Sikhi and Science
Harcharan Singh · 27 Jan 2006
Leicester University Sikh Society ® - ARTICLES Science has used this quite successfully since hypothesising, reasoning and proving have to be reliable and valid, wherever, whenever and by whoever they are done. Clearly then most things which are observable would fall under these categories; quite a few invisible ones would also fit into this category, so long as their effect can be detected indirectly. Example of visible things: petrol in a car would make the car move provided engine (a device to convert one form of energy into another) is there. Who moves the car? Energy. Can we see it? No, but its effect is apparent. Example of invisible things: Cathode Ray tube, where high energy electrons hit the zinc sulphide coated screen and causes it to fluoresce, the energy of which falls within the visible part of the spectrum. Remember, electrons are not visible and cannot ever be seen by the human eye since they would penetrate the light sensitive cells in the eye and will destroy them in the process. Clearly then in Science, so called "belief "in the realm of religion is replaced by 'proof', which must be reliable and valid even if obtained indirectly. Whilst this makes Science a very powerful discipline, and in today's world counts for its growing fortune, it is also its misfortune; the latter is not realised by many - neither by scientists (majority of them!) nor by their followers (brain washing!). Some of you are beginning to ask yourself this question as to whether what I am saying is true: can scientists be really brain washed by their own activities? The answer is YES. Clearly if we look back what we have discussed, we see that while Science will always strive for perfection too, it will never quite reach there! Why? It asks question, it solves it by the best possible tools available at the time. It gives rise to ten more questions in all directions. Solving these ten in a similar way as above raises further hundred. Take an example of any modern or past invention and see that ideas emerge from the mind as hypotheses, then reasoned and give rise to some crude model. When it is tried and tested, the process of refinement begins since its side effects become apparent. The process of perfection, based on reasoning continues for ever ……. ? Science or Sikhi-Conclusion: Science and Sikhi are not mutually exclusive though science and other religions may be. While in science things happen because of a favourable chance, according to Sikhi they happen because of the Will of Akal Purakh, Viz. hukmY aSdir sBu ko bfhir hukm n koie] jup jI, m[1, g[g[s 1 Listen to Guru Granth Sahib Ji again: “shs isafxpf lK hoih q iek n clY nfil]” jpu jI, g[g[s, p[1 (that is: even if thousands of thoughts and wisdoms were possessed, none shall accompany (me)). So, the ultimate truth, the Creator, cannot be reasoned out. As opposed to Science, religion is a belief. You may say then that if God cannot be found by reasoning, does this mean that the people should just submit themselves to the Will of God? How do we know what we are doing is right? After all what we are trying to sort out is being reasoned ….. ? ? Answer to the first question is that we do need to submit TOTALLY AND UNCONDITIONALLY. Second question is more serious and in fact relates to the first in the sense that some of you may say that it is a "blind faith" then, surely Science is lot better than this! Precisely, so, I will quote Guru Nanak Dev Ji again: …[aklI sfihbu syvIaY aklI pfeIaY mfnu] aklI piVÙ kY buJIaY aklI kIcY dfnu] nfnku afKY rfhu eyhu hoir glF sYqfnu]1] (m[1, 1245) Wise thing to do is to recite the Lord and be honoured; wise thing to do is to read (the bani that praises Lord), understand its deep intricate secrets and to expound to the others. Says Nanak! This is the only righteous path of life; s/he who tells otherwise is a Satan. Clearly then in submitting to His Will, Guru does not want us to lose our senses, to discern right from wrong; He only wants our total belief, so far as we don't doubt God. So we are instructed to be warned and look out for fake sadhus and sants and gurus (and there is no shortage of them in today's world !). Answer to the third question has automatically been given; while we have used reasoning to find out right from wrong, once on the right path, the time must not be wasted; INVOLUTION must begin. “mY Kojq Kojq jI hir inhclu su Gru pfieaf] ……” sUhI, m[5, CMq, g[g[s, 785 “……[[Kojq Kojq Koijaf nfmY ibnu kUru] jIvn suKu sBu sfD sMig pRB mnsf pUru]2]” iblfvlu mhlf 5, g[g[s 811 “Kojq Kojq pRB imly hir kruxf Dfry] ……[” kydfr, CMq m[5, g[g[s 1122 “soDq soDq soiD qqu bIcfiraf] nfm ibnf suKu nfih srpr hfiraf]4]” sUhI, m[5, g[g[s, 761 Clearly then what we should believe must not by pass of our scrutiny, whether we are on the right path. From here on ward, the Guru's Shabad, the Nam, the Amrit, begins to lead you in leaps and bounds. The state of reasoning, while supremely high in the scientific world, is very low in the search for the ultimate truth, the Creator. Where Science ends, Sikhi begins. Those who have found Him have become like Him; He is beyond description and so are His saints! No body created Him, He is rootless and free from illusion. “ Qfipaf n jfie kIqf n hoie] afpy afip inrMjnu soie]” m[1, g[g[s 2 Says Guru Gobind Singh Ji that Akal Purkh is neither reduced nor increases, He pervades His