Forum
Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 13 Feb 2006
Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harjinder Singh Thu Jul 25
If one were to compose a list of some of the most notable Sikhs of the 20th century, few I suspect would think to include any prominent Raagis in that list.
But, while the essence of the Sikh faith rests on the writings of Guru Nanak and the other Gurus, the primary vehicle for those teachings created by the Gurus themselves is a centuries old, incredibly rich and complex musical tradition - Gurbani Sangeet - that (sadly) very few Sikhs today have embraced and most have forgotten.
Those scant individuals that have mastered and preserved this pristine Sikh art deserve perhaps as much recognition as any in our historical texts.
If there indeed were such hallowed halls where some of the great Raagis of the 20th century were remembered, few would stand as tall as Bhai Avtar Singh, currently on tour in the USA with his jatha, accompanied by Bhai Swaran Singh (his nephew) and Bhai Kultar Singh (his son). Tracing his family's keertan lineage back to the time of Guru Arjan in the 16th century, Bhai Avtar Singh's knowledge and exposition of the traditional and original style of raagas from the time of the Gurus is arguably unmatched by any other person alive today.
For example, though many shabads in the Guru Granth Sahib explicitly record the word 'Partaal' in the heading as an indication that the shabad is to be sung in the complex style in which the Taal, or beat, of the shabad changes in its midst, not many Jathas alive today even know how to perform a Partaal, let alone render it with the delicacy and care of Bhai Avtar Singh.
In a time when one has grown accustomed to the renditions of keertan that stick to relatively simple taals such as kairva (8 beats), daadra (6 beats), teentaal (16 beats), or roopak (7 beats), who could imagine that a 9, 11, 15, or a 17 beat shabad (according to the metre laid out in the Guru Granth Sahib itself), could be rendered with such eloquence and rhythm. Today, when proponents of this complex style are virtually absent from the keertan landscape, one has to listen to Bhai Avtar Singh to even understand how this is possible.
But in his majesty over the original style of Kirtan, Bhai Avtar Singh's mastery over taal may be little more than a footnote compared to the grandeur with which he presents the raag (melody). Bhai Avtar Singh, unlike any other Raagi, regularly enraptures sangats in selections from each and every one of the 31 ragas in the Guru Granth Sahib, often using the forms and styles for those raags that were prevalent during the times of the Gurus themselves.
And if you have never heard a shabad sung in true dhrupad style as performed by Bhai Avtar Singh, it may well be said that you have never heard keertan as it was originally recorded and sung by the Gurus.
In dhrupad, the calm, steady, relentlessly slow rhythm draws out each word, wrenching them out at such a gradual pace and with such passion that each syllable seems to pierce the listener, stinging in its longing for the Guru, lingering long after the vibrations themselves have moved on to new sounds and new syllables. The vocal control required to sing in dhrupad style are beyond the abilities of most, even amongst the more accomplished Raagis today.
A friend that was taking a few advanced tabla lessons from Bhai Avtar Singh's brother, Bhai Gurcharan Singh, once joked that playing a basic form of chartaal (a tabla rhythm used for many dhrupad shabads), one could tap the tabla once, go for a coffee, and come back and tap it again and not miss the beat of the taal. Of course that's quite an exaggeration, but one might well appreciate that in the fast hip hop style of keertan that is in vogue today, tapping and singing along to a shabad in dhrupad must, to many, seem painfully slow.
I can still recall, in detail, one of my favorite keertan experiences of all time during a performance by Bhai Avtar Singh some nine or ten years ago.
A gurdwara in Toronto was holding a Basant durbar, in which all of the jathas were asked to perform shabads in Raag Basant during that Divaan. Basant is a raag traditionally associated with the spring and many of the shabads that the Gurus composed in this raag use the metaphor of spring (the blossoming of flowers, the forests awakening in energy and so on), to express the beauty of the spiritual union with Waheguru. It was once a tradition that, during the spring, Raagis would sing the first shabad in Raag Basant.
For this particular durbar, I had heard that some of the professional jathas that were to perform had been scrambling for days to learn a shabad in Basant. But if indeed they did not already know this raag, learn it they did, for most performed pleasant compositions in raag basant and set the mood accordingly.
As the last Jaatha to perform in that day's divaan, Bhai Avtar Singh walking up to the stage was highly anticipated by those that had gathered for this rare late afternoon divaan. But as he was unraveling the cloth about his baja, his tabla player, Bhai Swaran Singh was busy in the kitchen mixing aatta (flour) with water, as if overcome by a sudden pang of hunger and about to make rotis. It was a curious sight for one not aware until that day aware of the method of preparing the tabla for playing centuries old little known and even less used style called khulay bole.
In this style, typically rendered in chartaal to accompany a shabad sung in drupad (often also a partaal), the tabla is played with open palms rather than, as is almost universal today, with the index finger of the right hand and the middle two fingers of the left.
As Bhai Swaran Singh sat down on the stage, freshly made aatta in his bowl, he spread the aatta on the larger of the tabla pair (played with the left hand) to give it firmness and a deep reverberating sound when thumped hard with the hand. Bhai Avtar Singh, meanwhile, introduced the shabad, explaining that this particular reet (tune) used to be sung in the court of Guru Hargobind, almost four hundred years earlier and had been passed down through their family.
By the time Bhai Avtar Singh finished singing the Mangla Charan (preamble), my mind had wandered backwards in time and imagined that it was resting now in that very same court, somewhere in the vicinity of the Guru himself, listening not to Bhai Avtar Singh but rather to one of the long gone predecessors of his illustrious jatha. The prelude to his shabad, the two hours of Raag Basant that had preceded it, the amazing elegance of the rendition by Bhai Avtar Singh and the striking beauty of the Guru's own words, all of these contributed to one of my most memorable keertan experiences ever.
Over the years, I have come across no shortage of people that sit in complete awe of Bhai Avtar Singh and his keertan. Listening to his jatha is always a rare opportunity for an experience of classical Gurmat Sangeet that is otherwise very hard to come by. Perhaps because of this, I find it deeply saddening that, amongst the large crowds that throng to listen to the relatively simplistic filmy stylesof pop jathas, Bhai Avtar Singh is so little known and so little appreciated. Though Bhai Avtar Singh is now quite old (in his seventies), his voice still maintains considerable power and agility and his style of reets remain unsurpassed for their ability to focus one's attention on the message of the Guru.
Granted, the classical style of kirtan he performs requires considerably more depth and sensitivity to grasp and resonate with, but each divaan of kirtan in which he performs is a glorious glimpse into the living and vibrant history of a musical tradition that is otherwise fast fading from memory.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Gur Merai Sang · 04 Mar 2006
Very good article. Its funny how we stress so much on "REHAT" of Bana, cooking & eating, and pronouncing Gurbani, but overlook "REHAT" of Keertan.
I suppose its too hard, and "As if" anyone will say anything or object we do Keertan "IGNORANT" and "can't be bothered to learn or EVEN WANT TO LEARN" the 31 Raags which guru jee wants us to learn and strive to play.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 04 Mar 2006
Veer/Bhenji,
You are correct in what you say.
The home page of this website says "Gurdwara Tapoban Saahib is dedicated to preserving and practicing Tat-Gurmat Maryada or the most pristine and original form of Sikhism. Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib maintains a strict Khalsa rehit and conducts Akhand Keertan or collective singing of hymns in front of Sree Guru Granth Saahib jee, with active participation by the Sangat. True Khalsa rehits which are disappearing in the Panth are maintained at Gurdwara Tapoban Saahib including parkaash of Lareedaar Saroop of Sree Guru Granth Saahib jee and Sarbloh bibekee langar."
Whilst I have the utmost respect for many things Tapoban Sahib sangat stand for and do, it does break my heart that the 2 most prominent points in the above declaration - Akhand Kirtan in front of Guru Ji and preserving and practicing the most "pristine" and "original" form of Sikhsim, do not hold true in my opinion.
Nirdaareth Raag is the form of Kirtan our Guru's have blessed us with and authorised for each shabad in Gurbani. Doing Akhand Kirtan in Guru's ordained and ordered method, to me, is the only "pristine" and "original" form of Sikhism, and even better using the highly intelligent and purpose built saaj our Guru's blessed us with rather than faranghi second class instruments like the harmonium, especially now we have the resources and know how to bring Guru's Kirtan back.
Do ardaas Khalsa Ji, that one day Tapoban Sahib, and all other Guru ghar will be blessed with Puratan Kirtan, as intented by our Guru's.....
Bhul Chuk Maaf.
Harcharan Singh
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 04 Mar 2006
Satsriakal to all and Harcharan Singh Ji!
I got some questions after reading your long post.
One of the curiosities raised is this.
There are many kinds of Taals also in classical music to accompany different Raags.
Why in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji only Par-Taal is mentioned?
Please elaborate. I will be thankful.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
gabroo · 05 Mar 2006
vaheguru ji ka khalsaa
waheguru ji ki fatehh
i disagree with "wants us to learn" and "strive to play".
i think this is your perception.
what is the need in bringing in Guru's other beloved rehats to emphasise this argument? its like saying to a baby... it doesn't matter that you can walk now... u didn't crawl properly so i don't want to know until u go back and do that properly first and then show us you can walk. its such narrow mindedness.
...to put down other "well on their way" gursikhs who love Guru immensley, study and apply gurbani, sing their hearts out with Gurbani, why put them down and say... but you haven't even learnt raag.
its such a condesending tone and thinking.
i have read posts from these bana, bani, cooking & eating stressers saying they are open to looking into the importance of singing shabad in raag. thats an open invitation to pyare gursikhs who DO have skills in raag, to go to tapoban gurdwara sahib and speak to fellow gursikhs about it.
lets not just sit on forums and criticise if we're not going to be the ones that actually go out and teach fellow gursikhs rather than show out criticisms.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
singh1234 · 05 Mar 2006
change the record and tell your beloved surinder singh to stop eating mass and stop being his puppet
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 06 Mar 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Balbir Singh Jeeo,
There is some debate around taal in gurbani at the moment. Many people claim the "ghar" to mean taal - i.e. Ghar 7 = 7 taal.
However study shows that in the Vedic tradition (where raag was also used), the word "Greh" which means home, refered to shrusti (microtones).
Hence when ghar is mentioned by Guru Sahiban, they are telling us to place emphasis on a certain microtone within the composition - Kirtan. The change in microtone changes the whole essence (feeling) of a shabad.
To those who dispute this, how can ghar and partall be mentioned in the same sentance, this would be a contradiction.
There are 22 Shrustis, from memory I think Gurbani mentions 17 (please check this though).
If you are really interested, please listen to the lectures on raj academy website, the 4th lecture which will be put up soon, talks about taal in detail.
Gabroo Jeeo,
I respect and agree with your points completely. I do not critise those Gursikh who do kirtan in the only way they know, I have a problem with the ones who have the knowledge or are aware of it, but still do manmat or are to lazy to learn Kirtan in Guru's way.
