Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Muslim's prophets

Muslim's prophets

msingh · 22 Dec 2005

Have any of you been in a Mosque? If you have describe. Do they have pictures of their prophets in their mosques? The reason why I am asking you is because I feel that they do not have pictures in their homes, or in their mosques. They only have the Koran. Why is it that the Sikhs display pictures of Guru Jees when Guru Jee Strictly said that we are to belive and worship the words of Wehaguru which is in Guru Granth Sahib. Is this because we have weeknees because our ancestors sadly were Hindus.

Re: Muslim's prophets

Picture this · 22 Dec 2005

The Shias Muslims have pictures of Imam Ali all over the place, especially the persian Shias.

Re: Muslim's prophets

Guruvah · 22 Dec 2005

As far dass knows their syariat stops them from doing any paintings involving men and women.As it might bring some lustfull thoughst as they say!But,they do have their prophets physical appearance mentioned in their hadith or something. As for in Gurmat,it is PURE manmat to worship and have sharda paintings.BUT,I can surely say that Guru Sahib isn't againt's paintings.As Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib Maharaj made "his own" painting at the request of a bazurg Mata jee.This painting is still around to day in Victoria House,Calcutta,India. Any gursikh here from Culcutta can go and check it out.As Guru Sahib painted his OWN nuranee chehra with his own hands, and gave this painting to this MAta jee. Guru Ang Sang.........

Re: Muslim's prophets

khalistani · 22 Dec 2005

y r u copying muslims? painting aint agaisnt sikhi ull see loads of em in purtaan saroops but dont worship em thas guru jes point bhula chuka ma

Re: Muslim's prophets

msingh · 22 Dec 2005

Dear Khalistani I not copying muslims but why are so sadned when we find a wrapper of Guru Jee's Picture in the trash can or in a dumpster? People have commercialized Guru Jee's and what is next someone making a movie similar to "Temptations of Jesus Christ." In my eyes the future is heading that way wheather anyone likes it or not. Don't forget the recent movie Bola Sonh Hal.

Re: Muslim's prophets

happy singh · 23 Dec 2005

our ancestors were not hindus, but muslims, theists, athiests aswell. All types of people joined Guru Nanak

Re: Muslim's prophets

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Dec 2005

i am not sure if this is copying ?? anybody..BUT our GURU is SHABAD GURU...not DEH......DEH is NAASWAAN..destructible....BUT Shabad Guru is GYAN.....BRAHMGIAN....for ever and forever...limitless..beyond time/birth/disease/sickness/dukh/sukh whatever...form/pictures..

Re: Muslim's prophets

HD Singh · 23 Dec 2005

The problem with depictions of the Gurus is that people start to worship those depictions. I have relatives, who do 'pooja' or sadhnaa to those depictions everyday. Pictures of great historical figures like SHaheeds is good, but I don’t like the idea of having pictures of Gurus. One of the major Sikh groups who I wont mention by name but lets call them the ‘N’ sect also does pictures worship. This practice seems very unSikh to me. A deviation from Gurmat. Keep pictures of Gurus, but dont worship them. It is nothing but paper with colour on it.

Re: Muslim's prophets

K · 25 Dec 2005

the 'N' sect? lol!

Re: Muslim's prophets

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 27 Dec 2005

In my personal opinion, pictures can be good and bad. One the useful side, they are a reminder of our Guru -ji's and can help younger kids learn very basic things, like names of Guru - ji's (if there is some text at the bottom of the painting). BUT, when people start doing matha-tek, even dhoop waving in front of the pictures, then we have a problem. Dhan Guru, Dhan Guru Khalsa Panth

Re: Muslim's prophets

Harcharan Singh · 27 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Our Guru's never allowed any paintings of themselves to be made, nor did the Guru's after Guru Nanak Dev ji create paintings of Guru Nanak Dev ji, this should tell you something. Idol worship is the disease of all faiths. Buddha was against idol worship, yet all Buddists (and many non-Buddists) own Budda idols for worship/luck. Jesus Christ was against idol worship but most Christians own Jesus on a cross in many forms, turning tothe idol for help when in need. We have also gone down the same root. Sunny (orthodox) Muslims and possibly Jews are the only faiths that don't condone idols/paintings of their prophets. Which is somehting we can learn from. There main point of reverence is always their word of God. This is true for Sikhs also, but has recently been supplemented, and by many overtaken by having a nice handsome picture of a light skinned, well dressed, and in a lot of cases accessorized (jewellery) Guru. Most "purataan" paintings we see today are recent paintings (less than 150 years old). Ranjit Singh, upon establishing his kingdom, took on board many Moghul traits (as many of his cabinet and trusted men in charge were ex-Mughals). Painting was one of them. Ranjit Singh started the trend of painting our Guru's pictures, the oldest tested paintings are no more than 160?!? years old (Ranjit Singhs reign). This trend continued in the 1920's when many of the pictures that are seen in all the worlds Gurdwarai and many Punjabis homes were created. The SGPC are mainly to blame for this as they encouraged this and awarded awards for the best paintings. Not only do I see paintings as a direct act of disobedience to our Guru's wishes, it is also an insult to our Guru's, who is anyone to dare imagine how they looked, how can anyone's imagination be applauded for recreating our Guru's different to how God made them! There is no excuse, justification or answer. All the worlds main faiths are against idol worship, there is a good and commen sense reason for this. When ever man re-creates an image of God or his servents out of love/greed/manmat (what you will), it is inevitable that man will eventually end up turning to that image for strength, help, support etc rather than to God. This has always and will always happen. That is why our Guru's have constantly told us not to go down this root, that is why no real paintings of our Gurus exist ( I do not believe tourist industry claims as mentioned in previous posts). We should be ashamed, ask for Guru's forgiveness and learn a lesson from Muslims, adorn our homes with truth/fact, and not some manmukhs ego boosting and insulting idea of how our Guru's looked. Muslims decorate their homes with beautifully written pages of the Koran, why can we not have shabad adorning our homes, do we not have more reverence for our Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Why do we choose to instead decorate our homes with braminical paintings? Paintings of famous gursikhs and shaheed are fine, they give us motivation, courage, history, but more importantly there is no danger of us worhsipping them. I personally see most (not all) people who have paintings/khandai on their cars as people with an identity crisis. Listen to Dasmai Patshah, partake in khandai de Pahul, your identity crisis will be over. Sat Sri Akaal - Only the revered truth exists beyond the bounderies of time! Harcharan Singh

Re: Muslim's prophets

ns · 27 Dec 2005

Beautiful post Harcharn Singh Jeeo

Re: Muslim's prophets

Dogra · 08 Jan 2006

'idol worship' is a physical object. The other object whether pages from a book, or the thought, is another form of 'idol worship', as focus on something is used. In Indian subcontinent, theres to much classifying people into religious groups, rather than just accepting people as is, without asking, from what faith are u? In one religious place on the road from Delhi to Chandigargh, there are religious books from Islam, Sikhism and Hinduism all in one room. So what does that make the person? mixed religious like a mixed race person? Atheists also exist in India, and people who believe in God, but are not that religious, and do not go by any religious term, as they pick and choose what they like about each faith or none. In the words of Shaheed Udham Singh " RAM MOHAMMED SINGH AZAD"

Re: Muslim's prophets

khalistani · 08 Jan 2006

in india, al lot of the many purtaan saroops i saw had pictures in them iive also seen pics of dasam granth with picutre sin em nutin wrong wit pics as long as u dunt throw em in the trash, i understand tha point of view, and u dunt start worshippin em bhula chuka maf