Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

confused · 10 Jan 2006

WahiGuru Ji Ka Khalsa WahiGuru Ji Ki Fateeh! I am really confused. I wanted to know if I can eat nuts that have been already salted? Because I don't know who salted it. Would that stop the bibek rehat? Please help. confused bibeki WahiGuru Ji Ka Khalsa WahiGuru Ji Ki Fateeh!

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

... · 10 Jan 2006

Most bibekis do not eat already salted nuts. Usually these nuts have been roasted (out of shell) before hand as well which is also not acceptable. It's just as easy to buy nuts that are unsalted.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

H · 10 Jan 2006

heh? jus eat daal if your gonna be this fussy

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Admin · 10 Jan 2006

We deleted some messages accidently. Please repost them. Admin.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Jagbir Singh · 10 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh From what little bit knowledge I have, salted, roasted etc. type of nuts are not bibek. It is best to buy raw nuts, wash them properly and then do whatever you want to do with them yourself, ie, roast them, put salt etc. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

confused · 11 Jan 2006

So I shouldnt eat salted ones... i got another question. What bout milk? Do I have to get milk from a bibeki? I dont' think buying milk from outside is good, because people who smoke and drink handle that milk. And what about buying flour from outside? Should I get the grains and make my own flour? That would be bibeki right? I'm sorry I just don't know how far to go. Thank you for your patience with me. WahiGuru Ji Ka Khalsa WahiGuru Ji Ki Fateeh!

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

vaja blaster · 11 Jan 2006

conventional salt contains lot sodium bad for body. use rock salt from health shops much better

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

singh · 11 Jan 2006

salt is bibek so are nuts roasted nuts arent get milk from cow flours is dry, so bibek

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

confused · 11 Jan 2006

Thank you for the replies. But these items are handled by non-amritdharis, this does not make it bibek. What should i do?

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

???? · 11 Jan 2006

confused veerji/penji There are other threads on using milk as a bibeki as well just do a search. Practically all the dry, raw food is handled by non-amrithdharis before being cooked, therefore when you cook it in sarblo or without if not sarbloi but bibeki with naam simran then it has a difference. However as you prb have the knowledge that food cooked in sarblo also has a difference due to it passing through tat. Also that does not mean we should bye all pre-prepared dry foods and cook them in sarblo. i.e soya beans, pasta and so on.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

huh · 11 Jan 2006

but all nuts come in some kinda shell and you crack the shell to get da nuts. don't buy nuts that don't come inna shell. u all got no clue n no proof what wuz done 2 doze nuts before you eat them. dey taste betta anyway when u crack dem all yourself.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

akjuksingh · 16 Jan 2006

from reading bhai sahibs autobiography i have gathered the following info on bibek - food which does not comtain moisture like sugar, salt, flour, etc do NOT become jhoot, therefore are acceptable even if handled by non amritdharees. fruit, vege and nuts in whole natural form do NOT become jhoot, but do become jhoot if cut/prepared. milk and water become jhoot if handled by non amritdharees, therefore milk should be collected from a farm, and water from a spring/well.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Harcharan Singh · 16 Jan 2006

Dear AKJUK SINGH ji, It's a bit difficult to access a spring/well and a farm in Central London, and probably any other big city. How would you suggest these "bibeki" Sikhs obtain water and milk? Milk is an interesting topic in the west. Cows are kept in horrible high production factory farming units, there are constantly artificially impregnated from puberty, and thus have short life spans, they give birth continouesly. Cows udders become freakishly huge due to this unnatural life, and many cows develop all types of problems. As soon as the cow gives birth, the calf is taken away so that the cow can be impregnated again, and the calf is usually killed for beef, some females are kept to continue the milk business. This is a far cry from the respect and family love cows used to receive in Punjab in the old days, when they were appreciated for their milk. Would you say it is Sikh like to use milk from such a cruel source, and please do not give the example of 1 farm out of 10,000 that lets it cows graze in beautiful meadows. The world is not what it used to be. I think the treatment of the animal and compassionate ethics should be the no 1 factor in deciding where to procure goods from. Same goes for organic food. Should we not use naturally grown healthy fruit and vegetables instead of pesticide, insecticide, fertilizer, steroid injected products that we use in most homes and Gurdwarai today? There are many places in Punjab where drinking water and food is giving rise to many problems/cancers etc due to its high chemical content thanks to high production farming. Before we talk about "how" to cook the food or "what" to cook it in, I think we should consider our ethics, our health, the health animals and the health of the planet. Sat Sri Akaal. Harcharan Singh

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

akjuksingh · 18 Jan 2006

there are several places where you can collect, water from you just have to look around, (eg) youve heard of malvern spring water right? well you can go to the spring and collect from there. milk can be collected from bulk containers on farms, before its handled physically. lol have you visited many farms? from the sounds of it you havnt, cows are not continually impregnated as far as i know, they are injected with hormones to stimulate milk production, but im not 100%, i will double check. anyway you are going offpoint, whether you colloect milk from farm before its handled, or you get it from the supermarket, either way the cow has been treated badly (according to you), what im saying is 2 wrongs dont make a right, just cause the cow is treated bad, dont mean its ok to drink milk handled by smokers adulterers etc and from what ive seen on farms cows are treated very well, i dont know where you got youre info from.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

akjuksingh · 18 Jan 2006

It's a bit difficult to access a spring/well and a farm in Central London, and probably any other big city. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- who said bibek is easy, effort is what is rewarded.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Harcharan Singh · 18 Jan 2006

akjuk Singh, I have friends in France who own dairy farms who I have visited and stayed with. I have also done research on this subject. Many organic producers are also far from innocent. We as a community live in complete blind ignorence on this subject. Sarbloh is meaningless if the product being used has cruelty and blood in it's veins. I did not say it was ok to drink milk from people with no suchm, my point was there is a more important underlying issue to consider before even attaining the product. I can send you plenty of research, how much time have you got? I would suggest that you do some research yourself. Here is a start, please read it: The Dirt on Dairy Published 09/15/03 Source: Animal Issues, Volume 34 Number 3, Fall 2003 A Dairy Diary The modern-day dairy cow suffers greatly during her unnaturally short life. Her home is most often an overcrowded dirt lot, where she may be forced to stand in fetid pools of mud, urine, and manure. Fed from a trough, she rarely, if ever, sees a pasture. Each year she is forcefully inseminated so that she will conceive and give birth — a prerequisite for lactation. Her calf will be taken from her within hours of delivery; for days, she may bellow frantically in search of her baby. During her ten-month lactation period, machines will drain her of ten to twenty times the amount of milk her calf would suckle. If her calf is male, he will probably be thrown in a truck and sent to auction soon after he is born. If he survives this ordeal, he is likely sold to a veal operation. For the duration of his short life, he will be confined to a tiny crate that prevents almost all movement. He will be fed a meager, iron-poor diet so that his flesh will remain pale, the way “fine diners” prefer. A female calf will not fare much better. In most cases, she will remain on the farm to replace her mother or some other worn-out milk producer. A dairy cow might be injected with a variety of substances that then make their way into the human food supply. She may receive injections of synthetic hormones that increase her milk supply by an additional 30 percent. As a result, she will be chronically hungry and prone to mastitis — a painful udder infection that afflicts up to 75 percent of dairy cows. She will probably also receive large doses of antibiotics before she is butchered. A cow who becomes ill in modern dairy operations often suffers greatly before she is noticed and treated (or killed). According to Bill Bickert, an agricultural engineer at Michigan State University, “The large-scale dairy can result in a lack of attention to detail when it comes to procedures and individual cow care.” Dairy expert John Kirk, DVM, of the University of California at Davis, stated in a lecture last year [2002] that at least 20 to 25 percent of cows in dairy herds experience painful lameness. After years of cycling through continuous pregnancies, births, and lactations, a cow’s milk production will begin an irreversible decline and she will be “culled” from the herd. In California today, the average productive life for a dairy cow is a mere 2.4 lactations (starting at age 2) before she is sent to slaughter, even though she has a potential lifespan of 20 or more years. Nearly 15 percent of all beef consumed in the U.S. consists of the bodies of slaughtered dairy cows. Mega-Dairies, Mega-Destruction Not only are modern-day dairy practices inhumane to animals, they are dangerous to the planet. Large dairies containing many thousands of cows are increasingly common and are particularly hazardous to the environment. “Mega-dairies” are becoming the norm in California, which leads the nation in dairy production. In 2000, the state’s 2,195 dairies churned out 32 billion gallons of milk, or about 18 percent of the U.S.’s supply. Because the cost of land in California is generally very high, most dairies located there keep the maximum number of cows in the minimum amount of space. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), between 1993 and 1998, the average number of cows per dairy in California nearly doubled; in 2000, the state had 1.5 million dairy cows. The environmental havoc mega-dairies have wreaked in California should serve as warning to other states not yet as severely impacted, since the growth of large operations there merely reflects a national trend toward more concentrated operations. The EPA defines “large” dairies as those housing 700 or more cows, but many “mega-dairies” confine several thousand animals in a small area. These operations are a common point source of both water and air pollution, which fall unevenly across the region in which the dairies operate. The EPA's 2002 Progress Report for the Pacific Southwest Region illustrates the damaging effects of the waste produced at large-scale dairy operations. According to the report, “each cow produces about 120 pounds of wet manure per day.” A 1,000-cow dairy will produce the same amount of waste as a city of 