Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nirmalas

Nirmalas

Singh · 19 Dec 2005

There is a discussion going on an egroup about whether the words "Amrit" should be used or whether "khande ki pahul" should be used. It this discussion one poster has made the following post about nirmallas. I thought it was very interesting. There are some youth on the internet who base all their sikhi on the nirmallas, instead of mainstream sikhi. I was wondering what the rest of the sangat makes on the below post? Date: Wed, 14 Dec 2005 09:00:08 -0800 (PST) From: Adsm Subject: Re: Amrit vs Khande di Pahul Gur fateh , Panth Parkash was written by Giani Gian Singh whose bansavali is linked with Bhai Mani Singh Ji . He was a Nirmala Sikh and Nirmalas have been famous for distorting the Sikh History and traditions .Gian Singh worte his Book in 1880 i.e 39 years later than Rattan singh Bhangu. One Panth Parkash was witten by Rattan Singh Bhangu of Village Bharee near Khanna Luchaina and his fathers name was Rai Singh . He wrote as the explaination of Capt.Murrey in , but Gurmukhi in poetic form after some ammendments ( additions and deletions). Means he has given the source of his information which is very necessary to mention from reseacrh veiw point . It is one of the oldest episode of sikh history written around 1841 during the reign of Maharaja Ranjit Singh . Rattan Singh Bhangu expired in 1846 . He was grand son of S.Mehtab Singh of Meerankotia therefer need not verify his sikh faith .The Nihang Jathebandis respect this Granth too much and Baba Santa Singh Akali Budha Dal of Nihangs has made a Teeka of this granth .Bhai Bhangu clearly writes that " jihn bidh kahee Angrejan sang , rakho uthaanka sou sang " . Therfore its well evident that the contents are as per the version of some English persons .Where as Giani gian Singh singh did not mention his source of information . Some history about Nirmalas here looks a necssity.What is "Nirmal" , 'Sadh naam nirmal ta kai karam' and ' maya mamta tann te bhagi , upjio nirmal gian' (Basant M :9) . The person who does all deeds with a pure understanding without any game playing is Nirmal. But guru Gobind singh Ji used the word "Khalsa" in Jaagat joyte Sawaye and fixed this word of Khalsa in the fateh also . We never call any body "Nirmal ji" but bid fateh of guru .Guru Gobind singh Ji called the Khalsa Panth and not the Nirmal Panth any where .Otherwise the Nirmal is without any dirt as said "Ahnas navtan nirmala , maila kabhun na hovayee" and "sabad ratey sou Nirmaley" . Keeping such words into consideration a Nirmala Sect was started , which was against the ideology of Dasam guru . It is said some five sikhs were sent to study sanskrit from kanshi , does not mean that they five were assigned to start a new sect among sikhs . These five sikhs when came back brought so many Hindu rituals and bases which they tried to infilterate in Sikhism also. Some people(Nirmalas) at that time left the 5Ks and took the Langoti attire . Most of them were quite literate and wrote so many granths .But it all gave a big loss to the Sikhism . They used to call them Nirmalas and stated quoting the gurbani Tuks on the subject of Nirmla and Nirmal Panth .For some time the Nirmalaas kept the principles of 10th guru except 5Ks . The system of Guru Chela was started again . Due to having bhagvaan clothes they started mixing themselves with Hindu saints .Even upto 1940 they used to keep the parkash of SGGS at their deras and Matths and there after left it .The senior most was called Sari Manaht ji and mixed most of the rituals of hindu philosophy also in their Gurdwaras .So many Hindu grnnths were also respected equal to sggs in their deras . They established Gurdawras at hindu tirath and the innocent sikhs were misguided there .The Udasis are also the similar tyle of mahants .Around 1938 one Pt Niranjan singh started an other Branch and the followers were known as " katchu kateye" . They used to wear Silken clothes and used various types of scentes for good flavour . The states Sikh Rajas in 1918 gave them a recognition also and some Akhadas were installed and gave them Jagirs and big cash amounts .They framed their own 30 rules and the wearing of Kakars was negleted alsmost .because the rajas were afraid of Sikh Sabhias The sikh Pujaris/takhats/granthis prohibited their entry which gave them a big set back . Giani Gian Singh was one of the pioneer of Nirmalas whose foot steps are being followed by some followers of Bai Kala Afgana these days . I try to quote some of the gurbani refereces in which it is very clear that Amrit is a physical form of substance and is required to be taken : 1.nanak Amrit manney mahey , paeeye gurparsad ! Tinhi PEETA rang sion , jin kau likhia aad !! (Var sarang M:2 P 1238) 2.Gurmukh Amrit naam , jit KHADHEY sabh bhukh jaey !! (Var sarang M:3 P1250) 3. Amrit har ka naam hai jit PEETEY tikh jaey !! (Var Malhar M:1 P1283) Nanak Gurmukh jin PEEA tin bahud na lagi aaey !! 4. har amrit PEEVAI sadaa rang raatey , haumai trisna maar !! (Var Malhar M:3 P1281 5. Gur kai bhanai vich Amrit hai sehjey pavai koe !! jinah parapat tin PEEA humai vichu khoey !! (Siri M:3 P31) 6. Amrit naa, NIDHAN hai mil PEEVAU bhai !! (Var gaudi M:5 P318) 7. Sur nar munn jan amrit khojdey so amrit gur te payea !! ( Ramkali M:3 P918) 8. Tikha nivari sabad mann , amrit PEEA bharpoor !! (Ramkali Dakhni Onkar M:1) 9. vin chaakhai suaad kisey na ayea , gur kai sabad amrit PEEAYEA !! (Maru M:3) amrit PEE amrapad hoey , gur kai sabad ras taha re !! 10.Amritsar satgur satvadi , jit nahtai kaua hans hoey !! ( Gujri M:4 P493) Keeping all these order of guru sahiba the 10th master devised the Amrit to bw prepared with the help of Khanda and Bata and replaced the charan pahul system which were never in vogue and it was a brahamanical story of Bhai Gurdas as he has mentioned many Pope-leehla stories in his varan . adsmangat

