Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

singh · 30 Dec 2005

source:http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/bhagats/bhagatkabir.htm <> I know that only those aspects of the Bhagats are included in the Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj that were in accordance with the Guru Ghar. But I found it a bit ackward to know that very dear saint kabir ji was a bit against women.Can any veer who has read kabir granthavali or bijak give more insight? Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Muli Ram · 02 Jan 2006

It does not matter if Bhagat Kabir Ji was sexist or not. His bani has a deeper meaning then what you see. It maked perfectly good sense to me what he says. Kaam is a thing that can bring a person all the way down. Unless your homosexual you will think about the opposite sex. And why are you questioning Bhagat Kabir Ji's character. I think this should be the least of your worries. Sikhi tha dubri hai. I don't see you questioning that. Sikhs have become muslims without even the threat of persecution. How sikhs are to much into worldly belongins. Don't even mention the name punjab. Over there all you see is drunk rodey.

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Singh · 02 Jan 2006

The guy who wrote obviously does not completely understand the analogues in the shabads of bhagat kabeer ji

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Harcharan Singh · 02 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh This is ludicrous. These are analogies, understandable concepts used to explain something deeper. At Kabir Ji's time (and past and present), many men fell prey to their own lust, in the form of prostitues/adultry etc. This is something that many men were susceptible to due to the lack of a true path to God at the time. Kabir Ji simply used this analogy as people could (and still can relate to it). It is not to say women are evil, it is to say that lust (in the form of women) can distract a man from God. It is a generally accepted fact that men are more lustful than women. Men date for lust, women date for love/romance (in general). Dating for both reasons is wrong, as our love/romance should be directed towards Waheguru and our physical needs should only be met inside of a holy marriage. Basically Kabir ji speaks the truth, it is only uneducated minds that twist the truth, if anything, Kabir ji indirectly speaks of the stregth of women, as it is not them that are susceptible to lust. Kabir Ji is simply giving us a real life example to relate to in understanding what it means to surrender to maya, how easy it is, and what the consequences are. Sangat should all e-mail Allabout sikhs website and ask them to amend this nonsense which aims to throw sand in the face of our Guru. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

abc123 · 02 Jan 2006

u post a very good point.... i too would like to know the answer from someone in the know..... surely we cannot pick and chose wot areas we agree with from their bani......

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Singh · 02 Jan 2006

i tink kabir ji is portrayin maya in a physical form of a women. in some cases as a prositute who sleeps with the man and then leaves him, in the same way the 5 evils (women/maya) do there best to entice the mind (man) and after death they leave. i hope this has helped waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Gurpreet Sumra · 02 Jan 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, why dont you bring those granthavali etc. and also their source. if you can't get them then if it is published please provide us the publisher,ISBN no. and where we can get it. If you are sitting on the kirpa of websites, then veerji we have sri guru granth sahib ji.why dont you read SGGS ji and then talk.read bhagat kabir ji's bani.If you wll read it then you will come to know that he was a true revolutionary.In SGGS(Shri grur granth sahib ji) he is one of those preachers who is slapping bipar or anti sikhism in blunt language bind rakh jo tariye bhai If someone could save himself by celibacy, O Siblings of Destiny, khusre kyon naa param gat pai why then haven't eunuchs obtained the state of supreme dignity? The whole shabd is on ang(page no.) 324 I am responding on Gurmat for the first time. bhul chuk maaf Gurfateh [%sig%]

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Gurpreet Sumra · 02 Jan 2006

I am sorry, but I want to know the source from where you got this information that later part of this bhagat or that bhagat was not involved. I will really appreciate the name of author, his book ,ISBN no. and also the whole part if you have read that. please I send me the author. Gurfateh

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jan 2006

--------- But I found it a bit ackward to know that very dear saint kabir ji was a bit against women.Can any veer who has read kabir granthavali or bijak give more insight? --------- “Singh” you have brought forward a very interesting question. It is true that Bhagat Kabir jee’s baani outside of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not of same standard as baani inside. In order to understand this we need to realise that before reaching the Gurmat level of spiritual awareness, Bhagat Kabir jee underwent many phases. His first guru was a Muslim faqir from Banaras called Taqqi. Later he tried to become a disciple of Ramanand jee who at first did not accept him but later gave him Mantr and accepted him as his disciple. The baani that Bhagat Kabir jee wrote before meeting the true Guru is of much lower standard and reflects the Vaishnav beliefs that call women evil and call them by names like serpent, tigress etc. Tulsidas and other Vaishnav Bhagats wrote similar views about women. The change in Bhagat jee’s life did not occur all of sudden but was a result of his meeting the true Guru – Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. Siri Guru jee met Bhagat Kabir jee in Maghar and Bhagat Kabir jee became a Sikh of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Many historians have erroneously written that Bhagat Kabir jee lived before the time of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee but they are mistaken in their beliefs. It’s a known fact that Sikander Lodhi persecuted Bhagat Kabir jee by trying to drown him in Ganga. Sikander was the king at the time of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and he founded the famous city of Agra in the early 1500s. We see that Bhagat Kabir jee’s avastha went sharply upwards after meeting Satguru jee and this fact is comes out so clearly when you compare the baani of Kabir jee inside of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and outside of it. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

surajsingh · 04 Jan 2006

Kulbir Singh, You have shown great naiveness in your post or you have made this post knowing it was distortion. Please have a look at Bhai Gurdas Ji's var and find out relation between Bhagat Ramanand Ji and Bhagat Kabir. http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=B&PageNo=&ShabadID=5773&Format=2 Let's not defame great Bramgyanis like Bhagat Ramanand whose one hymns is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib. [%sig%]

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Gurpreet Sumra · 04 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, I am not a learned sikh like all of you here, but I want the source where bhagat kabir ji wrote against women. I also want the source from where you got this information that bhagat kabir's 1st guru was-----and all that. regarding drowning in river ganges, i am not sure abt the ang of guru granth sahib, but kabir ji is talking about bhagat Namdev, please provide proper reference always I cant recall the whole shabad its in SGGS ji "kya apradh sant hai kina bandh kor---------bandh kor----" I will post it as soon as I get time. FOR YOUR SATISFACTION IT IS IN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. AND AS PER HISTORY BHAGAT NAMDEV WAS THROWN IN FRONT OF A ELEPHANT AND THEN IN RIVER GANGES. SO DONT TRY TO SAY THAT GURU SAHIB'S ADOPTED DOUBLE STANDARDS, HOW CAN THEY DO IT IF GURU SAHIB GAVE GURGADDI TO VAISHNO DEVI'S BHAGAT BHAI LEHNA, WHO IS SECOND NANAK GURU ANGAD DEV JI. I THINK IT IS BETTER TO PROVIDE ALL REFERENCES AND SOURCES BEFORE MISGUIDING PEOPLE WHO DONT READ GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI,GURU'S MESSAGE AND ARE UNAWARE OF SIKH HISTORY. ONCE AGAIN I AM SORRY I AM NOT AS LEARNED AS YOU. Gurfateh [%sig%]