For your info, many people are trying very hard to spread this knowledge, we do not wish to keep it secret or become famous, we only wish to see Nirdaareth raag kirtan in all Guru Ghar.
I have approached Tapoban sahib about holding a Raag Kirtan darbaar there in April, and possibly creating a learning platform/change in their kirtan maryada, but they seem to be too busy at the moment. I would have thought they would have been able to spare an evening to listen to kirtan in Guru's raag and with Guru's beautiful instruments.
I also read some posts on this site from last year, where some members of Taboban Sahib said they would look into making changes to Gurdwara Sahibs kirtan maryada, but nothing happened. Unfortunatel, Kirtan does not seem to be at the top of the agenda for this part of the Akhand KIRTANI Jathaa.
Don't worry Veer ji, Guru's hukum is spreading, and nothing is going to stop it, there are currently over 600 Gursikh youth (around the world) from ages 5 upwards learning raag with Guru's saaj (with raj academy), this number is growing daily, everyone will have the opportunity to learn and teach soon, if you are interested in learning please contact me.
Singh 1234 - uhhhh (sigh)...,
People like you are cowards and pathetic, it takes a lot to wind me up, but one thing I can't stand is Nindah and cowardice.
You hide behind numbers (for a name) and give baseless and lying accusations. You should have some shame and have some fear of Waheguru.
I do respect Professor Ji for his huge contribution (which is only just starting) to revive Guru's Kirtan, and his big heart and patience.
I am not however anyones puppet. I am propogating my Guru's words and instructions directly from Gurbani, you my friend are the puppet, because puppets are not real, and you do not seem to either 1234 Singh.
You are probably someone who cannot give up listening to bhangra kirtan, and cannot be bothered to learn to praise Waheguru yourself, hence telling me to change the subject.
In case you have forgotten, this website is affiliated with KIRTAN = a"K"j
So please go and spread your filth and lies elsewhere and stop distracting SIKHS from learning how to carry out their Guru's instructions.
I pray you find it in your heart to realise your error and ask for Guru's forgiveness.
If you have any issue you should learn to take it up with someone in person like a man, and if you want to make an accusation (that is ridiculaously, pathetically false), at least provide evidence.
Otherwise recite the Anand Sahib, in Ramkali if you can, and learn something. If you would like to know how to recite Anand Sahib in Ramkali, and recite it in full (like Guru Amardaas Ji intended), and not just 1-5 and then jump to 40, then please come to Khalsa Centre, Tooting, London next Saturday (11th March) and learn something. You will also get the chance to do sangat with young Gursikh children who live for praising their Guru in teh most beautiful way possible, and will also be able to learn something of Sikh etiquette from some of the infants there.
It would also be nice for me to make your acqaintance.
SAT Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
jeevan · 06 Mar 2006
I learn raag but at sam time u need a jevan and to respcect panth and maryada not lag of any one and everyone fo trying to build up a jeevan!!
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Mar 2006
I saw the Kirtan at harmandir Sahib..it was being performed with Tantee saajs... maybe a revival is taking place..
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Tribune News Service · 06 Mar 2006
Tradition revived at Golden Temple
Pawan Kumar
Amritsar, March 6
The Golden Temple ambience today resonated with Gurbani kirtan performed with ancient and traditional musical instruments for the first time after partition. The tradition of performing kirtan accompanied with tanpura, rabab, swarmandal was revived in the gurdwara.
Prof Kartar Singh, Director of the SGPC-run Sangeet Academy at Anandpur Sahib, performed kirtan with the traditional instruments, including two tanpuras, taus, swarmandal and harmonium. He sang four shabads of Guru Nanak Dev and Guru Gobind Singh, including ‘Mitar piare nu’, and of Bhagat Kabir and Bhagat Ramanand in basant raag.
He said shabad kirtan and Gurbani had a classical base. However, he rued that we had lost the classical base and by using modern instruments which was against the Rehat Maryada. Due to this, the sangat did not attach with the shabads and Gurbani, he added. He praised the SGPC initiative of reviving the tradition.
Prof Kartar Singh will perform tomorrow also. Dr Gurnam Singh, Head of the Music Department, Punjabi University, Patiala, will also perform on March 7 and 8. Bhai Nirmal Singh Khalsa and Bhai Gurmit Singh Shant will perform kirtan on March 9-10 and March 16-17, respectively. Bhai Avtar Singh will perform on March 18.
Mr Avtar Singh, President of the SGPC, also enjoyed the kirtan. He said the committee would ensure that at least one raagi adept in traditional instruments was present during the kirtan in the sanctum santorum.
He said students were being trained at Punjabi University and the SGPC-run Sangeet Academy at Anandpur Sahib on traditional instruments.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 07 Mar 2006
Veer Jarnail Singh Ji,
There is no maybe, the revival has been underway for a few years now. Like I said there is a Khasla fauj of youth around the world reviving the gurmat kirtan maryada. And they perform mind blowing kirtan for their Guru - and not for the sangat!
Again if any one in the UK would like to get a taste of this, please come to Khasla Centre, Tooting, London this Sat evening (11th March - 6.30).
It is heart warming to hear that nirdaareth raag kirtan was perfomed using Guru de Saaj at Harminder Sahib, but SGPCs attitude is still off the mark.
Could some Guru Pyara "please" record the above mentioned kirtan for me, I would be forever indebted, I do not have Sky/Satellite.
I really wish these people would stop refering to Darbaar Sahib as Golden Temple! Alongside the Baja, this is another unwanted farengi (British) contribution we can't seem to shake off!
Jeevan Ji,
Yes I agree with you completely.
No one was "****ing* off anyone for trying, but simply telling those who "aren't" trying to stop holdng back those who are, by constatnly belittling Guru's kirtan maryada.
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 07 Mar 2006
Satsriakal to all and Harcharan Singh Ji!
Please expand your explanation on why only 'Par-taal' is mentioned in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? There are many
popular names of Raags though.
You wrote "There is some debate around taal in gurbani at the moment. Many people claim the "ghar" to mean taal -
i.e. Ghar 7 = 7 taal."
I am not sure if the meaning of the word 'Ghar' will be express 'taal' when majority of people vote for it.
Please explain little more about how 'Ghar' got the meaning 'shrusti' (microtones).
You also wrote "There are 22 Shrustis, from memory I think Gurbani mentions 17 (please check this though)."
Please provide a reference. I will be thankful.
I always heard that 'Shrutis' are scriptures.
I have few more questions. There is some information as titles before many Shabads in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. For
example these are 'Asa', 'Raag Goojree', 'Mehl', 'Salok Sahaskriti', ''Par_Taal' etc.
Are these all instructions to follow or purely informing titles? What instructions Gursikhs are suppose to follow
from 'MeHl'?
Please explain and oblige.
Balbir Singh
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
hmmm... · 07 Mar 2006
Harcharan Singh jeeo, what are your views about reading anand sahib? Do you think that we should all do FULL anand Sahib (all 40 pauris) and NOT the short one (1-5 + 40 pauris)?
Can you plz explain why this should be? Can you give references from Akaal Takhat Rehat Maryada etc...
Thanks
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 07 Mar 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Veer Balbir Singh Ji,
I have asked you on a number of occassions to listen to the following lectures, they should answer all your questions and many more:
http://rajacademy.com/articles.php?category_id=58
Also, if you are really interested in this topic, then please visit my Veer Angad Singhs blog and read all his articles, they are very educational, and again should ansewr many of your questions.
http://singhangad.blogspot.com/
I am not an expert on the subject, purley a mere beginner, but in my view, the title before each shabad is an order on how to render the kirtan, it makes complete sense if you listen to nirdaareth raag kirtan, the feelings invoked from the kirtan rendition exactly match the essense and meaning of the shabad - where rahao is used correctly as teh chorus and main stress point of the shabad.
I feel I am going around in circles answering the same questions, please lsiten to my benti and put in a little effort and listen to the lectures mentioned. You will be enlightened.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 07 Mar 2006
Hmmmm Ji,
I have already posed this question for discussion last week, as I am also looking for anwers, seems like breaking Guru Amardaas Ji's paath is not an important issue for the sangat.
As far as I know mainstream maryada say 1.5 jump---40 is fine.
But can anyone justify breaking a paath, why not then save time on Akhaand paath, and jump 80% of it and finish it in half a day?
A paath is normally done inclusive, not always the whole paath, but at least up to the end of a pauri. Please see my previous post on this subject. All old rehitnamas etc refer to paurian 1-5 or the full Anand Sahib, none mention skippng to 40, this in my view is a recent decision.
How can anyone realise Guru Amardaas Ji's intended Anand if they miss out 80% of the Anand Sahib?
It would be like doing 20% of the Sukhmani sahib everyday and saying you are Sukhi?
Why are we rearranging our Gurus shabad? If they intended 6 paurian, would they not have only written 6?
This is my personal opinion, but I know many Khalsa siblings who have the same opinion and who always do full Anand Sahib.
Sat-Naam
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
gabroo · 07 Mar 2006
Singhji,
its good that you have made the approach to hold a kirtan darbar there.
But why give up at the first apparant hurdle? If they say they're busy in April, you should accept the Singh's words not question it. Approach them after April to book an evening of kirtan. Simple.
I appreciate your candedness and information. thanks.
i have noticed though, that during parchar, the professer often makes comments in regards to the practise of akj (he wasn't direct enough to say the jatha name, though) kirtan is manmat and blasphemous to Guru.
i completely disagree with this comment, and any hope of learning from a person who has such blatant and direct disregard for other gursikhs is shattered as one wouldn't want the sangat of such a negative thinker.
in that sense, i don't think acadamy would be successful. not amongst gursikhs it wouldn't. in the same way that niddar singh may have had good skills to offer but since his attitude to others was so away from guru's-matt, he was shunned by the sangat in general.
i think the same applies here. there are much more important things in a Gursikh's path than learning the use of raag in kirtan. it is wrong to say it is of paramount importance. agreed, though, that it would aid one's 'feel' of a shabad. raag vidiya could be a tool to achieve this. but not the only tool either. Guru ji'a apaar kirpa would and the should be thing to seek.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 07 Mar 2006
Satsriakal to all and Harcharan Singh Ji!
Thanks for your efforts.
You seem to be a treasure of surprises. You wrote ". . . where rahao is used correctly as teh chorus . . ."
Please elaborate it. Is chorus (rahao) allowed with Raagees during Kirtan in Gurudwaras?
I will be extremely thankful when you provide a reference from the Guru's Baanee where they suggested anyone using
Taal.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Kaur Singh · 08 Mar 2006
Harcharan Singh How many raags are there?
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
ns · 08 Mar 2006
Waheguru Ji Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh
Veer Harcharn SIngh Jeeo
Could you give us the exact addres of Khasla Centre, Tooting, I may be able to pop down this Saturday. I agree whole heartedly with all your points.
I have no doubt Sikhs will revive this tradition.