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 21 Dec 2005

vijaydeep singh, you have given a very one sided view of them. Their role in Sikh history is very questionable. How successful have they been taking Sikhi to hindus? Or how successful have they been making Sikhs into Hindus? That is the question.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 22 Dec 2005

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Some of that initial information is incorrect even before the subjective bias and opinion. I have yet to visit a Nirmala dera/akhara/ashram (and I've been to enough) that doesn't have Prkash of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Likewise, I have never seen a Nirmala dera/akhara that has prkash of other granths. I have never read of a Nirmala dera where this happened. Udasi deras are different in this respect. How much influence did they have? Well you can see how much they have to this day with Nirmalas like Sant Attar Singh, Sant Ishar Singh Rarewale, Herkhowale Sant, Sant Harnam Singh who guided Baba Nand Singh, etc etc. They were the main scholars and brahmgyanis of the panth. They dedicated (and still do in many cases) their entire lives to study, prchaar and realising Gurmat. The saffron attire was given to them by Guru Maharaj himself. They were sent to Hindu pilgrimage centres by Guru ji himself. In the same way Guru Maharaj used sanskrit literature to advance Gurmat, Nirmalay did the same through studying all schools of traditional indian philosophy, which in contrast to today's 'preachers' meant they were experts of all systems of philsophy, able to give commentary on the differences between Gurmat and other perspectives. Anyone who reads Nirmala literature will find this. The taking of a 'vidyaguru' can be traced through direct textual evidence within the Nirmala literature to the time of Guru Maharaj and is not a 'later development' as is claimed. The tradition of a Sri Mahant only arose with formalising the Panchayati Akhara in the 19th century. Prior to that there was no Sri Mahant. The Sikh pujaris/takhats/granthis never prohibited entry (apart from a specific, more political incident at Hazoor Sahib in 1870 something) since they were the people who trained pujaris and granthis! Please read your history, rather than relying on second hand sources. The bungay around Sri Darbar Sahib where granthis and pujaris were trained were largely run by learned Nirmalay. If you have any other doubts or questions about the Nirmalay, ask Damdami Taksal or any other traditional group about the Nirmalas. You'll find that most of the great personalities and saints of Sikhi prior to the Singh Sabha were taught by or were Nirmalas - Bhai Maharaj Singh, Baba Bir Singh, Baba Sahib Singh Bedi, Thakur Dyal Singh, Sant Punjab Singh, etc etc.

