Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gurbani and our Gurus

Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 13 Jan 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is incorporated with the hymns (Baanee) from many enlightened beings as Kabir Ji, Namdev Ji, Jaidev Ji, Pipa Ji, Sain Ji, Ravidas Ji, Farid Ji and others. For Sikhs Baanee is Guru and Guru is Baanee. Do all God beings, whose Baanee is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, become automatically our Gurus? Please express your views. Balbir Singh

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

LionKing (LK) · 13 Jan 2006

Their bani is as much of Shabad Guru as anyone else's Bani. as of if they personally are Guru's can be discussed for years without any conclusion. The bottom line is that Shabad Guru is the Guru, and Sikhs will not accept any other bani of i.e Kabeer ji or Namdev ji outside of Guru ji's saroop, as they constantly developed spiritually, and it wasn't before their were "spritually mature" that their Bani (which wasn't even their, but it was dhurkibani now, as they did not exist any more. They completly siezed to exist. It was "tuhi tuhi mohina". There was no mai.) The Bani physically written by them is the Bani of Vaheguru and thus the same as any other Bani/Shabad in Maharaj. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 13 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and LionKing Ji! You wrote "as of if they personally are Guru's can be discussed for years without any conclusion." Have I understood you correctly? It cannot be concluded that the writers of Gurbani are our Gurus personally. You wrote in the upper lines "The bottom line is that Shabad Guru is the Guru, and Sikhs will not accept any other bani of i.e Kabeer ji or Namdev ji outside of Guru ji's saroop" The topic here is about Baanee from Kabir Ji or Namdev Ji inside of Guru Ji's Saroop. Do you want to say that only Baanee from them is Dhur Ki Baanee that is included in Sri Guru Granth Ji? But rest all what they spoke in life was not Dhur Ki Baanee? Your last sentence is "The Bani physically written by them is the Bani of Vaheguru and thus the same as any other Bani/Shabad in Maharaj." Is the Baanee that is physically spoken apart from the written by them, not God's Baanee? Is 'Dhur Ki Baanee' of Vaheguru only that what is written? Please elaborate. Balbir Singh

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

ks · 14 Jan 2006

this has a very simple answer: there are other shabads of the kabir/namdev/* which were not included. They were not because the Gurus did not believe those shabads were in line with the teachings of Sikhi. Now, if you want to consider these bhagats your guru, just remember that our Gurus rejected certain works from them.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Jan 2006

Pray TRUTH to all and Bulah Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh to all. Guru Arjun Ji/Guru Gobind Singh Ji prepared the Birr of Guru Garanth ji..and GURU GRANTH JI was the GURU bestowed Gurgadhi by Guru Gobind Singh ji. Therefore every single word inside Guru Granth ji is DHUR KI BANEE ayee tin saglee chint mitayee. Guru Granth Ji is our One and Only SHABAD GURU today....and it is the GURBANI that is SHABAD GURU..not Kabir Ji or Namdev Ji..or anyone else for that matter. It is pointless argument simialr to rirrking water to bring in questions like...when Kabir Ji asked his wife to make roti....is THAT "GURBANI" ?? or when Guru nanak ji requested his Mehl to bring him a towel...is "THAT" Gurbani dhur ki banee ?? etc etc. ONLY what GURU JI bothered to RECORD with their own Hast kamals is GURBANI......and "all that" is recorded inside the 1429 aangs of Guru Granth ji. Period. Guru Ji didnt bother to "sing" at his elder son's birth, or sing at his wedding, or "record" all those mundane words of everyday life....BUT when DHUR KI BANEE ayee..Guru Ji would tell Mardana......Mardania chherr rabab...banee ayee eh..and Guru Ji would duly WRITE all that DOWN in His Kitaab. There are a lot of people today who are trying to bring "doubts" regarding Gurbani in Guru Granth Ji and trying to "authenticate" other writings OUTSIDE Guru Granth ji..by bringing up such theories...."didnt Kabir Ji write MUCH MORE than what is inside Guru granth ji ?? Why isnt all that also GURBANI ?? Why did Guru Arjun ji leave all out ?? Why didnt Guru gobind Singh ji include all his own Gurbani...??? etc etc. We have the Final "bound Volume" before us and we BOW to the GURU GRANTH JI....ours is NOT to QUESTION WHY? WHEN? WHY NOT ? That is the way of the "saboteur" looking to destroy the unshakeable FAITH of the SIKH in His GURU. There are many such in Sikh disguise also seeking to popularise..for example..Baba Sri Chand's "Gurpurab" ( since when is baba sri chand ji a guru to have a gurpurab ??)...or make "gurpurabs" out of Guru nanak Ji's Wedding, Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Baraat chharrnee, etc etc. We have enough genuine GURPURABS....no need to invent new ones. Boleh so Nihal Sat Sri Akal Say Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 14 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji! Thanks for your views about the topic. You wrote "Guru Granth Ji is our One and Only SHABAD GURU today....and it is the GURBANI that is SHABAD GURU..not Kabir Ji or Namdev Ji..or anyone else for that matter." Do you celebrate birthdays of Guru Nanak Ji, Guru Gobind Singh Ji and other Gurus? Or do you celebrate the birthday of the SHABAD GURU? Balbir Singh

