Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

French editor fired over cartoons

French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 02 Feb 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sangat Jeo A French editor has been fired over publishing cartoons of Holy figures sitting on a cloud with the caption "Don't worry Muhammad, we've all been caricatured here". These cartoons included Holy figures from the Buddhish, Jewish,Christian and Muslim religion. What will be next? France is already the center of attention with both Sikhs and Muslims after they hype about removing of the Hajaab and Turbans. If this has happened with all these religions whats not to say the next cartoon feature would be that of Dhan Dhan Sahib Guru Nanak Dev Ji or any of the Dus Pathshahi's.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 02 Feb 2006

I agree with freedom of speech, but this is really crossing the line a bit. No one has the right to make fun of religous figures.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Harcharan Singh · 03 Feb 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, The offence to Muslims is "slightly" more, than that to other faiths in "my opinion". Islam has never allowed the image of their Prophet Mohammed to be portrayed. This is something highly respectful and all credit to Mussalmaan who after being here for 1500 years have heeded their faith and resisted the urge to create imaginery images of their leader, which inevitably leads to idol worship. The same cannot be said for Zorastors, Hindus, Buddists, Christians and Sikhs. Sikhs were strong in understanding the "poison" of imagery of God's servants also. It was only during Ranjit Singhs reign that depictions of Guru Sahibaan spiralled out of control due to Ranjit Singhs love of Mughal art and lack of Gurmat. Today we see the power and poison of image portrayel. One example is the painting of Bebe Nanaki tying a rakhri on Guru Nanak Dev Ji. This picture which is found in Sikh homes all over the world, has single handedly thrust the spear of Brahmanism in to the Sikh diasphora. Sikhs all over the world now practice this Brahman ritual citing the "fact" that Bebe Nanaki tyed a Rakhri, so it's ok. The fact that Guru Nanak Dev ji placed his trust in Akaal Purkh and not is magical protective threads (and such would not have allowed females to either) is completely ignored. Upon refusing to accept the Brahmans customary janeu, Guru said: "Let mercy be the cotton, contentment the thread, Continence the knot and truth the twist. O priest! If you have such a thread, Do give it to me. It'll not wear out, nor get soiled, nor burnt, nor lost. Says Nanak, blessed are those who go about wearing such a thread" This is just one example of how allowing imagery portrayel of Guru Sahibaan has wreaked havock on the Panth. Journalists, people with hidden agendas, artists will not stop abusing and insulting faiths, this is just the start. They will all say, "if you can paint your spiritual masters using your imagination, then why can't we"? Especially since Sikhi has become so divided and so many people believing in so many different versions of Sikh history, what is stop anyone painting a picture from the numerous sakhis, and adding their own twists? I am not saying we should not have pictures of History or of Shaheed, this inspires, but we must try and eradicate pictures and the now popular small silver moorthian of our Guru's that are decorating Sikh homes Guru ghar the world over. Unless we do something about this, this is going to a huge source of pain for the Panth in the near future. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan Singh

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

singh-2 · 03 Feb 2006

this is an incident which shows the eagerness of european secularists to ridicule religion in the name of free speech. free speech is never absolute and cannot be justified when causing gratuitous offence for a cheap laugh. this is just what these european societies just dont get; there are people for whom their religious belief is everything to them and to poke fun at their religion is to poke fun at them. when they dont have any strong beliefs themselves they find it impossible to comprehend that anyone else can value something so much so as to be so offended at a cartoon. for the sikh community in the uk there are two pressures in this debate. as always we have to distinguish who we are and so have to make clear we are not muslims. i heard jagjit singh do this on radio 5 live this morning and it is important. however, we must also not lose site of the big picture. this incident is an another example of the attack by european secular societies against all peoples of faith not just muslims. they express it through anti-muslim sentiments bacause muslims are more in number in europe and are considered fair game post sept 11. but dont be fooled into thinking these attacks are merely anti-muslim. they are anti any group that doesnt fit into the european ideal in terms of looks, dress, culture, values, beliefs etc. anyone expressing indignation at the collapse of morality in western european countries is a target. religious head-dress is outlawed but wearing revealing short skirts is encouraged; arranged marriage is backward but same sex marriage is considered enlightened - the list goes on. muslims are merely becoming the new jews of europe but the underlying intolerence of difference is the same. for example look at the furore created when sikhs protested against the besti play in birmingham. the same old tired arguments of free speech were used then as they are used now for these anti muslim cartoons. i am unsure whether sikh groups supported the recent bill on outlawing religious hatred in the uk but we should have. [%sig%]

