Bebe Nanaki Rehnsbai - too fast!
opinions · 21 Feb 2006
this was the views of a singh on discoversikhi.com message board about this weekends rehnsbai kirtan: Since this is a forum where everyone is entitled to their own opinion I just wanted to comment on the rehansbai that took place over the weekend. I personally did not enjoy it. Okay everyone is also entitled to cuss me now so please go ahead. It was all a million miles per hour. I now understand why some gursikhs speak against 'Dhuni' and honestly I would be supporting them for how that rehansai was conducted. When I got there a renowned local jatha was doing simran which was good and expected as usual but when the other keertanee jathas did seva..the 2 tablas, the dholkis and kartalas were still there as well as the extrememly fast simran. I dont really think anyone could have wholeheartedly say 'waheguru' each time, since you had a quarter of a second to say it in. Ive always thought of rehansbai keertan where one has the oppurtunity to sing the lords praises and with this evolve rass which ultimately leads to the betterment of your jeevan through contemplating and putting into practice what gurbani says as well as having the urge to do simran. I dont know if its just nyaan budhi but when Bibi Kuldep Kaur Jee did her mellow keertan everyone either went to sleep or left the darbar sahib: i guess there wasnt enough flashy tunes to do simran with! Kan rass can be good i suppose to attract individuals without any interest in sikhi towards keertan but I also think there should be a limit. I was attracted to keertan through listening to a bhai manjit singh cassette...it hasnt even got flashy tunes with really fast simran or anything...i just liked its simplicity i guess. If anyone listens to that keertan now they would agree that its nowhere near the 'explosiveness' of todays keertan. Another point is that certain things should be kept gupt to preserve it; i hate to see people making imitations or jokes of how people were doing simran but its not entirely there fault either. What do people think of this? My english is quite poor, therefore im sure some people will interepret this differently.