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 14 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and ks Ji! You mentioned "Now, if you want to consider these bhagats your guru, just remember that our Gurus rejected certain works from them." Please say something about the original question "Do all God beings, whose Baanee is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, become automatically our Gurus?" I do not know where our Gurus rejected certain works from the Bhagats whose Baanee is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Please provide some references. I will be grateful. Balbir Singh

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Jan 2006

Say TRUTH and Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh Balbir Singh jio, You ask.. Please say something about the original question "Do all God beings, whose Baanee is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, become automatically our Gurus?" >>>>>>> IS the "presence of Gurbani" the only criteria you consider as "certificate" for Guru ?? Guru Hargobind Ji, Guru Har rai Ji, Guru har Krishan Ji and Guru Gobind Singh ji DONT have a single panktee in Guru Granth ji. Yet they are all "Guru" as at one material time their human deh had been bestowed Gurgadhi and kept this jyot until passing on. Now this Ilahi JYOT NANAK resides in GURU GRANTH JI. You have also asked me whether i celebrate the Gurpurabs of Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh ji....and Gurpurab of Guru granth Ji. What a question. The Nanaksahi Calendar has clearly spelt out which Days the Gurpurabs of the Sikh Gurus are celebrated. The Gurpurabs connected with the SHABAD GURU Guru granth ji are listed as Pehla Parkash Diwas and Gurgadhi Diwas. I CELEBRATE ALL these Gurpurabs. Please do get a copy of the nanakshai Calendar from your nearest Gurdawra. ( I can send you one if you provide me postal address) Say TRUTH and only Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 15 Jan 2006

Jarnail Singh Gyani 'Arshi' Simply you are great. Bravo. Nice.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 15 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji! Thanks for your suggestion. I have gone through the Nanakshahi calendar. I could not find the birthday of the Shabad Guru mentioned in it. Perhaps those, who come to know the Shabad Guru, alone are aware of His birth and celebrate it. Still, it is great to hear you saying 'Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh'. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

ks · 15 Jan 2006

"balbir singh", are you telling me I need to explicitly answer your questions, that you know not of inference? 1. no. 2. are you telling me you don't know of the other works of the bhagats? Well, there are. You can find books about them in any respectable library.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 15 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and ks Ji! It looks like you have very valuable information but you do not want to share those with the Sikh world. Please do not close your fist and put it in the pockets of your trousers in a mysterious way. You made many curious. Now you are suggesting all to read books when asked what have you pretend to say. Forums for Sikhs are to exchange truthful views about Sikhi to destroy the orthodoxy, in my view. Should we give a list of questions to our younger generation what they are allowed to ask? It is strange that some of us feel so shaky when even basic questions are asked. I feel Sikhi is not collecting information about the past and present of Sikhs alone as some of the Sikh web sites and writers are working hard for. Sikhi is to enliven the truth of Simran. I started bringing impulses on forums which my near and dear youngsters raised. I hope and pray our youths can reveal all the wisdom of our Gurus and live as a true Sikh. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