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Jagjit Singh · 03 Feb 2006

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Pyare jio, for anyone who has not seen the cartoon, they can be seen on http://www.di2.nu/files/Muhammed_Cartoons_Jyllands_Posten.html I spoke on radio 5 live in the discussion about this earlier today. I am amazed at how big this has become. I do think muslims are handling it completely wrong. The cartoons are really poor. But the way muslims have reacted, they have given them alot of prominence. I feel western people have come to a point where they feel completely comfortable in rediculing religion. In fact, they enjoy it. Much of this is due to the dogmatic nature of Christianity, Islam, Judiaism, which are very fable and ritual based. The general lack of spirituality has made people feel that they are not special. Sikhism and Buddhism by nature are fundamentally spiritual, but they too have felt the brunt of the atheist agenda of so-called artists. The BNP court victory and behaviour of muslims have shown the darker side of freedom of speech, and the effects of its irresponsible use. I only found one cartoon funny, the rest were really poor. I do not think they should be published. But muslims who are calling for " A day of Anger" need to realise they are representing the very fundamentalism that these artist are attacking. I do think once again the beard and turban are caught in the heart of this. This will as always build peoples sterotypical predjudices against beards and turbans, ultimately affecting Sikhs. Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

curious · 03 Feb 2006

It's very impressive to see our Muslim brothers and sisters rally together at this time over this contoversy. See how they stood up for their faith. I hope this same spirit will bel alive in the Panth because the time will also come when Guruji will ask us to stand up. Let's stay Tyar Bar Tyar Singho!

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Gill · 03 Feb 2006

Don't we have cartoons of our Gurus? I mean by untrained bad painters! LOL

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Dogra · 03 Feb 2006

'Idol worship', each to their own. Portrait of the writings of the Koran is a different form of idol worship! There is no right or wrong, but ones conduct as a human being. The reaction of death threats is crossing the line, people can criticise these cartoons, but not burning flags and condemning nations. Saudi Arabia, wont even allow bibles in their country, yet have withdrawn thei ambassador.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Harcharan Singh · 04 Feb 2006

Dogra Ji, Would you therefore classify bowing to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as idol worship? It is amazing that Muslims put beautiful extracts of the Koran on their walls, this allows them to reflect on their given word of God, it is educational, inspiring, gives guests something spiritual to speak about. Muslims do not pray to the Koran. This is no way idol worship. Sikhism condems idol worship, meaning the worship of the false. If our Guru's never allowed any portrait to made of them (when art was prolific during the Mughal rule), why do think this was? Worshipping/praying/doing ardaas to stones, statues or paintings is not gurmat. These things are not and in no way represent God. We bow to our Guru Ji to give our head to them, to show allegiance, loyalty and submission to their hukum. Sikhs do ardaas to the formless Akaal Purkh only. I agree with you , each to their own, but as this is a Khalsa website, we must revolve all discussions around Khalsa maryada. As for the angry reaction, at least the Eurpopean Governments are listening and apologising, be it for their own security and economy. I don't agree with death threats, but certainly boycotting the relevant country (by burning flags) will teach them to have a more responsible attitude. I think it is excellent that the Middle East boycotted Danish goods and as a result have sent 2 major Danish companies into liquidation, as the Middle East made up a large part of their customer base. This is using non-violent means to make your point, this is in the tradition of Baba Ram Singh ji, who the British has to exile in order to save their economy. What reaction do you think Sikhs would have if this had been derogatory images of our Guru's? An angry one, and there would have been plenty of death threats, don't forget the huge numberof death threats that Gurpreet Bhatti received because of her offensive play...