creation uniformally at all times. He who remains in command from the beginning to the end, know Him to be my Guru. “ n vfD hY n Gft hY n vfD Gft hoiq hY ……” akfl Ausqiq, d[g, p[10 “ nf Ehu bZY n Gtqf jfie] akul inrMjn eykY Bie]” gAuVI, kbIr jI, g[g[s 383 Now lets have a look at how Guru Granth Sahib Ji answers the questions we put in the beginning, namely, • who you are and why you are here? • beginning of creation and how it is going to end? • cloning and playing God? Says Guru Granth Sahib Ji that you are part of that big play which has been played for countless number of ages. In the beginning was this singularity and nothing else; through shabad the whole visible and invisible game began: kIqf psfAu, eyko kvfAu, iqs qy hoie lK drIafAu]16] From one word (the Lord) evolved everything; thousands of rivers of life sprang - (cf. with big bang; it is big alright but without a bang). The visible form therefore is an expansion of the formless. The Lord has no colour, caste, creed, nor any physical shape or form. The actual account of creation in detail appears under: "arbd nrbd DUMDUkfrf, Drin n ggnf hukm apfrf] (mfrU, m[1, g[g[s 1035)." In essence, Sikhism states the followings: From Lord came air, from air came water and from water came lower beings, evolving into higher beings, including plants, culminating in humans as the supreme product of evolution. It does not advocate instant creation neither that the evolution is at an end. I do not know whether Prof. Hawking has made up his mind yet but Sikhism says that anything and everything that is created shall change and vanish one day, including the earth and the sky and the multiple universes. “Driq afkfsu pfqflu hY cMdu sUru ibnfsI] m[5, g[g[s 1100 The earth, sky, nether regions, moon, sun - all shall vanish. This game has been played many times before: “keI bfr psirE psfr] sdf sdf ieku eykMkfr]” suKmnI, m[5, a[10, g[g[s • So why are you here on this earth? BeI prfpq mnuK dyhurIaf goibMd imln kI ieh qyrI brIaf] m[5 It is your supreme duty, inter alia, that you received this body for one purpose and one purpose only: to realise that this is the time to unite with the Lord. Once the game is over, it is too late, - seek therefore here and now; heaven and hell are here and now. Imperfect shall transmigrate again and again. ~Mjogu ivjogu dooie kfr clfvih lyKY afvih Bfg] m[1, jpu jI (29) To unite and depart are the two ways bestowed by the Lord, according to our deeds. • Why do we want to be cloned? Sikhi supports all such research which is beneficial for the whole and which is both morally and ethically observed. For example, experimentation on the stem cells for producing organs would be acceptable - this is helping but creating a designer babies or cloning to live for ever is morally wrong and unethical. Here is Guru Granth Sahib's answer to this: jy jug cfry afrjf hor dsUxI hoie] If one could live a life equivalent to four ages and were to extend it by further ten folds; nvf KMzf ivic jfxIaY nfil clY sBu koie] Became popular/famous in the nine continents (of the world) and all were to be obedient; cMgf nfAu rKfie kY jsu kIriq jig lyie] Acquired a good name, became praised and fame worthy world over; jy iqsu ndir n afveI q vfq n puCY ky] But if one did not come under the gracious eye of the Akal Purakh (despite all the name and fame), one be ignominious and insignificant; kItf aSdir kItu kir dosI dosu Dry] Worm amongst worms; guilty of being forgetful of the Name; nfnk inrguix guxu kry guxvMiqaf guxu dy] qyhf koie n suJeI ij iqsu guxu koie kry] 7] O, Nanak! The Creator confers virtues on the virtue less, and greater virtues upon the pious ones. There is none else who could match Lord’s blessing (7). So in Sikhi, contentment is very important. To have happy and healthy body with healthy mind that is enlightened (conscious) with Lord is far more important than living for ever. So, I return to the question being asked in the beginning: whether religions are relevant to our lives in the modern computer age? I cannot speak for the others but the religion of the Nam, the Guru Granth Sahib,shall march on and on and on, undented by science’s discoveries. After all, the religion of the Nam is also discovery not ours but bestowed upon us as a realisation by the Lord, that it is He who is in control and shall remain so for ever more, no matter what, for Guru Nanak says: hukmY aSdir sBu ko bfhir hukm n koie] jup jI, m[1, g[g[s 1 Everything that happens is within His command, none is outside. Essence: • The Creator is invisible and supreme. It cannot be felt by our five senses and is only realised by few. • Science tests visible and invisible things that can be proved directly or indirectly; it is inherently evolutionary and therefore, both its instruments and analysis shall never be final. • Science can never find God, although it may play God! • Sikhi and Science are not mutually exclusive, they are same in most cases, except a) Science does not accept the Creator, neither answers where everything has come from; Science accepts chances, Sikhi His Will. • Sikhi begins where Science ends. Sikhi is total revelation from Akal Purakh. © Dr H S Dhillon, delivered on 10th October 2004 on the Quad Centennial of the Adi Granth Sahib Ji’s first installation in Harmandar Sahib, Amritsar, in 1604, at the Singh Sabha International (UK) convention at Cranford Community College, Cranford. [address removed]