I was in India a year ago in the Jalandar area trying to get holf of kirtan from Bhai Avtar Singh Ji mentioned above. It took almost two weeks to get hold of it as popular shops don't keep it. I'll be first to admit that most of my 30 odd years of life I've listened to AKJ style of kirtan, and I still do as this has been my stepping stone in Sikhi awareness.Due to having that awareness and listening to raag kirtan as performed by the likes of Raagi Avtar Singh/Balbir Singh the awareness is increased deeply from within. AKJ respects all kirtanes and I have seen many a time in the UK rehansbahis raagi kirtans performing seva in the rehansabhi. One must bear in mind if we are to bring about change :
"Change has a considerable psychological impact on the human mind. To the fearful it is threatening because it means that things may get worse. To the hopeful it is encouraging because things may get better. To the confident it is inspiring because the challenge exists to make things better. "
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 08 Mar 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh,
Gabroo Ji,
”But why give up at the first apparant hurdle? If they say they're busy in April, you should accept the Singh's words not question it. Approach them after April to book an evening of kirtan. Simple.”
Not so simple – the jathaa is trying to reach as much sangat around the globe as possible, they me tied up for a few years before Toronto is viable again, it was simply a matter of sparing one evening in a few weeks, that would have been simple. But I am not bitter, other Gurdwarai and sangat in Toronto will be educated, so not a major loss. It was just my personal ru, that Gurdwara Sahiban who makes such great efforts to be puran, should also add kirtan maryada/hukum to their already impressive list, especially as it is in my opinion one of the more important matters as it relates to Guru ki bani.
”I appreciate your candedness and information. thanks.”
I will take that as a compliment and not a dig.
”i have noticed though, that during parchar, the professer often makes comments in regards to the practise of akj (he wasn't direct enough to say the jatha name, though) kirtan is manmat and blasphemous to Guru. I completely disagree with this comment, and any hope of learning from a person who has such blatant and direct disregard for other gursikhs is shattered as one wouldn't want the sangat of such a negative thinker.”
Veerji,
You have answered your own question, no direct reference is made to anyone. The Sikh world is much much bigger than AKJ, there are many jathaas and many manmat kirtani who do kirtan for kan ras, sangat popularity, charavaa, fame, to be uniquene etc… these are the people Prof Ji is referring to and is upset with, rightly so, because these people and the sangat that follow them have turned Kirtan into a form of entertainment, with everyones favourite shabad being sung in everyones favourite tunes etc…. people are enjoying the tabla speed and beat rather than listening to the shabad, or are admiring the kirtanis very good voice rather than the shabad, people are remembering the scene/song from the relevant bollywood film that the shabad is being done to…this is real and happens everywhere, no jathaa is excempt… Prof is talking of individuals.
”in that sense, i don't think acadamy would be successful. not amongst gursikhs it wouldn't. in the same way that niddar singh may have had good skills to offer but since his attitude to others was so away from guru's-matt, he was shunned by the sangat in general.”
2 points
1 – Academy is successful (600 Gursikh Khalsa students world-wide and growing fast everyday)..many many sangats admire the academys work, people from all jathaas.
2 –Niddar Singh is comparable in some ways but not others. Prof refers everthing, even his opinions to Gurbani. Niddar’s opinions are mostly history based.
When the truth is spoken it is going to hurt some people, you can’t sugar coat the truth, we as a panth have lost our Guru’s precious gift which has been written forever, and we ignore it everyday, even whilst doing paath. That is a fact. No one is blaming anyone, we are simply trying to put this right and regain that element of our Guru’s pyaar again, by listening to what they asking us to do.
”i think the same applies here. there are much more important things in a Gursikh's path than learning the use of raag in kirtan. it is wrong to say it is of paramount importance. agreed, though, that it would aid one's 'feel' of a shabad. raag vidiya could be a tool to achieve this. but not the only tool either. Guru ji'a apaar kirpa would and the should be thing to seek.”
Veerji, kirtan is of paramount importance, you cannot deny that. We receive Guru Ji’s kirpa by listening to his hukum. Kirtan is one of his hukum. The way to perform that kirtan is also his hukum, which they have stamped Mahalla xx. I do agree that there is a lot more we need to do, no one is denying that, but that does not mean that this is than given less prominence. Nirdaareth raag is more than a simple tool, it is a huge tool, that helps us to understand the essence and meaning of Guru’s words, that is why Guru Arjun Dev Ji organised Bani in Raag format.
Yes we do need a gursikh jeevan alongside, but in each and every way, not just specific ways that have been deemed important by different jathaas.
SAT Sri Akaal
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 08 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh Ji,
It is widley known what rahao means and what purpose it plays.
All kirtan is supposed to be done using Rahao as the chorus, if you read any shabad you will understand why. The rahao is the power - central message - core - base of the shabad.
The shabad seeks to expand on the rahao. The rahao is the meditative essence - the tuk which is to be repeated.
It's no big surprise, I believe Akal Takht have (or about ) issue a Hukumnama ordering rahao to be used.
If you are really interested please read the posts that have been posted hear on rahao. Go to the search box and type rahao.
Taal.
I am not knowledgable on this subject, as I am only coming to learn the role of various taals in the kirtan I am learning. But as I have said twice before, if you listen to the lecture, your questions will be answered. Please put in some effort yourself also.
I am only aware that partaal (as stated in Bani) means using more than one taal in the subject, this is reflected in the more complicated nature/message of those particluar shabads. where more variation is needed.
Gurmat Sangeet is a big subject, elements of which are still under debate and research. With all due respect I would suggest understanding and learning the basics and actually learning and doing raag kirtan, so that you can understand and experience what our Guru's wanted us to feel, before we contribute to the more complex and currently researched issues.
No one is saying this is how it is, accept it, people are only saying please follow Guru's footsteps, respect and apply bani and help us to revive Guru's kirtan, the revival is far from complete, much more effort, research and help is required.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
gabroo · 08 Mar 2006
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki Fateh
thanks for replying ji.
and yes, the comment i made was a genuine compliment, and not even considered a dig in the slightest. i was thanking you for offering information and inviting me to come and learn.
daas may have missed an important point when writing about the professor's comments. he happended to making the comments to daas' wife, who while wearing a dastar, felt he specifically mentioned this to her since she looked to be part of the jatha.
you may consider this a argumentative point, but i suppose you had to be there.
bhai sahib, i dont think ANYone could deny that kirtan isn't of importance... its of the hugest importance. daas was saying (you may look back) that learning raag vidiya was not a hukam.
when you mention Guruji saying mahalla panjva, for e.g, that refers to the Guru sahib writing the bani, does it not?... but ghar pehla, for e.g, was the octive (or some other musical/rythmic denotion, if i'm not mistaken) to be singing in. i could be wrong, but nevertheless, this, does not encompass a hukam to learn kirtan in this form... at the same time, as i mentioned before... i'm sure it could help towards obtaining the feeling of a shabd, but this is NO way means that someone not singing kirtan in a prescribed raag is doing anything close to manmat.
at the same time jio, i should say that there may well be a very good reason why the Gurdwara may not benefit from booking the programme in that particular month, but i may not be a liberty to say, so won't. you should just accept that if they say they're busy, they truly are. not wonder why they cant make time for something important. since already being engaged in something important is a reason enough.
daas has talked too much jio... and hadn't intended anything ill in the above. but apoligise if you took anything ill from it.
to end, theres a lot more that could be said on the matter, but it might be easier to say that someone who does NOT yet sing kirtan in raag perscribed, can NOT under ANY circumstances be put down for it. not even in the slightest. that is if the person is singing due to being drenched in the rang of the Lord.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Kaur singh · 08 Mar 2006
Prof Ji ... ? sorry who r u refering to? How many ragas... hheellloo am I invisible??
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
ns · 08 Mar 2006
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh
I whole heartdly agree with Gabroo, we read daily in our nitnem:
"aavo sikh satguru ke pyaroo gaavoo sachee bani"
]
I doubt if at all it's ever mentioned in the SGGS to "gavvo raag ki bani" , I 'm sure Guru Ji wouldn've mentioned it if the need was so great.
I do also agree to a certain point with Harcharn Jee, puratan ways should be bought forward and learnt. However with bani in mind from assa di vaar:
"koi gavee raggi naadi bediee boh bhant kar neheen har har bejeee ramm rajee, jinah andar kupt vikaar"
apologies for spelling mistakes, it's obvious any kirtania who sings Gurbani is to ensure to singh without kupt and vikaar is the hukam from Guru Ji is it not?
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 08 Mar 2006
Khalsa Jeeo,
Kaur Singh Ji, Tapoban is not my full time occupation, please be a little patient when waiting for a response. In my understanding there are 59 raags, with a 60th currently being investigated.
Please listen to lectures on raj academy website if you are interested in learning more.
Gabroo Ji,
Thanks for clarifying that.
To me, Raamkali being stated at the beginning of the Anand Sahib is hukum, as is every other word in the bani. This is pure common sense.
There is no other reason for the whole Guru Granth Sahib to be organised according to mood (raag). Why did our Guru's not organise Bani by author?
Each mood has it's place in the set order - Sri is the first chapter after JapJi - it represents the complete revelation/attack, of truth - all the shabads reflect this. This folows on perfectly from Jap ji chapter.
You will have to do your own research to see how this then continues....
Each mood - raag compliments the content of the previous and oncoming chapter...
I have already stated I am not critising those Guru de pyare who do kirtan in the only way they know how, I do have a problem with those who know of or have access to raag learning, but can't be bothered or think that Nirdaareth raag kirtan is not important and who try and persuade others as such.
Nirdaareth raag kirtan was how kirtan was don for 400 years, every Sikh respected and followed in their Guru's footsteps, who are we to change our Guru's style of kirtan. Everyone keeps saying others are no less Sikhs, true, but what of those who know raag and then still choose to use their own tunes (well borrowed tunes from films and other songs), so they no simply imply that Guru's raag is not good enough?
We need to look at the core problems, this is not a simple issue where all people can be branded into one pot, that goes for both sides raag and non-raag.
Non-raag - already mentioned those who are innocent, thats fine, I love them. What about others, who know of raag - they still use filmy music becasue - charava, jaathaa culture (rather than Guru culture), popularity, fame, wealth, want to be unique etc......
I have no respect for any of those reasons, if you know how to do kirtan in Guru's method, then use it.
Why is it that for every single other topic, everyone jumps up and says, "because that is what our Guru's did"? Why does the same not apply here.
Irrelevant of any Gursikh or jathaa or culture, who should be our role model, Guru or someone else?
Why is it important to have banaa, to have sarbloh bibek, to do NITNEM, to do ishnaan, are these not all things which our Guru did?
Then why is Nirdaareth raag kirtan any less important?
I'll tell you why, because it isn't in SGPC/Akal Takht Maryada per se.
So what, is that maryada (which is flawed in parts anyway) higher than Guru ki Bani? If Bani tells us the raag before each shabad, is that not enough hukum, does the whole organisation of bani based on the mood (raag) of the shabads not give you enough evidence of Guru Arjun Dev Ji's intentions, this is not to mention that we have chucked our Guru Sahibaans divine gifts in the trash and replaced them with a farangi sub-standard baja.