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Jang VEER Bahadur Singh · 04 Feb 2006

This is NOTHING more than show case hypocrisy!The problem is muslims do not know neither have democracy in their own countries. They bann everything they see a threat to islam!to the extent of even bricking alive two little 7 ad 9 year old sahibzade- here they are ranting and raving about cartoons!When they regard killing a kaffir as duty - they should regard this as a matter to be laughed at. People admiring muslims and supporting their stupid hoo haa cause are no better to realise the truth and facts!The argument is simple,if you hate the western ideas sooo much JUST GO BACK TO WHERE YOU COME FROM, no body stops you ! I would suggest they first go and practice freedom in their own coutries where to build a gurduara or a church can be a crime.Bibles are not allowed in many countries and Guru Grnath sahib was banned in Saudi arabia.In fact it was only recently S arabia lifted the ban of Sikhs and any one with the name of Singh from entering SArabia. These is nothing but HYPOCRISY of the lowest level -speaking with fork tongues and values about islam and lesser valaues about another religion!! Sikhs have their own issues than to worry about these silly cartoons! if cartoons can upset a religion, there is nothing much in such religion! Just imagine how much has bollywood tried to upset sikhs, yet we shine through and get tougher and hard! if we have become a lughing stock sometimes, it is not the movies, bUT the cartoony and joker behaviours of Sikhs leaders themselves! What stops us making cartoons of such editors, and joining in the world to laugh at them??

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Dogra · 04 Feb 2006

Harcharan Singhji, 'idol worship' is to help in focusing towards the words of God. Everyone has their own path in how to do this. Hindu faith have idols, they are a representation to chanel towards God, Mulsim faith have writings of the Koran in their homes, this again is to focus on the words of God. As regards the boycotting Danish goods, when a newspaper published the cartoon, is just racism pure and simple. Deal with the individuals, but do not cundemn a people. Also in Islamic countries do people enjoy freedom to practise their own faith, as they do in the west? The % of the minority population of Pakistan has drastically dropped since partition why? In India the % of Muslim faith population has remained, if not increased, the same.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

curious · 04 Feb 2006

Forget carttoons, we have people this world burning Birs of Guru Granth SahiAnd what do we do about it.....nothing! I pray to Waheguru that another leader comes soon, Like Sant Ji did, to wake us up.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 05 Feb 2006

why do you need someone like sant ji to come and wake you up? can you not be awake by yourself?

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Smethwickwala · 05 Feb 2006

why do we seem to be waiting for leaders to come on the scene ? whats wrong with us? i'm sure they are loads of gursikhs out their that are tuned into sikhi whats wrong with our gursikhs talking out against things, but instead every1 seems to be waiting for another sant ji? its up to the khalsa to make amends not an individual person.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Jang VEER Bahadur Singh · 05 Feb 2006

all they are good is showing to the world that they are good gursikhs!nothing else!they have no worry about the patit sikh children.they have no worry about Sikh girls running off with muslims and others.Instead they proudly call them Sikhs!they are not worried about sikh girls being killed by parents in the hope of a son!they are not interested in spreading sikhi but showing off their own.They are silent in all government quarters about sikh voice.they will not even break their silence to asset Sikh voice.they are not concerend about sikhs becomming christians.But as soon as one organuisations is set up they are so incencesed that they will set another one up. It is all empty talk and shouts about khlaistan.We cannot run united Gurduara ,instead we have divided ourselves into so many jataan pataan.Now we have some tiddi dal dal khalsa running down the kala takhat!twenty years alter all these dal jhalsis have ever done is sit with people who have no good for the sikhs community and drank cups of tea! so much so i could NOT care less anymore which idiot is sgpc or akali dal or congressi ..in their own ways they are all BIG mouths.These akj, ddt and dal khalsis are just about wasting their own time and others who follow them blindly! No no wants to eardicate jaat paat, stand for sikh values, do parchar to the rest of india and increase sikh numbers. All they do is argue about vege or non vege when it has been clearly decided, argue who wears a round pagrri or square pagrri or no paggrrri ...who is akj or who less ddt , they are all detached from reallity and living in a zombie wolrd...they worry about muslim koran, when they cant sort out their own problems! An honest circus the sikhs are in .

