Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

praatun singh · 20 Mar 2006

WJKK WJKF I was wondering what tapoban's views are on Sri Raag Mahala and why tapoban does not beleive in it? And is this proof that it doesnt exist all start from Bhai Sahib Bhai Randeer Singh? or did other singhs bring this up in the past? WJKK WJKF

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 20 Mar 2006

I'm not sure what to make of this post. Sri Raag Mahalla: Mahalla waht? Pehla? Teeja? Panjvaan? All the Panth believes in Sri Raag and all the Mahallas in it. If you mean ragmala, then you're quite correct, AKJ does not believe in it and many Singhs including Kavi Santokh Singh, Giani Gian Singh, Tara Singh Narotam and others did not believe in it.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Mar 2006

This is not a "spelling mistake"... I have come across many youngsters who think Sri Raag Mahalla is "raagmala" ??? One even questioned me..asking i have sat through your First Raol..and I heard you CLEARLY READING SRI RAAG MAHALLA..... for nearly 2 hours..and yet you always declare that YOU dont beleive in Sri Raag mahalla as Gurbani ??? ????????????????? surprised..you bet Jarnail Singh....

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Dhur ki bani aaeee... · 21 Mar 2006

Yes, Bhai Sahib didn't believe in Raag Mala, but IMHO he didnt make an issue of it in the panth because he did have utmost respect for the Akal Takht. Nowdays I see people condemning or promoting Raag mala because 'thier' jathebandi has that view. I wonder how many people have actually read and understood the 1429 angs that come before Raagmala. Bhai Sahib had great khoj of bani and a lot of kamai? I wonder how many of us have that. I guess what i'm trying to say is, don't just belive what the next person says, go and do your research, do khoj of bani, and with wahegurus kirpa you will yourself know what the answer is. peeoo dhaadhae kaa khol ddit(h)aa khajaanaa || When I opened it up and gazed upon the treasures of my father and grandfather, thaa maerai man bhaeiaa nidhhaanaa ||1|| then my mind became very happy. ||1|| [%sig%]

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

sk · 21 Mar 2006

sadh sangat jeo It seems these Singhs are in illusion and wish to delete Sri Raag Mahala. Are they more informative than Guru ji, who included in SGGS Bhul chuk maaf karna satnam kaur

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Rajinder Pal Singh · 21 Mar 2006

Raagmala is not gurbani. It has been well proved long long ago. Any body who has any doubt about it, can read the recently written book by S. Mahinder Singh Josh. The name of book is 'Khast Raag Kin Gaye'.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

?? · 21 Mar 2006

SK with what authority u r saying that Guru Ji included Raagmala in SGGS ji.Please give authentic references.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

sk (Satnam Kaur) · 21 Mar 2006

Dear Rajinder Pal Singh jeo, Wat Khoj and wat not. Everybody wants to be in the limelight by speaking on the wrong points. That is a negative energy and will not add to the development of the conscious. Hope you believe in Guru Gobind Singh ji, It was included by Him while he could manage to create 2nd edition of Guru Granth Sahib through Bhai Mani Singh plus the Gurbani of Guru Teg Bahadur. Simply talking hearsey does not look nice. Already so many Jathebandis in Sikhism, at least, do not create conflict in Guru Granth Sahib ji. Meat Khana, aur Sharab Peenee Band Karo, ta Gal samajh ayegi. Bhul chuk maaf karna, please. satname kaur

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

<> · 21 Mar 2006

SK, Rather than shooting off self righteous posts, do some research before you type. You are ignorant on this issue. Guru Gobind Singh did NOT include it in Sri Guru Granth Sahib. If it was that simple, are we all crazy to hold this belief? If there were proof that Guru Sahib had it in the saroop, would we dare question his decision? This composition was added later like many others were before. The others like Ratanamala, Jit Dar Lakh Muhamada, etc. were taken out but this one was not for some reason. This is a very old controversy in the Panth and was addressed by old historians like Kavi Santokh Singh and Giani Gian Singh who wrote that Ragmala is not bani. Please take the time to get information before typing off replies.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

no way its baani · 21 Mar 2006

benji sk u need 2 do more research on raag maalaa issue, its been added by a muslim poet who had relation with a prostitue............

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

sk (Satnam Kaur) · 22 Mar 2006

Pyari sadh sangat jeo, Of course, Kavi Santokh Singh and Giani Gyan Singh, were original to many of the points, and what khoj they could do, which is possible now, in the technological world and when many thousands have come out with research by doing Ph.D. and M.Phil. by visiting various places, by reading various granths, by readings various sikh scriptures and by discussing with learned people, besides their own personal experiences and happenings in the life and the society. And we are simply struck of that, this was done by Mr so and so and this was written by Mr so and so, and we cannot go ahead, with new ideas. This is educated world, earlier it was a different world. People have no much accessibility and there was no printing press and there was no mode of communication and conveyance to reach at fast speed to different places of interest to find and work out on the research side. If you people are bent upon - Mai Na Manoo - then Bhai sahib jeo, it is upto you. who will bother to read and accept and practize your wordings in the life. People are not going to stop to their destination and you go on speaking your old version, but to yourself only. Daily, new research,information are coming up, in various magazines and newspapers and discussions are coming up at the TV on various topics. If life with us in Canada is fast, it is much faster in India, just visit and roam for 3 to 4 months and collect the information on the issues, just by sitting in Brampton, it is not going to serve the purpose. In India, more TV channels are there, which impart more knowledge to the development of conscious, than in our Canada. We have money here, that too upto our extent, whereas in India, people are doing much Naam, Simran and Sewa. Try to broad the outlook. Otherwise, it is upto you. I would appreciate, if you will kindly write back your age and years of research you have done on the subject and what is your qualifications in Gurmat. Bhul chuk maaf karna, please. Satnam kaur

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

typoo · 22 Mar 2006

THIS WHOLE THREAD IS WRONG!!!!!!!! the original poster is talking about SRI RAAG. SRI RAAG is the FIRST raag in Maharaj. the issue that many Sikhs have question with is the composition of 'raagmala', which is the last composition in Maharaj's print. Mr praatun singh, i hope that clarifies it. if you have issue with the debate on raagmala, then view the many threads that already exist on the matter. stop kicking up old dust, ESPECIALLY when you've gone and picked totally different baani. as for the rest of us, we took the bait and went off on a wild one with raagmala again!! hahaha. even though the original poster doesn't know what he's talking about.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

just me · 22 Mar 2006

I wish these pro-raagmalias would realise it is called raagmala, not raag mahala! Then I wish they stop trying to make the Gurus look thick by pushing raagmala! The Gurus spent so much time compiling the Guru Granth Sahib. They had so much knowledge on raags, that they even invented new raags. You would think that when they wrote a raagmala, that they would get the right raags in there? But no, the raagmala has the wrong raags in it. So were our Gurus thick? I do not think so... it is the blind worship people who think that Guru ji would create a numbering system so that no kaatchie bani could be added. But then leave whole empty pages for brahmins to write Ratanmala, Jit Dar Lakh Muhamada, etc. Then Guru ji would come back and write a wrong raagmala. Then the whole Panth, including taksal, sant samaj reject Ratanmala, Jit Dar Lakh Muhamada! How stupid to these pro-raagmalias want to Guru to look??

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Khalistan_zindabaad · 22 Mar 2006

it seems some of these singhs think they have greater jeevans than shaheed baba deep singh ji . sant jarnail singh ji etc who believed in raagmala. . . pathetic as always. . .

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

lol · 22 Mar 2006

Author: Khalistan_zindabaad Date: 03-22-06 04:45 it seems some of these singhs think they have greater jeevans than shaheed baba deep singh ji . sant jarnail singh ji etc who believed in raagmala. . . pathetic as always. . . no i didnt say i had a better jeevan then sant jarnail singh i just think he was wrong on raagmala... i hate to break it to you but sant jarnail singh wasnt god...and there are plenty of people with a better jeevan than you who dont believe raagmala...

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

wondering · 22 Mar 2006

where is the proof that baba deep singh believed in raagmala?

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

<> · 22 Mar 2006

sk, You want to know my "qualifications" in Gurmat? What does that mean? Would you like to know which khands I have access to or something? As for new researches, which researches have you come across that have shown you that ragmala is bani? I have seen a number of puratan saroops and my research leads me to believe that it is clearly not. But please do tell me which new researches you have come across in this new fast age that have lead you to believe in ragmala.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

moorukh · 22 Mar 2006

the posts in this thread totally sum up the state of our panth - people slagging each other off; pulling at each others' legs when trying to climb the ladder of spirituality. if we spent less time doing khoj (theory) and more time doing Sangat and Naam (practical) each one of us will be living in a higher state of conciousness because Naam would provide the intuition required to live the life of a panth that Guru Maharaj wants us to. Sikhi is ALL (110%) practical not at all theoretical - that is why it is unique and that is why it is the most difficult path. Bhul Chuk Maaf. Unjaan Moorukh

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

j walla!! · 22 Mar 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh!! sangat ji stop wasting your time.naam japo We dont no when our last breath is going to end. gurooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! forgive this unjaan papi waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh!!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

JSGyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2006

Author: moorukh Date: 03-22-06 08:19 the posts in this thread totally sum up the state of our panth - people slagging each other off; pulling at each others' legs when trying to climb the ladder of spirituality. if we spent less time doing khoj (theory)<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< then you are missing out on GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's HUKM... Jo PRABH ko mil Boch Hai..KHOJ SHABAD meh lai.. KHOJ is VITAL to SIKHI/GURMATT...No BLIND FAITH here... Jarnail singh

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

mehak · 23 Mar 2006

You are correct, Bha ji, JS Gyani Arshi. My life, my khoj, my individual level of link with Guru. Opinions create conflicts only. Mehak

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

nobody · 23 Mar 2006

gurfateh can anyone tell me in which granth or book....kavi santokh singh has written tat raag maala is not baani?...another thing i have a steek of raagmala....which the arth done by baba sunder singh jee Bhinranwale.......another thing.....wasnt raagmala included in the Kartarpur Birh?....im juz wondering.....im still new in this....pls do guide me jeeo......bhullan chukan di maafi....gurfateh

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

?? · 23 Mar 2006

what baba sunder singh jee Bhindranwale or sant gurbachan singh ji bhindranwale said is not gospel truth. Read sant gurbachan singh ji bhindranwale's Sikh rehatmaryada most of it contradicts the Akal Thakat's Sikh rehatmaryada. He also wrote that Guru Nanak Ji recited Jap Ji at Batala just before his own wedding so that he can have lavan around Jap Ji and not the fire.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

nobody · 23 Mar 2006

gurfateh.......aha ok.....but then veerji my question was in which granth did kavi santokh singh tat raag mala not bani?....

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

murakh · 27 Mar 2006

Question for AKJ veers. Guru Granth Sahib Beer in Tapoban and your homes....Does it contain raagmaala.....I know you don't believe it to be Bani....If it is a regular Beer as sanctioned by SGPC....what do you do....Stop at just before Raagmaala for samapati.... Second Question if it is the Complete beer with 1430 angs....Do you mattha teko to something that is not Bani... WJKK WJKF Main Murakh Neech Ajaan....

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 27 Mar 2006

The saroop at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib is a standard laridaar saroop printed by the SGPC and does have ragmala. At the bhog of Akhand Path Sahib, the bhog is done at Mundavani followed by "tera kita jato nahi". As for your second question, when we matha tekk, we bow to the bani. The Saroop also contains the name of the publisher (SGPC) and the name of the printing press. It also contains the Tatkarra (table of contents). So, by the standard you set, we all bow to things we don't consider bani, belief in ragmala aside.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

soorma · 27 Mar 2006

guru gobind singh ji wrote the dasam granth with 1 page less than the guru granth sahib ji so if the dasam granth has 1429 pages in it then the guru granth sahib must include ragmala!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

murakh · 27 Mar 2006

Fair enough...Has AKJ tried having saroops printed without raagmaala as it is their absolute belief that raagmaala is not bani and reading raagmaala is sacrilegious and bipran ki reet...have a 'uncontaminated' version printed. What is the Akal Takht Maryada or directive towards issue of Raagmaala. WJKK WJKF Main Murakh Neech Ajaan....

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 27 Mar 2006

Soorma, Your argument is totally off. Guru Gobind Singh didn't compile Dasam Granth. It was Bhai Mani Singh after 1708. Also, 1430 angs of Guru Granth Sahib is a modern convention that is used by printing presses. Puratan saroops don't have a set number of angs. At Guru Gobind Singh jee's time, Guru Granth Sahib did not have 1430 angs. Murakh, Akhand Kirtani Jatha respects the Akal Takhat Sahib directive that no saroops should be printed without Ragmala. In the interest of Panthic solidarity, and respect for Akal Takhat Sahib, no such saroops have been printed. Akal Takhat Sahib's directive on the issue of Ragmala in general is that Sikhs can decide whether to do bhog at Ragmala or Mundavani. Bhogs at Akal Takhat Sahib before used to happen at Mundavani (changed later by Jasbir Singh Rode).

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

murakh · 27 Mar 2006

Veerji "Akal Takhat Sahib's directive on the issue of Ragmala in general is that Sikhs can decide whether to do bhog at Ragmala or Mundavani" ....If above is true than is not a very brave and prinicpled stand on part of Akal Takht (actually the people in charge)...Either some thing is RIGHT or its NOT ...Its trying to appease both sides. (someone is right on this issue..??) "Bhogs at Akal Takhat Sahib before used to happen at Mundavani (changed later by Jasbir Singh Rode)." ....Didn't it happen when he was Jathedar of Akal Takht. We all know Satkar yog Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh ji had a absolute respect for supermacy of Akal Takht....If he was still with us today wouldn't he bow before Akal Takhts latest decision regarding the issue even against his personal convictions. Whenever, there are conflicts panth always looks towards Akal Takht and takes its word as final directive. Above is in the current context.... Lets see it in some common sense historical context and see if it logically makes sense that raagmaala was (or could have been) included by a Mussalman or Brahmin (even "Singhs" have multiple theories about that) and not by Kalgidhar Patshah himself. * How likely it is that someone could just insert entire raagmaala and nobody objected for almost 200 years until late 19th century(Kavi Santokh Singh...if that is true) or early 2oth century when Jatha in association with Babu Teja Singh of Bhasaur declared Ragmaala not be the Bani of Guru Granth Saheb. Later, Bhai Saheb dissassociated himself from Babu Teja Singh who became British loyalist and was excommunicated from Panth by Akal Takht. After Bhai Saheb's release from prison he tried to meet bhai saheb who declined to meet Babu Teja Singh on the grounds that he failed to obey Akal Takht. Should not supermacy of Akal Takht Saheb also apply to Jattha itself, which refuses to accept raagmaala as part of Shri Guru Granth Saheb ji. * Damdami Taksal is not just Sant Jarnail Singh, Giani Gurbachan Singh or even Giani Sunder Singh. It was started by Baba Deep Singh ji Shaheed, who took khande da amrit from Kalgidhar Patshah himself. Sant Jarnail Singhji was 14th head of Taksal. Taksal has maintained all its traditions for almost 300 years. You think Baba ji, who was doing the sewa of writing pothis before picking up the khanda, would have let anyone include raagmaala just like that. After Baba Deep Singhji's Shaheedi there is a 300 year continuity in Damdami Taksal until now. In my opinion, at the least, Taksal would not allow such thingh to happen. *Takht Hazur Saheb, Patna Saheb physically distant from each other and thousands of kilometers from all historical Gurudwaras(and Takhts) of Punjab and Damdami Taksal, many great Mahapurakhs of Sikh Panth Such as Baba Attar Singh Mastuana, Baba Nand Singh ji, Baba Isher Singh ji, Baba karam Singh ji Hoti Mardaan, all has strongly believed in Raagmaala as part of Guru Granth Sahib ji and stood up firmly when there were attemps in mid part of last century to have Raagmaala officially removed from Guru Granth Sahib ji. Additionaly during the Puratan times when means of communication were scarce, any Mussalman or Brahmin could not have the guts and logistics to do such a blatant thing, simultaneously all accross the different corners of india and get away with it. Unless we think Puratan Singhs were so gullible or stupid that they would let this happen, it just does not make sense. I have high respect for Bhai Saheb ji and his exemplary jeevan. Even though AKJ has 100% faith of in whatever he said...Is it not possible that bhai sahab ji could have been not right on this issue as was a human(though far better than most of us) as Gurbani says 'Bhulan under sabh ko abhul Guru Kartar.' Bhul chuk maaf karni ji. WJKK WJKF Main Murakh Neech Ajaan....

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 27 Mar 2006

Murakh, Jasbir Singh Rode ordered Ragmala be read at Akal Takhat (unilaterally and without any process) but even he didn't go so far as to implement this decision for the entire Panth. By your logic, the whole Panth shouldn't have been reading Ragmala before Rode decided this because it wasn't being read at Akal Takhat Sahib. I think you need to research the history of ragmala more. The ragmala issue wasn't brought up by Teja Singh Bhasaur alone. It has been a major issue in the Panth for a long time. Kavi Santokh Singh and Giani Gian Singh, both the major historians of the Panth declared it to not be bani. Giaini Gian Singh writes about a meeting of Gianis of the Panth where it was decided to remove Ragmala (along with all the other extra things added in bani like "jit dar lakh mohamadan" and Ratanmala) from saroops. Teja Singh Bhasaur was excommunicated for cutting out Bhatt Bani from Guru Granth Sahib, changing Ardas, changing Gurmantar and changing the Amrit Sannchaar ceremony. NOT for denying Ragmala. Damdami Taksal was started by Baba Deep Singh. The line is NOT unbroken up to the present however. It's a fact that Giani Sant Singh, who was a "mukhi" of Taksal had his main student Kavi Santokh Singh, who wrote AGAINST Ragmala. Jatha Bhindran is a respected Jathebandi but it does not trace its lineage back to Baba Deep Singh directly. This has been argued and proven many times in the past on this website and others. Baba Attar Singh Mastuana did NOT believe in Ragmala. He had akhand paath sahibs done without ragmala in fact. The Takhats argument (being so far apart yet same stand) is also nonsensical because the sevadars always went from Punjab. McCauliffe laments in his book that the pure Sikhs at Patna have been influenced by the messed up Punjabi Sikhs and the same is happening in Hazoor Sahib. Do you think that the rituals like Arti and putting a Tikka on the head are puraatan as well? Both happen at Hazur Sahib. Then your argument about "guts". Whoever added stuff also added Ratnamala, Jit Dar Lakh Muhamadan, Bai aatis aab khak, and siahi ki vidhh. All that extra stuff was taken out by the Panth but but poor Sikhs are still reading Ragmala which is the song of a prostitute named Kaam-Kandla. The writers of saroops were generally Udasis and Nirmallas. They thought extra stuff sounded nice and they added it to saroops. NOt just Ragmala but Ratanmala, and story of Shivnabh. The fact is, when you look at the puratan saroops, all the fake stuff comes after Mundavani and finally the last thing to come is Ragmala. If Ragmala were there from Guru Gobind Singh, it would follow Mundavani and all the fake stuff would come after. But no. It follows all the fake stuff. Ragmala is not bani. I suggest all those who think it is haven't done their research.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

S Singh · 28 Mar 2006

well said Bhai .... ji! I wish these pro-raagmalias would learn to read a book and not just listen to gallan!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

guruji's_student · 28 Mar 2006

peronsally... to me .... raag malla IS BANI!! ... as when youre doing matha teak to guru ji .. are you onli doing matha teak to only half of guru ji ? and at akand paats ... everybody reads raag malaa .. as its in guru granth sahib ji its guru ji .. Never doubt youre guru ji !! .. all hukam dhan waheguru DHAN DHAN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

sk (Satnam kaur) · 28 Mar 2006

Guru piyareo, Better go to India, and see how much work is being done, on the basis of khoj. Simply challenging me and others will not serve the purpose. ok, you go on saying, that Raag mala is not Bani. Nobody will stop reading SGGS as it is. Please do not creat conflict unwantingly. Already many opinions on different topics. Baki, tuhadee marzi hai, bha ji. Bhul chuk maaf karna. SATNAM KAUR [%sig%]

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 28 Mar 2006

No one has any arguments for ragmala just statements like "it's bani ok??!!!" I told you, when you matha tek, whether you believe in Ragmala or not, you matha tek to the name of the publisher and the tatkara. Is that bani too? Then you say we don't believe in 1/2 of Guru Granth Sahib. Last time I checked, Ragmala wasn't 1/2 Guru Granth Sahib. Just the size of one ang. Also SK, bhainjee, please tell me what khoj is happening? There is MUCH MORE Khoj showing Ragmala is NOT bani then anyone can produce showing it is.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

singh · 28 Mar 2006

Pro-Ragmalais - you say that someone who does not believe in Ragmala should not Matha Tekh to a Saroop with Ragmala...so... Would you not Matha Tekh to a Puratan Saroop which contains all Bani plus other Kachi Bani like Rattanmala?

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

darshan kaur · 28 Mar 2006

so raagmala is now half of Guru Ji? you guys get worse and worse! Live in the real world!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

singh · 28 Mar 2006

sri raagmala is BANI, any1 hu questions this therefore is questioning sri guru granth sahib ji maharaaj. if u lot hav real luv for sri guru granth sahib ji the thought should have never arisen in the first place, na da way sum people have totally degraded it, well u lot need to question n look at exactly what views u are suggesting. [%sig%]

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Singh · 28 Mar 2006

Author: singh Date: 03-28-06 10:00 sri raagmala is BANI, any1 hu questions this therefore is questioning sri guru granth sahib ji maharaaj. if u lot hav real luv for sri guru granth sahib ji the thought should have never arisen in the first place, na da way sum people have totally degraded it, well u lot need to question n look at exactly what views u are suggesting. >>>>>>>>>> What type of brainless reply is this. Have you even bothered to read what is written? If you actually read the posts, you would see that Puratan Saroops contain MANY Kachi bani compositions. Raagmala is not different. I used to be fairly convinced by anti-Raagmala arguments but the more and more I hear pro-Ragmala Veers spout the same mindless nonsense, I am more and more sure that they have no argument and just repeat "DON'T QUESTION IT BECAUSE IT IS BANI". What is so difficult to understand about the idea that before the Singh Sabha movement, there was no standardised 1430 Ang Saroop of Guru Granth Sahib. There were many different Saroops with many variations. Use your brain!!!!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

amarjeet singh · 28 Mar 2006

"and at akand paats ... everybody reads raag malaa " actually that statement is incorrect

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

OMG!! · 28 Mar 2006

omg.. i cnt belive akjers man.. seriously!! ... tryin to break away from khalsa panth thats wot theyre tying to do . Cus you all know bhai randhir singh ji when he was dying said he made a mistakee!!! waheguru RAAG MALAA IS BANI !! .. gudness sakeeeee .... talk about ppl not wanting to get into sikhi .. so many conflicts accept it guru granth sahib ji ... HUKAM !!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 28 Mar 2006

OMG!!, Do you realise that you have just perfectly summarised the pro-ragmala argument in your post? Good for you. Hysteria, irrationality, refusal to look at any fact or provide any evidence. Just parrot: "Ragmala is bani!! Hukam!!!"

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

. · 28 Mar 2006

when did bhai sahib randhir singh jee say this..can someone confirm?

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Niranjan Singh · 28 Mar 2006

>>>>Cus you all know bhai randhir singh ji when he was dying said he made a mistakee!!! Pro-Ragmala people know more about Bhai Randhir Singh's last moments than anyone in the AKJ or Bhai Sahib's family. That is amazing. Sounds like the trash Dhumma was spreading in California before he took off to Mehta. How about making up a story about Kavi Santokh Singh's or Giani Gian Singh's last moments ? I am sure that is also in the works. Perhaps those conjured up the trash about Bhai Randhir Singh can help out.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Mar 2006

and OMG has also repeated a BLATANT LIE about Bhai Sahib Bhai randhir Singh ji's last dying moments.... This LIE is told even by Brahmginai Sants just to bolster their arguments for raagmaala...cn you beat that..a brahmgiani sant and a lier all in ONE..

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

mk · 29 Mar 2006

what year and how did Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh ji pass away. I tried finding it on the net but did not find anything. Was it sudden or prolonged illness.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

just me · 29 Mar 2006

Always the same. No reasoning, no debate, just raagmala is bani Ok? Or my latest bhramgiani says so, so it is! In the last few days, that is all you have. How shameful.... Answer the questions if you can? In my last posts, I asked these questions. lets see if you can asnswer them? "I wish these pro-raagmalias would realise it is called raagmala, not raag mahala! Then I wish they would stop trying to make the Gurus look thick by pushing raagmala! The Gurus spent so much time compiling the Guru Granth Sahib. They had so much knowledge on raags, that they even invented new raags. You would think that when they wrote a raagmala, that they would get the right raags in there? But no, the raagmala has the wrong raags in it. So were our Gurus thick? I do not think so... it is the blind worship people who think that Guru ji would create a numbering system so that no kaatchie bani could be added. But then leave whole empty pages for brahmins to write Ratanmala, Jit Dar Lakh Muhamada, etc. Then Guru ji would come back and write a wrong raagmala. Then the whole Panth, including taksal, sant samaj reject Ratanmala, Jit Dar Lakh Muhamada! How stupid to these pro-raagmalias want to Guru to look??"

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

singh · 29 Mar 2006

You guys need to stop fighting, let the pro-raag mallas believe in it and the anti-raag mallas not, us callnig each other pathetic and saying the other side isn't truly gursikh isnt getting us anywhere, us arguing will truly get us no where, the truth is we will never no if guru gobind singh wrote it or not, and we will never kno what bhai sahib randder singh said when he passed away, people saying "He DID say this" and people saying "He DIDNT say this" is untrue because we will never know what he truly said, we need to stop bad mouthing each other and stop arguing over our beliefs and stand as one nation

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Niranjan Singh · 29 Mar 2006

>>>we will never kno what bhai sahib randder singh said when he passed >>>away, people saying "He DID say this" and people saying "He DIDNT >>>say this" is untrue because we will never know what he truly said singh, you seem to be giving legitimacy to habitual liars. Bhai Sahib passed away in the early 1960's not in the 1700s so we know what occured, what happened isn't some cloud of mystery to are claiming it to be. Some of those who were there during his final moment are still alive, they can attest that bhai sahib said no such things. The folks making up these fairy tales, mostly jealous taksalis, were not there at all. Who do you beleive ? Saying we just don't know is a cop out. Truth should not be trampled by koorr for some false "unity". When these people stop making up such trash then maybe this talk of unity can be seriously considered.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

!!!!! · 30 Mar 2006

sangat ji daas is doing benti, dont fight plz the truth is that both sides of the argument have wicked gursikhs on them so watever its ur choice wat u want to do

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

DasnDas* · 30 Mar 2006

vjkk, vjkf I picked this up from one of Admin jee's posts... ____________________________________________________________ The Final Moments of Bhai Sahib's Earthly Life By Bhai Trilochan Singh in Sankhaep Jeevan Bh. Sb. Randhir Singh Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org In 1960 Bhai Sahib's leg veins became weak due to having spent so much time in the dark dungeons, though the rest of his body was healthy. He only had trouble walking about. On April 13, 1961, all the Jatha came to see Bhai Sahib for Vaisakhi. On April 14th he wished good bye to everyone and sent them off. On April 16th, in the morning, he prepared to leave for Gurpuri. It was a Sunday. On Saturday night, his entire bed had moved and his body seemed very restless as though the time had arrived for that great soul to leave his body. From Amrit Vela, Veer Balbir Singh [Bh. Sb.'s son], Veer Sajan Singh, Bibi Dalaer Kaur, I and my Singhnee along with some others sat beside Bhai Sahib. At 7 am, I rose to have some words with Bhai Balbir Singh who was in the yard when Bhai Sahib raised both his arms, motioning for me to remain seated. I sat near him. He lovingly called Bibi Dalaer Kaur and he tightly clasped my right arm. I took his other hand and put it to my chest. A very strong current passed through my body. Everyone began to feel that the moment was drawing near. Everyone wanted to say some words to him or at least hear some final words but that holy soul who had spent his final days in peace, happiness and Sehaj avashtaa, also made his final moments miraculous. With the power of his breaths, he said "Vahi" and raised the swaas from his naabh kanval and with "Guru" he took his breaths to teh Gagan Mandal of Dasam Duaar. Again for the second time and then the third time he said "Vahiguru" he put his swaas in Dasam Duaar and then took his place in Gurpuri. This happened at 7.30am on April 16, 1961. His saskaar (cremation) happened at the pond between Gujjarwal and Narangwal. ___________________________________________________________ so stop spreading lies about bhai sahib, it's paap (lying in general)..so stop it vjkk ,vjkf

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Some guy · 31 Mar 2006

wjkk wjkf Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Sant Kartar Singh Ji Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji all sed it was bani and did katha on raagmala listen to brhamgyani bachan bhul chuk maaf wjkk wjkf

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 31 Mar 2006

keep it up Ragmala supporters! "Baba jee was a Brahmgyani, so it MUST be so!!!" Forget facts or arguments. Do you have a guarantee that these Singhs were Brahmgyanis? I have all respect for them, but I don't think I have the ability to declare who is a Brahmgyani and who isn't. I think Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was a Brahmgyani and he didn't believe in it. Go to the facts.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Singh · 31 Mar 2006

Many pro Ragmalla Veers who also had strong affiliations to Taksal, said respect Baba Takhur Singhs Brahmgyani Bachan that Sant Jarnail Singh will return before Baba Ji passes away. Baba Takhur Singh passed away without declaring another Jathedar for Taksal. And Sant Jarnail Singh did not return.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

yo · 31 Mar 2006

what has sant jarnail singh being in chardi kala havta do with raag malla?

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

JSGyani "Arshi" · 31 Mar 2006

Author: yo Date: 03-31-06 13:20 what has sant jarnail singh being in chardi kala havta do with raag malla? >>>>>>>>>>>>>.. ask "some guy"..above who brought this up... I agree with you..NONE of the persons listed have anything to do with Raagmala..its just "name dropping" scare tactics... NOT FACTS.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

yo · 31 Mar 2006

naw "Some guy" was merely stating that these sant's supported it, just like a lot of people state that bhai sahib bhai randeer singh didnt support, "Singh" starting talk about how Baba Thakur Ji said sant ji is in chardi kala which has nuthin to do with sri raag malla

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Singh · 31 Mar 2006

It has everything to do with Raag Mala. As has been demonstrated on this topic, pro Raag Mala Veers have absolutely no argument whatsoever. Even neutral non Sikh scholars who have studied the Madhavnal story take the anti Raag Mala side. The main argument that the pro Raag Mala Veers have is name dropping various personalities from history and saying they are Brahmgyani and therefore whatever they say must be right. By mentioning "Sant Ji's Chardi Kala" what I have tried to put across is just as Baba Takhur Singh's Bachan was wrong (Sant Jarnail Singh never did reappear in Baba Ji's lifetime), simply taking the word of someone that you personally believe to be a Brahmgyani (and, may I add, there is no proof to this other than blind faith and opinion), is not acceptable reasoning for accepting Raagmala. If a Kamai Wala Sikh such as Baba Takhur Singh can be wrong about one thing, then (shock horror) maybe other Kamai Wala Sikhs can be wrong about other things too! I have met a number of older Gursikhs associated with AKJ and the experiences I have had with them, convinces me it is quite possible that some of them may have reached the highest Avastha of Brahmgyan (but again, one can never be sure as it takes a Brahmgyani to know one!). And none of them believe in Raagmala.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

yo · 01 Apr 2006

maybe if u actually knew Baba Thakur Ji and actaully knew what he said you would know what he really said about sant ji being in chardi kala, maybe you should talk to sum singhs who actually talked to him aabout sant ji being in chardi kala before saying he was wrong and assumnig taht he said that sant ji will be back before baba ji leaves for sach khand, you tell pro raag malla's not to go purely on here-say, but you are doing the exact same thing

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

singh · 01 Apr 2006

Why is saying Sant Gurbachan Singh or Baba Harnam Singh believed in Raagmala such a bad argument? These are some of the most respected individuals our panth has ever seen, so how come when there names are brought up anti raagmala people say its not valid to mention their names. I think it is very valid. My opinion. Either way I do not think you will be denied mukhti or presence in sachkhand on either side of the argument. There have been amazing gursikhs, few who did not believe in it few who did.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

karkoo · 01 Apr 2006

a lot of people on this site say "i kno gursikhis in india who do this" ( alot of the time talknig about bibek, and bhai sahib randeer singh said this, but when we said sant baba gurbachan singh and sant baba jarnail singh said this, it doesnt fly on this site, you guys needed to stop being so one sided

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

simple singhani · 02 Apr 2006

NAAM SIMRAN= ANSWERS TO EVERYTHING!!!!!

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

just me · 03 Apr 2006

It has been almost a week, and still no pro-raagmalias has been able to naswer the points I raised about raagmala?

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Singh · 04 Apr 2006

When I researched into the origins of Madhavnala Kamkandla, I read various books written by non Sikh authors. Every single one agreed on the anti Raagmala theory that Alam's version was written before compilation of Sri Adi Granth Sahib, backed up with various manuscripts, historical information, and views of scholars who have devoted their lives to studying classical Indian literature. However there was one scholar out of these many who did not agree. I studied this one exception more carefully and I realised that this view had been put forward by no one other than Balbir Singh, BROTHER of Bhai Veer Singh. When I tried to find what the basis of his false claims were, it was just one single unreliable copy of a manuscript. There were some other dubious details related to it which I cannot remember now but Veers or Bhains who do the research can find out themselves. When I found the location of the manuscript, unsuprisingly, it was said to be in Bhai Veer Singh's own library :) . I think that the shaky evidence for the pro Ragmala side speaks for itself.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Prabhjoyt Singh · 04 Apr 2006

"just me" The empty pages you talk about in the Kartarpur Bir were left for Guru Tegh Bahadur sahib ji's bani also the Bir at Harmandir Sahib is praatun and that contains Raagmaala. And Niranjan Singh you asked about Giani Gian Singhs last moments well this was the man who took "pheem" and claimed Dasam Patashah Guru Gobind Singh Ji took "pheem" his last moments were he admitted his faults and said it wasnt true that Guru ji too "peem" and he just said it to justify his actions.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

... · 04 Apr 2006

Parbhjoyt Singh, The empty spaces in the "Kartarpuri Bir" we see today are not in places where Guru Tegh Bahadur's bani would go. In fact, the bir the Dhirmalis show today is different than the one that was described in detail by Bhai Kanh Singh Nabha. It even has very serious spelling mistakes like "tatana bunana" instead of " tanana bunana" in fact, the saloks of Sukhmani Sahib are even numbered up to 6 which is not in any other saroop and then it goes back to just putting "1". Giani Gian Singh had some major faults but if you throw out everything he wrote, you throw out a lot of Sikh history. What he writes that isn't against Gurmat and is confirmed by other writers is still acceptable. Will you throw out Kavi Sanotkh Singh's writings too? His Katha is done in Taksal even today. The bir at Darbar Sahib is not puratan. It was written in the 1900s.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

just me · 05 Apr 2006

prabhjyot singh please stick to facts that actually answer the question. This is the whole point about raagmala, when we get to the crunch, people realise it is not bani. Forget all the rumours and made up stories. Directly look at the facts.

Re: Sri Raag Mahala......Zindabad

Singh Ji · 09 May 2006