Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Singh · 04 Dec 2003

Man killed in Muslim-Sikh clashes One man was killed and five injured after a group of Sikhs attacked Muslim-owned properties, police in the southern Indian city of Hyderabad say. The attack followed reports that a Sikh holy flag had been torched in Hyderabad's Kishan Bagh district. The dead man was a 25-year-old auto rickshaw driver, Muhammed Afzal. Locals say the police stood by during the attacks, but police official A Khan said 15 arrests were made and calm had been restored. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/3291081.stm

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

disgusted · 04 Dec 2003

well even in uk muslims burnt da nishan sahib of a gurdwara here in 1995, and den vandalised and attacked gurdwaras ands beat up gianni ji at villers rd gurdwara southall after eid celebrations. many instances of nishan sahibs being burnt have been reported here too. these muslims think its just a flag.

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Khalsa Soulja · 04 Dec 2003

lol, sikhs in south india have showed the musaaalmaaans what happens when u burn a nishan sahib, if any muslom burns a sikh flag in southall then ill come down n do the same thing hahahahaha r u sure that happened in 95? since there are quite alot of sikhs in southall? didnt singhs do anything back?

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 05 Dec 2003

its rss no1 else sikhs and muslims sympathise with each toher in india

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Singh · 05 Dec 2003

http://www.newkerala.com/news-daily/news/features.php?action=fullnews&id=1911 India News: Andhra Pradesh: One killed in sectarian clashes By Mohammed Shafeeq, Hyderabad, Dec 4 A man was killed and five people were injured in clashes between Muslims and Sikhs here Thursday, police officials said. The clashes occurred in Kishanbagh neighbourhood in the old quarters of the city after unidentified people burnt a Sikh religious flag. Armed Sikh men then started attacking houses and shops of Muslims, suspecting their involvement in the incident. Residents of the area alleged the violence continued for almost 90 minutes but the police did nothing to stop the mob. The mob attacked people and damaged a dozen houses and shops. Police said they had taken 15 people into custody and seized some swords. Additional police forces were deployed in the area as tension was still simmering there. "The situation is now under control. The elders of the two communities sat together and expressed their regret over the incidents," said Additional Commissioner of Police A.K. Khan. The situation was brought under control after former legislator and Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen leader Asaduddin Owaisi intervened and persuaded the crowd to disperse peacefully. Owaisi got the Sikh religious flag restored at its original spot. Khan said trouble began Thursday morning when the Sikhs found their Nishan-e-Mubarak or religious flag lying burnt on the ground at Kishanbagh, which is home to about 10,000 Sikhs. A large number of Sikhs, armed with swords, gathered in the area and attacked the houses and shops of Muslims. The mob stabbed and killed Mohammed Afzal, 25, an auto rickshaw driver. Five people were injured in separate incidents of violence. Ghan Singh, a Sikh, was critically injured when some Muslim youths retaliated. His condition was described as critical. A Sikh woman intervened to save the life of one Mahmood Ali, a daily wage labourer who was returning home on not getting work for the day. The armed mob surrounded and attacked Ali, who was injured on the neck and back before the woman came to his rescue.