It's all about culture and being patriotic - to our jathaa, or our Gurdwara or our family or our heroes.
Our Guru's should be our jathaa, their culture our culture and they should be our heroes/role models 1st of all!
As for Prof, I am sure there has been a misunderstanding. Many of teh Bibian students including his personal students, wear a dastaar, including my wife, and many more are planning to soon!
Bhai ns Ji,
If yo look at the start of any shabad, the 1st word written should answer your question.
Guru Ji says time and time again that without naam and hukum, all actions are useless including raag. Banaa, naam simran, sarbloh, NITNEM ... Veerji are also useless without pyaar for Guru. The example is out of context.
I can give you referneces where Guru also praises the use of raag.
This is a non-arguement. The answer is completely clear in Guru Maharaj.
SAT Sri Akaal
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 08 Mar 2006
ns Ji,
The address is - Tooting Broadway, Tooting, South west London.
Please see the attached, it gives full details of address and picture of the Gurdwara.
http://www.rajacademy.com/article.php?article_id=126&PHPSESSID=25be8eb1188d32e83216133586d03c6f
Would be great to see you there (and any other bhen/bhraa that can make it), I promise you will love it!
And you will get to see the Anand Sahib done in full (40 Paurian) in Ramkali -with Guru's saaj, all done by many Gur-sikhs.... experience how Gursikh invoked Anand Sahib for 400 years until the British came and SGPC made all it's changes.. it is a magical experience, I promise you.
Saturday - 6.30pm>>>
Sat-Naam
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Malkit Soor (Scotland) · 08 Mar 2006
There are thousands of raags within Kirtan, no one can ever know them all, just to clear that up.
Puratan kirtan is top, nowadays, this is not the case, many are making own things up. In Puratan times, raag was sung in Darbar sahib, nothing like we have today, times are and have changed unfortunately.
Before you had people like Zakhmi, Sant Sujan Singh, Sant Bahdhur Ji, Giani Amolak Singh Ji, Bhai Randhir Singh Ji (only heard 2 shabads though of Bhai sahib Ji's).
Nowadays weve got ragis like Rangila, Sant Anoop Singh Prof Darshan Singh, Jaghadhri Wale, who are nowhere near as good as these puratan Ragis, today, these ragis are just out to make money, its a shame, but thats how it is today, The time we live in today is bad! Maybe in the future, things will change, we have to kep praying to Waheguru!
Bhul Chuk Marf Ji!
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 08 Mar 2006
Satsriakal to all and Harcharan Singh Ji!
You wrote "I am not knowledgable on this subject, as I am only coming to learn the role of various taals in the kirtan I am learning."
I found the following Vaak in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji from Guru Nanak Ji.
[gurbani]kr ibnu vwjw pg ibnu qwlw ][/gurbani]
"kar bin vaajaa pag bin taalaa."
Hands without a music instrument, feet without beat
[gurbani]jy sbdu buJY qw scu inhwlw ][/gurbani]
"jay sabad bujhai taa sach nihaalaa." SGGS Ang 412-10
When Shabad is resolved then truth lavishes on.
Gurdev is saying when Shabad is resolved without music instruments in hands and without music beats being counted by feet then truth lavishes on.
Why are you pleading for resolving Shabad with music instruments and learning various Taals?
Please explain? What have you reached up to now?
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 09 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh Ji,
I am not going to get into a pointless discussion with you again.
You are clearly stating that music is not important.
Again misinterpreting Gurbani for your own ignorent and biased views.
What I have reached? It's not about what "I" have reached, it's about where Guru Ji's gift has reached, I have nothing to offer, I am simply trying to help in re-establishing our Guru's kirtan, even if my effort is only worht 2 cents.
You will be pleased to hear that there are many Gursikh who have read these posts and found them inspirational and are interested in learning about Guru Ji's puratan Kirtan, and would also like Tapoban Sahib to host a pratan Kirtan event.
Veer ji, if you don't mind me saying, you have series issues, I don't know what they are, but should seek to resolve them elsewhere, may be you heard some really unpleasant kirtan in your childhood and the memory is possibly still sub-consiously haunting you.
Either way, I am not propogating anything bad, I am simply speaking about kirtan as was done/intended by our Guru Sahiban and about the saaj that they created as a gift for us.
In the face of these facts a long side a tradition that was started by Guru Nanak Dev Ji in order to propogate the truth around the world and heal peoples man and athmaa, your miscontrued interpretations of gurbani speak for themself.
You have contributed one iota to any discussion we have had, but simply tried your hardest to discredit not just Guru's Nirdaareth raag, but kirtan in general as your previous post clearly shows.
And for your info - the aforementioned shabad is predominantly talking about Vedic traditions of worship which are both dancing and singing, and they beleive that thay is enough to reach God.
They also say the same about ishnaan and mediating, does that mean that we don't need to do those either!
Where as Guru Maharaj emphasises that they are not, we must find naam japna, do seva, do kirtan, be truthful... submit our self to him, submit ourslef to his hukum, live our life according to Guru's will.
Please stop tying in searches for instruments, taals and raag to prove your non-existent point. All your misinpretations have been disproved in previous discussions.
Have some fear of Waheguru Veer ji, stop trying to stop the love of praising Waheguru in Guru's manner spreading.
SAT SRI AKAAL
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
LK · 09 Mar 2006
-----------
Then why is Nirdaareth raag kirtan any less important?
I'll tell you why, because it isn't in SGPC/Akal Takht Maryada per se.
So what, is that maryada (which is flawed in parts anyway) higher than Guru ki Bani? If Bani tells us the raag before each shabad, is that not enough hukum, does the whole organisation of bani based on the mood (raag) of the shabads not give you enough evidence of Guru Arjun Dev Ji's intentions, this is not to mention that we have chucked our Guru Sahibaans divine gifts in the trash and replaced them with a farangi sub-standard baja.
-----------
Take a chill pill bhaji. No need to attack Akal Thakhat Maryada. I've got massive respect for Raag Kirtan, and agree that ideally all Kirtan should be done in raag, but don't have a dig at Akal Thkhat Maryada for not mentioning it. SIkh missionary which follows Akal Thkhat emphasizes the importance of Raag Kirtan in their litterature.
In no place does Akal takhat Rehitmaryada CONTRADICT or claim to go agianst Gurbani. Don't you ever dare to talk that way about Akal Thakhat again. Shame on us for calling ourselves Sikhs, yet not giving two hoots about what Akal Thakhat has to say.
I totally agre with Raag Kirtan, and most of the other things youy've got to say, but don't ever dare to attack Akal Thakhat in future.
Shame on us, for calling ourselves Sikhs yet ATTACKING the Akal Thakhat maryada for not mentioning something that you like?
What next? Bhai Chaupa Singh maryada mentioned how to go to the toilet? Diss Akal Thakhat for not including that in their Maryada? Some things are common sense. If Guru Sahib has prescribed a Raag, ofcourse it is to be read - is there a queestion abotu it? Obviously nowdays most people don't know, so yes it could be something thta could be added in todays circumstances, but that you should go and sugest to the Akal Thkhat and not resort to attaching it.
Shame on us. We have no respect tot he instutitions created by our Gurus.
What's next? Who cares about Sarbat Khalsa, or puratan Gurmateey?
Vaheguru
Bhull chukk maaf
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
LK · 09 Mar 2006
------------
Nowadays weve got ragis like Rangila, Sant Anoop Singh Prof Darshan Singh, Jaghadhri Wale, who are nowhere near as good as these puratan Ragis, today, these ragis are just out to make money, its a shame, but thats how it is today, The time we live in today is bad! Maybe in the future, things will change, we have to kep praying to Waheguru!
Bhul Chuk Marf Ji!
-------------
Although I agree with your point that todays raagis are not much compared to the old day ones, I wonder -
1- What are you doing to sort the situation out?
2- Is it right to mention names of specific Raagis? i.e. Prof Darshan Singh, if all he was after was money, there was no need for him to speak out against the Indian Government and be tortured in jails (The Truth Magazine, published in Quebec). Ki lorRh si, if all he was after was money?
Prof Darshan Singh JI has doesn LOADS of Seva, including that of beign Akal Thakhat Jathedar, and is the only one who has decently resigned with a personal will and not been thrown out like the rest of our corrupt leaders.
Let's not have a dig on people to provide our point, because we could unconsciously be slanding pretty good Sikhs :)
-------
Author: Balbir Singh
Date: 03-08-06 15:53
Satsriakal to all and Harcharan Singh Ji!
You wrote "I am not knowledgable on this subject, as I am only coming to learn the role of various taals in the kirtan I am learning."
I found the following Vaak in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji from Guru Nanak Ji.
kr ibnu vwjw pg ibnu qwlw ]
"kar bin vaajaa pag bin taalaa."
Hands without a music instrument, feet without beat
jy sbdu buJY qw scu inhwlw ]
"jay sabad bujhai taa sach nihaalaa." SGGS Ang 412-10
When Shabad is resolved then truth lavishes on.
Gurdev is saying when Shabad is resolved without music instruments in hands and without music beats being counted by feet then truth lavishes on.
Why are you pleading for resolving Shabad with music instruments and learning various Taals?
Please explain? What have you reached up to now?
Balbir Singh
----------------------
Why did Guru Arjan Dev Ji then bother to play the Saranda (and even design it?)
or Guru Gobind Singh ji bother to desin the Taus, I'm sure they could have done something else during that time. Seems like a mis-interpretationg of the Shabad. Please read explaination on gurugranthdarpan.com, and if the Shahad still confuses you, let us know, as there are many knowledgbe Singhs on this forum, with knowledge on Gurbani, Including 'Panga Man' (Gyani ji of Malaysia) and Veer Kulbir Singh Ji (of Canada)
bhull chukk maaf.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 09 Mar 2006
Veer LK Ji,
I did not intend to offend anyone or attack the Akaal Takht maryada.
I stick by my opinion that the maryada is not 100% perfect, but I do have respect for and follow most of it. It is highly necessary as it brings some kind of standardisation amongst the panth, although we know other maryadas are also largely followed i.e. Taksaal.
My main issue with Akaal Takht maryada is their instruction on the recital of Anand sahib, pauriyan 1-5 then shortcut to 40. I do not believe our Pyare Guru Amardaas Ji gave us the song of bliss for 7/8ths of it to be missed out on a daily basis.
The same way you have spoken of common sense, the same common sense can be applied to the above, we should not skip out parts of a shabad. At the least end on a consecutive pauri i.e. 1-5.
But I agree there was no need need for my comment, it was outside the scope of the discussion.
I simply made that comment, because some clever cloggs would have said "where does it mention raag in our maryada".
I do beleive that SGPC are responsible for getting rid of the 15 odd raagis that used to perform kirtan at Darbaar Sahib, and replaced them and Guru's saaj with a few amateur kirtani and much cheaper and easier to learn bajai, which were readily been pushed into the Punjab by the British, another clever trick to destroy our heritage, alongside eliminating our Shaster Vidya by bounty hunting Akalis and reintroducing the caste system by forcing the poplulace to categorise themselves under the headings identified by the British.
