dress for anand karaj
singh · 20 Feb 2006
i just wanna sangats views that is it ok to wear same dress for 10 bibi's who comes with bride in gurdwara for lavan
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
singh · 20 Feb 2006
i just wanna sangats views that is it ok to wear same dress for 10 bibi's who comes with bride in gurdwara for lavanJarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Feb 2006
OF Course..Why NOT ?? even 1000 Bibis can wear the SAME dress ...lol Jarnail Singh'' · 20 Feb 2006
i think hes refering to 'brides maids'... · 20 Feb 2006
If the idea is of a a group of Singhnis walking in together dressed the same, then that's great. Would be amazing to see. If you mean "brides maids" dressed in fancy lenghas walking in front of the bride throwing flowers, then that is not great. You can call me an extremist or a taliban, but I think anand kaaraj, like it originally was, should only be for amritdharis. When you let people with no faith in Sikhi come in, they make a mockery of the anand kaaraj. And on a final note; when the brides maids come in throwing flowers, don't they realise someone's going to have to actually pick those up. Making extra work for the sevadars.. · 20 Feb 2006
vjkk, vjkf also please don't bring flowers or anything because from what I have seen sooo many times is that they would bring flowers while walking in...matha tek and put the flowers infront of Guru Jee while matha teking and then when they get up they take the flowers with them...that is very disrespect of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. sorry to go off topic but please ensure that if flowers are brought in, they are left with Guru Jee. vjkk, vjkfManvir Kaur · 20 Feb 2006
wjkk wjkf ji hanji wa i think is yh they shud be in same dress but wa if all in gurur ka bana ahhh wa a scene i can imagine atm :p....but it'll be really great if all wear bana ,it'll luk like gurur diyan fauja ......waheguru jii( bas naal 10 singh v khade kar deo bhul na jeo kite) wjkk wjkf jiunreal · 20 Feb 2006
I understand what you are saying and if something is presented to Guru ji then it definitely shouldn't be taken away. That said, when a bride does put her flowers down, it's not with the intent of giving them to Guru ji so it doesn't matter that she takes them with her - she puts them down so she can matha tek. It's similar to women putting their purses down so they can matha tek - they are not giving the purses to Guru ji but putting them down so they can matha tek. I think the key is whether there is intent to give. On the issue of whether brides should or shouldn't be carrying in flowers, I see no harm in it and think its purely a matter of opinion whether one should or shouldn't. Personally, I don't have any strong opinions one way or the other. . wrote: > vjkk, vjkf > > also please don't bring flowers or anything because from what I > have seen sooo many times is that they would bring flowers > while walking in...matha tek and put the flowers infront of > Guru Jee while matha teking and then when they get up they take > the flowers with them...that is very disrespect of Sri Guru > Granth Sahib Jee. > > sorry to go off topic but please ensure that if flowers are > brought in, they are left with Guru Jee. > > vjkk, vjkf. · 21 Feb 2006
vjkk, vjkf but what's the point of the flowers then...to surround the couple instead of Guru Jee??...to be sitting near sangats feet rather than guru jee's feet? it will look nice for sure ...but it'll be something special for sure to give to guru jee not just take off with them...and they'll last longer with guru jee than with anyone else. like if they're not for guru jee...i don't see any point of them except for show or making it look nice, and that's not really a point either. sorry to go offtopic again :( vjkk, vjkfunreal · 21 Feb 2006
I'm not saying it's better to keep the flowers for yourself than it is to give it to Guru ji - only that the brides are not giving the flowers to Guru ji and then taking it away as indicated in the fifth post. And yes, the point of the flowers is for "looks", to add a little floral beauty. I don't see anything wrong in doing something to look nicer. For example, I am sure most of us spend at least some time making sure our clothes are neat and pressed, our dastars are tied cleanly and smoothly etc. To argue that holding flowers is some kind of terrible manmat, I think, is a huge stretch. For sure, it would be great if the flowers were presented to Guru ji as a gift from the bride but I think that is all dependant on the bride's learning and sharda. The same could be said of us, who walk in to the gurudwara with full wallets, but only put a token 2 or 5 dollars into the donation