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 05 Dec 2003

wow tha's amazing much respect to bibi ji who stopped the mob of so called sikhs

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

disgusted · 05 Dec 2003

yes khalsa souljah it happend in southall eid celebrations, muslims came from chalvey, luton, birmingham, congregated in southall like 2000 of em hardcore guys. this is before the southall sp came on the scene. no one knew nuttin about it till it happened, they started off down the broadway blocking traffic , yelling, then started attacking gurdwara villeirs rd, beat up the gianni, smashed the lights they were very smart they gave support and waited outside the gurdwara and sent in their black converts, to do the biz. they tried to do the same to park avenue but the gates were locked at night. there was commotion in southall at the time, the police were called in due to the large numbers, started cordoning streets off, news got around a gurdwara was attacked, then about 300 sikhs, monai gathered up, but couldnt get through because of the cordons and riot police blocked the streets off. thereafter sp emerged, in southall, but again i dont entirely agree with it either, but then again at least they have some spirit of wanting to help the community and come together even if their ways aint always summit we agree with. after muslim owned shops were attacked in southall, and led to some friction between youth in old southall past and around king street sides, but that was very sad because innocent people whether sikh muslim were caught up in it, there was also a follow on to the slough riots. nishan sahib was burnt down in a popular gurdwara where rensbhais take place woodlands rd ramgaria gurdwara by young muslims. nishan sahib was hurled up to mark up 300th year of khalsa anniversary in east ham town hall temporarily then bengali muslim fanatics ripped it down and burnt it in front of every1. nishan sahibs were burnt down on eid day in east london green street, and ilford lane, in 3 seperate incidents, and 2 sikh owned shops attacked barely 2 years ago. In those incidents i think either ht or khalifa played a part because they have been distributing leaflets for years on the streets that promote hatred against jews, christians sikhs and hindus with mentionof historical events such as 1947, kashmir etc. these are just a few cases, muslim women were even sent to a gurdwara in east london when sikhs were marking a peace vigil for the killed in sep 11 and started causing disruption shouting abuse. thereafter muslim kids were throwing bricks, insulting the giannis, kicking footballs at the gurughar. recently in another gurdwara which gets high numbrs of sikhs on weekends, but in a muslim dominated area in east ham , ive found their trying to kick off 10 yeards away outside the gurdwara on the rd over parking and shouting jibes like " does this area belong to your father?" " you people think you rule" ... and then start swearing, block the rd off so the traffic cant pass, i mean all its gonna take is one sikh to kick off then because its a muslim area, they will gather up and attack the gurdwara which lead to stupidity. I think in time it will get worse as muslims are larger in number with strong purist missionary groups embedded like ht and khalifa who send out the wrong message to youngsters and sikhs are less not in number but in unity and this brother sisterhood thing.

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Singhani · 05 Dec 2003

Well done to those Sikhs who stood up to these filthy pigs. Im with KS, they try something here and I wouldn't hesitate to the same to these low lifes.

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Jagroop Singh · 05 Dec 2003

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh If it happened like it says, then thats terrible; if there was no evidence and inocent Muslims were killed...if that is the case then these 'Sikhs' were no better than the delhi rioters and are very far from Guru Ji. Who knows...its sounds more like an RSS thing. They would have alot to gain from any trouble which flares up between Muslims and Sikhs in Pakistan. I imagine that in the fullness of time, we may find out what actually happened...if Vahiguru wills it. Khalsa Soulja Paaji, the death of an person who may be innocent is no laughing matter. Please behave like a true Khalsa Soldier / Sant Sipahi. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

. · 05 Dec 2003

Yo wats wrong wid some of u ppl REVENGE AND RETRIBUTION are not good things!!! the idea of an eye-for-an-eye is the stupidest thing i've heard, if one muslim burns a nishan sahib, wat right to singhs have to go an attack differnet muslims in the form of a mob, wat will that achieve, how that rectify the situation. Some of u shud think b4 u spk, didn't the guru's teach forgiveness or have u forgotten that, theres a difference between standing up to defend yur religion, and acting out of anger and hatred whist seeking revenge.... GROW UP,

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Khalsa Soulja · 05 Dec 2003

"disgusted"..............thnx for the info.........do u know anything else that is happening like TODAY...........in southall or area around it? i hope the musalmans remember what happened in that slough estate a while bak w/ shere panjab................cuz if they are not careful they will make national news again...but not for the right reasons :) :) :)

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

hmm · 06 Dec 2003

More updated news said that the Singh also passed away. Two ways to look at it - A Singh became shaheed for protecting the honour of the nishaan, A singh pointlessly lost his life when a group of misfit fake Sikhs started randomly attacking innocent muslims We don't know what really happened though..

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Gaiani · 06 Dec 2003

r some of u actually suggesting that we let our Nishan Sahib be disrespected?

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

disgusted · 06 Dec 2003

yes it could be rss then again it might not be. Just because sikhs and muslims are both oppressed in india does that mean that out of 150 million muslims in india not even one would attack on sikhs and take a nishan sahib down? i live in england i know indian muslims who are a part of the ht and khalifa who have a known track record of attacking sikhs in the uk, both verbally and physically with aims of attacking sikh ideology as well as sikh instituitions.what are sikhs categorised as under the supposed khalifat? kaffar = infidel. what the rss and goi r doing with support of state, some (NOT ALL) muslim groups also do off their own back due to our weakness and lack of united spirit. we often deny and overlook that because of events in 1984. It wasnt a right move for sikhs to attack muslim properties or kill a muslim at all or even cause a riot in a muslim area for that causes problems for sikh muslim relations whatever exists of them now anyway. Two wrongs dont make a right, but at the same time if you sit there living in england we have seen they grow more confident and bold in attacking sikhi in every way be that gurdwaras, nishan sahibs, hacking off a sikh boys joora, physically attacking sikhs. I think its easy to say summit here on what we wud have done or have liked to have done based on sikh ideals, when your in the situation you dont know, depends what circumstances your faced with, ie if youve got 10 muslims shouting abuse in your face for being a sikh and challanging you while you protesting about nishan sahib what you gonna do walk away and say my ideals wont let me hurt you for i am in defence only?but a nishan sahib has just been burnt? when you try n talk to some of these people you sense intolerance of your existance which dulls any aspect of peaceful dialogue. Then how are you supposed to walk away? Check this out, 4 sikhs went out on th trains in acton west london, one was dressed in orange head to toe 4 years ago. Loads of muslims jumped on with checkered red scarves on and gave dirty looks to the sikhs, came upto the one in orange and started spitting at him and drenched him in spit head to toe while the few sikhs were scared cos they were few in number. Then thefanatics gloated and waited for a challange, laughed and said " we like the colour orange". The ironic thing was there were a good 40 of them packed out the carriage. Now ok those 4 sikhs were scared, its not their fault, we cant say " they should have lernt ghatka or what not" basically passing off the buck of racial and religious hatred which does exist right in front of our faces. this should not be happening in a modern world but it is. When it does that raises questions. This is not 1947, 1984, or a stone aged jihad. There is hatred resurfacing from something or somewhere, that leads to things like this, it cant be rss in every single case of muslims picking on sikhs even if their involved in the indian one right now. U wont see it in canada america yet, because numbers r less and sikhs r more. Thats why sikhs over there find it hard to see it from our boots here.

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 07 Dec 2003

WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! i am pretty sure that it was not actual muslims that burned the nishan sahib i bet it was actual rrs ppl who live in that area and pretend to be "muslims", as for the "sikhs" who did the rioting i also wouldnt be suprised if they too are actually rss ppl who pretend to be sikhs. i dont think any real sikhs would carelessy riot like that (more likely they would find those responsible and punish then not just any ole muslim shopkeeper ect.) rss or whoever they were probably want to increase hatred between REAL muslim and sikhs so that they would start killing each other and have mass riots like in gujraat. ################################################ Residents of the area alleged the violence continued for almost 90 minutes but the police did nothing to stop the mob. ################################################ interesting that how the police even shows up when sikhs even do a simple demonstration (like in 1978) and stop the sikhs, yet when there is a riot they do nothing. most likely they allowed this becasue it will add "fuel to the fire" between the two groups. -my thoughts WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!!

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Khalsa Soulja · 07 Dec 2003

lets not blame everything on RSS. can be just as bad as bahmans. but of course the police will be a bit lax because they dont mind a bit of sikh-muslim tension. i personally see nothing wrong with the rickshaw guy dying if he was the one who burnt the nishan sahib. if someone disrespects sikhi to that level, they arent exactly going to saackhand anyway, u might as well give them a head start thru their chaursi lakh lives hahahaha seriously though, what happened to shere punjab.....i know they r a bunch of dumb monneh but there have been times when they have given the a good kicking......where r they now?

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Bikramjitsingh · 08 Dec 2003

WJKK WJKF There seems to be some confusion because there is now mention in the newspapers about Hindus getting involved as well. NDTV states that 'unknown' assailants burnt the Nishan Sahib at the Gurdwara. So there may be some truth that Hindus might have done in to cause Sikh-Muslim riots but knowing Muslims and the level of their intelligence I would not be surprised if Muslims were involved. That said, it seems like the Sikhs gave a good account of themselves. These Sikhs of Hyderabad aren't the Sikhs we get in Punjab many of whom are too scared to ven keep their kesh. These Sikhs of Hyderabad are the descendents of Sikhs who went from Punjab in the 19th century and were recruited into the Nizam of Hyderabad's army. They are called Dakhni Sikhs and keep the rehat and don't take any BS from Muslims. GurFateh Bikramjit

