Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

opinions · 21 Feb 2006

this was the views of a singh on discoversikhi.com message board about this weekends rehnsbai kirtan: Since this is a forum where everyone is entitled to their own opinion I just wanted to comment on the rehansbai that took place over the weekend. I personally did not enjoy it. Okay everyone is also entitled to cuss me now so please go ahead. It was all a million miles per hour. I now understand why some gursikhs speak against 'Dhuni' and honestly I would be supporting them for how that rehansai was conducted. When I got there a renowned local jatha was doing simran which was good and expected as usual but when the other keertanee jathas did seva..the 2 tablas, the dholkis and kartalas were still there as well as the extrememly fast simran. I dont really think anyone could have wholeheartedly say 'waheguru' each time, since you had a quarter of a second to say it in. Ive always thought of rehansbai keertan where one has the oppurtunity to sing the lords praises and with this evolve rass which ultimately leads to the betterment of your jeevan through contemplating and putting into practice what gurbani says as well as having the urge to do simran. I dont know if its just nyaan budhi but when Bibi Kuldep Kaur Jee did her mellow keertan everyone either went to sleep or left the darbar sahib: i guess there wasnt enough flashy tunes to do simran with! Kan rass can be good i suppose to attract individuals without any interest in sikhi towards keertan but I also think there should be a limit. I was attracted to keertan through listening to a bhai manjit singh cassette...it hasnt even got flashy tunes with really fast simran or anything...i just liked its simplicity i guess. If anyone listens to that keertan now they would agree that its nowhere near the 'explosiveness' of todays keertan. Another point is that certain things should be kept gupt to preserve it; i hate to see people making imitations or jokes of how people were doing simran but its not entirely there fault either. What do people think of this? My english is quite poor, therefore im sure some people will interepret this differently.

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

Jagjit Singh · 21 Feb 2006

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Pyare jio, although I missed the rainsbhai due to my baby being abit unwell. I can guess what the Gursikh is on about from previous programmes. When people do simran in groups or at rainsbhais, it needs to be done in one "liv". This basically means that it should be done together at one pace and level. Then the energy at like an ocean of bliss in everyones minds and hearts. If not, then it can just turn into noise, and individuals are unable keep to the tempo, losing their concentration. Personally at some programmes it can be frustatrating, so i would just block it all out, and just do simran myself at my own slow pace. Often in simran programmes, I have seen Bhai Rama singh or even bhai Jarnial singh once, stop everyone and make them go again in one "liv". Although this can be done in simran programmes, or house keertan programmes, it is not always possible to as the whole sangat at rainsbhais. Youth often get excited and go at fast past, or at a pace completely different to the rest of the sangat. Bhai Rama singh was very strict on this. He used to say we should always do simran together at one pace. The sangat then turns into one body, doing simran. I personally have experienced this, when the whole sangat does simran in one"liv" , it is so amazing, and your Rass is increased so much more. Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

singhni · 21 Feb 2006

vaheguru... one of my local sisters said the same, that she didnt get much enjoyment from the rainsbai because it was too fast for her. (i was unable to go). I think we should speak honestly about this. I also wish kirtan would be sung slower during rainsbai's

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

Harcharan Singh · 21 Feb 2006

We have people doing simran and kirtan to blues, jazz, bhangra, bollywood, pop you name it's now being done. Strange that how for 400+ years sikhs were happy to abide by their Guru's rules regarding kirtan - i.e. the style of music, the emotion and even the taal (speed) as clearly shown in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. I cannot imagine, nor can anyone prove that our Guru's would hold kirtan programmes where people were struggling to keep up! Our Guru's designed Kirtan and simran to be enjoyed, experienced and shared by all. The tabla, which is a relatively new instrument (150 years old) is today used completely out of context. The original drum used was the Jora, a Pakavaj that was divided into two pieces by Guru Arjun Dev Ji, and was used to set the pace of the nirdaareth kirtan. It was simply in the background and would be used in places to end a pauri, emphasise words etc... not like todays drum and badd tabla players and listeners who bash the hell out of it so fast that it overtakes both the shabad and the music! Even when you look at the sangat they are enjoying the tabla beats, not the shabad! Brave of Veer/Bhen Ji to raise this, well done. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

hello!! · 21 Feb 2006

From my knowledge, AKJ UK is not against doing simran in Keertan where appropriate, But the Gurmantar should be clearly definable, If you are going to say Waheguru then put the effort in saying the Mantar fully. I remember the times when Gursikhs like Bhai Manjeet SIngh Jee and Bhai Harpreet Singh Jee used to do simran for 10-20minutes but it was so fantastic that you felt elated listening to it. These days it is not the same. However this is not a crticism of anyone but it also depends on the Gursikhs behind the Keertanee, because they can raise the Keertan or spoil it. I know a lot of elders in the Jatha are totally opposed to doing Saas Graas Simran in Rehensbhais however the Youngster's these days encouraged by some elders who should know better still do this and in the main do not understand how to read gurbani, Sing it, or even understand it. In previous times if Keertani were told not to do Saas Graas they would do there upmost to stop themselves as they try to follow Gurmukhs Hukam. In certain occasions it can be difficult and we should understand this. The point of Rehnsbhais is that Keertan is to be sung and the Sangat should join in. In some occasions there is more simran than Keertan and this is totally wrong IMHO. We do have Simran Programs and they should be seperate from Rehnsbhais. Just my 2 cents worth!! [%sig%]

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

Tabla basher · 21 Feb 2006

I have to agree with Veer Harcharan Singh. I've noticed nowadays that the Sangat is more concerned with the speed of the tabla and simran rather than Guru's Bani that is being sung. I was there at Bebe Nanaki and it was crazy! And not in a good way! Instead of mellow Simran being done where the whole Sangat participates, full on Saas Graas Simran was being done. Personally I feel that this is just wrong, especially if this is being done by youths! The mentality of Rainsbai's are slowly changing. A new "tabla bashing, 200mph Simran" culture is here, and unless you have lungs the size of watermelons, youre not gonna keep up! I also noticed the posts on this forum regarding the Leicester Raensabaee, and how it was "amazing" and the "atmosphere" was brilliant. But having listened to the recordings, I know people are really trying to say. "The Simran was wicked man!!! Really fast and loud!!!" [%sig%]

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

gabroo · 21 Feb 2006

i'm pleased that no one has taken offence here and that this is being discussed ammicably. daas too doesn't mind the simran dhunni in rensbais and infact can feel the emmergence of the dhunni sometimes, but in cases such as the current rensbai... it sometimes feels there was not enough emphasis on keertan than some of he youth satisfying their urge to simmar. i could be wrong, and don't intend to cause any hurtful feelings appologise in advance if anyone takes offense. but at the sametime, it could be said that these youth were 'feeling' the dhunni a lot more and just opening up into simran... in which case, they perhaps should control themselves internally. it feels awful to say this cos it could sound like trying to put a restriction on someone which is horrible. satisfying an urge to simmar couldn't be wrong, but the singhs/nis in question should consider it's impact on the concentration of others too. anyway... huge apologies for sounding like i'm preaching or judgjing. loved the sangat and kirtan regardless, and hope akhand kirtani jatha continues kirtan seva vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguruji ki fateh

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

... · 21 Feb 2006

yes theres room for improvement naam repition should be slowed down so the whole sound can be heard clearly listening to the sound of naam is the key in naam abyaas theres no point going at a rate which means the whole sound cannot be heard

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

:))))) · 21 Feb 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh ji Intereting topic Soem Gursikhs want to do loud simran Some Gursikhs want to do it internally and quiet Some Gursikhs want to listen to the Gurbani only Soem Gursikhs want to do fast Simran Does it really matter? At a rain-sbai everyones at a different level, let Gursikhs do as they pls. Okay, some might say loud and fast simran ruins concentration, but for others it helps. Lets not segegrate ourselevs further based on what type of simran we do. Also a few yrs ago, everyone would ask 'where are all the youths at rain-sbais' now with Guru's kirpa there are loads, lets encourage them to flourish into Gursikhs 99% of the world are caught up in kaljug, they drink, smoke, etc etc, so there aren't many Gursikhs. Lets realsie we all have differences and not judge them.

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

LionKing (LK) · 21 Feb 2006

HOW about doing Kirtan with Maryada =D Gurbani Kirtan in Maryada on Reinsabai: Coming Soon to an area close to you :D

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

shota bhai · 21 Feb 2006

akhand kirtan jio... not akhand simran... through kirtan is how the liv is connected... simran ji BOHT vaddiya ji, but unless the kirtan is heard there... many cannot get connected. please think of those needing to be connected.

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

simple singhani · 21 Feb 2006

what wrong wiith having 2 tubleh???

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

hm · 21 Feb 2006

yeh bt the ppl who do it loudly mite distract the ones who like to do it quietly...every1 shud respect each other. ok so some simran is good an dnice but while the shabad is going on, its nice to just be able to listen to the shabad

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

Waheguru · 21 Feb 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh Personally, i think that the rhensabhi was great and inspiring. If you leave out all the simran, the kirtan (shabads) said were brilliant, the meaning and pace...brilliant. I also agree that simran at the worng point does ruin in and it shouldn't be too fast. But overall the rhensabhi was brilliant. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh!!!

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

MOW! · 21 Feb 2006

come on please! i like my simran in my keertan but this is just getting ridiculous. there was no flow in any of the shabads, the bani was just used as gap fillers between the simran which was super fast and i doubt anyone could keep up. i know we shouldnt be critical and see the good in everything but so many people have complained about this program i asked some gurmukh singhs they said the same thing. these singhs have been doing abhiyaas for many years they know about what is proper and what isnt - ive never been to a rainsabai like that before its wasnt so graet! come on akj uk, i've only been going to rainsabais for about 2 years but ive seen a big change from keertan being focussed on exploring the shabad, to now where its just some crazy hyperventilation simran! i also know at some of the house programs organised by the group who run this gurdwara (not akj) there are people rolling on the floor and fainting, this is hyperventilation not simran, if these things are happening you need to pesh at a jatha organised rainsabai and learn how to do simran properly please!

Re: Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!

Admin · 21 Feb 2006

topic closed.