ks · 16 Jan 2006

this is silly! you expect me to do your *basic* research!? there is no special hidden information that tells us that the bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib wrote other shabads. This is information available upon the most cursory of investigations into bhagat kabir or sheik farid. I'm fairly sure english isn't your first language, but here's a tip: try not to use such flowery language. I mean, "Please do not close your fist and put it in the pockets of your trousers in a mysterious way." That's just gross.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

Balbir Singh Ji..you wrote: I have gone through the Nanakshahi calendar. I could not find the birthday of the Shabad Guru mentioned in it. >>>>>>>>>> I am sure you wont find that....its PARKASH DIWAS...of Shabad Guru and Guur Khalsa Panth. "Shabd Guru" is AAD GURU....NO "human Birthdays"....and of course no DEH, no baths, no feeling cold/hot/tired/sleepy/needs rest etc etc. I know a lot of so called "shardhaloos" who like to treat Shabad Guru like a human deh....but its totally out of sync with reality. Say Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Love Jarnail singh

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 16 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and ks Ji! Please do not deviate from the topic and waste time in researching the origin of my English language. You wrote about Bhagats whose Baanee is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji "just remember that our Gurus rejected certain works from them." Did you write it to express or hide something? -------------- Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji! You wrote <<<"Shabd Guru" is AAD GURU....NO "human Birthdays"....and of course no DEH>>> In a previous post you stressed in Capitol letters about Gurus birthdays "I CELEBRATE ALL these Gurpurabs." Please elaborate why the above statements from you are not contradictory. I feel Shabad Guru takes birth and the true Simran, the Sikh living, begins. Shabad Guru does not take birth by doing Prakash of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

My dearest Balbir Singh Jio, There is NO CONTRADICTION. SHABAD GURU is "AAD GURU" becasue this has EXISTED for FOREVER and will Exist for ever...as such there is NO BIRTH/DEATH of SG..... In the Human Context our GURU JI SAHIBAANS....for the Kaliyaan of Humanity, have brought SHABAD GURU in the Form of written GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB.....this is strictly for HUMANS in this World, and it is based on Human language/grammar/linguistic barriers/limitations/paper/ink etc...this "FORM" of Shabad Guru has a "beginning"..in the writings of Guru nanak Ji...and culminated in the Official Gurgadhee by Guru Gobind Singh ji in 1708. It is simply a ploy and playing with words to "see" contradictions...there are NONE. The EK Oankaar Has NO Birth/Death/no beginning/no end...but I celebrate ALL GURPURABS..of the JYOT of EK Oankaar beginning with Guru nanak Ji ( AAD GURU) to Guru Granth Ji. I hope this elaboration is enough for you. Thank You. and Love Say Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. PS. by the way i "miss" your daily attendance on SPN...

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

ks · 16 Jan 2006

dear english major, rejection is implicit in non-inclusion.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 17 Jan 2006

Satsriakal to all and Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji! Your understanding is "In the Human Context our GURU JI SAHIBAANS....for the Kaliyaan of Humanity, have brought SHABAD GURU in the Form of written GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB" What accompanies a human being when he reaches God? Is this the Shabad Guru or the Form of written GURBANI in GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB? Please guide many further. Thanks for giving me a corner in your heart. Do not miss me searching somewhere else. -------------- ks Ji! Please say some truth in English. Balbir Singh

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

ks · 17 Jan 2006

a tautology for a teutonic prick: you've brought nothing to this discussion, nor have you bothered to read and comprehend what people have wrote. Instead, your mind wanders in muddy waters attempting to see truth where there is only your own empty semantics.

Re: Gurbani and our Gurus

Balbir Singh · 17 Jan 2006

The topic here is 'Gurbani and our Gurus'. I didn't know that exhibitionists also seek a stage here.