Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

veechar on a tuk

veechar on a tuk

G-Singh · 08 Feb 2006

[gurbani]Anyk aupwv krI gur kwrix gur BwvY so Qwie pweI ]29] rYix idnsu gur crx ArwDI dieAw krhu myry sweI ]30] nwnk kw jIau ipMfu gurU hY gur imil iqRpiq AGweI ]31] nwnk kw pRBu pUir rihE hY jq kq qq gosweI ]32]1] [/gurbani] with the tuk of bani that has a space left before it and after it, does this tuk show us that guru sahib is nirgun AS well as Sargun saropp of akaal purakh? Can i please hear everyones veechars on this tuk Kulbir Singh jee, it seems that you dont post too often anymore but if you can, please reply to this msg. It would be interesting to see your opinion on this topic [%sig%]

Re: veechar on a tuk

_ · 09 Feb 2006

!!

Re: veechar on a tuk

G-Singh · 12 Feb 2006

no one has an opinion? its strange that whenever someone wants to discuss whether raagmala is bani or not 300 people reply but when some bani that we all agree on is asked to be discussed no one wants to say anything. Or is it that we only strive to gain knowledge on the more controversial aspects of sikhi so we are good at arguing and dont even bother learning the meanings of other parts of bani?

Re: veechar on a tuk

... · 12 Feb 2006

Dr. Sahib Singh has said that this means that Nanak's life is the Gurus and Nanak's body is the Guru's. I'm not sure that's right. What I take from this is that Guru is everything. I didn't take that Guru Nanak is the Sargun saroop of Akaal Purakh. I believe that bani tells us that Vahiguru is Nirankaar. I don't think we can say Guru Nanak had the physical form of God.

Re: veechar on a tuk

A · 12 Feb 2006

I guess so. The earths are straight forward. God is everywhere Ghat Ghat Mai Har Ju basai-- hes in every ones heart. Sikhism is about spirituality, inner knoweldge, and rehat

Re: veechar on a tuk

G-Singh · 12 Feb 2006

that is what i was thinking but than I thought, bani is nirankaar, akaal purakh is nirankaar...so when you contemplate bani in your mind you are contemplating akaal purakhs nirgun saroop. But than the way we receive bani in the sargun is through each and every letter written in guru granth sahib jee. So wouldn't that make guru granth sahib jee the sargun saroop of bani, hence the sargun saroop of akaal purakh?

Re: veechar on a tuk

A · 13 Feb 2006

Nirgun Sargun ek hai = the formless and the forms are one.