20,000 people, with no sewage treatment. These outsized quantities of manure can contaminate rivers and groundwater supplies, including sources of drinking water for humans. Water pollution from dairies occurs in a number of different ways, from slow continuous leaking of manure-laced runoff into groundwater, to untimely rain after the application of manure to a field, to breaks or overflows in “lagoons” built to hold vast amounts of waste. According to the EPA, dairy waste pollutes waters with “nutrients (e.g., nitrate, phosphorous), organic matter, sediments ... heavy metals, hormones, antibiotics and ammonia” deadly to fish and aquatic ecosystems. The EPA also warns of “public health threats” caused by microorganisms in animal wastes, such as E. coli, salmonella, and cryptosporidium, which, when they enter the human drinking water supply, can cause serious illness or death. In 1998, the California Water Resources Control Board listed the water quality of 9 rivers and 49 ground water basins in the state as impaired by waste from animal operations, particularly dairies. Pollution is not the only impact on local water supplies. Dairy farms are also intensive users of water. For example, The Heritage Dairy, a hotly-contested 6,000-cow facility recently given permission to operate in Dixon, CA (see sidebar) will consume approximately 9 million gallons of well water each year. With droughts and development already putting water supplies in jeopardy, the country can ill afford to pump vast quantities of this resource into the ballooning dairy industry. The Air We Breathe Of all environmental impacts created by mega-dairies, air pollution generally imposes the most immediate problem for the community. Dairy workers and those living near dairies frequently report adverse health effects from exposure to animal waste. People who experience prolonged exposure to dairy-related pollutants are vulnerable to respiratory illness, lung inflammation, and asthma, according to the EPA. The agency also states that “odorous and potentially toxic gases, such as sulfur dioxide, produced by the decomposition of animal wastes, may also cause nausea, headaches, and throat and eye irritation.” Recently, three men at two different dairies in California died when they were overcome by toxic fumes from liquefied manure, fell into manure holding tanks, and drowned. Dairy facilities also contribute to other air quality problems by introducing dust, smog, and greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. For example, manure lagoons are a major source of methane, a potent greenhouse gas that contributes to global warming. According to the EPA, the world’s livestock herds and waste lagoons comprise the largest source (30 percent) of human-induced emissions of methane. Emissions from dairies and other animal feeding operations also play a role in the formation of ozone (smog) and other pollutants that pose a danger to public health and that are regulated by the Clean Air Act. High ozone levels can also reduce crop yields and make plants more vulnerable to disease. In California’s Central Valley, a largely agricultural region in which ozone and particular matter often exceed national health standards, state projections show that animal waste is on track to become one of the largest sources of smog within the next three years. Dust and dried manure particles kicked up by cows on crowded feedlots also contribute to air pollution. According to a May 15, 2002 article in the Los Angeles Times, the particulates in cow excrement carried downwind from dairies in Chino contribute to “some of the worst particle air pollution in the nation.” Moreover, in the American Lung Association's May 2001 report on air pollution, California counties receiving a grade of “F” for air quality included all the major dairy-producing counties: Fresno (105 dairies), Kern (33 dairies), Kings (151 dairies), Madera (46 dairies), Merced (313 dairies), Riverside (109 dairies), Sacramento (55 dairies), San Bernardino (193 dairies), San Joaquin (151 dairies), Stanislaus (305 dairies), and Tulare (236 dairies) (1998 dairy statistics from the California Department of Agriculture). Until 2002, factory farms were exempt from clean air requirements in California because of a long-standing legal loophole that was closed only after community groups, including Medical Alliance for Healthy Air, Communities for a Better Environment, and the Natural Resources Defense Council, filed suit. A recent study by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS), however, reveals that regulation of air quality problems arising from factory farms is a tricky endeavor. According to the NAS, “Because the Clean Air Act and its regulations generally rely on objective measures of pollutants, the regulatory process has not been effective in controlling odors, which are difficult to measure objectively.” In other words, permitting mega-dairies and other industrial-sized farms under the Clean Air Act will do little to protect the community (including humans, wildlife, and domestic animals) from air quality problems associated with factory farming. Ironically, while communities suffer from the impacts of industrial-sized dairies, and cows suffer from the effects of overcrowding and forced milk stimulation, the dairy industry itself is experiencing economic hardship due to overproduction: Because supplies are abundant, farmers receive lower prices for the milk they produce. State and federal subsidies, which encourage even greater milk output, only exacerbate the problem — at the taxpayers’ expense. In California, for example, the state plans to pay dairy farmers up to $45 million over a 12-month period in the form of agricultural subsidies. Even some in the dairy industry point out the illogic of using tax dollars to pay farmers for overproduction. Rachel Kaldor, Executive Director of the Dairy Institute in Sacramento, told The Sacramento Bee earlier this year, “We have so much extra milk right now ... and we know as sure as the sun will rise tomorrow that when you give dairymen or anyone else more money for their product, they will make more.” It’s a costly, destructive cycle that shows no sign of slowing. Healthier Humans Fortunately, not only do numerous dairy alternatives exist, they are increasing in popularity — and for good reason. Research