New type of Akhand Paath
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Mar 2006
in the Ajit of Sunday 19th i read a news item that the Nanaksar babeh are doing a new type of Akhand Paath that is "TUK SAMPAT"...
They already have "Sampat paath" whereby they read some bani/shabad after completing a certain section of paath ( thus INTERRUPTING the smooth flow of GURBANI as written By GURU ARJUN JI SAHIB)
Now they seem to have invented this new "TUK SAMPAT AKHAND PAATH"..as per my understanding they must be INTERRUPTING every TUK of Gurbani with another Shabad which is read again and again...
What will these babaeh do next ?
Jarnail Singh
Re: New type of Akhand Paath
karmjeet singh · 19 Mar 2006
gyani ji calm down . u dunt have to worry about anything
there is nothing wrong with doing these sampat paths . ( the only reason tha t might be wrong is doing it for selfish motives such as making money or publicity )
Baba Nand Singh ji did these sampat paths in the past
Baba Ishar singh ji did these sampat paths .
If these two brahmgyanis did these sampat paths then who are we paapi manukhs to say that sampat paths are wrong .
by brahmgyani i dont mean a joke . i seriously mean it . they were poorant sants mahpurakhs about whom guru ji talks about in gurbani , they were not like the modern day sants .
sampath path maryada is very kathin , and they should only be done under the supervision of mahapurakhs .
i dunt know who these nanaksar babe are . because these days there a lot of babes who call them nanaksariye just for increasing their fame .
The only nanaksariye babe that i had trust were
Baba Nand Singh ji
Baba Ishar singhji
Baba Kundan Singh ji
Sant Gurdev ji
gyani ji , these sampat paths sound unusual to u becus u never heard of them beforre . they have been since the time of guru gobind singh ji . the marayda of sampat paths is described in mukat marg granth by guru gobinf singh ji .
wjkk wjkf
Re: New type of Akhand Paath
Gurpreet Sumra · 19 Mar 2006
I have heard of some dasam granth attributed to the name of Guru Gobind Singh ji but this mukat marg ,I am hearing for the first time.
Regarding Akhand paaths and sampat paaths, even Akhand paaths were not prevalent at the time of Guru Gobind Singhji. These Akhand paaths started when Sikhs were living in Jungles and more during misl periods. During Guru Saabs time bani was not only recited to just finish it off, so the point of Akhand paaths dont arise.
These sant babas have attributed akhand paaths even to Guru Tegh Bahadur saab for putar prapti.
Re: New type of Akhand Paath
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Mar 2006
what information do you have on " TUK SAMPAT AKHAND PAATH".... an ordinary AP takes 48 hours to compelte with five good readers...How LONG will an TSAP take with each TUK being SAMPATTED ??to me that sounds like a gross insult of Gurbani..sampatting every TUK- like "interrupting" someone after every sentence !!
Any one having info about this please share.
and Gurpreet Singh is absolutely right...no akhand paaths were done during Guru jis time.....GURU JI was there in person doing discourses and kirtan katha vichaar...paaths only began when gurgadee passed to GURU GRANTH JI....becasue then THAT became the ONLY way to have a public "Conversation" with Guru ji
Re: New type of Akhand Paath
Khalistan_zindabaad · 20 Mar 2006
causing conflict as always it seems . . . grow up
Re: New type of Akhand Paath
gurdev mata · 20 Mar 2006
why do we always look at other people and there actions , to judge them?
it is not a new akhand paath this sampat akhand paath has been going on for around 30 years in england! it is a matter of understanding of what is behind these sampat paath why do we do these? sampat paath is for the jagat, world peace , after all we are living in kal jug?
how can you break the flow of bani when GURU IS THE BANI?
BANI GURU GURU HAI BANI VICH BANI AMRIT SARAY
the main point that the bani is say is naam japo naam japo! each indivisual person naam japo not look wat hes doing! he should not be doin that!
if somebody is doing good congratulate them not bring them down thet is just pure evil!
forgive me if i have said wrong
Re: New type of Akhand Paath
gurdev pita · 21 Mar 2006
dont worry dassandass jio...all is always forgiven at the lotus feet of gurudev....
gurudev even forgivers those who interrupt His Bani with other Bani...