HELP ME PLEASE

HMM · 22 Dec 2005

ANYONE KNOW THE SHABAD PAGE NUMBER OF THIS SHABAD IN AMRIT KEERTAN gur gobind soora WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KEE FATEH

Re: HELP ME PLEASE

* · 22 Dec 2005

To HMM, The shabad begins with "Praan meet parmatmaa purkhotam pooraa" and is on 282 of the Amrit Keertan pothi.

Re: Nirmalas

Knower · 22 Dec 2005

True Nirmalas who are outside of Punjab, in places like UP and Bihar are the true Nirmalas. Recently some Sant Mat groups have started to claim Nirmala origin even though they follow none of the Nirmala traditions such as the ones in UP and Bihar do. the last two years or so some Internet youths have began claiming Sant Attar Singh Mastuanaywalay and even Nanaksar, Raraywalay Sants as 'Nirmalas', which seems like a fabrication of history to me. Just because someone had contact with a Nirmala during their lifetime does not make them Nirmala. It's almost like me talking to a Nirmala and by next week people start calling me a Nirmala simply because I was seen talking to a Nirmala. Sorry, but that's not how it works.

Re: Nirmalas

singh · 23 Dec 2005

Can anyone provide conclsuive evidence that any of these Gursikhs are Niramalas? What is the test? It just seems like name dropping.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 23 Dec 2005

The test is simply who they studied with, who they associated with and what their approach and practices were. On the one hand people are criticising the vidyaguru-shishya tradition among Nirmalay, yet on the other the same people are questionning whether the influence on such individuals who were Nirmalas or studied with them! Rarewale have a direct lineage which is 100% Nirmala (i.e. all branches of this lineage are Nirmalas), Nanaksar - Baba Nand Singh studied with Baba Harnam Singh. His influence is clear on Baba Nand Singh and the nature of that relationship is a traditional one. If you read Sant Attar Singh's life story he clearly continues Nirmala practices of asceticism, he studied with Nirmalas, he sought out the company of Nirmalas and he maintained the rehit of Nirmalas, he and his shish are willingly recorded within modern histories of the Nirmalas.

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 23 Dec 2005

so what was he doing in the panch khalsa diwan with bhai randhir singh, and the strictist singhs in the Panth? why do nanaksar not do a nishan sahib outside gurdwaras?

Re: Nirmalas

Panthic Singh · 23 Dec 2005

Avidhya jee, although I like and respect Sant Ishar Singh Jee Raraywalay very much, but the Rara Sahib Sampradha like other groups has a made up lineage with no concrete historical link to Guru Gobind Singh Jee. Prior to 4 years or so, no one had even heard of Raraywalay and Nanaksar having this supposed 300 year old lineage, this is a very recent claim by Rara Sahib and Nanaksar. It is a complete fabrication of history infront of our own two eyes within the last few years. Hundreds of Sadh Mat groups are claiming a 300 year old lineage to Guru Gobind Singh Jee, as if Guru Gobind Singh Jee had nothing better to do with his time. Guru Jee started the Khalsa Panth and that is it. All other Sampradahs, groups, Panths etc are man made, and that is a fact. Rara Sahib Sampradha or even Nanaksar Sampradah have no mention in any of the historical Granths such as Pracheen Panth Parkaash, Mehma Parkash, Suraj Parkash, Twareek Guru Khalsa or even Mahan Kosh.

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 23 Dec 2005

May I also add that this point on fake lineages also applies to Damdami Taksal Buddha Dal ("Nihang" Samprada) When questioned on why no references exist in old texts, the usual excuses given are usually "history has been distorted" (slightly more acceptable, but just how did every single reference to all these lineages magically disappear?) or more commonly and amusingly "just HOW can you question BABA JI/SANT JI?!? do you know better than BABA JI!?! do you really think BABA JI would LIE?"

Re: Nirmalas

Neo Singh · 23 Dec 2005

Panthic Singh, Reason you don't hear much about Rara Sahib, Reru sahib, Hoti Mardan, Harkhowaley, Nanaksar Samparda because they are sub branches of Bhai Dya Singh Nirmali Sampardae(One of two main branches of Nirmale). Each unbroken sub branches have full rights to claims it's orgin to branches. Like it or not, they are puratan lineages going back to the either Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji or his pyares- bhai dya singh, bhai dharam singh. They don't need to meet approval from others. Here is pictorial glimpse of naurangabadi up samparda( sub branch of bhai dya singh samparda). source: taken from Jivan Kirane by Harkhowale Sant. [%sig%]