box - wouldn't it be better if we put all of that money into the donation box - YES, but everyone's sharda (and himmat) is different, not to mention the Sikhi education we have received. Lets not judge others on the basis of flowers - I think there is more harm in casting such judgments than there is in actually carrying such flowers. . wrote: > vjkk, vjkf > > but what's the point of the flowers then...to surround the > couple instead of Guru Jee??...to be sitting near sangats feet > rather than guru jee's feet? it will look nice for sure ...but > it'll be something special for sure to give to guru jee not > just take off with them...and they'll last longer with guru jee > than with anyone else. > > like if they're not for guru jee...i don't see any point of > them except for show or making it look nice, and that's not > really a point either. > > sorry to go offtopic again :( > > vjkk, vjkf [%sig%]. · 21 Feb 2006
vjkk, vjkf totally agree with unreal...sorry my mistake...I didn't mean to get out a message saying that flowers are wrong. Nothing wrong with flowers..i was just giving a suggestion that they would look nice with guru jee. sorry for my big mistake of not choosing right wording. bhul chuk maph karnee jee vjkk, vjkfDhanwant · 22 Feb 2006
i ddnt know that ppl cared about wat they wore in their anadh karaj....really u jus want the blessings of the sangat and Dhan Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Ji.u can get them by jus wearin simple clothes and having a simple wedding.why does the bibi need so many bridesmaids??is this a church wedding??LOL!!ppl tek the mick man gosh!!Goreh Banjo!!jus chillout and have a nice simple wedding...Guru maharaj will bless u wid all his grace trust me...Dhanwant Singh.Singh78 · 22 Feb 2006
We must understand that the BaNa of Guru Sahib is for all Amritdharis with no exceptions for days or times. All must wear Gurmukhi BaNa in Darbar of Guru wheter it be the same as someone getting married or not.k@ur · 22 Feb 2006
good comment singh 78!!! these days singhni's with dastar have no respect for why they are wearing the dastar esp during the anand karaj. maybe they should question the whole point of wearing a dastar. to look for their in-laws or others or to respect and represent sikhi.pkaur · 22 Feb 2006
wjkk wjkf There was a beautiful wedding in vancouver last year where the bride and groom looked amazing. The Singhni wore a beautiful simple blue suit. It was stunning because it was simple. Not like these so called over-kadayed suits that others so called singhni's wore on their wedding day. Some of them are so heavy that they worry about how their chunni's are going to stay on the keski and they have hundreds of pins everywhere!. The sisters/friends all wore the same colored suits but again they were simple. Thats the way it should be......and i think thats more acceptable :) wjkk wjkfunreal · 22 Feb 2006
Dear pkaur, Forgive me if I am understanding you incorrectly, but why do you say "so-called singhnis"? Does their choice of wedding suit now all of a sudden put their Sikhi into question? Are they no longer Sikhs because they chose kadayi over no kadayi in their suits? It's a personal choice - please don't question or judge someone else's Sikhi on the basis of a clothing choice they have made. I would say, even if a singhni wears something, say, too revealing, don't automatically judge her and strip her of her Sikhi - give her the benefit of the doubt and consider talking to her and kindly letting her know the perception it creates - it may be the singhni just made a bad choice without putting too much thought into it. Guru de piaro, show a little piar and a little less "automatic-machine gun" judgment. regards, unrealtroubled · 22 Feb 2006
'automatic machine gun' hahaha thats such a good way of putting it!! just a quick question to '...' ji what if someone isnt amritdhaari khalsa as they havent reached that level in their spirituality but have love understanding and respect for sikhi, should they be able to have anand karaj? (not tryin to start an argument just curious)kharkoo · 23 Feb 2006
How many out of all those posting on this thread wear bana to uni or work? I bet not many. But everyone is quite quick to pick on others. This is the downfall of Sikhi.LionKing (LK) · 23 Feb 2006
Christianized Sikhiw/ever · 23 Feb 2006
as for the bridesmaid thing though - i don't get it imho it's quite lame and all the attention then gets focused on them and the huge entrance they make rather than on Guru ji - the most important Being there, the Sole Reason we are there, if the bride is adamant on having brides maids or w/ever then she can keep it for outside the Darbar Hall and have them in pictures or w/ever.