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Jan 2006

There are a lot of "so called Sikhs scholars and the like" who are VERY BUSY promoting this SUB STANDARD "bani" of Bhagat kabir Ji, so as to JUSTIFY their Bhassaurria beleifs that ALL BHAGAT BANI is NOT GURBANI and should be discarded from Guru Granth ji. Teja Singh Bhassaurria was EXCOMMUNICATED by the Akal Takhat Sahib for this evil....and his Family has even now many decades afterwards APOLOGISED to Akal Takhat on his behalf...BUT His evil "genius" lives on in the Minds of many many bhassaurria sikhs..On many Boards and Mailing lists this kachee bani of Kabir is being promoted to show that he is anti women, and alot else besides..and so it is IMPOSSIBLE that His Bani could be GURBANI..and thus wrongly put in the Guru Granth by some Hindus etc etc and shoudl be REMOVED. The FACTS are as Bhai kulbir Singh Ji has aptly put forward above. Guru Arjun Ji Sahib very very CAREFULLY chose ONLy those lines from Bhagat banis that AGREE 100% with GURMAT. Thus there is not a single line of any Gurbani that contradicts any other line...no matter who the author is. It is an undeniable FACT that ALL GURBANI in the GURU GRANTH JI is GURBANI of Equal Standard and Beleif. We BOW to the ENTIRE and COMPLETE GURU GRANTH JI..not parts and factions. The "only" composition that is NOT GURBANI ( and we are thus given the choice whether to read it or NOT READ IT..is Raagmaaala). NO other Gurbani is thus addressed by the Akal Takhat maryada. IF Bhagat kabir ji wrote "substandard" bani while NOT yet a SIKH of Guru nanak Ji... then we also have example of "Bhai Lehna Ji...who was doing the rounds of the Mandirs and devis etc etc when He was NOT YET a SIKH of Guru nanak ji....at this Material Time Bhai lehna Ji is NOT even a SIKH much less a GURU....we only pay homage to Him as GURU ANGAD JI when He has passed the Litmus Test. Similarly ALL the GURBANI that Bhgat kabir Ji wrote and was chosen By Guru Arjun Ji to be placed in Guru Garanth ji is GURBANI....all the rest of his writings are of no consequence to us.

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Jan 2006

veer vijaydeep singh writes: There Das found that he has good praise for Babu Teja Singh Ji.<<<<<<< >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> I have no problem with that. Babu Teja Singh was a good Gurmukh person..at first..at that time even Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh ji was on good terms with him....but later on when he went agaisnt BHagta bani as the bani fo low castes etc and threw it out of a copy of the Granth Ji he compiled...he was excommunicated. BSB Randheer Singh ji then never saw him again. I am a LIFE MEMBER of the Biggest Gurdawra in Kuala Lumpur...it si also the OLDEST. It was controlled by Bhassaurria Sikhs..followers of Teja Singh. Raagmala was NEVER READ at this Gurdawara until the late 1990's. Teja Singh is among those that helped to compile the Present day Sikh rehat Maryada of the Akal Takhat...only their rehat was much stricter. Their society was called PANCH KHALSA DIWAN. His great grandson apologised to the Akal takhat on his behalf some tiem ago.

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Gurpreet Sumra · 06 Jan 2006

wahe guru ji ka khalsa wahe guru ji ki fateh, Pleases tell me what is Sikh rehat maryada? I want to read eevry word of it.So please dont do any injustice to sikh rehat maryada, which should be followed everywhere. Is Darbar sahib foloowing sikh rehat maryada??? I want an answer from anyone and everyone. I will not write anythng more bcos i think u know why? gurfateh

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Prabhjoyt Singh · 07 Jan 2006

wasnt Teja su bhasauria the one who did ardas from Sri Harmandar sahib saying "je Raagmaala bani hai fir mere mu vich keeray pe jaan" and then after a while us de mu vich keeray pe ge si

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

... · 07 Jan 2006

Sorry Prabhjoyt Singh, although Teja Singh wasn't the smartest fellow, and was thrown out of the Panth for his opposition to Bhagat Bani and making up his own gurmantar, he NEVER had any keeraas in his mouth. The keera story is a Taksali fabrication and never happened to anyone. It is a lie.

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

Dhanwant · 09 Jan 2006

no......he had a wife.

Re: Was Saint Kabir Ji anti women?

............. · 09 Jan 2006

"Sorry Prabhjoyt Singh, although Teja SinSorry Prabhjoyt Singh, although Teja Singh wasn't the smartest fellow, and was thrown out of the Panth for his opposition to Bhagat Bani and making up his own gurmantar, he NEVER had any keeraas in his mouth. The keera story is a Taksali fabrication and never happened to anyone. It is a lie." ah well I expected thet when in doubt akj always blame the Taksalis