Re: Nirmalas

Panthic Singh · 23 Dec 2005

N30 Singh Jee, according to that 'chart', how can so many people have all succeeded Baba Karm Singh Jee Hotimardan? Anyone who knows a thing about the Indian system of Sampradayas knows that you can only have one successor. Yet according to that 'chart' we have atleast 15 successors to Baba Karm Singh Hotimardan! That is not how the Sampradaya system works, and that is just one example according to that chart. They may have been mere students of Baba Hoti Mardaan, but they certainly are no successors to Baba Jee. and people have no right to change history by claiming false lineages. Furthermore, why is it that if all of them are successors from the same tree, why do they follow different rehets and traditions? Can you please answer some of these. N30 Singh wrote: -------------------------------- “Like it or not, they are puratan lineages going back to the either Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji or his pyares- bhai dya singh, bhai dharam singh.” ---------------------------------- N30 Singh Jee, going by that logic the entire Panth is decended from those first five Panj Pyaras. Using this logic even I can claim direct descent from the first Panj Pyaras. Forget about me! even SGPC, Missionary, AKJ, Singh Sabha can claim direct descent to the original Panj Pyaras. But sorry to say that is not how it works. These lineages are all fabrications. The integrity of this chart has way too many holes to be true. As a critical thinker I can not accept this blindly. This chart in itself seems to contradict the Indian tradition of Sampradayas.

Re: Nirmalas

simply the best · 24 Dec 2005

It is so funny that the same people who are crying themselves hoarse about 'distorted' history and the same ones whose own lineages cannot stand the test of critical examination. Panthic Singh is right. Only KHALSA panth was created by the Guru. No other panth, samparda, lineage was created by Guru Gobind Singh. All these Nirmalas made their appearance when the Khalsa had taken over Punjab. Have you heard of any Shaheeds who were Nirmalas? Was Taru Singh, Shahbeg Singh, Bhai Mani Singh Nirmalas? Millions of Sikhs were made Shaheed by the Mughals and Afghans but where do you see Nirmalas being Shaheed? All the bakwas about so and so Baba was Nirmala because he happened to bump into some Nirmala is being spread by the likes of Avidya and his neo-nang friends. Strange who the ones who talk about the diversity within Sikhi like to pigeon hole all the great Gursikhs into some made up samparda or other. Avidya may be an articulate writer but he knows Nirmalas are not mentioned in any contemporary texts pre-1760s. Lots of people came out of the woodwork to get the benefits of Khalsa Raj and among them were Udasis and Nirmalas.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 24 Dec 2005

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Dear Panthic Singh, Your suggestion that 'anyone who knows anything about samprdaya's knows theres only one succesor' is unfounded. The proliferation of tradition is that each vidyaguru will have a number of shish who then go and continue to propagate the same. To my mind this is the misunderstanding among some modern groups, particularly where there is a dera involved! In this case there is a succesor mahant allocated, but shish are usually equal in credibility. Likewise your opinion is not shared by Hoti Mardan, its traditions nor I'd imagine Baba Karam Singh himself judging by his acceptance of the samprdaya and its institution of guru-shishya in matters of vidya and practice. As for trying to find these individual lineages in texts like Suraj Prakash and Twarikh Guru Khalsa, that is slightly daft. Both texts were written by Nirmalay! The institutions we're talking about, the personalities we're talking about appear and are explained by the same author of Twarikh Guru Khalsa in Nirmal Panth Prdeepika, Gyani Gyan Singh. You'll need to read a bit more on history to find out the role Bhai Dya Singh and Bhai Dharam Singh play in Nirmala traditions. This isn't simply, 'they took amrit from them' but studying and scholarship as well and the samprda's internal structure. Find a book on the Nirmala Samprdaya such as Pritam Singh's book of the same name published by Guru Nanak Dev Uni. On the issue of Rarasahibwale, it would be pretty foolish looking for 'raresahib samprda' in old texts! Its a place! However, the individuals in their parampra were real, they were Nirmalas, and thus they extend through vidyaguru to shish. There is no doubt in my mind as to the lineage. Look in the early 20th century record of these lineages and they exist in the same format. Therefore your suggestion that 'these traditions didn't exist until four years ago' is unfounded. If you would like to prove this then fair enough. You can reference texts by Mahant Dyal Singh, Mahant Ganesha Singh from the beginning of this century, alongwith Mahant Bishan Singh's text from the 70s about modern Nirmalay including Raresahib, Mahant Balwant Singh's works also including his text on Sant Attar Siingh ji. Just simply read up!

