Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sharam dee Gal

Sharam dee Gal

khalsa · 12 Dec 2003

http://www.tribuneindia.com/2003/20031212/chd.htm This is such a disturbing site, scroll down until you see Bibiaan with white dastaar's prancing around and entertaining the crowds as they dance to punjabi music. What is this??? I just finished reading the beautiful story of Bibi Susheel Kaur and then I see the above link. I am so disgusted. I see there being no link between Gursikhi and this "new aged cultural sikhi" these people are trying to create. This is pure GARBAGE and there is no room in a Gursikh's life for this, something needs to be done about this immediately before naive young singhniaan start to think it's OK to do this.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Dec 2003

khalsa paji, every1 is'nt at the same level of sikhi as u for they have'nt eleminated worldly joys. i don't think this is such an important topic, when we have "babaye" wearing dastaars drinking.....we have munde these days turban shave drinking smoking weed........ these bibian are probablly sober

Re: Sharam dee Gal

Singhnee · 12 Dec 2003

I agree with 'Khalsa' seeing that picture is DISTURBING. Bibiaan dancing around for entertainment is against sikhi. Especially wearing a Daastar a gursikhs CROWN! Something should be done to educate people, like those girls wearing daastars and dancing around for people pure MANMAT.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

singh · 12 Dec 2003

These are yogi's 3ho kids. I've seen pictures of them dancing traditional hindu dances before as well. This is pure manmat. The mughals used to get women to dance in front of them to entertain them and hindu women dance in front of priests and idols as a part of their religious rites. This is obviously not a part of the gurmat tradition and it's sad that these kids are being taught this as part of their studies at the Miri Piri Academy in Amritsar. You'd think the education at such an institution would center around gursikhee and not teach them to dance to entertain crowds.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Dec 2003

question: all one should do is paat and simiran? don't wanna get flamed, but this is indeed backwards, we can't throw out every single cultural aspect. U can throw out things like dowry, and man first cause those deny ppl rights...... u can throw out booze cause its an intoxicant........ but dancing???????????? cleanly is also illeagle?

Re: Sharam dee Gal

Tohada Daas_/\_ · 12 Dec 2003

Thats shocking.............................................. gurfateh ji

Re: Sharam dee Gal

Kulbir Singh · 12 Dec 2003

This is truly shocking. Just as that keshadhari and smoking professor spoils the Sikh image, same way these dancing dastar-waaliyaan bibiyaan too spoil the Sikh image and culture. Gabhroo jeeo, you mention that Sikhs too need to entertain themselves and then you justify dancing. Dancing is not the way the Sikhs entertain themselves. Dancing is the way of kanjars. Singhs and Singhanis live in the fear and love of Guru Sahib. They do not get involved in such immoral pleasures. If you talk about culture, then realize that according to Punjabi culture, only bazaaroo (bad) women dance in front of stranger men. In Punjabi culture, women of good families used to dance but only in with other women and this dance was called gidha. No men were allowed in that area. Only immoral women danced in front of men and that too for money. If you want to follow culture then follow it properly. Such dance as these women (in the url above) is neither in accordance with Sikhi nor Punjabi culture. These dastaared bibiyaan wearing red suits and dancing in front of men are doing pure manmatt. For a Sikh such dance is wrong. The only dance a Sikh can do is, let his mann dance in front of Satguru i.e. obeying the hukams of Satguru (IH MANN NAACHAI, SATGUR AAGAI; ANHAD SHABAD DHUN TOOR VAJAEEYA). Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sharam dee Gal

concerned · 12 Dec 2003

i agree with bhai kulbir singh

Re: Sharam dee Gal

khalsa · 12 Dec 2003

Very well said Kulbir Singh Veerji. "khalsa paji, every1 is'nt at the same level of sikhi as u" Gabroo veerji, this has nothing to do with any level of sikhi, this is straight up basic stuff. Wearing the sundar dastaar that Guru sahib has blessed you with and shaking your hips (quite obvious from the picture) infront of male/female audience to a beat as a part of a bhangra group from the Miri Piri Academy???? I don't think it takes too high a "level of sikhi" to understand that is wrong! It is definately the reverse of punjabi culture if that is what they are going for...like veerji has stated in their above post, 'punjabi culture' involved 'punjabi women' dancing amongst themselves and not infront of crowds of males/females, but again I see no place in Sikhi for this. I recall hearing of the Miri Piri Academy a few years back when a group of young Gursikh's very well learned in classical keertan came abroad to various gurdwara sahib's. I'm shocked that this is the same Miri Piri Academy that has released this 'colorful' group of dancers!

Re: Sharam dee Gal

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Dec 2003

why dancing wrong? simple question

Re: Sharam dee Gal

khalsa · 12 Dec 2003

why do you have khalistan in your name and innocently promote this stuff? insult to shaheed singhs who fought for sikhi.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

Singhstah · 12 Dec 2003

Gabroo Khalistan Dah, I'll tell you whats wrong , we being Sikhs are akal purakh ki fauj would you find akal purukh ki fauj dancing around infront of people?

Re: Sharam dee Gal

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Dec 2003

so u guys are saying eleminate all worldy fun, allllll emotional contact jusss have 1 thing paat? ppl this is the world...... if the piwater(pure) kharkhoo singhs from the 80s felt that bhangra wuz wrong they wuld have done something about it. they felt chamikilla's obsence lyrics where wrong, so they kindly gave him warnings after warnings and read is kirtan sohila. they saw that marriages where being done without ethic (dowry), they governed them ( motorcycle wallaye ). tha's how i c it, rather the kharhoo mahan gur-sikhs contracted singers such as hans raj hans, malkit singh, and other big time singers from that time and got them 2 sing pro kharkhoo songs from the same ppl that sing these supposed "lustfull, dirty lyrics" chamikilla for example had a perverted mind, but he also outta fear sang tonnes of dharmik songs, but the singhs did'nt appreciate this, for the same mouth spat out dirt and Dharam so they kindy took repair of him.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

? · 12 Dec 2003

y just chamkila though?its strange how other singers also sang dirty songs and got away with it.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

- · 12 Dec 2003

who says paath is not fun? THis topic has already been discuused on this forum and it was mentioned that a sikh is above wordly pleasures like dancing around like an idiot without any shame whatsoever infront of the opposite sex. The way for a gursikh to have fun is paath reqading bani gatka or having vichaars with other gursikhs. If you have a choice between the sangat of the khalsa and dancing around like kanjars, why would anyone choose the latter and then justify it as fun? Author: GABROO KHALISTAN DAH Date: 12-11-03 23:05 question: all one should do is paat and simiran? You seem to ask this question as if doing that is a bad thing, but from all ive learned, this is actually the aim of a gursikh.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 13 Dec 2003

***admin cut*** i'm sorry guys i know dis topic is wierd one and its sure not gonna help my sikhi (which there is none off) so i humbly bow off hopefull i will catch ur way 2 :D (not meant as sarcasim, cause text can sound like that juss wanna clarify) to . it is man i agree with u . singh/kaur my apology :)

Re: Sharam dee Gal

Dancer · 13 Dec 2003

Comments about Worldly Dancing by Satguru Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj anadhin naachai sukath nivaarai siv ghar needh n hoee One who dances night and day, and banishes Shakti's Maya, enters the House of the Lord Shiva, where there is no sleep. sukuthee ghar juguth soothaa naachai ttaapai avuro gaavai munumukh bhugath n hoee The world is asleep in Maya, the house of Shakti; it dances, jumps and sings in duality. The self-willed manmukh has no devotion. ||3|| paakhundd bhugath nirath dhukh hoe the dances and the worship of the hypocrites bring only pain. ||3|| bhugath kurehi moorukh aap junaavehi The fools perform devotional worship by showing off; nach nach ttupehi buhuth dhukh paavehi they dance and dance and jump all around, but they only suffer in terrible pain. nirath kurae buhu vaajae vujaaeae One may dance and play numerous instruments; eihu mun andhaa bolaa hai kis aakh sunaaeae but this mind is blind and deaf, so for whose benefit is this speaking and preaching? ---------- vaaein chaelae nuchan gur The disciples play the music, and the gurus dance. pair hulaaein faeran isir They move their feet and roll their heads. oudd oudd raavaa jhaattai paae The dust flies and falls upon their hair. vaekhai lok husai ghar jaae Beholding them, the people laugh, and then go home. rotteeaa kaaran poorehi thaal They beat the drums for the sake of bread. ****************************************** kind of dancing permitted in SIKHI as per the HUKAM by Satguru Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj naachun soe j mun sio naachai He alone is a dancer, who dances with his mind. ----- gurumukh nirath har laagai bhaao The Gurmukh's dance is to embrace love for the Lord; poorae thaal vichuhu aap guvaae to the beat of the drum, he sheds his ego from within. har kae dhaas dhaas hum keejai mun nirath kurae kar naachae Make me the slave of the Lord's slaves, so that my mind might dance in Your Love. ||3|| vaajaa math pukhaavuj bhaao Make your intellect your instrument, and love your tambourine; hoe anundh sudhaa man chaao thus bliss and lasting pleasure shall be produced in your mind. eaehaa bhugath eaeho thup thaao This is devotional worship, and this is the practice of penance. eith rung naachuhu rakh rakh paao So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||1|| poorae thaal jaanai saalaah Know that the perfect beat is the Praise of the Lord; hor nuchunaa khuseeaa mun maah other dances produce only temporary pleasure in the mind. ||1||Pause|| suth sunthokh vujehi dhue thaal Play the two cymbals of truth and contentment. pairee vaajaa sudhaa nihaal Let your ankle bells be the lasting Vision of the Lord. raag naadh nehee dhoojaa bhaao Let your harmony and music be the elimination of duality. eith rung naachuhu rakh rakh paao So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||2|| bho faeree hovai mun cheeth Let the fear of God within your heart and mind be your spinning dance, behadhiaa outhadhiaa neethaa neeth and keep up, whether sitting or standing. laettan laett jaanai thun suaahu To roll around in the dust is to know that the body is only ashes. eith rung naachuhu rakh rakh paao So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||3|| sikh subhaa dheekhiaa kaa bhaao Keep the company of the disciples, the students who love the teachings. gurumukh sununaa saachaa naao As Gurmukh, listen to the True Name. naanuk aakhun vaeraa vaer O Nanak, chant it, over and over again. eith rung naachuhu rakh rakh pair So dance in this love, and keep the beat with your feet. ||4||6|| ******************* thaeraa jun nirath kurae gun gaavai Your humble servant dances and sings Your Glorious Praises. rubaab pukhaavuj thaal ghunghuroo anehudh subudh vujaavai He plays upon the guitar, tambourine and cymbals, and the unstruck sound current of the Shabad resounds. ||1||Pause|| aisee nirath nuruk nivaarai naanuk gurumukh jaagai Such a dance eliminates hell; O Nanak, the Gurmukh remains wakeful. ||4||4||43|| ****************** naach rae mun gur kai aagai So dance, O mind, before your Guru. gur kai bhaanai naachehi thaa sukh paavehi anthae jum bho bhaagai If you dance according to the Guru's Will, you shall obtain peace, and in the end, the fear of death shall leave you. ||Pause|| ******************* eihu mun naachai sathigur aagai anehudh subudh dhun thoor vujeeaa This mind dances before the True Guru. The unstruck sound current of the Shabad resounds, vibrating the celestial melody.

Re: Sharam dee Gal

Sarbloh Soulja · 13 Dec 2003

Oh man, thats messed

Re: Sharam dee Gal

warrior*princess · 14 Dec 2003

i was shocked to see that one!