Help needed in deciding what to Research
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 09 Mar 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa,
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Daas has applied to study MPhil in Sikh Studies and has to submit a research proposal outlining what topic daas wishes to research next year. I can choose any topic of my choice.
I would appreciate if anyone could suggest some possible ideas of a topic or areas to consider researching in Sikhi (something which is achievable to be completed in the time span). The dissertation will be 20,000 words.
I would appreciate if the Sangat could share their ideas
Thanks.
Daas,
Manvir Singh Khalsa
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
no jatha singh · 09 Mar 2006
how successful the sikhs have been as a group - all over the world, in comparison to others.
- this would be morale-boosting esp. for youngsters and a good response to sardar ji bashers & media etc. a better strategy than bombing cinemas or getting 300 people to "boycott" a film that they weren't gonna watch anyway.
(the suggested research has already been looked at by goray)
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 10 Mar 2006
Thanks. Great ideas.
Other ideas from the Sangat would also be greatly appreciated.
Thanks again.
daas,
Manvir Singh Khalsa
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 10 Mar 2006
Dear Veerji Manvir Singh ji,
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaaheguroo jee kee fathehhh !!!!!
I am currently in Delhi and will be returning to Canada on Sunday.
On your blog you have posted various details of your trip to India. You posted about langar maryada being violated and halvaee's being used. You also posted about "money, money, money" focus of kar seva babas. Similarly, there was a new article on www.SikhNN.com about beadbi of pavitar asthhan Gurdwara Sahib Sri Nankana Sahib, prakash asthhan of Satguru Sri Guru Nanak Dev SAhib ji maharaj.
Recently on this phorum I posted about "jyot" at "Shaheedaan Gurdwara" antam sanskaar asthhan Shaheed Baba Deep Singh jee near Gurdwara Ramsar Sahib in Amritsar. They have a flame lit which people come and put there hands in for some type of powers.
Similarly, there are gurdwaras like this all over India, where our 200 or 300 year old building have been (and still are being) torn down, and big marble buildings are being built over top of them. All of our historic buildings are being torn down and expensive, kind of ugly marble buildings are being put in their place. Granted, some kar seva babas do it with lots of sharda, but there is serious mismanagement happening.
Lastly, you know yourself what the SGPC has done to the Rehit Maryada - the recent controversy. In addition to that, the SGPC is mismanaging a lot more. All of the guest houses for foreigners at Harimandir Sahib (Guru Arjan Dev Nivas in particular) are operated by sevadaars who are more bureaucratic than the Indian government.
Taking all of these things into account I humbly request you to FIND SOMEBODY who is doing an MA or PhD in Sikh Religion and make a EMERGENCY REQUEST to them to do their thesis / research proposal about "Mismanagement of Gurdwaras and Sikh heritage in India and Pakistan"
I know you are doing Philosophy so this topic may not be relevant but I'm sure you can see that it is extremely important.
I have a lot of pictures and can give details of my experiences in India of corruption and mismanagement of gurdwaras.
Also I can put the researcher in touch with employees of SGPC and other people in Amritsar who could speak with the researcher on the topic.
It is a very important issue and if somebody were to publish a research paper on this topic, they could present it at conferences around the world. Furthermore, they could also present to Joginder Singh Vedanti and Ranjit Singh and other "leaders."
We could also send it to all Sikh newspapers in the world and TV stations.
I know I haven't really helped with your question but I know you have connections with a lot of the sangat in UK - so could you please find out about this and e-mail me back at [address removed]
stay in chardee kalaa jee
Thank you
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
Gyani Sahib · 10 Mar 2006
Just out of humour
"Gyan Jarnail Singh Arshi and his Amol Bachan....LOL"
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
Jagjit Singh · 10 Mar 2006
waheguru ji kakhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, considering modern phenomenoms, it may be worth writing something like;
The Gurmat Concept of Shabad Guru - its purpose, aims, and why Guru ji made a Shabad Guru, rather than an endless lineage of human Gurus. Plus attacks on Shabad Guru by modern cults and Guru-doms, such as Narinder Grewal, radhaswomis, narankaris, etc. What makes these groups flourish? Are they finding or exploiting gaps between Gurmat ideology and its practice by modern sikhs? How can sikh youth address this?
waheguru ji kakhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 11 Mar 2006
Thanks for the ideas. The Concept of Shabad Guru looks good and seems useful for the Panth as well.
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
finalevolution.blogspot.com · 13 Mar 2006
I didn't read all the posts. How about looking at the Whitewashing of Sikh history? eg. Bhai Mardana Ji's home torn down to make a gurdwara extension. Unique Gurdwaras covered up in white marble.
Re: Help needed in deciding what to Research
Manvir Singh Khalsa · 13 Mar 2006
I prefer to focus on Gurbani and Sikh philosophy/theology/concepts rather than anthropology and sociology.
But thanks for the ideas.