Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

simran at samagams

simran at samagams

wonderer · 17 Jan 2006

i hear that we must be blessed by guru ji to do simran, which can only be taught at amrit sanchar. if this is true, why does akj do simran at samagams etc? i believed there was a method to do simran, and this method is not being used during the kirtan in which it is sung. i was under the impression that only sikhs who have been blessed by guru to do simran can do the simran. is this true, or am i mistaken?

Re: simran at samagams

singh · 17 Jan 2006

in bhai randhir singhs book he has written the 3 ways of simran. with the tongue (repeating vaheguru vaheguru like in keertan) with the breath (like in amrit vela and during the whole day, where you are taught in amrit sanchar with guru sahibs kirpa) and ajapa jap (which is a stage thru akal purakhs kirpa that only very spiritually elevated people reach.)

Re: simran at samagams

everybody · 17 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh i think Simran is about LOVE.....LOVE for GOD and LOVE for ALL. Everybody can do it. Anybody can do Simran. However, true Spiritual progress can only be attained through Guru Ji's AMRIT. Gurparsad. Amrit is like a "Visa" for Sach Khand. If you want entry into Sach Khand, you need Amrit. Dont ever be mistaken of that. However, SIMRAN can be done by anybody. Amritdharis and Non-Amritdharis, but true progress is only made with the blessings of Great Guru through Amrit. bhul chuk maaf

Re: simran at samagams

abc · 17 Jan 2006

Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa Waheguroo ji ki Fateh !! Of course you are right that only the blessed ones can do the simran but again we shall do simran as much as possible. Blessed ones do with every breath. Also you are right that simran can be taught at Amrit Sanchaar by panj payaare. But I don't see any logic in not doing simran at samagams in both of your statements as in samagams we are doing Simran and not teaching... Please clarify your question! Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa Waheguroo ji ki Fateh !!

Re: simran at samagams

wjkk wjkf · 18 Jan 2006

wjkk wjkf ! i think that there is nothing wrong with doing simran at kirtans along as you don't got OTT ! it makes the kirtan mor enjoyable... but as they all say the true naam can be achieved by taking guru ji's amrit. wjkk wjkf

Re: simran at samagams

Novtej Singh · 18 Jan 2006

wonderer wrote: "this method is not being used during the kirtan in which it is sung." This 'method' has only become apparent in recent years where a large proportion of the sangat indulge in simran with their swaas. However I think this point is debatable for whether or not it should be done openly or not but, I do know that before I knew what saas giraas simran was this never used to happen. Its good that you see it as a gift to those who have it but on the other side, some might get freaked out. waheguru ji ka khalsa wahrugu ji ki fateh

Re: simran at samagams

singh · 18 Jan 2006

its just that some people do it louder; people who have received naam drirrh and are serious about their sikhi, are doing swas swas when listening to akhand paaths, akhand keertan, walking around all day. it can be done quietly and go unnoticed.

Re: simran at samagams

M Singh · 19 Jan 2006

Simran, if one likes, can do it. Every body can do it. No check. But; that activity to be fruitful, one should first have "Amrit". Gurbani says; it is not fruitful otherwise. And also; after Amrit; one should behave in responsible way while doing Simran. Guru gave it to him.

Re: simran at samagams

LionKing (LK) · 19 Jan 2006

M Singh - Where in Gurbani does it say Simran is not fruitful without Amrit (i.e Khande Batte di Pahul) ?

Re: simran at samagams

why · 20 Jan 2006

i thought that swas swas should not be done in front of Non-Amritdharis as only the panj pyare can give the gift to amritdharis when they take amt??

Re: simran at samagams

M Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Dear Lionking, Gurbani Pankiti may be quoted later on; but you agree that many references are there which say that only "saying" is not sufficient. One must have it from the GURU. "Ram Ram Sab Ko Kahe; Kahea Ram Na hoey.Gurparsadi Ram man Vase Ta Fal Pave Koe."