Re: question about Bibek
Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2006
-----------
I would humbly like to ask as a sarblo bibeki one only intendes to eat from a bibeki, regardless if they are sarbloi or not but aslong as they are bibeki.
So if a person who is a bibeki except they eat from the gurdwara where even say like non-amrithdharis have made the langar, should a sarblo bibeki eat from that person.
-------------
No.
As far as I know and as far as I have seen at Tapoban Sahib and Singhs in India, one should eat from tyar bar tyar Gursikh only.
Kulbir Singh
Re: question about Bibek
Kulbir Singh · 17 Mar 2006
Great post "P Walla".
Regarding Bhai Jeevan Singh jee, he was a pakka sarblohi and Bibeki during the times of Bhai Sahib and even up to eighties. Later on perhaps due to old age he could not keep up with Sarbloh Bibek. He is a great supporter of Sarbloh and I personally have witnessed him inspiring Gursikhs to keep this rehit.
Kulbir Singh
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeet singh · 17 Mar 2006
excellent post pwalla
Re: question about Bibek
Dhan Dhan Bibek · 17 Mar 2006
VaahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VaahegurooJeeKeeFateh
Pavai mukat na horthai koi, puchhoh Bibekia jae.
Ive recently took amrit on the 1st of January at Bibeksar sahib and i cant explain how amazing it was. As soon as i got out amrit sanchar there where fireworks going of and i had the best feeling ever.
Singhs all i would like to say is just try being Bibek for just one week and you will realise.
Keep being Nimrata.
VaahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VaahegurooJeeKeeFateh
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeet singh · 18 Mar 2006
Author: d
Date: 03-17-06 12:10
"but daas does belive that one should not talk to a mona "
how on earth will other people be inspired, if they are not told about sikhi.
sikhs are suposed to try and spread there wings, spread their faith and knowledge wherever they go...thats the beauty of sikhi.is it not?
"'Should there be a balance? Is a balance a comprimise?'
This is what we have been doing for the last decade...COMPIRMISING!! LOOK WHERE SIKHI IS NOW!! There should be no balance...one should follow mahrajs hukam to all limits!!"
but mahraj's hukam is to find a balance.you dont rush into everything all at once, mahraj says take ur time, do it sehaje sehaje-har ka bilovana bilovo mere bhaayee, otherwise u will loose the essence. step by step..
bhai sahib u seem to have a very nostalgic view...you look alot into the past.that can be very good as we have alot of gursikhs to be inspired by.but we have to stop looking in the past and focus on the present.things and situations are different.i always wonder whether if gurusahib was present in the human form...( gurugranthsahib ji is living and some argue he is "human"), but i mean..as in the form of a human...whether mahraj would keep bibek.from what i know of gurbani(which is very little), i would always come to the answer "no".
but then others would argue that as we are not at gurusahibs stage, every little thing affects us.
but if we were doing naam baanee constantly, impurity would not touch us...imagine doings simran continuosly, how could any sort of impurity ever come near us?
i rate those people who make their own food and actualy use bibek as an exscuse to just jap naam more whilst their making the food.i think this is closer to true bibek than anything else.
anyway back to the point,
now i was having a discussion with a gursikh after reading this thread and i asked one simple question...i said "bhaisahib what if soemone who was really bad, really false who ate meat made ur degh would u eat it?"
and the gursikh replied " guruji says in gurbani that those who do nindhiaa and chuglee eat human meat" and this really made me think. we have to look at ourselves. we cannot do nindheea and chugli and then refuse to eat from someone else.
obivously this gursikh was trying to point this out(doesnt mean he's eat from someone who ate meat)
secondly i said "what if the person who made degh was really false and a paapi"
and the gursikh replied "i dont know anyone who's worse than i am?"
made me think of the tuk- mandaa jaane aap ko avar bhalaa sansar.
everyone has weaknesses.
everyone tries to folows the rehat they think will ge them closer to Vahegurooo...and if that includes bibek, then so be it..but lets not hurt anyone/break anyones heart in the process...coz then, i believe we've lost from the very begining.w'eve fallen before weve even taken the first step.
