Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Kaljug Jeev · 18 Feb 2006
waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh...i have a question..my friend and thier family is having an akhand path and they are told by someone to do the puratan way..which is while the whole akahnd path is been recited someone does japji sahib da path..it this a puratan maryada..and is ok to do..and why do they do this if its ok to do so?...plz enlighten me..
bhul chuk maaf..
waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh!
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
akj 4neva and neva · 19 Feb 2006
yes it is....this is because if the main akand paath is stopped then bani is still being recited so the akand doesnt break as such........hope that makes sense
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Gurpreet Sumra · 19 Feb 2006
A well known Santji writes in his book that with Akhand paath japji is must and as many number of japji as there are number of akhand paaths.
Saadh sangat ji aakho satnam shri waheguruuuu!!!!!!!!
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
LionKing (LK) · 19 Feb 2006
According to Panth Parvan Rehit Maryada, which has been implimented by Guru Panth, it is prohibited to read other paath
(c) Placing a pitcher, ceremonial clarified butted fed lamp, coconut, etc. around , during the course of the uninterrupted or any other reading of Guru Granth Sahib, or reading of other Scriptural texts side by side with or in the course of such reading is contrary to the gurmat (Guru's way).
It is Manmat, according to Panth Parvan Rehit Maryada.
Thus, do tell the family in question not to do anything going against the way of the Guru...
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Feb 2006
IT is NOT "puratan" or any other Maryada. IN Fact as Lion King Ji has quoted this Practice is BANNED in the Panthic Rehat Maryada.
The "reasons" to explain it are as illogical as the "purratan".."Akhand bani" , "IF" Akahnd paath gets interrupted...( Koi inhhan nu puchhey ki JE Japji Sahib gets interrupted..THEN WHAT ??)..DONT we DO ARDASS that the Akahnd Path shouldnt get interrupted ?? so whats the use of that ardass..its just for show or what ?? ) etc reasons given for it.
Just stick to the CORRECT Maryada...of the Guru Khalsa panth..perform the Path YOURSELVES ( at least one paathi from family !!), listen as much as possible, and dont let the "purattan thugghs" trick you into placing gharreh of pani, red clothes, conches, havan samgree etc etc...those are for their own "kharchas"
Jarnail Singh.
BTW I NEVER attend an Akahnd paath if i know such pakhand is being carried on
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Kaljug Jeev · 19 Feb 2006
waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh...phenjis/veerjis....the guy who told them to do so is a taksali singh..but hes humble and cardikala..the thing is..i to nvr went to an akhand path where japji sahib path is recited...so wht u suggest??..oh and yea..on march 12 theres a wedding here in our local gurdwara..the thing is i have to do lavan kirtan ..i dont know its not a gursikhs wedding.is it like ok for me the lavan...was just curious...bhul chuk maaff...and thanks for the reply sangat jio..
waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Gurpreet Sumra · 19 Feb 2006
Well known santji writes water in amritsar sarovar has become amrit, same way during akhand paath the water in pot becomes amrit.
Saadh sangat ji aakho Satnam shri waheguru!!!
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Kaljug Jeev · 19 Feb 2006
waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh..if i dont do the lavan path..is it ok for me to sit on guru maharaj tabia to read from maharaj?cause then there wouldnt be any ppl..just for my info..sorry..
waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Kaljug Jeev · 19 Feb 2006
o waheguroo..ok..ill try my best to stay away and attend the khand path..lol..well thanks alot..really helped..and i think i will ask the veerji on the japji sahib thing...and let u guys know whats the reason..if u guys one..thanks alot..
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Kharag Singh · 20 Feb 2006
Author: ...
Date: 02-19-06 21:06
kaljugi jeev,
all we can do is try our best to follow Gurmat. The Gurmat answer to your question is that we shouldn't attend the marriages of non-amritdharis.
___________________________________________________________
If you dont attend the wedding then how can you expect to keep Guru Granth Sahib there while your at home content with the fact that you didnt attend a "manmukhs" wedding? So what next, stop all non amritdharis getting married altogether? Then maybe even stop all non amritdharis coming to the Gurdwara altogether.
This extremism is going to push people further away from Sikhi then closer.
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Gurpreet Sumra · 20 Feb 2006
Read as much bani as one wants.It is good and beneficial.But when Akhand Paath is going on then as per Panth parvant Sikh Rehat Maryada, it says that a Sikh should do the paath hmself, in case if he can't do it then someone else can do it but he should listen to Akhand paath.
I think it definitely makes sense.If bani is being read out and you ar3 not listening to it just ignoring it and doing akal ustat,japji saab,rehras saab(they are bani too) then don't you think there is no point of that akhand paath that is going on.Only Paathi is doing it.
Whole Guru Granth Sahib is to be read and understood not just some banis otherwise these Akhand paaths just become mantar ratans by paathis.
In fact they have become, people book akhand paath in Gurudwaras and nobody is sitting in hall no.1 and it is a social gathering in a langar hall.
Otherwise there is no other reason, if you want to ignore rest of bani, nobody is stopping you, go ahead.
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
really Mr joka · 20 Feb 2006
Mr Joka jee,
no-one said to him not to go and listen to bani. people just said it is not the right maryada, and it is not prataan.
So do not be such a joka urself!
Re: Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
shota singh · 21 Feb 2006
the PANTHIC REHAT MARYADA ####HAS##### been adhered to by these akj.
the only point of contension, is not eating ANY meat!!
the basic required minimum bani quoted in the maryada IS completed AND surpassed with further baani.
the kakaar, is KEPT! even though considered a bodypart and the actual kakar the keski item. the KES HAS NOT BEEN SHED. therefore the pathic maryada HAS been followed.
SO the panthic maryada IS followed to the letter!!! so of course it can be 'invoked'.
...a few things for you to think about!!!
Gurfateh Singh jee
Is This Puratan Rehat And should It go on?..
Forgiveness! · 21 Feb 2006
The reason we do Jap Ji Sahib While Akhand Paath is being done is to ask forgiveness for any mistakes that are made. The same way people will say Waheguru if they make a mistake while doing paath!