Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Sherbahadar Singh · 15 Jan 2006
WJKK WJKF,
Several of my friends have gone back to Punjab during the summer over the past few years and each one of them tells me things are really bad back home. Some of the things they say are so disturbing that I don't even know whether I should believe them or not.
This summer, after my exams are finished, I'll be going to Punjab for a couple of months to see things for myself. I hope things are not as bad as my friends have described; otherwise, we've all got a much bigger problem than we think.
WJKK WJKF
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Gurpreet Singh · 15 Jan 2006
sher bahadur singh..........vah ji vah......what a name
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Sherbahadar Singh · 16 Jan 2006
WJKK WJKF,
The jist of what I've heard is something like this: there are roday everywhere. The percentage of young keshdari Sikhs is small and the percentage of true Sikhs is extremely small and declining exponentially. Doing hard drugs like pheem, bhang, dhamakhu has gone completely out of control. Just about everywhere you look, there are drug addicts around every corner. And it's not just the guys only; things are just as bad as with the girls. Pre-marital sex is rampant and is spiraling out of control. Prostitution is increasing everywhere, and from what one Gursikh tells me (a very good chardikala friend of mine) these kinds of things are not uncommon in even Amritsar. People everywhere are looking for ways both legal and illegal to get out of Punjab. Everyone cares only about money, everything else (religion, morality, ethics, etc.) has gone out the window.
Sikhism in Punjab is dead.
Sikhism is at the fringe of complete annihilation and it's only a matter of time (if things keep up this way) that we'll be just a relic of the past. I know those are bitter words, but I'm at a deficit when finding appropriate words to describe the situation in Punjab.
Somehow, like some of the other posts have mentioned, we need a new, dynamic, spiritual leader similar to Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale and a massive spiritual lift is required to get things back on track. In the mean time, all we can do is make sure our rehats are in check and do naam simran, panthic seva, and kirtan and hope for the best from Waheguru Ji.
WJKK WJKF
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 16 Jan 2006
looks like you guys have just woken up.This has been going on for the last twenty years.
But sadly, every body speaks of this phantom dream -khalistan!No body is able to explin anything about it, but there is where all energy is going to.NO BODY in PUNJAB has ANY interest in Khalistan, bar the usual die hards in any community.
khalsiatn will not solve any issues of Sikhs.Our Gurduara track records ,if anything to go by, will show the same will happen in any dream khalistan.
The time is to restart sikhi on the scale of Singh sabha lehar.We need to start a Sikh bacho-Paggri sambhalo-lehar chalao.
We ned to strengthen Sikhi and bbringback those who hav e ventured out and spread among the rest of indians...only then will our numbers increase and problems lessen.With increased numbers Khalistan will come much more less persuasively, and far more easily.
At the moment so mucg energy is beong wasted on this phnatom khalistan, that Sikhs are not payting attention to save Sikhi and reiterate the values of Sikhi.
Khalsa ji, drreams are nice for dreaming, Khalistan is a nice dream, but the REALLITY is Sikhi is on the decline and NO BODY PAYS A T*** to that issue!
Stop dreaming and wasting time,, and start Sikhi bachao, paggri sambhalo- lehar chalao.That is the only salavation we have towards Khalistan.With strong Sikhi and larger numbers , Khalistan will fall into our laps!
Sikhs in india are NOT interested in Khalistan, but in Sikhi we can rope them in.
but people are such fools, they will chase after the invisible dream and shy away from the REAL challenge, spread SIKHI!
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006
dont be "fooled" by the long gatras/flowing beards and blue/saffron dastaars either....IF "they are followers of one PARTICULAR SANT-BABA"...and swear by HIS "AMRIT"....then they are that baba's followers and NOT Amrtidharees in the real sense of the word. If you DONT beleive me..see all these so called "Amrtidharees" MATHA TEKING to Sant-Baba Ranjit Singh Dadrianwalla ji on His BIRTHDAY VIDEO....all of them are in LONG GATRAS/flowing BEARDS and all.....BUT they are DISREGARDING GURU JI's EXPLICIT COMMAND to only matha tek to GURU GRANTH JI and NO HUMAN !!!
The DERAS are filled to OVERFLOWING by such "amritdharees"....and many thousands of others who are like Rulda Singh of RSS ( Dastardharee HINDUS ) who have become "sikhs" to take over the Gurdwaras...
