Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

CBC News · 02 Mar 2006

Supreme Court overturns ban on Sikh dagger Last Updated Thu, 02 Mar 2006 10:21:39 EST CBC News A Montreal Sikh boy can now wear his ceremonial dagger in the classroom after Canada's top court overturned a ban on the kirpan. In its 8-0 judgment, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled on Thursday that a total ban infringes guarantees of religious freedom under the Charter of Rights. Gurbaj Singh The case stems from a November 2001 incident at Ste-Catherine-Laboure school in LaSalle. Gurbaj Singh Multani's cloth-wrapped dagger came loose from around his waist and fell to the ground at the elementary school. The school's principal ordered the 12-year-old to remove the kirpan, but Gurbaj left school rather than remove the 10-centimetre long dagger, which he says is a key component of his faith. He eventually switched to another school and his family took the matter to court. The court threw out arguments from lawyers for the school board that had originally implemented the ban, saying there is no suggestion the kirpan is a weapon of violence or that Gurbaj intended to use it as one. "Lastly, the argument that the wearing of kirpans should be prohibited because the kirpan is a symbol of violence and because it sends the message that using force is necessary to assert rights and resolve conflict is not only contradicted by the evidence regarding the symbolic nature of the kirpan, but is also disrespectful to believers in the Sikh religion and does not take into account Canadian values based on multiculturalism," wrote the judges. Lower court decision upheld The case has been winding its way through the legal system for four years. In May 2002, the Quebec Superior Court ruled Gurbaj could wear his kirpan to school if it was wrapped in heavy cloth inside a wooden case, underneath his clothing. FROM MAY 17, 2002: Sikh boy wins kirpan case in Quebec Quebec's government at the time, the Parti Québécois, appealed the decision. In 2004, the Quebec Court of Appeal struck down the decision, ruling the kirpan had the makings of a weapon and was dangerous. Although banning the weapon was a hindrance to freedom of religion, the court ruled that community safety comes first. FROM CBC ARCHIVES: Religion in the Classroom McGill University professor Jack Jedwab said Canadians are looking for guidance in determining where to draw the line when it comes to issues of religious freedom. "People are looking for some leadership on this point and hopefully they'll get some from the Supreme Court," he said. Manjeet Singh, the Sikh chaplain at McGill and Concordia universities, who also assisted Gurbaj Singh's legal team, said baptized Sikhs believed the kirpan is a symbol of courage, freedom and responsibility to stand up for their rights. "It is one of the five articles of faith that every baptized Sikh is supposed to have on their person, all the time," said Manjeet Singh. Craig Buchanan, the vice-president of English affairs with for the Quebec Federation of Parents Committee, said the issue is divisive. "It's a tricky situation. If you start to try to limit the religious freedoms, then what's that going to do to other religious freedoms?" said Buchanan. "And if you seek to compromise safety in schools, how far is that going to go as far as safety in the schools?"

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

... · 02 Mar 2006

An 8-0 decision is a CLEAR voice in favour of the kirpan. You very rarely get unanimous decisions like this from the Supreme Court. This is a very great day for Sikhs in Canada. This decision is in the face of of the majority of the Canadian public who are irrationally hostile to the kirpan yet see no problems with other much more harmful objects being around.

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

Jagjit Singh · 02 Mar 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, this is good news for Gursikhs in Canada. Thank Guru ji, it was all his kirpa. Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

paapi · 02 Mar 2006

Waheguru Judge da bhala kare bhai....lol

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

Kulbir Singh · 02 Mar 2006

Lakh Lakh Shukar hai Guru Kalgidhar jee daa. Kulbir Singh

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

Kulbir Singh · 02 Mar 2006

Dagger ban overturned But officials may impose restrictions, top court rules Mar. 2, 2006. 10:14 AM CANADIAN PRESS OTTAWA - A Montreal school board went too far in imposing a blanket ban on the wearing of Sikh ceremonial daggers by students, says the Supreme Court of Canada. In an 8-0 judgment, the court overturned a decision that barred teenager Gurbaj Singh Multani from wearing the dagger, known as a kirpan, to class. The court said a total ban can’t pass muster under the Charter of Rights, because the policy infringes on guarantees of religious freedom. But the court left room for some restrictions to be imposed on the carrying of kirpans in the name of public safety. A number of schools in British Columbia, Alberta and Ontario have long permitted the wearing of kirpans subject to certain conditions. The rules often include a size limit on the dagger, or a requirement to keep it sheathed and to wear it under clothing and out of sight. Orthodox Sikhs, who make up about 10 per cent of the estimated 250,000 Sikhs in Canada, are required by their religion to wear the kirpan at all times. The Montreal dispute arose in 2001 when Gurbaj Singh, the aged 12, first wore his kirpan to school. Officials tried at first to work out a compromise that would allow him to continue wearing the religious emblem, but with some conditions for the sake of safety. The governing council of the Margueriite-Bourgeoys school board overruled that approach and imposed a total ban. During a Supreme Court hearing last April, Julius Grey, the lawyer for the Multani family, noted there has never been a school assault committed with a kirpan anywhere in Canada. That amounts to “overwhelming empirical evidence that the kirpan is not a dangerous weapon,” said Grey. Francois Aquin, the lawyer for the Montreal board, retorted that there have never been any school assaults with kitchen knives either. “That doesn’t mean we will allow students to carry kitchen knives in school.” The case made its way to the high court after conflicting decisions at the provincial level. A Quebec Superior Court judge ruled in Gurbaj Singh’s favour in 2002, saying he could carry the kirpan under certain conditions — for example, if he kept it sewn into a cloth envelope to be worn beneath his clothing. Quebec Court of Appeal reversed that decision in 2004, ruling that the school board had the power to impose a total ban. Other precedents in other provinces have produced a patchwork of policies — not only in schools but in other public institutions. For example, Sikh MPs can wear kirpans in the House of Commons and visitors can wear them in the public galleries. It’s all right to wear kirpans in the Supreme Court of Canada, but trial judges in some provinces have banned them from their courtrooms. Most airlines once allowed passengers to wear kirpans with blades no longer than 10 centimetres. In the security crackdown that followed the 9-11 terrorist attacks, however, Transport Canada decreed a country-wide ban. The judgment of the high court is confined to school situations and does not apply to other areas.

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

Amar · 02 Mar 2006

WJKK WJKF We may have won the court of law, now we have to win the court of public opinion: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20060302.wkirpan0302/CommentStory/National/home WJKK WJKF

Re: Supreme Court of Canada Rules for Kirpan

Gurtej Singh · 02 Mar 2006

Satnam sri Waheguru. Finally, Sikhs are able to carry that which is their birth right! GSingh