And I also believe that the maryada reflects this, as folk and traditional tunes are mentioned, but not Nirdaareth raag, which is how Kirtan was done prior to the 1920's when the maryada was being put together.
I do not mean to attack our institutions or cause further division, but surely we can question things as a collective? My voice alone is worthless, if a few more people had similar opinions, then maybe we could do a benti.
I do have my opinions on the current Akaal Takht set up and the SGPC appointed Jathedaar, but I will keep those to my self - or save them for a more appropriate time.
Sincere apologies if I came accross offensively in anyway.
Harcharan Singh
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 09 Mar 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Veer Harcharan Singh Ji!
I pray your wishes get fulfilled. And you become a successful entrepreneur opening many music schools. But please for God sake, do not do it on the name of the Gurus. Raagees do not become holier because they alaap Raags, count Taals and imitate the Gurus.
No where the Gurus have suggested Raagees to sing or teach Raags and Taals to get enlightenment.
Raags and Taals are a way to earn bread in this world.
[gurbani]rotIAw kwrix pUrih qwl ][/gurbani]
"rotee-aa kaaran pooreh taal."
For the sake of bread he performs Taal.
[gurbani]Awpu pCwVih DrqI nwil ][/gurbani]SGGS Ang 465-8
"aap pachhaarheh Dhartee naal."
To win own earthly needs
As the result of true Simran, Gurus sang God's praise spontaneously. They did not perform rehearsals earlier.
Worldly religions have turned ugly because their followers started imitating their Gurus.
I have seen Kabir Panthees started weaving clothing material, Krishna lovers started stealing butter and Guru Arjan Dev Ji's followers started manufacturing the music instrument 'Saranda'.
They are convinced to have realized the truth of their Gurus.
It is surprising that you are not able to provide one instruction from the Gurus where they have suggested us to learn or teach Raags and Taals to achieve truth.
Please ponder over the Guru's experience about Taals.
[gurbani]ijau bysÍw ky prY AKwrw ][/gurbani]
"ji-o baisvaa kay parai akhaaraa."
Like falling in a trap of a prostitute
[gurbani]kwpru pihir krih séØIgwrw ][/gurbani]
"kaapar pahir karahi seeNgaaraa."
Adorning oneself wearing garments
[gurbani]pUry qwl inhwly sws ][/gurbani]
"pooray taal nihaalay saas."
He performs Taal lavishing on breath
[gurbani]vw ky gly jm kw hY Pws ]3][/gurbani]
"vaa kay galay jam kaa hai faas." ||3|| SGGS Ang 1165-4
Around his neck is the noose of Jam.
Veer Ji! Nobody is preaching you to stop singing Raags with beats (Taals), the Maya's influence. But please do not pose it as Guru's instruction.
The Gurus have clearly written about Truth. There is no chance to misinterpret the Guru's Baanee, in my view.
**************
Veer LK Ji wrote "Why did Guru Arjan Dev Ji then bother to play the Saranda (and even design it?) or Guru Gobind Singh ji bother to desin the Taus, I'm sure they could have done something else during that time."
Singing God's praise in a particular way is Will of God. The world observes it as a natural happening.
What should the rest of the world do who are blessed with other virtues than designing 'Taus' or playing 'Saranda'?
Are they still allowed to receive Naam and praise God?
Balbir Singh
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
LK · 09 Mar 2006
--------------
Author: Harcharan Singh
Date: 03-09-06 11:41
Veer LK Ji,
I did not intend to offend anyone or attack the Akaal Takht maryada.
I stick by my opinion that the maryada is not 100% perfect, but I do have respect for and follow most of it. It is highly necessary as it brings some kind of standardisation amongst the panth, although we know other maryadas are also largely followed i.e. Taksaal.
-----------------
So the Panth needs to stand up and meet together and do soething about it, liek it did 80 years ago. No point in attacking the only maryada going almost 99.9% to Gurbani.
---------------
My main issue with Akaal Takht maryada is their instruction on the recital of Anand sahib, pauriyan 1-5 then shortcut to 40. I do not believe our Pyare Guru Amardaas Ji gave us the song of bliss for 7/8ths of it to be missed out on a daily basis.
The same way you have spoken of common sense, the same common sense can be applied to the above, we should not skip out parts of a shabad. At the least end on a consecutive pauri i.e. 1-5.
----------------
You have an issue, talk to the people who have gian about it. Talk to Akal Thakhat, since your issue concerns them, and I'm sure historians such as Dr G.S Dhillon of Punjabi University (phd on SIngh Sabha Movement), Prof Darshan Singh Ji, go visit the British Library since they've got puratan Saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, they might have old gutkey as well. I'm sure Taksali Singhs wouldn't mind you having darshan of the Gutka they claim to belong to Baba Deep Singh Ji. You won't find answers to everything on the internet. If there's something that makes you anxious, go out and find the answer. Google doesn't have everything to do with Sikh ithas, whether we like it or not.
Your argument could be refered to about Chaupie Sahib as well. Why are only a FEW SHABADS from Guru Granth Sahib JI and a FEW from Dasam Granth read - why not all of them?
Although I see the issue you have, I think you should approuch real historians if it's sometihng that really concerns you. Go Punjabi University and meet up with real historians. Meet up with People like Dr Gurdip Singh Ji who have real knowledge of Gurbani, approuch people like Dr G.S Dhillon and other historians who have spent life time on research on Sikh Ithhas and Gurbani.
---------
But I agree there was no need need for my comment, it was outside the scope of the discussion.
I simply made that comment, because some clever cloggs would have said "where does it mention raag in our maryada".
----------
As you have mentioned, Gurbani is above all Maryadas, and thus the title Raag speaks for itself. No Maryada on this planet needs to mention something that Gurbani already mentions (although it could be nice to have it there, it doesn't have to)
---------
I do beleive that SGPC are responsible for getting rid of the 15 odd raagis that used to perform kirtan at Darbaar Sahib, and replaced them and Guru's saaj with a few amateur kirtani and much cheaper and easier to learn bajai, which were readily been pushed into the Punjab by the British, another clever trick to destroy our heritage, alongside eliminating our Shaster Vidya by bounty hunting Akalis and reintroducing the caste system by forcing the poplulace to categorise themselves under the headings identified by the British.
------------
As you probably know, the original SGPC was a bunch of good guys and not anyone who had an interest in ruining it for Panth. It included JEMS of the Panth. It is possible that the saajs were replaced during the time the British controlled the Darbar Sahib, before the SGPC actually took over. Pleave provide reference where the SGPC was responsible for stripping the panth of the puratan Kirtan saajs.
-----------
And I also believe that the maryada reflects this, as folk and traditional tunes are mentioned, but not Nirdaareth raag, which is how Kirtan was done prior to the 1920's when the maryada was being put together.
------------
I'm not sure whether you've actually have read the maryada now since what you say does not reflect the maryada. PLease re-read the Rehitmaryada @ the Kirtan section:
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
(d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be a refrain
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/rehat/rehat_03.htm#art6
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
[gurbani]s) SbdW nUM jotIAW dI Dwrnw jW rwg nwl pVHidAW bwhr dIAW mn-GVq qy vwDU qukW lw ky Dwrnw lwauxI jW gwauxw AXog hY[ Sbd dI quk hI Dwrnw bxweI jwvy[[/gurbani]
http://sgpc.net/sikhism/punjabi/kirtan.asp
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
It does indeed acknowledge the Singing of raag-kirtan.
------------
I do not mean to attack our institutions or cause further division, but surely we can question things as a collective? My voice alone is worthless, if a few more people had similar opinions, then maybe we could do a benti.
I do have my opinions on the current Akaal Takht set up and the SGPC appointed Jathedaar, but I will keep those to my self - or save them for a more appropriate time.
Sincere apologies if I came accross offensively in anyway.
Harcharan Singh
------------
The way daas saw it was that you were attacking a mahan institution of the panth. yes today unforuantly the corrupt SGPC leaders have control, and are doign their gand-mand, but the institution cannot be attacked just because this is a phase in history where we have lost and arn't doign anything to get back control from the modern day mahants.
bhull chukk maaf
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 09 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh Ji,
Your interpretations get worse and worse.
And your twisting of words gets even worse than that.
Your post is flawed I don't feel the need to respond, sangat can look at our previous conversations which you are trying to replicate by putting in searches for key words and then misinterpreting them.
You say "Worldly religions have turned ugly because their followers started imitating their Gurus.".
I say the world has turned ugly because followers stopped following in their Guru's footsteps and started thinking they know better.
All your baseless arguements will never change the fact the Kirtan was at the heart of Guru's life and those of their sikhs - and that Gurbani tells us time and time again to do kirtan to our Lord.
They will also not be able to change the structure of Gurbani - which is around raag - you will never be able to provide a decent arguement against why our Guru's did this.
Kirtan was how Gods truth was spread, too bad if you don't want to be a part of it.
I have no plansto open music schools, I am quite content in my career, and devote all my spare time to my Guru, and at present to learning and propogating my Guru's kirtan.
And the kirtan that I try to do at present (very basic for your info) is not Maya influenced, nor was my Guru's or any of the millions of Sikhs who followed my Guru. It is influenced by Dhan Dhan Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj, who showed us the power of Kirtan to change peoples lives and to be able to express our emotions and love to our true lord in teh most beautiful way possible.
We have nothing more to discuss.
Waheguru
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
------------- · 09 Mar 2006
harcharan singhs you should answer questions raised by balbir singh and not get angry. you should refrain from making personal attacks.
and you seem to be obsessed with raag. too much raag is not good for your spiritual health. nirdharat raag is just a tool to sing gurbani. you are making it seem as if its a big sin to casually sing gurbani without nirdharat raag. the whole panth sings "tu thakur tum peh ardaas" before ardaas. the whole panth does it in one tune and this tune is definitely not in gauri raag. are you supposed to sing this in gauri raag only?
just mere mention of raag on the top of the shabad does not mean that this is a hukam of guru sahib to sing in this raag only. its simply for our information. no gurbani pankiti gives us order to sing gurbani in raags. gurbani only says to sing gurbani. it does not say sing it in raags. please answer this question.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 09 Mar 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Veer Harcharan Singh Ji!
There is again a poor post from you. It is poor because it does not contain one reference from the Gurus to support your views.
Stubbornness is not going to help. Sikhs are anyway not Hatha Yogis.
I know it painful to leave Manmat. I was also a classical Raagee in the past lives.
Gurbani says [gurbani]scw AlK AByau hiT n pqIjeI ][/gurbani]
"sachaa alakh abhay-o hath na pateeja-ee."
The true, imperceptible by the eye, beyond any form is not pleased by stubbornness.
[gurbani]ieik gwvih rwg prIAw rwig n BIjeI ][/gurbani]
"ik gaavahi raag paree-aa raag na bheej-ee."
One sings Raags and sub-raags. He does not melt.