SIKHI is NOT in DANGER..SIKHS are !!! The Badals/Tohras are fond of saying Panth in Danger.....it turned out...that the Badals were the ones SINKING the panth's Boat by sitting in it and making holes in its floor ( while wearing RSS Life-Jackets !!!)
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Sherbahadar Singh · 16 Jan 2006
WJKK, WJKF
"SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang":
"looks like you guys have just woken up.This has been going on for the last twenty years."
Thank you for enlightening me Jang Sahib. Perhaps you don't know that I wasn't even born 20 years ago, so excuse me if I was born too late to see things first hand.
"But sadly, every body speaks of this phantom dream -khalistan!No body is able to explin anything about it, but there is where all energy is going to.NO BODY in PUNJAB has ANY interest in Khalistan, bar the usual die hards in any community."
Where in my posts did I even mention Khalistan? Here I was talking about the kinds of things I've heard from my friends about what's going on in Punjab are how the situation seems to be worsening. In the end of my post, I suggested that we "make sure our rehats are in check and do naam simran, panthic seva, and kirtan and hope for the best from Waheguru Ji". You tried to interpolate my thoughts and suggest that I am Khalistani kharkoo, which is incorrect. You took the whole topic out of context.
Here I am, a university moorakh born in a family of moorakhs and now I'm finally starting to undestand my religion and history and the problems we're currently facing as a whole and what I get is your generous bitch-slapping from you. Yeah! Go Sikhism! Thank you Veer Ji, thank you!
I agree with you that Khalistan is merely a pipe dream for the moment and right now, we need to concentrate on our own rehats to make sure we don't fall into the black hole like many others have. On the spiritual level, the Sikhs are not 'Khalis' (pure) enough yet to even think of Khalistan. I agree with your vision of the inception of Khalistan, even though this whole Khalistan issue was not the point of any of my postings.
"but people are such fools, they will chase after the invisible dream and shy away from the REAL challenge, spread SIKHI!"
More mud-slinging from ours truly.
Then, our beloved Ranbir jumps onto the bandwaggon with "SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang".
Veer Ji, You wrote:
"How did you arrive in the Western World?
It's because your parents left India for a better quality of life and better economic opportunities same as what the youth today are doing."
Correct, my parents were in great debt; my grandfather had passed away young and my father, being the only son (who was still unmarried at the time), had to bear a lot of responsibility at a very young age. He had to get himself married, and two younger sisters married too, all while in debt, despite having a Masters degree in PolSci and was unemployed for 16 months. Under such extremes he decided to venture outside, unlike our friend ABC Singh next door who had a Ph.D. in whatever and was making 30 thousand rupees/month as a full-time lecturer with permanent job stability and is now driving a taxi for a living or XYZ Singh who has 100 acres of land and isn't utilizing any of it to its full extent simply because he's too lazy and so he decided to venture outside.
"How many of you would honestly be willing to give up your live's now to work on a farm in the boiling heat for 8 hours + a day, especially if you had a good education."
"boiling heat for 8 hours + a day". Funny thing you mention that because most immigrants I know are indeed doing this in Canada, instead of on the farm, they are doing it in a boiling hot, greenhouse-like factory for 12 to 16 hours a day to get that extra bit of overtime, nevermind what their children are up to. The work conditions aren't really any better, but are in fact worse in my opinion (especially looking at long-term effects). Then we have the other group of people who drive trucks for 16 or more hours a day across a few odd hundred kilometers, again, never minding what their children are up to. The only major difference (there are others) in work condition wise I see is the payout, which is about 40 times as much (the approximate CAD/INR rate right now).
To be honest Veer Ji, most of the people I see here in Canada who recently came from Punjab are anything but educated. When I say educated, I mean really educated, not just some guy with a B.A. who drank up to his nose through university, flunked everything and got a duped degree by paying his way out. Most people I know are from the extremes; either very smart (M.Sc.'s, Ph.D.'s) or below Metric (grade 10), with the latter making up the vast majority.
Right now, most youth in Canada are not aware of the difference between the different Sikh cults that are in place right now and actual Sikhism. Most don't know the difference between Nirankaris, Narakdharis, fake Bhabha's, fake $ants, the RSS, GOI Agents, Radhaswamis, Arya Samajis, Naamdharis, Nangs, other fake "Sikhs" OR the AKJ, DDT, other genuine jathas and true Gursikhs. Right now, I'm finishing my final year in University (only 2.5 months left!) and I regret I didn't take any part in the Sikh Students Association mostly because I learned the greatness of my religion, its glorious history and the true path all too late. However, when I'm done, I'll be going to a different University (another degree) and I have vowed to actively take part in the SSA over there.