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 06 Feb 2006

WJKK WJKF To be be perfectly honest Jang Veer Bahudur Singh I am quite diguested with your views and opinion. So I guess your saying if one is bad so are the rest so it doesn't matter let them suffer while we stand and watch closely buy. For you kind information when I was working for a certain company and my turban was ridiculed the only person to stand up for me was a muslim who back me and supported me all the way. My so called Sikh brothers and trust me their was no shortage of them stood back and watch in silence so I guess they were having a good laugh at my expense because the Crown bestowed on my head my dastarr given by Dhan Dhan Sahib Sir Guru Gobind Singh Ji was a reason for a joke. I don't even know why people like you bother to even present your arguements. When Gury Sahib was fighting the mugals it was to protects the rights of others, if he was so strongly against Islam - why was the foundation of Akal Takht Sahib laid by a muslim pir, I guess your knowledge is probably greater in comparison to that of our Guru Sahibs. I suggest you think strongly before you decided to put forward such a pathetic argument. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 06 Feb 2006

jang bahadhur Singh For some one with a name like that, your thinking is very Tendi kala! What is the point of having a chardi kala name if your are going to spend all your time talking negative rubbish. Every individual needs to stand and be counted. Why are looking at others, when you should look at yourself first.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

polsia · 06 Feb 2006

al mushrooms did beyadbi in their leaflets on guru nanak ji, khalifa did too. a muslim writer in pakistan wrote sikhs used to be thieves. what happened to freedom of speech then? respect is a two way street. muslims openly mock other religions in england. according to a gujrati muslim work colleague they should protest and hold public debate about their prophet being criticised but not be like kids spoilt by freedom. the media is weird. a white middle class cambridge educated lawyer was stabbed to death by a few blacks, he came on news for 2 weeks. a sikh punjabi was dragged t his death by robvbers the same day not even one mention of the punjabi. kio?

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Jang VEER Bahadur Singh · 06 Feb 2006

singh qquite the contcarary your thinking is the most stupid and fully contradictory I have ever come across. No body said individuals are bad.Are you calling the british police fools who are now studying along ...the troble makers in knightbridge! For one muslim that stood, it look like you are so ignorant of your own views thousands killed sikhs for no reasons from the times of Guru Arjan Dev ji.Either you are selectively ignorant or totally uneducated about history and reality. If we follow YOUR line of argument, there is a Sikh PM and Sikh general of the Indian army ...go and tell the Khalistanis and the many other groups there is NO need for khalistan ..as all is well. Bhai sahib , the likes of you say because one individual muslim who was MORE human than anything else spoke up , does not mean all are well and fine.those causing mayhem on the streets must be Sikhs then ?those that ransacked the streets in jakarta must be sikhs then.. balle balle for such author! With a name like mine I stand and speak where I stand ....not shift positions like you !

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Jang VEER Bahadur Singh · 06 Feb 2006

dont worry about being disgusted with me, you have right to be as I have every right to ignore the sour grapes like you and treat with all the contempt .....dont let the khalistnis be disgusted with you when they see your reasoning line as one muslim who was more human than probably a muslim stood up..I know of thousands of gore and others who have stood up for Siksh turbans,,,I have never needed any one to stand for mine as I stand fine and well .... ...and use it to point out ,,,hell presto ...two sikhs leading india ....so all is fine !

