Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Gurpreet Singh · 13 Feb 2006

Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh!!! I recently found out from a Singh that Khushwant Singh is being honored by Centennial Youth Foundation. As many of us know Khushwant Singh doesn't even consider sikhism as a distinct religion. He claims that sikhs are keshdhari hindus and in many of his articles, he has insulted mahaan shaheeds of the panth . He also blatantly states that he's a wine lover. Please Khalsa ji, take some time to contact the Centennial Foundation and let them know that such a person shouldn't be honored as a Sikh. Clearly its a failure to honor someone such as him and give him the status of a role model for our young Sikh brothers and sisters. Please check link for info on event : http://www.centennialfoundation.org/2006gala.html Contact Info : Parminder Batra phone: 416-671-7276 Nampreet Singh phone: 647-668-1040 Email: [address removed] Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

... · 13 Feb 2006

I'll be frank. I expect nothing from the Centennial Foundation and they do not represent Sikhs at large. The Centennial Foundation represents the "upper class" and "elite" Sikhs who have made a name (and a lot of money) for themselves in Canadian Society. They can honour whoever they like. The fact that Khushwant condemns Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and calls the movement for Sikh Freedom a "lunatic fringe" doesn't matter to them. The fact that he's an avowed atheist is also moot. Overall, let the elite live in their crystal palaces and have their posh soirees. They do not represent me nor the community.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

jss · 13 Feb 2006

dear ... i understand where you are coming from..i'm not a fan of the centennial foundation...however it is an organization that has access to a lot of politicians and influential people in society..who believe that the foundation is representing sikhs... this is where i take issue with the stance "let them dow what they want" because their actions to have an effect on what others think about sikhi. in the past they have had meat at their dinners and other things that are not in line with gurmat. I believe that we need more gursikhs to voice their opinions and perhaps get involved in their planning committee so that we can bring changes to their organization. I know there are many educated youth and young adults that visit this site...people like Balpreet Singh who is a very articulate law student and others could have a positive affect on the situation. Therefore it is my plea to all of you to write an email to them explaining how honouring such a man will not inspire our youth to follow gursikhi...i have already emailed them and basically was told that i'm an intolerant person. i believe there is a big difference between tolerance and Honouring. in fact i don't believe sikhi even preaches tolerance...sikhi preaches acceptance and love...and i believe we can accept kushwant singh as a talented writer, but NOT HONOUR him for being a role model to our youth.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Kulwinder Singh · 13 Feb 2006

Dear All, I personally do not agree, with Kushwant Singh’s lot of point of views, but you cant say he has done no good for the Sikhs, his history of Sikhs is a valuable work, I value his work although I disagree with him a lot, He spoke well against the Operation Blue Star after June 84, Yes he was heavy in criticising Bhindrawale which I think was great loss. If he like wine and open about it , how come that is worst then those who drink but pretend to be 100% pure. He never claimed to be Good Sikh, I think if somebody take him as a exemplary Good Sikh they are stupid themselves. I regard him a good writer ( Who I disagree many many times) and valuable part of broader Sikh community ( same community which include people like Gurucharn Singh Tohra who was unanimously President of SGPC for the large 30 years of his power and did lot of “GOOD” for Sikhs). So rather then Jumping on people who we disagree to say they are nothing and deserve no acknowledgment, we should have at lease accommodation for those who at least open about their views and don’t hide behind the false images. Kushwant Singh done more good then lot of our leaders put together and have done negligible damage to Sikhs in his life. He is the one of the most brutal critics of Hindu Fundamentalism in India. To be 100% accurate he is against all type of Fundamentalism which is more close to Sikh Philosophy then stand taken by our own religious parties who side with Hindu Fundamentalists. I went on the site mentioned and there is no mention of Saying Khuswant Singh is going to be honoured to imply as “a role model for our young Sikh brothers and sisters” So this topic seem to be raised out of nothing, jealousy, Hate for Sikh’s any event, Stupidity or some other sinister ideas. Beware people :: Check what the intention of Gurpreet Singh Ji is , if this Mr. Gurpreet Singh is well known good intention Sikh then I apologies in advance for doubting his intention. Think my dear brothers, sister and friends Think! Best Regards Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

Gurpreet Singh · 13 Feb 2006

Bhai Sahib Ji, I have personally read Khushwant Singhs books before I got into Sikhi two years ago and I wouldn't want to comment on the stuff I came across because its disgusting. He may be a prolific but he definitely isn't a role model for anyone I know. Anyways Veerjio, I really don't have enough time to write an essay on this however please take a look at the mission statement of Centennial Foundation and if you still require a comment I will try my best. Take care Veerjio. http://www.centennialfoundation.org/about.html

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Heera Singh · 13 Feb 2006

nobodys disputing the fact he's a 'good writer'... but, the questions still haven't been answered... how is he a 'valuable' part of the broader Sikh community?.. and i still don't understand how what 'good' he's done for Sikhi...

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Kulwinder Singh · 13 Feb 2006

Vir Gurpreet Singh Ji, I have already apologised to you in advance in my first post for using harsh words, as you seem humble and kind Sikh. But I hope you can understand my view too on elements who just want to make negative image of Sikhs in the media that we some how behave just as bad as others if not worst. I have read the statement of the site, I am not suggesting by any mean that Khuswant Singh is a good Sikh, as I have said in my previous post that it would be stupid to think of that, but when he get Saroopa from Sikh Leaders in Punjab please have a look http://www.tribuneindia.com/khalsa/page13.htm , He has been given Order of the Khalsa, at a ceremony at Anadpur Sahib on Tuesday, April 13,1999 I am not saying it is good or bad, I am saying don’t make an issue of such things , he is far less harmless then those who have claimed to be our leaders. He is at least known for his controversial ness and he don’t hide behind some well crafted fake image, I appreciate his honesty even when it hurt me like hell. Please try to see my point. Last thing you want is some stupid thing to happen to defame the Sikhs. We have tendency to get hyper on these things and act without thinking. I am not saying Vir Ji you are like that but some people just want some issue to make some stupid point. Dear Hira Singh Ji if you have not read his books then please read on , although some things you will find offensive but as a bee you should collect the honey from where ever you can and enjoy the good bits and appreciate his efforts. It is not essential to have some kind of uniformity among human thinking, he is human and yes he have very distinct approach , we may not like it but you cant say he has not made genuine efforts to write about Sikh history. Best Regards Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

Gurpreet Singh · 14 Feb 2006

Bhai Sahib Ji, I understand you concerns but I must say I don't agree with it. We can't just sit back and watch these people make a mockery of the teachings of our Guru. I am honestly shocked to see him given the order of the Khalsa. There was a time in history where Sikhs stood up for the rights of people. Now we have sheeps in lions disguise and insted of coming out and saying this is not a sikh of the guru because he's doing everything that our Guru Sahibans have told us not to do..instead we sit back and watch WHY? because we are worried about something happen to defame sikhs?....Isn't Sikhi being defamed already by this author??. Sikhi is not a part time affair. It is not a hobby, It is a way of life. Today someone writes about how many drinks he had and what women he danced with at the party and tommorrow all of a sudden he's a great sikh author because he translated Japji Sahib and wrote a book on the History of Sikhs.....even the Radha Soamis have translated Japji Sahib the other day ..should we honor them too.... I know you are saying he's not a sikh and theres many other people out there who are an insult to Sikhi but we have to start from somewhere...insted of saying we shouldn't make a big deal about this...we should look at the long term damages......this foundation invites loads of politicians to their functions....and its been a constant struggle for sikhs in Canada. We are being recognised .....people are learning about the Kirpan and our other kakkars...now we have a guy who looks like a sikh and drinks alot and thinks that sikhs are hindus and writes kaami stuff....we are honoring him...what does that say about sikhi?....anyways Bhai Sahib Ji, My benti is If you don't want to email them and let them know... don't do it. But please don't discourage others...take care bhai sahib jio... chardikalaaa always :)