Gurpreet Singh wrote:
"sher bahadur singh..........vah ji vah......what a name".
Thank you, I belive my parent aptly chose it.
Panjab wrote:
"why hope on others like jarnail singh? why not all make an effort together all do our part?"
As I mentioned, my recommendation was to "make sure our rehats are in check and do naam simran, panthic seva, and kirtan and hope for the best from Waheguru Ji". I think having a person with a dynamic personality and charisma with genuine understanding and belief in Sikhi like Bhindranwale will GREATLY benefit the youth of this generation as they will have someone to look up to. I think Dhadrianwale is OK (even though I'm not a real fan of him) for the time being since he at least tells youths to stay away from drugs and alcohol and get in touch with Sikhi. However, as Gyani "Arashi" Ji has mentioned, some of his actions are questionable as well as the Kachi bani he preaches. If he preached real gurbani, wasn't a religious profiteer and had great gian, then I think we would have had our man (using it as a figure of speech only).
All in all, some interesting anecdotes about Khalistan and jumping to false, presumptous conclusions to add icing on the cake.
WJKK, WJKF
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 17 Jan 2006
Sher bahdur Singh ji,dont get too sensitive, there is no neccesity to defend anything you wrote neither for any one else.
Khalistan came in because it is one dream that any one body not following a baba or dera is chasing-and wasting time.
This is one good example, when sikhs get togther to discuss, soon one will jump off the band wagon and get offensive and defensive.This a very good prime example.Instead of listening to all and more, you have taken pains to be critical of those who wrote a little differently.
wah bhai wah!
just listen and listen and then we can get the cores ...and work on that!
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 17 Jan 2006
Dear Sadh Sangat jeo
While in India, we all want to come to U.K and USA/Canada and now when we are out of India, we talk about the declining of Sikhism in India.
AAGE SAMAJH CHALO NAND LALLA
PACHHE JO BEETEE SO BEETEE.
Bhai Nand Lal Singh Ji, the most learned and blessed poet of Guru Gobind Singh Sahib.
Still we have not learnt the lesson from the Brahamins. Even at Tapoban.org, we condemn each other.
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
[address removed]
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Sherbahadar Singh · 17 Jan 2006
WJKK, WJKF
This whole conversation flared up when the topic was warped out of context and elements that weren't being discussed were brought in and people were accused of saying or promoting things they didn't.
"Sher bahdur Singh ji,dont get too sensitive, there is no neccesity to defend anything you wrote neither for any one else."
Actually, Veer Ji, I'm very calm. I think there is, in fact, a reason for me to defend myself, especially when I've been tagged with saying or promoting something that I didn't.
"Khalistan came in because it is one dream that any one body not following a baba or dera is chasing-and wasting time."
And gladly, I'm not one of them. I'm not a bhabha or dera chaser or Khalistan visionary (which is what you wrongly assumed).
"This is one good example, when sikhs get togther to discuss, soon one will jump off the band wagon and get offensive and defensive."
If you re-read your original post, re-read my original post, I think you will conclude that you drew first blood with the flambouyant tone of your original post.
"Instead of listening to all and more, you have taken pains to be critical of those who wrote a little differently."
I don't mind constructive criticism or differences in opinion as long as the conversation stays within context, which wasn't the case with you. My message is still, for the third time, to "make sure our rehats are in check and do naam simran, panthic seva, and kirtan and hope for the best from Waheguru Ji".
In any case, I don't think it's worth our time or energy fighting one another with "he said, she said" arguments. I hope it's more clear to you why I reacted the way I did, even though it wasn't an attack on you, your character, your opinions or anything else. If I said anything offensive, I apologize and take it all back.
WJKK, WJKF
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 17 Jan 2006
And gladly, I'm not one of them. I'm not a bhabha or dera chaser or Khalistan visionary (which is what you wrongly assumed).
No body assumed you were pro khalistani.The rrest about drwaing blood again goes in the same lines!
I used to dream about Khalistan from the age of about 9, Long long before any 1984 came up!
But having seen and studied the Sikh mentality and wores, and seeing the decline of Sikh identity, I conclude, these guys chasing khalistan are no different than the ones they call kesadhari hindus, etc!
None of them is really concerend about the REAL issues!Like ensuring we can revive sikhi, instead they are on a wild goose chase.
