Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what is sikhi coming too...

what is sikhi coming too...

Disturbed · 14 Dec 2003

I was told by someone really close to me that they seen a bibi with a keski (from the looks of it, she looked like she was in grade 9) kissing a guy at school. This is so disturbing. What is Sikhi coming to, people with keski that date, cut, smoke, etc are giving the rest of us a bad name. They are also letting others think that these things are allowed in sikhi... This is so DISTURBING!!!!!

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Singhnee · 14 Dec 2003

VERY DISTURBING :(

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 14 Dec 2003

aaaaaahhhhh tha's grosse man

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 14 Dec 2003

let her parents worry about her you have nothing to do with it... it doesnt affect your sikhi, and how are they giving us a bad name... to who? everyone does that stuff... so how is it givin us a bad name... all it is showin that we are humans too... we are only human... and "disturbed" its none of our buisness what other people do unless its effecting us directly... and its just ninday if your sayin this... you didnt see it with your own eyes... its none of your or none of my buisness its for her and her parents not any of us so it may upset you but its just a part of life people have emotions people fall in love people do stupid things... who are we to judge.. are we so diffrent? are we so much better? I know my self Im not any better than anyone... I think its more disturbing that this is being posted on this message board... because its none of our buisness and its ninday

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 14 Dec 2003

I also belive the people who make "sikhs" look bad are the ones who act like they are better than everyone else... act like the rest of the world is bad act totally outa touch with this world... people are not perfect everyone has faults who are we to judge

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

:S · 14 Dec 2003

I don't think thats true. it just sounds so unrealistic.... think about it guys...... certain girls with keskis might be up to this sort of stuff..... but they're not DUMB enough to do this sort of behaviour in public? right? doing this manmat in private is horrible and shameless, and doing it in public is equally horrible, but it requires a whole new level of shamelessness to pull that off. i think girls with keskis generally have a better sense than that? if not, then yes, this is the most disgusting and disheartening thing i've ever heard. but i still don't think its true.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

? · 14 Dec 2003

where did this happen?

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Jagroop Singh · 14 Dec 2003

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Do the Seva of these people in a humble a good-willed manner. Find out who she is, talk to her and in a TRULY Guru-inspired Loving manner, point out the implications of her actions...ask her how she feels and why she is acting like this...is her home life ok...was she forced to wear The Keski...maybe there's lots of issues below the surface. If she carries on with her actions even after this, make contact with the Gursikh Sangat close to her...who should also make these attempts with Love... And most of all, do Ardaases for her...ask Guru Sahib to guide His lost sheep...Guru Sahib always listens to His Gursikhs. If she still doesn't refrain, and her Ahankaar and Kaam have got the better of her and are leading her evermore onwards, ask her politely to remove Guru's Sahib's Crown and then socially boycott her...it seems that Guru Sahib does not wish her to be in his Roop - Vahiguru's Bhana. Bhul chuk maaf karna. What do the GurSikhs think: Is such an approach Gurmat or not? Should less/more be done in such a situation? What does Guru Sahib sanction in such a situation? Can we use GurBani/Sikh History/Rehitnamae to forge out a Gurmat approach? Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

anon. · 14 Dec 2003

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh when i got into sikhi, i remember talking to my brother. we were in the same bed at the time. he was talking and i was doing naam simran. all of a sudden i froze. i could hear him talking, but i couldn't talk or move. his voice became quieter and i tried to move my arms and legs but couldn't. i then heard a real evil laugh. i thought 'what the heck is this'. then i remembered naam. i started doing simran in my mind and then suddenly it all stopped. everything was back to normal. Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

warrior*princess · 14 Dec 2003

:(((( I think that we can only help by telling those type of people, if possible, about why they should not pursue manmat actions...since it is our duty to do sikhi parchaar. But we have to approach with pyaar and not gussa....we must remember that it is by Vaheguru's will that they are mis-guided, and this can happen to anyone... so we should not come across as judgemental to 'em but instead helpful and caring.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

warrior*princess · 15 Dec 2003

Dear anon. , good thing you knew about Naam :D vaheguroo! :)

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 15 Dec 2003

its none of your buisness so dont interfere, you know what its like to have people getting into your buisness especially when they dont know what they are talking about... because they just "heard" something leave the poor girl alone... if she has done something wrong that is up to Guru ji to decide, mind your own buisness people

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

P · 15 Dec 2003

pyaario listen to 'G' i agree with his post but i do not agree with him for hating hindus and musulmaans

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

premi · 15 Dec 2003

VAHAGUROO JI KA KHALSA! VAHAGUROO JE KE FATEH!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT DO YOU MEAN (G) ! I DO NOT KNOW WHO YOU ARE BUT CAN NOT BELIEVE THAT YOU ARE A SIKH DAUGTER OR SON.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I AM A PARENT OF A 10 YEAR OLD DAUGHTER AND 2 YOUNGER SONS, I BRING MY CHILDREN UP WITH HIGH STANDARDS OF LOVE AND DEVOTION OF OUR GURU, AND THE TEACHINGS OF OUR RESPECTED LEADER BHAI SAHIB RANDHIR SINGH JI. WE LIVE IN ENGLAND AND ALL MY CHILDREN WERE DISTAARS TO SCHOOL. I HOPE THAT I HAVE TEACHED THEM LOVE ! RESPECT ! AND REHIT NAMA! THEY ARE YOUNG YET AND HAVE A LONG WAY TO GO, BUT IF THIS WAS MY DAUGHTER AND I WAS NOT THERE TO SEE THIS, THEN I WOULD HOPE THAT ONE OF OUR KHALSA FAMILY BROTHER OR SISTERS WOULD TELL HER THAT WHAT SHE WAS DOING WAS WRONG, AND HOPEFULLY WOULD INFORM ME SO I COULD SEE WHAT I WAS DOING WRONG !!!!, AND TRY TO HELP HER SEE WHAT A WONDERFULL CHANCE VAHAGUROO JI HAS GIVEN AS. SO PLEASE BEFORE WRITING ! TRY TO UNDERSTAND HOW BLESSED WE ARE! DO NOT JUGDE! BUT HELP OUR BROTHERS ! SISTERS ! DAUGHTERS ! SONS OUR KHALSA FAMILY !!!!!!! WE ARE THE KHALSA THE MIGHTY MIGHTY KHALSA !! BUT IF WE DO NOT WATCH OUT THERE WILL BE NOTHING, NOTHING AT ALL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. VAHAGUROO JI KA KHALSA ! VAHAGUROO JI KI FATEH !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

jagjit singh · 15 Dec 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, when I first kept my kesh, and starting coming into the sangat, I met many wonderful Gursikhs, including some inspiring biban. One day, a lad I met in a gurdwara, came and told me one of them bibian was going out with a muslim, and had a bad character. I was quite shocked by it, and really did not believe it, so just ignored it. Some time later, I got to know that same bibi through doing seva together at a camp. She was very dedicated to sikhi, and an excellent role model. So I mentioned to her older brother, what that lad had said, and said we should stop the ninda. A few weeks later we cornered that lad in at a gurdwara, and asked him why he was spreading lies. He finally admitted, he has secretly liked that bibi, and asked her out, but she was strong in her sikhi, and told him she does not do things like that. Anyway this rejection made him spread lies about her, to other youth, especially anti-akj circles, because she was keski wale bibi. Anyway after a strong talking to, he admitted his mistake, and to his credit a few days later he went and apologised to that bibi for his ninda. She was not happy, but did forgive him. He since has learned from that and become a quite sincere young man. The moral is do not always believe everything you hear. especially ninda about another Gursikh. Always give a Gursikh the benefit of the doubt, remembering many people have many agendas. However even if it is true, do something constructive to bring that person back on the path of Guru Ji. But do not put wieght on yourself of more ninda. Otherwise are not just as big a paapi as her? waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

warrior*princess · 15 Dec 2003

excellent post veer jee!!

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Surrey Singh · 15 Dec 2003

VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH Hey "G"...i must say that what you are saying is nothing but manmat. You are saying its none of our business what she is doing?...look buddy, when we see our Khalsa brothers and sisters straying from the Path, we don't turn our heads the other way. It is our duty to help each other out. Maybe this girl needs someone to remind her that what she is doing is a kurat, and she is no longer Khalsa. Personally, i would approach this girl, and tell her if she has any fear of God, she would repent, and Pesh, because if she got hit by a car, and died today, she would die with her back to Guru, and God knows where she would be heading. Sometimes people's Sikhi begins to lack, and they need someone to give them a rude awakening. VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Malton 187 · 15 Dec 2003

when we see a mona steal, how do we react? we might be concerned, but we just shrug it off. what do we do when see a sardar steal? we are totally shocked. we ask ourselves how someone could wear a distar or pug and steal. when we hear of a mona do something, its one thing. when hear an amritdhari do something, its extremely distrubing. why is it like this, we ask. to put it simply, we as sikhs have a responsibility to maintain the respect of our father, Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji and the purity of the Khalsa. unfortuantely, society labels people. in canada we have enough truoble with people not knowing about is, and this type of stuff makes matters worse. lets keep a look out for a sisters...

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 15 Dec 2003

Hey "Surrey Singh" mind your own buisness

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Dec 2003

hey "G" surrey singh is rite on

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 15 Dec 2003

ok and another thing... My personal experinces Ive been told by people... that I have had sex and I am like wow when did this happen... people been going around spreading rumors about me without knowing anything... you dont know how much this happens... I Started to hate "Gursikhs" because I heard so much bs from them they told me im doin this im doin that but I had done nuting.... My brothers and sisters are spreadin rumors about me, personally I just went with everyone let them say what they want.. sure I did that because its easyier because at least when "Gursikhs" think im bad they leave me alone because they dont want to be associated with somone who is a "manmukh" now life is great I dont hear nuting from "Gursikhs" They dont stick their noses in my buisness... and in actual reality I have done nuting... but its nice for them to think I have because they leave me alone... it is kinda sad though because I only have about 4 Gursikh friends that I trust or really talk to... I guess the point im tryin to get accross is that just because somone said something doesnt mean there is any truth to it what so ever and these rumors can be very harmfull to the person and can ruin their lifes think now if this girls name gets circulated around and she wants to get married in the future and her fiance hears she was kissing a guy (when in reality she wasnt) and he breaks off the wedding... do you understand what Im sayin it is manmut to even be speakin of this as far as Im concerned because the more you talk about it the more people find out the more the girls reputation will go down the drain the more ninday is being done... so when I say mind your own buisness I mean... mind your own sikhi... like I said IF this has not effected you directly then mind YOUR OWN BUISNESS... if you where the person who saw it dont tell anyone else and you can go strait to the persons parents... but otherwise this should be discussed

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 15 Dec 2003

I dont know when I see you Gursikhs acting like this It pushes me farther away from sikhi... it hurts I dont understand how you could even think of doing this to another Gursikh thinking your doing the right thing... you dont know how much it wieghs on a persons mind when this happens... this is not sikhi... sikhi is your own personal sikhi when you die you dont take other peoples sikhi with you... you take your own

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 15 Dec 2003

hey "GABROO KHALISTAN DAH" I dissagree

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

kakaree · 16 Dec 2003

There are couple instances -one where it is said one girl is wearing keski cuz she was caught with a boy and her parents threatened to send her to India if she didn't tie distar. So she just got sneakier and make sure she don't get caught, tie distar, sit on stage and every one look up at her. Still she hasn't accepted getting married. Don't know what she does anymore or what is true or not, don't really care. I love her and give her love so inside she will want to be good. Another one where lots of folks shunned some one cuz they found out some stuff and started threatening beatings etc. Finally that person went away to where the sangat gave love, then behaviour slowly began to improve from inside. People are people. If character is bad, it may be due to influence or flaw - while shutting them out may make them act better on the outside - inside same thing is going on. It can't get better cuz there is no love to make it better- there is just hurt. Remember Guru Nanak wore different garb not hindu not muslim some of both. What someone may wear is not going to give one pyar or make anyone holy. People with young children better off crossing their fingers rather than pointing them at others- give them as much love and understanding of your values as you can now and then be prepared to have your heart broken anyway later on - hope and pray that it may not come to a choice between accepting or shunning your own childs behaviour. I have my own problems, but because of shunning mentality there is no one I can risk talking to about what really goes on inside me except for waheguru who already knows everything and sees bigger picture then me. One thing I know is that what I was most down on others for and most judging of, I had to go through myself. I love everybody but I just don't want to be around people that shun those who are in so much need of love. Shunning is done out of fear and selfishness. If you can't love someone unconditionally then your love is merely selfish and not really love at all. The same goes for your sikhi. If it is selfish sikhi it is based on homai. Think for a minute. When Guru Nanak travelled and he met up with Sajan Thug. He didn't shun him at all, but went to him and in the most kind and loving way won his heart. Beatings and shunning make it impossible for someone on the wrong track to trust anyone enough to open up and be honest. It makes it very difficult to get on the right track again. It is my feeling that it takes someone with a very dirty heart or very dirty mind in the first place to assume someone else is dirty. If i had to guess i would think maybe this girl had genuine innocent feelings of love and went to express them. Problem is then the reproductive drive sets in and the body gets caught up in the act of procreation. This is something entirely natural, but with out any healthy/appropriate outlet. Look at what ages our Guru entered the state of matrimony. Guru gobind singh was 15 years old and had a wife. But in our modern society everyone is so worried about education and status that marriage is put off. We have healthy young adults with no appropriate outlets postponing marriage in to late 20's and early 30' and for some of them more than others it creates a lot of difficulty and stress, guilt and shame. Then we have others judging gossiping pointing fingers. Beatings go on and even murders all to save face. It's hard to want to associate with sangat if it all it comes down to is judging others in interest of making oneself look good. What has happened to having sangat for sake of praising waheguru?

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mr. Singh · 16 Dec 2003

well said kakaree

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Surrey Singh · 16 Dec 2003

VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH ok..."G"...i agree with you about not feeding on rumours heard about people. It's not hard to ruin someone's reputation by going around telling people lies about others. After more and more people hear about these rumours, people begin to think: "Well, everyone's saying it...it must be true" so, i agree with you that we shouldn't believe everything we hear, but if we actually see something with our own eyes, then it's different. I think at that point, it is our farj (responsibility) to help out our brothers/sisters, by reminding them of what they are doing, and the potential consequenses. I know some people might say, "they already know what they are doing is wrong"...but sometimes people need to actually hear it from others in order to realize just how wrong it really is. The evil mind will just make up excuses for everything, and make a person believe that what they are doing is not that bad...or it will tell you, "don't worry, do it now, and then start doing Bhagti, and everything will be forgiven"...so...i don't think we should believe rumours, or spread them, but if you see it yourself, then don't just turn your head the other way, help the fallen soldier back up. VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 16 Dec 2003

yeh thats fair if you see it then its fine... if you just heard it then ignore it... me personally if I saw it I wouldnt care either way... I would probally give them props for kissing... I guess only because Im tired of seeing everyone flip out over nothing.... I like to see the elder sikhs go crazzy "omg they kissed thats soo wrong" haha kissin is nothing in the first place sikhi doesnt even mention it... I just think people flip out over somone kissin another person... but when it comes down to Gursikhs backstabbing each other why are Gursikhs ok with that? you act like kissing is soo bad but if another Gursikh stabs me in the back its ok... One is an act of love... the other is an act of hate... which one is worse? there are soo many worse things "gursikhs" do than kissing but they are accepted... but when it comes down to them "likeing" each other or kissing itss soooo bad omggg "gursikhs" arent aloud to fall in love with each other thats soooo wrongg!!! haha oh well I know you guys dont share my opinion at all... thats fine but I think its silly that you think you have the right to pick your childrens husband/wife especially when that has nothing to do with sikhi thats just punjabi culture... but I guess "gursikhs" like to mix punjabi culture with Sikhi... they cant tell the diffrence most of the time

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

? · 16 Dec 2003

g "gursikhs" like to mix punjabi culture with Sikhi" not all gursikhs are like that.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

warrior*princess · 17 Dec 2003

G jee, you wrote: >>>thats fine but I think its silly that you think you have the right to pick your childrens husband/wife especially when that has nothing to do with sikhi thats just punjabi culture<<< Yes parents do have that right, if they fed and helped the child to grow into an adult with Guru jee's kirpaa, then hanjee they have the right to be involved when it comes to the daughters or sons marriage so that they know the kids have found a good partner to marry to. Parents naturally care for their childs well-being. Often parents make the decision 'with' the daughter/son, and most cases the daughter/son is accepting of this! The world is under Akaal Purakhs command, nothing evolves outside of that hukum...therefore when gursikhs parents decide to become involved in rishtaa matters, they are right to do so and it is Sikhi! OTHERWISE, it can only end up being like some dating agency. If parents did not help in the matter, then the persons wanting to get married will start looking by themselves and then will actually approach potential partners in person - and it is highly unlikely it may not work out in the end or there are problems....going from one person to the next in person is just losing respect for yourself whether you are male/female...this is not okay without parents involvement unless there is a very good reason....but if parents cannot help in the matter then a respected gursikh can be requested to do the sevaa for them of finding a partner. Then the person involved with the parents can decide further as to whether they wish to pursue the rishtaa. Guru Sahib jee wants us to have faith in EVERYTHING...this means, we have to surrender our MAT/ mind to Guru jee...by doing that, we accept that Guru jee understands our needs and will help us resolve our affairs, in return we keep reht. If we cannot keep such bharosaa in Guru Sahib jee then we have not truly given our heads, i.e. minds to Guru Sahib jee. Also, we are either Sikhs or we are not. There is no half way. Therefore, punjabi culture has not place in GurSikhi jeevan, because we cannot be traditional and religious at one time....our footsteps must be towards Guru jee, any other direction just has to be the wrong way/ path. Veer jee if you believe the practise of tradition is allowed in a GurSikhi jeevan, then please present Gurbanee, which states this. Lastly you said: >>but when it comes down to them "likeing" each other or kissing itss soooo bad omggg "gursikhs" arent aloud to fall in love with each other thats soooo wrongg<< If any adultry is committed, that is a bujjer kureht, therefore if you were a parent of a daughter/son who pursued such an action, you would definately be saying 'OMG!', and will try to fix the situation. As for GurSikhs falling in love....thats their business & is ONLY okay IF the couple are married!!! Other than that, Gurbanee explains again and again how our ultimate and true love really is for Akal Puraakh, Vaheguru jee. No other love or satisfaction can compare. This achievement is one of the goals of a gursikh married couple. We males/females are the soul brides of Vaheguru jee, our destination is to become one with Akal Purakh, in SaachKhand...until then we have to endure punishment or circle of life and deaths, or come again in the womb etc. So lets start making the most of this jeevan while we have the comforts in this lifestyle.. Vaheguru jee is the Great Giver, but we are the Ungrateful Beasts.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

singh · 17 Dec 2003

jis a(n)dhar chugalee chugalo vajai keethaa karathiaa ous dhaa sabh gaeiaa || One whose heart is filled with malicious gossip, is known as a malicious gossip; everything he does is in vain. par ni(n)dhaa mukh thae nehee shhoottee nifal bhee sabh saevaa ||1|| Your mouth has not stopped slandering and gossiping about others. Your service is useless and fruitless. ||1|| chugal ni(n)dhak bhukhae rul mueae eaenaa hathh n kithhaaoo paae || The gossipers and slanderers shall remain hungry and die, rolling in the dust; their hands cannot reach anywhere. You wanna know what disgusts me..........what i find gross 25 postings about gossiping on a sikhi phorum...... focus on yourself........not the buisness of others Thought this was a phorum of gursikhs.......not old bibis drinking cha and gossipinh

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Akali_Fauj · 17 Dec 2003

>You wanna know what disgusts me..........what i find gross >25 postings about gossiping on a sikhi phorum...... >focus on yourself........not the buisness of others Veerji, These people are just giving their own opinion. You are right that one should focus on themselves. But when these issues are being addressed in Sikhi, it should be okay for them to be discussed. We gain our knowledge when we discuss issues amongst each other and come to a reasonable conclusion. No one is bad mouthing this girl, they are just stating how this is wrong and should be stopped. The responses that have been given might knock some sense into someone else that is dating, and for this, this is a good thread. The saying goes, one should not be quick to judge others. you can tell others that ninda is not good and should not be done, but the sad truth is that we all do it. Before we preach something we should be able to live up to it. If someone is going to go around telling others that gossiping is wrong, then they should first fix their own ways. Gossiping is wrong, but in this situation no one is gossiping. the girls identity has not been revealed and everyone is giving their opinion on this issue and what should be done.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 17 Dec 2003

soo Parents have the right to pick your husband wife because - "they fed and helped the child to grow into an adult with Guru jee's kirpaa" give me a break... There is no reason for a Parent to pick your husband/wife they can aprove or disaprove they have that right... but they dont have to spend every day with this person sleep with this person procreate with this person... what Gives Them that right? because they raised u? well guess what when they get old Im gonna be taking care of them just like they took care of me when I was young soo I think the debt is repaid right there... they dont have ANY right to pick your husband/wife... its a selfish thing for parents to do that to a child... and it has no bases in sikhi... parents picking their childrens parents is punjabi culture NOT Sikhi so dont ever use sikhi as a reason for that its an insult, besides most parents who pick their childrens mate pick them based upon if they make alot of money... or what caste they are... now you know in sikhi there is no caste... but even really strick gursikhs said to me they wouldnt marry their children outside their caste... why? because they said there family's will get along better, wow these are great reasons for them to marry each other... wow I wouldnt want parents like that picking my wife, only thing parents have the right to do is Approve or dissaprove... you parents swear you have done so much for your children... you dont even understand them... what did you really do you brought them into this world? DID THEY ASK YOU? why would you bring somone into this horrible world anyways... ok so you raised them brought them up... well they are going to have to take care of you when your too old to take care of your self... so what else have you really done for them... you dont try to understand them you just say these are the rules this is how it is... your very selfesh you can say all you want your looking out for the best interests of your children... well News flash you dont allways know whats best for your children... but its ok you can be egotistic and think you do... its up to you

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Singh 0 · 17 Dec 2003

Whats new unfortunatly we all knows that SOME keski wearing peoplr are not really spiritual but wear it for packhand or because their parents or freinds wear it. Sometimes such things actually begin at Rainsebais by the Jatha

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003

Much has been written on this topic. A concerned gursikh wrote about an incident that bothered him. I don’t understand what wrong did this gursikh do by sharing his disappointment in a person wearing keski and doing anti-gurmat activities. My advice is that you correct this girl who was wearing a keski and kissing someone at school or where ever. If you are not comfortable with her, then let her parents know about this. Her parents will be grateful to you for letting them know about their girl. If she is corrected now, it can save her spiritual life. You actually would be helping her by trying to correct her. To ignore it is totally wrong. Would you ignore it if it was your own sister? Same way all amritdharis are brothers and sisters. We should try to help. Of course if they don’t want to hear, then you would leave them alone but we should at least try once. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

