< Interesting Article >
Jagroop Singh · 08 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Please read the pasted article below and see what you think... I'm interested in anyone's opinions/historical corrections concerning the 'Baba Banda Bahadur bit' and all those other interesting 'facts'. To use the past as a 'lesson' supporting the jpournalist's view of the present is a favourite tactic and a powerful technique. I think deconstruction/analysis of media reports/articles is a very important issue for Sikhs; it is the media who are in a position to assail Sikh ideological/political movements of the present and future - especially the Indian Media. It is more important than ever to spot misinformation and other subtle techniques that journalists have at their disposal so that we are in a position to react in a definitive way. Thanks. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20031207/edit.htm#2 Ample opportunity to work for a just civil order by S.S. Dhanoa CHANDIGARH has recently played host to two conclaves of Sikh intellectuals. One related to "Khalistan", its past and present future. The other was about Guru Granth Saheb and the Panth. Indirectly, even the second was concerned about the loss of political power by the Khalsa. Punjab has been witnessing turmoils on such issues ever since the British conquered Punjab defeating the Khalsa armies in 1849. It was hoped that this ghost would be laid to rest but the preoccupation of the Sikh intelligentsia with seminars of the type held at Chandigarh and abroad is a danger signal for long-term peace in Punjab. This preoccupation of the Sikhs has to be understood for resolving this problem and ensuring peace in Punjab. We can trace the origin of this fixation to the refrain "Raj Kareja Khalsa" which seems to have come into vogue among the Sikhs immediately after the demise of Guru Gobind Singh. The Khalsa was designed to be a brotherhood of equals and gurmukhs who had transcended their self identity called "haumai" in Gurbani. Their objective was to establish righteousness and to fight for it if any one tried to thwart their endeavour. The Khalsa joined Banda Bahadur in chastising the Sirhind Governor but quickly disassociated from him when he tried to hijack the Khalsa to establish a kingdom. Mata Sundariji, the widow of Guru Gobind Singh who was recognised as worthy of respect of the Khalsa after Guru Gobind Singh, gave a clear directive to the Khalsa not to associate with Banda Bahadur. To the question on Guru Gobind Singh's assurance on "Raj Karega Khalsa", she said that the Khalsa's objective was to fight for "dharma" and if they fight for the cause of "dharma" the Guru's blessings would be with them and the "Raj" would come their way. Those who cherished immediate prospect of the "Raj" went with Banda Bahadur and the "Tat Khalsa" for the time being converted their swords into plough-shares so far as fighting against the Mughal administration was concerned. Those who joined Banda Bahadur perished and those who remained steadfast in the "Tat Khalsa" triumphed and succeeded in vanquishing everyone who came in their way. Apparently, the number of the Sikhs following Banda Bahadur was fairly large as after his martyrdom, they staked a claim on the offerings at the time of the Sikhs' annual get-together at Amritsar. Both sides almost came to a fight which got averted through the elders who persuaded both sides to accept a verdict that came from dropping chits in the holy Sarovar. On one chit "Fateh darshan" was written while on the other "Waheguru ji ki fateh" was mentioned. Since the latter came up first, it was settled that "Tat Khalsa" was the real Khalsa. The Bandai challenge receded into the background because the situation in Punjab changed in favour of the "Tat Khalsa" as their Rakhi system ushered in peace and safety to those who opted for it in those troubled times when Punjab got trampled under the feet of Nadir Shah and later Ahmed Shah Abdali with consequent breakdown of the Mughal administration. The Khalsa triumphed over all odds. They were succeeded by Maharaja Ranjit Singh. The first lapse of the Khalsa can be traced to this period when they allowed individual Sikhs to rule in the name of the Khalsa. So long as a Sikh in appearance was ruling, the Khalsa was not very much perturbed. The Khalsa was partially awakened by the internecine killings indulged in by the successors of Maharaja Ranjit Singh and we had the soldiers constituting panchayats in the name of the Khalsa. They killed Jawahar Singh, the then Prime Minister, and the brother of the Maharani for his role in the killing of sons of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. It was this period about which Shah Mohammed wrote "Shah Muhammada phiran sardar lukde bhut mandali hoi tiyar miyan". The phase ended with the annexation of Punjab by