If Sikhi becomes strong, things like khalistan will follow.But to make Sikhi strong -no body wants to take the challenge.
The causes for falling Sikhi is not sim0ply the saadhd , deras, it is the nit picking among Sikhs, the dirty politrics, the wrong objectives and phantom dreams ..BUT funnily NO BODY care about the RREAL problem....
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 18 Jan 2006
Yes, i have also seen clean shaven monas shouting the same !That is your sikhi when you get khalistan !
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Swinder Singh · 18 Jan 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh
Right here in Punjab I would try put up the real picture of the present day situation/problem. This is multi-dimensional problem.
1.Illiteracy: Punjab mostly resides in villages. The parents are mostly illiterate or less educated to guide their wards about studies to be undertaken and vocational guidance at the college level studies. Rather wards start guiding them in all their affairs and get an upper hand as such. After completion of their studies they start thinking to fly over to some foreign land to make a good buck and in the course to be fit in the alien land they start thinking in their terms of looking and living.
2.Lack of knowledge of parents about the religion: Only some of them know some sakhis and mostly blank on gurbani frontal or real sikhi. Secondly some parents themselves are lacking sikhi spirit. All of us might have seen in some of the posts where the children are asking their parents that they want to go this of sikhi and in some cases parents are reluctant and/or in the other cases they are negative too.
3.Illiterate/in-experienced Bhais/parcharaks in villages: If we chalk up a gradation system for the bhais in the village gurdwaras, from Ist standard to MA. In most of the villages they would not be qualifying the Ist standard. Mostly the bhais are who did not get any job after completion of their studies of 8th or 10th standard. The unfortunate side of the problem is that there is program or agenda of their training by the SGPC.
4.Bashing up of Sikhs in media: In most of the Indian films or ads. Sikhs are shown as a laughing stock by presenting them as drivers and other such roles. This is all under a drawn up program or scheme though it will be a costly affair to its sponsors in the long run.
5.Political interference in religious matter such as Akal Takhat. This sickens some of the right thinking people.
6.Bollywood culture
7.So called Punjabi culture of new singers with hair cut, and adoring ear rings and black goggles.
8.Globalization
9.Systematic and planned expansion of Radha Soami cult.
10.Influx of Migrated labor
11.Westernization by immigrants from Punjab to foreign lands
12.Lack of Parchar by the SGPC and no solid program to tackle the menace
13.Invasion by the Christianity at the soft targets such to give financial help to the poor and needy to instigate them to convert.
14.To look smart and modern with their spouses at the time of marriage.
15.Somewhat costly affairs and easy way of life for the have-nots
16.Petty babe such as tantrik/bhaniarewale etc.
17.Opening of wine retailing outlets every where in Punjab by the Punjab Government.
Though the dera culture is not ok in terms of Khalsa/pathic traditions, yet I think it is helping a lot to make the youth live in bondage with sikhi. So at the movement we should not out rightly criticize them alike. A movement like Singh Sabha be started to put the Sikhs on a single platform, thereafter the dera culture should be addressed.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 19 Jan 2006
what would they call you ?true Hinduvata Sikh ?man yopu dont seem to get the issue!
What is AKJ or Dhadrain or akali way ?
is this NOT supposed to be only ONE Sikhs way ??
the kahlistanis will stil, shout ...Khalistan Zindapbaad!!when you look who shouted it is one with clean shaven face and no dastaar!!
sikhs are good to blame anyone else ,..except learn to take responsibility for their own faults!
Start a Sikhi bachao, paggrri sambhalo and lehar chlao!
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 20 Jan 2006
No chance for furtherance of sikhism in Punjab because of Sarri hoi, Galli hoi, Pappian di Committe (SGPC).
I vouch for Nanaksar pattern, so long they give full respects to Guru Granth Sahib and recite kirtan properly in London, Birm.Can.and USA.
A girl had to wait for elevel years till his guide died for Ph.D.in Punjabi, because of the demand of his guide for illicit relationship and now she never suggests for Ph.D.in Punjabi to any girl. She is 39 and unmarried and no job because of age-bar.
It is easy to talk, while sitting outside India on various topics, as truly and sincerely presented by Sawinder, Arshi and Jung.
for detals:
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
[address removed]
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
harpreet singh · 21 Jan 2006
badal government has done nothing for youth in punjab, and when kids have nothing to do they join the army work in farms or do drugs.