[gurbani]ieik nic nic pUrih qwl Bgiq n kIjeI ][/gurbani]
"ik nach nach pooreh taal bhagat na keej-ee." SGGS Ang 1285-13
One goes on dancing performing Taals. Bhagati is not done.
Now please do not try to convince that Bhagati is perfect when performed in Raags and Taal without dancing.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
. · 09 Mar 2006
vjkk, vjkf
how do you know that you were a classical ragi in past lives??
vjkk, vjkf
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh,
Look at the first word from all the shabads you have taken one tuk from, and you will find your answer.
Your selctive quotes refer to people who think that raag, taal and dance are singular forms of worship, which were at large in Guru's times - they refer to those who followed the vedic tradition, if you read the sam-veda and rig-veda you will understand what I mean.
Kirtan is a way of expressing our love to our Lord, the debate is simply this, should we perform that kirtan as our Guru's did, in their measures and emotions, or using our own.
No one is saying raag, taal and dance are the singular measures for finding God, only you are.
Thank you for going on your judgemental trip again and kindly identifying my weaknesses, much appreciated, I will work on them.
Your claim to being a classical ragi in your past life has nothing to do with Sikhi, both in terms of your statment of of classical raag.
We are not talking about classical raag, we are talking about Guru's raag and gurmat sangeet.
Your last line is non-senseical "Now please do not try to convince that Bhagati is perfect when performed in Raags and Taal without dancing.".
I think this may have been meant for another thread.
God bless you.
Waheguru
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006
--------Ji,
"harcharan singhs you should answer questions raised by balbir singh and not get angry. you should refrain from making personal attacks."
I apologise if I am loosing my patience, but if you read previous threads, you will see we have already had these discussions with Balbir Singh, he is anti kirtan full stop, let alone raag.
"and you seem to be obsessed with raag. too much raag is not good for your spiritual health. nirdharat raag is just a tool to sing gurbani. you are making it seem as if its a big sin to casually sing gurbani without nirdharat raag. the whole panth sings "tu thakur tum peh ardaas" before ardaas. the whole panth does it in one tune and this tune is definitely not in gauri raag. are you supposed to sing this in gauri raag only?"
just mere mention of raag on the top of the shabad does not mean that this is a hukam of guru sahib to sing in this raag only. its simply for our information. no gurbani pankiti gives us order to sing gurbani in raags. gurbani only says to sing gurbani. it does not say sing it in raags. please answer this question.
Khalsa ji, I am trying to help bring back our Guru's gifts. If your thinking is that the whole structure of Gurbani and the start of every shabad with raag it should be rendered in is a coincidence or is "mere", then thats your choice, nothing my Guru did is "mere" or casuakl, there every action served a purpose.
My answer to your question is with a question, why is the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji organised according to the raag - mood of the shabads? Why was it not organised according to the authors? Please answer this question.
If every shabad starts with a raag, what more hukum or spoon feeding do you need to understand why Guru Ji has done this?
And you should also consider that all kirtan was done in Nirdaareth raag until the 1900's, why are you only looking at the last 100 years, why not the last 400?
This subject is being researched by many people currently, I will post some research here very soon to.
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Bhai LK Ji,
1 – The answer to NITNEM, which as it is today (created in the 1920’s), will not be found in puratan saroops – puritan saroops and Pothis contain complete shabads, not short cut versions, unless someone cares to argue otherwise. Skipping the Anand Sahib recital was purely a decision made on an intellectual basis, by the intellectuals of the day.
2 – All rehitnamas, old historical texts refer to either Anand Sahib (full) or the first 5 paurian only, none refers to 1-5>>>>>40.
3 – My argument does also refer to Chaupai Sahib, but most Sikh groups already practice the full version i.e. Nanaksar, Nishkaam Sevak Jathaa, Budda Daal, Baba Isher Singh Ji Rare Wale sangat to name a few, it’s only Singh Sabha that really don’t.
4 – I take your comments on board, this does need to be discussed at a higher level, but there is nothing wrong with stating opinions, they are not anti-gurmat – they are simply saying lets attain the full pyaar of the shabad, not just a tiny part of it. All changes-movements start at a floor level, the argument/discussion would be stronger with more people on board, before the people that be are approached.
I am aware that actions speaker louder than words, that is why I hope you will join us in Tooting, London this Saturday to experience the full Anand Sahib recited in Ramkali after an evening of Naam Simran.
Ultimately, irrelevant of marydai, everyone will still do what they want, be it Guru’s raag, full Anand Sahib or neither, small people like me can only express what our heart says and how we understand our Guru, we are not forcing anything on anyone nor doing Guru’s beadbi, quite the opposite in fact, I feel I am defending my Guru’s gifts (not that they need my help) and am letting people know they have a choice, and reasons for that choice.
(d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be a refrain
(d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be a refrain
Veer ji, this clearly states that alongside “traditional musical measure” (which may or may not be interpreted as Nirdaareth raag), rhythmic folk tunes are also acceptable.
To me there is a difference between hukum and tradition, Nirdaareth raag has been placed at the start of ever shabad, this is not tradition, this is immortalised in Bani – it is hukum.
Tradition can refer to Guru’s saaj, to the type of banaa we wear, the colour of our dastaar etc….
Anyway, change will come in time with Guru’s kirpa, if not as long as Guru’s traditions and hukums don’t disappear and are not grossly misinterpreted, at least the sangat/panth will always have the option of making up their own mind.
Lastly,
The saaj and raag disappearance is currently being worked on.
Irrelevant of whether this disappearance happened beofre or after SGPC inception, the point is that the kirtan maryada was not retained, and SGPC are responsible for that.
Lets, concentrate on the here and now, history will always be subjective in it's nature.
Waheguru
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Satsriakal to all and Harcharan Singh Ji!
Please listen. Guru Arjan Dev Ji, the apprehender of Raags and Taals, is singing.
[gurbani]GUGr bwiD bjwvih qwlw ][/gurbani]
"ghooghar baaDh bajaaveh taalaa."
One tie bells and plays Taals.
[gurbani]AMqir kptu iPrih byqwlw ][/gurbani]
"antar kapat fireh baytaalaa."
Inside deceptions move as demons.
[gurbani]vrmI mwrI swpu n mUAw ][/gurbani]
"varmee maaree saap na moo-aa."
A hole is destroyed. The snake is not killed.
[gurbani]pRBu sB ikCu jwnY ijin qU kIAw ]3][/gurbani]
"parabh sabh kichh jaanai jin too kee-aa." ||3|| SGGS Ang 1348-5,
God knows everything that you do.
**************
You wrote "Look at the first word from all the shabads you have taken one tuk from, and you will find your answer."
Perhaps you are asking to look at the first title before the Shabads.
Quote <<>>
Why are you trying to deviate people from the Guru's Shabad?
Quote <<>>
Please provide one reference from the Gurus Baanee where they have suggested us to imitate them.
Quote <<>>
These are your interpretations. I have only referred to Guru's Vaaks.
Quote<<>>
Are you sure now that Sikhi has nothing to do with classical Raagees, also in the past?
Quote <<>>
I have yet to find such titles in Gurbaanee to get convinced. I hope you give me some time.
Quote <<>>
Please close your eyes when you remember those and meditate.
God blesses you too.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear All and Single Point (.) Ji!
The Gurus often sang Hymns mentioning 'last lives'.
Talking about past lives precisely is not necessary.
The danger is that many will find me related with them somehow on regularly changing worldly levels.
The bliss is in realizing the permanent relation from where we all originated.
Come to know Simran.
One may forget to ask such questions.
God's Wisdom is only the answer.
**************
Mind leads one constantly toward outer worlds through senses that are open outwardly.
This is like the pendulum moving in one direction known as world.
The true Gurshabad leads one toward inner worlds and the center of the origin.
On this way they store all lives and their experiences as memory.
We all know God. God is our origin and the beginning. We are HIS present Saroop.
Anybody can realize his past lives and the origin too.
True Simran is the easiest way.
**************
Here is a tip. Remembering past lives is not an art and aim as these lives were lived unconsciously with ego.
The art is to transcend lives with the true Shabad Guru and realize God. God is the true destination and the origin simultaneously.
Love.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh,
What has that shabad got to do with this discussion, who is claiming that taals will give yo umukti, are you a Vedic follower, neither am I nor the sangat, again your quote is out of context. God forgive you.
Why does every shabads "title" contain a raag, why is Mahraaj organised in raag format, with all shabads from all Guru Sahiban and bhagats being placed under certain raag chapters? Why was Maharaaj not organised according to Authors or subjects or any other index?
Please enlighten us.
You are starting your "it's silly to imitate our Guru's" arguement again.
I would be interested to know how many people in this sangat do not look at our Guru's as role models.
ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਪਿਛੈ ਭਜਿ ਪਵਹਿ ਏਹਾ ਕਰਣੀ ਸਾਰੁ ॥
satgur pichhai bhaj paveh ayhaa karnee saar.
You say:
"Please close your eyes when you remember those and meditate."
I do vichaar to my pithas words, not yours. Your words do not need vichaar, reflect your opinions quite clearly.
Waheguru
ਜਿਨੀ ਮੇਰਾ ਪਿਆਰਾ ਰਾਵਿਆ ਤਿਨ ਪੀਛੈ ਲਾਗਿ ਫਿਰਾਉ ॥
jinee mayraa pi-aaraa raavi-aa tin peechhai laag firaa-o.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
LK · 10 Mar 2006
----------------------------------------
Author: Harcharan Singh
Date: 03-10-06 04:54
Bhai LK Ji,
1 – The answer to NITNEM, which as it is today (created in the 1920’s), will not be found in puratan saroops – puritan saroops and Pothis contain complete shabads, not short cut versions, unless someone cares to argue otherwise. Skipping the Anand Sahib recital was purely a decision made on an intellectual basis, by the intellectuals of the day.
2 – All rehitnamas, old historical texts refer to either Anand Sahib (full) or the first 5 paurian only, none refers to 1-5>>>>>40.
-----------------------------------------
* Have you looked at old Gutkey, of the RehiRaas Sahib, or are you only assuming that the short Anand Sahib only came in 1920's.
How many old gutkey have you looked at?
How many historians who have spent all their life on researching Singh Sabha Movement, have you approuched?
* I'm not sure why you mention Nitnem in this thread since it is completly irrelevant, if you are implying the 3 or 5 bani controversy then I have a response to you, but please clearify.
--------------------------
3 – My argument does also refer to Chaupai Sahib, but most Sikh groups already practice the full version i.e. Nanaksar, Nishkaam Sevak Jathaa, Budda Daal, Baba Isher Singh Ji Rare Wale sangat to name a few, it’s only Singh Sabha that really don’t.
--------------------------
Most jathebandis (or Sikh groups, as you refer them as) also do short Anand Sahib in Rehiraas.
Most Jathebandis also ignore Raag Kirtan, and Singh Sabha are one of the few trying to revive it. What was the point in killing it if they are now reviving it? Perhaps they weren't out to kill it after all..