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Niranjan Singh · 14 Feb 2006

>>>He has been given Order of the Khalsa, at a ceremony at Anadpur Sahib on Tuesday, April 13,1999 Kulwinder Singh, does that mean if Bal Thakaray or Indira Gandhi had recevied some similar phony award from pattits like Badal, then you would view them differently ? There is no question that these idiots give each other rewards and sipropas at public functions, but why should any intelligent Sikh fall into thier self serving trap and give them validity ? Manmukh praising manukhs will not make them Gurmukhs.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

... · 14 Feb 2006

Khushwant Singh: "Japji Sahib is Based on the Upanishads" By JAGPAL SINGH TIWANA Jagpal Singh Tiwana taught political science at Khalsa College (Patiala, Punjab, India). He is presently librarian and cybrarian at both the Nova Scotia Teachers College (Truro, Nova Scotia, Canada) and the Maritime Sikh Society (Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada). He is the author of The Maritime Sikh Society: Origin and Growth and an advisor-at-large to The Sikh Times. Subsequent to it's initial publication here, this interview also appeared in the Jul., 2003 issue of The Sikh Review and the Sep., 2003 issue of the The Sikh Bulletin. The Sikh Times, Feb. 15, 2003 It was not easy to get Khushwant Singh to agree to a meeting. Perhaps my book reviews published in The Sikh Review helped. Whatever the reason, after a couple of telephone calls, he agreed to see me at his residence on the morning of Feb. 15. He lives in an apartment complex across the street from Hotel Ambassador in Sujan Singh Park, Delhi. From the outside, it is a majestic looking complex of apartment buildings. However, it is not all that well maintained from the inside. I made it to his door five minutes early for my 11 a.m. appointment. The door, walls, and hallway wear an old look are in need of paint. There are cobwebs in the corners. I did not have to wait long and was allowed in by a servant via a side door which led me to the backyard. The eighty eight year young man was sprawling on a long easy chair like the Sphinx. I was expecting a well groomed lawn, decorated with flowery shrubs in British style. However, like the sardar sahib [Sikh gentleman] himself, everything looked aged and somewhat unkempt. Dressed in old crumpled clothes, worn out shoes and socks, Singh looked a little like a neglected widower. As we started conversing, I realized that the old warrior is still young at heart and jovial as ever. He exuded warmth and affection and made me feel right at home. There was a healthy glow on his face and he looked much more handsome than he does on television. He is not the cranky old man - impatient, irritable, and snobbish - that I had imagined him to be. Rather, he turned out to be very amiable and easy to get along with. Jagpal Singh Tiwana: You mention in your autobiography, Truth, Love and a Little Malice, that you were a leftist in your early years at Lahore. What inspired you to embrace this ideology? Khushwant Singh: When I was in England as a student, socialism was much talked about among us. We read and discussed Bertrand Russell and attended lectures by Harold J. Laski. I have not retained many socialistic ideas, but I am still an agnostic. J.S.T.: You are a non-believer, yet you spent a night at Bangla Sahib gurdwara to seek the Guru's support during a difficult time in your personal life when your wife had threatened to leave you. K.S.: This is one of those things - a contradiction. It was an emotional issue for me. I was born and raised in a Sikh family. I still keep my beard and turban and identify myself with the Sikh community. J.S.T.: Some Sikhs say we are discriminated against in India. What do you think? K.S.: No, not at all. They are making progress all over the country. They are in the mainstream of Indian life. They are now found in almost all political parties, even the R.S.S. J.S.T.: No Sikh general has been appointed army chief. Harbakhash's name was recommended by outgoing army chief Kumarmanglam and approved by the Defence Committee, but [then prime minister] Indira Gandhi ignored the recommendations and appointed Manekshaw. K.S.: They can't trust a non-Hindu to be the army chief, the most powerful wing of the defense forces, though Arjan Singh and Dilbagh Singh had gone to the top in the Air Force. May be someone did in the Navy as well, I'm not sure. J.S.T.: Kapur Singh wrote in Sachi Sakhi [true biography] that what incensed him most was a letter, issued by the state governor, Chandu Lal Trivedi, warning district authorities in the Punjab against criminal tendencies of the Sikh people. K.S.: Wrong. No such a document exists. Chandu Lal Trivedi was in a responsible position. How could he give such instructions in writing? It is all a figment of Kapur Singh's imagination. He was bitter because he was dismissed from a government job in a corruption case. J.S.T.: What do you think of R.S.S. chief Sudershan's statements, which Sikhs find highly offensive? K.S.: R.S.S. is a communal organization and dangerous to the country's secular fabric. Look what they did to Muslims in Gujrat. However, they take a different approach with the Sikhs. During the 1984 Sikh pogrom, they did save many Sikh lives. R.S.S. volunteers participated during the tercentenary celebrations of the Khalsa in 1999. They consider the Khalsa to be a military wing of Hinduism and their savior. J.S.T.: What about the statements that suggest that Sikhs are kes-dhari [sporting unshorn hair] Hindus? You yourself wrote in The Wall Street Journal (Oct. 12, 2001) that Sikhism is a branch of Hinduism. K.S.: That is correct. Sikhs are kes-dhari Hindus. Their religious source is Hinduism. Sikhism is a tradition developed within Hinduism. Guru Granth Sahib reflects Vedantic philosophy and Japji Sahib is based on the Upanishads. J.S.T.: Those are loaded statements. You could be accused of blasphemy and summoned to the Akal Takht. K.S.: They don't have the guts to summon me. They only go after the weak and the timid. Why don't they summon Ranjit Singh who claims he is the real jathedar [high priest] of Akal Takht? Pashaura Singh talked to me after appearing before Akal Takhat jathedar. I told him, 'What is the point now? You should have contacted me earlier.' [Pashaura Singh's reaction dated Mar. 21, 2003: 'I did not meet Khushwant after appearing before the Akal Takht. Maybe, Khushwant is confusing me with Dr. Piar Singh. He certainly spoke in Piar's defense on television after Piar was awarded religious penance at the Akal Takht. I had written to Khushwant and many other Sikh scholars in 1993 explaining my point of view regarding the controversy over my doctoral thesis. In fact, Khushwant acknowledged my letter and wished me well. But that was well before my Akal Takht appearance.'] No scholar should be summoned to Akal Takht. Is it a religious place or a kotwali (police station)? J.S.T.: How do you view the controversy on the Dasam Granth? K.S.: This area needs more research. No hasty conclusion