Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

Deep Singh · 31 Jan 2006

Quoted in "Memo on developing better indicators of ethnic and non ethnic identities" by Steven Wilkinson (May 3, 2002, LiCEP 5) presented at LICEP 5th Meeting, Stanford University. "[In] the Indian state of Punjab [the 'East' Punjab State], we know that a majority of Hindu Punjabi speakers in that state declared themselves as speaking Hindi in the 1961 census as part of a movement by the Arya Samaj organization to block a Sikh-led movement for the partition of Punjab along linguistic grounds. As a result of this strategic switch the proportion of Punjabi-speakers dropped from over 60% in previous Punjab censuses [as in 1951] to 41% in 1961." Original source: Paul Brass, Language, Religion and Politics in North India (Cambridge University Press, 1974) pp.293-97. This implies that about 33% decrease in the number of Punjabi speakers in the 'East' Punjab State (before the creation of "Punjabi Suba" in 1966). Another rough estimate (based on the proportion of Sikh (ca.33%) and Hindu (ca.65%) populations in the 'East' Punjab State) is that around 50% of Punjabi Hindus abandoned Punjabi as their mother tongue from 1951 to 1961. This should mean that parts of Haryanvis (and some areas in Himachal) also were Punjabi speaking areas, but the locals abandoned Punjabi in order to block the formation of a Punjabi state... Shocking!!

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

A Singh · 31 Jan 2006

Lala Jagat Narian played a key role in convincing majority Hindus to declare, their mother tongue as Hindi in 1961 census. Majority Hindus declared Hindi as their mother tongue in cencus but continue to speak Punjabi till date. In Harayan and Himachal still a sizable Punjabi speaking population can be seen.

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

Truth · 31 Jan 2006

If you visit Punjab NOW.... 1. 55% Sikh...and shrinking 2. only 10% Youth (below the age 20) visible Sikhs We got Punjab now, but within the next 10-15 years, Sikhs will become a minority in Punjab due to migration, lower birth rate, assimilation into wider Hindu society. Already the Amritdhar population stands at only roughly 10-15% from the Sikh population. In 20 years the combined population of Amritdhari non-Amritdhari, monay will be around 40% in Punjab.

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Jan 2006

The Home Minister at the time was Gulzari Lala nanda..staunchest of the staunch Kattarr Arya Samajist..and he was instruemntal in all these doings to make Punjabi Suba as small a SUBEE as possible ( they knew the demand for PS would have to be conceded no matter what...so try to put as many minggnnan as possible into the "milk"...and on the opposite side they ahd traitors like Sant fateh Singh who would do ardass at Akal Takhat..even make a Havan Kund ( for self immolations) to die ...and then BACK OFF..these traitors helped the Govt no end to castrate the sikhs Demands... the result is before us...no capital, no rivers, no electricity, no industry, no education, NOTHING..except plant as much rice for the rest of India at cheap prices but buy back the fertiliser at sky high prices..why do you think the Naxalbari Movement earlier 1970's and then the Youth Movement of the 1980s arise.. Such "Communalist HINDUS" as the Punjabi Arya Samajists DONT EXIST anywhere else except in Punjab/Haryana/Delhi ( so called Hindi belt)..and it is these who have led the Anti Sikh, Anti Punajb tirade all these years..leading first to Craetion of Pakistan..then all the troubles of 1984. That is why the other 99% of Indian Hindus fail to see what the problem of the Sikhs/Punjab is ?? Hardline Sikhs treat ALL HINDUS as their enemy....while ONLy the 0.5% of the ARYA SAMAJIST HIndus are the real enemy...they have managed to hide behind the other good Hindus. Unfortunatley these 0.5% are 95% in the GOI....and GOI rules India...so the other 90% good hindus cant do anything about it as they are unaware !!

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

KS · 01 Feb 2006

It was this sense of betrayal by Punjabi Hindus which has led to the current situation in Punjab. many people try to blame the Sikhs for all troubles , but there were many provacations to the Sikhs which led to 1984. Even today the Arya Samaj have their propaganda by appearing on 'Yoga' programmes on Cable/Satellite which many Sikhs watch and recommend, without relising that Hindu ideas are being pushed.

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

5abi · 01 Feb 2006

Lets also not forget how we Punjabis were also betrayed by Bandit Nehru and Gandoo Jee.

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

5abi · 03 Feb 2006

Sat Sri Akal Vir Vijaydeep Singh Jee I understand where you are coming from. But being a Sikh, Nehru and Gandhi really anger me alot. Even the Hindutwa movment did not like them. Just go to the hinduunity.org or swardoftruth.com and you will see that they hate those two men. Nehru supported all the Arya Samaji newspapers in north india which was always anti Sikh and even anti-Punjabi. Even Bandit Nehru's economic systems was a disaster for India, because of which India has not been able to progress much economically. Those two deserve the name Bandit Nehru and Gandoo Jee. [%sig%]

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

Dogra · 03 Feb 2006

Good post Vijaydeepji! This Arya samaji just play communal politiking. Punjabi is the language of Punjab. If people want to learn Hindi then fine, like an optional subject at school. But English and Punjabi should be compulsory throughout Old Punjab.

Re: Census of 1961: How Punjabis abandoned their mother tongue

singh · 07 Feb 2006

i think most of the hindu punjabi jaats chose hindi as their momis tongue in hariane. these people dont seem to look punjabi, they certainly do not have punjabio traditions except for north indian punjab given republican values of panchayt, sarpanch. The surnames of jaats do not match with punjabis like tonk, takur, alawat, lamha bagaria etc. The jaats neither have obvious punjabi folk culture ie bhangra, giddah, or punjabi folk dress. The hindu punjabis opted for hariana as their homeland are 4 distinct divisions of migrants baghris ( from rajistan deserts) dheswalis from UP, dhes ( apparently punjabi ie sandhus sidhus gills but not heard of any so far) and another division perhaps pachadda branch. their music does not even appear to be punjabi or hindi. all in all overly nationalist, strangely still believe they are punjabi when their customs do not match in punjab. the national turban for jaats is green as opposed to the punjabi sikh buddhist and hindu orange.