Re: Nirmalas

Panthic Singh · 25 Dec 2005

Avidhya, i am currently not in my town, so I cannot reply at the moment. I will give you a reply in just a few days when i come back.

Re: Nirmalas

singh · 03 Jan 2006

so basically there is no concrete to your claim that Bhai daya singh was a niramala. Clearly he was a khalsa. So every amritdhari sikh has descended from him. But as far as him being a nirmala, it is just another jackanory story!

Re: Nirmalas

singh · 04 Jan 2006

can`t anyone answer my question above? There is no concrete proof that niramalas were started by Bhai daya singh?

Re: Nirmalas

singh · 06 Jan 2006

Ok, then the whole sampradaya thing is just one big lie like so many others. There is only lineage and that starts with Guru Nanak dev ji, and ends with us the khalsa. The rest is all false.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 06 Jan 2006

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh 'Singh' I didn't bother replying since you seem to be quite convinced of your stance, and I presume any dialogue would fall on deaf ears. However, when it comes to tradition it is important to not be so cynical, for cynicism inevitably effects people's sadhana. I'd advise you to really read into it, in detail from all sources available. I personally feel it is unimaginable that the Guru who opened his darbar to scholars, saints and mystics, who instigated so much scholarship, would not have wished this to continue and not have designated individuals with his specific directions for this to continue. Key historical sources support this position. However, I guess if cynicism takes you to the view that Sri Dasam Granth is other people's 'hindumat' writings, and that Guru ji never translated sanskrit texts into braj, and likewise history sources are also 'brahminmat' written by 'enemies of the panth', then none of that is 'unimaginable' to you. If this is your line, then you should also recognise that doubting all of those things effectively questions much of what we know of Sikhi, since once a source is unreliable, all of it is unreliable, and opens it into a free for all of recreation just what exactly Sikhi is. The whole Kala Afghana saga is an example of what happens when you discredit everything. Others may then take the line, 'we should simply use gurbani to know what Guru Gobind Singh ji's intentions were' and yes that it true. But even a 14 year old on a GCSE religious studies course will learn about and recognise that one person's interpretation will inevitably be different to another's. And in this situation, this is where tradition itself comes in, and the samprdas, who through teacher to student process have acquired traditional meaning from generation to generation going back to those original few individuals who studied under the Guru's direction and directed to propogate the teachings to others.

Re: Nirmalas

singh! · 06 Jan 2006

Guru saahib had sikhs go get educated, no doubt about that. And these sikhs would obviously have passed on their knowledge to others. That's just natural. However, there is no concrete evidence or even reason for assuming, that any official nirmala samparda was started at the time of the guru's. This all came later. Even nirmalas can't agree on when they started. Some say at Guru Gobind Singh Jee's time, others take it back to Guru Nanak Dev Jee. It's all made up. The sikhs that went to learn sanskrit and whatever else, received khanday dee pahul and were simply educated singhs. They taught others who wanted to learn and eventually someone turned it into a samparda with lineages. This was not how it was originally set up.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 07 Jan 2006

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh What are your arguments based on? You sound convinced. The first point to mention is that you seem to have different understanding of what a samprda is. As you accept 'educated Singhs being given direction from Guruji to go and propogate vidya and taking in students'...that is a samprda! Traditional knowledge being passed down from generation to generation thus creating lineages! Without going into details, there are references from the later half of the 18th century (early writings by the first Nirmalas) which clarify Guru ji starting the Nirmalas as an order. The source of this for the author was his own original vidyaguru (described as such) who was a hazoori singh of Guru ji. These early texts contain all the distinctive components of the Nirmalay. Thats the evidence I'm talking about. Which begs the question, that apart from your own opinion what evidence do you have to counter it? As for Nirmalas not being able to agree on who started it, yes it is true that Gyani Gyan Singh argues in Nirmal Panth Pradeepika that Guru Nanak Dev ji is the one who started the Nirmalay. Personally for this reason I looked beyond the 19th century sources. Another interesting point also has been raised recently by Amritpal Singh on his website to do with the very appearance of Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj. Nirmala tradition narrates not just one event, but a number of 'bakshishes' by the Guru to individual initial Nirmalas, hence the different lineages. One of which states that Guru ji as he occasionally did, wearing his 'nirban' or saffron sadhu robes was observing the langar, and on being impressed by the devotion and learning of one Singh, gave him his dress and specific instructions to one hazoori Singh. Amritpal Singh ji has also noted that in 'Sri Guru Sobha' it is recorded that Guru ji would appeared in 'nirban' roop. These are just some of the numerous complementary points that give credibility to the Guru's intentions in instigating the Nirmala order, and I recommend as I've stated before to simply do some reading, not of 20th century punjabi and english accounts, but primary sources both within and outside the samprdaya.