should be drawn. I must say that I am not as familiar with it as I should be. J.S.T.: Some say that Singh Sabha scholars distorted Sikh history and tried to cut all links with Hinduism. K.S.: Partly true. They did not distort Sikh history; they only emphasized, sometimes too greatly, the differences between the new reform movement, i.e. Sikhism, and the old, traditional, and degenerated Hinduism. What they portray as unique to Sikhism, like unity of God, casteless society, etc. were also preached by other Vaishnava bhaktas [saints] of the time. J.S.T.: Should a mona (non-turbaned) or sahaj-dhari [unorthodox] Sikh have the right to vote in S.G.P.C. elections? K.S.: Why not? As long as someone declares he or she is a Sikh, that person is a Sikh. He or she should have a right to vote. Sahaj-dharis have been part of the Panth (community) since the very beginning. Now they say only amrit-dhari [orthodox] men can do seva at Harmandar Sahib, but not women, even if they are amrit-dharis. This is not congruent with the Gurus' teachings: maanas kii jaati sabhai ekai pahchaanbo (all humans are equal regardless of caste or creed) [Source: Dasam Granth, Akal Ustati, pp. 19, stanza 15/85, line 2; Courtesy: Joginder Ahluwalia, Richmond, California)]. Every Sikh should be allowed to do seva [service], whether amrit-dhari or non-amrit-dhari. J.S.T.: In your earlier works, you had surmised that Sikhism is a blend of Hinduism and Sufism. However, later, when Hew McLeod's works started appearing, you wrote in the Encyclopedia Britannica that Sikhism is a tradition developed within Hinduism or an extension of the bhakti movement. K.S.: Yes, McLeod's works did change my ideas on this issue. A scholar must keep an open mind. I, however, do not like his new book, Sikhs of the Khalsa. He has translated rahits [code of conduct documents] authored by many insignificant people. Who was this Chaupa Singh to give rahit to the Sikhs? His rahitnama says ridiculous things like how to urinate, where to defecate, never trust a woman, etc. Every nathu khahra (ordinary Joe) cannot write rahit for the Sikhs. It is just like a maulvi [preacher] of that masjid [mosque] (pointing to the east) writing instructions in name of Muhammad. J.S.T.: What do you think of McLeod's research? Sometimes he is called an agent of G.O.I. or R.S.S. or a Christian missionary out to damage Sikhism. K.S.: That is nonsense. He is a scholar in search of original documents on Sikh history. He has raised many questions. The onus is on us to supply him with the facts. No, he is honest; a skeptic historian. J.S.T.: Some people discern a pro-Jat bias in your works. Someone on the Sikh-Diaspora forum (Yahoo! Groups) quoted you as saying, 'Sikhs were nothing before Jats became Sikhs.' K.S.: I base my opinion on historical evidence. After Guru Gobind Singh's death, Sikh peasantry rose in arms under Banda Bahadur. Then Jats in the Sikh misls [armed groups] fought all through the 18th century to establish Khalsa raj [rule]. Out of the 12 Sikh misls, 9 were headed by Jat chiefs. In this struggle, they made tremendous sacrifices. If one generation was wiped out, the next generation took up arms. Finally, they emerged victorious at the end of the century. Are Tiwanas Jats? Any relation with that Punjabi woman writer? J.S.T.: Dalip Kaur Tiwana? No relationship with her or with the Punjabi film director Harpal Tiwana. However, we [Dalip, Harpal and I] were contemporaries at Mahendra College, Patiala. Dalip was four years senior to me while Harpal and I were classmates. Yes, Tiwanas are Jats. Gurcharan Singh Tohra, former S.G.P.C. chief, is also a Tiwana. K.S.: We had Muslim Tiwanas, Khizar Hayat and Ummar Hayat - big landlords - as our neighbors in Western Punjab. J.S.T.: What is your view on the Nanak Shahi calendar? K.S.: I have no view on this issue . . . (pause) . . . What is wrong with the Christian calendar which is prevalent all over the world now? J.S.T.: Which one of your books earned you the most royalty - your most kamaoo putt (highest-earning son)? K.S.: My autobiography, Truth, Love and a Little Malice, earned me the most money. It earned Rs. 26.5 lakh [1 lakh = 100,000] in the first six months. It is a very big figure for India. Possibly the biggest ever in Indian publishing. Thereafter, sales dropped as the pirated editions appeared in India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. Last year it got me only Rs. 1 lakh. The next highest royalty earned was from The Company of Women. Both the autobiography and this novel remained on the top of the best-sellers lists for over six months. J.S.T.: Here is a book for you, The Maritime Sikh Society: Origin and Growth, from the Maritime Sikh Society in Halifax, Canada. It may not be of any use to you, but the book does have a few features of some value. It not only lists the addresses and accounts of all Sikhs settled there, but also their years of migration to the region and their places of origin in India or abroad. It covers the story of 174 Sikh refugees who were dropped ashore in Charlesville, Nova Scotia by the Swedish ship, Amelie, one fine morning in Jul. 1987. They were illegal immigrants; the Canadian police took them into custody. The notorious terrorist, Talvinder Singh Parmar, retained the famous Toronto immigration lawyer, Mendel Green, and accompanied him to Halifax. The Maritime Sikh Society took their case to court and got them released. Most histories of Sikh settlement in Canada mention this incident along with that of the Komagata Maru incident of 1914. K.S.: I do know of that incident. The Canadian high-commissioner had consulted me. He wanted an unbiased opinion. He said the government of India wanted them back and assured him of a fair treatment. I pleaded with him, 'For heaven's sake, do not hand over the boys to the G.O.I. They would be locked up in jails for all their lives without any trial. They want to settle in Canada. They have sold their lands in order to buy this passage to Canada. They could be very productive citizens. Give them a chance. They are not terrorists, but they will become terrorists if not accepted by Canada.' J.S.T.: Thank you! You were so right. All of them are now happily settled in Canada and occasionally visit us or call us to express their gratitude for the help they received in their time of need. One of them has settled in Halifax. . . . You've had a very fulfilling life. Any regrets about things you could not do or achieve? K.S.: I have no regrets in life. I long to remain in charhdi kalaa (buoyant spirits) till it's my time to go. J.S.T.: Would you like to be remembered as a historian, journalist, or fiction writer? K.S.: Why not all three? I have worked hard on each (stated with pride and an endearing smile). J.S.T.: In my humble view, your two volume classic, A History of the Sikhs, is a monumental work unmatched by any other Sikh historian. However, as a journalist and fiction writer you have several competitors. . . . Any message for Sikhs abroad? K.S.: Chardi kalaa. Keep your spirits high. And don't fight in gurdwaras. http://www.sikhtimes.com/bios_021503a.html

