Re: PETA
Sherbahadar Singh · 24 Feb 2006
WJKK, WJKF
Veer S Singh Ji,
I agree with your sentiments towards the cruelty and brutality inflicted upon millions and millions of animals daily and I agree with you that we need to spread public awareness regarding this type of barbarity that ever persists in our so-called "modern" society.
However, I do not agree with helping PETA not because of PETA's message, but their methods of delivery. A gora friend of mine stopped his membership with PETA several years ago because he was disgusted with how PETA heavily utilized members of the sex trade industry to convey their message. I am not going to get into detail but if you researched using google, you'd find out what I'm talking about and I'm pretty sure you would be quite disturbed.
For example, PETA's own integrity has come under question time and time again. How does it make sense to protest an animal circus by painting women (barely wearing anything) like a tiger and putting them in a cage beside the circus entrance? Don't these people have any sense about what they're doing? There are parents with children going to the circus. Their lack of sensitivity really sickens me and they've got a very long history of doing these kinds of neo-hippiesh things. Methods like this are the kinds they use to denounce animal cruelty.
The kind of vegetarianism PETA advocates ("veganism") is beyond that of Sikhism even. According to them, NO animal products (including milk) should be consumed and we should all consume soy milk and a whole bunch of other stipulations. I don't think many Sikhs would agree with that.
Other organizations like the WWF, WSPA, various Humane Societies and other Animal Societies do not resort to these types of narrow-minded methods and in my opinion, they are better to help.
WJKK, WJKF
Re: PETA
Sherbahadar Singh · 25 Feb 2006
WJKK, WJKF
I think you guys don't have the slightest clue to what end PETA goes to make their mark. In my first post, I asked you to do some research about them and I refrained myself from using the language required to talk about PETA's methods, but now I won't hold back.
In my eyes, PETA is nothing more (right now, at least) than a single minded organization that sexually exploits women ever increasingly to get their message across. I honestly haven't seen any other organization that goes the extra mile like PETA when I say this. They are single minded because all they care is about animal rights at the expense of everything else (literally). Please read the links below to understand my perspective better. As a warning, the sites contains sexually suggestive images so please be careful.
Other things that PETA does are just damn stupid. Several years ago, in downtown Toronto (I was at home watching the news when this happened), a couple was having sex in public daylight in the middle of some grass pasture near a very busy subway entrance in a sleeping bag to make their point that "vegetarians have better sex". I was like "What the F***?". Next day I went to school, a very violent altercation was narrowly avoided between me and some goras (I went to a school with like 98% gorey, rest Chinese and Indians, I was the only visible Sikh) who knew I was vegetarian and were making very offensive comments.
Also, last year, while I was walking in downtown to go for a job interview (around Janruary), from a distance, I could see a crowd of guys assembled. At first I thought somebody had slipped and fallen on the ground as it was very icy. When I got somewhat closer (but still quite some distance away), was a women wearing a bra and panties with made out of lettuce and wearing rabbit ears handing out samples of "Not Dogs", (vegetarian hot-dogs) in frigid cold temperature.
There are LOADS of other sites detailing PETA perverse tactics to get their message across. And also, these are NOT one-time experimental methods for PETA; they routinely exploit women to meet their ends and are now doing it more than ever.
I don't mean to offend anyone, but I've got several questions for the guys that support PETA. First, do you honestly think any of our Gurus would support these methods to stop people from abusing animals? What if these women that PETA exploits were your sisters, how would you feel then? Again, I'm not flaming anyone, I'm just trying to create awareness of the issue at stake. Please do more research regarding PETA and its tactics before you start supporting them financially or otherwise. There are MANY other animal rights organizations that don't rely on such low-minded tactics and I believe you should support them.
As Sikhs, we need to avoid hypocritical organizations with potential double standards and conflicts of interest. I urge you to look at alternative organizations.
WJKK, WJKF
Re: PETA
S Singh (original poster) · 26 Feb 2006
S Singh,
Do you even know the kind of treatment that is inflicted on the oxe at Qila Raipur games? they not only whip them, but the whip is tipped with a sharp nail which is hammered into the whip. So when the race is on, the guy stabs that nail repeatedly on the oxe making him run faster because it's in so much pain. For God sake, how would YOU like it buddy if some one were to stab you in the back with a sharp nail? would you still be defending these inhumane games which torture the hell out of these oxe?
Re: PETA
S Singh(original poster) · 27 Feb 2006
S Singh,
It is NOT a rumour I heard. I come from Punjab(born there) and saw this first hand. The whip being tiped by a nail is common knowledge in Punjab. If you do not even know this much (which is common knowledge in Punjab) I am assuming that you are a western born and bred. My suggestion to you to please go to Punjab and see the games first hand and see the reality of this barbarity which in inflicted on those oxe. In India many animals are abused. For example, snake charmers (sapairaas) who keep snakes pull the teeth of the snake out with a plier. In UP you will come accross some who make bears dance. If you were to see this in person you would realise the kind of cruelty that is inflicted on those bears.
I understand that most of you live in nice comfortable air conditioned houses in the west and may not realise the rest of the world is not as so cushi wushi as you may have seen on discovery channal. The ground reality is much more harsh. Welcome to reality my friends...
Re: PETA
S Singh(original poster) · 27 Feb 2006
Well well well...
Now the reality has come out (aslihat baar nikal he ahi!). So the reason you defend torturerers of animals is becuase your family are also into these barbaric games. Wah! kia Khandani pesha hai! to torture animals seems to be a way of life for you. I am really surprised how you even deny these tortures which happens to be common knowledbe for those from Punjab. Suger-coating turture will not make it any less torture my friend. So the oxe is fed and treated is like 'family' as you claim. But on the day of the race that animals goes through the worst torture imaginable with a nail being stabbed in it's back repeatedly. You call that oxe 'being treated like family'? with family like this, who needs enemies!
[%sig%]
Re: PETA
Guroo Guroo · 27 Feb 2006
Panjabis seem to struggle to see Waheguru in Baby Girls!! God help us when coming to see God in animals.