i dnt know.thats what i think
forgive any mistakes
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. inspire people?? y does evry one think now a days tht we shud go out and preach to moneh and try and convert em
the only way we can inspire someone is through our actions, we should try our best to build up our sikhi as best we can and then moneh will follow.
jnm mrx duhhU mih nwhI jn praupkwrI Awey ]
junum murun dhuhehoo mehi naahee jun puroupukaaree aaeae
Those generous, humble beings are above both birth and death.
jIA dwnu dy BgqI lwiein hir isau lYin imlwey ]2]
jeea dhaan dhae bhuguthee laaein har sio lain milaaeae
They give the gift of the soul, and practice devotional worship; they inspire others to meet the Lord. ||2||
it specifically says in gurbani to avoid sangat of manmukhs
kbIr mwrI mrau kusMg kI kyly inkit ju byir ]
kubeer maaree muro kusung kee kaelae nikatt j baer
Kabeer, I have been ruined and destroyed by bad company, like the banana plant near the thorn bush.
auh JUlY auh cIrIAY swkq sMgu n hyir ]88]
ouh jhoolai ouh cheereeai saakuth sung n haer
The thorn bush waves in the wind, and pierces the banana plant; see this, and do not associate with the faithless cynics. ||88||
"spread their faith and knowledge wherever they go"
u make it sound like sikhi is a religion of preaching to evryone about their religion, jus like these christian missionaries do
maharaaj's hukam is to find a balance?? where does it say tht??
i think u have change the meanings of sehaje for ur own cause. sehaje doesnt mean, take evrything real slow, eg. if ur gambling or something and u find out gambling is rong, u dont say alrite ill slolwy decrease the amount of money i spend. u stop str8 away. u try ur best to follow all of guru jis hukams. sehaje in tht tuk means like do naam wtih concentration, slowly yeh, so u can conentrate. doesnt mean progress in sikhi slowly. some ppl go from not wakin up at amrit vela to pukka 2am amrit vela just like tht.
i dunno wa nostaligic means so i wont comment on tht
of couse guru ji would be bibek, wat a silly assumption. just as guru gobind singh ji prepare amrit in a sarbloh bata emphasizing sarbloh bibek. guru nanak dev ji refused to eat from the saakat maalik bhago.
guru gobind singh jis hukam is to eat from khalsa.
but then u cud say guru ji hunted does tht mean we can
the only way we could do bani and naam all the time is by following rehit, if we eat impure things how are we going to become pure? without rehit we cannot do bani and simran all the time. we do naam and bani when making food for a reason.
"i rate those people who make their own food and actualy use bibek as an exscuse to just jap naam more whilst their making the food.i think this is closer to true bibek than anything else."
use bibek as an excuse???? dnt get tht. ur sposed to do simran/bani when mkaing food thts the whole idea of food bibek.
""bhaisahib what if soemone who was really bad, really false who ate meat made ur degh would u eat it?""
im not sure but i think u mite b thinking of the tuk "koorh bol murdaar khahi"
yes, and.... we should eaten from liars then either.
"we cannot do nindheea and chugli and then refuse to eat from someone else."
we try our best to follow each of gurus hukams, that doesnt mean tht if disobey one, we disobey another one. it doesnt cancel out. we should try even harder to follw guru ji if we do somet rong, not relax our rehit.
" "i dont know anyone who's worse than i am?""
thts great, i wish i could be tht humble. but although u shud think ur the lowest of the low tht doesnt mean u dont differentionate between good and bad sangat, gursikhs an manmukhs. gurbani says dont associate with manmukhs, "bhagauti bhagvant bhagat ka rang. tiaagai dust ka sang
u dont have to tihnk ur higher than them by not associating with them , or not eating from them. ur just following guru jis hukam, trying to keep ur naam flowing
"everyone has weaknesses.
everyone tries to folows the rehat they think will ge them closer to Vahegurooo...and if that includes bibek, then so be it..but lets not hurt anyone/break anyones heart in the process...coz then, i believe we've lost from the very begining.w'eve fallen before weve even taken the first step."
of course we should try our best not to hurt peoples feelings, i agree, but in some cases this may be unavoidable. like what if ma freind really wanted me to come to pizza hut for his birthday party and eat pizza with them? id have to say no even though it mite hurt his feelings.