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

kuljot Singh · 14 Feb 2006

I think you should not only think one way! If they honor him he is being honored! I think this very unfair to the people who are running the centennial foundation. You are making matters worse to the people who need to stay focused on this job. From what I hear, they all are volenteers! Kushwant singh is only 1 out of millions of sikhs that likes alchohal. Over 50% of sikhs drink so why arent you bothering them? If I were you all I would pull my act together.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Kulwinder Singh · 14 Feb 2006

Dear Vir Gurpreet Singh Ji, If we start saying this person is not Sikh because of this and that, then you will end up everybody making statements making every other Sikh as non Sikh, if a person have grave differences with your version of Sikhi then you are right to have opinion and other person is entitle for their opinion. Sikhi is a mahan ( super ) Suraz (sun) if Tom Dick and Harry sing on loud speaker that it is not a Sun it is a one small lamp believe me it will not make any difference for other people A Super Sun of Sikh Shine not because any particular person make it shine or group of people make it shine it shines because of its attributes itself. So don’t bother about if some person give idiotic remarks about the Sikhi, People always know what is truth and lie. If you make issue of people’s character and then try to label them as some kind of inferior Sikhs or human being the whole practice of this type will make the people who are doing this look even uglier then the person they are mentioning. I have clearly said by no means Kushwant Singh is a great Sikh, He don’t claim himself to be a Good Sikh either, How ever we must learn how to have accommodation those who we may disagree like hell but still consider them to have some good attributes, His work is valuable make no doubts about that. I don’t like his practices and some very bonkers views but I respect his integrity and honesty that , He write what he think rather then faking it. You rather have people who are honest and upfront rather then sly and sinister. To kick him out of Sikhism officially will not serve any good, You can even learn something from your most daring opponents so be wise and analysis, think objectively what you want to achieve, I doubt if 1 person in the whole world will think he is an exemplary good Sikh to start with epically when he never ever claim to be a good Sikh himself. You have said “he's a great sikh author because he translated Japji Sahib and wrote a book on the History of Sikhs.....even the Radha Soamis have translated Japji Sahib the other day ..should we honor them too....” Dear vir ji, I am the most blunt opponent of any body who even dare to even hint that they are in some kind of remote parallel to my Guru Sahib, So my View of Radha Soamis or Odha Swami are clear, but if somebody make efforts to translate Guru Bani without distortion and maintain the Guru Bani’s sentiments , with the aim to help Humanity , I think even if Arungzeb do that I am happy to say well done but will still maintain my other opinions about them, We should consecrate on the bigger picture and think what we want to achieve with our actions, Take Christianity Jesus can be ridiculed , but at the same time their biggest weapon forgiveness make Christianity shine very well , It is the biggest and most powerful argument they have that they are forgiving like GOD. Even if somebody swear at GOD , God do not say I am not going to let you breath, or I am not powering your heart any more so you going to die, This is same as Gurubani say that a Godly person should be like GOD. What ever we do in life, we should think is this bringing us close to GOD or taking us away from him, You can only come close to GOD if you try to be like him, He like compassion, Humbleness, Love, kindness and Sweetness. Everybody treat nice people nicely but GOD even treat nasty people same loving way, but it is the nasty people’s own deeds which make them go down the hill, it is not the desire of GOD to put anybody down, it our own actions which do that. You are saying “now we have a guy who looks like a sikh and drinks alot and thinks that sikhs are hindus and writes kaami stuff....we are honoring him...what does that say about sikhi?....” Vir Ji that is how considerably large number of people in Sikh Community behave, you do not have to go far, just look at the social evils in Punjab which still exist, alcoholism, killing of female foetus, Drugs, Kesh Katel ( cutting of kesh), dirty songs ….. that is all also done by people who are Sikhs in general too. Amount of fighting we do in temples, the shameless racism based on caste, village, region and Jathebandie we have is far more damaging to Sikhism then honouring some body who even do not claim to be a good sikh. Before we go bonkers and make efforts to put mud on a person’s so called Honour, we should all change our own families and friends and neighbourhood then we will look good to make a case involving such things, without addressing these issues we are just going to look ridicules Dear Sikho first change yourselves and concentrate on real issues and don’t waste your energy on issue which we can only hamper the image of Sikh Community. Have unity, focus on solving our own house first, then label others as inferior or non Sikhs. Dear Narajan Singh Ji “Kulwinder Singh, does that mean if Bal Thakaray or Indira Gandhi had recevied some similar phony award from pattits like Badal, then you would view them differently ?” Vir Ji I have already said I am not saying giving him award at Anadpur was good or bad, I think Badal lot wanted to invite him so they did. I mentioned it as to say that they do this India as well, so no need to make fuss I west as it will not achieve anything it will only label us as trouble makers, think what we want to achieve with our efforts, and how we can achieve that best. Dear “Author: ... “ Ji , I have no idea if this interview is true or not , But I would expect Kushwant singh to Say some of these Bonkers things anyway. I am not siding with him to be 100% clear, I have said that I do not think for 1 micro second that he is a good Sikh, What I am saying is making fuss over these kind of things is waste of efforts, as it will not achieve anything, we should make positive efforts which help us to uplift our community, by showing him down will not serve any good. Best Regards Kulwinder Singh

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

jss · 14 Feb 2006

kulwinder singh. you''re making the mistake of confusing Honouring and accepting...that is why your whole argument is flawed and useless. it is one thing to say he's a great literary...fair enough it is another thing to make him the honouree of the dinner where they claim to want to promote sikh ideals...honouring him will show that we have no other people worthy of being honoured who have excelled both in their chosen field and in gursikhi...that would be a true honouree... this is pure politics....all these people i have all the responses i received from the organizer at centennial foudation...parminder batra...totally sidestepped every issue that i brought up and accused me of being angry...which is funny cuz all i did was talk about ISSUES and they took it all personal and refused to address the issues... just because something is messed up in india doesn't mean we have to accept it here in canada... oh well...our bantering isn't going to change anything..the centennial foundation is an organizaton that has lost the plot...the sangat shall see a new organization of young sikh professionals being formed shortly and this organization will keep true to gursikhi principles and show the world that it is possible to be successful in both miri and piri like our guru sahibs wanted us to be...

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

Sher Khalsa · 14 Feb 2006

khushwant singh himself says hes not sikh, but just keeps turban for social and cultural purposes... so how can you honor him as a sikh

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LS · 15 Feb 2006

Khuswant Singh was often used by the media organisations to act as a spokesman for Sikhs during the peak of the movement, he used to put down the Singhs and praise people like KPS Gill. It was only after many Amnesty International reports on Punjab came out that he changed his mind ,but he done a lot of damage by then. If he is an atheist give him an award for story telling , why link in Sikhism?

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LionKing (LK) · 15 Feb 2006

******* Author: LS Date: 02-15-06 08:24 Khuswant Singh was often used by the media organisations to act as a spokesman for Sikhs during the peak of the movement, he used to put down the Singhs and praise people like KPS Gill. It was only after many Amnesty International reports on Punjab came out that he changed his mind ,but he done a lot of damage by then. If he is an atheist give him an award for story telling , why link in Sikhism? ****************** Where does he condone actions of KP GILL? Although I disagree with his comments on Sikhs being Hindus, he did make a big fuss out of Operation bluestar in parliament, he did condemn the army attack, he did expose Gandhi of backiing out in every negotiation (along with Kuldip Nayar). He did not say he was an atheist, but that he was an agnotist. THeres a difference... If this is some kind of award thingy for being an ideal Sikh - then no he doesn't affort it. If this is some kind of award for spreading info on Sikhism - doubtful, as he's written some good things, as well as some bad things Ultimately he's allowed to hold and express his views as much as he likes. To be awarded for it? No.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Kuljot Singh · 15 Feb 2006

Kushwant "singh" is one of the biggest idiots of our times. The kind of garbage he spews is laughable. Rocks and stones should be thrown at him instead. <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>< Author: kuljot Singh Date: 02-14-06 14:36 I think you should not only think one way! If they honor him he is being honored! I think this very unfair to the people who are running the centennial foundation. You are making matters worse to the people who need to stay focused on this job. From what I hear, they all are volenteers! Kushwant singh is only 1 out of millions of sikhs that likes alchohal. Over 50% of sikhs drink so why arent you bothering them? If I were you all I would pull my act together. <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>< Interesting to see you have the same name as me...however, you make no sense. Try thinking with your brain, please... -kuljot singh

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

simmi · 15 Feb 2006

I personally agree with kulvinder singh veerji when he says one must change themselves before they criticise anybody who are we to judge who is true sikh or who is not bhul chuk maaph

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Kulwinder Singh · 15 Feb 2006

Dear Jss Ji, This organisation is also honouring a Muslim as well, If the organisation feel somebody deserve acknowledgement then it is up to them, they have not asked you to vote for it ? Learn to accommodate others views rather then just trying all the time to have your own way. You do seems to have some rage about this issue, if we all start saying who is proper Sikh and who should be honoured, then most of the Gurudawara Management even don’t do 1% of the things a normal Sikh should do , What you going to do , Go and protest against them first who claim to be Sikhs or Good Sikhs, then do direct damage to Sikhi. Or you want to be know for protesting against some body who is world famous, because that fit with your ego very well. Lion King Ji I accept that according to some Sikhs he should not be awards, but that is their own view, an organisation have write to do how they see right, Tomorrow we will say that this temple should not do this and that temple should not do this, I am all up for unity and standard in Gurudawars but we are not going to achieve that by pushing people and showing intolerance for other’s point of view. I do know you are not saying to push or be intolerant at all. I am just making point, I do find your comments and view sensible, Thanks . Kuljot Singh Ji “Kushwant "singh" is one of the biggest idiots of our times. The kind of garbage he spews is laughable. Rocks and stones should be thrown at him instead.” Are you a Sikh ? who want to throw stones at people ? When our 80 year old Guru Amardass ji got kicked in the diwan by Bhia Datu, he did not say one harsh word against him, he did not even lifted his eyelid to hint to his Sikhs to sort Bhai Datu. And hear are you who want to throw stones at somebody who never the less spoke against operation blue star in very effective way and still does speak against the Hindu Extremists. Kuljot Singh ji see how you are in sync with Sikh ideas. Many thanks Simmi Ji for your comments. Best Regards Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