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

Parvindar · 09 Dec 2003

Considering the situation, i would have blamed on RSS. But when it happened around 6th December, it will be muslims only. RSS wants to consider Sikh also as hindu and for that, they will prefere any clash between sikh and muslims. They will be benefitiary from clashes. But considering long bloody history of sikh and muslims and extrimism in muslims, they should be behind this. About killing a muslim rikshaw driver, he may be innocent. But if you dont reply, you suffer more. Its upto sikh living in hydrabad to decide whether it was wrong or not. They have to live in muslim neighbourhood and they have to die. They should decide how to live and reply. Others have no right to comment on that. As long as NDTV news is concerned, for everything, blame will be on RSS directly or indirectly.

Dealing with it

Jagroop Singh · 09 Dec 2003

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Without pure faith in Guru Sahib, Sikhs are open to all forms of attack - internal and external ememies of the Panth have an easy time. If we don't follow Guru Sahib with every particle of our being (Mun and Tun) then His grace is not with us. Whether it's the RSS or some 'Muslims' in the UK, they all prosper because of the current intentional/unintentional ignorance on the part of the majority of ourselves, our 'leaders', institutions parents etc. Those who suffer do so because they have turned their back on Gursikhi. When one turns away from such positivity, they can only expect negativity...This is all Vahiguru's Perfect Hukam. Forgiveness goes a long way but as Sahib Dasmesh Pita's Sant SIPAHI, we are not expected to constantly forgive those who opress the weak or disrespect Guru Sahib or the Gursikhs. I believe Guru Sahib wishes us to recourse to the law as all of our exemplary Gursikhs have done so in the past (including Bhai Fauja Singh, Baba Jarnail Singh) and then if that does not allow righteousness to prevail (i.e. corrupt indian/mughal government, blind Muslims/Muslim leaders, corrupt Gurdvara Committees) and these 'legally accepted' avenues fail to produce Righteous results, we are instructed to 'draw the sword' i.e. we are sanctioned by the Most Legally Authoritative Vahiguru to use physical force if neccesary. It is clear how the situation we have discussed concerning the Nishan Sahibs can thus be faced. Bhai Fauja Singh and others protected a Gurdvara which was being openly attacked by 'Hindu' thugs. There is no reason why, when the situation arises that we cannot do the same. The most important point is to keep details, records of conversations etc. so that if the law doesn't achieve the neccesary results, 'the earthly law' are aware that Gursikhs will nt take such open insults lying down. This approach keeps us within Guru Sahib's Hukam and can be applied to all situations. When Guru Sahib has given us such a righteous, well-defined process which encompasses Saintly Forbearance and Soldierly Strength, we do not need to reduce ourselves to hateful actions...or hateful words. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Muslim-Sikh Clash in Hyderabad

concerned · 12 Dec 2003

the england muslims attack sikhs in the uk through physical violence it has changed from "uneducated monaiy gangs" to openly attacking sikhs in dastars and roop deliberatly in the last few years through planned provocation. paki panthers and chalvey boys the HUT and khalifa crew are just few of the hundreds of other groups spanning across. I have witnessed scenes that are made to look like accident such as HUT members carrying their religious stool equipment which involves wooden sheets walk behind a singh then walk 1 metre away and pretend to turn innocently which results in the sheet swinging then hit the wooden sheet on the singhs dastar then just walk off, or unceromoniously say " oh i didnt see you mate sorry bye". etc etc the list goes on and its getting worse especially for sikhs in dastars in british muslim areas. These are not one offs they hang about in large groups of 20s 30s spanning from early teens to men in their late twenties. when a little 15 year old dastarvala was badly beaten in a racist attack by muslims in their religious clothes and left in a hospital , the gurdwara made a fuss and spoke to the muslim clergy ONLY bcos the beaten up boys dad was in the committee at the gurdwara. Loadss of other attcks occur but get no publicity the committee aint interested the victims dont have the links to highlight what happens to them and no one wants to know cos facing these british muslims in big numbers is a challenge! instead excuses are made we are not into sikhi bla bla, but its sikhs now in roop that they are targetting anyway. if they go round burning nishan sahibs we cant say its ok lets have a word and try to educate them. Its not about always about ignorance, if they hate you , they hate you , you can bend ovr backwards but your not one of them. burning that is something in itself asking for it. thres no excuse.