Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kabirji Vs Loyi by Sant Baba Kirtaniya

Kabirji Vs Loyi by Sant Baba Kirtaniya

Gurpreet Sumra · 09 Mar 2006

Does SGGS contains story of Kabir ji fighting with his wife? Kirtaniya, Sant Baba starts as follows: Bhagat Kabir ji was a very generous person. He used to donate a lot and it was famous that nobody was turned down from his door step. One day Kabir ji had a bet with his wife: His wife said that women has 400 different characters and I will prove this to you one day.(Balihar jaiye on those who tell this story from the stages on Gurdwara in the hazoori of SGGS ji, they should first know what SGGS says about women, these famous so called kirtaniya are insulting women right in front of SGGS and Sangat after listening to these self made stories says WAAAH kya katha kari hai!!!!!!!) One day some people came to Kabir jis house, his wife said that Kabir has gone mad and whoever comes, Kabir ji ties them with rope and beats them with a sota. They turned back, by that time kabir ji came back and his wife said that they were asking for rope and sota, then kabir ji took rope and sota from his backyard and went after them.When these people saw Kabir coming with rope and sota they started running. Saadh sangat ji aakho satnam shri waheguru!!!!!!!!!! What kind of illogical, senseless without any kind of base this story is that insults women by saying that women has 400 characters. Let us see what Guru Saab says about women: “bhand jamiye bhand nimiye bhand mangan vyah Bhandoh howe dosti bhandoh chale raah Bhand mua bhand bhaliye bhand howe bandhan So kyon manda aakhiye jit jame rajan Bhandoh hi bhand upje, bhande baaj na koi Nanak bhande bahara eko sacha soyi”(SGGS,p473) Within a woman, the man is conceived and from a woman he is born. With a woman he is betrothed and married. With the woman man contracts friendship and with a woman the system of propagation keep on going. When one’s wife dies, another lady is sought for. It is through a woman that man makes his family. Why call her bad, from whom are born the king. From a woman, a woman is born, Without a woman, there, can be none. Nanak, only the one True Lord, is without a woman. I have heard this story many times and used to wonder, where do they get this story as it is totally against Gurmat. Then I came to know that these so called stories are in a book called “bhagat maal”, in which Hinduism has been fed in whatsoever way possible to show bhagats as followers of Brahmin philosophy and thought, same is done with bhagat dhanna ji and so on. Same applies to Taksali, Sant Samaj, who opposes the right of Sewa of women in Darbar Sahib. When someone asks them why not? They say puratan maryada. What is puratan Maryada? “dhor shudar nari, yeh sab tadan ke adhikari” this puratan maryada is Brahminic maryada, not Guru Saab’s Maryada. Jathedar Vedanti also don’t pass any hukamnama on this issue, which has been enshrined in our SGGS. Then Kabirji got angry with his wife that why you turned them and so kabir ji’s wife rus gayi and turned her back in the bedroom towards kabirji( now they have brought Guru’s bani into the bedroom of Kabirji, aakho satnam shri waheguru!!!!) Then kabir ji recited this shabad “hau vari mukh pher pyare Karwat de mau ko kahe ko mare”(SGGS,p484) “kehat kabir suno ri loyi “ab tumri partit na hoyi”(SGGS,p484) Then Kirtaniya baba says that Kabir ji is trying to make up with his wife “Loyi” and asking that why you have done karwat away from me. Shame on them, at the same time they are insulting Kabir ji who is talking about God. On one hand we say that Gurbani is Universal Truth. What is Universal Truth? Which contains only truth, that talks only about akal purakh, waheguru and ways to get him in a truthful manner, which can be followed by any person irrespective of his religion,color,caste,creed as it does not contain any useless stories but only praises lord. It does not contain stories of adam-eve, how earth was made,noah’ arc,biological warfare of ramayan. How it is Universal truth? It don’t even contains stories of our own guru’s,their personal life, their sons,daughters,WIFES, when and where they were born. It talks about only supreme lord.That’s why it is dhur ki bani or Universal truth. SGGS don’t contain stories of Guru saab, but these kirtaniya baba has made it a soap opera by inserting self made stories about bhagats and we get very happy listening to them because we have sworn that “HUM NAHI SUDHERANGE” Whole shabad is as follows “karvat bhala na karwat teri Laag gale sun benti meri Hau vari mukh pher pyaare Karwat de mau ko kahe ko mare Jaun tan cheere ang na morau Pind pare tau preet na torau Hum tum beech bhayo nahi koi Tumho su kant naar hum soi Kehat kabir suno re loyi Ab tumri partit na hoyi” (SGGS,p484) Karvat : aara(saw) there was a custom that in Kanshi there was a saw under a tree, and if somebody donates all his wealth to Brahmin and get himself sewn by that saw he gets a non stop flight to swarg/heaven.This tree was brought down by jehangir. Prof Sahib Singh: karvat : aara, karwat : peeth, na morau : main pichaan nahi hatanga, pind pare : je sarir naas bhi ho jaayega, re loyi : hey lok,hey jagat,hey moh(loyi is not the wife of kabir ji) Loyi is used by Kabir ji in lot of other places as well and is also used by Guru nanak saab for jagat. O supreme lord, look at me why are you killing me by turning your back to me.To be cut with saw is better then your turning your back on me.O lord there is no one between us you are my husband and I am your jeev istri wife.Kabir says listen O world I will never trust you, you are the one who take me away from my husband lord. Now I cant find any romantic story of husband and wife in this, Dhan kirtaniye te Dhan assi who listen to these stories and say Satnam shri waheguru. Here in Dixie Gurdwara I went to a very famous Kirtaniya after his katha kirtan listening to whom Sangat badi nihal ho rahi c, I asked him about the story he was telling(not this story)he said “eh gallan baith ke karan waliyaaa ne” and ran away. We should stand up and question them because this way they are not only distorting Gurbani but rewriting history as they want. (Thanks to Veer Bhupinder Singh who explained this shabad) [%sig%]