Re: Nirmalas

*.* · 08 Jan 2006

vijaydeep you stated "...Nirmalas are exepert in Herbal or Ayurvedic medicine" a dear one of mine is in agony due to arthritis, can you please share which Nirmala you refer off when saying "expert in Herbal or Ayurvedic medicine" which Nirmala in particular? If her illness permits she will be going to India soon, and she wants to know where to take desi medicine from so vijaydeep your input would be greatly appreciated. thankyou

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 09 Jan 2006

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Many Nirmalas (although not all) set up ayurvedic dispernsaries attached to their deras. For example a dear friend of mine has his free dispensary in his dera and like most Nirmalas alongwith practical tutoring in Haridwar, uses Mahant Ganesha Singh's compendiums. There is a lot of 19th century ayurvedic literature translated into braj or punjabi from sanskrit by Nirmala scholars.

Re: Nirmalas

singh · 09 Jan 2006

so basically we have got no further. There is no contemporary evidence to suggest that Nirmalas were started by Bhai daya singh. still nothing has been presented.

Re: Nirmalas

still singh · 11 Jan 2006

vijaydeep, you do not need to go to a nirmala for that. You can get the answer from the swami on Asstha TV. However can any nirmalla supporters, especially NEo, super mod of sikhawareness, who spends his days slagging of tapoban to his potted plants, please answer my question. Where is the concrete proof that Bhai daya singh ji is not a Khalsa, but a nirmala?

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 12 Jan 2006

'Singh' Two things to keep in mind. One is that the Nirmalas were not separate from the Khalsa, but one side of it. The early Nirmala sources from the 18th century state the same. The second thing to bear in mind is that the early formation of the Nirmalas was through individual encounters with Guruji. It is not as you seem to think, some heralding and establishment of a huge group of people as an order, but a quieter instigation of a tradition among the spiritually illuminated and scholarly Singhs to continue Guru ji's scholarly activities and for the transmission of Gurmat philosophy. If you read something more comprehensive like Gyani Ishar Singh Nara's 'Zafarnama te Safarnama', about this time, these things often happen on a more individual level. That means that you will not find direct written sources from the time describing these events. Now be careful. It has been a position by some scholars like McLeod for example, that if there is no clear written dated reference to something in accepted sources, then they cannot be relied upon. The consequence of this approach is that A LOT of what we hold dear comes under question. Personally, through research it is possible to come to conclusions based on the persuasiveness of a whole set of supportive events across written sources, physical places and tradition. What there is for Bhai Dya Singh is...if you have faith in Bhai Dya Singh's own rehitnama then you should recognise that it extends into specific rehits for both 'bihangams' (Nirmalas) and 'Akalis' (Nihangs). You find 19th century sources stating the same position (Khalsa as warriors and scholarly preachers), oral tradition within sampardayas all state the same here. As i'm sure you are aware, it is this post Khalsa period before the rise of the misaldars that has less primary source material available. Gurbilas literature exists, but with issues of when it was written. The Nirmala sources from the 18th century I refer to, with clear written dates (within the texts themselves) and clear of not only the author, but the author's vidyaguru and the intentions of Maharaj himself in creating the Nirmalas.

Re: Nirmalas

hmmmmm · 12 Jan 2006

then why does these four fake sampradayas, need to exist? There work can and should be done under the khalsa banner.

Re: Nirmalas

Harcharan Singh · 12 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Avidya ji, Could you please direct me towards Bhai Daya Singh Ji's rehitnama, can it be found on the net, or is there an unadulterated (non SGPC) translation available? Thank you. Harcharan Singh

Re: Nirmalas

hmmmmm · 12 Jan 2006

why is none of these sampardayas can agree on which one is right. Is it because it made up? There is only one order and that is the Khalsa Panth.

