Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ear hair and Hearing Aid

Ear hair and Hearing Aid

J Singh · 16 Mar 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji kee Fathe! Sangat jee, I have problem that hopefully you will be able to help me with. My grandfather is an Amritdhari Sikh who just recently got fitted for a hearing aid. The problem is, however, that the hearing aid will not stay in his ear due to excessive ear hair. It keeps getting pushed out and wont fit comfortably. What can be done in this situation? The audiologist recommends that the hair be plucked. Does the Sangat have any suggestions?

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

Suggestion · 16 Mar 2006

It's up to your Grandfather. At the end of the day he needs to weigh out whether he wants his kes or hearing. The balls in his court.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2006

Cutting or plucking hair is not an option. I see that your grandfather is in a difficult position but he has to make a choice i.e. whether to keep Sikhi or use this hearing aid. It’s hard to believe that there is no other way to use this hearing aid. Try using some other kind of hearing aid and see if that works. In any case, as stated before, cutting or plucking of hair is not acceptable in Gurmat. Kulbir Singh

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

... · 16 Mar 2006

for an amritdhari, removal of the hair isn't an option. If you let the audiologist know this, s/he will give you whatever options are available. They can usually think of alternatives.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

LK · 16 Mar 2006

If there are no optinos, then your grand father will have to eigh the alternatives, and make his own mind up.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

. · 16 Mar 2006

there must be another way to keep the hearing aid in, if there isnt then it could be kept there with an elastic band or something? sorry if it sounds stupid but its better than cutting ur kes off.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

.... · 16 Mar 2006

i agree that cutting Kes is not an option but what about for an operation/surgery for someone with cancer? should they just accept death?

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

Kaur!!! · 16 Mar 2006

That is a very hard question to answer really, Bhai taru singh would rather be scalped alive than have even one hair be removed! i think you'd have to take a hukamnama out and accept the will of god!

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

LK · 16 Mar 2006

It's completly up to the person itself. Especially if it's a life and death situation. If the person thinks: *Well If i cut it now, I can do bhagtee later on, and "compensate" for the pap done, and do more bhagti since I'm going to be alive* Or they can think *The Mahan Shaheeds of the past did not waver, all though their lives were threatened - how can I cut my hair?* The Individual him/her self determines the sitution, after consulting Panj (who probably will ask you to make your own decision, but i don't know, may'be not) WE have been blessed with a brain to use.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

ks · 16 Mar 2006

sometimes I really wonder... the Guru gave us the gift of kes and we cherish for two reasons, primarily: discipline and identity. when one has to remove some minor hair (shaving chest for heart surgery, ear hair (come on, ear hair!) for a hearing aid) for a medical reason, these do not violate the concepts of discipline or identity. Hell, even non minor hair as in shaving head for brain surgery is not violating these, as it is medically necessary. To simply state that Sikhi is more important than life is contradictory to Sikhi itself---the life that god has given us is sacred! We must do our best to keep our bodies healthy, otherwise why would the Guru ask us to be sipahis? those who bring up bhai taru singh know what he didn't give his hair because of any commonplace reason, he was defending his faith. These are completely different situations. as a final thought, there are those who will believe that a hearing aid is not medically necessary. Ask those old people who cannot participate in life any longer how necessary it is. As humans we must communicate, and as Sikhs we aren't silent monks.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

........ · 16 Mar 2006

"As humans we must communicate, and as Sikhs we aren't silent monks." There was once a rishi known as kak rishi who would not appreciate this advice, he had his neck cut out for talking too much.

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

Jeewan Singh · 16 Mar 2006

My grandfather can barely hear anything, when we talk to him we basically have to yell. We all wanted to get him an hearing aid, but he said he didn't need it. Thinking about it, it makes sense, he does simran and paath all day, all the time, if he got his hearing back, it would just become another distraction. Maybe we should accept that things happen for the best...just a suggestion...

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

ks · 16 Mar 2006

for those who think hearing isn't necessary for sikhs: how would one listen to the Guru's kirten?

Re: Ear hair and Hearing Aid

Jasmin · 17 Mar 2006

So if your born deaf, you can't be a Sikh?