classical style or kaachi style
Gurpreet Singh · 13 Jan 2006
A lor of raagis (classical/purataan) style, when they do the shabad hae rav hae sas hae karnaanaid maeree abai baentee sun leejai, many times they say MAEREE ABAI BAENTEE SUN LEEJAI MAHARAAJ.....MAEREE ABAI BAENTEE
now im not sure if this is purataan way of doing this shabad because raagis such as bhai avtaar singh and bhai balbeer singh do it this style and bhai avtaar singh has family raagi lineage going back a long way.
Now what i am wondering if this is purataan style of this shabad?
Is this "kachi bani" or beadbi of bani?
Is this acceptable?
Re: classical style or kaachi style
LionKing (LK) · 14 Jan 2006
I'm sure Bhai Balbir Singh Ji doesn't do that :S, could you please post a link to the Shabad please?
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006
here is the link, you must have realplayer and you can stream the audio of the net
http://www.sikhnet.com/Sikhnet/Music.nsf/ace1374d5dbde2fa8725695300003f04/2209bf38d10ac76887256b5300795d1e!OpenDocument
and for bhai avtar singh doing this shabad like this, i know the recording i have of him doing asa di vaar he does it like this in part 2 of the recording
can someone please answer my question???
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Gurpreet Singh · 14 Jan 2006
i should correct what i said earlier, what they do they is not what i posted but actually
SUN LEEJAI MAHARAJ MAEREE ABAI BAENTEE
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Harcharan Singh · 15 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Veer Gurpreet Ji,
Excuse my ignorence, could you give me the source of this shabad, ang etc..
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Harcharan Singh · 15 Jan 2006
In that case, this is clearly changing Guru Ji's words.
Bhai Avtar and Bhai Balbir Singh Ji are wrong for doing this if they have done it.
Which is a shame because I hold Bhai Balbir Singh Ji in high esteem.
I am sure they will say they add Maharaj out of ras and chaa, but that doesn't make it correct.
Ardaas is different, it is mostly panth made and does already differ amongst people.
Guru's words are perfect, and changing them is paap.
Sat Sri Akaal.
Harcharan Singh
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Gurpreet Singh · 15 Jan 2006
its in dasam granth, i dunno wat ang, use sridasam.org to search it
Re: classical style or kaachi style
LionKing (LK) · 15 Jan 2006
I havn't been able to listen to the recording, but if it is as you say Gurpreet Singh Ji, then I disagree with them adding the word. I too, hold Bhai Balbir Singh ji in high esteem, but yes I disagree with him doing that as well...
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Gurpreet Singh · 15 Jan 2006
its at the start of the recording, after the mangla charan of tum ho sab rajan kae raja, its the first shabad he does
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Gurpreet Singh · 15 Jan 2006
i personally believe both are wrong and shabaxds shouldnt be inserted into other ones and simran should also not be inserted UNLESSS the keertanee gets into so much bairaag they cannot control........but your post really got me thinking................i dont really know anything, who am i to judge, however someone gets anand is good for them, i should probably leave the judging to dharam raj
Re: classical style or kaachi style
Harcharan Singh · 16 Jan 2006
In my opinion, irrelevant of who is singing, which jathaa, which Baba...changing Guru Ji's set shabad is wrong.
Guru ji has clearly laid out how to sing the shabad, which chorus to use, which tune to use, we should not try and improve on Guru's Kirtan, we can't.
This is not to say that all people who have done and still do this do not have good intentions, some do, but many people don't. It's obviously best to work within Guru Ji's hukum.
Sat Sri Akaal