AMimRqu Kwxw AMimRqu pYnxw nwnk nwmu vfweI hoie ]1]
anmrith khaanaa anmrith painunaa naanuk naam vuddaaee hoe
The Ambrosial Amrit is his food, and the Ambrosial Amrit is his clothes; O Nanak, through the Naam, the Name of the Lord, greatness is obtained. ||1||
[%sig%]
Re: question about Bibek
Rashpal Singh · 18 Mar 2006
Great post Amarjeet Singh!
[%sig%]
Re: question about Bibek
bibek daa... · 18 Mar 2006
h,
to answer your question. if it is not possible for you to keep bibek. try your best to be as close as possible to bibek.
your guru would not let you starve. also from the countless sakis (and not all of them are just stories) guru sahib took food from people who prepared it with sharda.
do your best. that is all you can do. if it is not possible at this time, it is not possible at this time.
Re: question about Bibek
tarrandeepkaur · 19 Mar 2006
to d, amarjeetsingh, boongwala, akjukute, (and mayb pwala)
piayre jio!!
if u search older topics ther are soo many threads about bibek, and the posts are soo long, people are wastin ther tym.if u agree with bibek gr8, gurji has dun massive kirpa on u 2 folow this rehit. if u dnt blieve in food bibek then thats fine too. but i dnt think ne of u lot r gona change ur minds. so dnt waste tym debatin!!im sure u can use ur tym much more effectively, this paapi is a massive hypacrite, but i jus wana do benti tht u lot stop debatin!! sorry if this moorakh has made ne mistakes.
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh!!!
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeetsingh · 19 Mar 2006
"d"
i thought u were rong and everyone else was right, if so what was the need for another post
about ur whole theory of not hurting peoples feelings. i agree, we shouldnt hurt peoples feelings, tht doesnt mean to say, lets drop rehit to make people happy.
please answer me this, guru sahib has said
kbIr mwrI mrau kusMg kI kyly inkit ju byir ]
kubeer maaree muro kusung kee kaelae nikatt j baer
Kabeer, I have been ruined and destroyed by bad company, like the banana plant near the thorn bush.
auh JUlY auh cIrIAY swkq sMgu n hyir ]88]
ouh jhoolai ouh cheereeai saakuth sung n haer
The thorn bush waves in the wind, and pierces the banana plant; see this, and do not associate with the faithless cynics. ||88||
so what do we do if someone really wants to go out with us to some cinema or something and they smoke and drink all the tym. do we go with them to avoid hurting their feelings? or do we follow guru sahibs hukam? sounds simple to me.
and why not reply to boongawalas and mine previous posts, cant b bothered, or just cant full stop?
why would guru sahib dont associate with the faithless cynics if you can eat from them?
if evry1 is same why does guru sahib say dont associate with manmukhs
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeetsingh · 19 Mar 2006
[gurbani]
hmrI mudR nwmu hir suAwmI ird AMqir dust dustwrI ]
[/gurbani]
I appear to chant the Lord's Name, but within my heart, I am the most wicked of the wicked.
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeetsingh · 19 Mar 2006
Author: d
Date: 03-18-06 00:25
hanji you're all totally right and im totally wrong
Vaheguroooo
.......................................................................................................................
[gurbani]hmrY jIie horu muiK horu hoq hY hm krmhIx kUiVAwrI ]1][/gurbani]
humurai jeee hor mukh hor hoth hai hum kurumeheen koorriaaree
I have one thing in my mind, and another thing on my lips; I am such a poor, unfortunate liar! ||1||
Re: question about Bibek
??????????? · 19 Mar 2006
I think ur all being a bit harsh on 'd' as this person only stated that how are we meant to let sikhi blossom by just keeping it 2 ourseleves and 'p walla' saying that we shudn't talk 2 moneh is wrong! evreyone has 2 start from sumwhere and if we dont preach sikhi then its slowly goin to decrease!
i think thats the problem with youth 2day they think they r soo much better than other ppl... dont talk 2 moneh theyre below us... u shudn't hav this thinkin... and if u didnt hav this thinkin then im sorry p walla but personally this is the way it sounded!
if all the guru jis didnt preach sikhi, we wuldn;t be ehre 2day! i dont no if anyone has heard the sakhi about where guru nanak dev ji and mardana went to a village with all bad people and he told these ppl 2 not leave the village, and then he went to another village with good people and he told these ppl 2 spread. mardana questioned guru ji about why he told the good people to go and the bad stay and guru ji said that it was because the good people can go and do parchaar of sikhi... this is what we need! we need to teach the ppl that dont no much bout sikhi about how great it is!
ive been informed that many gurdwaras hav been havin discussion classes and loads of moneh etc attend and it has changed some of their lives! i think this is a great thing and it shud carry on... if u know alot about sikhi, dont be selfish and keep it 2 urselves, show people how breautiful our religion is!
everyone has 2 start sumwhere, even bhai rama singh got influenced from somewhere and if the gursikhs who inspired bhai sahib weren't willing to talk 2 him cos he was a mona, then this wuld be very bad. Many kids r born into amritdharee families nowadays because their parents were mona but were influenced by gursikhs... if the gursikhs didnt do this and 'kept away from them' then who knows how many amritdharee families there wuld be....
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeet singh · 20 Mar 2006
??????? ji
u r mistaken
from what i deduct from ur post u think its all about bringin ppl in2 sikhi, u 4get only guru ji can bring ppl into sikhi. hu r we to preach???
the only way we can get ppl into sikhi, is by making our sikhi as strong as possible and others will be inspired.
if u honestly think tht by spending time with the mona he/she will get into sikhi by ur sangat, then fine, and only talk bout sikhi and tht, but u cant go round trying to preach to evry mona, keep company of gursikhs plaese
"..." pwala didnt say bibek was the only hukam, he was just sayin its sad tht not many ppl follow this partricular hukam
LK, food made by a mona is not in accordance with bibek
avidya, u poor soul, u seem to be very confused
akjute, brilliant post mate
Re: question about Bibek
Jasmer Singh · 20 Mar 2006
... "p walla! thats very offensive. bibek isnt the only hukam, or did you forget about the rest?"
..., i think you are confused about what bibek actually is, what rest are you talking about ? bibek is not just eating food prepared by amritharis and in sarbloh bateh, bibek is following every hukam of guru ji.
eating from amritharis in sarbloh bateh is just one of the many hukams given by guru ji.
Re: question about Bibek
??????????? · 21 Mar 2006
I am sorry 'p walla' i think i did sound a bit harsh in the last post i wrote... didnt mean 2 aim it at u but forgive me! i was jus tryin 2 make the point that dont let ego creep in by sayin e shudn't talk 2 moneh... i agree with you points but i jus think that u r not puttin them across right. i think when u get 2 a certain stage, after doin naam simran, seva and ur strong in ur sikhi then ull automatically want 2 keep bibek... i dont think we shud be forcing people 2 keep it but if u look back at all the gursikhs of our time, they all kept bibek. its gud 2 do as much as u can in sikhi and if u can keep bibek thats amazing and keep it up, if u cant, build ur sikhi up until u can. i think u start keepin bibek when u get a certain stage, not any old person can keep it, they need wahegurus grace and by doin ardaas u can ask 4 this... i agree with 'Jasmer singh' as he says bibek is not just sarbloh bibek or 2 do with food... its guru jis strict rehat, i think there was a bit of confusion there... but i dont think that bibek (2 do with food) is hukam, i think that it comes naturally when u feel it is right 2 start keepin bibek.... sangat jee, do ardaas and u will get 2 that stage!
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!
Re: question about Bibek
amarjeet singh · 21 Mar 2006
when it comes naturally??????
what does that mean
what a great idea
lets all lie in bed and only wake up at amrit vela when it comes naturally. lets all stick to basic 5 bani nitnem until it comes naturally for us to do more
no, we have to put the effort in to follow every one of guru jis hukams.
to follow rehit s much as we can. we dont jus sit bak and hope it floats to us miraculously.
food bibek is a hukam we should try and follow just like all of guru jis hukams, with effort.
not keeping sangat of manmukhs is not haumai, its following gurbani
bhagauti bhagvant bhagat ka rang
sagal tiagai dust ka sang
thanks