Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Seeker of Understanding · 29 Mar 2006

Do you think that it is the "individualism" of the west that makes people cut their hair and not identify with the larger Sikh identity (turban and all 5 Ks)? Everything in most western societies focuses on getting yourself ahead focusing on your likes and dislikes under the modes of consumerism - building an identity based on a personal style and preference – and no longer focuses on community or group identity. Do you think this hurts the Sikh identity.... do you think it puts in the mind that we are not a nation of Sikhs anymore... that we are simply individuals with a choice to be whoever we want to be as long as we can find the right identity produced by popular culture... or is that we have always had these issues in the Panth and it is God's will that some are strong Sikhs who don't care what others think and are firm in their faith thus building the Sikh identity in their own personal life rather than giving in to the norm (cutting hair)? It certainly wasn’t easier being a Sikh during the time of the Moguls but after that time was it easier keeping hair since it might have been a norm back then? Any thoughts? Do you think modernity is the downfall or the element that causes Sikhs to want to be like everyone else...Thus the quest to fit in? Or has it always been like this? [%sig%]

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Singh · 29 Mar 2006

I think its completely opposite; western society forces you to confirm with various social norms in terms of identity, whilst Guru Ji has always made each Khalsa completely distinct and "individual". Whilst people in western society may think they are being individual really they are all following the exact same lifestyle, dress code, etc, and any deviation from this is seen as not normal. And I don't think there can be any comparison between Puratan times and now. In Puratan times, the Singhs had Naam Kamai, and now, they have none, so even the smallest of problems seems to be causing widespread apostacy in the Kaum.

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

ns · 30 Mar 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh It's obvious it hasn't always been like this, it's a well known fact when you reflect on Sikh hostory that when everything was done to destory Sikhe then the Sikhs set aside their differences and went on a mission with full faith and aquireed raj. However the problem now is there is no mission as you can be the type of sikh you want to be in the west as there is no threat to the religion. Actually the Sikhs are the biggest threat to themselves at the present stage.Sikhs are killing off Sikhism more now than ever before. You may find that strange but it's true when you look at the overall picture.

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Jasmin · 30 Mar 2006

It's not individuality when your doing what every one else is doing.( ; )

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Seeker of Understanding · 30 Mar 2006

"However the problem now is there is no mission as you can be the type of sikh you want to be in the west as there is no threat to the religion. Actually the Sikhs are the biggest threat to themselves at the present stage.Sikhs are killing off Sikhism more now than ever before. You may find that strange but it's true when you look at the overall picture." Hello NS, Can you elaborate on the above statement... or can anyone else add an oppinion to the above statement. The west is tolerant in some cases to the Sikh religion such as Canada (with exception I am sure - nothing is absolute) but what about America and Europe where things are considerably more difficult and Singhs and albeit Singhnees too are getting arrested quite frequently for the Kirpan and in the case of Europe are not allowed to wear a Dastar to school and while taking drivers license pictures. Do you see the above breaches of human rights enough to questions the legitimacy of the West for Sikhs? Do you think if there was a sovereign place for Sikhs - a place we may perhaps need sooner than latter as result of our very unique identity, in order preserve it before it is melted into the waive of postmodernism - we as a nation would still have as many global struggles to convince people of our faith in all its dimensions, physical appearance included? Do you think this sovereign place would give Sikhs more encouragement to become gursikhs? Do you think this sovereign place would protect Sikh rights worldwide? Any thoughts? [%sig%]

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Nav Singh · 30 Mar 2006

You have a very intelligent question. It'd be great to see more questions like this raised. Here is my 2 cents on it: Individualism has affected ALL the great religious traditions of the world. In pre-modern times (and even today in non-Western cultures) group identities overshadow individual identiities. Group identities can be identities like family, caste, nation, profession, religious identities like the Khalsa etc. We're entering an age where individual identity is far more important than any group identity and ALL the religious traditions of the world emerged in times when group identity was more important...so the ethics and teachings of these traditions stress group/communal values. Hence we have the conflict between modern thinkers such as the Enlightenment thinkers (Voltaire, Diderot, Hume) and religious traditions. Religious traditions will gradually evolve to cater more to individual identities while giving a sense of belonging. This is already happening with Christianity in America. I think Sikhism in the West will go through a lot of changes and something different from the current version of Sikhism practiced in Punjab today, will emerge in the West. Remember, a lot of the problems with the way Sikhism is practiced today come from an excessive emphasis on group identity (casteism, discrimination against women, etc.) and these things will not be relevant in a culture where individual identity is more important.

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Seeker of Understanding · 30 Mar 2006

Dear Singh, ns and Jasmin: Do you think you have more freedom being a Sikh in the West more so over being one in India? Where would you say you have more freedoms to practice Sikhi in its organic form? Please include all factors that may help or hinder you in each geographic region. Is there anyone on this form that has practiced Sikhi in India and then moved to the west and found it easier or more difficult to practice? This question is more geared toward those who have taken Amrit and are still continuing to wear a turban and 5 Ks. Any thoughts?

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Seeker of Understanding · 30 Mar 2006

"This is already happening with Christianity in America. I think Sikhism in the West will go through a lot of changes and something different from the current version of Sikhism practiced in Punjab today, will emerge in the West. Remember, a lot of the problems with the way Sikhism is practiced today come from an excessive emphasis on group identity (casteism, discrimination against women, etc.) and these things will not be relevant in a culture where individual identity is more important." Nav Singh, As the Christian religion has evolved it has done so at the rate of perhaps compromising certain tenants which Jesus himself emphasized so dearly in his proclamation to his people. Such as to love one's neighbor and to be righteous human beings to all including the most down trodden i.e. the poor, those affected by terminal illness the AIDS of the 1st century: Leprosy, and those forced into the sex trade: prostitutes. In today’s age this type of tolerance doesn't exist and there have been many trade offs to Jesus’ organic message of Love and ultimate understanding. However with the Sikhs I find there is an element which is unique to this particular religion, an element which many other religions do not have. It is the physical element not just the intangible which identifies a Sikh. Ideas can parish with time yet the physical is much more difficult to erase as it can be excavated and discovered over time and brought back and preserved. This can also be said for scripture which are ideas on paper yet interpretation sets in and people tend to add their opinion to the organic message and reinterpret the message as in the case of Paul and Jesus’ apostles hence the bible – when the message for the faith is not complete. Yet when one looks closer and dissects the history of the Khalsa the reasoning behind Guru Gobind Singhs organic message of what a Sikh should be it was/is quite clear. Interpretation was/is not necessary to complete this message as Guru Gobind Singh himself vocalized it clearly in his actions and speech, along with the hukam of ending the continual succession of the guru ship and ultimately placing the everlasting with Siri Guru Granth Sahib. For the Sikhs, the message was complete and the actions of Guru Gobind Singh made it clear and defined the necessary knowledge of who a Sikh should be, how a Sikh should look and who a Sikh should pray too: Waheguru. The turban and the 5Ks are identifying factors and are one part of the equation which eventually equals to a Sikh once the spiritual is instilled. This two part equation is what defines Sikhism. In many other religions I have come across such as the many forms of Christianity I have not seen such a saint/soldier element. That is the unique beauty that should be preserved otherwise their will be no Sikh left. [%sig%]

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

Seeker of Understanding · 30 Mar 2006

Nav Singh, Also in the case of casteism and sexism, do you believe that these are values which the Siri Guru Granth Sahib preaches? Do you believe these elements may perhaps be the erosion of the organic nature of Sikhism by the invisible hand of pre existing cultural aspects of Hinduism in respect to casteism. Do you also think perhaps the values of sexism are implanted by the nature and etiquette of British colonialism? Although British women used the conquered ethnic women as tools to gain their own independence from British male domination (they argued to their male counterparts they too could civilize the underdeveloped/barbaric since they too held British citizenship) did not mean they were liberating Sikh women. It meant they were instilling British norms and values on the women, thus promoting the lifestyle of being in the kitchen and raising children like a "good lady" not fighting on horseback like a Khalsa soldier. As this implanted value persisted it inevitably was the erosion for the masses, the collective psyche took hold of the concept that a woman did not have the role outside the prescribed place where the British had placed her. Yet when you see the revolution of 1984 you can clearly see that women where picking up arms and fighting side by side to their male counterparts. They were also equally getting arrested and not succumbing to torture. This was the reflection of the true Khalsa nature for both men and women. It took going back to the organic nature of Sikhism in order for this to take place. When Amrit is a factor along with the 5 Ks the barriers are bashed because we are finally coming home. A home that values equality in every respect – castims and sexism included. [%sig%]

Re: Modernity vs. Our Organic Sikh Identity

moorakh · 30 Mar 2006

1) Practice Amrit Vela India : Yes Canada: yes 2) Wear Punj Kakaars in Public India : Yes Canada: yes 3) Wear Bana in Public India : Yes Canada: Yes 4) Wear Bana to Work India: Depends on Employer Canada: Depends on Employer, Less Likely 5) Hold a Peaceful Protest India: Depends on Topic of Protest Canada: Yes 6) Hold a Khalistan Independence Rally India: Hell No Canada: Yes 7) Give a speech on Khalistan India: Hello No Canada: yes 8) Have a Nagar Keertan India: Almost Anywhere Anytime Canada: Almost Anywhere Anytime with Government Approval 9) Political Refuge India: Hell No Canada: Sometimes 10) Innocent Until Proven Guilty India: Nope Canada: Most of the time, except in the media