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 12 Jan 2006

avidya, You know well that Bhai Daya Singh Rehatnama is not written by Bhai Daya Singh of the original Panj Pyare. If you genuinely didn't know that, it doesn't say much for any of your historical evidence. If you did, and you said it anyway, that is called knowingly spreading misinformation.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 12 Jan 2006

'Singh' Please elaborate. Which rehitnamay are reliable, and which early written sources would you state are also reliable? I look forward to your reply.

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 12 Jan 2006

avidya, What is "reliable"? The Rehatnameh are a product of their time. But before I reply to this question, you need to answer, do you believe Daya Singh Rehatnama was written by Bhai Daya Singh of original Panj Pyare, or did you knowingly write something untrue to try and spread your agenda. Let's not avoid the issue by talking about other Rehatnameh or other accounts.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 13 Jan 2006

'Singh' Clearly you have an axe to grind here! I have consistently answered your questions and have no 'agenda' either but to answer your questions! As for Bhai Dya Singh rehatnama, I haven't read the manuscript copies that Ashok and Padam compiled myself to comment on them. I've read McLeod's evaluation of it and like much of McLeod's evaluation am not convinced. Even if it were not written by Bhai Dya Singh himself (as is argued), it at least represents what was accepted in the 18th century which was that the Khalsa was divided into 'Nirmalay' Singhs and 'Akali' Singhs and its source. Now over to you. Please comment on which are acceptable and which are not, and which primary sources consititute evidence. You sound pretty confident on these things.

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 16 Jan 2006

so there is no concrete evidence?

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 16 Jan 2006

'Singh' I'm still waiting for your answer! Please state what rehitnamas and historical sources constitute 'concrete evidence', just the names is fine. Please don't shy away from the question, it will help in further discussion.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 20 Jan 2006

'Singh' what happened?! You still haven't stated what 'concrete evidence' is. Doesn't that make your argument pointless?

Re: Nirmalas

Singh · 20 Jan 2006

avidya, I have been away for a week and you get excited! Concrete evidence such as Gurbani, Bhai nand lal ji rehitnama or Bhai gurdas ji vaar or Bhatt vahis. References are made to sikh and khalsa, but nothing about bhai daya singh ji being a nirmalla.

Re: Nirmalas

avidya · 20 Jan 2006

'Singh' thanks for the reply. To be frank, I'm surprised they're the only sources you accept as concrete, unaltered evidence. I shall reply later having refreshed myself with some of them with questions.

Re: Nirmalas

dalbir singh shergill · 23 Mar 2006

ok this whole crapy abt the nirmalas ya there are nirmalas who do not have guru granth sahib parkash and there are nirmalas like the nirmal ashram of rishikesh which has branchs all over india like the one in karnal of GT ROAD in front of the goverment court there is the nirmal bagh in haridwar they all have guru granth sahib parkash how do i know this because i have been there many a time my father has been in the service of mahant baba ram singh ji for 20 years i assure u that they can trace there lineage to guru gobind singh ji i have at home the whole granth about the history of the ashram [%sig%]

Re: Nirmalas

dalbir singh shergill · 25 Mar 2006

no i am not talking abt udaseens i am talking abt nirmalas they are part of the nirmal akharda they have donate a gold palki to the nirmal akharda all the location of the nirmal ashram have guru granth shahib parkash specially the bigger locations there is always a akhand pattah going on specially in nirmal kutia karnal there is long waiting list there. nirmal kutia is the places where SANT BABA NIKKA SINGH JI MAHARAJ 'VIRAKAT' did meditation for many years and the other place is the one in rishikesh the nirmal ashram- that place always i mean always has parkash of guru granth sahib ji i have been there many a time during my life i cant even count it in riskhesh there are only 2 place for u to stay at if u are going on to hemkunt sahib it is the last stop for the journey the one place in the gurudwara under the sgpc the other is the nirmal ashram the gurudwara i think has few rooms if any at all the ashram has more rooms and better facilities for the sangat many come there i suggest u go there if u are making the yatra to hemkunt sahib [%sig%]

Re: Nirmalas

dalbir singh shergill · 25 Mar 2006

o yes here is the website for nirmal ashram http://nirmalashramrishikesh.org/Main.htm [%sig%]