I am not anti khalistani, the singhs who laid their lives down for this ideal should never ever be forgotten..but im glad to see that some youth in the west are not falling into this khalistan zindibad sentiment that gets a hold of alot of young people after visiting msg boards and websites..it had a hold of me too but after realizing what the real issues are it becomes crystal clear khalistan is not what is necessary right now.
I also just came from india, and yes their are innocent sikhs in prisons, but we are not facing persecution at india at the present time..atleast i didnt see it..if others did please let me kno.. we are freely allowed to practice our religion, nobody stops you in india from attending the gurdwara or learning about sikh eithas. I seen shops in india with sant jarnail singh pictures up, i bought sant ji posters and other posters of prominant kharkoos OPENLY on the street.. i looked for any type of persecution but i just didnt see it in any form.. im not saying india is this great democratic nation cuz it is not and if this country has to it can turn real evil in a second..but at the present time it is not.. if nething i saw secularism
Also, Sikhs worst enemy is other sikhs, not hindus..it was sardaars who chased down kharkoos, its sikhs who are currently doing nothing to help the situation in punjab.. we need to stop BLAMING HINDUS AND START BLAMING OURSELVES.
punjabis are a very tribal kind of people sticking to groups, territories and not good at working together on large scales..this is very clear when two gurdwaras or two jathas cannot get along.
The situation is bad..but dont blame others we only have our own communities to blame.
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 22 Jan 2006
VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
'If Sikhi becomes strong, things like khalistan will follow.But to make Sikhi strong -no body wants to take the challenge.'
I completely AND truly agree with Bhai Sahib 'SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang' Jeeo, great post.
Guru Gobind Singh Jee said that when the Sikhs turn into Khalsa by accepting Amritvelaa, Naam, Bani, all rehits including Sarbloh Bebek then Khalsa Raj will be bestowed upon that fortunate one.
Khalsa Raj is a reality and it will occur soon.
The light of a Khalsa is so strong and magnetically charged by Naam that the small light within others such as Manmukhs will be attracted to the Khalsa’s light and will then convert to a Khalsa too. Therefore, Khalistan will follow a Khalsa in numerous ways.
Bhai Sahib ‘Professor Mohinder Pal Singh’ Jeeo.
The source of where Sikhi originated from, which is India, has become weak and all there faith is lost and instead doubts run in their mind.
Once Guru Nanak Dev jee went to a village to gain shelter but due to the unkindness of the people they told him that they had no room for him. ‘No room’, ‘No room’ – think about it – no room for the love of Guru Jee, no room for the Rehits given by Guru Jee, no room for the faith in Guru Jee.
As I was saying Guru Nanak Dev Jee then told the people with such hatred in the village to stay there and never leave the village whereas to another village where instead kindness and generosity lived amongst the hearts of the people were told by Guru Jee to leave the village and spread their purity to others.
To leave the village, which could have been a metaphor for country, now the true Sikhs live amongst the world in other countries.
Bhai Sahib ‘vijaydeep Singh Jeeo.
I think Sikhi parchaar should be done to the Sikhs living in countries such as England, America and Canada, etc and not yet India – as after the Sikhs or most of the Sikhs have turned into Khalsa in these countries then we should do Sikhi parchaar in India. There are already white people in America that have converted into a Sikh but I think with more Sikhi Parchaar done in those areas they can become much stronger.
Even if the Sikhs now do Sikhi Parchaar in India, the Sikhs there will waver again as there faith isn’t strong enough yet but will be with the helping hand of…
Finally, even some of the Sikhs in India are against the Sikhs that actually make effort in their Sikhi, basically the really religious Sikhs. There are only a few true Sikhs that can be strengthened with faith and truth about Sikhi but they just need to be showed the way.
Every Rehit is compulsory in Sikhi but within Naam they’re nothing, so that is how Khalsa Raj will be achieved by reciting Naam greatly and intensely but with the support of the rehits the acceptation and satisfaction of all this can be achieved by Guru Jee. Remember that by going through the Guru Jee, Vaheguru Jee can be met.
Guru Jee is there as the best man on the wedding day of Vaheguru Jee and the Khalsa.
The Savior of the existence of this world lies within the Khalsa.
