Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Singh · 17 Jan 2006

Is this a true account of what happened in 1845? Why did we lose? Anglo-Sikh War ANGLO-SIKH WAR 1, 1845-46, resulting in partial subjugation of the Sikh kingdom, as the outcome of British expansionism. It was near-anarchical conditions that overtook the Lahore court after the death of Maharaja Ranjit Singh in June 1839. The English, by then firmly installed in Firozpur the Sikh frontier, about 70 km from Lahore, the Sikh capital, were watching the happenings across the border with more than neighbour's interest The disorder that revealed there promised them a good opportunity for direct intervention. Up to 1838, the British troops on the Sikh frontier had amounted to one regiment at Sabathu in the hills and two at Ludhiana with six pieces of artillery, equaling in all about 2,500 men. The total rose to 8,000 during the time of Lord Auckland (1836 42) who increased the number of troops at Ludhiana and created a new military post at Firozpur, which was actually Past of Sikh kingdom's dominion south of the Sutlej. British preparations for a war with the Sikhs began seriously in 1843 when the new governor-general, Lord Ellenborough (1842-44), discussed with the Home government the possibilities of a military occupation of the Punjab. English and Indian infantry reinforcement began arriving at each of the frontier posts of Firozpur and Ludhiana. Cavalry and artillery regiments moved up to Ambala and Kasauli. Works were in the process of erection around the magazine at Firozpur, and the fort at Ludhiana began to he fortified. Plans for the construction of bridges over the rivers Markanda and Ghaggar were prepared, and a new road link to join Meerut and Ambala was taken in hand. Exclusive of the newly constructed cantonments of Kasauli and Shimla, Ellenborough had been able to collect a force of 11,639 men and 48 guns at Ambala, Ludhiana and Firozpur. Everywhere," wrote Lord Ellenborough, we are trying to get things in order and especially to strengthen and equip the artillery with which the fight will be." Seventy boats of thirty-five tons each, with the necessary equipments to bridge the Sutlej at any point, were under construction; fifty-six pontoons were on their way from Bombay for use in Sindh, and two steamers were being constructed to ply on the River Sutlej. in November 1845," he informed the Duke of Wellington, "the army will be equal to any operation. I should be sorry to have it called to the field sooner." In July 1844, Lord Ellenborough was replaced by Lord Hardinge (1844-48), a Peninsula veteran, as governor-general of India. Hardinge further accelerated the process of strengthening the Sutlej frontier for a war with the Sikhs. The abrasive and belligerent Major George Broadfoot as the political agent on the Punjab frontier replaced the affable Colonel Richmond. Lord Cough, the commander-in-chief, established his headquarters at Ambala. In October 1844, the British military force on the frontier was 17,000 infantry and 60 guns. Another 10,000 troops were to be ready by the end of November. Firozpur's garrison strength under the command of Sir John Littler was raised to 7,000; by January 1845, the total British force amounted to 20,000 men and 60 guns. We can collect," Hardinge reported to the Home government, 33,000 infantry, 6,000 cavalry and 100 guns in six weeks." In March additional British and Indian regiments were quietly moved to Flrozpur, Ludhiana and Ambala. Field batteries of 9 pounders with horses or bullocks to draw them, and 24 additional pieces of heavy ordnance were on their way to the frontier. In addition, 600 elephants to draw the battering train of 24-pounder batteries had reached Agra, and 7,000 camels between Kanpur and the Sutlej were to move up in the summer to Firozpur, which was to be the concentration point for a forward offensive movement. Lord Hardinge, blamed unnecessarily by the Home government for inadequate military preparations for the first Sikh war, had, during the seventeen months between Ellen borough's departure and the commencement of hostilities with the Sikhs, increased the garrison strength at Ferozpur from 4,596 men and 12 guns to 10,472 men and 24 guns; at Ambala from 4,113 men and 24 guns to 12, 972 men and 32 guns; at Ludhiana from 3,030 men and 12 guns to 7,235 men and 12 guns, and at Meerut from 5,573 men and 18 guns to 9,844 men and 24 guns. The relevant strength of the advanced armies, including those at the hill stations of Sabathu and Kasauli, was raised from 24,000 men and 66 guns to 45,500 men and 98 guns. These figures are based on official British papers, particularly Hardinge's private correspondence on Punjab affairs with his predecessor, Lord Ellenborough. Thus Total number of British troops around Punjab was 86,023 men and 116 guns. In addition to the concentration of troops on the border, an elaborate supply depot was set up by the British at Basslan, near Raikot, in Ludhiana district. The Lahore Darbar's vamps or representatives and news writers in the cis-Sutlej region sent alarming reports of these large-scale British military movements across the border. The Sikhs were deeply wrought upon by these war preparations, especially by Broad foot’s acts of hostility. The rapid march in November 1845 of the governor-general towards the frontier and a report of Sir Charles Napier's speech in the Delhi Gazette saying that the British were going to war with the Sikhs filled Lahore with rumors of invasion. The Sikh ranks, alerted to the danger of a British offensive, started their own preparations. Yet the army pinches or regimental representatives, who had taken over the affairs of the Lahore forces into their own hands after the death of Wazir Jawahar Singh, were at this time maintaining, according to George Campbell, a British civilian employed in the cis-Sutlej territory, Memoirs of My Indian Career , "Wonderful order at Lahore.. and almost puritanical discipline in the military republic." However, the emergence of the army Panchayats as a new centre of power greatly perturbed the British authority that termed