... · 15 Feb 2006

Kulwinder Singh, You are perhaps the most stubborn person I have come across. Simple question: should Sikhs be honouring someone who has called Sikhs keshdhari Hindus? No. Is he the worst person in the world? No, of course not. But of all the people that could be honoured, he is not very high on the list.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LS · 15 Feb 2006

K.P.S. Gill Is a "Hero" By KHUSHWANT SINGH The Tribune, Oct. 16, 2004 Photo: Khushwant Singh ''For 10 years, the Punjab countryside was in the grip of terrorists, over 10,000 lives were lost before the Punjab Police led by J.F. Ribeiro and following him K.P.S. Gill put them down with a heavy hand. A small section of the community hailed Bhindranwale as a martyr, lent tacit support to the demand for a separate state and condemned Gill as a wanton killer. In my judgement, they were wrong and Gill saved Sikhs and Punjab for India. He comes out as a hero in my assessment. However, I had also to look into charges levelled against him and his police by human rights activists and the disposal of over 1,000 bodies without proper identification or post-mortem. I could do no more than mention this without passing judgment." What I meant was that before Khuswant Singh would not even except human rights violations were going on , the mention of the disposal of bodies above is from the Amnesty International report Reduced to Ashes.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Kulwinder Singh · 15 Feb 2006

Dear … You have said “You are perhaps the most stubborn person I have come across.” I am sorry for being stubborn but my intentions are not to prove the stubbornness quite the opposite of it. Never the less a Sikh Should not be stubborn, I do apologies if my writing offend you even mildly. I have thought many times that I should stop writing on the form especially when my writing hurt some peoples . My intentions is never to cause hurt , I always try to write what I believe and understand with my microscopic (Tush) intelligence( Budhi). I am sorry again dear … ji. But I feel I have to answer. As always what I am saying is not heard people imagine on what they would like to hear and think that is what I am saying . 1. I have not said honour Khushwant Singh. 2. I have not said He is a good Sikh 3. I have not said he represent Sikhs 4. I have not said I agree with his view , comments or writings 5. I have not said he is somebody I look up to be like 6. I have not said he is a model human being 7. I have not said his contribution to Sikhi is most impressive 8. I have not said that he had fought for Sikh rights 9. I have not said his writings can be taken as guidelines 10. I have not said he is some kind of pillar or Sikh Community What I have said is 1 He is booker from time to time 2 His comments are offensive many times to many people 3 He is no in sync with my understanding of Gurbani 4 He is not somebody we can take as exemplary Sikh 5 I am not siding with him 6 I do not think even for 1 micro second that he is good Sikh 7 Making fuss over this thing will make Sikhs community look bad 8 We should think objectively as what we want to achieve and how we can achieve better. 9 by showing him down will not serve any good 10 I appreciate his honesty even when it hurt me like hell. ( yes it does hurt me when he goes bonkers from time to time) Point also to note that this organisation Centennial Foundation neither claim nor does represent all the Sikhs community . If they want to honour somebody according to their understanding then fine , We have not contributed towards the decision so why it bother us, especially they also honour non Sikhs and Kushwant Singh don’t claim to be a representative of the Sikhs or being a good Sikhs, Generating bad feelings in the media about Sikhs does not serve us, so what is wrong in suggesting to people to be careful in making efforts to raising these kind of issue in the media when it will only produce the opposite result of which exactly what we want to promote: Some people want to raise the issue so the honour of the Sikh community is protected and make fuss so they don’t honour Kushwant Singh, Kuljot Singh ji was saying “Rocks and stones should be thrown at him instead” Any body tell me if even one person is thinking of doing something like that how it will look, if some really stupid person actually go and do that how will it look on Sikh community as whole that, we throw stones on some know writer of world level, That will only prove that we hate people who have onions , brain and have difference of views. Now Think that is what you want to promote with your action. Think how would Guru Sahib ji will deal with this, People throw stones on Guru Nanak dev Ji, Called him names what did he do, Did he asked his follower to go and do the same to them or did he showed his kindness to them. Sikh Guru Sahiban are only leaders in the world who every body want to be included in their religion, Muslims want Guru Nank to be part of them, Hindus want him as well, both Hindus and Muslims have differences like water and fire, then how come both want to be associate with Guru Nanak, Q: is it because Guru Nanak Dev ji wanted to please everybody and kept everybody sweet and changed his view depending on who was on the front ? Or Q: because he was unclear about his views ? Or Q: because his philosophy is so great that it is impossible not to love , and it is so unique and loving and tolerable that every body can love it without feeling threatened ? So where we should be ? Guru Sahib will say be loving, accepting, tolerable and deal with hard issues in such manner that even our opponents could not help but fall in love with us due to our Great Guru Sahbain Ji. Need less to say that some time you would have to raise arms to fight the real evil that is also part of being a Sikh. In simple words, Think Objectively what you want to achieve and what is the best way to do that , think of long term not short term Best Regards Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

Otpreka Singh · 12 Mar 2006

[URL] www.thepanthicotpreka.blogspot.com [/URL] Daas has put together some quotes of Khushwant Singh, please feel free to take a look on daas's blog. Daas will try to post below, but it may be easier to read on daas's blog at www.thepanthicotpreka.blogspot.com Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, Daas is very passionate about the following post. Daas asks you to please read this post very carefully. It has come to Daas’s attention that the Centennial Foundation is holding its annual Gala where they honor Sikhs for their work in the community. One of the honorees this year is Khushwant Singh. This has shocked daas, and daas is deeply saddened that anyone in their right mind can honor someone as Khuswant Singh as a Sikh. Daas is aware that Centennial Foundation has been contacted and refuse to budge on their stance and continue to support Khushwant Singh. Daas feels this is a slap in the face to all Sikhs. Daas will give you some samples of what Khushwant Singh has written below, and you can decide for yourselves if honoring Khushwant Singh is deeply offensive to the Sikh Panth or not. Centennial Foundation is honoring Khushwant Singh as a Sikh, but Khushwant Singh has himself admitted that he is not a Sikh and just keeps his hair and turban because of the social aspect of it. (http://www.sikhtimes.com/bios_021503a.html) Khushwant Singh: When I was in England as a student, socialism was much talked about among us. We read and discussed Bertrand Russell and attended lectures by Harold J. Laski. I have not retained many socialistic ideas, but I am still an agnostic. J.S.T.: You are a non-believer, yet you spent a night at Bangla Sahib gurdwara to seek the Guru's support during a difficult time in your personal life when your wife had threatened to leave you. K.S.: This is one of those things - a contradiction. It was an emotional issue for me. I was born and raised in a Sikh family. I still keep my beard and turban and identify myself with the Sikh community. To prove this point further and to see how much our precious Gurus meant to Khushwant Singh, lets see what he says, "What would Gandhi have done under the circumstances? I didn't subscribe to his fads-prohibition, celibacy, no doctors-but generally he was always right. He meant more to me than any of my panth, my gurus." Guru sahib has taught us that the Khalsa Panth is Nyaara distinct. Guru Sahib has openly denounced many Hindu practices. Even after all this Khushwant Singh still writes; (http://www.sikhtimes.com/bios_021503a.html) J.S.T.: What about the statements that suggest that Sikhs are kes-dhari [sporting unshorn hair] Hindus? You yourself wrote in The Wall Street Journal (Oct. 12, 2001) that Sikhism is a branch of Hinduism. K.S.: That is correct. Sikhs are kes-dhari Hindus. Their religious source is Hinduism. Sikhism is a tradition developed within Hinduism. Guru Granth Sahib reflects Vedantic philosophy and Japji Sahib is based on the Upanishads. When asked about the Akal Takht, Khushwant Singh says; J.S.T.: Those are loaded statements. You could be accused of blasphemy and summoned to the Akal Takht. K.S.: They don't have the guts to summon me. They only go after the weak and the timid Sikhs all across the world were hurt and are still hurt by the Human Rights violations being committed against Sikhs in India, and at how Sikhs are being discriminated in India. Yet Khushwant Singh writes, J.S.T.: Some Sikhs say we are discriminated against in India. What do you think? K.S.: No, not at all. They are making progress all over the country. They are in the mainstream of Indian life. They are now found in almost all political parties, even the R.S.S. Even worse, look at what he writes about KPS Gill, the man who was behind the brutal torture of so many innocent people and the rape of so many innocent women. The man who was responsible for tearing apart so many families and killing thousands and thousands of innocent people. (http://www.sikhtimes.com/books_062003a.html) "I supported K.P.S. Gill for resorting to extra-judicial methods to stamp out terrorism. The judiciary was in a state of collapse and magistrates too terrified to refuse applications for bail put by terrorists. The administration was paralysed and people gave in to extortion and violence perpetrated by gangs. If the police caught those with criminal records or those who admitted to murdering innocent people, instead of taking them to court, the police eliminated them. It was jungle justice but it had an element of justification behind it. But even in this savage war of attrition, we expected the police to discriminate between criminals and others who were proving a nuisance to them." I wont even get into the lies he spews from his mouth about shaheeds and Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale. Just from the few extracts above, is this a person who should be honored as a Sikh? Well he is, hes being honored by the Centennial Foundation. How confused these people are. The man says himself that he’s not Sikh and speaks contrary to Sikh teachings, he justifies brutal torture on Sikhs, and he openly challenges Akal Takht. Centennial Foundation should be ashamed of themselves, they have been told about Khushwant Singh and they refuse to budge on their position and support of him. May Waheguru do kirpa on his Sikhs and give us the common sense to know right from wrong, and to stick together for the betterment of the Panth. Daas encourages you to get in touch with Centennial Foundation and continue to put pressure on them to reconsider their decision to support Khushwant Singh and honor him at their annual Gala. http://www.centennialfoundation.org/2006gala.html Contact Info: Parminder Batra phone: 416-671-7276 Nampreet Singh phone: 647-668-1040 Email: [address removed] Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh *here is another extract to tell you a little bit of Khushwants character (http://www.hindu.com/thehindu/mag/2002/02/24/stories/2002022400510200.htm): WHEN you read a sentence in Khushwant Singh's recent autobiography which begins `the most fulfilling thing I have done in my life was ...', you expect it to conclude with the name of some beautiful woman he long desired and finally seduced. Alternatively, you expect to learn the name of some smooth single malt he savoured after a prolonged delay. But you'd be wrong. The second half of the sentence reads: `... working on Sikh religion and history'. This reminds us that there is much more to Khushwant Singh than Truth, Love, and a Little Malice. Sex and scotch may have provided the central juice to this sardar's roaring rhetoric and disguised the core of scholarship he possesses, but with sentences such as this, his autobiography frequently betrays the persona of a Drink-and-Desire-Bum, which he has cultivated. This is a sardar who knows that, metaphorically speaking, what has meant most to him is not carnal knowledge of a virgin but intellectual knowledge of Virgil. Alongside his ability to call a spade a spade when everyone else is calling it a pitchfork, this bedrock of learning is the basis of his self-respect. It underlies all the fluff he has churned out to please the millions and earn himself roughly the same. Without it he would have ended up as the male Shobha De.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LK · 12 Mar 2006

May I ask what exactly he's beign awarded for? I doubt it's for his Sikhi life-style. If it isn't then what right do we haveto point out every kurehit, and every pap he commits? He openly says he doesn't consider himself a Sikh but the apperance was inherited. He NEVER as far as I'm aware said he was a Sikh nor pretended to be one. Am I siding with him? No. Just a few speculations I made. Does anyone know exactly what he's being awarded for, as that might cool down the discussiona bit.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyl

Sher Khalsa · 12 Mar 2006

at the end of the day, a 'Sikh' organization should never honor a person like Khushwant, regardless of what the award is for. Its a matter of principle

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

sainapat · 13 Mar 2006

WJKK WJKF Kulwinder Singh's posts are the best example of why our nation is in the state it is in now. He has been given very good examples of why a agnostic like Khushwant Singh should be honoured by the Centennial Foundation. The reasons given by Kulwinder Singh are so weak that I am surprised that he still stands by them. Going through his posts one get the gist of his arguments 1. We shouldn't oppose honouring him BECAUSE we have worse leaders in Punjab!! Have you ever wondered Mr Kulwinder Singh why we still have leaders like Badal? It is because no one is prepared to make a stand against them. Perhaps we can make a start on the small fry like Khushwant Singh and the manmati leadership of the centennial foundation and then move on to Badal. 2. If you oppose his honouring then you will get to a situation where Sikhs will start to question whether other Sikhs are Sikhs at all! Talk about a panic reaction. If Khushwant Singh doesn't get honoured then Sikhi breaks down! What a great conclusion by Kulwinder Singh! Amazing that the way we treat Khushwant Singh has such an effect on the fortunes of Sikhi! 3. Khuswant Singh may be a womaniser, a drunk, a gossip monger and a supporter of the genocide of the Sikh nation but at least he's open about it! Compare this with those who keep the 5 K's and yet do these things in secret!! Again a great argument (lol) by Kulwinder Singh. Khushwant Singh is what in rural Punjab would be referred to as a 'Lucha Lafangha' (a perverted cripple). Sikhi may be weak in rural Punjab but if a person like Khushwant Singh was ever to 'openly' do the things he does he would find himself on the back of a donkey, chappals around his neck and his face blackened. Unfortunately the so called elite leadership in the centennial foundation sees nothing wrong in honouring such a person. This is just a gist of Kulwinder Singh's arguments. If anything he does at least give people a good laugh!

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LK · 13 Mar 2006

Although I do acknowledge the bad things he ahs written, I would award him for completly shaking the ground of the Parliament by bringing up Bluestar and openly critisizing it, and also for his efforts to show how the Akalis were open to negotiate with Bibi Indira, but she backed out every time. That is something I think he should be awarded with (along with Kuldip Nayyar). For being an ideal Sikh? Absolutly not. So it completly depends on what he's being honoured for.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Daas Soora · 13 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh Well said Bhai Sahib Sher Khalsa Jeeo, this Khushwant person is giving a bad name for the rest of the Sikhs out there, as he's making the innocent minded youth think that whatever actions he's performing are allowed in Sikhi, ie wine. THe only thing he keeps on doing is destroying the Sikh image, and fitting in the Hindu image within the Sikh to make the Sikh seem like a Hindu as well. With the way he's at he doesn't deserve anything from another Sikh, but he's obviously not going to be looked at of his actions/deeds here in this world. India's nation of Sikhs already don't care for Sikhi, as instead their minds have been delusioned by westerners and their lifestyle, and so Khushwant has immated the westerners to catch the youth's attention. Daas Soora VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Frank · 13 Mar 2006

Can anyone give some background on the Centennial Foundation - who they are? i.e who runs it, what there beliefs are? They seem like a group of people who can't really live the Sikhi way of life, so to make themselves feel better they slap on the Sikh name to an alcoholic dinner and think they are supporting the panth? It is Kaljug - this is to be expected.