shows that dairy products supply about one-third of the saturated fat found in the typical American diet; saturated fat raises “bad” cholesterol levels in the blood more than other forms of fat. Residues from the hormones and antibiotics fed to many dairy cows also threaten human health. Further, according to a recent study published in the journal Nature Genetics, between 30 million and 50 million North Americans, including 75 percent of African-Americans and 90 percent of Asian-Americans, are lactose intolerant and frequently experience nausea, cramps, bloating, gas, and diarrhea after ingesting dairy foods. Despite the dairy industry’s attempts to peddle the image of milk and milk-based products as “health foods,” the truth is, a dairy-free diet may be a better bet, nutritionally speaking. “But what about calcium?” is a question commonly posed to those who choose not to eat dairy. Although the public largely associates calcium with dairy this essentially nutrient is actually present in many non-dairy products, such as leafy green vegetables, fortified orange juice and soy beverages, dried figs, and enriched wheat flour. In fact, the calcium in leafy greens (with the exception of spinach and collard greens) is often more plentiful and better absorbed than the calcium in dairy products, and contains no cholesterol or saturated fat. Additionally, unlike dairy foods, vegetables contain beneficial phytochemicals and are loaded with fiber. Moreover, while dairy products do contain calcium, there is no evidence that milk consumption prevents osteoporosis, as the milk industry often implies. In fact, documented evidence now suggests that the opposite may be true. A 1998 study published by the Journal of the American Dietetic Association revealed that vegan women did not have lower bone density than vegetarian women despite the fact that the vegan women consumed no dairy products and had lower intakes of calcium. The reason for this may be that reducing calcium loss is more important than levels of calcium intake. Diets high in protein, particularly animal protein, appear to increase the loss of calcium through the urine and lead to a weakening of the bones. Another recent study (in which two API staff participated) further supports the benefits of a dairy-free diet. Researchers at the University of California at Davis, exploring the relationship between osteoporosis and diet, compared women who eat both animal and plant foods to women who only eat plant-derived foods. Their results indicated that rates of bone resorption — in which calcium is leached from bones into the bloodstream — were the same in the omnivore women and the vegan women. Bone formation rates, however, were significantly lower in the women who ate animal products, indicating a possible association between omnivorous diets and lower bone densities. Dairy products also appear to increase vulnerability to cancer. According to a study published in the July 16, 2003 edition of the Journal of the National Cancer Institute found that premenopausal women aged 26-46 who eat red meat and high-fat dairy foods, such as cheese, may be at greater risk for breast cancer than those whose fats come primarily from plant sources. This is not the first time that animal products have been implicated in contributing to certain cancers. A report published in the January 2001 American Journal of Clinical Nutrition linked eating meat with certain cancers and found colon cancer to be most strongly correlated with a meat-heavy diet. A 1997 report by the American Institute for Cancer Research and the world Cancer Research Fund concluded that vegetarians have decreased rates of several kinds of cancer, due to their larger intake of plant foods. If we choose to listen, there is a clear message to be heard in the results of these health studies, in the suffering of the cows exploited in dairy production, and in the environmental harm dairies cause to our air, soil, and water: For the sake of animals, people, and the planet, don’t buy dairy! If you would like more information on healthy and humane nutrition, download a free copy of API’'s “Going Veggie: A Beginner’s Guide,” or visit www.ChooseVeggie.com. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Community Fights Mega-dairy Invasion When a 6,000-cow mega-dairy was allowed to move in next door to the small town of Dixon, CA, without an environmental review or public input, API sprang into action. API joined forces with Viva!, Animal Place, The Association of Veterinarians for Animal Rights, and local residents to form the Citizen Action Group Against Mega Dairies. This grassroots coalition demanded that the local government and planning commission listen to the community concerns about the environment, property values, human health, and animal welfare. Many California dairy producers have learned the value of doing business in counties that have no experience with industrial-sized dairies. When land prices or regulatory burdens increase in one area, many dairies opt to pack up and move to a location with cheaper land and minimal or nonexistent regulations. Such was the case in Dixon, a town targeted by two companies experiencing environmental challenges in other California locales. First, in the spring of 2002, The Heritage Dairy, a 6,000-cow operation, relocated to Dixon from Ontario, in southern California. Soon afterward, the Zysling Dairy submitted an application for another 6,000-cow dairy, after facing environmental challenges in Tulare County, CA. Members of the Citizens Group protested to county and city officials, testified at hearings, and alerted the media about the mega-dairies. This public outcry led to more intense scrutiny of the Zysling Dairy, which subsequently withdrew its permit request. After a public workshop conducted at the request of the Citizen Group, county officials are now considering a moratorium on large dairies in the county until studies are done to determine whether the impacts of such facilities can be mitigated. By joining stakeholders together to educate the public, lobby decision-makers, and voice residents’ concerns, the Citizens Group can serve as an inspiration for other communities challenging the presence of mega-dairies and other dangerous businesses in their area.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