-------
aapae bhaa(n)ddae saajian aapae pooran dhaee ||
He Himself fashioned the vessel of the body, and He Himself fills it.
eikanhee dhudhh samaaeeai eik chulhai rehanih charrae ||
Into some, milk is poured, while others remain on the fire.
eik nihaalee pai savanih eik oupar rehan kharrae ||
Some lie down and sleep on soft beds, while others remain watchful.
thinhaa savaarae naanakaa jinh ko nadhar karae ||1||
He adorns those, O Nanak, upon whom He casts His Glance of Grace. ||1||
those, O Nanak, upon whom He casts His Glance of Grace. ||1||
-------
VahegurooJekaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
[%sig%]
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 22 Jan 2006
That is exactly, what I have said.Stop dreamingf and chahsing after phantom dreams.Let us start raisng the Sikhi ideals,and Sikh numbers.let us bring out Sikhs back into the fold.Create a pride in them with sikhi for sikhi, through Sikhi.
Once Sikhi is strong in mentality, identity and thought and in numbers , the rest will become simple and clear, and easy.then do whatever we want.
'Respect' with or within khalistan and no Sikhi is no respect.Respect with Sikhi is respect for su
ikhs and it will be respected in khalistan just as much as anywhere else.
Again people are using emotive words, to justify dreams and the unreal.
let us start with rejunivating sikhi,Sikhi Sikhi Sikhi, then all will know what Sikhs are made of !And WHAT sikhs will be taekn seriously!
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
SherVeerbahadur Singh Jang · 23 Jan 2006
I have said this before and like the sikh yahoo group SikhEKTA has as its introduction...Sikhi bechao, pagrri sambhalo, -lehar chelao!
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 23 Jan 2006
Dear Shaktishali Sha Soora
I am glad to read the reference mentioned by you of Guru Nanak Sahib.
No room, No room to stay is happening here with us also in this part.
But one thing, if all the doctors (Sewak, and teachers like you), of our community will sit back in UK/USA/Canada, then, who will bother for the disease of the patients in India. The patients will die, and doctors will talk only, with honeyed quoted language, about the point of origin of their roots. Our hearts are connected to Punjab, Darbar Sahib, Anandpur Sahib, Hazoor Sahib-Nanded, Kiratpur Sahib, Patna Sahib, Sirhind , Bangla Sahib, Sis Ganj Sahib, Rakab Ganj Sahib etc. and with the Gurbani, Guru Sahibans, but bodies are staying back elsewhere for the sake of temptation of luxuries. Of course, we are reciting Gurbani.
I have appreciated your referece and not criticised at all to anybody, simply expressed the truth, please take it in a positive way. This is my request very humbly.
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Sherbahadar Singh · 03 Feb 2006
WJKK, WJKF
I think there are two popular houses of thought as far as the inception of Khalistan are concerned.
The first suggests that Khalistan will be a natural outcome of Sikhs being excellent Sikhs.
The second suggests that we need Khalistan right now to lay out the foundations for Sikhism to flourish to begin with.
I think the optimal combination is somewhat a bit of both. First and foremost importantly, we must "make sure our rehats are in check and do naam simran, panthic seva, and kirtan and hope for the best from Waheguru Ji". Without that, we will get nowhere. In addition, at the same time, we need a new, honest Sikh leader akin to Bhindranwale as a to help restore the pride and respect of the self-image of Sikhs within themselves. When such a charismatic leader will be born, who is to know but until then, friendly indirect parchar amongst our close circles of friends and family should be our goal in my opinion.
WJKK, WJKF
Re: Sikhism in decline in India???
Heera Singh · 04 Feb 2006
I haven't read many of the above posts.. but i'm gonna get straight to the point... i think we can all agree that the situation in India isn't the greatest situation... now.. the real question:
What can we do to help?
there IS some positive parchar being done, but obviously not enuff... one'a the above posts mentioned the 'decline' of sikhi and the 'rise' of Radhaswaomi's and Naamdhari's etc... this is because they do a lot of parchar... in fact, I remebmer sum1 tellin me that there are as many or more radhaswaomi gurdwara's then there are Sikh Gurdwara's.... i dunno how accurate that is.. but just the thought of it tells you how much parchar they are doing...
Gurdwara's make a lot of $$ and I think should be using some of the money to help the local communities... for example... Radhaswaomi gurdwara's help build schools and hospitals in local communities.... I think SGPC should also start helping local communities (if they are not doing so already)... but that is stuff thats Local for them.... so its a lot easier for them do things...
for people like us, living in Canada, USA, UK.... what is it that we can do? I know we're all busy with our own lives, but there's always somethin that can be done.... people are hesitant to donate to 'charities' 'cause they dont' know exactly whats being done with their money..
so we need to find a way we can help from down here..
ne thoughts?