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

curious · 06 Feb 2006

u mean 2 of Indira's Chapalee Sikhs that are leading India...if u are refering to Manmohan Singh and Gen JJ Singh

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 07 Feb 2006

WJKK WJKF Jang Veer Bahadur Singh Maybe I don't know about history as much as you, maybe I am not into Sikhi as much as you, maybe everything I said is off track but I was speaking from experience. There are two sides to every argument and if I don't agree with your view then I should be in a position to express that and the same goes for you. Did I mention anything about Khalistan? No! why is it that politics has to be dragged into everything. For you information I had family who suffered hugely in the 1984 attacks on Sri Akal Takht Sahib and Punjab as a whole, where Singh members of my family were dragged by their hair. So yeh it perfectly legit for me to go and attack innocent hindu's, sikhs, muslims to get my own back, that the perfect solution. When I was talking of individuals, I was refering to people who side with the truth who are not afraid to go against their own if they are wrong in their doing that goes for all people regardless of religion, cultural background or creed. My only concern was if the media have gone to the point of insulting one religion today what is their to say that they will not target another soon!!! As for standing up for myself I am quite capable, my only point is that when I was rediculed my other sikh colleague's stood by not saying a word, and yes I have respect for the person who stood up for me, obviously this person had a better understanding of humanity than certain other individuals. Guru Fateh Parvaan WJKK WJKF

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Jang VEER Bahadur Singh · 07 Feb 2006

I think you are just frustated person who could not even afford the oneanna chapli and callothers name you very deserve yourself.This is about ALL sikhs can do these days - call lowly names at otherss.he may be whatever, but someone like you who knows how to only call names may not even be allowed near his chaplis!

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

bijjli kumari sharmeyah wali · 07 Feb 2006

whats manmohan singh doing for development in punjab? why is the focus for success taken to other parts? where was gen jj singh when sikhs were attacked outside punjab recently? any dude can wear a turban and call himself a sikh and share from the same handouts with dushts like sajjan tyts hk bhagats etc just like the rajputs sleeping in bed with moghuls no difference. And by doing so that doesnt make the turban wearer named singh a sikh unless he publically fulfills his duty as both indian leader and a sikh in which there should be no conflict. The same token the rajputs were no more hindu for sleeping with moghuls and producing mixed hindu moghi lal khans. conclusion - whats in a name? im a sikh wow im a hindu wow a muslim wow bullflowers! everything comes down to following what your religion says then you are what it is. you aint no brahmin if you do not follow your books? so manmohan aint no singh if he does not fulfill the duty of a singh alongside his role of being a minister. rehat does not end with panj banis growing kes and wearing a turban. each sikh has a duty wherever he she is, it does not just rst with akhal takhat jathedar and some sgpc big tiddies. If manmohan has clout then he should also look out for the welfare of sikhs and punjab equally as development goes in madras, south indian and delhi. as for khalistan, khalsa raj will come. khalistani fire has come and gone, the future is khalsa raj. India will be the first to become khalsa, all 4castes will unite into one. dont give me this crap about sikhs not doing it, the future will unfold with a divine conclusion for sikhs and india. there will be no divisions just ekta in khalsa raj. so keep up the indian national themes, the flag of khalsa will be hoisted on red fort. our chands lals sharmas vermas will become dastar wearing sikhs in future and then we distribute the ladus what you saying jangliz? sohna plan yah keyah soorbirah?

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

kiran · 07 Feb 2006

Harcharan, What is so hard about threatening and giving death-threats to a woman, why do men have to prove thier worth by abusing women ? Can't you rise above it ? Why do you have to copy everything bad muslims do ? When the whole world sees it as a threat. If you are so tough then issue a death-threat to Bin Laden (who you admire so much) then we'll see how tough yo are About muslims in the west, many Sikh girls and other non-muslim girls face daily forceful conversion tactics from muslims, yet some people like Harcharan praise this sort of mentality If you dont like living within Western value system then sod off back to Saudi Arabia before Europe become Islamic state, then we'll see what you do for democracy. If such people can't handle childish sattire then their beleif is as fragile and intolerant just as the cartoonist has depicted.

Re: French editor fired over cartoons

Singh · 07 Feb 2006

Jang Veer Bahadur Singh I don't remember calling anyone names, if I did I apologise as that was not my intention. Secondly please state your views clearly as understanding your posts is quite a task. Anyway I'm entitled to my opinion and you have yours so lets agree to disagree. Guru Fateh Parvaan Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh