Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

Gurpreet Sumra · 21 Mar 2006

Sant Baba starts : Dhanna jatt used to graze his cows, he saw a Brahmin worshipping stone.Dhanna jatt asked, what are you doing? Pundit said I am worshipping thakur, by worshipping him, all your wishes are fulfilled. Dhanna jatt also asked for thakur, so pundit gave him a stone wrapped in red cloth, dhanna brought that stone home and started worshipping it and put roti and lassi in front of it and said that until god/thakur do bhog, I will not eat anything.So god thought that dhanna is really serious, if he dies in front of stone then who will worship me.Then god took the appearance of kishan and ate roti and lassi. Dekhya Saadh Sangat ji , shardha howe te rab pathar wichon v aa janda hai(baba means shardha rakho sadi kahaniyaan te, assi v rab hi haan, Guru Granth ch ki rakhya hai, bhalan di SGGS condemns pathar puja) Aakho satnam shri waheguruuuuuuuuuuu!!!!(lag gayi seal story te) Few days back I was at my friends place, his uncle was also telling the same thing,shardha honi chahidi hai , dekho dhanne ne pathar chon rab kad leya(rab koi dudh,dahi hain jo kad leya). If you ask such people what about shardha in SGGS, then they say we do have. Then how can you believe such stupid stories because SGGS tells that you are not going to get any rab from stones. Then they start arguing bcos sant baba cant be wrong.What they don’t know is that this story is from a book called “bhagat maal” which tries to portray all bhagats as followers of brahmnic philosophy. There are lot of senseless stories being spread by this sant baba mafia. I have also heard that God grazed dhanna’s cows and used to water his fields. Someone ask them if God was in dhanna’s field then, were you taking care of the rest of this world? Shame on these sant baba who are insulting SGGS by saying that SGGS contains bani of someone who used to worship idols. At the same time they are insulting Bhagat Dhanna ji and in a way saying that dhannaji was so stupid that a pundit gave him a stone and he started worshipping it. IN Bhagat dhannaji's shabads in SGGS, there is no mention of worshipping stones in them at all. “brhamat firat bahu janam bilane,tan man nahi dheere Laalach bhikh kaam lubadh rata, man bisre prabh heere Bhikh fal meeth lage,man baure,chaar bichar naa janya Gun te preet badi an bhaanti,janam maran fir taanya Jugat jaan nahi ride niwasi ,jalat jaal jam fandh pare Bhikh fal sanch bhare man aise, param purakh prabh man bisre Gyan praves gureh dhan diya, dhyan maan man ek maye Prem bhagat mani such jaanya, tript aghane mukat bhaye Jyot samayi samani jaa ke, achli prabh pehchanya Dhanne dhan paya dharnidhar, mil jan sant samanya”(SGGS,p487) In attachment with maya many births are lost,body is also destroyed ,and money is also not forever. Greedy jeev is lost in poison like substances, overcome by lust forgets lord.Hey mann! These poisonous substances seems sweet to you, you don’t like good thoughts and you are developing love for different type of attachments and are weaving the web of birth and death.Lost in this worldly love you are , like you have been surrounded by death.hey mann! You were so lost in amassing these worldy substances that you forget the true lord. When the Guru Gives the wealth of the entry into Divine Knoweldge enjoying Lord’s meditation the man becomes one with him.Inside whom the lords omnipresent jyot starts residing he has recognized the true lord and can not be deceived by worldly attachments. Note : Bhagat dhanna ji is talking about residing lord in your heart, I wonder where these babe kirtaniya got this research paper of finding rab in pathar by dhanna jatt. Dhanna has obtained the true lord and by meeting saadh sangat is merged into this lord. Note: sant here means Pundit ramanand ,dhannaji’s guru not Sant chimtewala or dholkiwala “re chit chetas ki naa dayal damodar bibeh naa janas koi Je dhaawe brahmand khand kou karta kare su hoi Janani kere udar udak main pind kiya das duara Deyi aahar agan main raakhe, aisa khasam hamara Kumi jal mahe tan tis bahar pankh khir tin nahi Puran parmanand manohar samajh dekh man nahi Pakhan keet gupt hoyi rehta taa cho marg nahi Kahe dhanna putan tahu ko mat re jee daraheen”(SGGS,p488) O my soul, why don’t you remembere the merciful Lord,? Why recognise any other(includes stones also). If you run through the universe and the continents,that alone happens what the Creator does. He built the body having ten gates in the water of the mother’s womb. He gives it sustenance and preserves it in fire, such is my Lord. the she-tortoise is in water and her young ones are outside the water.They are neither protected by mother’s wings nor fed upon her milk, the true lord takes care of them. The worm lives hidden in a stone, and for him there is no way of escape.Dhanna says, hey jinde! Don’t fear. Now Dhanna ji here is talking about worms living in stone, but kirtaniye babe are digging god out of stone. I wonder which shabad of bhagat dhanna ji gives them an idea that dhanna ji worshipped stone. When they are talking of this senseless story, if someone ask them to talk about bhagat dhanna ji’s shabad, I think they wont be able to say anything except “aakho satnaaaaaaaam shri waheguruuuuuu”. In between these two shabads, is Guru Arjan saabs shabad in which Guru saab is telling how Dhanna got the true lord.It seems that such a story may be prevalent at that time so guru saab says: “gobind gobind sang naamdeo man leena, aadh dhaam ko chheepro hoyo laakhina Bunana tunana tyag ke preeti charan kabeera, neech kula julaha bhayo gunigaheera Ravidas dhuvanta dhor nit tin tyagi maya pargat hoya saadh sang har darsan paya Sain nai butkariya oh ghar ghar suniya hirde vasya par braham bhata main ganiya Eh bidh sun ke jattdo utth bhagti laga, mile prathak gosaiyaan DHANNA vadbhaga”(SGGS,p487) In this guru saab gives the name of different bhagats, whose bani is included in SGGS so as to dispel any selfmade stories about these bhagats. This shabad clearly tells how these bhagat sahibaans got true lord. Namdev was always imbued in lords name so that poor tailor worth half a penny became rich.Kabir gave up his attachment with weaving clothes and attached to lords name and became full of excellences.Ravidas who used to carry dead cattle gave up attachment with maya and in saadh sangat obtained lord.Sain barber came to be known in every house once he has lord in his heart and was counted among bhagats. Listening to all this Dhanna jatt also started bhagti and obtained true lord. Here again Guru saab is talking that, Dhanna listening to how others have obtained lord by giving up attachments with worldly affairs and appearing in saadh sangat also followed their path and obtained lord. Guru Ramdas saab says about dhanna ji “Saadh saran pare so ubbare khatri Brahman shudra vaish chandaal chandaiya Nama jaidev kabir tralochan aaujat ravidas chamiyar chamaiya Jo jo mile saadh jan sangat dhan dhanna jat sain milya har daiya”(SGGS,p835) Who so ever comes in gurus sharan, he is saved whether he is kshatriya,Brahmin,shudra,vaish,chandal.Namdev,jaidev,kabir lowcaste ravidas DHANNA jatt sain barber all of them get lord in saadh sangat. Here Saadh is not unewale,mewewale,pehwewale,dhadriwale,chhatriwale, saadh is used for guru. Now lets see what Guru saab says about stones or pathar : “jo pathar ko kehte dev,taa ki birtha howe sev Jo pathar ki payi paye, tis ki ghaal ajai jaaye Thakur humra sada bolanta, sarab jeea ko prabh daan deta Antar dev naa jaane andh, brham ka moya paawe fandh Naa paathar bole na kich deyi fokat karam nifal hai sev”(SGGS,p1160) Those who says that stone is god there service or sewa is useless,those who touch the feet of stones their hardwork goes waste.Our lord always speaks he is the giver to all of us.Blind person don’t recognize the lord in himself and keeps on weaving useless webs.Stone neither speaks nor it gives anything, this stone worship is useless. “ghar main thakur nadir naa aawe, gal main pahan le latkawe Bharme bhula sakat firta, neer birole khap khap marta Jis pahan ko thakur kehta, oh pahan hai le usko dubta Gunahgaar loon harami, pahan naav na paargirami”(SGGS,p739) You don’t see lord in your heart but have (stones) lockets around your neck.Detached from lord people worship stones and gets nothing.Those who call stone as their lord, that very stones drowns them in vices.This stone is not getting you anywhere O sinful person. “eke paathar keeje bhau, duje paathar dhariye pao Je oh dev ta oh bhi deva Kahe Namdev hum har ki sewa”(SGGS,p525) You worship some stones as god, and hit others with your feet, if one stone is god then other should also be.Namdev says! I worship only true lord. This also applies to pictures, photographs as well ,to which people bows. How an artists imagination can be god? Some people also have Pictures of Gurus to which they bow. Even in Gurdwaras you can find pictures.I wonder who told them that this is Guru. When these Sant Baba starts these stories, we should tell them to talk something that’s Gurmat and don’t give us fairytales like Guru Nanak saab plucked jalebis from a tree for mardana. (Some points borrowed from Gursharan Singh ji kasail) [%sig%]

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2006

Absolutely and unrevocably CORRECT - Gurpeet Singh Jio. Dhan Dhan Guru Garnth Ji Sahib doesnt contain any IDOL WORSHIPPING BHAGAT's BANI. ALL contributors to Guru Garanth Ji Sahib are the worshippers of the One and Only AKAL PURAKH...no idols, no devis, no shaktees, no mata, no beris, no taals, no sapt srings, no tiraths, no pippals, no marrhis,no massannis....and no manukhs....ONLY AKAL PURAKH known by His hundreds of thousands of Names..especially WAHEGURU - the GURMANTAR for all. Of course the Boloh Satnam Sri waheguru types of frauds DONT LIKE this ONE AKAL PURAKH only.... where will they be without the multiple chances at making money and spinning tales...the more devtas and such..the merrier..THATS why the Vily Brahmin invented the 33 kror devtas in the first place..our Boloh Satnam waheguru "bippars" are just about 60 years into this...give them a thousand years into the future and we will also have 33 kror "sants" and Maha sants..and Super Duper Sants...to worship.. Guru Nanak Ji and the following GURUS set up entire towns.... Kartar Pur, Goindwaal, Khadoor Sahib, Ramdass Pur (Amrtisar).. Kirat Pur ..Paonta Sahib, ANAND PUR SAHIB.... notice NO "personal" names at all.. Our modern day sants set up "Parmeshawar Dwaar" "Nanaksar" and what not..the First one means Parmeshar only lives in his dwaar....the second one ??? Why cant we have JUST GURDWARA SAHIB....and just the place name.... Guru Ji goes for "KARTAR".."KIRAT".."ANAND"...principles of Gurmatt jsut some personal...thoughts..no need for any replies

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

Gurpreet Singh · 22 Mar 2006

Waheguroo, Wahegurooo I swear both of the stories You mentioned......I heard them from my roomies dad..i was trying to convince him... pictures of gurus don't have no meaning in sikhi...i think he was coming around with what i told him by quoting from guru sahib but the next day he started bringing twisted theories again...oh well thats crazy though cuz when we push those stories we make ourselves look like we are confused when guru sahib clearly states idol worship has no place in sikhi

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

. · 22 Mar 2006

DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ੴ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ik-oNkaar satgur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: ਬਸੰਤੁ ਮਹਲਾ ੫ ਘਰੁ ੧ ਦੁਤੁਕੀਆ basant mehlaa 5 ghar 1 dutukee-aa Basant, Fifth Mehl, First House, Du-Tukee: ਸੁਣਿ ਸਾਖੀ ਮਨ ਜਪਿ ਪਿਆਰ ॥ sun saakhee man jap pi-aar. Listen to the stories of the devotees, O my mind, and meditate with love. ਅਜਾਮਲੁ ਉਧਰਿਆ ਕਹਿ ਏਕ ਬਾਰ ॥ ajaamal uDhri-aa kahi ayk baar. Ajaamal uttered the Lord's Name once, and was saved. ਬਾਲਮੀਕੈ ਹੋਆ ਸਾਧਸੰਗੁ ॥ baalmeekai ho-aa saaDhsang. Baalmeek found the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy. ਧ੍ਰੂ ਕਉ ਮਿਲਿਆ ਹਰਿ ਨਿਸੰਗ ॥੧॥ Dharoo ka-o mili-aa har nisang. ||1|| The Lord definitely met Dhroo. ||1|| ਤੇਰਿਆ ਸੰਤਾ ਜਾਚਉ ਚਰਨ ਰੇਨ ॥ tayri-aa santaa jaacha-o charan rayn. I beg for the dust of the feet of Your Saints. ਲੇ ਮਸਤਕਿ ਲਾਵਉ ਕਰਿ ਕ੍ਰਿਪਾ ਦੇਨ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ lay mastak laava-o kar kirpaa dayn. ||1|| rahaa-o. Please bless me with Your Mercy, Lord, that I may apply it to my forehead. ||1||Pause|| ਗਨਿਕਾ ਉਧਰੀ ਹਰਿ ਕਹੈ ਤੋਤ ॥ ganikaa uDhree har kahai tot. Ganika the prostitute was saved, when her parrot uttered the Lord's Name. ਗਜਇੰਦ੍ਰ ਧਿਆਇਓ ਹਰਿ ਕੀਓ ਮੋਖ ॥ gaj-indar Dhi-aa-i-o har kee-o mokh. The elephant meditated on the Lord, and was saved. ਬਿਪ੍ਰ ਸੁਦਾਮੇ ਦਾਲਦੁ ਭੰਜ ॥ bipar sudaamay daalad bhanj. He delivered the poor Brahmin Sudama out of poverty. ਰੇ ਮਨ ਤੂ ਭੀ ਭਜੁ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ॥੨॥ ray man too bhee bhaj gobind. ||2|| O my mind, you too must meditate and vibrate on the Lord of the Universe. ||2|| ਬਧਿਕੁ ਉਧਾਰਿਓ ਖਮਿ ਪ੍ਰਹਾਰ ॥ baDhik uDhaari-o kham par-haar. Even the hunter who shot an arrow at Krishna was saved. ਕੁਬਿਜਾ ਉਧਰੀ ਅੰਗੁਸਟ ਧਾਰ ॥ kubijaa uDhree angusat Dhaar. Kubija the hunchback was saved, when God placed His Feet on her thumb. ਬਿਦਰੁ ਉਧਾਰਿਓ ਦਾਸਤ ਭਾਇ ॥ bidar uDhaari-o daasat bhaa-ay. Bidar was saved by his attitude of humility. ਰੇ ਮਨ ਤੂ ਭੀ ਹਰਿ ਧਿਆਇ ॥੩॥ ray man too bhee har Dhi-aa-ay. ||3|| O my mind, you too must meditate on the Lord. ||3|| ਪ੍ਰਹਲਾਦ ਰਖੀ ਹਰਿ ਪੈਜ ਆਪ ॥ parahlaad rakhee har paij aap. The Lord Himself saved the honor of Prahlaad. ਬਸਤ੍ਰ ਛੀਨਤ ਦ੍ਰੋਪਤੀ ਰਖੀ ਲਾਜ ॥ bastar chheenat daropatee rakhee laaj. Even when she was being disrobed in court, Dropatee's honor was preserved. ਜਿਨਿ ਜਿਨਿ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਅੰਤ ਬਾਰ ॥ jin jin sayvi-aa ant baar. Those who have served the Lord, even at the very last instant of their lives, are saved. ਰੇ ਮਨ ਸੇਵਿ ਤੂ ਪਰਹਿ ਪਾਰ ॥੪॥ ray man sayv too pareh paar. ||4|| O my mind, serve Him, and you shall be carried across to the other side. ||4|| ਧੰਨੈ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਬਾਲ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ Dhannai sayvi-aa baal buDh. Dhanna served the Lord, with the innocence of a child. ਤ੍ਰਿਲੋਚਨ ਗੁਰ ਮਿਲਿ ਭਈ ਸਿਧਿ ॥ tarilochan gur mil bha-ee siDh. Meeting with the Guru, Trilochan attained the perfection of the Siddhas. ਬੇਣੀ ਕਉ ਗੁਰਿ ਕੀਓ ਪ੍ਰਗਾਸੁ ॥ baynee ka-o gur kee-o pargaas. The Guru blessed Baynee with His Divine Illumination. ਰੇ ਮਨ ਤੂ ਭੀ ਹੋਹਿ ਦਾਸੁ ॥੫॥ ray man too bhee hohi daas. ||5|| O my mind, you too must be the Lord's slave. ||5|| ਜੈਦੇਵ ਤਿਆਗਿਓ ਅਹੰਮੇਵ ॥ jaidayv ti-aagi-o ahamayv. Jai Dayv gave up his egotism. ਨਾਈ ਉਧਰਿਓ ਸੈਨੁ ਸੇਵ ॥ naa-ee uDhaari-o sain sayv. Sain the barber was saved through his selfless service. ਮਨੁ ਡੀਗਿ ਨ ਡੋਲੈ ਕਹੂੰ ਜਾਇ ॥ man deeg na dolai kahoo-aN jaa-ay. Do not let your mind waver or wander; do not let it go anywhere. ਮਨ ਤੂ ਭੀ ਤਰਸਹਿ ਸਰਣਿ ਪਾਇ ॥੬॥ man too bhee tarseh saran paa-ay. ||6|| O my mind, you too shall cross over; seek the Sanctuary of God. ||6|| ਜਿਹ ਅਨੁਗ੍ਰਹੁ ਠਾਕੁਰਿ ਕੀਓ ਆਪਿ ॥ jih anoograhu thaakur kee-o aap. O my Lord and Master, You have shown Your Mercy to them. ਸੇ ਤੈਂ ਲੀਨੇ ਭਗਤ ਰਾਖਿ ॥ say taiN leenay bhagat raakh. You saved those devotees. ਤਿਨ ਕਾ ਗੁਣੁ ਅਵਗਣੁ ਨ ਬੀਚਾਰਿਓ ਕੋਇ ॥ tin kaa gun avgan na beechaari-o ko-ay. You do not take their merits and demerits into account. ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਦੇਖਿ ਮਨੁ ਲਗਾ ਸੇਵ ॥੭॥ ih biDh daykh man lagaa sayv. ||7|| Seeing these ways of Yours, I have dedicated my mind to Your service. ||7|| ਕਬੀਰਿ ਧਿਆਇਓ ਏਕ ਰੰਗ ॥ kabeer Dhi-aa-i-o ayk rang. Kabeer meditated on the One Lord with love. ਨਾਮਦੇਵ ਹਰਿ ਜੀਉ ਬਸਹਿ ਸੰਗਿ ॥ naamdayv har jee-o baseh sang. Naam Dayv lived with the Dear Lord. ਰਵਿਦਾਸ ਧਿਆਏ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਅਨੂਪ ॥ ravidaas Dhi-aa-ay parabh anoop. Ravi Daas meditated on God, the Incomparably Beautiful. ਗੁਰ ਨਾਨਕ ਦੇਵ ਗੋਵਿੰਦ ਰੂਪ ॥੮॥੧॥ gur naanak dayv govind roop. ||8||1|| Guru Nanak Dayv is the Embodiment of the Lord of the Universe. ||8||1|| www.srigranth.org

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

LK · 24 Mar 2006

Panthic.org has had a few good articles on this: *************************************** Bhagat Dhanna Ji: Story of Worshipping a Stone? Sunday 4th December, 2005 Panthic Weekly Columnist (KP) - Bhagat Dhanna Ji’s father’s name was Bhai Maahee Ji. His family belonged to the MaarvaaR area in Rajasthan. They were simple land-owner farmers. Bhagat Dhanna Ji obtained a ‘Saalgaraam’ (small stone idol) from a Brahman, and began doing its pooja (worship). He decorated the idol and prepared food, which he placed before it. However, the idol did not speak, nor did eat or do anything! Disappointed, he returned back to the Brahman and returned the stone idol. He said to the Brahman, “The stone idol god seems angry with me, as he is not eating the food I prepare.” The Brahman told him the real the truth of the matter to Bhagat Dhanna Ji: “This is a stone, it does not eat or drink, God is someone else.” This incident had a profound effect on Bhagat Dhanna Ji and eventually he joined the Sangat of Gurmukhs like Bhagat Ramanand Ji. Sadly, there are many stories told in our Gurdwaré by ignorant Katha-vaachiks and parchaariks (preachers). These distorted stories of Bhagat Dhanna Ji have been coined up by dubious individuals and groups who have an agenda. Gurmat is clear that idol-worship is fruitless and by worshipping a stone, one drowns with it! So, how can we have a story that says that Bhagat Dhanna Ji made food and put if before the stone idol. The stone idol did not eat the food and Bhagat Dhanna Ji remained hungry, as he was not going to eat until the Lord eats first. Not being able to see His devotee go hungry and go through this torment, God revealed himself through the stone statue and ate the food. Seeing this miracle Bhagat Dhanna Ji became happy. This version of the story is nonsense. When our Guru is alive and with us, then why do we place such faith in such distorted stories? Why not ask Guru Sahib for the answer? Well, if we placed more faith in Guru Granth Sahib Ji rather than twisted historians, ignorant parchaariks and RSS propaganda then we would not bee in this confusion. ਨਾਮਾ ਜੈਦੇਉ ਕੰਬੀਰੁ ਤ੍ਰਿਲੋਚਨੁ ਅਉਜਾਤਿ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਚਮਿਆਰੁ ਚਮਈਆ ॥ ਜੋ ਜੋ ਮਿਲੈ ਸਾਧੂ ਜਨ ਸੰਗਤਿ ਧਨੁ ਧੰਨਾ ਜਟੁ ਸੈਣੁ ਮਿਲਿਆ ਹਰਿ ਦਈਆ ॥7॥ "Naam Dev, Jai Dev, Kabeer, Trilochan and Ravi Daas the low-caste leather-worker, blessed Dhanna and Sain; all those who joined the humble Saadh Sangat, met the Merciful Lord, Waheguru. ||7||" (Bilaaval, Ang 835, SGGS) Guru Raam Daas Ji is clear of how Bhagat Dhanna Ji met and experienced Waheguru. Is it through worshipping a lifeless stone? Is it through God revealing himself through a stone? No. It is through the “Saadh Sangat”, the company of the Holy. Furthermore Guru Arjan Dev Ji has also said in Gurbani how Bhagat Dhanna Ji became a devotee of God and became absorbed into Waheguru. And the answer is not that he saw God in a lifeless stone idol. ਮਹਲਾ 5 ॥ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਸੰਗਿ, ਨਾਮਦੇਉ ਮਨੁ ਲੀਣਾ ॥ ਆਢ ਦਾਮ ਕੋ ਛੀਪਰੋ, ਹੋਇਓ ਲਾਖੀਣਾ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਬੁਨਨਾ ਤਨਨਾ ਤਿਆਗਿ ਕੈ, ਪ੍ਰੀਤਿ ਚਰਨ ਕਬੀਰਾ ॥ ਨੀਚ ਕੁਲਾ ਜੋਲਾਹਰਾ, ਭਇਓ ਗੁਨੀਯ ਗਹੀਰਾ ॥1॥ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਢੁਵੰਤਾ ਢੋਰ ਨੀਤਿ, ਤਿਨਿ ਤਿਆਗੀ ਮਾਇਆ ॥ ਪਰਗਟੁ ਹੋਆ ਸਾਧ ਸੰਗਿ, ਹਰਿ ਦਰਸਨੁ ਪਾਇਆ ॥2॥ ਸੈਨੁ ਨਾਈ ਬੁਤਕਾਰੀਆ, ਓਹੁ ਘਰਿ ਘਰਿ ਸੁਨਿਆ ॥ ਹਿਰਦੇ ਵਸਿਆ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ, ਭਗਤਾ ਮਹਿ ਗਨਿਆ ॥3॥ ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ ਜਾਟਰੋ, ਉਠਿ ਭਗਤੀ ਲਾਗਾ ॥ ਮਿਲੇ ਪ੍ਰਤਖਿ ਗੁਸਾਈਆ, ਧੰਨਾ ਵਡ ਭਾਗਾ ॥4॥2॥ “Fifth Mehl: Naam Dayv's mind was absorbed into Waheguru, Gobind, Gobind, Gobind. The calico-printer, worth half a shell, became worth millions. ||1||Pause|| Abandoning weaving and stretching thread, Kabeer enshrined love for the Waheguru's lotus feet. A weaver from a lowly family, he became an ocean of excellence. ||1|| Ravi Daas, who used to carry dead cows every day, renounced the world of Maya. He became famous in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, and obtained the Blessed Vision of the Waheguru's Darshan. ||2|| Sain, the barber, the village drudge, became famous in each and every house. The Supreme Lord Waheguru dwelled in his heart, and he was counted among the devotees. ||3|| Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat (farmer) applied himself to devotional worship. Waheguru, the Lord of the Universe met him personally; Dhanna was so very blessed. ||4||2||” (Aasa, Ang 488, SGGS) “Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat (farmer) applied himself to devotional worship” (ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ ਜਾਟਰੋ, ਉਠਿ ਭਗਤੀ ਲਾਗਾ ॥) Hearing what? Guru Sahib gives the answer to this question by reading the full shabad together. By reading the shabad by using the line “Hearing this” (ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ). Bhagat Dhanna Ji heard the praise of Bhagat Naam Dev Ji, he heard of the state of Bhagat Kabeer Ji, he heard the way of Bhagat Ravidaas Ji, and he heard of the popularity of Bhagat Sain Ji. Hearing this, feeling of loving-devotion and wanting to do Bhagti welled up within Bhagat Dhanna Ji. Guru Arjan Dev Ji placed this shabad purposefully in Bhagat Dhanna Ji’s Bani, illustrating that the ignorant people of Guru Sahib’s time were being misled on how Bhagat Dhanna Ji began his Bhagti (devotional worship) through ridiculous stories about idol worship. Those stories have been dismissed with this shabad, as it is written in the shabad that the real reason for Bhagat Dhanna Ji being absorbed in Waheguru was through being inspired by hearing the spiritual state of Bhagat Naam Dev Ji, Bhagat Ravidaas Ji, and Bhagat Sain Ji. If we try to find the truth from Sri Guru Granth Sahib, and instead of following stories passed down from others, which are mixed with lines of Gurbani, we should take the benefit of going straight to the source of truth. If we did this, then there would be no confusion or duality over Bhagat Dhanna Ji. If Bhagat Dhanna Ji met Waheguru through worshipping a stone, then this means that as a result of Guru Arjan Dev Ji including the Bani of a someone who has supposedly found God by worshipping a stone, Guru Sahib has accepted that one can meet and experience God through a lifeless stone. But Guru Sahib’s Hukam (order) is: ਜਿਸੁ ਪਾਹਨ ਕਉ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਕਹਤਾ ॥ ਉਹੁ ਪਾਹਨੁ ਲੈ ਉਸ ਕਉ ਡੁਬਤਾ ॥2॥ ਗੁਨਹਗਾਰੁ ਲੂਣ ਹਰਾਮੀ ॥ ਪਾਹਨ ਨਾਵ ਨ ਪਾਰਗਰਾਮੀ ॥3॥ “That stone, which he calls his god, that stone pulls him down and drowns him. ||2||” (Soohee, Ang 739, SGGS). Therefore, it is clear that Bhagat Danna Ji did not experience Waheguru through worhsipping a stone, but instead through the Saadh Sangat and being inspired by other Bhagats. http://panthic.org/news/132/ARTICLE/2050/2005-12-04.html

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

G · 25 Mar 2006

Sangat Ji, Please refer to Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars (vaar 10, pauri 13) - it outlines in simple terms what happened with Bhagat Dhanna Ji. He was indeed a pathar pujari. However, Bhai Gurdas ji concludes at the end that 'Bhola Bhao Govind Milavai'. The stone didn't do it, the 'Bhola Bhao' did. As an aside, please stop disowning our history. This Kala Afghana type revisionism is more dangerous than the RSS. WJKK WJKF! [%sig%]

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Mar 2006

Author: G Date: 03-25-06 22:07 Sangat Ji, Please refer to Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars (vaar 10, pauri 13) - it outlines in simple terms what happened with Bhagat Dhanna Ji. He was indeed a pathar pujari. However, Bhai Gurdas ji concludes at the end that 'Bhola Bhao Govind Milavai'. The stone didn't do it, the 'Bhola Bhao' did. As an aside, please stop disowning our history. This Kala Afghana type revisionism is more dangerous than the RSS. WJKK WJKF! <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< ISNT GURU ARJUN JI's WRITTEN TESTIMONY simple enough for YOU...who would you rather beleive..GURU JI in GURU GRANTH JI or "bhai gurdass Ji" vaar which may be adulterated ?? ITs even more dangerous to drag in "bhai kala afghana" needlessly as a scare tactic..he is NOT involved here...IT is GURU ARJUN JI s written Gurbani in very very very SIMPLE PUNJABI.....Read Prof Sahib Singh Jis Darpan for even more simpler explanations....i dotn know how much simpler can anything get. Bhagat Ji WAS NOT a Pathhar Pujaree..NEVER...not as a child and not as an elder bhagat..it is the usual bippar brahmin trying to make a Jatt look like a Fool as always..not that it counts anyway....all BHAGATS are same jaat - of WAHEGURU. Jarnail Singh

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

LK · 26 Mar 2006

ਨਾਮਾ ਜੈਦੇਉ ਕੰਬੀਰੁ ਤ੍ਰਿਲੋਚਨੁ ਅਉਜਾਤਿ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਚਮਿਆਰੁ ਚਮਈਆ ॥ ਜੋ ਜੋ ਮਿਲੈ ਸਾਧੂ ਜਨ ਸੰਗਤਿ ਧਨੁ ਧੰਨਾ ਜਟੁ ਸੈਣੁ ਮਿਲਿਆ ਹਰਿ ਦਈਆ ॥7॥ "Naam Dev, Jai Dev, Kabeer, Trilochan and Ravi Daas the low-caste leather-worker, blessed Dhanna and Sain; all those who joined the humble Saadh Sangat, met the Merciful Lord, Waheguru. ||7||" (Bilaaval, Ang 835, SGGS)

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

G · 26 Mar 2006

Bhai Sahib Arshi Ji, Please stop creating doubt over Bhai Gurdas ji's vaars. In the panthic parvaan rehat maryada, Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars have been given supreme status by allowing them to be sung alongside Gurbani, and essentially every jathebandi is in agreement on their authenticity. If you have evidence that they were adulterated, please present it. Bhagat Dhanna ji's story as given by Bhai Gurdas does not contradict Gurbani. It does not condone pathar pooja in any way. I'm afraid the Kala Afghana reference in this case is not a 'scare tactic', though I wish it were. These are exactly the types of arguments they like to present, and in the process dismiss major parts of our history and traditions. WJKK WJKF!

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

Jiti Singh · 26 Mar 2006

If "our history and traditions" means swallowing dubious stories that neither have any basis nor stand up to scrutiny, then we should dismiss them. Yes, Bhai Gurdas' Vaars have been accorded the status of the Chaabi/Key to the Guru Granth Sahib. The only other scriptures that are allowed to be read in a Gurdwara are Bhai Nand Lal's writings (although there are few now left who can read his Persian writings), and some parts of Dasam Granth. The Sikh rehat maryada states: "Sri Guru Granth Sahib is the primary source of Sikh Code of Conduct. It is supported by Dasam Granth, Vars of Bhai Gurdas and writings of Bhai Nand Lal." The key word here is "supported". This neatly captures the care that needs to be taken with these 'secondary' scriptures. Not all of Dasam Granth is written by Guru Gobind Singh, and some of it most certainly cannot have been written by him. Similarly, there were two Bhai Gurdases - the original who was the scribe of Guru Arjan (he was also Guru Arjan's mama/maternal uncle), and a later one. The original Bhai Gurdas lived up to the time of the sixth Guru, Guru Hargobind who personally performed his funeral rites. The second Bhai Gurdas was a contemporary of Guru Gobind Singh. So which Bhai Gurdas wrote the Bhagat Dhanna vaar? Well, actually it was the first and original one. But does that mean we take the story as being literally true, or is it the message that's the key? Here is what Bhai Gurdas wrote about Bhagat Dhanna (as transalted by Gobind Singh Mansukhani in his "Hymns from Bhai Gurdas's Compositions): Dhana Bhagat and a Brahmin A Brahmin worshipped idols near a well, where Dhana Bhagat came to water his cows. Out of curiosity, Dhana asked the Brahmin what he was worshipping. The Brahmin answered that he was worshipping the idol which fulfilled all his wishes. Dhana requested the Brahmin to give him a similar idol for his worship. To get rid of Dhana, the Brahmin picked up an idol and delivered it to Dhana. Like the Brahmin, Dhana bathed the idol, and placed bread and curds before it to eat. When the idol did not take the food, Dhana felt miserable, feeling that the idol was displeased with him. Dhana said to the idol: "If you do not take my food, I shall starve myself to death." The idol came to life and took the food and drink. God is pleased with simple and devoted folk. It is this last line that says "Bhola bhau Gobind millavai". And this is the important message in this vaar; as Gobind Singh Mansukhani notes, "Simplicity and devotion are passports to spiritual success and achievement." It is not the details of the story that are important, but the message. Why? Well, let's take another vaar to make this point clear: Prahlad Bhagat In the miserable home of the wicked king Harnakash, was born a lotus-like child named Prahlad. His father put him to school: the teacher felt happy with the royal ward. Then Prahlad began to recite God's Name, and to sing hymns of Divine Praise. Other students joined in the choruses and the teacher was much astonished. The teacher complained to the King who was upset by his son's behaviour. In utter despair, King Harnakash threw his son into a fire, then later into water, but somehow through God's grace Prahlad survived. Being unsuccesful, Harnakash drew his sword, then asked his son: "Who is your Guru?" At this, suddenly God appeared from a pillar, as an incarnation of a clawed lion. The lion then threw Harnakash on the ground and killed him: God, as always, is the Saviour of His devotees. The whole world congratulated Prahlad for his courage. Again, it is the message that is important, not the story. It patently cannot be true that God came as an incarnation of a lion from a pillar. Nor can it be true that an idol comes to life and starts eating and drinking food. These are allegories that contain teachings which, in these two cases, are simplicity and devotion, and faith that God will protect you if you follow his path. Jiti Singh [%sig%]

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

singhq2 · 26 Mar 2006

yes you are right. the message or methaphor is important. This does NOT mean that the saakhi is not true. Bani also says that although these methods worked for 'Ganika' or Dhanna Jatt or any of the various methods by which people were saved, they will not work for others. Naam is the key. These saakhiya are true. OTherwise whywould bhai gurdas ji write them but arshee jee has questioned the validity of this sakhee being true. therefore he is doubting Bhai Gurdas Jees vaaran of which the whole panth accepts. strange, how one man has the audacity to question what our Guru's said was the chaabi to Sri Guru Granth Sahib. i hope Guru Jee does some serious kirpa on you and give you some basic knowledge and faith in the writing of his Gursikhs. I actually quite respected to you before this. but you are talking complete manmat.

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

G · 26 Mar 2006

Bhai Jiti Singh Ji, I mentioned in my first post that 'Bhola Bhao Gobind Milavai' is the key concept here, as it is the concluding line of the pauri. I've clearly stated in both of my posts that neither Bhai Gurdas nor Gurmat condones pathar pooja. I'm not understanding the controversy here. Regarding the two different Bhai Gurdas Ji's, I'm well aware of this. Thank you for the refresher. Whether these sakhis are allegories or not is a subject for another debate. Perhaps you could start a topic and the more learned gurmukhs on this forum could give their input. Having said that, the Bhagat Dhanna sakhi is accepted by Bhai Gurdas at face value, allegory or not, and the key concept ('Bhola Bhao') is what we're meant to take away from it. WJKK WJKF! [%sig%]

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 26 Mar 2006

Bhai G Jio, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. I have a choice before me... either choose GURUBANI as written in Guru Granth Ji Sahib...OR choose what is OUTSIDE. I am 1110% SURE that what GURU JI wrote is as EXACTLY as He DID..no adulterations, no changes, no NOTHING..EXACTLY in GURU GRANTH JI becasue He wrote all HIMSELF and SIGNED it. I have CHOSEN GURUBANI INSIDE GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...over all outside sources... Fact: it is just an oral tradition about KUNJI. Please give the authentic Sikh historical record if any. Thats all.. NOT that I RESPECT Bhai gurdass Ji and many others LESS just as much as Gursikhs..But I RESPECT GURU JI even MORE. IF thta is a "fault" i respectfully ADMIT to beign faulty...by CHOICE. jarnail Singh

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

panthic · 27 Mar 2006

The PRIMARY SOURCE for Sikhs is SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. Texts such as Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Vaara(n), Bhai Nand Lal Singh's writings and Rehitnamas SUPPLEMENT and SUPPORT gurmat. As Giani Jarnail Singh Arshi has rightly said so that the story of Bhagat Dhanna jee in GURBANI is the TRUE STORY. In regards to the account about Bhagat Dhanna jee in Bhai Gurdaas jee's Vaara(n)... One is expected FIRST to go to GURBANI, THEN to go to BHAI GURDAAS JEE's VAARA(N). So someone reading Bhai Gurdaas jee's vaara(n) should at least have GURMAT and GURBANI gyan. According to Prof. Sahib Singh, during the Guru's time, these Manmat stories about Bhagat Dhanna jee were prevalent. However, there was no WRITTEN record of these prevalent stories, which Guru Arjan Dev jee ADDRESSES in his shabad when explaining HOW Bhagat Dhanna jee got into Bhagti. Bhai Gurdaas jee has simply RECORDED and PRESERVED the prevalent "DISTORTED" story about Bhagat Dhanna Jee - NOT THAT WE BELIEVE AND FOLLOW THIS - INSTEAD so that we have knowledge that this was believed by many people.... BUT same time WE KNOW for a FACT that the TRUE ACCOUNT is written by Guru Arjan Dev jee.

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

LK · 27 Mar 2006

Bhai Gurdas Ji all the way!!!!!!!

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

The Khalsa Fauj · 27 Mar 2006

Bhai Gurdaas Ji just recorded stories that were prevalent during those times. E.g. The vaar about people having lifespans of thousands of years in different yugs. Bhai Gurdass Ji gives information. We need to understand that. Bhai Gurdass Ji also presented Gurmat philosophy in his vaars. So we got both, information and Gurmat philosophy. We apply Gurmat philosophy and keep information for future use and knowledge. Aarshi Singh Ji prob. meant to say that. Sometimes, in a hurry or when tired, we say things we don't mean!!

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

sanjo · 27 Mar 2006

whats all this "Kala Afghana" business that was argued about above, i have no knowledge on thsi could anyone explain.

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

. · 27 Mar 2006

DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ਧੰਨੈ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਬਾਲ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ Dhannai sayvi-aa baal buDh. Dhanna served the Lord, with the innocence of a child. ਧੰਨੈ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਬਾਲ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ Dhannai sayvi-aa baal buDh. Dhanna served the Lord, with the innocence of a child. ਧੰਨੈ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਬਾਲ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ Dhannai sayvi-aa baal buDh. Dhanna served the Lord, with the innocence of a child. ਧੰਨੈ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਬਾਲ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ Dhannai sayvi-aa baal buDh. Dhanna served the Lord, with the innocence of a child. ਧੰਨੈ ਸੇਵਿਆ ਬਾਲ ਬੁਧਿ ॥ Dhannai sayvi-aa baal buDh. Dhanna served the Lord, with the innocence of a child. www.srigranth.org THE ABOVE FROM SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE SHOULD VALIDATE THE WRITING OF BHAAEE GURDAAS JEE REGARDING BHAGAT DHANNA JEE

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Mar 2006

Author: sanjo Date: 03-27-06 14:19 whats all this "Kala Afghana" business that was argued about above, i have no knowledge on thsi could anyone explain. >>>>>>>>>>>>> The subject is "BANNED" by Jathedar Akal Takhat vedanti Ji....as Bhai gurbaksh Singh Kala Afghana is at present "excommunicated" fro writign TEN Books on how the BIPPAR has introduced adulteration into Gurmatt and Sikh history....books like the Gurbilas Patshahi Chhevin and Dasveen etc tell false tales about our Gurus etc etc..and he also "attacked" a lot of other things like "amrit" as a ritual, sarovar ishnaans as a ritual etc etc. It all depends on how you view the AKAL TAKHAT..."excommunication" order...some follow it 110% and so refuse to even mention KA ( dirty word)..others dont think that way. Your own choice as a SIKH. Akal takaht Jathedar ahs banned reading.keeping.looking at his books. Jarnail singh

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

singh · 27 Mar 2006

agree with "panthic" and "the khalsa fauj"

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

LK · 28 Mar 2006

Author: JSGyani "Arshi" Date: 03-27-06 16:37 Author: sanjo Date: 03-27-06 14:19 whats all this "Kala Afghana" business that was argued about above, i have no knowledge on thsi could anyone explain. >>>>>>>>>>>>> The subject is "BANNED" by Jathedar Akal Takhat vedanti Ji....as Bhai gurbaksh Singh Kala Afghana is at present "excommunicated" fro writign TEN Books on how the BIPPAR has introduced adulteration into Gurmatt and Sikh history....books like the Gurbilas Patshahi Chhevin and Dasveen etc tell false tales about our Gurus etc etc..and he also "attacked" a lot of other things like "amrit" as a ritual, sarovar ishnaans as a ritual etc etc. It all depends on how you view the AKAL TAKHAT..."excommunication" order...some follow it 110% and so refuse to even mention KA ( dirty word)..others dont think that way. Your own choice as a SIKH. Akal takaht Jathedar ahs banned reading.keeping.looking at his books. Jarnail singh ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 - What is your opinion on his writings Gyani Ji? 2 - Does anything he write, for you, feel like manmat? 3 - Although I am no fan off KA, and hardly know anything about him, I am not too sure of excommunicating scholars left and right. KA might have made hoesnt research (he might have not, I do not know), and reached dodgy conclusions. I do however not agree with Akal Thakhat excommunicatiing him. What has been achieved? Exactly the same as when Harjot Oberoi (hardcore anti-panthic) was summoned. Why not do it like the Singh Sabha scholars did? Write books refuting dodgy scholar's writing, instead of excommunicating left and right. That's exactly what I think Akal Thakhat should do- employ a committee to refute anti-gurmat writings (whether by Kushwant, Oberoi, or KA - I am not judging here), in their own books and show that these people are not reflecting true Sikhi. Instea the Jathedar is acting like the pope of the vatican imposing his views on other people (like the popes used to do back in the day, instead of refuting, they summoned, had trails and punished people with different views) But this they will not do. This takes away a lot of their power of summoning and excommunicating. Why are they not summoning the people that SHOULD be summoned, lika Chicago Baba, or the people takign Guru ji's saroop to party halls? Bhull Chukk maaf

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Mar 2006

Dear LK ji, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh Ji. 1. I have ALL his Books and have READ all of them. I dont agree 100% with everything he says BUT dont reject everything as well. He backs up his conclusions with at least FIVE Gurbani Shabads..and MORE. 2. Yes some of his ideas may be manmatt..and the Akal takhat should have REFUTED these with Gurbani quotes...his challenge on these was not accepted But Most of what is "allegedly manmatt" as claimed by his opponents is actually NOT what he writes BUT what he says "is claimed to be written.." By this I mean that He writes that certain writings like Tria chitars are NOT the writigns of Guru Gobind Singh ji..and He "QUOTES" from these Tria Chitars to PROVE his point. But what happens is his opponents QUOTE his wriitngs and allege that HE is writing such bad things about GURU Gobind Singh ji.... i have met a few of such people who havent even seen a copy of dasam granth..and yet they ahd the nerve to tell me KA wrote such FILTHY things about GURU GOBIND SINGH JI..( they havent seen any of KA's books also..but thats beside the point ??!!). 3. I firmly beleive he was excommunicated ( there is no such thing in Gurmatt) by Vedanti as a PERSONAL VENDETTA for proving Vedanti wrong about Gurbilas Patshahi Chhevin. Same has been done for Editor Spokesman..and now the Rozana spokesman is target of SGPC President when the sgpc has failed in all its tasks. 4. I beleive there are NO SCHOLARS in the sgpc stables...any worthwhile one that dares to raise his head..like Gurtej Singh, or Giani Bara pind etc is pressured or "excommunicated". NO SGPC scholar has written anything aginst Harjit oberoi, MCleod , Pashaura Singh etc who are doing untold harm to panth by their hardcore anti panthic writings. These anti panthic writers still occupy chairs in the west..and produce anti panth literature. 5. Why are baba chicago, manna pehova, dhanwanta, badals and alike NOT summoned or Excommunicated..the answer lies in my para 3 above..who knows ??? I serve my "conscience"...i dont want to be what Guru Sahib jee calls Mann ANDAAH.naam SUJAAN... Bhul Chuk Maaf Jarnail Singh

Re: Was Dhanna jatt pathar pujari?

... · 29 Mar 2006

Kala Afghana is a Kanjar. He was a government agent working against the Sikh movement and plotted against Sant Jarnail Singh. He then came to Canada and sexually assaulted a woman. He is sponsored by anti-Sikh elements who are bent upon cutting at the roots of Sikhi. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Khalsa v. Bhullar Between Gurbaksh Singh Khalsa, Plaintiff, and Taranjit Kaur Bhullar, Hariner Singh Bhullar, Gurnham Singh Bajwa and Kahar Singh Pannu, Defendants [1992] B.C.J. No. 378 Victoria Registry No. 89/1983 British Columbia Supreme Court Victoria, British Columbia Macdonell J. Heard: September 3 - 6, 9 - 12 and November 7, 1991 Judgment: February 24, 1992 (15 pp.) Torts - Defamation 2- Defences - Truth. Sexual assault - Damages - General damages - Punitive damages - Punitive damage award appropriate where a /1 priest of the Sikh religion breached his position of trust by sexually assaulting a parishioner. The plaintiff sued for damages for defamation of character. The defendants counterclaimed for damages for sexual assault. The plaintiff was a priest of a Sikh religious temple. The summer following the incident which was the subject of this lawsuit, the plaintiff was discharged. The plaintiff was 68-years-old, and resided in the living quarters with his wife and a daughter. His argument was that a faction in the temple wanted to get rid of him, so they attempted to put him in a compromising position with Mrs. B. He claimed that she wrongfully exposed herself before him and was sexually aggressive towards him, and that he took no part in it. He further argued that such a false accusation against a priest is particularly devastating; in fact it resulted in his being wrongfully dismissed and being unable to obtain further employment as a priest. The case for the defence was that the plaintiff was not defamed and that, in fact, the allegation of sexual assault was true. HELD: The plaintiffs action was dismissed. The defendant Mrs. B succeeded on her counterclaim, having proved that the plaintiff in fact sexually assaulted her. The court awarded her $5,000.00 in general damages, and $5,000.00 in special damages. The plaintiff had failed to prove his allegation of a wrongful accusation of sexual assault. The defendants had proved their counterclaim AND THE COURT FOUND THAT IN FACT THE SEXUAL ASSAULT HAD TAKEN PLACE. With respect to general damages for the sexual assault, the court had to bear in mind the gravity of the assault, the circumstances of it, and its effect on Mrs. B. The assault was of a relatively minor nature in the sense that there was only one incident. The assault here was committed by a priest in the living quarters of a Sikh temple upon a parishioner who was requested to attend by the priest. The emotional impact of the forceful touching of the plaintiffs chest and the attempt to remove her stockings was not only offensive but appalling, particularly as the priest in the Sikh religion is held in high esteem and the utmost in decorum is expected of him. He was in a position of trust and abused the trust. On the other hand, there did not appear to be any serious after-effects on Mrs. B other than distaste for the whole matter. The impact on Mrs. B would be lessened by her vindication in this lawsuit, allowing her to save face. MACDONELL J.:- The plaintiffs action against the defendants is for defamation of character arising out of an accusation by the defendant Taranjit Bhullar that she was sexually assaulted by the plaintiff, which accusation was published by the defendants. The defendant Mrs. Bhullar alleges that the plaintiff sexually assaulted her, and she and her husband counterclaim for damages against the plaintiff. The background, briefly, is that the plaintiff at all material times was the priest at the Topaz Street Temple of the Khalsa Diwan Society, which is a Sikh religious society. The plaintiff came to Canada in 1984 and resided for a year in Grand Prairie with his daughter. Prior to coming to Canada, he had been a policeman in the Punjab and retired with the rank of Inspector in 1981. He had no training in the priesthood but was a devout Sikh. There does not seem to be much dispute that he was knowledgeable in the religion and was qualified to act as a priest, as there does not appear to be any need for prior formal religious training to act as a priest in a temple. While in Grand Prairie, he saw an advertisement in an ethnic ne"",spaper advertising for a priest at Golden. He applied and was successful and presided as a priest there for some nine months. With this experience he was accepted as a priest at 1 00 Mile House where he presided for a year. He then heard of an opening at the Topaz Street Temple in Victoria and on October 1st, 1986, he was employed there as the priest on a contract basis which provided for two months' notice by either party. He continued as priest until the summer following the incident which is the subject of this law suit, when he was discharged. The plaintiff was sixty-eight years of age at all material times, was married and had children. He and his wife and a daughter resided in the living quarters of the temple. Following his appointment, things went along reasonably well, although there was friction with the executive of the Society - no doubt partly due to the plaintiffs rigidity in some areas. Toward the end of December, 1987 the friction between him and the Committee increased and the plaintiff became convinced that a group in the temple, including the defendants, wished to be rid of him. It is his position that there was a conspiracy to effect his removal, starting with their sending a white woman to the temple to compromise him sexually. That plot failed as she was drunk. He alleges that thereafter there was a meeting between the various defendants and others who plotted to have the female defendant compromise him, again with the purpose of getting rid of him. However, as part of his case, the plaintiff alleges only the slander and not a conspiracy to remove him as priest, which seems to be the subject matter of another lawsuit. The plaintiff testified that he met the Bhullars in 1986 and that they were regular attenders at the temple. They were helpful with his daughter's marriage and by 1987 he and the Bhullars became good friends. He testified that from time to time he saw Mrs. Bhullar alone and that at times they discussed problems she had with her husband. He described their relationship as that of a family membership. The female defendant is thirty-five years of age and her husband is a comparable age. The plaintiff said that in 1988, when Mrs. Bhullar left one night after visiting, she embraced him and kissed him on the cheek. He said that he was very upset by this. He said that following this she telephoned him and explained that such conduct was not unusual in Canada. He said that in January and February 1989 nothing of a sexual nature took place between them and that they did not meet privately during that time. He said that on March 25th, which was just prior to his and his wife's visit to Seattle, Mrs. Bhullar came to the temple at lunchtime in response to a call from him. He said they took food after her arrival and then he went to take a rest in his bedroom. He said that the defendant came into the room. At that time he was sitting on a chair removing his jacket. He said that she removed her blouse, exposing her naked breasts, sat on his lap, and put her hands around his neck. He testified that she said, "I know you need me". He said he was stunned and pushed her away, telling her that this was not the way for a daughter to act. The defendant left and the plaintiff then went to the temple and prostrated himself before the Holy Book. He said that he and his wife left for Seattle the next day, returning April 5th of 1989. He telephoned Mrs. Bhullar at her office but as she was busy she telephoned him the following day. He said he recorded the call on his answering machine. He said he told her he would tell her husband that she was not acting like a daughter. He said he did, in fact, telephone her husband on the 6th and told him that his wife was not faithful. He met her husband in the afternoon and spoke to him further. He said that on April 30th there was a meeting of the Committee and his employment and raise were discussed. He denied that there was any condition of immediate dismissal in the case of lack of moral turpitude. He said he did not speak to the defendants from April through to June. On July 22nd, there was a meeting of the Temple Committee and the plaintiff was advised by Mr. Bajwa and Mr. Pannu that Mr. and Mrs. Bhullar had lodged a complaint against him and that there was a tape of a conversation between the plaintiff and Mrs. Bhullar. The tape was apparently played, which resulted in the plaintiffs employment being terminated. After listening to the tape and hearing the accusation of Mrs. Bhullar, the Committee accepted as a fact that the plaintiff had sexually assaulted the female defendant. The plaintiffs position is that this allegation is false and that the true state of affairs is that it was the defendant who wrongfully exposed herself before him and was sexually aggressive toward him, and that he took no part in it. The plaintiffs position is that such a false accusation against a priest is particularly devastating; in fact it resulted in his being wrongfully dismissed and being unable to obtain further employment as a priest. A considerable amount of evidence was called with respect to various taped telephone conversations, produced by both the plaintiff and the defendants Bhullar, and other evidence of conflicts in the temple which do not relate much to the law suit. The plaintiff alleges that there was a conspiracy to remove him and that the conduct of the female defendant which he described was orchestrated by a group in the Committee, which included Mr. Pannu and Mr. Bajwa, to compromise the plaintiff. The plaintiff called Mr. Gurbakash Sihota, who testified that he met the defendants Bajwa and Pannu in February 1989 and that Mr. Johal, Mr. Ajwall and Mr. Sanhera were there. The meeting was at approximately 9:00 p.m. and was arranged to congratulate Bajwa and Pannu for their election to office on the Temple Committee. The last three mentioned come from Vancouver. He said they then discussed getting rid of the plaintiff, as there was a complaint by Mr. Bajwa about the priest interfering in a wedding ceremony when Mr. Bajwa sang a poem. Mr. Pannu's complaint was that the priest contradicted his mother-in-law. The consensus was that they should get rid of the priest and that they had a girl ready to entice him into making sexual advances. The name mentioned was the female defendant, Bhullar. Mr. Sihota said that Pannu had mentioned that they had tried a white lady but it did not work because she got drunk when she was sent to the temple and the plaintiff" got away". In cross-examination the witness tied himself to the meeting taking place on February 11 tho The case for the defence is that the plaintiff was not defamed and that, in fact, the allegation of a sexual assault is true. The Bhullars in their counterclaim ask for damages against the plaintiff for the sexual assault. The female defendant is thirty-five years of age, was born in India and came to Canada in 1962, where she took her education through Grade 12 at Oak Bay High School and Camosun College. She has been with the Workers Compensation Board for some seventeen years and is presently a Claims Adjudicator, a position she has held for some four years. She was married in 1985 and has one daughter of five years of age. Her husband works for the Municipality of Saanich. They met the plaintiff when he became a priest. They attended the Topaz Street Temple regularly from 1986 through 1988 and they became close to the plaintiff. Initially, Mrs. Bhullar and her husband responded to his need for help in the community as he was a stranger. In 1987 the plaintiff needed a drive to a religious ceremony. Mrs. Bhullar drove him there and said he put his hand on her hand and she asked him to take it off. He later asked, "How about a kiss?" and she said, "You've got to be kidding". She told her husband about this incident and they cut down their visits with the plaintiff and their attendance at the temple significantly. She said that at the end of 1988 the plaintiff called her to meet him in private to talk over his problems. She said they met at the temple and nothing untoward happened. In December of 1988 the plaintiff was persistently telephoning her and at times asked her to bring food. On one occasion she did take along Chinese food and it was consumed in his quarters. On leaving she said he asked for a hug and a kiss and that she pushed him away. Following this she received telephone calls at work and by January and February 1989 he was calling her as much as four times a day, two or three times a week. In addition, when she was not available, she received messages from time to time that "Father had called". She said that in early January the plaintiff had telephoned and was very angry and upset with her as somebody in his family had died and the Bhullars had not been available to help him. She said that in mid-February the plaintiff wanted to meet her at the library in the temple for lunch as he wanted to talk to her. She went and was met at the top of the stairs by the plaintiff, who said the lunch was laid on in the library. She asked where his wife and daughter were and he told her they had had their lunch and were sleeping. She said "We went to another room, which was the guest room, where lunch was laid out". There were two beds and a dresser. They ate the food sitting on the beds. He sat on one and she sat on the other. She said that the plaintiff came to the bed and put his arm around her and pushed her back onto the bed. She said he put his hand underneath her blouse and with his other hand tugged at her skirt. She said she tried to pull away. He told her he couldn't take her nylons off, although he was trying. She said she pulled herself together and pushed him away. She said she "got loud", meaning that she raised her voice. He said "Don't get loud, the bitches are sleeping in the next room". Mrs. Bhullar then left through the library and went back to work, very upset. At that time she did not discuss what had happened with Ms. Mettis, her case assistant, although Ms. Mettis asked her what was the matter. She said in April she received a call from the plaintiff threatening to blackmail her. He said that he had a taped conversation which incriminated her. She said she was devastated. She reported to work as usual, but while going over a file with Ms. Mettis she broke down in tears and then told her what had happened at the temple. She was advised to tell her husband, which she did. They did not attend at the temple after that. Following her disclosure of the assault to her husband they went to the police, who suggested that the matter be sorted out in the Sikh community. She said to protect themselves against a case of slander they purchased a recording device and that during conversations with the plaintiff she led him to believe that she had not told her husband. Various conversations were recorded. At the same time, the plaintiff was busy recording conversations on his machine. Mrs. Bhullar denies that she was a party to any conspiracy to compromise the plaintiff with the purpose of having him removed. The defendant husband was called and his evidence paralleled that of his wife. He also testified that he was not a party to any agreement to effect the removal of the plaintiff. The other defendants were called and they all gave evidence to the same effect. After hearing Mrs. Bhullar's accusation of sexual assault by the plaintiff, which they believed, and the taped telephone conversations, they concluded that he had in fact committed a sexual assault and this was the foundation for his being removed as a priest. The defendants deny that there was any meeting as alleged by Mr. Sihota. The defence called Ms. Mettis, who confirmed the evidence of the female defendant and, in particular, the numerous calls made by the plaintiff to Mrs. Bhullar, her emotional state following the visit to the temple, and what was disclosed to her later when Mrs. Bhullar broke down at the office. The defence called Mr. Rajinder Sihota, who is a senior accountant with the Ministry of Finance. He testified that on February 13th, 1989 he was in a police station in the Punjab with respect to a complaint concerning Gurbakash Sihota, the witness called for the plaintiff who alleged the conspiracy meeting. Mr. Rajinder Sihota testified that the plaintiffs witness was not only in the Punjab on the 13th February, but had been there for some time. Logistically it would not have been possible for him to be in Victoria on February lIth due to time changes and travelling time. Mr. Rajinder Sihota also testified that the plaintiffs witness Sihota was a cousin of his and had a bad reputation. In addition, he had information that his cousin had been in the Punjab for a few months at that time. The defence's position can be summarized as a complete denial of the allegation of defamation or of a conspiracy. With respect to the counterclai:t;n, the defence claims that the evidence of the defendants should be accepted and that the Court should find that the plaintiff sexually assaulted the female defendant. I have to assess the credibility of the various witnesses called and also consider the tape recordings which have been led in evidence and the allegation by the defence that the plaintiffs tape recordings have been tampered with and are, in fact, extracts from other conversations taken out of context. The defence also takes the position that the tape recordings that have been produced by the defence make it quite clear that the plaintiff admitted to the sexual assault. Both the plaintiff and the defence called evidence of experts dealing with the authenticity of the tapes. The defendants' expert listened to the tapes and conducted sound tests. In my view, his evidence should be preferred to that of the plaintiffs expert, who did not carry out this testing. The conclusion of the defendants' expert is that the tape of the plaintiff was not prepared, as he testified, by using a tape recorder or answering machine and speaking to an answering machine and telephone, but that in fact all the conversations were taken from a telephone line. I find this evidence credible. I accept it and conclude that the tape prepared by the plaintiff has been concocted by him and not recorded as he testified. Listening to the defendants' tapes with the assistance of the witnesses and the interpreter persuades me that the inference to be taken from them is that the plaintiff admitted to sexually assaulting the female defendant and that the Committee was well justified in accepting the evidence of Mrs. Bhullar and the tapes in concluding that the plaintiff had sexually assaulted her. With respect to the alleged meeting between the executives at Mr. Sihota's house, I conclude that this evidence was fabricated and quite untrue and I accept the evidence of Mr. Rajinder Sihota called for the defence that the plaintiffs witness Sihota was in fact in the Punjab at the time when the supposed conversation and conspiracy took place. I conclude therefore that the plaintiff has failed to prove his allegation of a wrongful accusation of sexual assault and find that in fact the sexual assault did take place. The plaintiffs action is accordingly dismissed with costs. With respect to the counterclaim, I find that the defendants have proved their counterclaim and that the plaintiff in fact sexually assaulted the female defendant. The plaintiff - who, as a priest in a position of authority and influence, sexually assaulted a female parishioner in the tight-knit society of the Sikh community in Victoria - is guilty of an extremely serious offence. DAMAGES The counterclaim is advanced by both Bhullars against the plaintiff for the sexual assault. It is my view that the only one who can succeed in the counterclaim is Mrs. Bhullar. The defendant argues as if there is a counterclaim for defamation of character as well as sexual assault, but in fact that is not what the pleadings disclose. In any event, a case has not been made out to entitle Mr. Bhullar to damages. With respect to general damages for the sexual assault, I have to bear in mind the gravity of the assault, the circumstances of it, and its effect on Mrs. Bhullar. In this case, unlike a number of others where damages have been sought for sexual assault, the assault is of a comparatively minor nature in the sense that there was only the one incident, as opposed to cases where the assault was a rape or a similar crime of violence, or assaults on younger people, that have often continued over a number of years. Little is to be gained by trying to compare damages in cases that are not similar to the case at bar, so I do not propose to review the current authorities which are not bountiful. What I have to deal with here is an assault by a priest in the living quarters of a Sikh temple upon a parishioner who was requested to attend by the priest, who is the plaintiff. The emotional impact of the forceful touching of the plaintiffs chest and the attempt to take off her stockings is not only offensive but appalling, particularly as the priest in the Sikh religion is held in high esteem and the utmost in decorum is expected of him. He was in a position of trust and abused that trust. The assault was made possible because of the respect of Mrs. Bhullar for the plaintiff as priest and her being at the temple at all was at his request. With respect to the consequences or the effect on Mrs. Bhullar, there is very little evidence before me other than her feelings of humiliation, shock and degradation. There do not appear to be any serious after-effects other than distaste for the whole matter. Consequently, it is my view that the damages should reflect the seriousness of the assault but damages in other more serious cases should be borne in mind to keep a balanced perspective of damages under this head. To some extent the impact on Mrs Bhullard is lessened, as her success in this lawsuit vindicates her and face is saved in a society where it is very important. By the same token, the plaintiff is discredited and has lost all respect and credibility in his community. I award general damages to Mrs. Bhullar in the amount of $5,000.00 for the sexual assault. A claim has been advanced for punitive damages. In this case it is my view that it is appropriate that punitive damages be awarded. They are not awarded on the basis of compensation but on the principle of punishment. In this case no criminal proceedings were launched, although the Bhullars did report the matter to the police, who left it to the Sikh community to sort out the matter and did not proceed with charges. Consequently, the element of punishment of the plaintiff for his conduct has not been addressed. In this case punitive damages need be awarded to express society's disapproval of the conduct of the plaintiff as a priest in authority and trust breaching that trust and sexually assaulting a parishioner. His attempting, after that, to manufacture evidence and shift the blame away from himself and his harassment of Mrs. Bhullar is despicable. I award the sum of $5,000.00 as punitive damages. Mrs. Bhullar will have her costs of the counterclaim and pre-judgment interest at the rate set by the Registrar from time to time. MACDONELL J. (JUDGE)