Re: Kabirji Vs Loyi by Sant Baba Kirtaniya

boring · 09 Mar 2006

after skipping thru another one of ur "great" articles that oh so many people reply to i have a question for u a) in ur name why do u not have the name singh or kaur? b) in ur email "sumrajatt" ..so ur caste based?

Re: Kabirji Vs Loyi by Sant Baba Kirtaniya

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Mar 2006

Author: boring Date: 03-09-06 12:58 after skipping thru another one of ur "great" articles that oh so many people reply to i have a question for u a) in ur name why do u not have the name singh or kaur? b) in ur email "sumrajatt" ..so ur caste based? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> not my intention to jump in..but.... I dont see any Singh/Kaur in your "boring" name either. ??? Jarnail singh

Re: Kabirji Vs Loyi by Sant Baba Kirtaniya

Daas Soora · 10 Mar 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh boring, don't show bitterness towards Guru Jee's sikhs or for a matter of fact anyone. If you can't say anything nice don't say anything at all. The comment you made doesn't relate to the original article at all. The rehit states not to argue with Sikhs. You should be ashamed of yourself, as someone is trying to preach Sikhi but your trying to blow them off. This is really wrong. Daas Soora VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFAteh

Re: Kabirji Vs Loyi by Sant Baba Kirtaniya

Bazzer · 10 Mar 2006

Gurpreet Sumra – we are oh so knowledgably aren’t we? A little knowledge is a dangerous thing ! For your information there are bad women, just as there are bad men, this is a fact. But you are so politically correct it is sad to see. Guru maharaj Ji praises women and men many times as they also chastise them both, just as they chastise the Hindu and Musallman. In Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s bani the characters and wiles of women and men are documented. So what if this story tells of a quarrel between Kabir Sahib Ji and Mai Loyi? Does that make all women bad? You seem very quick to point out other peoples weaknesses, which is what most of your posts about, what about the ‘Singh’ in your name where is that? What about ‘samrajatt’ what is that all about if not about jaat-paat? Try looking into yourself before your criticise others. As for my name “Bazzer” (before Arshi Punga Guy sticks his oar in) I am using an alias unlike Gurpreet sumra which is your proper name BUT you choose to miss out the SINGH. Admin : please let this through as I am just responding to what has already been said.