh Ji and regularly, and is known to have shunned off some of the advantage taking Singhs who were aparently collecting funds for the freedom struggle post 1984 in pretty agressive manners, by questioning them and saying how do I know you will put the money to the use you claim? Because we are Singhs they replied? Are you NITNEMi? Babaji used to say Baba Jarnail Singh ji did Japped Japji over 100 times a day, he had true kamai, whatkamai do you have to be representatives of helping the downtrodden? So for the "usual suspects" whom everyone knows on these forums, stop inventing lies, start acting like Sikhs. If you have a problem sort it out with people to their face, not slandering them behind their backs. I also believe Baba Puran Singh ji was in agreement with Dam Dama Taksaal Maryada due to their meat eating stance. This was the only main thing that the Sevak Jathaa was in disagreement with SGPC run Akaal Takht. I am not 100% sure, but I have heard that Baba Jarnail Singh did seek to change the Maryada at Akaal Takht regarding the meat issue at Baba Puran Singh Ji's request (it was obviously Baba Jarnail Singh Ji's view anyhow). May be some "learned" Gursikh could comment on this. I am not part of the Sevak Jathaa, but am impressed by their smagms, they are inspirational and their seva second to none. I have also met "loads" of impressive Gursikh who have taken amrit after meeting Baba Puran Singh Ji. There is always a lot of huffing and puffing on this phorum by the same few, which is shame for the majority of people who are trying to find inspiration to become Sikhs, these people are def not that inspiration. Respect, homework, communication, politeness, compassion, truth, humility and sincerity are the qualities discussions should reflect, not hate, lies, promoting your own jathaa and always putting down all others. May Guru give his Kirpa to us all. Harcharan Singh

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Please do click on this link and get all the FACTS... http://www.sikhmarg.com/2006/hero-peace.pdf

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

daasan daas · 17 Jan 2006

you cannot not judge Bhai Mohinder Singh on what is stated here. if you want to know what bhai sahib is about please look at the following video link. http://www.ektaone.com/video/mohindersinghtalk.wmv

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Jan 2006

Author: daasan daas Date: 01-17-06 15:02 <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Veer I listened/saw the video at the link you mentioned above....nothing wrong with anything said there. ( on the sant-sadhu-baba being important etc i have my own opinion and he has his own - no problem with that either). But what is being discussed in the Emails sent by Swaran Singh Panesar and others regarding the TITLES..Keeper of the Golden Temple etc is another issue alltogether. NO ONE is "Keepr" of any Sikh Place of Worship...and DARBAR SAHIB is NOT "Golden Temple". Maybe those in the know around Mahinder Singh ji could get these things cleared up and clear the air. Thank You. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Sikh Peace Team in Israel

Harcharan Singh · 18 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Daasan Daas Ji, Thank you for that link, it was hugley inspiring to see an elder Gursikh teaching love and not hate, unity and not division, with intricate and excellently communicated Gurbani knowledge. This is what we need more of, educated experienced (of life) Gursikhs who can reach out to the world, rather than just to the Punjabi minority. Satnaam. Harcharan Singh