------------------------
4 – I take your comments on board, this does need to be discussed at a higher level, but there is nothing wrong with stating opinions, they are not anti-gurmat – they are simply saying lets attain the full pyaar of the shabad, not just a tiny part of it. All changes-movements start at a floor level, the argument/discussion would be stronger with more people on board, before the people that be are approached.
--------------------------
I disagree. If you have an issue with someone you should go and approuch them and ask them about it and give them a chance to clearify, before making it into a huge controversy. Thre's not point in 'preparing a web army', if you can be explain the real meaning and reason in the way it is done.
Please please please, insteaed of trying to stir this subject up, PLEASE approuch historians, puratan Gutkey, Akal Thakhat, SIkh missionary and ASK THEM ABOUT IT, instead of making a big issue out of it without doing proper reserach. PLEASE accept daas' petty benti, and DO TAKE TIME and research, but do not stir things up without looking at the above mentioned very simple sources, since they might prove to be extremely valueble in this issue.
--------------
I am aware that actions speaker louder than words, that is why I hope you will join us in Tooting, London this Saturday to experience the full Anand Sahib recited in Ramkali after an evening of Naam Simran.
---------------
AS much as I'd love to be there I will not be able to due to personal reasons.
-------------
Ultimately, irrelevant of marydai, everyone will still do what they want, be it Guru’s raag, full Anand Sahib or neither, small people like me can only express what our heart says and how we understand our Guru, we are not forcing anything on anyone nor doing Guru’s beadbi, quite the opposite in fact, I feel I am defending my Guru’s gifts (not that they need my help) and am letting people know they have a choice, and reasons for that choice.
-------------
But before thinking that you are defending Guru Sahib's Shabads, you should find out if the concept of doign Anand Sahib is old or not, and thus i think you should spend some time in Punjab, and do some PROPER reserach, and not just rely on google as your best friend to find everything for you.
----------
(d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be a refrain
(d) It is improper, while singing hymns to rhythmic folk tunes or to traditional musical measures, or in team singing, to induct into them improvised and extraneous refrains. Only a line from the hymn should be a refrain
Veer ji, this clearly states that alongside “traditional musical measure” (which may or may not be interpreted as Nirdaareth raag), rhythmic folk tunes are also acceptable.
To me there is a difference between hukum and tradition, Nirdaareth raag has been placed at the start of ever shabad, this is not tradition, this is immortalised in Bani – it is hukum.
Tradition can refer to Guru’s saaj, to the type of banaa we wear, the colour of our dastaar etc….
---------------
* That is exactly why I refered to the Punjabi version, and am not sure whether you read it or not. 'Traditional music measures'is probably the most suitable translation the translator could find, for a person who knows nothing about raags or classical indian musicology. The specific word 'raag' is used in the punjabi version, which I did quote in my previous post. I will requote my previous post:
[gurbani]s) SbdW nUM jotIAW dI Dwrnw jW rwg nwl pVHidAW bwhr dIAW mn-GVq qy vwDU qukW lw ky Dwrnw lwauxI jW gwauxw AXog hY[ Sbd dI quk hI Dwrnw bxweI jwvy[[/gurbani]
-------------------
Anyway, change will come in time with Guru’s kirpa, if not as long as Guru’s traditions and hukums don’t disappear and are not grossly misinterpreted, at least the sangat/panth will always have the option of making up their own mind.
--------------------
Agreed =D
---------------
Lastly,
The saaj and raag disappearance is currently being worked on.
Irrelevant of whether this disappearance happened beofre or after SGPC inception, the point is that the kirtan maryada was not retained, and SGPC are responsible for that.
Lets, concentrate on the here and now, history will always be subjective in it's nature.
Waheguru
-----------------
* It is relevant whether this disapperance happened before or after SGPC, sice we have people going around bashing the old-day SGPC which was one of the most panthic people around, and it is absolutely not acceptble that someone goes around bashing them.
* I do not think you can expect anything from modern day SGPC, but consider that it is your own responsibilty for reviving it (which you are), since SGPC isn't working for the panth any more. However I will leave you with this article from the Sikhsangat and tribune news services:
http://www.sikhsangat.org/publish/article_886.shtml
Also there was an article earlier on on a bhai sahib who just recently (during 2005) did kirtan with Taus in Darbar Sahib.
Bhull chukk maaf
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
ks · 10 Mar 2006
indeed, the key is why is the Guru Granth Sabih organized by raag, and not author, theme, or most logically, lexographically?
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 11 Mar 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Harcharan Singh Ji!
Thanks for the wonderful references from Guru's Baanee.
[gurbani]siqgur ipCY Bij pvih eyhw krxI swru ][/gurbani]
"satgur pichhai bhaj paveh ayhaa karnee saar."
One should run after the true method. This is the essence of doing.
[gurbani]siqguru KoitAhu Kry kry sbid svwrxhwru ][/gurbani]
"satguru khoti-ahu kharay karay sabad savaaranhaar." SGGS Ang 143-16
Sat Guru makes the counterfeit genuine. Shabad is embellishing.
Veer Ji! Since when have you stopped running after the true method (Gur) and started learning Raags?
We know the Guru's views about Raags, Taals and imitating enlightened persons. Don't we?
**************
[gurbani]ijnI myrw ipAwrw rwivAw iqn pICY lwig iPrwau ][/gurbani]
"jinee mayraa pi-aaraa raavi-aa tin peechhai laag firaa-o."
Those who are aware of my beloved they follow Him ever.
[gurbani]kir imMniq kir jodVI mY pRBu imlxY kw cwau ]1][/gurbani]
"kar minat kar jod-rhee mai parabh milnai kaa chaa-o." ||1|| SGGS Ang 41-1,
Make solicitation. Make an obeisance. I am enthusiastic to meet God.
Veer Ji, Gurdev is suggesting us to [gurbani]pICY lwig iPrwau [/gurbani], make solicitation and make an obeisance.
What guided you to learn Raags, Taals and perform those? The Gurus have not once suggested us to learn and perform those though.
**************
There are persons who live in illusion to have found the key to open the wisdom of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
Strange is that they go on wasting the precious life to unlock the treasure.
The true key is never given in the hands of ignorant.
The story is different in the truthful world of Paramayshwar.
Everyone is the treasure of God's Wisdom.
The key is in the hands of the true Guru.
[gurbani]ijs kw igRhu iqin dIAw qwlw kuMjI gur saupweI ][/gurbani]
"jis kaa garihu tin dee-aa taalaa kunjee gur sa-upaa-ee."
Who owns home (body), he has locked it up and gave the key to the Guru.
[gurbani]Aink aupwv kry nhI pwvY ibnu siqgur srxweI ]3][/gurbani]
"anik upaav karay nahee paavai bin satgur sarnaa-ee." ||3||
He does many efforts, does not get it without coming to the true Guru's shelter.
Harcharan Singh Ji! Singing Raags with awareness of different beats is also one of the efforts, in my experience.
The true key is realized when the lock is found open.
All other keys are pseudo till the lock is on.
Do you know why people are searching for the key?
It is because they do not want to become a Sikh.
They want to become a Guru.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
LK · 11 Mar 2006
What guided you to learn Raags, Taals and perform those? The Gurus have not once suggested us to learn and perform those though.
------------------
The Gurus themselves showed the importance of instrumentsl by themselves designing them and themselves playing them.
Guru Arjan Dev ji Sahib ordered Guru Granth Sahib Ji after raag, after all there must be some reason for this
Guru Sahib himself played the saranda
Guru Hargobind Sahib emphasized DhaDi Vaara with the sarangi
Guru Gobind Singh ji desgned the Taus, all string instrument designed to be played using the raga system.
Guru Sahib himself wrote the name of a raag before every single shabad
all of the above things seem to be too much to be a coinsidence don't you think?
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 12 Mar 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear LK Ji!
You wrote "Guru Sahib himself played the saranda
Guru Hargobind Sahib emphasized DhaDi Vaara with the sarangi
Guru Gobind Singh ji desgned the Taus, all string instrument designed to be played using the raga system."
I am surprised why the world does not recognize them as musicians or a music instrument inventor or manufacturer.
Quote <<>>
Come to know true Simran. The answer is waiting for you.
Quote "Guru Sahib himself wrote the name of a raag before every single shabad
all of the above things seem to be too much to be a coinsidence don't you think?"
A person gets birth in Canada. He is blessed with white skin, blond hair and blue eyes. He learns French, English and Latin languages. He studies and practices medicine. Later he becomes a popular author.
He also receives Naam from the Sat Guru and gets enlightenment.
Now please let all know. What would you prefer to imitate from his life?
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 12 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh Ji,
"I am surprised why the world does not recognize them as musicians or a music instrument inventor or manufacturer."
-----------
Well actually, I thought our Guru's were recognised as the perfect human beings, and were recognised for their mastery and correct utilisation of any field that they entered?
Fir example, our Guru's ARE recognised as healers, charity workers, master musicians, master designers (in many fields), masters of linguistics, master poets, master of shaster vidya, master diplomats, shaheed, master debaters, the ultimate parchaaraks..... we as a panth should look to our Guru's to see how to utilise each of these fields correctly, our Guru's mastered these fields on a pure gurmat basis, which is what we should do.
Our Guru's are role models like it or not, if I want to become a psychologist, I will look to my Guru 1st, not modern experts, our Guru's use of psychology was so beauiful, hard hitting, compassionate, educational, life saving and 100% correct, that we can learn much from it.
Quote <<>>
Come to know true Simran. The answer is waiting for you.
---------
Thats a cop out. Why use this arguement when faced with this question, and give your opinion on all other questions, please be consistent, "come to know simran" should apply to all discussions that you have been involved in.
As you have come to know simran and we evidently have not, then please help out your lost little brothers, and explain why Sri Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj hsa been compliled according to raag, and no according to author, time periods, subject or any other field?
And please explain if simran is the only requisite, then why did our Guru's devote such large parts of their lives to kirtan, why was kirtan the centre of their darbaar, why was kirtan used as the single most powerful tool to propogate Gods word?????
Why did Guru Nanak Dev Ji have Bhai Mardana accompany him everywhere?
Could it be because Guru Ji was trying to appeal to peoples minds and souls? Could it be that Guru Ji's method of communication to Tamils, Assamese, Tibetans, Nepalese was through Bhai Mardana's rabab as well as the sweetness and truth of Guru Ji's voice - which the poeple of many lands may or may not have been able to understand linguistically?
Gurmat Sangeet is a universal language dear brother. If used correctly, in the correct context, by the correct people, with the correct words, creating the correct emotion, it can win over and unite man, as it did for our Guru's. This is why Kirtan was the heart of their darbaar, this is why raag is the backbone of the structure of Bani.
"A person gets birth in Canada. He is blessed with white skin, blond hair and blue eyes. He learns French, English and Latin languages. He studies and practices medicine. Later he becomes a popular author.
He also receives Naam from the Sat Guru and gets enlightenment.
Now please let all know. What would you prefer to imitate from his life?"