it as "unholy alliance between the republican army and the Darbar." In this process Sikh army had indeed been transformed. It had now assumed the role of the Khalsa. It worked through elected regimental committees declaring that Guru Gobind Singh's ideal of the Sikh commonwealth had been revived, with the Sarbatt Khalsa or the Sikh as a whole assuming all executive, military and civil authority in the State. The British decried this as "the dangerous military democracy of the panchayat system," in which soldiers were in a state of success mutiny. " When the British agent made a reference the Lahore Darbar about military preparations in the Punjab, it replied that there only defensive measures to counter the signs of the British. The Darbar, on other hand, asked for the return of the estimated at over seventeen lakh of the Lahore grandee Suchet Singh had left buried in Firozpur, the restoration of the village of Mauran granted by Maharaja Ranjit Singh to one of his generals Hukam Singh Malvai, but subsequently resumed by the ruler of Nabha with the active connivance of the British, and free passage of Punjabi armed constabulary — a right that had been acknowledged by the British on paper but more often than not in practice. The British government rejected the Darbar's claims and severed diplomatic relations with it. The armies under Hugh Gough and Lord Hardinge began proceeding towards Firozpur. To forestall their joining those at Firozpur, the Sikh army began to cross the Sutlej on 11 December near Harike Pattan into its own territory on the other side of the river. The crossing over the Sutlej by Sikhs was made a pretext by the British for opening hostilities and on 13 December Governor-General Lord Hardinge issued a proclamation announcing war on the Sikhs. The declaration charged the State of Lahore with violation of the treaty of friendship of 1809 and justified British preparations as merely precautionary measures for the protection of the Sutlej frontier. The British simultaneously declared Sikh possessions on the left bank of the Sutlej forfeit. Hesitation and indecision marred Sikh military operations. Having crossed the Sutlej with five divisions, each 8,000 - 12,000 strong, an obvious strategy for them would have been to move forward. They did in a bold sweeping movement first encircle Firozpur, then held by Sir John Littler with only 7,000 men, but withdrew without driving the advantage home and dispersed their armies in a wide semicircle from Harike to Mudki and thence to Ferozeshah, 16 km southeast of Firozpur. The abandonment of Firozpur as a first target was the result of the treachery of the Sikh Prime Minister, Lal Singh, who was in treasonable communication with Captain Peter Nicholson, the assistant political agent of the British. He asked the latter's advice and was told not to attack Firozpur. This instruction he followed seducing the Sikhs with an ingenious excuse that, instead of falling upon an easy prey, the Khalsa should exalt their fame by captivity or the death of the Lat Sahib (the governor general) himself A division precipitately moved towards Ludhiana also remained inactive long enough to lose the benefit of the initiative The Khalsa army had crossed the Sutlej borne on a wave of popular enthusiasm, it was equally matched (60000 Sikh soldiers vs. 86,000 British soldiers) if not superior to the British force. Its soldiers had the will and determination to fight or die, but not its commanders. There was no unique among them, and each of them seemed to act as he thought best. Drift was the policy deliberately adopted by them. On 18 December, the Sikhs came in touch with British army, which arrived under Sir Hugh Gough, the commander-in-chief, from Ludhiana. A battle took place at Mudki, 32 km from Flrozpur. Lal Singh, who headed the Sikh attack, deserted his army and fled the field when the Sikhs stood firm in their order, fighting in a resolute and determined manner. The leaderless Sikhs fought a grim hand-to-hand battle against the more numerous enemy led by the most experienced commanders in the world. The battle continued with unabated fury till midnight (and came thereafter to be known as "Midnight Mudki"). The Sikhs retired with a loss of 17 guns while the British suffered heavy causalities amounting to 872 killed and wounded, including Quartermaster-General Sir Robert Sale, Sir John McCaskill and Brigadier Boulton. Reinforcements were sent for from Ambala, Meerut and Delhi. Lord Hardinge, unmindful of his superior position of governor-general, offered to become second-in-command to his commander-in-chief. The second action was fought three days later, on 21 December at Ferozeshah, 16 km both from Mudki and Firozpur. The governor-general and the commander-in-chief, assisted by reinforcements led by General Littler from Firozpur, made an attack upon the Sikhs who were awaiting them behind strong entrenchments. The British — 16,700 men and 69 guns—tried to overrun the Sikhs in one massive cavalry, infantry and artillery onslaught, but the assault was stubbornly resisted. Sikhs' batteries fired with rapidity and precision. There was confusion in the ranks of the English and their position became increasingly critical. The growing darkness of the frosty winter night reduced them to sore straits. The battle of Ferozeshah is regarded as one of the most fiercely contested battles fought by the British in India. During that "night of horrors," the commander-in-chief acknowledged, "We were in a critical and perilous state." Counsels of retreat and surrender were raised and despair struck the British camp. In the words of General Sir ISope Grant, Sir Henry Hardinge thought it was all up and gave his sword—a present from the Duke of Wellington and which once belonged to Napoleon—and his Star of the ISath to his son, with directions to proceed to Firozpur, remarking that "if the day were lost, he must fall. " Lal Singh and Tej Singh again came to the rescue of the English. The former suddenly deserted the Khalsa army during the night and the latter the next morning (22 December), which enabled the British to turn defeat