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LK · 13 Mar 2006

Author: Daas Soora Date: 03-13-06 02:19 VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh Well said Bhai Sahib Sher Khalsa Jeeo, this Khushwant person is giving a bad name for the rest of the Sikhs out there, as he's making the innocent minded youth think that whatever actions he's performing are allowed in Sikhi, ie wine. ------------------ He has NEVER said that. As a matter of fact he openly says he's not even a believer, although he associates himself with the SIKH COMMUNITY. In an interview he openl said that and didn't refute being a non-believer (I was mistaken before tihnking he was an agnostic) ************ J.S.T.: You are a non-believer, yet you spent a night at Bangla Sahib gurdwara to seek the Guru's support during a difficult time in your personal life when your wife had threatened to leave you. K.S.: This is one of those things - a contradiction. It was an emotional issue for me. I was born and raised in a Sikh family. I still keep my beard and turban and identify myself with the Sikh community. ************** +++++++++++++++++ THe only thing he keeps on doing is destroying the Sikh image, and fitting in the Hindu image within the Sikh to make the Sikh seem like a Hindu as well. With the way he's at he doesn't deserve anything from another Sikh, but he's obviously not going to be looked at of his actions/deeds here in this world. India's nation of Sikhs already don't care for Sikhi, as instead their minds have been delusioned by westerners and their lifestyle, and so Khushwant has immated the westerners to catch the youth's attention. Daas Soora VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh ++++++++++++++++++++ How has hushwant tried to catch the youth's attention? THe rest of your poins about him associting Sikhs with Hindus is totaly valid =)

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

Daas Soora · 13 Mar 2006

vaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa vaheguruJeeKeeFateh 'has immated the westerners to catch the youth's attention.' Sorry bhai Sahib 'LK' Jeeo when I said 'immated' i was suppose to say imitated, and also Khushwant has used the westerners image, but the youth automatically got attracted to this, so they think whatever he does is applicable/acceptable for the Sikh community. It's fine that your defending him, but why so much? Correct me if I've made any mistakes. Daas Soora vaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa vaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

LK · 13 Mar 2006

Author: Daas Soora Date: 03-13-06 09:53 vaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa vaheguruJeeKeeFateh 'has immated the westerners to catch the youth's attention.' Sorry bhai Sahib 'LK' Jeeo when I said 'immated' i was suppose to say imitated, and also Khushwant has used the westerners image, but the youth automatically got attracted to this, so they think whatever he does is applicable/acceptable for the Sikh community. It's fine that your defending him, but why so much? Correct me if I've made any mistakes. Daas Soora vaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa vaheguruJeeKeeFateh ----------------------------- In what way does he used the westerner image? I've never heard of anyone attraced to Khsuhwant singh, but then again, what do I know? I am nto defending him, but just consider that he should be acknowledge for the (little) good he has done. He has (along with Kuldip Nayar) seriously exposed bibi Indira in her false attempts to negotiate with the Akalis. Some of his work on bluestar is very valueble, since Kuldip Nayar was one of the guys who negotiated for her, and exposed that she backed out every time. That is extremly valueble information. Where he does something wrong, he does something wrong, I try not to care too much about it. He says Sikhs are kesdhari hindus. I disagree 200%, but acknowledge that he has an opinion and is entitled to it. He believes that is Sikhi, and thus expresses it in interviews etc etc, just like you and I express our opnion about Sikhi. Yes I agree his opnion on Sikhi is a bit messed up, but he's entitled to having his own views. So I am in no way pro or anti Khushwant, simply acknowledge his good things, and try to filter out the bad ones (although the bad ones do make me furious at times, at him saying the Japji Sahib is a summary of the Upanishads etc etc)