---------
What have our Guru's physical attributes got to do with anything? No one is talking about their features?
Our Guru's gave us Gurmukhi, this is the language of bani, are yuo saying that learning our Guru's language is not important?
Our Guru's have used many languages in bani, farsi, braj etc why?
Maybe so that Guru's message could be shared by all? Do we not therefore have a duty to follow in our Guru's footsteps and learn more languages so that bani can be made available to more people and shared with mankind,rahter than just be kept by Punjabis (which was not our Guru's plan, Punjabis are the chosen people?
All this with the caveat that to understand bani in it's true essence, one must finally learn Gurmukhi.
Our Guru's practiced Shaster Vidya to defend themselves and others against oppression, are you saying that we should not immitate?
Our Guru's showed us how to be charitable, how to accept people of all faiths and defend all faiths are yuo saying we should immitate?
Our Guru's gave us kirtan, so that we can express our longings, happiness, sadness, worries, anxieties, questions, bereavement etc... a way of cleansing these emotions out of us so that we can once again be balanced with Guru's kirpa - a way of healing us, and Guru has given us the tools to do this, are you saying we should ignore this?
Please don't use simran arguement, naam japna on each and every saas is a pre-requisite, there is not an option as you make out, that you can either do one or the other.
There is no point naam japna, if you are going to then close your eyes and ignore the rest of Guru's hukums and take lessons from their jeevans.
Your imitation arguement is so..., I don't kno why you carry it on.
Here are some facts about life:
You are an imitator, each and every one us is, this is how people learn things in life, through imitation.
How did you learn how to speak English/Punjabi, it wasn;t a divine revelation, yo imitated your parents and teachers, how did you learn to eat, how did you learn about the law, ho did you learn to drive, how did you learn to read a map, how did you learn to type, how did you learn of this website.......
Imitation is the method of learning used by all animal species in the world, and also used by all of us.
How did yo learn about simran, how did you to do simran, how did you learn to read bani.............................
Please stop using "why do you imitate" arguement.
The ultimate imitation - with the objective of finding Gods charan is to follow in Guru Sahiban's footsteps, is to learn of and try and attain their gun, is to try and think and act like them (gurmat), is to try and be brave like them, be unprejudiced like them, is to try and live our jeevan like them.
Is reading gurbani and following their hukum not imitating what millions of Gur Pyare have done for 400 years?
Sat Naam
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Balbir Singh · 12 Mar 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Harcharan Singh Ji!
I have a friend. He is Shaiv, a strict Bhagat of Shiv. He has a beautiful picture of Shiv sitting in Samaadhi. Sometimes I wish to ask him a question.
You meditate on Shiv and on whom Shiv is meditating?
Today I feel like asking you this question.
On whom the Gurus meditated? Didn't they suggest us to meditate on the formless too?
**************
The Gurus have explained everything that is necessary. Why are you trying to search answers the Gurus did not want you to know right now?
At the same time you are ignoring their suggestions not to sing Raags with Taals and imitate them.
The Gurus answered every question they have raised.
Arrangement of Hymns with particular titles is the Godly evolution. It can be experienced, alone with the growth of consciousness through Simran not any discussion.
**************
You confessed in theses words what you are missing "There is no point naam japna, if you are going to then close your eyes and ignore the rest of Guru's hukums and take lessons from their jeevans."
In my view, People alone with true Naam Jap can realize the truth also from the Guru's lives.
**************
I appreciate your truthful statement "Gurmat Sangeet is a universal language dear brother."
May God bless you to keep busy and reach universe.
**************
Your last sentence is "Is reading gurbani and following their hukum not imitating what millions of Gur Pyare have done for 400 years?"
The Gurus never appreciated reading or reciting scriptures to realize Truth. Nor they ever did it.
Who knows? How many people go on with rebirths for how many years with the desire of imitating?
Blessed is the rare Jeev- aatmaa who gets salvation and solace.
This is my last post in this thread.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 13 Mar 2006
Balbir Singh Ji,
I have a friend. He is Shaiv, a strict Bhagat of Shiv. He has a beautiful picture of Shiv sitting in Samaadhi. Sometimes I wish to ask him a question.
You meditate on Shiv and on whom Shiv is meditating?
Today I feel like asking you this question.
On whom the Gurus meditated? Didn't they suggest us to meditate on the formless too?
**************
Veer Ji, I am not sure why you thought of me when remembering your friend. I meditate on my Akaal Murath, my Antarjami, my Nirbau…..
I meditate on the same Wahe Guru my Guru Sahibaan did, on the same Guru my eternal father, Guru Gobind Singh Ji Mahraaj did, in my opinion, on the same Karta Purkh that all the blessed souls from every corner of this dhardhee meditate on.
”The Gurus have explained everything that is necessary. Why are you trying to search answers the Gurus did not want you to know right now?
At the same time you are ignoring their suggestions not to sing Raags with Taals and imitate them.
The Gurus answered every question they have raised.
Arrangement of Hymns with particular titles is the Godly evolution. It can be experienced, alone with the growth of consciousness through Simran not any discussion.”
**************
Veer Ji, I don’t think our Guru’s didn’t want us to know the meaning of raags and how to utilise them during kirtan, if they didn’t want us to know this then why did they put he Nirdaareth raag in front of every shabad? Why did they compile Ad Granth Sahib in Raag format – chapters, why have Sikhs from Guru Sahibs times been doing kirtan to raag (only diluting it this century).
Even more commonsensical – Guru Gobind Singh performed raag kirtan with his Taus, would his Sikhs not have sang with him and done the same. Post Guru Ji, would they not have carried on doing Kirtan as they had done with our Guru’s? Would they not have taught there children the same?
It is no big mystery as people make out, it is in black and white in Bani, the gift has only been nearly lost this century for many many reasons (which I have stated on another thread).
With Guru’s kirpa, some sevadaar are now doing mahaan seva and have deidated their whole life to bringing Guru’; kirtan back, for the love of their Guru and for the opportunity to praise their Waheguru in the most beautiful way known to man.
I have explained your misunderstood explanations of raad, dance and taal many times. Please do a little research into Vedic texts and culture and you will understand what our Guru Ji was speaking against. It makes zero sense if we take your translation, why would Guru ji refer that to us, and then break the Pakavaj and invent the Joraa (Original Sikh Tabla – also making a comeback), which gives us a rhythm, skeleton, base, speed, consistency amonst the kirtani and sangat in which to do kirtan? Why would they themselves have used raag and then spoken against them?
They are saying that as per Vedic faith, raag, taal or dance are not singular ways to achieve Anand, but they demonstrate and show that they are important aids (less dance) in understanding bani (emotion of the shabad) when doing kirtan, the foremost way to express the our love through bani.
In addition, our Guru’s did not invent all the raags in bani, they utilised some existing ones (which were still unspoilt), and added their own correct ones in accordance with the shabad.
Yes all, raags are of divine inspiration, our Guru’s divinity, which in my opinion cannot be matched by anyone else, hence, Sikhs have been using their divine inspiration in many ways for hundreds of years, including Langar Seva, Shaster Vidya (defending ourselves and the weak), charity, parchaar/kathaa etc….
And I agree with you, it is through gurmantar/ guru di yaadh, guru mat, that one can compose and perform the perfect kirtan, as per our Guru’s guidelines and divine inspiration, the acceptance of Guru’s hukum/tradition is sign of humility and loyalty also, I am not applying that to myself, I am far from this state.
”You confessed in theses words what you are missing "There is no point naam japna, if you are going to then close your eyes and ignore the rest of Guru's hukums and take lessons from their jeevans."
In my view, People alone with true Naam Jap can realize the truth also from the Guru's lives.”
**************
I will assume you don’t mean have visions of history or time travel, if you mean understand bani, then yes I agree. But is also important to have some historical knowledge of their time period and of other faiths (in order to understand what Guru Ji is referring to in Bani correctly).
”I appreciate your truthful statement "Gurmat Sangeet is a universal language dear brother."
May God bless you to keep busy and reach universe.”
**************
I do not intend to be an astronaut, I do kirpa to my Wahe Guru that he keeps me busy in doing his seva in way small way that I can and helps me to find/reach his charan, which are on a incomparable scale and dimension to this physical universe.
”Your last sentence is "Is reading gurbani and following their hukum not imitating what millions of Gur Pyare have done for 400 years?"
The Gurus never appreciated reading or reciting scriptures to realize Truth. Nor they ever did it.
Who knows? How many people go on with rebirths for how many years with the desire of imitating?”
***********
I think our Guru’s did read from Ad Granth sahib (yes they were antarjami, but reading and writing to set us an example – and show the same humilty we do today – to Guru Nanak Dev Jis revelation), right from Guru Arjun Dev Ji Maharaj’s time, Ad Granth ji was revered and treated with complete respect. Would it not have been Guru Ji who initially read and taught from Bani? Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji not teach Baba Deep Singh and Bhai Manni Singh about Bani, and how to continue this tradition thereforth?
It also seems that you are implying that we also do not need to read the “scriptures” to realise the truth. How did you become aware of naam Simran?
I also do not appreciate you calling Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji scriptures, scriptures imply holy text, a book. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the Jagdi Jot of our 10 Guru’s, it differs from all holy texts of the world in this form, and is the only word of God, written by Gods servants them selves.
With regards to your imitating comment, do you wear the panj kakaar? That should answer your imitating question.
In addition Guru Amardaas Ji Maharaj says: “baabaanee-aa kahaanee-aa put saput karayn.”
”Blessed is the rare Jeev- aatmaa who gets salvation and solace.” Hanji.
This is my last post in this thread.
Thank you for your participation, you have highlighted many misunderstandings of Guru Ji’s kirtan and given us the opportunity to correct them.
Thank you for this priceless seva. Guru twade te mahaan kipra karai.
Wahe Guru ji ka Khalsa Wahe Guru ji ki Fateh.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Ranj · 13 Mar 2006
Harcharan Singh, u say thank you to Balbir Singh for highlighting misunderstandings in Bani, wt makes u such an expert??? puttin Balbir Singh down with a comment like that simply exposes ur ego!!
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Harcharan Singh · 13 Mar 2006
Ranj Ji,
So be it. I never claimed to be an angel, nor a Giani. I have ony pointed out simple facts. Maybe you should read this thread and all previous threads with our discussions before you make this judgement.
Also, take on board the number of times Balbir Singh Ji has passed judgments on myself, that was his choice, I simply thanked him for helping me to strengthen my resolve in Guru Jis jeevan and allowing not only me, but other posters, to show how Guru Ji's hukum is being ignored.
2 conflicting opinions make a discussion Veer ji, expertism has nothing to do with it, the sangat will make up their own mind.
If I have come across as egotistical, then I ask for my Guru Ji's forgiveness.
My statement stands.
Sat Sri Akaal.
Re: Fading Parampara of Keertan As Sung And Heard In The Gurus' Durbars
Angad Singh · 28 Mar 2006
http://singhangad.blogspot.com/2006/03/partaals.html
a short study done on partaals..and some awsome shabad links!
fateh!