MOW! · 18 Jan 2006

mr harcharan singh please refrain from abusing these cows

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

... · 19 Jan 2006

harcharan singh, i dont understand what you are trying to say, can you just summarise.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Harcharan Singh · 19 Jan 2006

I am simply raising the issue of healthy sustenance, be it food or milk. We are so obsessed with Sarbloh maryada (which is fine), that we actually don't question the origin of our food. I have highlighted the cruelty that todays cows endure and the unnatural life they are forced to live, alongside the ritual slaughter of calves to feed teh beef market. Insecticide, pesticide, chemical fertiliser, steriod injected fruit and vegetables are also not good for the health, which can be seen in the many villages n Punjab where people are now suffering ill health. Point is simple, these issues should be resolved 1st alongside promoting Sarbloh maryada in Gurdwarai and Sikh homes. Our langars are providing milk and food that is produced from cruelty and greed (mass production) and which ultimately are not good for the sangats health. Alongside the benefits of Sarbloh, Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj expected Sikhs to have common sense, one is useless without the other. MOW, not sure what you mean, you seem a very confused individual, go take a cold shower. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

akjuksingh · 19 Jan 2006

ok, why didnt you just say that in the first place. i cant see how you can use youre argument to justify not doing sarbloh bibek. all we can do is try our best, yeah fair enough cows should be treated properly, but just cause theyre not dont give you an excuse to criticise sarbloh bibek, or sarbloh bibekis.

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

Harcharan Singh · 19 Jan 2006

To clarify and conclude: I wasn't critising Sarbloh Bibek; I was saying that Sarbloh Bibek is meaningless unless the food/milk used in it is of pure quality and honest/healthy/harmless derivation also, they go hand in hand, the purity of the food and of the utensils. Apologies for leaving my post open ended - I should have also proposed a solution alongside identifying thr problem: Proposal: At the very least, could the sangat please try there very best to speak to the management of their respective local Gurdwarai and try to persuade them to use organic milk and organic fruit and vegetables. This would ensure we are providing the purest, natural, healthy food in Guru Ji's holy langar, rather than ignorently derived, cheap, blood stained, unhealthy alternatives. This is the least respect we can give our Guru Ji for giving us the greatest charitable institution on earth, and the least care we can provide for teh sangats worldwide. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan Singh

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

... · 19 Jan 2006

harcharan singh - "Before we talk about "how" to cook the food or "what" to cook it in, I think we should consider our ethics, our health, the health animals and the health of the planet." so what do you propose stop using milk fulstop? health of the planet?? do you drive a car? use buses? trains? these are all bad for the planet. do you use electricity at home? why dont you go everywhere by bicycle/ walking, its better for the planet. are you trying to say looking after the planet is more important than following rehit, eg) would you refuse to drive to a water spring to collect water in sarbloh, because the car journey polutes the environment? what are you trying to say? whats this got to do with the discussion on bibek?

Re: Should we eat nuts that have been salted?

... · 19 Jan 2006

Sarbloh Bibek is meaningless unless the food/milk used in it is of pure quality and honest/healthy/harmless derivation also, they go hand in hand, the purity of the food and of the utensils. i wouldnt say its meaningless, if theres no other option/ nowhere else to get milk from then we can only do with what we've got.