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

santbir singh · 14 Mar 2006

I think the biggest issue here is this. The Centennial Foundation is a well respected organization in Ontario that many politicians and community leaders attend. To honour a man like Khushwant "singh" at a gathering that celebrates the Khalsa (it is a Baisakhi "banquet") is not just a disgrace or an unfortunate event, it is, indeed, a slap in the face to our Guru. An overstatement? I don’t think so. Khushwant Singh's faults are many. Let us look at them. 1. In the first edition of his "great" work on Sikh history, a work that is filled with historical inaccuracies that has done a LOT of damage over the last fifty years through its constant reprints and its wide distribution (strange that this has been so well published and other accounts by Sikh authors, which are much more historically accurate and well written have been ignored), Khushwant claims that Sikhism will be a dead and finished religion by the end of the century. He was writing this in the 1950's. He went on to say that Sikhism was surely dying out and that is why he was writing this book, to remember a fading people. While this little preface was left out of later editions, as it might come as a bit of a shock to read that today, you can find early editions of the book and read it yourself. At my University library here in Montreal I have read this with my own eyes. 2. He was, or more accurately, he claimed to be a close friend of the Gandhi family. (I write claim because in later years there has been some suspicion into how close he really was and how close he just WANTED to be). When in 1972 Indira Gandhi declared Emergency Rule Khushwant happened to be the editor of one of the most prominent, if not the most prominent newspaper in India, The Hindustan Times. What did he do? He fully defended Indira's positions. Even as she tortured thousands of Indian citizens, including many university students, castrated and sterilized thousands of low caste people, destroyed thousands of slums killing hundreds in the process, targeted minority groups including the Sikhs, and carried out a brutal campaign against all her enemies, real or perceived, he stood by her, just when he had the opportunity to speak out and make a real difference. (There’s also a bit of a scandal regarding how he got the job as senior editor in the first place… Indira sure wasn’t beyond interfering in the media.) 3. Many Sikhs today are finally waking up to the fact that Sikhs are the "niggers" of India. We are mocked, made into clownish figures and paraded like animals on Indian television and cinema. While Punjabi culture is absorbed and looted by the Hindi majority, our maryada and panthic traditions are inaccurately displayed. A lot of this current mocking and denigrating of our religion in Indian popular culture can in fact be traced back to the "sardar" jokes that have been so popular for quite awhile now. Well guess whose written more "sardar" jokes books then anyone else??? Khushwant, of course. Khushwant has, in fact, written a bunch of these books and it is really from these jokes that much of his popularity stems. Its not his novels, which even contemporary Indian critics don’t look upon favourably, nor his history books, which are really quite shabby, but these ridiculous and racist little joke books that have won him the most fame. 4. In the increasingly turbulent times leading up to the attack on Darbar Sahib in '84, Khushwant Singh was a HUGE supporter of Indira. He was also on the forefront of the campaign to slander and demonize Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Khalsa. Khushwant has always had an ego problem, from his obsession of wanting to be associated with the Gandhi family to his constant stupid and ridiculous statements designed to keep him in the limelight even as an decrepit old man. We know, and most Sikhs back then also knew, that all the government claims against Baba Jarnail Singh were ridiculous and baseless and there was a definite and coordinated attempt to brand him as an extremist and terrorist. Khushwant was a big part of this process. In fact, Khushwant went along ways to create the climate that not only allowed the attacks to take place, but in fact created the public demand for such an attack. Let us not forget that despite what the government and the media says now about an "unfortunate" event, the majority of Hindus and almost all of parliament were FIRMLY behind Indira when she attacked Darbar Sahib and many people in fact cheered in the streets when they heard of the attack (as did parliament). Khushwant himself made up some really ridiculous claims about Baba Jarnail Singh. He said that he received a letter from Jarnail Singh in which Jarnail Singh threatened to kill him if he did not denounce Indira Gandhi and also stop drinking alcohol. Baba Jarnail Singh's response to this accusation? He literally laughed it off. On stage, at Manji Sahib, Baba Jarnail Singh clearly states that he hasn't even heard of this Khushwant before and he has never written him any letters. He goes on to say that he couldn't care less what he does or does not do. And while he wishes all Sikhs would stop drinking, most of his anger was directed at those who claim to be amritdhari and drink alcohol in secret. Khushwant, we need not forget, has never ever been an amritdhari. It seems that Khushwant’s ego couldn’t’ handle the fact that Baba Jarnail Singh was targeting prominent anti-Sikh leaders but was leaving him out. Of course, Khushwant’s claims were spread wide by the media and were added to the “evidence” against Jarnail Singh, the evidence that he was a terrorist and a madman. 5. After '84, Khushwant made a few statements against the government. Its kind of hard not to make such statements when you yourself have faced death. Khushwant only survived the 84 anti-Sikh pogroms in Delhi because he had buddies at the Swedish embassy who let him in when he desperately came running. Otherwise, he would have been killed along with a lot of other Sikhs not so well connected. However, he continued in his anti-Jarnail Singh rhetoric. The question is this, are his few statements against the attack enough to deserve praise? My answer would be NO. He never acknowledged the root of the problem; that Sikhs were and had been discriminated against in India since '47. He did not acknowledge the fact that Sikhs had legal, democratic and constitutionally valid demands in the form of the Anandpur Sahib resolution, demands that were never seriously considered despite decades of PEACEFUL protest, nor did he acknowledge the huge number of human rights abuses that had been committed against the Sikhs since Baisakhi of 1978, including the murder of over 238 young Sikh men, the rapes of dozens of Sikh girls and women, the desecration of many Guru Granth Sahib jee's and attacks on Gurdwaras in the states of Rajasthan and Haryana. To speak out against one event but to be silent to a history of oppression and discriminatory treatment is a GREATER crime than having said nothing in the first place. By being so selective in his criticism, Khushwant did not put events in their proper context and also allowed for the blame for the Blusestar attack to be laid at not only Indira’s feet but also at the feet of our brave brothers and sisters who died defending our most beloved Takht and Gurdwara. 6. His praise of KP Gill. This should be, in my opinion, enough to not only NOT honour the man, but to instead make a real effort to get out there and KICK HIS ASS. Seriously. If a Jewish organization was holding an event, lets say it’s a reform Jewish group and not an Orthodox one, and they at that event honour a writer who has praised a Nazi war criminal would that organization not be committing an outrageous blunder! Is equating KP Gill with a Nazi going too far? No. While he did not kill nearly as many people, over 300,000 innocent Sikhs is still not a small number. Hundreds of thousands of women raped and thousands upon thousands of Sikhs tortured would also have to be taken into account. Remember that international human rights organizations have described the Punjab Police's policies against the Sikhs as tantamount to GENOCIDE. And also remember that the greatest architect of this horrific campaign was KP Gill. To praise such a man is an inexcusable and unpardonable offense. 7. While there are thousands of people in the world who are "Sikhs" or claim to be at least, When we honour Sikhs we should not go out of our way to honour those who consume alcohol, have NUMEROUS (or claim to) extramarital affairs and in fact, state openly that they do not believe in God. Just does NOT make sense. Fine, many non-Amritdharees are worthy of being honoured, but if they themselves state that they don’t even believe in Vaaheguru, then really, do they deserve to be singled out for special treatement??? They can be honoured at secular events, but should not be honoured at a Sikh organized event. 8. There can be no doubt that in addition to being made into clowns for the entertainment of India's masses, there has also been a widespread and longstanding campaign, carried out by western intellectuals, the Indian government and their state controlled universities and professors and the VHP and its many branches (RSS, etc) to demonstrate that Sikhs are Hindus. Khushwant Singh's statements, statements he continues to make up to the present time, that Sikhs are Hindus have gone along way to help in this campaign. If he is not a part of this obviously well planned attack on Sikhi, then he is definitely a supporter of it. So, in conclusion, Khushwant Singh is a man who believed that Sikhism would be dead by the begging of the 21st century (nice to know we proved him wrong... with no small help from great Sikhs like Baba Jarnail Singh), a man who was complicit in massive human rights abuses committed by the Indian government against not only Sikhs but hundred of thousands of Indian citizens from all backgrounds in the Emergency, is a man who has made a career off of mocking and denigrating his "own" people, assisted in the government demonization of the Sikhs that allowed for them to attack the Darbar Sahib in 1984, going so far as to having made up false claims about Baba Jarnail Singh, is a man who has praised the Butcher of Punjab, a man who destroyed a generation of young men and was responsible for the rape of THOUSANDS of our sisters, mothers and DAUGHTERS (we need not go into how young some of the girls were who were raped by the Punjab Police), does not even pretend to live like a Sikh, and believes that Sikhi is not an authentic religion but is instead nothing more than another sect of Hinduism, one of thousands (if only this were true, maybe they wouldn't have killed so many of our brothers and sisters). Fine, I understand that the Centennial foundation is not an overtly religious organization. I also understand that it honour Sikhs and non-Sikhs. I also understand that it honours many Sikhs who are not amritdhari. I have no real problems with this. I in fact attended one of their events a few years ago (I was a little shocked by what I saw, but that’s just me). But, to honour someone who is not only not a practicing Sikh, but someone who is ANTI-SIKH... well that just doesn't make any sense. Instead of honouring a man like this, the foundation should be using their resources and ties to the government to have KP Gill brought to justice. Remember when Modi couldn't get a visa to the US. That was a fairly big deal and had tremendous repercussions in India and in the Hindu diaspora. Imagine if KP Gill was not offered visas to western nations. What a message that would send... however, even with our many MP's and MLA's we are as Baba Jarnail Singh would say “slaves without even understanding that we are in fact enslaved”. Why? Because we are capable of standing up for even such a basic thing as getting a massive human rights abuser like Gill brought to justice. On a side note, I have been involved with the Kirpan case. As a member of the Montreal sangat, I was chosen by the Gurdwara Sahib and the Multanis to speak on their behalf. Recently, Gurbaj Singh's father received a phone call from the Centennial Foundation. They wished to honour him at their banquet for having been victorious in the kirpan case. When I explained to Balvir Singh, Gurbaj’s father, who else would be honoured there, he not only said no but was fairly disgusted and angry. In his words, "How can they honour the Kirpan when they themselves have no idea what the Kirpan stands for? We have no interest in getting awards or commendations of any kind, we only want to spread the message of the Guru's kakkars and amrit. They obviously have no care for the Guru's amrit if they honour people like that, there's no way we can attend." Too bad really. Instead of Gurbaj Singh, a young amritdharee boy who stood up against not only his school but the entire province of Quebec... and at the age of 12 at that, they're honouring an old, tired, pathetic and fairly disgusting man who has spent his life whoring himself and his people just to make a name for himself. They’re honouring a man who has NEVER, EVER made a courageous stand in his life, and has SEVERAL times over the half century come down on the side of the enemies of the Guru. Congratulations Centennial Foundation, you're truly doing the Sikh Panth proud. santbir singh

Re: Important : Khushwant Singh being Honored for contributions to sikh lifestyle!!

santbir singh singh · 14 Mar 2006

Sorry, Khushwant wasn't the editor of the Hindustan Times during the Emergency, he was the editor of The Illustrated Weekly of India. Also, one has to ask whether the Centennial Foundation is living up to its own stated goals, which are displayed on their homepage: "Creating and fostering a postive and accurate portrayal of Sikhs Celebrating the achievment of excellence in accordance with Sikh ideals Promoting an awareness and understanding of Sikh milestones Promoting an undestanding of a Sikh way of life Making Sikh heritage and history accesible" WOW, khushwant fails on EVERY point... santbir singh