? · 17 Dec 2003

bhai sahib parents and families dont always recieve that well. some parents and brothers flip and accuse you of doing nindia of their family, i have been in that boat before and my friendship was ruined as a result with one of my brothers who i had known since kindergarten when i told him his sister was doin summit wrong.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

kakaree · 17 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh This whole anti-gurmat attitude completely sickens me. We have young people brought up to a way of life and they are doing their best with it. They are GOOD because what they have been given is good. But they still have struggles. After the ik on kar symbol the first word in gurbani is sat- truth- The truth is a very high majority of any dastar bibi I know personally and correspondingly the unmarried singhs especially those who sit on stage (probably because they are the ones I know best) are all involved in one way or another in this girl-boy stuff. The ones who aren't is lack of opportunity so point and gossip maliciously about ones who are and the little ones are watching and can't wait til they big enough. The ones i don't know about is probably because i don't know them well enough to know whats going on with them, and then for benefit of doubt let's say there are some innocents. And I'm not trying to be unkind, just tell it like it is. WE need to really face up to the truth of this before we can do anything about it. Another truth is that it is a cultural bias to call it anti-gurmat and wrong and bad behaviour. What is wrong about it is that it is mostly deceitful behaviour because of the predjudice and back biting that goes on associated with it. So it takes a more subversive form. Creates a kind of isolation (like through shunning) so there is no support or safety net. And yes who said it begins in the rainsubhais is right on. So what are we going to do tell them all to take off their crowns, strip them of the only tools/defences/weapons they have and kick them into the world unarmed. There goes our next generation. What is going on is completely natural normal courtship behaviour that is part of the creators design. What is wrong about it is that it can cause all kinds of trouble, social and otherwise. Maybe we can sort out what makes it anti-gurmat, so at least I can understand this better. Someone said it is ok only to fall in love if you are married. Love is not something someone chooses, what they do about it is. The thing is young people that what ever you do in life is training and becomes habit. Dating, getting physically intimate with this or that person with out commitment leads to disappointment heartbreak, unwanted pregnancy, abortion, abandonment and spreading of disease. Help me out people I'm sure you can think of more. When you do get married and you get discouraged or attractions happen, you fall back on your experience and there goes your marriage. Because If your MO has been changing partners when things didn't work out, or following up on attraction then what do you think is likely to happen? Our gurus gave us practical wisdom. Save it (the behaviour) for committed relationship and you can bypass a huge mess of problems. If you go for it, you are taking on on the problems that come along with it. You think DISTURBED was disappointed when he or she heard this story. Well think of the poor girl the story is about. Everybody is now discussing her personal business. Before long this romantic adventure is likely to fizzle out, her little heart gets broken and goes looking for someone else to fix it. At some point her parents catch on. If she's lucky and they have good communication maybe some good will come of it. But if she's not, she could be scorned, put down, possibly beaten, maybe even forced into a marriage she doesn't want. And yes alot of folks are in denial. They refuse to hear truth because it couldn't possibly be that way because it doesn't fit it with what they want to acknowledge. Just like a bunch of you are choking on my opening statement, and denying it is true or it is you. (Good for you if it isn't :) But even if it is. Hey you are a human being doing what you were designed for. The thing is nobody is going to be hurt more than you by the consequences, (even if no one ever finds out). Acceptance is the first step towards the possibility of change. And why do we want this change because we love and care for you and want to see you have the best possible life. We know that if you can get out of your bio-logical predicament for just and instant that you can be logical. When you are logical you can think. Isn't this why we give our head to guru. So we can follow gurus logic. Its not so much about "right and wrong" anti- this or pro that, good or bad, as it is what is right and wrong for you, what effect you are having on your own life and your own future. Everyone had different personal circumstances, still every one shares general social circumstances. What i would really like to see if this discussion continues is solution oriented posting. Supportive behaviour and interaction. Yes when your brother or sister falls on the battle field pick them up. But don't tell them how bad they are for falling. Gurbani says that we are lovingly held and our faults are over looked and never even considered. So can't we do that for each other. We can Say hey singho singhni I know what you really want deep down inside is love. You are worried is any one going to love you. You want to experiment with attraction and that's natural. But it is a pitfall and a trap like quicksand, it can suck you under, so be really careful. Lets talk about your goals and how they can be effected/affected by what you are going through. Let's give each other tons of love, mega tons of unending inexhaustable love. Let's uplift each other. If we can't get through right away to someone what are we going to do? - give up or give love. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

no way · 17 Dec 2003

ANYONE WHO READ KAKAREE'S POST: BE CAREFUL!!!!!!! this kind of thinking pushes people into fulfilling their lustful desires. we look at people in the western world saying, "it's a natural thing, its ok". well, its not ok. TV and western thinking has warped your mind so much, that you are forgetting your Guru's teachings. Don't do it! fight your urges! do Ardas! kakaree, you are hurting the youth by saying these things. Many youth are having a hard time controlling kaam, and ur post is just giving them an excuse to 'give in to their feelings'. also, don't go out there saying that most bibis/singhs are involved in this manmat. maybe its just your friends? i'm not saying that nobody does it, its just that ALOT don't do it, and maybe you haven't met them. i know you will respond with ur fancy words, and i hope the sangat doesn't get any 'rehat harming' ideas from them.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 17 Dec 2003

"no way" first off all karkee is tryin to say... Young girls/boys are going to do what they want and if they get caught they are just going to hide it more and go behind their parents backs more... and If parents would just be more understanding instead of punishing them cutting them off from all their friends gettin them married off... the parents would get much better results... but parents arent understanding and they punish their kids.. and the result is the kids end up worse, all she was sayin was we are human we have urges try to understand that b4 you call us bad Parents should be understanding but they arent... so why dont you apologize to karkaree for sayin what you had said jut because you could not understand it.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 17 Dec 2003

lets switch up here for a moment... the topic is What is sikhi coming to... its focusing on a girl kissin a boy... why is this focused on there is much worse things happening to sikhi than this... this is nothing its not even a pen prick... how about how sikhi is splitting up into diffrent groups... how about how sikhs are allways fighting... how about the Gurdwaras that are ran by monay who drink and smoke... how about Gursikhs backstabbing each other... how about Greed Egotism.... how about all this? why do we focus on one little girl when this is all happening and we dont hear a peep about it, What is sikhi coming to? its falling apart its not a spec of what it was in Guru ji's time sangat is split up everyone is fighting... me my self I get angry I have so much krodh towards many Gursikhs.. this Is what sikhi is coming to not some girl kissing why would you even bring that up its of so little signifigance its not any of our buisness in the first place... it just seems so sad here we are with all these problems in sikhi and somone is talking about some ninday they heard Sikhis about piyar love not about whos right and wrong not about all these little things piyaar is the most important thign in sikhi and we choose to ignore it and concentrate on other things... thats what sikhi is coming to and it sad very sad

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

ping · 18 Dec 2003

on the one hand ur told to fight ur urges, then we r told to lead greesti jeevan to overcome that, then shud we get marrid to overcome it then? does that mean we shud marry at young ages? where this procreation thing urge will be overcome?

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

kakaree · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Dear "no way", You are putting words in my mouth. I'm not telling anyone to go for it because its natural. I'm saying that is's natural because it is natural, and that you have to be careful that you don't get sucked in by natural urges and do something you'll be sorry for later. I don't need any apology from you if you misunderstood that's ok, and if you don't tell me, I'm not going to be able to correct the misconception. Try reading it all again and see that what has been said is that there is a tremendous amount of problems that can occur by giving in. So what is going to stop someone from giving in. Thinking they are bad? NO If they think they are bad and what they are doing is bad they may just give up and give in. It needs to be understood that what is going on goes on with nearly everyone. Either in an appropriate way or in an unappropriate way. What will keep someone from giving in is knowing there are consequences, and some of these cannot be hidden from others because they happen to you personally and you are stuck with it then. Choices can be made based on knowing consequences and avoiding the behaviour that causes them. Also i'm NOT saying go for it because everyone else is. What is being said is that all lot of stuff is going on that is being denied. If it is denied then it is very hard to make changes for the better."No way" you yourself stated youth have a hard time controlling kaam. Well that is exactly my point. If the problem is acknowledged then there is a chance to help young people develop skills for dealing with the issue. Just telling them they are bad and making them feel guilty is not going to be very effective. They just get better at hiding what they are doing and hiding from their guilt. That does not mean the problem has gone away. I feel sad because I wonder do we have a particularly screwed up sangat? It was certainly easier to be in the dark and think everybody was perfect. I worry about these youth too. If mistakes are made then the consequences have to be suffered. There is no way around it. If we can give enough love and encourage each other to have courage and confide in each other when confronted with this kind of stuff. We can help each other out of it.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Balpreet Singh · 18 Dec 2003

I think that the point being driven across is this: humans have a weakness and that is attraction to the other gender. This is a weakness that Gurmat helps us overcome. However, if someone falters and makes a mistake, we should not shun them or condemn them. We should understand they are humans and have made a mistake. We should help them see their mistake and give them our assitance in coming back to the path. I think others have tried to point out that this problem is more common than we may think and we shouldn't condemn anyone who is discovered or be very shocked. I agree with all of the above. But at the same time I think that having a boyfriend or girlfriend is not appropriate and is against Gurmat. If someone we know is making this mistake, we should speak to them. If we do not, we are in fact betraying that friend and not doing him/her a favour. If we see someone drowning, we cannot walk away and say it's not our business. In the same way if somone is spiritually drowning we cannot ignore it. Why so many posts on this topic? Because it's probably something every young Sikh will have to face or has faced. I think we can all agree on these facts.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 18 Dec 2003

The mojority of young gursikhs have dated... all the ones i know have it seems silly they go to keertans and the are all checking each other out... so for those of you who think that it doesnt happen... it does some people are just better at hidein it than others...

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 18 Dec 2003

> humans have a weakness and that is attraction to the other gender. Right, one of our most basic survival instinct is a "weakness." You go on keep believing that.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Balpreet Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Dorothy, I think I've mentioned that your contributions to this forum and others are generally very confrontational and rude. The same applies to the above post. Kaam/Lust is a weakness that makes an individual go crazy for the body of another person. Under the influence of kaam people can make big mistakes that they regret later and even crimes like sexual assault, etc. Kaam is a feeling that a Sikh tries to overcome. If you do not agree that it is something that needs to be overcome, then that is your opinion. This is a Sikh forum and I'm pretty sure the Admins aren't going to allow someone to promote the "benefits" of kaam/lust.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

kakaree · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Bhai Balpreet singh ji, You seem kind and so i'm asking for your help. I don't disagree with you, but i need you to elaborate on >"having a boyfriend or girlfriend is not appropriate and is against Gurmat." I could give you lists on pros and cons the dangers (and downright disgusting aspects) of dating as well the benefits of getting to know someone well enough to know whether you are suitable for each other as lifemates. So what i need from you (and others) is really practical information, guidelines for behaviour what is or isn't acceptable and why. And how does this relate to gurmat. Just telling me it goes against it, closes down the avenue of communication rather than opening it. You are right every one has to face these issues sometime. If we can open up enough and be accepting enough we can provide a valuable service for our youth. If not there are other avenues they can and do turn to. I have seen them on other msg boards where these human relations are the topic of disscussion. It goes something like i had/have a boy/girl friend - if my family knew i would be dead, its against my relgion and so on. It is possible this is a brand new problem for Sikh Youth, because of changes and exposure to permissive western culture, compounded by the internet and the global climate. Part of the problem is sikh youth grow up in a repressed atmosphere at home and at sikh functions, then they go to school where anything and everything goes. When they begin to experiment with each other, they really have no idea of appropriate conduct, they go way overboard. Even after growing up in the US and in a very permissive environment, I am continually shocked by Sikh Youth behaviour as some are much more forward and explicit then all but the roughest sort of characters i have ever encountered. I don't think they are bad, in fact mostly they are quite innocent, however they simply seem to have no idea of the limits of social conduct once they overstep the strict boundries they were raised with. This endangers them much more then if they had some idea of how to act reasonably around the opposite gender. It could be likened to a half grown pup who has been kept confined in a small kennel and suddenly the gate flies open and it runs out with pent up energy leaping and bounding about. Dorothy every thing has two faces like a coin. The strength of the basic survival Instinct can also pose one of the greatest weakness depending on whether it controls someone or they control it. What we want to do is develop practical guidelines and skills for self control.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Balpreet Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Kakaaree, Your question is a valid one. If not boyfriends and girlfriends, then what?? I have seen some Singhs try to come up with a "new" type of courtship for Sikh people that attempts to keep behaviour within certain limits and bounds. I havn't seen those Singhs succeed in finding a partner nor have they been able to avoid causing serious problems for themselves. Frankly, I believe that a Singh or Kaur should stay in sangat. When they feel they want to get married, talk to older Gursikhs or parents. I don't support finding your own partner as this causes a lot of problems: I've seen unrequited love, misinterpreted intentions, people going too far and commiting a bujjer kurehit, deceiving families. It's too much of a problem.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

G · 18 Dec 2003

I believe if 2 people talk to each other and are interested in getting married they should tell there parents... and then they should work something out... and they can do that b4 the relationship developes into anything more... but its not set up like that if they tell their parents... their parents get upset make them stop talkin to the person say no for whatever reasons caste, job, degree, race... or they just dont like it because they dont like their children "likeing" somone... since its like this... when they start to like each other... they have to hide it from their parents... and therefore it developes into something more... they start doing whatever going behind their paretns backs... its because their parents arent understanding... so they have to do it this way... if they could just tell there parents they are interested in this person... and wanted to marry them and their parents where ok with it... and let them talk and get to know each other better it would be fine... there's nothing wrong with that...but its not like that because of how irrational everyone thinks and how they act... if your child dates... you really have no one to blame besides your selfs... that would be the best solution to dateing... because when they talk at least you know they are and you are there to make sure its appropriate so i dont know its up to you... you can either have your children do it behind your backs or infront of you...

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 18 Dec 2003

Dear Dorothy.. eating is a basic human instinct.. what if we go outside and start eating trees and grass because we are hungry? we will get sick.. what if we just start eating and eating and eating.. we will get really really fat.. so eating can be bad and unhealthy, depending on circumstances right? so can sex. its an instinct for having children, but you want to do it for pleasure. why dont u keep doing it without protection and have a kid everytime you meet a guy? thats how nature intended it right? why dont u get some diseases? and where do you stop? why does western culture have such things as statutory rape? sex crimes? obviously western society also sees a problem with sex, we just have different definitions. in africa theres a huge aids epidemic.. you would never see this in a sikh community.. why? because we have standards.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

beant singh chagghar · 18 Dec 2003

thats all fair enough but lets be practical, what if your not from jatt ancestry? how many families are gonna help you find a keski vali wife? theres quiet a few sikh amritdhari men in their prime who have approached the panth and are often knocked back in polite ways with answers like " we dont know anyone" etc. and such gursikhs are forced to break their rehet and marry outside of the jatha through their own families setting up rishte with girls who arent even amritdhari let alone keski valee bibiya. This of course leads to life pattern changes which conflict with the rehet of a sikh as well as dreams of leading a gursikhi jeevan as taught and practiced by earlier gursikhs. im not saying dating is a way out or a right method of course it leads to lust and lust is what each sikh shud fight even when married, qoutes of bani refer to lust not unmarried lust or married life unlimited lust. but this thing of elder gursikhs setting up rishte only works for some and not for all under the prevailing circumstances. A process which would need correction in future not to deny or push aside which leads to further complications. This of course is as big a problem as youth dating although not the prime cause or effect. If the panth wants to stand together in every aspect then surely it must demonstrate otherwise people will see through it and wonder, what do i do when faced with ideology, values rehet in my life or practicality? it will become like 2 streets merged into one? right and wrong will not be on the persons mind clear cut as those who have a lot more at their disposal to practice the pratan rehet. This is not the 17 18 19th century we live in a highly competitive environment as it is with a lot more social interaction.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

kakaree · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Bhai Beant singh ji you stated>"lust is what each sikh shud fight even when married, qoutes of bani refer to lust not unmarried lust or married life unlimited lust." THANK YOU so much for this observation!!! It been said before that its only kaam if its before marriage but afterwards its not- However When the appetite for kaam is subdued it is very disturbing to encounter even within confine of marriage, having nothing to do with frequency (in this case quantity of action) but having every thing to do with frequency (as in transmitting in this case being tuned to vibrations of naam waves). This is a of paramount importance to someone living a spiritually oriented life to have a lifepartner who is also tuned to the spiritual vibration.. Bhai Balpreet singh ji Let us further address the subject of courtship. Thinking about it I'm guessing part of the problem with the youth is - because they brought up in a morally strict enviornment, As soon as the opportunity presents itself, they jump right into thinking that because they are talking with someone they might want to marry them (otherwise it would be wrong) so unfortunately real trouble starts because they then start thinking intimate behaviour is apropriate. It might be a good idea to put alot more stress on boys and girls behaving as siblings- we are one family and another person is our direct relative. Instead of discouraging interaction. We need to focus on actual guidelines on how to behave ( properly/appropriately) with the other gender - that doesn't come from as TV and movies as "NO WAY" pointed out. Also the youth need to know they can have friends and be friends ( in the platonic sense) with out being "girlfriend-boyfiend" When boys and girls are discouraged to interact with each other in the open in gurudwara setting, a conflicting msg is being given that person is not your brother or sister. Then too as soon as they get to school they can talk to anyone openly and you get problems like the one that started this thread. G had a very good point when stating that parents today are being faced with a choice, of their children either doing what they do with their supervision or behind their backs (where so much trouble can happen). If even one adult knows what is going on it is a safety valve, the child knows an adult knows and is more likely to set limits and keep them (more so then when its friends or peers who are aware.) A number of marriages 'have' taken place recently where the youth acted responsibly, involved their parents and married a partner of their choice. It has happened too when getting involved over their heads and things were going too far they were counseled to speak to the parents. In such cases, it sometimes takes time and alot of trust from the fearful child to initiate the communication and a lot of compassion understanding and fogiveness on the part of the parent. But gets things under control again. This is what we are striving for. More open communication and acceptance from the parents, so there can be effective interaction in the childs life. Unfortunately there is a huge problem with either denial or anger. Neither is of any help to the situation and both make it worse. I do feel hopeful though because if we here on this forum can stop judging and begin communicating, acknowledge the problem, provide counsel and guidance, it is a step towards helping sort things out. I feel as though this has begun. Thanks on behalf of all our youth Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 19 Dec 2003

>>>When boys and girls are discouraged to interact with each other in the open in gurudwara setting, a conflicting msg is being given that person is not your brother or sister. <<<< I totally agree.. ive grown up in this environment.. on one side we are told, hey thats your sister, they are all your sisters.. ok if they are my sisters why dont we actually spend time as a family.. ":O :O NO WAY!! SHES A GIRL you cant even talk to her!!!" big fat hypocrisy. We are very close to another family, have been all our lives, they have a daughter our age and this hypocrisy is always showing itself. a lot of the time we would be like a family, would treat each other as cousins, then other times they would not even allow us to speak in public (they meaning parents). its really strange how our society works if you think about it. ive never ever been able to put this into words, thank you so much kakaree jeeo. im not saying that we should just let everyone "run free" but we do need a degree of openness to truly be a family. we really need to rid ourselves of hypocrisy. Guru sahib says that hypocrisy is also an evil, if we practice it daily, what good is our simran/keertan?

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 19 Dec 2003

__Balpreet Singh said:__ >Kaam/Lust is a weakness that makes an individual go crazy for the body >of another person. Under the influence of kaam people can make big mistakes >that they regret later and even crimes like sexual assault, etc. So should we blame guns for killing people as well? Should we blame video games too? Does that sound silly to you? Blaming Lust as the reason for sexual assaults is just as silly. You can not blame sexual assault on a verb!! You must blame the person! __kakaree said:__ >Dorothy every thing has two faces like a coin. The strength of the basic survival >Instinct can also pose one of the greatest weakness depending on whether it controls > someone or they control it. > >What we want to do is develop practical guidelines and skills for self control So we have established that is it a basic survival instinct. Who gave us this basic survival instinct? God. But as Mkhalsa said, taking anything, even if it is a survival instinct, too far is detrimental to anyones health. From the responses I have seen here people seem to recommend a total withdrawal from any prurient desires which I don't think is the way to go. If god gave us the gift of lust, who are we to deny it? He gave us all of our basic instincts, and there is a reason for all of them. I always hear people saying, "Oh god gave you hair, why do you cut it and deny what he has given you," well I pose a similar question to you: God gave you lust, why do you deny it? Now I know someone will come in here and paste some random shabds they found on some website and run away without any of there own commentary... but I can't do anything about that, but hopefully someone will come and give me a rational reason for denying one thing from god and accepting another. The key to life is moderation. Don't let lust run your life, but at the same time don't avoid the gift god has given you.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 20 Dec 2003

dorothy, its simple.. the survival instinct is NOT lust. the instinct is procreation. lust is a pleasure whereas procreation is for survival. false pleasures take one away from god and hurt thier personal relationship with god. I know this personally. lust is detrimental to ones mental and spiritual well being.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

kakaree · 20 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Dorothy, the aim to strive for is balance. What we have is the 1st generation in the US and some 2nd generation in UK youth who are under lots of social pressures between the strict morals of Eastern Tradition and permissive western culture. You can look around you Dorothy and see the effects of uncommitted relationships. Self control is not a bad thing it's not necessarily even denying desire exists. But the ideal is to have desire be a tool, rather than be the tool of desire. And Yes our scriptures, shabads, meditation, do help to subdue and ease the demon that desire can become, causing undue stress, acting out or a host of problems. Also knowing social skills and appropriate behavior to keep relations ships in the proper confines of platonic love are very helpful. Part of setting limits and keeping them is knowing how to be able to interpret or read other peoples signals and use common sense. These can easily be misinterpreted. There was a singh who came from panjab. In his first year he saw a young man and woman who were working together and were on break. They had met just moments earlier. The man was seated and the woman began braiding his shoulder length hair. They were talking and being friendly. The singh was aware they had just met. Still He asked if they were getting married, and he was absolutely serious. (As it turned out neither of them wanted to listen to the other they both liked talking too much and the relation ship fizzled out quickly never going beyond those few minutes of chatting.) As you probably know Dorothy in the US it may take years of dating even living together before people marry. In India, it is not uncommon for a couple to never even meet previously to their wedding day. Every thing is arranged by family members. The children growing up here have parents whose marriages were arranged and expect them to think of others as sisters and brothers but at the same time as soon as they reach puberty even talking to each other is discouraged especially in public. These same youth go to public schools. They have no experience outside of what they get at school in dealing with the other gender. There are no guidelines set up except "don't talk or it’s against gurmat" How helpful is that? They are extremely vulnerable. For the most part these youth have a strong moral character and expectations for themselves. They want to be in committed relationships. But they end up hiding, sneaking, lying and feeling very guilty, about whatever they do, and thinking the solution is that they should marry the person they talk to. But they are often too young, not emotionally ready for the relationship they are in, much less marriage. Families are not involved and won't accept the person they are interested in. It causes problems, and things can get very messy. What MSKhalsa refers to as hypocrisy goes on. Everyone is concerned about reputation and image. It's very easy in this crossing of cultural barriers for that to be misread. So families who may have relaxed and open communications with their children/parents will still impose strictures to protect their children where there is a possibility of their being misread or misunderstood. It's a sensitive situation. It will take time and perseverance and compassion to resolve, and the absolute affirmation that the goal is worth the endeavor.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

ĤĀ&# · 20 Dec 2003

dorothy if it is your real name i was wondering, if you don'y beleive anything from gurbani, then what the hell arer you doing here? If you question everything that pops up about bujjer kurayts and say it is ok, then what are you doing on this forum? Personally i doon care about what you think about how people should be able to do whatever, but if you are going to criticize everything why are you here? What i mean is if you don't beleive in what sikhism preaches then why go and argue? now asumming that you are chirstan, should i go around asking how the hell did a virgin give birth? It would be beneficial for you to either accept skhism or if you don't, stop arguing with every ristriction. It is people like you that probably have aid and going to die at the age of 55 saying whatever I lived my life, and the rest of you wasted it. Well i really dont care if you beleive in being a player or whatever but aleast dont try to convince others its okay. the piont of sikhi is the get rid of the five evils, of which lust is probably the most dangerous, and progress to higher stages of sprituality. And if you agree with then keep it to yourself.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 20 Dec 2003

__Mkhalsa said:__ >the survival instinct is NOT lust. the instinct is procreation. >lust is a pleasure whereas procreation is for survival. But lust and procreating go hand in hand. Ever wonder why procreation feels so good? >false pleasures take one away from god and hurt thier personal >relationship with god. How can it be a false pleasure when god gave you this pleasure? How can it hurt my personal relationship with god? Let's compare two things. One procreating and the other kirtan. We are both accepting as a fact that god created humans correct? So on one hand we have a pleasure that god instinctively gave us and on the other hand we have a more or less man crafted pleasure (the hymns may be divine, but the musical and mechanical aspects of it are definitely man made, so at best we can say it is a 50/50 god/human construct). Now you tell me, how can a pleasure that god gave me be bad, while a man made pleasure (kirtan) can be good? Are you questioning gods divine wisdom? Are you saying your man made creation of kirtan is more worthy than the simple pleasure of procreation god gave you? >I know this personally. lust is detrimental to ones mental and >spiritual well being. Perhaps for you. But you can't say that just because it is detrimental your your mental health it is also detrimental for everyones mental health. One solution does not work for all. For you it may be detrimental, for me it may be beneficial.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 21 Dec 2003

Dorothy, Nobody here asked you to become a Sikh. I never told you that what I do or don't do should effect you in anyway. Besides, what do you know about spiritual health. I will not brush you off, if thats what your thinking. I'm going to reply to the best of my limited knowledge. And who questioned gods divine wisdom? its you who are questioning it. First off, god created maya, this illusion for us to live in, without it we are really kind of lost and drifting. Maya is where our bodies are. Hmm.. i think kulbir singh jee could best explain this part as I do have a hard time putting things into words at times. Anyway, this maya only distracts us from god and keeps us from him. It depends on our karams, our free will, and gods grace of how we react to maya. If we fully indulge in it and get "pleasure" from it then that is our perogative, but then we made a personal choice to be stuck in it and continue reincarnating. You are making us all think about sikhi from different perspectives, for this, I am thankful and your doubts only seem to ground me more in sikhi. But the real pleasure, an immesurable pleasure is in amrit bani and keertan. Its indescribable. No drug, no boyfriend nothing can compare to the pleasure that meditation upon god gives us. It is your loss, I have nothing to gain from trying to show you that its 10000 times better than any "pleasure" you have experienced, and trust me, i know. how would you explain to an alien whos never eaten the pleasures of eating a chocolate cake with fudge ice cream? they would just look at you quizzically thinking ur a nut. thats exactly what you are doing. You look at us thinking we havent experienced your pleasures, trust me, most of the people reading this board have lived enough and they find the world vile and dispicable in its "pleasures." They have found the true pleasure and not a single person would turn back. why? because they are so happy and full of pleasure all day every day, how about that? i mean, your boyfriend probably leaves and goes home, your drugs wear off... but the power of Naam, that stays with you, its in your blood, its in your heart, and that never leaves, and once you have it, you never want to turn back. Guru sahib says those who have naam are addicted to it and go after it like a crack addict would after crack, like a fish would after water!!! if somehow i lost my ability to do naam simran, id probably go insane. (i almost did after i realized i have bad allergies and cannot sing much with congregation.. that was something i seriously had to deal with) so in conclusion, The guru has given us the ultimate high, the ultimate experience, the ultimate pleasure, the ultimate food, the ultimate EVERYTHING and nothing you have or can do can possibly compare to that. NOTHING.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 21 Dec 2003

aasaa mehalaa 5 || paavath raleeaa joban baleeaa || naam binaa maattee sa(n)g raleeaa ||1|| kaan ku(n)ddaleeaa basathr oudtaleeaa || saej sukhaleeaa man garabaleeaa ||1|| rehaao || thalai ku(n)chareeaa sir kanik shhathareeaa || har bhagath binaa lae dhharan gaddaleeaa ||2|| roop su(n)dhareeaa anik eisathareeaa || har ras bin sabh suaadh fikareeaa ||3|| maaeiaa shhaleeaa bikaar bikhaleeaa || saran naanak prabh purakh dhaeialeeaa ||4||4||55|| Aasaa, Fifth Mehl: The mortal revels in joy, in the vigor of youth; but without the Name, he mingles with dust. ||1|| He may wear ear-rings and fine clothes, and have a comfortable bed, and his mind may be so proud. ||1||Pause|| He may have elephants to ride, and golden umbrellas over his head; but without devotional worship to the Lord, he is buried beneath the dirt. ||2|| He may enjoy many women, of exquisite beauty; but without the sublime essence of the Lord, all tastes are tasteless. ||3|| Deluded by Maya, the mortal is led into sin and corruption. Nanak seeks the Sanctuary of God, the All-powerful, Compassionate Lord. ||4||4||55||

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 21 Dec 2003

sireeraag mehalaa 1 ghar dhoojaa 2 || aapae raseeaa aap ras aapae raavanehaar || aapae hovai cholarraa aapae saej bhathaar ||1|| ra(n)g rathaa maeraa saahib rav rehiaa bharapoor ||1|| rehaao || aapae maashhee mashhulee aapae paanee jaal || aapae jaal manakarraa aapae a(n)dhar laal ||2|| aapae bahu bidhh ra(n)gulaa sakheeeae maeraa laal || nith ravai sohaaganee dhaekh hamaaraa haal ||3|| pranavai naanak baenathee thoo saravar thoo ha(n)s || koul thoo hai kaveeaa thoo hai aapae vaekh vigas ||4||25|| Siree Raag, First Mehl, Second House: He Himself is the Enjoyer, and He Himself is the Enjoyment. He Himself is the Ravisher of all. He Himself is the Bride in her dress, He Himself is the Bridegroom on the bed. ||1|| My Lord and Master is imbued with love; He is totally permeating and pervading all. ||1||Pause|| He Himself is the fisherman and the fish; He Himself is the water and the net. He Himself is the sinker, and He Himself is the bait. ||2|| He Himself loves in so many ways. O sister soul-brides, He is my Beloved. He continually ravishes and enjoys the happy soul-brides; just look at the plight I am in without Him! ||3|| Prays Nanak, please hear my prayer: You are the pool, and You are the soul-swan. You are the lotus flower of the day and You are the water-lily of the night. You Yourself behold them, and blossom forth in bliss. ||4||25||

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 21 Dec 2003

This shabad is kind of what i was feeling earlier: gourree mehalaa 5 || dhulabh dhaeh paaee vaddabhaagee || naam n japehi thae aatham ghaathee ||1|| mar n jaahee jinaa bisarath raam || naam bihoon jeevan koun kaam ||1|| rehaao || khaath peeth khaelath hasath bisathhaar || kavan arathh mirathak seegaar ||2|| jo n sunehi jas paramaana(n)dhaa || pas pa(n)khee thrigadh jon thae ma(n)dhaa ||3|| kahu naanak gur ma(n)thra dhrirraaeiaa || kaeval naam ridh maahi samaaeiaa ||4||42||111|| Gauree, Fifth Mehl: This human body is so difficult to obtain; it is only obtained by great good fortune. Those who do not meditate on the Naam, the Name of the Lord, are murderers of the soul. ||1|| Those who forget the Lord might just as well die. (when sung most people have the feeling that they might as well die without rememberance of guru sahib) Without the Naam, of what use are their lives? ||1||Pause|| (without naam what use is my life or life in general?) Eating, drinking, playing, laughing and showing off - what use are the ostentatious displays of the dead? ||2|| Those who do not listen to the Praises of the Lord of supreme bliss, are worse off than beasts, birds or creeping creatures. ||3|| Says Nanak, the GurMantra has been implanted within me; the Name alone is contained within my heart. ||4||42||111|| *sigh*

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 21 Dec 2003

__kakaree said:__  >You can look around you Dorothy and see the effects of uncommitted relationships. >Self control is not a bad thing it's not necessarily even denying desire exists. >But the ideal is to have desire be a tool, rather than be the tool of desire. Which is almost exactly what I am saying. >The children growing up here have parents whose marriages were arranged and expect >them to think of others as sisters and brothers but at the same time as soon as they >reach puberty even talking to each other is discouraged especially in public. These >same youth go to public schools. They have no experience outside of what they get at >school in dealing with the other gender. There are no guidelines set up except "don't talk >or it’s against gurmat" How helpful is that? They are extremely vulnerable. Which is why it is important to be open about it instead of treating it like a dirty little secret as most people on this board seem to want to. __ĤĀ&# said:__   >if you don'y beleive anything from gurbani, then what the hell arer you doing here? Why do you assume that? >If you question everything that pops up about bujjer kurayts and say it is ok, >then what are you doing on this forum? What have I said is okay? I have posted in two threads. One which was about smoking. In it I never said it was okay according to Sikhi to smoke. I was simply say harassing others for there personal decisions is not a good idea. The only other thread is this one. >Personally i doon care about what you think about how people should be able to do whatever, >but if you are going to criticize everything why are you here? What i mean is if you don't >beleive in what sikhism preaches then why go and argue? I am here to learn. Is that not what you are supposed to be doing as well? Is that not the definition of what a Sikh is, someone that continually learns? Why are you so afraid to hear a voice that does not sing in perfect harmony with yours? >now asumming that you are chirstan, should i go around asking how the hell did a virgin give birth? Actually that is valid question. How does a virgin give birth? Does it not contradict the definition of virginity? >It would be beneficial for you to either accept skhism or if you don't, stop arguing with >every ristriction. Why? Why are you so afraid to ask questions? No one is forcing anyone to do anything here, we are merely discussing a topic and hopefully everyone is learning. As a Sikh should you not be encouraging more discourse to learn not only more about your faith, but others faiths and beliefs as well? If anything, hearing from the other side should only strengthen your own beliefs unless they were weak to being with. In which case why would you want to still hold on to them (note: I am talking about this posters personal beliefs, not Sikhism)? >It is people like you that probably have aid and going to die at the age of 55 saying whatever >I lived my life, and the rest of you wasted it. I was going to reply to this, but I won't because I don't think it is appropriate to be discussion sex, safe sex, and STD prevention on this forum. But if for some reason you do wish to discuss this, e-mail me. >Well i really dont care if you beleive in being a player or whatever but aleast dont >try to convince others its okay. Being a "player"? Where did that come from? How am I trying to convince others to be a "player"?

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Mkhalsa · 22 Dec 2003

>>>I was going to reply to this, but I won't because I don't think it is appropriate to be discussion sex, safe sex, and STD prevention on this forum. But if for some reason you do wish to discuss this, e-mail me.<<<<< Really? You had absolutely NO problem discussing this on Sikhsangat.com a YOUTH forum frequented by kids as young as 7 years old. All of a sudden you have a hard time talking about it with adults?

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 22 Dec 2003

__Mkhalsa said:__ >And who questioned gods divine wisdom? its you who are questioning it. First off, god created maya, >this illusion for us to live in, without it weare really kind of lost and drifting. Maya is where >our bodies are. Hmm.. i think kulbir singh jee could best explain this part as I do have a hard >time putting things into words at times. Okay I am going to base all my responses on "maya" being the universe and our reality. >Anyway, this maya only distracts us from god and keeps us from him. It depends on our karams, our >free will, and gods grace of how we react to maya. If we fully indulge in it and get "pleasure" >from it then that is our perogative, but then we made a personal choice to be stuck in it >and continue reincarnating. Explain to me why god would create something, then not want us to use it. Ask yourself this question, would you ever create something for the sole purpose of not using it? It doesn't make sense to me. >You are making us all think about sikhi from different perspectives, for this, I am thankful >and your doubts only seem to ground me more in sikhi. Awesome. >No drug, no boyfriend nothing can compare to the pleasure that meditation upon god gives us. >It is your loss, I have nothing to gain from trying to show you that its 10000 times better than >any "pleasure" you have experienced, and trust me, i know. 1) You assume I have never experienced spiritual pleasure which is false. 2) But let's say I had not. All I have to go on is spiritual pleasure being better than a worldly pleasure is your word? Sorry, your a interesting fellow, but just having your word is not enough. >how would you explain to an alien whos never eaten the pleasures of eating a chocolate cake with >fudge ice cream? they would just look at you quizzically thinking ur a nut. You would explain to them the textures (i.e. rough, smooth, silky) and tastes (i.e. sweet, bitter, sour) of the cake. >thats exactly what you are doing. You look at us thinking we havent experienced your pleasures, >trust me, most of the people reading this board have lived enough and they find the world vile >and dispicable in its "pleasures." 1) Why do you hate worldly pleasures? God created them just as he created spiritual pleasures. Why totally cut yourself off from them? but more importantly: 2) Why can worldly and spiritual pleasures not go hand in hand? Why must you deny one and accept the other? Both are made by god, why do you avoid one but accept the other? Like I said before, it's about balance. Why not experience both worlds? Spiritual and physical pleasure.

Re: what is sikhi coming too...

Admin · 22 Dec 2003

This thread is now closed. Nothing new is coming out of this thread. No more messages under this thread will be approved. We thank everyone for their input. Admin