Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Vinegar!!

Vinegar!!

Information · 08 Jan 2006

Is all Vinegar OK to use in food? Some Vinegar suggests that it has alcohol in it, i.e. white wine vinegar, cider vinegar. I heard all vinegar has a miniscule amount of alcohol init anyway. Obviously before anyone jumps on the bandwagon that you shouldn't use vinegar because it might have alcohol in it, I don't think you can get drunk on it, I think it might be same as some medicines. Please can some Gursikhs from a chemistry background give a answer PLEASE!!! Also lets stick to the topic please as most posts seem to go off subject within the first few posts. Fateh!! [%sig%]

Re: Vinegar!!

indy · 08 Jan 2006

vinegar contains usually 2.5-10% of ethanol hydroxide, a true singh/singni will refrain from using vinegar.

Re: Vinegar!!

simple singhani · 08 Jan 2006

how about ketchup? im told the heinz one is pure..

Re: Vinegar!!

Guru kian Beant Faujan · 08 Jan 2006

As I understand the process of distilling vinegar is similar to whisky and rum. The Sarblohi Singhs in India do not use it as it is not bibek. However the Tapoban Singhs do consume it in the process of making paneer. There are other alternatives that should be used, such as lemon juice. As for ketchup - that is not bibek unless you make it yourself.

Re: Vinegar!!

Balpreet Singh · 08 Jan 2006

Guru Kian Beant Faujan, Vinegar is not used as a rule to make paneer by the "tapoban singhs". I can't speak for all the sangat that attends the Gurdwara Sahib but most do know that vinegar should not be used. If someone does use it, it is out of ignorance and not the rule.

Re: Vinegar!!

khalistani · 08 Jan 2006

lool milk has bacteria in it the air u breathe has life in it, microogranisms this is when the shabvads by guru nanak dev je on hyporcrisyt are reaaly intrsting if u drink vinegar u tellin me im gonna get drunk? wa bout the medicnes u take wa the hell u think they are DRUUGGS bhang and all this stuff is all drugs only thing is bhang is outlawed and asprin is not bhang will have a lopt of the same effects as asprin, the only thing asprin has better is it thins ure blood out stop breathing IT PAAP:o bhula chuka maf

Re: Vinegar!!

Singh · 08 Jan 2006

khalistani you think it is ok to use a substance which has small amounts of alcohol because you wont get drunk. going by this logic is it acceptable to add small amounts of low alcohol content beer or other types of alcohol to cooking? many gora's add rum, etc for taste. if it wouldnt get you drunk, is it ok? you clearly may choose not to follow strict bibek but have some respect for those who do.

Re: Vinegar!!

... · 08 Jan 2006

Khalistani, if you smoke one cigarette will you be intoxicated? How about a VERY small dose of Bacardi? One beer? There's a difference between medicine and recreational use. I don't think vinegar is alcoholic and I believe it all evapourates in cooking anyways, but your logic is wrong. Are you advocating the use of bhang? Are you going to compare the twice daily use of bhang amongst nihangs to using aspirin? I can understand if someone has an injury and is in pain, but using it like them twice a day doesn't make any sense. At any rate, even if vinegar doesn't give alcohol into the food, it isn't bibeki so it isn't used. Breathing: the kurehit is kuthaa or eating slaughtered meat. Breathing in bacteria, etc. is not a Kurehit.

Re: Vinegar!!

singh · 08 Jan 2006

"if you smoke one cigarette will you be intoxicated? " yes actually you would. lol thats the point.lol muppet

Re: Vinegar!!

cyber singh · 08 Jan 2006

....theres a difference between chemical 'alcohol' and alcohol that makes you drunk. alcohol is something that has an Oxygen and hydrogen group. your own body makes alcohol in many reactions that are essential to the body. so the question is , does vinegar contain chemicals with OH groups or does it contain drinking alcohol. alcohol that is for intoxication is fermented using yeast i believe. i doubt vinegar contains this kind of alcohol.. the blanket term 'alcohol' is ignorant

Re: Vinegar!!

relaxsingh · 16 Jan 2006

Author... and co, Where does it say in Gurbani that ALCOHOL is against Sikhi Maryada??? It clearly explainsto us that 'dont consume anything which with alter your mental state - or don't consume anything which will put you in a state where you cannot keep control over yourself'... So tell me, will vinegar get you drunk?? I think this is ridiculous.... Its purely used in small small doses to flavour food, not to get drunk on it!!! Take a chill pill (unless you think thats a drug too) and do some more SEVA SIMRAN ,,,, thats what Sikhi is all about. Respect to Singh and CYber Singh! Akaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaal!

Re: Vinegar!!

