Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Not Ramgharia · 30 Mar 2006

The weird thing is there was an application for a Gurdwara the other day in Surrey for a Ramgharia Gurdwara. I find it shocking and appalling, people would name a gurdwara after your caste, like name it after a Guru Ji or something, but why name it after your caste. Will non-ramgharia's be able to partake in langar or going to diwan hall? I mean, its getting to a point when you say to a person, my religion promotes equality among people and you have individuals in our community who do the other thing. I just find all these gurdwaras are just being built for power or control over a minor fraction of our community, its turning into one big joke. I am all for gurdwaras, but its not so that we can develop our youth, its all just this big ego stroke for the pardan and the guys who make it so they can make money off people. I guess like they say in marketing, find a target market and exploit.

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Bhagwant Singh Virk · 30 Mar 2006

Khalsa ji Ramgarhia is not a name of a caste but the name of a misil from a golden period of Sikh history. Just like all other misils it was made of Sikhs from many castes. Therefore to behave as a caste is going against not only Sikh religious principles but also against the historical basis of the misil itself. To have the name of Ramgarhia Gurdwara just like Baba Deep Singh Gurdwara or other historically figure based Gurdwara names is not wrong as long as it is based upon the principles of Sikhism, and caste plays no part WJK,WJF Bhagwant Singh Virk [%sig%]

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Gandalf · 30 Mar 2006

Sad to say, but the Jatt gurdwaras aren't any better....and I am born into a Jatt family Gurdwaras are mostly controlled by the Jatts, and if you are of a certain non-jatt caste, you have no say in how the gurdwara is run... i can understand why they would create a Ramgharia Gurdwara....it has nothing to do with power or money, its just wanting to do seva.... In Toronto, the Ramgharia gurdwara is one of the best, I go there whenever I get the chance...it is nice and quiet, it actually feels like a community there....not like Dixie..

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Deaogan · 30 Mar 2006

AKJ have'nt even got an asthan (gurudwara).

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

to singh · 30 Mar 2006

gandalf.. i am from toronto .. i grew up in toronto and hence i use to goto rivalda gurughar (previously known as ramgharia gurughar). we are 'tharkhans' but yet i dont believe it anymore in caste.. ive seen no sign of nice/quiet at that gurughar or any other gurughar.. to me every gurughar is the same, and its not much different then dixie.. the same kind of scene goes on there ..

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

confused · 30 Mar 2006

What about Bhagat Ravidass Gurdwhara's? They have a different nishan sahib, different ardass. Why do they focus on Bhagat Ravidassji opposed to other gurus yet they do have guru granth sahib de prakash. It is all confusing.

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

JSGyani · 31 Mar 2006

Thats because they feel that since their caste of chmaar is same as Bhagat ravidss ji...they somehow "own" him.....thye even call bhagt ji as "GURU" when Guru ji calls him Bhagat ji. They have no choice except to Parkash Guru Granth Ji sahib as they dont have thier own "gurbani"....the ONLY GURBANI tht Bhagat Ji wrote is preserved in the Guru Granth Ji..

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

A Singh · 31 Mar 2006

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa! VaheguruJiKiFateh! Ramgarhia Gurdvaras, Ravidasia Gurdvaras, Bhatra Gurdvaras Balmiki Asthaans are all the result of similar socio-political factors. If we stick with the last 100 year or so, in 1901 the British passed the Punjab Land Alienation Act which in a nutshell restricted land ownership to agricultural classes – in other words to Jatts – the boasts of landownership and zamindars etc actually originates from this British influenced act. There are various political reasons as to why the Act was passed, however the biggest impact it had was upon the Tarkhans, Lohars and other artisan communities during its initial phasing, as these communities had over the previous 200 years seen considerable upwards mobility, enhanced particularly by the likes of Sardar Jassa Singh Ramgarhia (hence the adoption of the title Ramgarhia subsequently by all Artisan Sikhs) and now stood to loose large portion of their acquired economic success as a result of this politically motivated Act. The result was similar to what happened post-partition with the influx of largely Khatri and Arora Sikh families into Punjab who fared a similar disadvantage and in some cases in animosity from their Jatt counterparts, who now enjoyed the fruits of the Land Act. In short, these communities migrated to Delhi and set themselves up as successful traders in various areas of commerce – hence why during the 1984 riots, many of the prejudices that the attacking mobs held against Sikhs in Delhi was their apparent economic success and wealth (and likewise to that in Punjab – views to the effect that “when have you seen a Sikh begging in the street – never” soon turned into “what reason do they have to complain about problems, they are all well off “ in the hands of the politically charged Hindu right). Back to the Artisan communites , they also migrated away from Punjab and congregating collectively as Ramgarhias, migrated in large numbers to East Africa and once more established their socio-economic success. They were subsequently uprooted and settled predominantly in the UK where they were perhaps the first community of Sikh settlers (perhaps before them only remote Bhatra groups) who did not cut their Kesh and remove their turbans upon entry into the UK on the pretence of finding work and “fitting in” as early, largely Jatt communities had done. The end result of all of this was that the so-called scheduled castes or communities (in Punjabi, Churas, Chamars etc) suffered greatly as a result of the Land Act, who now were forced to live on the outskirts of villages and have any rights to land ownership that they may have earned stripped from them. The impact of this can still be seen to this day with some the treatment meted out these communities in various Punjab villages. As a result, the Chamar community, congregated itself around the writings of Bhagat Ravidas, also of similar origin and begun to revere him as Guru Ravidas – this was quite different from the parallel Ramgarhia or Bhatra Gurdvaras which only used the titles to denote the management of the Gurdvaras, however in practice held firm to common Sikh belief and practice in most cases. The “Guru Ravidas Gurdvara” however came to be a mixed movement of Keshadhari Sikhs and predominantly clean shaven Sikhs (in many respects similar to many global Jatt settlements) however whilst retaining the Guru Granth Sahib as their central axis, they replaced the Kesri Nishan Sahib with a Bhagwa coloured one, similar to Nirmalas with the inscription “Har” or “So Hung”. In latter years as tensions between the Ravidasia or “Aad Dharmi” community and others persisted, attempts were made to establish a new scripture consisting solely of the writings of Bhagat Ravi Das (this was called “Guru Sikhia Sahib”) – some Amritdhari Sikhs within this community protested and a further split occurred, one who retained the Guru Ravidas Gurdvara title and in practice were largely similar to most other Sikh Gurdvaras, another begun to establish long more partisan lines. Over time a third group emerged who reverted more to a Hindu practice and installed a murti of Bhagat Ravi Das. The Balmikias comprised a community of so called ‘untouchable’ castes (chooras or achuuts). They pretty much immediately established their own asthaans along more Hindu lines and outraged many with their writings on the Balmiki Ramayana in which their claimed a whole manner of changes to the more popular Ramayan theme, namely that Sita was impregnated by Ravan and not Rama. Insofar as present day Sikh practice is concerned, I personally believe we should be careful not to confuse the titles Ramgarhia, Ahluwalia, Bindravale, Ravidasia with caste per se and even terms such as Jatt, Tarkhan, Khatri, Arora, Chamar etc with caste as understood in the Hindu context, where the readings of scripture and spiritual practice are restricted on a caste basis – within Sikh, despite the existence of these various communities and whatever social tensions may arise from time to time, no one group is forbidden from participation in Sikh practices from reading or listening to the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, no one group is restricted from eating Langar, no one is prevented from offering their heads for the blessings of Amrit. These communities and titles are pretty much here to stay, rather than fighting a loosing (and largely unnecessary battle) trying to destroy them, it would be far easier to focus on more involved community projects and seva – in most towns in the UK that I have visited for example, Vaisakhi Jor Melas and Nagar Kirtans are held via a combined effort from all Gurdvaras, further development along these lines will ensure progress in the direction that ultimately everyone has in their hearts. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Mr Singh · 31 Mar 2006

Ramgarhia gurdwaras ban any non - ramgarhia caste member from any position in the Gurdwara. So it is a caste thing, not a historical figure thing. Slough Ramgarhia is an example of a ramgarhia Gurdwara. It has never had an amrit sanchaar. Kathakaars complain when they go there, they are told not to speak on rehit. Next to it is the ramgarhia club, which is a booze hall. Outside it is a statue of Jassa Singh ramgarhia, which cost £40,000. They have never given any contribution like that to the sikh school. If you read history, then you will find Jassa Singh ramgarhia was actually a farmer, which makes a jatt. I do not believe in caste, but that fact is very ironic!

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

A Singh · 31 Mar 2006

I guess this flows through with the logic of some elders I heard during the 1980s when many for the first time adorned or re-adorned Sikhi Saroop and deemed themselves authority figures on Gurmat and many times one would be told that Guru Nanak Dev Jee was a farmer hence the Gurus were Jatts!!! Yeah...nice one...we can see where this is going!

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

..... · 31 Mar 2006

Excellent Informative Post.

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

Harcharan Singh · 31 Mar 2006

Not that it matters, as all the misledars were not entagled in caste - hence members of all occupations being dominant in all misls and being land owners prior to the British land owning rules.. Sardar Jassa Singh Ji has commonly been refered to as Tocca Singh by historians who visited Punjab during the misle period (mid to late 1700s) i.e. Francis Xavier Wendel. Tocca was a common reference made to people from a labour intensive background who used hammers. It is most likely that Sardar Jassa Singh Ji was actually a Lahaar (Blacksmith). although otherhistorians have refered to him as a carpenter. Sardar Jassa Singh Aluvalia Ji has been refered to as Calaal Singh, calaal refers to inn-keeper/distiller, but obviously Sardar Ji's parvaar left this occupation upon receiveing Guru Ji's darshan, most Sikh Calaals actually found other means of income, which is why Aluvalias are so successful in numnerous business sectors today. Another Misledar has been called Tchersa Singh (leather worker). Most of the mahaan shaheheed that were executed in Delhi alongside Banda Singh Bahadur were said to be of so called low caste i.e. choorai, chumaar etc. All this just goes to show that caste had no relevance in the old days, caste was reinstituted/glorified by the British during various projects i.e. army recruitment, land owndership, various census etc.. They did the same thing all around the world, teh Rwanda genocide of 2 million people no so long ago was a result of caste creation by teh Europeans before they evacuated the congo, and left hand picked light skinned natives in charge. As for the Gurdwarai, it's very uneducated to blame any one party for the division in Gurdwarai, as all are to blame. Many Singh Sabhia Gurdwarai did not let non-jatts in management, a trend started in the early to mid 1900's in India which spread around the world. So called lower castes were discriminated against in this way, hence setting up on their own. Obviously, 2 rights don't make a wrong, so they are also to blame. But I have noticed in recent times, as the older guilty generation is dying off, that the more educated younger people are ridding the caste element, it is not long before caste basis will finally be eliminated and Singhs from all types of historical occupations will be invloved in all Gurdwara i.e. Singh Sabha, Ramgharia etc... Slowly the surnames are disappearing, and the true name given by Dasmai Patshah is taking precsedence again, Singhs are looking as one again in dastaar and banaa, all differences are disappearing, it's only a matter of time before the caste diseased people are vanquished from Guru Ghar forever! Waheguru

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

GS · 31 Mar 2006

There isnt anything wrong with a Ramgarhia Gurdwaras. They are probabaly no worse or better than any other Gurdwara. Actually Ramgarhia Gurdwaras were started because Ramgarhia Sikhs were not allowed to have a say or be members of the "Singh Sabha" Gurdwaras (This mainly started in Africa). Despite the fact that Singh Sabha means association of Singhs, Singh Sabhas were, and still primarily are, run by Jatt Sikhs whom do not allow Ramgarhias to be on the commitee, because Jatts consider Ramgarhia Sikhs as a lower caste. This is because Jatts became very rich due to the green revolution in Panjab and additionally, because Ramgarhia Sikhs would make tools for Jatts to do the farming with... Jatts began to belive themselves as being superior. So when Ramgarhias were not allowed to be part of Gurdwaras, they naturally felt unwelcome, they were forced to build there on Gurdwaras, so that they could also run Gurdwaras and do seva. If you look in Panjab at all the Governments, SGPC positions, and so forth, you'l find the majority of positions filled by Jatts, as other so-called castes are not given equal oppurtunities. In the UK, I dont see why Ramgarhias are still considered lower by the Jatts... because most Jatt youth now wear Ramgarhia style dastaars and also take up the profession of building work. At the end of the day, we have forgotten Guru Jis message... not to divide ourselves into castes, and consider each and every Sikh an equal.

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

blenddacastes · 01 Apr 2006

i have to admit when i go ravidas temple they have a lot of respect when they see singhs as if their graced and humbled by the sight of sikhs. This is the kind of love that all sikhs should strive to have and bring a harmnonious atmosphere to any gurdwara and encourage more. But ramgharia two sides, on one theres seva being done and less political atmosphere more chilled but i have seen the constituition of ramgharia gurdwaras and i am personally disgusted by the fact non terkhaans cannot join on the political front of seva but the seva that does exist is excellent and i have seen minimal clashes. I have no knowledge if ravidas lot have the same consituition that bars non chamars. The reason behind barring and selecting members of certain caste appears to be in counter reaction to singh sabha corryupt politics or in other words percieved jatt domination. Now what is the point of creating a caste system in black and white inside a gurdwara? Surely ramgharia gurdwara (and ravidasis if they do the same) would really promote sikhism, heal rifts, and bring to the surface true sikh teachings if they actively declare members of all castes welcome and represent everyone. This can be achieved through selective eligable voting ie rehtdhari lokh. Let us say democracy and elections is ganth. Now whats wrong with the committees selecting even most of their own members and even a few non caste members to just send even a tiny message out that they are reforming their constituition for a start? and perhaps side by side hold kirtan programmes and darbars, workshops jointly as to promote equality and ekta. It can become a better situation if we all agree we have mistakes and weaknesses and work on building a divine bridge together. its such a shame that a lot of nice spiritually inclined people end up divided into this stupidity from childhood and thus invisible walls created with the divinity of sikhism on one side and the ugliness of temporary cultural honors and prejudices holding people back.

Re: Ramgharia Gurdwaras

to singh · 01 Apr 2006

maybe the 'only non-jatts' can be part of committee is only in UK .. cuz i know the ramgharia gurughars here in toronto are mixed, even the main pardhan is jatt ! im not for them but just stating facts..