into victory. The British loss was again heavy, 1,560 killed and 1,721 wounded. The number of causalities among officers was comparatively higller. The Sikhs lost about 2,000 men and 73 pieces of artillery. A temporary cessation of hostilities followed the battle of Ferozeshah. The English were not in a position to assume the offensive and waited for heavy guns and reinforcements to arrive from Delhi. Lal Singh and Tej Singh allowed them the much-needed respite in as much as they kept the Sikhs from recrossing the Sutlej. To induce desertions, Lord Hardinge issued a proclamation on the Christmas day inviting all natives of Hindustan to quit the service of the Sikh State on pain of forfeiting their property and to claim protection from the British government. The deserters were also offered liberal rewards and pensions. A Sikh sardar, Ranjodh Singh Majlthia, crossed the Sutlej in force and was joined by Ajit Singh, of Ladva, from the other side of the river. They marched towards Ludhiana and burnt a portion of the cantonment. Sir Harry Smith (afterwards Governor of Cape Colony), who was sent to relieve Ludhlana, marched eastwards from Firozpur, keeping a few miles away from the Sutlej. Ranjodh Singh Majithia harried Smith's column and, when Smith tried to make a detour at Baddoval, attacked his rear with great vigor and captured his baggage train and stores (21 January). But Harry Smith retrieved his position a week later by inflicting a defeat on Ranjodh Singh Majithia and Ajlt Singh, of Ladva, (28January). The last battle of the campaign took place on 10 February. To check the enemy advance on Lahore, a large portion of the Sikh army was entrenched in a horseshoe curve on the Sutlej near the village of Sabhraon, under the command of Tej Singh while the cavalry battalions and the dreaded ghorcharas under Lal Singh were a little higher up the river. Entrenchments at Sabhraon were on the left bank of the Sutlej with a pontoon bridge connecting them with their base camp. Their big guns were placed behind high embankments and consequently immobilized for offensive action. The infantry was also posted behind earthworks and could not, therefore, be deployed to harass the opponents. Early in February, the British received ample stores of ammunition from Delhi. Lal Singh had already passed on to the English officers the required clues for an effective assault. Gough and Hardinge now decided to make a frontal attack on Sabhraon and destroy the Darbar army at one blow. A heavy mist hung over the battlefield, enveloping both contending armies. As the sun broke through the mist, the Sikhs found themselves encircled between two horseshoes: facing them were the British and behind them was the Sutlej, now in spate. After a preliminary artillery duel, British cavalry made a feint to check on the exact location of the Sikh guns. The cannonade was resumed, and in two hours British guns put the Darbar artillery out of action. Then the British charged Sikh entrenchments from three sides. Tej Singh fled across the pontoon bridge as soon as the contest started and had it destroyed making reinforcement or return of Sikh soldiers impossible. Gulab Singh Dogra stopped sending supplies and rations from Lahore. Lal Singh's ghorcharas did not put in their appearance at Sabhraon. In the midst of these treacheries, a Sikh warrior, Sham Singh Attarivala, symbolizing the unflinching will of the Khalsa, vowed to fight unto the last and fall in battle rather than retire in defeat. He rallied the ranks depleted by desertions. His courage inspired the Sikhs to make a determined bid to save the day, but the odds were against them. Sham Singh fell fighting in the foremost ranks along with his dauntless comrades. The British casualties at Sabhraon were 2,403 killed; the Sikhs lost 3,125 men in the action and all their guns were either captured or abandoned in the river. Captain J.D. Cunningham, who was present as an additional aide-de-camp to the governor-general, describes the last scene of the battle vividly in his A History of the Sikhs: "...although assailed on either side by squadrons of horse and battalions of foot, no Sikh offered to submit, and no disciple of Guru Gobind Singh asked for quarter. They everywhere showed a front to the victors, and stalked slowly and sullenly away, while many rushed singly forth to meet assured death by contending with a multitude. The victors looked with stolid wonderment upon the indomitable courage of the vanquished.... " Lord Hugh Gough, the British commander-in-chief, under whose leadership the two Anglo-Sikh wars were fought, described Sabhraon as the Waterloo of India. Paying tribute to the gallantry of the Sikhs, he said: "Policy precluded me publicly recording my sentiments on the splendid gallantry of our fallen foe, or to record the acts of heroism displayed, not only individually, but almost collectively, by the Sikh sardars and the army; and I declare were it not from a deep conviction that my country's good required the sacrifice, I could have wept to have witnessed the fearful slaughter of so devoted a body of men." Lord Hardinge, who saw the action, wrote: " Few escaped; none, it may be said, surrendered. The Sikhs met their fate with the resignation, which distinguishes their race. Two days after their victory at Sabhraon, British forces crossed the Sutlej and occupied Kasur. The Lahore Darbar empowered Gulab Singh Dogra, who had earlier come down to Lahore with regiments of hillmen, to negotiate a treaty of peace. The wily Gulab Singh first obtained assurances from the army Parishes that they would agree to the terms he made and then tendered the submission of the darbar to Lord Hardinge. The governor-general, realizing that the Sikhs were far from vanquished, forbore from immediate occupation of the country. By the terms imposed by the victorious British through the peace treaty of 9 March, the Lahore Darbar was compelled to give up Jalandhar Doab, pay a war indemnity amounting to a million and a half sterling, reduce its army to 20,000 infantry and 12,000 cavalry, hand over all the guns used in the war and relinquish control of both banks of the Sutlej to the British. A further condition was added two days later on 11 March: the posting of a British unit in Lahore till the end of the year on payment of expenses. The Darbar was unable to pay the full war indemnity and ceded in lieu thereof the hill territories between the Beas and the Indus. Kashmir was sold to Gulab Singh Dogra for 75 lakh rupees. A week later, on 16 March, another treaty was signed at Amritsar recognizing him as Maharaja of Jammu and Kashmir, affirming the suspicion that Gulab Singh Dogra indeed was involved in sedition against Khalsa Sarkar. Although Maharani Jind Kaur continued to act as the regent and Raja Lal Singh as water of the minor Maharaja Duleep Singh, effective power had passed into the hands of the British resident, Colonel Henry Lawrence. And thus end the First Anglo-Sikh war.. The Second Anglo-Sikh War ANGLO-SIKH WAR II, 1848-49, which resulted in the abrogation of the Sikh kingdom of the Punjab, was virtually a campaign by the victors of the first Anglo-Sikh war (1945-46) and since then the de facto rulers of the State finally to overcome the resistance of some of the sardars who chafed at the defeat in the earlier war which, they believed, had been lost owing to the treachery on the part of the commanders at the top and not to any lack of fighting strength of the Sikh army. It marked also the fulfillment of the imperialist ambition of the new governor-general, Lord Dalhousie (184856), to carry forward the British flag up to the natural boundary of India on the northwest. According to the peace settlement of March 1846, at the end of Anglo-Sikh war I, the British force in Lahore was to be withdrawn at the end of the year, but a severer treaty was imposed on the Sikhs before the expiry of that date. Sir Henry Hardinge, the then governor-general, had his Agent, Frederick Currie, persuade the Lahore Darbar to request the British for the continuance of the troops in Lahore. According to the treaty, which was consequently signed at Bharoval on 16 December 1846, Henry Lawrence was appointed Resident with "full authority to direct and control all matters in every department of the State." The Council of Regency, consisting of the nominees of the Resident and headed by Tej Singh, was appointed. The power to make changes in its personnel vested in the resident. Under another clause the British could maintain as many troops in the Punjab as they thought necessary for the preservation of peace and order. This treaty was to remain in operation until the minor Maharaja Duleep Singh attained the age of 16. By a proclamation issued in July 1847, the governor-general further enhanced the powers of the Resident. On 23 October 1847, Sir Henry Hardinge wrote to Henry Lawrence: "In all our measures taken during the minority we must bear in mind that by the treaty of Lahore, March 1846, the Punjab never was intended to be an independent State. By the clause I added the chief of the State could neither make war or peace, or exchange or sell an acre of territory or admit a European officer, or refuse us a thoroughfare through his territories, or, in fact, perform any act without our permission. In fact the native Prince is in fetters, and under our protection and must do our bidding." In the words of British historian John Clark Marshman, "an officer of the Company's artillery became, in fact, the successor to Ranjit Singh." The Sikhs resented this gradual liquidation of their authority in the Punjab. The new government at Lahore became totally unpopular. The abolition of tigers in the Jalandhar Doab and changes introduced in the system of land revenue and its collection angered the landed classes. Maharani Jind Kaur, who was described by Lord Dalhousie as the only woman it the Punjab with manly understanding and in whom the British Resident foresaw a rallying point for the well-wishers of the Sikh dynasty, was kept under close surveillance. Henry Lawrence laid down that she could not receive in audience more than five or six sardars in a month and that she remains in purdah like the ladies of the royal families of Nepal, Jodhpur and Jaipur. In January 1848, Henry Lawrence took leave of absence and traveled back home with Lord Hardinge, who had completed his term in India. The former was replaced by Frederick Currie and the latter by the Earl of Dalhousie. The new regime confronted a rebellion in the Sikh province of Multan, which it utilized as an excuse for the annexation of the Punjab. The British Resident at Lahore increased the levy payable by the Multan governor, Diwan Mul Raj , who, finding himself unable to comply, resigned his office. Frederick Currie appointed General Kahn Singh Man in his place and sent him to Multan along with two British officers P.A. Vans Agnew and William Anderson, to take charge from Mul Raj The party arrived at Multan on 18 April 1848, and the Diwan vacated the Fort and made over the keys to the representatives of the Lahore Darbar But his soldiers rebelled and the British officers were set upon in their camp and killed This was the beginning of the Multan outbreak. Some soldiers of the Lahore escort deserted their officers and joined Mul Raj's army. Currie received the news at Lahore on 21 April, but delayed action Lord Dalhousie allowed the Multan rebellion to spread for five months. The interval was utilized by the British further to provoke Sikh opinion. The Resident did his best to fan the flames of rebellion. Maharani Jind Kaur, then under detention in the Fort of Sheikupura, was exiled from the Punjab She was taken to Firozpur and thence to Banaras, in the British dominions. Her annual allowance, which according to the treaty of Bharoval had been fixed at one and a half lakh of rupees, was reduced to twelve thousand. Her jewellery worth fifty thousand of rupees was forfeited; so was her cash amounting to a lakh and a half. The humiliating treatment of the Maharani caused deep resentment among the people of the Punjab Even the Muslim ruler of Afghanistan, Amir Dost Muhammad, protested to the British, saying that such treatment is objectionable to all creeds."

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

singh surma · 17 Jan 2006

if these gorey never came we would have been ruling india by now. it does not escape my attension to rcent events in pakistan, the whole nation except for the gov is mobilising demos against american attacks on a tribal area in pakistan supposedly to strike at al qadas number 2. The attacka had killed a number of women and children rather than the intended target. so even when the sarkar of pakistan is bought out by gorey the people of pakistan in general still stuck to their tribal religious national loyalties. I aint no fan of mussle but i do admire their sense of togetherness and identity. but when sikhs are attacked be it nation, darbar sahib, post genocides why is it hardly a small minority backs the right cause while other sikhs turn against their own? why were sikhs not able to rise up against the british after so quickly and declare a homeland again? im sure siklhi would have been declining hard at that time.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Harcharan Singh · 18 Jan 2006

Singh Surma and Singh, Answer is simple. Lack of a true leader. If you take some time to read pre and post Ranjit Singh history, you will see that apart from Ranjit Singh there were no natural leaders. Ranjit is reknowned as being one of the greatest military geniuses in modern wartime history. He is said to be the only ruler who never conceded land (through war) during his reign. The problem with Ranjit Singh was (in my opinion) lack of religion. Guru Gobind Singh states: Sutantar Vicharna. Raaj Kaaj dian kamaan tae doosrae mutaa dia purshaan noo huk nahi daenaa - Rule Independently? In the affaris of government, do not give people of other religions authority/power Ranjit Singh had to many Hindus in places of power and trust, the poison challace being Rajput Dogra - Ghulab Singh. It was Ghulab Singh who pulled the carpet out from underneath the Sikhs feet when he conspired with British who in turn awarded him Kashmir. The Sikh army had modern weapons, cannon - long and short range, guns, training in European warfare (through the other great military genius Napoleans ex generals, G'n Ventura namely) and numbers. But what they lacked was guidance through Akaal Purkh and a leader. Infighting, greed, jealousy and decline in faith destroyed the sikh rule. This aside, the bigger problem was the monarchy system that Ranjit Singh implemented. This was against Gurmat thinking. Any rule should have been centred around Akal Takht, and not his government. It is a well known fact the Ranjit Singh kept his distance from Akali Nihangs (who were taking care of Darbaar Sahib and Akal Takht), he knew that the Akalis didn't like his personal lifestyle and choices being made by him alone, and no the Khalsa Panth. He always used to get a telling off when going to Darbaar Sahib. Ranjit Singh is also known for helping to diminish Akali numbers by sending them to fight in the front line during his Afghan campaigns. He always used have a personal bodyguard around him to keep akalis away. Read Ranjit Singhs stance on Akali Phoola Singhs story re the attack on the British. This aside, I have come accross a sakhi (can't remember the source) in which Guru Gobind stated that nobody should make any monuments in his memory, or else their line will perish. This is quite well known. Ranjit Singh however is known for building many Gurwarai in memory of Guru Gobind Singh. All of Mahara Ranjit Singhs sons were killed. This was just for info, I personally do not have any opinion as to the genuiness of the story, but do agree with the thinking i.e. not having memorials. The same problem has occured today. we had one great leader, Baba Jarnail Singh Ji, who stood up against injustice and the facist government, but there has been no one to replace him. I think most importantly, the thing to remember is that it is Waheguru who decided that we loose our nation and don't have one yet, simple. Our Guru's never fought for a nation, they fought for equality, justice, freedom of worship and truth, never for a country. Our Guru's were divince, they would never limit their revelation of the truth to a set of man made bounderies. The nation we should be trying to build should be a spiritual one. If we can help the 22 million odd so called Sikhs (but in essence only Punjabis) remember the sacrifices of their ancestors and unite in preaching the Guru Ji's sach, the spiritual nation would be 1,000,000 times stronger than a boundery limited one. In addition if we can start to spread Guru Ji's message across the world to other nations, faiths, languages, we will inevitably strengthening the true Sikh nation, and with Guru Kirpa, who knows what may be possible in terms of having our own spiritual home land also. But 1st, we need to sort out our own internal problems and get rid of the so called Sikh representatives that are purely politics, greed and power driven, and unite all our factions. Sat Sri Akaal. Harcharan Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Harcharan Singh · 18 Jan 2006

One correction - I said no natural leaders pre and post Ranjit Singh, I meant to say directly after his death. There were obviously many great leaders pre and post, Sardaar Jassa Singh x2, Sardaar Nawab Kapur Singh, Baba Ram Singh etc.. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Jan 2006

Shah Muhamaddah..EK SARKAAR bajohn Faujaan aaj jit ke harian ne... Sikh Victory was on the Battlefield....Britihsh "Victory" was political..bargaining/spies/treachery/saboteurs/bought agents/traitors etc. The same way Raja Porus of PUNJAB was "defeated" by Alexander the great centuries before... It is a fact the British are masters at deception....even the Second World war was fought with much deception - the Germans soldier was better - but the Anglos had better spies/traitors/ and "intellignece" than the Germans.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

JS · 19 Jan 2006

Potential other Sikh leaders at the time of Ranjit Singh could have been Hari Singh Nalwa. He was not in favour of an absolute monarchy and suggested to Ranjit Singh that decisions should be put to a forum of prominent Sikhs. The Dogras feared Hari Singh and got him posted to the Afghan border where he was latter killed. Another potential leader could have been Ranjit Singh's grandson Nau Nihal Singh he had shown great leadership at an early age. He was murdered by the Dogras at his fathers funeral.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

mintu · 19 Jan 2006

why need leaders? occupation means resistance.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

s · 19 Jan 2006

a sant sura sipahi was created as a leader, which is what every sikh should be humble inwards united yet able to fight defend and remain sovereign as and when required. sikhs never really united under one during and after the misals. Before that sikhs were serious about fighting the panj chors and being god focused. sadly we do not see much of that around us today and most probably in raja ranjit singhs reign. in my opinion royalty was not good for sikhs, it was counterproductive.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

S Singh · 19 Jan 2006

>>This aside, I have come accross a sakhi (can't remember the source) in which Guru Gobind stated that nobody should make any monuments in his memory, or else their line will perish. This is quite well known. Ranjit Singh however is known for building many Gurwarai in memory of Guru Gobind Singh. Is this true or an old wives tale. Firstly people say Guru Ji said build nothing in my memory. Then everyone you ever see claims that Guru Ji waits for you to visit Hazoor Sahib until you are XX years old. The two things contradict each other. So what is actually the truth ?

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jan 2006

My comments about the Post Maharaja Ranjit Singh period are as follows: 1. Good or bad, we never got a strong leader like Maharaja after him. Maharaja was the only person who was able to unite the Sikhs and the whole world saw the power of Sarkar-e-Khalsa. Maharaja died at such an early age of 51years. I am pretty certain that he was poisoned. It’s true that he was not the most perfect Sikh as far as rehit was concerned but Sikhi did flourish a lot in his rule and if he had ruled for another 50 years, whole of present day Pakistan, East Punjab, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu, Kashmir, and even Sindh would have been Sikh. There would have been no such thing as “Punjabi Hindu”. They all would have converted and their second or third generation would have been normal Sikhs. 2. Kanwar Nau Nihal Singh was a very promising leader. He was the son of Raja Kharak Singh, the eldest son of Maharaja jee. Raja Kharak Singh was a very saintly person who spent a lot of his time doing paath. He was a Sadhoo banda and he tried in vain to remove Dhyan Singh Dogra from the post of Prime Minister. Dhyan Singh incited Nau Nihal Singh to ascend to the throne in and imprison his own father. Nau Nihal Singh committed this blunder of imprisoning his saintly father and himself ascending to the throne. This created a very negative Karma for him. Raja Kharak Singh jee died as a result of slow poisoning at the hands of Dhyan Singh Dogra and the day he was cremated, both Kanwar Nau Nihal Singh and a son of Dhyan Singh Dogra died as a result of an accident. It was a divine punishment. Some historians claim that Nau Nihal Singh was murdered by Dhyan Singh Dogra but I don’t think that the mishap was a result of a conspiracy by Dogra. I think it was a divine punishment given to Nau Nihal Singh by Guru Sahib for imprisoning his father. 3. After the quick deaths of Raja Kharak Singh and Kanwar Nau Nihal Singh, Raja Sher Singh the second son of Maharaja jee ascended to the throne. Sher Singh was a very able and promising ruler and he too tried his best to control the situation but he failed because of the Duffer-ness and Dumbness of Sandhawalias namely Sardar Lehna Singh and his son Ajit Singh. They both were cousins of Maharaja Ranjit Singh but were really dumb people. They were very brave and courageous but they destroyed the Sikh kingdom. They deceived Raja Sher Singh and killed him and his son Kanwar Partap Singh. Can you imagine a Chacha killing his nephew and a grandfather killing his grandson (Partap Singh). Then they went on to kill Dhyan Singh Dogra. They both were in turn killed by the Sikh army who by now had formed a panchayat. 4. Maharaja Dalip Singh ascended to the throne under the patronage of Rani Jindan and she tried her best to control the damage but Dogras wouldn’t let it. They incited the Sikh army and got her brother Sardar Jawahir Singh killed. So much destruction followed. We got totally destroyed. 5. A very good development was the formation of army Panchayats. The whole army got organized under the leadership of Punj Pyaray chosen by the army. This went on for some time but before they could solidify themselves, they were pushed into the war with the British. In the war too we would have crushed the British but alas, our own leaders deceived us. 6. The only true leader we had in the post-Anglo-Sikh wars period was Baba Maharaaj Singh. Baba jee was instrumental in giving a humiliating defeat to the British in the Chillianwala battle of second Anglo-Sikh wars. This was the only battle in against British in which the Sikh leadership had not sold-out to British and in this war we did really good. I don’t understand why they abstained from totally annihilating the British army the same night after it was defeated in this battle. 7. If the Sikh kingdom had survived, it would have been the best country in the world. No country could have come even near our kingdom. Our population would have been at least 250 million. Alas! Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Harcharan Singh · 19 Jan 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, We do not know if our nation would have been the greatest. All you have to do is look at the division of our people now to see what turmoil there possibly could have been. Any man made "Kingdom" is doomed to failure, as it consists of a monarchy. In my humble opinion, Ranjit Singh sowed the seeds of destruction, by promoting the Mughal fashions: More than one wife Intoxication (drinking) Painting (Ranjit Singh started the trend encouraging of types of paintings relating to our Guru's i.e. with Hindu deitys). Not putting Akaal Takht above his own rule Gold Gilding on Darbaar Sahib (I personally find it offensive that he did this, he changed the pure design of Guru's, I have heard non-Sikhs talk of how out of sync the "Golden Temple" is with Sikhism and Sikhs i.e. humility. To name but a few. This would not have become "the best Kingdom". Plus, a Khalsa, a Sardaar, a Singh does not have a king, so I am not quite sure who's "Maharaj" Ranjit was. I am not taking away from his social, political and military genius, that is a given, but without naam, all was bound to end in tears. Above all else, Waheguru didn't wish it, so no alas, satnaam always knows and does best. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jan 2006

Harcharan Singh jeeo, It’s a given that Maharaja Ranjit Singh was not an ideal Sikh and I wrote this in my post but I do believe that if his kingdom had remained Sikhi would have flourished. Under Ashoka’s rule Buddhism spread far and wide. Under Muslim rule, Islam spread. Same way in under his rule and under his successors’ rule, Sikhi would have spread far and wide. Though he himself was not a Rehitvaan Sikh, most of the Hindus in Punjab had become Sikhs. When he died, most of the Hindus reverted back to their old religion. If Ranjit Singh’s raj had stayed for another generation or so, those converted Hindus would have stayed Sikhs. The reason I said that Sikh nation today would have been a great nation because Sikhs are very hard working and progressing people. With their hard work they would have created a strong and wealthy nation. This is my opinion. Kulbir Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

