Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Preserving Sikh Heritage - on Ebay!!

Preserving Sikh Heritage - on Ebay!!

Curious Singh · 17 Jan 2006

Dear All On Ebay: http://search.ebay.com/_W0QQfgtpZ1QQfrppZ25QQsassZtoshkhana "Toshkhana", aka Parmjit Singh Grewal of Warrior Saints fame and his naive cousin Davinder Singh Toor appear to be making a tidy sum buy auctioning off artifacts that are of great significance to Sikhs, in other words, "Sikh Heritage". It is indeed an ironic twist of fate that an individual such as Parmjit has teamed up with Amandeep Madra - a self confessed preserver of "Sikh Heritage". This team of "Sikh Heritage" preservers have many other individuals under their influence, namely Jeevan Deol and Gurmeet Rai to name a few. I remember Parmjit Singh's latest co-author Nidar Singh having a pop at the Guru Nanak Nishkam Sewak Jatha, the Dumdumi Taksal and even the AKJ for the karsewa they have done at Harmandir Sahib, Akal Takht Sahib and Hazoor Sahib at a lecture at a London University. He commented with great pomp about the low level of skill used to preserve the work, and even hinted at these groups may be stealing gold, manuscripts, books, and other items. Perhaps the venerated Nidar Singh should also include Parmjit Singh, "Akaal Arms" (aka Runjeet Singh), "Khalsa Arms" (aka Sukhbinder "Two and a half strikes" Singh), in his list of the guilty, unless of course Nidar Singh himself is receiving a cut of the profits in which case it is understandable that he should turn a blind eye. Afterall, if your only means of income is through National Lottery grants, Heritage Funds, declaring bankruptcies on a regular basis, claiming disablity benefit, and tax fraud, then any avenue for money is welcome. From that advert on Ebay that closely appears to parallel the look of the posters for lectures on Sikh Heritage, the evidence seems to indicate that the public is being duped into believing these people have the interest of Sikhs at heart. I seem to recall their organisation being called "UKPHA" - UK Punjab Heritage Association. Ah - heritage I hear you cry! Isnt that what Parmjit and his dopey cousin are auctioning off on Ebay? The reality dear friends, is that anything will be sold (and is) for the right price. Are we to believe that auctioning off relics of India and Punjab is preserving them? What a handsome manner to make profit and contribute to Sikhism at the same time. I must have been asleep when this scheme was introduced as a quick way to do your bit for Sikhism. The items on the page alone if sold will fetch a few thousand Pounds Sterling - not bad for a day's work. (Oh Darn it!! I really missed the boat on this one eh?) Perhaps the Madra and Grewal clan was never told the bedtime story of Bhai Lalo. At least Maharaja Ranjit Singh would be happy in the sound knowledge that his portrait was on Ebay once! I would like to thank UKPHA for contributing to Sikhism in the manner they have. We can at least smile knowing that thier books and lectures are cheaper than the Sikh artifacts they are selling off on Ebay. Whether anyone would actually be idiotic enough to bid for their books knowing the dualist character of these people is another question. Nevertheless, a person cannot insult knowledge of any kind because that would be arrogance on his/her part. Amandeep and Parmjit should in future design a series of lectures regarding the history of each item that has been sold off by them on Ebay. It shouldnt be easy, especially if the Heritage Lottery fund is there to be looted. Consider it another angle of perserving heritage, one that is more colourful than the lackluster, and distinctly characterless performances exhibited at the lectures done previously - the exception being Jeevan Deol and Gurmeet Rai, both of whom expressed remarkable wisdom. I would like to make a suggestion - please avoid lectures being given by washed up accountants. Accountants are dull whether they are in a job or not! Sikh Heritage - going once, going twice - sold to the highest bidder!

Re: Preserving Sikh Heritage - on Ebay!!

S Singh · 18 Jan 2006

Not exactly rare Sikh heritage. Most the pieces are very common and far from being rare.

Re: Preserving Sikh Heritage - on Ebay!!

Harcharan Singh · 18 Jan 2006

Curious, You obviously have your own hidden agenda here, and your propoganda is a pathetic effort. I've looked at the weapons on E-bay, where does it say that any of them are Sikh? For your information, Muslims and Hindus were using these same weapons over the last 600 years also. The adverts clearly state, Turkish, Hindu, Perisan etc... What proof so you have that these items have been obtained illegally? If they have why don't you report this to the relevant authorities? And even if they were selling Sikh weapons (which they aren't), what business is it of yours if you don't have proof of illegal activity? If you are so concerned why don't you put all your excess energy into bidding for the items and preserving them? Please have some shame and stop spreading hate and nindah for what is so clearly your own personal problem witht the people you have mentioned. Guru Kirpa Hacharan Singh

Re: Preserving Sikh Heritage - on Ebay!!

MS · 18 Jan 2006

Not that im speaking in defense of any Nangs or various other thuglikes out there however some of the concernes with regards to the 'seva' at darbar sahib do seem genuine and we have seen pics on this forum as to the state of disrepair and the 'strip and patch' approach gone into 'restoring', again not an attack on anyone just an acknoledgement that they are not necessarily wrong on all their points. Possibly one of their reasons for saying the above could be to get some credibility as its a serious issue. Secondly, as for the grants etc... Well isn't that what they are there for. I find it sad that thuggies are able to gain easy access to govt money only so that they can pocket it for themselves as you claim curious singh, but we are unable to access these funds for our own geuine positive projects..

Re: Preserving Sikh Heritage - on Ebay!!

BirRaas Singh · 18 Jan 2006

An image of Harmandir Sahib, or a Indo Persian weapon isnt exactly "Sikh Heritage", Sikh Heritage would be items such as the original weapons of the Gurus, Gifts handed by the Guru to their Sikhs, manuscripts attributed to the Gurus etc. The architecture in historical Gurdwaras IS Sikh Heritage, the arts of the Sikhs such as Raag and Shastar Vidiya IS Sikh Heritage, things which Niddar Singh is actively trying to promote and preserve. A very weak attempt at character assassination.