Information · 16 Jan 2006

Thank you Sangat Jee for all your responses. I have spoken to several Sikhs who are from a scientific background and they also say the alcohol used in Vinegar is different to that normally drunk by people. However is it OK to use Cider Vinegar and white wine vinegar? the only reason I have asked this as I came across these words and wanted to know if they contain alcohol or is vinegar made from apples and grapes.

Re: Vinegar!!

?? · 16 Jan 2006

I think I have heard of this also

Re: Vinegar!!

singh · 16 Jan 2006

alcohol in any quantity is not gurmat however research carried out by the great professor mow shows that vinegar does in fact contain no alcohol as it is all evaporated

Re: Vinegar!!

Jj · 16 Jan 2006

but even though its evaporated the fact that it was there should put you off having it!!

Re: Vinegar!!

ekta · 16 Jan 2006

Honestly, I think the biggest thing is for sikhs to ge an education in general... Back in da day.....daroo/sharaab was a drink that got u intoxicated.... in scientific lingo......the intoxicating agent is a type of alcohol.... there are more then one type...only one gets u drunk...so the rest are NOT anti-gurmat... KHALISTANI HIT THE NAILONTHE HEAD NO WHERE DOES IT SAY ALCOHOL...IN THE CHEMICAL SENSE IS ANTI-GURMAT..SO PLEASE PPL EDUCAE UR SELF AND STOP BEING SO BLOODY IGNORANT.

Re: Vinegar!!

professor MOW! · 16 Jan 2006

the vinegar only has no alcohol if you boil it for a period of time first but for bibekis such as O i dont think its counts as bibek

Re: Vinegar!!

hjdsffd · 28 Jan 2006

wen u cook sumthing, the alcohol evaporates. So lets say u add vanilla extract to the chocolate chip cookies u makin (Yummy!:P lol), the vanilla extract ingredient list says "alcohol." So even if the alcohol evaporates, does that count as a bujjer kurahit? I kno that bibekees shouldnt eat it, but moorakhs like me r not bibekee, yet. Hopefulkly with Guroo Jees Kirpaa i soon wil b. :) Bhull CHuk Maph

Re: Vinegar!!

uhh · 28 Jan 2006

vinegar is a biproduct of teh process of making alcohol. distilled vinegar is chemically made only for the purpose of being PURE vinegar. others, such as white wine vinegar, is a biproduct of making white wine, same with red whine etc. balsalmic on the other hand uses the same wine making process but only for the sole purpose of making balsalmic vinegar and the alcohol is a biproduct which is removed. but other vinegars such as rum vinegar, cider vinegar, red whine vinegar, champagne vinegar etc are biproducts of making those alcohol products.

Re: Vinegar!!

kaur · 29 Jan 2006

Why the heck would you want to consume vinegar? It's not an essential nutrient for our body. At my University, they use vinegar to clean the washrooms because it's an environmentally friendly antimicrobial agent! Other than medical purposes, the use of vinegar should be limited. I know that some health care practitioners prescribe apple cider vinegar to stimulate gastric acid secretions prior to meals. It's found in a variety of pharmaceuticals as well. Some forms can be toxic to breath let alone eat! I say keep away! [%sig%]

Re: Vinegar!!

khalistani · 29 Jan 2006

man dont get all craz vinergar isnt a paap it will not ge tu drunk dont get too craz here if ure gonna go THA bibeki, find out wa molucuiles make up alacahol, and dont eat anythin witht hiose molcules either take it to the next level ektha made a good point theres abig difference between vinegar and bacardi drink bacardi and it WILL get u drunklol so will one cigartee thas its POINT to get u DRUNK now when u show me someone who will get drunk by drinkin vinegar then u got a point bhula chuka maf

Re: Vinegar!!

LK · 30 Jan 2006

****** khalistani you think it is ok to use a substance which has small amounts of alcohol because you wont get drunk. going by this logic is it acceptable to add small amounts of low alcohol content beer or other types of alcohol to cooking? many gora's add rum, etc for taste. if it wouldnt get you drunk, is it ok? ******* It's the intention - why do you smoke, why do you drink rum or beer - to get high. The point of vinegar is NOT to get HIGH. Alcohole can be found in medicine, and it actually USED as medicine. Some alcohole used for health reasons is ethanol (sharab) again it's ther intention - if you do it to get high then ...

Re: Vinegar!!

amarjeet singh · 30 Jan 2006

oh so khalistani if u dont get drunk by it, its alrite. so i off pop down the pub tonite and ask the bar tender jus to giv me some beer but not enuff 2 make me drunk, is this graet?

Re: Vinegar!!

khalistani · 30 Jan 2006

i dunt understand amarjeet singh je i dunt think u understand the point of alcahol in the bars its to gt u DRUNK thasthe POINT there is no well if i go and have jusssst enough it dont work like tha please read my post again theres no point in rewriting everything:) bhula chuka maf