Punjab not trusted by India
BS · 21 Jan 2006
Punjab is still a disturbed state according to India after saying for years that state was under their control again. Why do Sikh passenger have to get special security clearance to travel to Pakistan? Is this the freedom that Sikhs died for? Tribune Amritsar-Lahore bus Road is still not smooth enough It is not enough to just utter sweet nothings on the need for warming up India-Pakistan relations or roll out a ceremonial red carpet when the bus from Lahore arrives in Amritsar. The air of distrust and suspicion that still prevails must be sincerely removed to make the people-to-people contact really meaningful. That passengers are shying away from boarding the Amritsar-Lahore bus, thanks to irritating security concerns of extra-cautious mandarins on both sides of the border, points to the need for restoring their confidence and removing whatever irritants remain. Of course, there can be less obtrusive and less jarring ways of keeping an eye on undesirable elements trying to cross the border. It could have been an ominus start. The Centre had unwittingly hurt Punjabi sensitivities by treating the state as a disturbed area like Jammu & Kashmir. The damage, however, was controlled well in time. Although the Union Home Ministry has withdrawn the objectionable security vetting, travel is still not hassle-free. That the passengers are required to buy tickets well in advance, perhaps to check their credentials, is fair enough. But why should those boarding the bus at Amritsar need to first go to Delhi to secure a visa? Isn’t it simpler for the Pakistan authorities to open a visa office in Amritsar to avoid inconvenience to travellers? Their enthusiasm and goodwill must not be robbed at the very start of a journey. The Amritsar-Lahore bus service, the third after the success on the Srinagar-Muzaffrabad and Delhi-Lahore routes, is only a first step towards building far more cordial relations. If both countries divert their resources from competitive defence spending to cementing and extending cooperation on the economic, cultural and sports fronts, people on both sides of the border would breathe much easier. Ideally, sports, medicare, trade and tourism should be insulated from diplomatic highs and lows in India-Pakistan relations.