the British with Sikh soldiery joining the British Army, soon to prove their worth for the British in 1957. The Sikh aristocracy heaved a sigh of relief on being saved from the rebels going berserk in the name of the Khalsa. Their loyalty was further ensured by the British by confirming and protecting their privileges. The British knew that it was a Muslim population basically that Ranjit Singh ruled. He had banned cow slaughter. The British lifted the ban to earn the Muslims' goodwill. This was like adding insult to the injury after the loss of empire and political power by the Khalsa. This phase produced the Namdhari movement among the Sikhs. The movement gave some headache to the British but it got crushed when some Namdhari followers of Baba Ram Singh killed some Muslim butchers for having slaughtered cows. No one seems to have studied or understood as to where the real strength of the Khalsa was which could be tapped to deal with the new situation created by the British rule over India. Meanwhile, the valour of the Sikh soldiers recruited after being administered Amrit by the British Indian Army, made the Sikhs a community held in favour by the British so much so that some scholars hold the view that the Khalsa identity was a creation of the British. We can take the modern period for the Khalsa to have started with the Gurdwara Reform Movement (GRM) starting around 1920. The SGPC and the SAD trace their origin directly to this movement. The model adopted for both was the non-violent struggle model unfolded by Mahatma Gandhi. The GRM was the biggest mass movement among the Sikhs after the turmoil of the period of Banda Bahadur. Yet the leaders of the movement decided to take their lessons from Gandhiji. The Nabha agitation gave misgivings for which Gandhi required an assurance that the aim of the Akalis was not to establish the Khalsa Raj. Could Gandhi see through the designs of the Sikh leaders? The Akali leaders who claimed that they were the Khalsa Panth could not work out a plausible response to the situation created by the British announcement to transfer power to Indians in 1947. Master Tara Singh, the Sikhs' supreme leader, admits in his autobiography that when he was sent to prison in free India, he read about Israel. He says with some remorse that if he had known about it earlier, he would have handled negotiations with the British differently. The "deep structure" in the community perhaps forced Akali leaders to adopt different postures depending on the circumstances prevailing in Punjab. Among the Sikh leaders, when Master Tara Singh was perceived to have reached a stalemate, the backing shifted to Sant Fateh Singh. When despite getting Punjabi Suba the goal was still perceived to be beyond them, the community was successfully swayed to try the insane and dangerous line propounded by Bhindranwale and those who went under the name of Khadkus. Sardar Beant Singh and K.P.S. Gill have to be thanked for saving Punjab from the brink of an abyss. All the intellectuals who saw in the killers and murderers as "avant-garde" youth or the heroes enforcing Khalsa values, have trooped back to the homeland, professing to fight for their cause in a democratic and peaceful manner. The present Akali leaders survived by attending "Bhog" ceremonies of the militants. The Khadkus compelled the then Akal Takht Jathedar to make an official declaration in favour of Khalistan. Kaonke, the Jathedar, after ardas at the Akal Takhat, resorted to putting slips of papers in the sacred pool to seek the Guru's guidance. The slip that had "No Khalistan" written on it, came out first, from the pool but unlike the Bandai Sikhs the Khadkus went ahead with their declaration. It is blasphemous for a Sikh thereafter to talk about Khalistan. One wishes that Vedantiji takes note of it and issues a "hukumnama" banning Sikhs from supporting Khalistan. All those who yearn for "Raj Karega Khalsa" should know that in the modern world which has become a global village, the rule of one group over any other group is not feasible against its wishes. If the Khalistanis think that Khalistan is something desirable, they should focus on the Hindus comprising about half of the population of the Khalistan in whatever manner its boundaries may be fixed. They should understand that the Khalsa Raj of the 18th century got established as a divine dispensation due to the prevailing political turmoil and the steadfastness of the Khalsa who fought for the weak and the deprived. There is no turmoil in Punjab now but there is ample opportunity for the Khalsa to do something concrete for the weak and the deprived and to establish a just civil order where Dharma prevails. The Khalsa would thus come to be recognised as leaders and the Khalsa Raj's boundaries could extend to the whole world. The writer is a former Chief Secretary of Punjab