JS · 20 Jan 2006

Kulbir Singh wrote ' The only true leader we had in the post-Anglo-Sikh wars period was Baba Maharaaj Singh. Baba jee was instrumental in giving a humiliating defeat to the British in the Chillianwala battle of second Anglo-Sikh wars. This was the only battle in against British in which the Sikh leadership had not sold-out to British and in this war we did really good. I don’t understand why they abstained from totally annihilating the British army the same night after it was defeated in this battle. ' The Sikh commander Sher Singh Atariwala had also sufferred loses in the battle the Sikh strength was about 10,000 men at the start and the British and their Indian allies had about 30,000 plus Dogras. The Sikhs sufferred about 2000 casualities while the British lost 3000 men mostly the European solidiers (the Indians having run away at first sight of the Sikhs). The Sikhs were running low on ammunition so an immediate attack was not wise. Sher Singh having inflicted a defeat now wanted to negotiate with the British rather than fighting another costly battle as he did not have the same resources as the British and Indians. Sher Singh wanted Sikh rule restored over the Punjab but the British did not listen and wanted revenge.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jan 2006

JS, you are right in pointing out that Sardar Sher Singh hesitated in going all out assault because he was looking for negotiating. I wish they had gone for annihilating the British army. Sometimes I think that Maharaja Ranjit Singh should have never acceded Sindh to the British and should have fought a battle with them. He should have moved to take over the Malwa region of Punjab all the way up to Delhi. The Sikh kingdoms of Malwa really deceived our Panth by siding with the British. They went under the British protection and this is what enabled the British to come up to Sutlej river. Our natural boundry with rest of India was Yamuna and not Sutlej. So many blunders were committed at that time. British won in India out of sheer luck. So many times they won battles because of luck. Their first victory i.e. the battle of Plassey was won due to pure luck. God was on their side I guess. The Sikhs who had successfully taken on the Afghans would have easily defeated the British. The time for war with the British was 1820s and 1830s and certainly not early 1840s. Lord Dalhousie was a serpent. I have a very alive loathe for this fellow. Kulbir Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 21 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jeeo are you sure that was the full name of Baba Maharaaj Singh, because if it is, I really don't know anything concerning his existence. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh [%sig%]

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Harcharan Singh · 21 Jan 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, Sikhi is not so restricted so as to need geological boundaries. All we need to know is Waheguru didn't want us to have our country. A reason could be because the post-annex related suffering caused Sikhs (and thus Sikhi) to spread around the world. Just my opinion. You say "God was on their side", Veer ji, you should know better, sometimes God gives pain to the ones he loves. We could just as easily say God was on the Mughals side when they finally captured their nemesis Banda Singh Bahadur, I don't believe so. I believe Banda Singh and his armies shaheediyan fuelled courage in the Khalsa. It certainly invokes pride in me when I read European and Mughal accounts of Banda Singhs war and Shaheedi. There has been a lot of talk of how the British were decieptful, but Ranjit Singh was not exactly a saint. The only the reason the didn't dare attack Punjab during his reign was because they knew he was more crafty than they were. Don't forget how Ranjit Singh took over the Punjab and erased memory of the Misls i.e. getting rid of the Alluvalia and Ramgaria Bungas. Many people cry about the Kohinoor, but do they know it was acquired? I personally don't believe in "what if's - only if's", I believe everything Waheguru does is good, and we shouldn't regret history, we should learn from it. "Gorai" aren't the worst people to come to earth, all civilisations have grown through cruelty, cunning and politics i.e. Romans, Mongals, Mughals, Spanish (Americas) etc... It's just human nature, Punjabis are no different, Ranjit Singh was no different. The only important thing in the world is "Truth", learning it, living it and promoting it. Who is meant to rule in Kalyug will do so. Our Guru's accepted this fact, they weren't concerned with overthrowing rule, they were solely concerned with the propogation of the truth. Our Guru's and Mughal rulers only came into conflict when the truth was compromised. Waheguru ji ka Khasla Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

ghanna · 23 Jan 2006

"All we need to know is Waheguru didn't want us to have our country. A reason could be because the post-annex related suffering caused Sikhs (and thus Sikhi) to spread around the world. Just my opinion." raj karega khalsa! everything else agree. gorei in my experience can be far better than apnei they either like you or not, no slimey behind your back thing. Gorei may have done bad in some ways british raj but they have also given good to the world in development, organisation, transport, invensions and rational freethought.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

------ Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jeeo are you sure that was the full name of Baba Maharaaj Singh, because if it is, I really don't know anything concerning his existence. ------- Baba Maharaj Singh’s real name was Baba Nihal Singh but no one ever called him by that name. He was a sewadaar in the dera of Baba Bir Singh jee Naurangabad. While doing sewa in langar he used to call everyone maharaja e.g. Parshada jee Maharaaj, Daala jee Maharaaj, Jal jee Maharaaj etc. People started calling him Maharaj Singh. Another great sewadar at the dera of Baba Bir Singh jee was Baba Khuda Singh jee. Baba Maharaj Singh jee was a saint soldier. About Baba Bir Singh jee, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written with great respect and considered him to be a Jyot Vigaasi Singh. Same way, Baba Maharaj Singh jee was respected within the Sikhs as a Brahmgyani Singh. If Baba jee had stayed for another few years, he would have driven the British out. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. Further to what Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji has written above...may i add that Bhai maharaj Singh Ji was kept in an UNDERFROUND DUNGEON in Singapore. His cell was always dark..he soon lost his eyesight. There was only small opening in the roof through which some food and water was thrown down every few days. Bhai Sahib passed away and the dungeon was then sealed. Many years later, when Outram Prison was absorbed into the Singapore General Hospital, it was reported by the Contractors that any heavy machinery passing over a certian place would just die and refuse to move or topple over. The contractors or soembody placed a Guru Garnth Ji sahib there and started worshipping.. The Singapore Govt then dug the place and removed the remains of Bhai Sahib Maharaj Singh ( known as Baba Karam Singh locally) to Gurdwara Baba Karam Singh Samadh where they are buried in the Gurdawra Compund. After that no more disturbances and the construction proceeded smoothly. The name Baba KARAM Singh was probabaly an attempt by the British to Hide the reality that it was baba Maharaj Singh Ji who was a life time prisoner. Just like Baba Raam Singh and other Sikh Revolutionaris, it was a State secret as to where they were imprisoned. The details are a little sketchy..forgive me if anything is wrong. Probably a Singaporean may have better facts.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jan 2006

Veero, DONT put Maharaja Ranjit Singh down..because of a few faults. Who doesnt have faults ?? Maharaja ranjit Singh was the Best Punjabi maharaja after Raja Poros who was defeated by Alexander the Great only through TREACHERY of Raja Poros' brother. I am totally ashamed to be a Malawaii...becaause my fellow Malwaiis ( my pind is in Patiala and was under Bhoopie..grandfather of the Present Maharaja who prefers to be demoted to Captain !!) were TRAITORS to Khalsa Raaj and caused it to fall. I have lots of respect for Maharaja Ranjit Singh.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

bal krishan chandra · 24 Jan 2006

jarnail singh please do not be ashamed. what someone did 200 year ago not your fault. i suggest the new generation of amritdharis to very much not become regional, sikhs should increase cross state relations, ie malwa majha delhi jammu punjab and even pakistani sikhs. maybe a way forward malwa sikh marry majha sikh, jammu sikh marry doba sikh so then no such regional thing left. sikh is sikh chaktho fateh

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

khalsa · 24 Jan 2006

I THINK MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH WAS A GREAT LEADER !!!!! THE BEST THING THAT HE DONE WAS BRING SECURITY FOR THE SIKHS !!! NOBODY COULD MASSACRE SIKHS, ARE RIGHTS WERE SAFEGUARDED !! SOME THING WE DON'T HAVE NOW IN INDIA ! [%sig%]

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

45th Rattray's Sikhs · 25 Jan 2006

The Phulkian States provided the British with battalions of Sikh soldiers. In my collection, i have a couple of medals awarded to Sikhs by the British for serving in the Anglo-Sikh Wars. I feel bitter-sweet collecting so-called "traitor" medals, but i feel there of great historical importance. Sutlej Medal (1st. Sikh War) 2 Clasp + Moodkee Sobraon Aliwal SEPOY SURBDOWN SING 24TH Native Infantry Punjab Medal (2nd. Sikh War) 2 Clasp Goojerat Mooltan SEPOY JUGDEESE SINGH 52nd. Native Infantry The Punjab Medal really pours salt on the wounds as the medal depicts Sikh troops surrending their arms and bowing before the british. If anyones interested i can put-up some pics. (i have no idea how, but maybe i can send the pics to someone who does) 45th Rattray's Sikhs

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Singh · 25 Jan 2006

Please can you put some of your photos online. Are you a historian on the 45th some of my relatives served in this regiment during the 1st and 2nd World Wars.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

45th Rattray's Sikhs · 25 Jan 2006

that's pretty amazing 'singh'.... do you still have the medals in your family??? unfortunately, 90-95 % of medals have either been sold off by family members or melted down for silver value (silver boom of the 1970's) i have about a dozen medals to the 45th Rattray Sikhs..... ranging from Queen Victoria to WW1...... a WW1 uniform and a victorian pugri badge. if anyones interested in pics.... send me an email. 45th Rattray's Sikhs

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

avidya · 26 Jan 2006

Waheguruji Ka Khalsa Waheguruji Ki Fateh Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh ji I'm glad you mentioned Baba Maharaaj Singh ji and Baba Bir Singh Naurangabad. His example is exemplary in the way he decided to put down weapons and die honourably when attacked by the then Maharaja's Sikh forces, stating that he would not allow one of his men to harm a fellow Sikh. This famous Nirmala lineage linking with Baba Khuda Singh ji is explained in great detail in the large granth Sri Bir Mrigesh Gurbilas Devdharu written by another shish of the same dera, Pandit Sher Singh Ji. It is also worth noting that Baba Bir Singh Naurangabad alongwith Baba Khuda Singh ji hold key positions in a number of nirmalay upsamprdas.

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

same thing · 26 Jan 2006

I don't see how it was a good thing that the sikh's faught and died for the british rather then their own brothers and sisters. [%sig%]

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

av383 · 21 May 2006

I have read your article. How do you know, the medals are awarded to Sikh Soldiers? Could be Rajput or Dogra. I am also a collector. Still nice Medals to have. av383

Re: Anglo-Sikh War - what really happened?

Balwant Rao · 22 May 2006

the British succedded in India beause they hade greater depth in their man material OUr kingdoms would flourish under a powerful king but fall under their incompetent successors. The Britsh on the other hand has systmens of officers and ranks who were capable of filling in gaps when a leader fell all the way down to the common soldier The British were defeated on several occassions by the Marathas but instead they bided their time. After the death of Mahadji Sindhia the Marathas were led by incompetent and selfish leaders and his empire fell like a pack of cards His French trained captains and commander deserted the 'campoo' armies who were then almost killed to the last man by the Duke of Wellington The fault is ours. We did not train a sufficent officer class, backed up by strong economic factors and industry. The same thing happened after the death of Ranjit Singh The British had national unity. Half of the Sikhs were always seperate from the main body of Siihs united by Ranjit Singh. Whilst Ranjit SIngh is respceted by people in Maharashtra the cis Sutlej Sikhs are reagarded as treacherous who broke many treaties of friendship with the Marathas (1785 treaty etc) They supported the Pathan/Mughal war against the Marathas in 1788 They then supported the British against the Marathas in the 1803 war They then sided with the British against Ranjit Singh and in the two Sikh wars They still rule Punjab today