Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

singing with everyone!!***

singing with everyone!!***

Harmeet Singh · 11 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf *Just one comment to add...what I'm seeing these days a lotttt now...it's even slipping into India and is already there in other countries such as Uk, Canada, America... is that the Sangat is not singing with everyone. They only sing with someone they know..or their favourite or someone like that. Like seriously..it really bothers me to see someone doing keertan from their heart and maybe they came from another country too to attend and no one or barely anyone is singing with them. And then the next thing you know, someone else who probably is more favoured sits behind the keertan and the hall is filled with people singing to the top of their voices. Doesn't matter if it's a child doing keertan or the oldest gurmukh...sing with everyoneeee. One example...ok at a smagam..any smagam...no ones singing with anyone or barely right not no one..but very few..and all of a sudden Bhai Tejinderpal Singh Jee (Dulla Veerji) ...this is not directed at him or anything but an example from what I have seen...and then all of a sudden everyone is singing with so much rus with him... really tears my heart. don't mean to cause an arguement..just an awarement/improvement kind of post. pul chuk maph karnee jee vjkk, vjkf

Re: singing with everyone!!***

Harmeet Singh · 11 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf sits behind the harmonium*** forgive my mistake... vjkk, vjkf

Re: singing with everyone!!***

G-Singh · 12 Feb 2006

the problem i believe is that people like listening to keertan for kan raas there days and not for aatmik raas.

Re: singing with everyone!!***

moorakh · 12 Feb 2006

totally agree

Re: singing with everyone!!***

MOW! · 12 Feb 2006

yes this is something that really disappoints me too and its such a shame if it has spread to india aswell! maybe smagam organisers should stop inviting all the big name keertanees for a while, but then again then sadly half the sangat wouldnt turn up then. :(

Re: singing with everyone!!***

* · 13 Feb 2006

This doesn't just occur with the "big name" keertanis. This happens even at small programs where the sangat only consists of a handful of people to begin with. Nothing could be more discouraging than having no one sing and even people who get up and leave until you're finished. It really is nonsense. If you're only going to sing with people you like and then fall silent for those you're not fond of, why even bother coming?? You could sit at home and listen to recordings of the keertanis you prefer to hear and you don't have to be bothered sitting through the agony of hearing people you despise.

Re: singing with everyone!!***

... · 13 Feb 2006

I feel that although ideally we should try to sing with everyone, sometimes some kirtan lends itself to singing more than others. The sangat is not perfect and sometimes individuals aren't inspired. If a kirtani is inspiring then of course the sangat will be prompted to sing with them. I don't think it's necessarily a conscious decision. As for leaving, if someone has been given time and should not have been, (maybe they have made serious mistakes in Gurmat or something else), and the person in sangat has no control over it, I know in that situation, people in sangat do sometimes get up and leave. Finally my comment would be that the kirtani gets as much satkaar from the sangat as s/he gives to the sangat.

Re: singing with everyone!!***

Harmeet Singh · 13 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf I feel that sangat is paying more attention on the keertani and maybe being more attracted to the keertani's style or voice or something about them rather than the shabad....like ok...if you have heard old recordings from I think maybe 1 or 2 years after Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee passed away the Sangat is singing at the top of their voices with full pyar...and even at the boringest tunes there was so much ras...here listen to this...beautiful..simply beautiful: http://www.sskhalsa.com/downloads/Keertan/Rare%20AKJ%20Files/Dr.%20Pritam%20S%20Anjaan%203.mp3 you can just feel it :)....vah vjkk, vjkf

Re: singing with everyone!!***

. · 17 Feb 2006

vjkk, vjkf I agree with all of the above. vjkk, vjkf

Re: singing with everyone!!***

... · 06 Mar 2006

great point this is one reason why rensvai's in india feel more chardikala i think epecially those who sit on stage should backup the kirtani and sing gurbani out loud. singing along also helps you concentrate on the gurbani akhand kirtan is purposely simple, so that sanghat can sing along, sanghat singing along is what makes akhand kirtan akhand kirtan.

Re: singing with everyone!!***

:D · 06 Mar 2006

vaheguru jee ka khalsa, vaheguru jee kee fateh everone please listen to the link of keertan..it's soo beautiful... wish it was like that these days :D :) vjkk, vjkf

Re: singing with everyone!!***

.../\.... · 07 Mar 2006

Vaaheguroo! this unfortunately even happens everywhere. Its quite disappointing and makes you just wanting to back off. But it is maya if you really think about it... Getting passed it all to attain Aatmik Russ is a challenge. NO matter who is singing, sometimes you can raise your voice and no one else is... yet sangat is supposed to be ONE. so doesnt make much sense but to me its just a way of distraction, isnt it? (maya)...

Re: singing with everyone!!***

123 · 07 Mar 2006

maya is money?

Re: singing with everyone!!***

. · 06 Apr 2006

looks like when there is an arguement going on almost everyone wants part in it but if there's a good topic that is just a kind of reminder/awarement kind of thing...there is barely an amout of replies.

Re: singing with everyone!!***

sanjo · 06 Apr 2006

its definatly true what has been said above, but i dont see many kirtani urging the sangat to join in, i think if more kirtani encouraged sangat to join in i think they would, i agree some tunes are more easy for the sangat to join in with, but if the whole sangat was to join in it would certainly feel fantastic, what i find is that if u just go ahead n sing out load in sangat the sangat sitting around u feel free to join in more, so we shud try n encourage others by singing these beautiful shabads ourselves. strangely i find akj kirtan is easier to join in with i duno what it is, its a unique style, for some reason there are always more people joining in at akj rehansbhais compared to non akj. then agn ive only eva been to one non akj rehansbhai. but i have yet to experience the whole sangat joining in n creating what would be a fantastic atmosphere, i hope to experience this in my lifetime, waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh