Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
amarjeetsingh · 19 Mar 2006
rehraas is from so dar tera keha
to tera kita jato nahi
Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Mar 2006
and when these same people go and PRINT their own versions...it confuses others even more..
we have the SANT SAMAAJ to thank for these varied versions..they have different maryadas on everything..as different as their sants
buy the AKAL TAKHAT version from SGPC - although judging by the way things are developing in Amrtisar these days...sgpc will be issuing sant versions...and sants will issue sgpc versions !!
Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
??????????? · 19 Mar 2006
'amarjeet singh'-- how do u no this?
i was told it was from dukh daru sukh rog bhaye to rakhe rakhan har aap... etc
theres different ways, but i think do whatever ur panj piyare say but also MORE! the more gurbani u read... the more it helps u!
Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 19 Mar 2006
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefathehhhh !!!!!!!!!
gurmukh pyare jee,
i have interviewed a few older gursikhs, and they are not part of any jatha. they have no affiliation with damdami taksal or akhand kirtani jatha. they just follow mostly the "sikh rehit maryada" published by sgpc (the original one from the 1930's, not the new ILLEGALLY AND IMMORALLY revised one of 2006).
those gursikhs told me that when they were young, they had old gutkas, and in those old gutkas they used to always notice sampuran chaupai sahib and sampuran rehiras sahib.
they had no bias or any reason to say this - i just asked them and they said matter-of-factly that, "oh yes, that's true those gutkas had the full chaupai sahib." in fact they do the short version because that's how they were raised, they are in their 60's and so when they were young, it was the 1940's and 50's.
The old gutkas they had were old at that time, so maybe they were 20 - 30 years old? In any case they were from before the time that SGPC rehit maryada was printed.
This was one convincing thing for me, that perhaps sampuran rehiras sahib and sampuran chaupai sahib is a puratan tradition.
Then, a few weeks ago when I was in Punjab, we went to Anandpur Sahib. And near Anandpur Sahib there is a gurdwara sahib on the banks of the Sutlej River. At this gurdwara, which is NOT managed by damdami taksal, there is the history of this gurdwara posted there.
The history states that Guru Gobind Singh Sahib ji stayed here, when it was the home of a Raja of this area, and he stayed for many months.
Here, on the banks of the Sutlej, Guru ji first recied Chaupai Sahib.
I have pictures of this gurdwara and the board that describes the history. And the proof of this is Guru ji's own bani from DAsam Granth Sahib:
sambath sathray sahas bhanijai
ard sahas phun theen kahijai
It was the year 1700 plus half a century and 3 more (1753 Bikrami)
bhaadrav sudhee asthmee ravivaaraa
theer sathudrav granthh sudaaraa
It was the month of Bhaado, the 8th Day, Ravivaar (Sunday)
On the banks of the Sathudrav (Sutlej) this writing was completed
At this gurdwara, which I reiterate is not managed by any jathebandi,
they sell small gutkas of chaupai sahib.
These small gutkas have the sampuran chaupai sahib with "kripa kari ham par jag mata" and arill and chaupai and swaiye and dohra.
This was another convincing thing for me that perhaps Guru Sahib ji did ucharan chaupai sahib in the full sampuran roop.
Furthermore, although i could be wrong I do not think that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh jee or any other brahmgyani gurmukh has openly declared that the shortened SGPC version of chaupai sahib is the actual version written by Guru Gobind Singh ji.
However, many brahmgyani gurmukhs HAVE openly declared that the shortened SGPC version it is NOT the actual version and sampuran chaupai sahib is the actual writing.
I have also been told that puratan hand-written copies of Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Ji's Panj Granthi, which has Rehiras Sahib, has the sampuran Rehiras Sahib and not the shortened SGPC version.
In addition, some people say that they believe that the shortened SGPC version of rehiras sahib is the proper version that Guru Gobind Singh Sahib instructed us to read, but they say that they don't disagree with people who read the sampuran Rehiras SAhib because it is good to read more bani.
However, gurmukh jee, is it not a serious offense to alter bani ? Would it not be a serious offense for a gursikh to "add" things to certain banis ? If Rehiras Sahib was from 'So Dar' upto 'Thera Kita Jato Nahi' then why would a gursikh use his mental power to add banis?
Think about it for yourself - do you seriously think that gurmukh brahmgyanis like Sant Baba Sundar Singh ji, Sant Gyani Gurbachan Singh ji, Sant Gyani Kartar Singh ji, Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji, Sant Baba Harnaam Singh ji RampurKhera Wale, Sant Baba Thakur Singh ji, and others would alter Guru ji's Chaupai SAhib or Guru ji's Rehiras Sahib and add banis from other places in Dasam Granth and say they are "part" of Chaupai Sahib.
They would not do this. They did not change it, this is the way Guru ji has written Chaupai Sahib.
That would be like telling people that "Basant Kee Vaar" is a part of "Anand Sahib" ... it is not, and no Gursikh would dare try to take different banis from Guru Granth Sahib and put it under one name.
Therefore I think Sampuran Chaupai Sahib is the same way that Guru ji wrote it and it has continued on, unchanged since the time that Guru ji did ucharan of it at that place I mentioned above where there is now a gurdwara sahib near Anandpur Sahib.
Lastly, and MOST OBVIOUSLY, if you read Sri Dasam Granth Sahib, you will see that the Kabyo Baach Bayntee Chaupai that is written in Sri Dasam Granth Sahib does not end at "kharag kayth mai saran thuhaaree." It includes Kirpa Kari ham par jag matha, Arill, and chaupai.
Check for yourself at www.sridasam.org
I humbly request Guru ji and sadhsangat to forgive my mistakes and forgive any comments against Gurmat.
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefathehhhh !!!!!!!!!
Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 19 Mar 2006
... jee,
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!!
gurmukh pyare jee this is good vichar and i hope other sangat reading this understands that this is vichaar, not argument
i am dust of your feet and feel respect and love for you as a gursikh so please respond openly to my post and share your wisdom so that with guru ji's kirpa guru ji will do mercy on me and help me practice sikhi.
the original SO DAR is in guru granth sahib ji, that is not the original REHIRAS.
before guru gobind singh ji's hukam for nitnem banis the gursikhs used to read So Dar, however the Khalsa reads Rehiras Sahib which includes So Dar.
If you believe the original Rehiras is in Guru GRanth SAhib, then why read Chaupai Sahib, Anand Sahib, Mundavani and Salok Mahal 5 ? Those are not after So Dar in Guru Granth Sahib.
The reality is So Dar is a bani which is part of Rehiras Sahib.
There are other banis which appear differently in Guru Granth Sahib ji and are read different as "Bani" such as Shabad Hazare and Asa Di Var.
So i dont think that is a valid argument.
The next you were saying veerji what is the relevance of "kripa karee ham par jag maataa" because it mentions a "granth"
when you read Rehiras Sahib you say "thhaal vich thin vastu paeio" -- but you haven't done Akhand Paath, you have just done Rehiras Sahib, so which thhaal are you talking about? Rehiras Sahib or Guru GRanth Sahib?
obviously Guru GRanth Sahib.
what kind of logic is this that you can't mention an external granth in a single bani ?
"granth kara puran subh raataa" refers to the granth which Chaupai SAhib is a part of. Just because this line refers to the whole granth but you are only reading Chaupai Sahib - that is not a reason to exclude this line.
"kripa karee ham par jag maata" is a part of chaupai sahib. if you read sri dasam granth sahib you will see that it is part of chaupai sahib.
would you cut "salok" out of jap ji sahib ?
who are we to judge which is relevant and which isn't?
guru ji made it part of chaupai sahib. guru ji did NOT make "kripa karee ham par jag maata" part of another swaiya or chaupai or chhand or salok.
guru ji made it continuous as a pauri of chaupai sahib.
"kharag kayt mai saran thihari" is one pauri
"kripa kari ham par jag maataa" is the next pauri
there is no indication that you should "stop" reading here.
would you stop anand sahib after 38 pauris ?
With all due respect to Giani Mohan Singh ji, he is not Guru Gobind Singh ji. Nor is he Jathedar of damdami taksal. nor is the jathedar of akal takhat sahib.
sampuran chaupai sahib is not what "somebody" makes, or the way somebody prints it in their gutka, it is the ACTUAL full form of the gurbani, in whichever form guru ji did its uchaaran.
The gurdwara near Anandpur Sahib where Guru Gobind Singh ji first did ucharan of Chaupai Sahib - they sell gutkas of chaupai sahib in which it is sampuran, i.e. it has "kripa kari ham par jag mata" and arill and chaupai and swaiye and dohra... and that gurdwara is NOT managed by ddt, akj, or any samparda or jatha.. it is a PANTHIC gurdwara and it distributes sampuran rehiras as Guru Gobind singh ji wrote it..
and puratan handwritten panj granthis by Bhai Mani Singh as well as puratan gutkas have sampuran rehiras sahib
can you please explain all of the above and how it is even remotely still possible for the shortened SGPC version of rehiras sahib to be the full rehiras sahib?
please forgive me for my mistakes. please forgive me for any comments against gurmat. i look forward to learning from your reply.
i am a total moorakh with no kamaee so these are just "small time" arguments that i make from my extremely limited understanding. please guru ji forgive my shortcomings.
stay in chardeekalaa jee
vaaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhhhh !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
Gurpreet Sumra · 20 Mar 2006
"thaal vich tin vastu paiyo sat santokh vicharo"(SGGS,1429)
Prof Sahib Singh : thaal :Hirde vich
In your heart you should maintain three things Truth,contentment,and thoughts of aatmak jiwan
"thaal vich te vastu paiyo ,har bhojhan amrit saar"(SGGS,645)
thaale : hirde vich
same meaning
difference :first one is Guru Arjan saab and other is Guru Amardas saab.
Re: RehRas An Evening Bani
Anand Sahib · 21 Mar 2006
Interesting, what about full Anand Sahib? Should we read this with Sampuran Rehras too? I know several Gursikhs that do this.
Can someone clearly give a reason for the sort Anand Sahib? Why has it be shortened? Why do we read 6 puari's not 40?
[%sig%]